Rune Stones Board Game - Both Expansions Reviewed! - Beyond The Base Game
Transcript
these are what i want expansions for a game to do introduce new elements if you like but make them simple hi everyone welcome to another beyond the base game review so you will have seen recently i did a full detail review for runestones not the newest game out there but one that i consider to be horrendously underrated one of my new favorite deck builders i have in my collection well i said i also needed to talk about the expansions and that's what this video is here for you so most of what you see here is from the base game but i have both expansions in my collection i even kept the boxes just so i could do this video at some point in my life so i'm glad i held on to them but the first one nocturnal creatures was the first expansion and the next one after that was the enchanted forest there is also a queenie expansion you can get which gives you two more runestones that's cool it's more content if you can get it but these are the two that i am talking about specifically so runestones as you already know love it it's a light deck builder where you are playing cards with the uh abilities on them but you're playing two at a time to get the gems in order to buy these artifacts which you then use to gather these runestones as well as victory points and with these runestones they have game breakery powers that you know like give you a new strategy to go for differentiate you from the other players but for the main part it's the case of having to you know be really crafty with these cards with really lovely artwork
and simplistic abilities where when you play two cards at a time the one with the highest value trashes out of your deck so you you don't have to worry about artificially trashing your cards the game does that for you but you need to buy more cards in order to keep up the momentum of whatever it is you're doing i love it i've talked enough about it go check out my detailed review as to why i love the game and i actually i'm not going to spoil the rating but yeah spoiler alert i love the game but you know i gave it a high rating the question is do these two expansions improve on it you may also notice that my copy is a little bit pimped out because i've got the e-wrapped insert as well as their overlays for the player boards the insert you can kind of take or leave it but i definitely recommend these overlays you know you put the wood bit on the back screw in the plastic bit on top and it holds the artifacts and your gems nicely and it just looks really good and makes them more sturdy i love these overlays they turn and they always get attention every time i bring them out but the expansion so nocturnal creatures expansion one this basically brings in a lot of uh kind of like banshee cards as well as these whiffs tokens that you can get for bonuses it's the easiest expansion out of the two and one that you might as well just throw into every single game i can't think of a single reason you wouldn't just throw this in and forget it was even an expansion it introduces two main elements first up you have banshees this is a new card type that goes into the communal deck and there's four essentially they come in all the different colors but there's four main abilities that these cards have
the first one is a slight bit of take that not a big deal it's a very small and you can see it coming but basically it nicks a certain color gem from all the other players now when somebody buys the card you know they have it the decks are small you know when it's back in their deck so you can plan ahead that you maybe should not have a horde of that color gem if you know that they can potentially nick it so it's not like a really horrific take-back mechanic so don't be too flummoxed by that the next banshee is an interesting one card switch this allows you to take a card from the display and actually take it into your hand rather than your discard pile and even better is that the banshee trashes itself rather than the higher card of the two cards that you played so it's kind of like a two for one deal here you get a card into your hand and it trashes itself it does mean it's a bit of a one-hit wonder though but you know what the hell it gave you a really good card from the display hopefully and it takes it into your hand so you have it ready for next turn pretty sweet card all round then you get the first card that allows you to go through the discard pile yes finally normally when they trash at your deck you're unlikely to ever see them again well now this card allows you to get a card from the discard pile of your choice look through the entire lot and put it into your discard power into your deck so it allows you to retrieve those cards that you trashed earlier that you want to get back or maybe another player has played a card that you thought that was pretty sweet i'd like that please yink and you can have it for yourself and then the final one links into the other part of this expansion which is the wisp tokens the card basically allows you to take a wisp tile and get the bonus what exactly
does that mean well let me explain what the list tokens are there's a little sideboard very small very small where you put these tokens on and there's only a few here but there's more in the box and essentially they all have a bonus on them so roll up the die get two cards get one from the display two victory points roll a die get some gems whatever very standard bonuses you know nothing particularly complex and the idea with these is that there are these little wisp markers that you put on the victory point track around the side of the board randomly you flip them over at the start of the game and only three out of the ten are actually wisps and so it could appear like right at the start it could be spread out they could be at the very end of the victory point track it differentiates every game the idea is when any player doesn't not first come first serve when any player goes over a wisk token they get to look at this board and take one of the four that's available and resolve its bonus that's literally all it is it's just another bonus but it accelerates the game a little bit because now there's three bonuses that you got that you didn't before which could help you you know shorten your strategy by a turn or two but the fact that it's like i really could use more cards but i don't want to spend time buying them well hang on a minute there's a whisk token here now i get two cards from the top of the deck into my deck sweet i'll take that instead that way i don't have to waste time buying cards it's very simple and you can pretty much throw this into any game and forget it was even an expansion it's so simple now that is literally what the expansion does you've got a small rule book you've got the different languages as usual but there's literally three pages of rules for this so easy a minor change for the setup and
then it tells you what the four different banshee cards do with pictorial examples and then tells you what all the whisper knight tiles do that is literally it that's all the rules so simple there is no reason not to grab this and have it with the game at all times does it take the game from you know because i alright spoiler alert i gave runestones a nine okay you're probably watching that video before you watch this one i gave it a 9 out of 10. does this elevate it to a 10 out of 10 no it is an improvement on the game and it's definitely nice to have more variety but it doesn't change up much apart from just accelerating the game slightly and giving you some more card types and bonuses that's about it really it's not like a revolutionary change it's mainly more of the good stuff but because it's so easy to throw into a game there's no reason not to have it in the game just teach it with it it's not going to confuse anybody and the abilities on these banshees are pretty straightforward in how they work well maybe the card switch one is a little fiddly but the example in the book is all you need and it should teach you what you need to know now before we get into the second half of this review please consider leaving a thumbs up on the video it means the world to me to know you appreciate the content also don't forget that this channel is sponsored by zatu.co.uk in the description you will find a code for five percent discount of anything you purchase off their website if you like the sound of this game or anything else i've reviewed on the channel and you want to save yourself a bit of money while purchasing some great games consider visiting at uk and making a purchase today now on to the rest of this review so with nocturnal creatures out of the way let's
move on to the second one now this was a lucky find for me i didn't even realize there was a second one this just came out of nowhere and it's like there's a second expansion but rooms i must have it now give me give me give me give me and i found it on ebay for the normal price uh i don't even know if there was any retailer that had it but you know if runestones is going to get reprinted in september which is what i'm hearing on the grapevine and hopefully it means that the expansions will be easy to find as well but the enchanted forest i grabbed and this is another kind of modular expansion of it like this you know with i mean with this one you kind of have to throw everything in the one of the banshees uses the whisk tokens so to not have the whisk tokens would make one of the banshees obsolete so you are basically throwing everything in here this on the other hand has two main modules and you can actually play them independently of each other and i can see the reason why you might leave one out not because it's bad but because obviously if you start throwing everything into this game you might think well hang on this is taking it out of the gateway level is it making it a bit too complex for new gamers we'll see well first up let's talk about that slightly tenuous bit the familiar board here what happens is that you have a sideboard so another board it's got a big like gnome dude on the back and you have another token a familiar a little animal that goes along this track and there's points at the end of the game for how far you get as well as being at the end but the main thing is that as you play cards you can choose to ignore the ability on a card or both of them and if you do you move further along the track you get extra gems roll the die extra cards every now and again just by going over spots but the red
spots are toadstool tokens which are these things again there's more in the box i've just got a few here and what these are is that they're similar to the wisp tiles and that they give you a cool bonus but you keep these so you keep them like face down in front of you until you need to trigger them and then you get the respective bonus and these are a bit more intricate than the wiss token ones i mean you've got ones where you can sort of turn like you know gems into wild or get a free card but they last for the turn so you can for a whole turn make your blues wild for example or all your gems wild sorry not just the blues but then there's really cool ones like for the turn you get to copy the effect of an opponent's runestone uh on this turn you get to keep both of the cards that you play you don't have to trash any on this card you can buy pretty much any card for all the mana points that you spend and there's even one that allows you to copy a card that an opponent has just played and get its ability so these are pretty nice like bonuses to get but you get to hang on to them until you're ready so it's a nice little addition but i will say that it's oh yeah one thing to mention first there is also i can't find a token for it but the bonuses on the board which you get for forging certain artifacts you get a new bonus tile which goes above the second smallest one that normally has no bonus and if you buy that artifact you also get to move one space along here which is pretty good it's really the main way you'll move along this spot because it's not often you want to skip the ability on a card but this is a nice addition but i wouldn't say it's a fantastic one i
throw it into every game because i like to have everything in there and i think it's very simple rules but it's not a game changer these bonuses are nice and it's cool to have them but it's not much incentive in here to be all the way along the track to get to the end to get the free bonus points there's eight five three one points for being first second third and fourth at the end but that's not a huge differential i mean eight to five to three to one so three points more than one player two points more than another and then you know it i don't feel like this end game scoring for the familiar board really changes the outcome of the game that much most of the time one more two players will kind of be in the lead and close to the finish and then the familiar board doesn't change things now maybe that's because i've got the home field advantage i know the game better so i tend to win by larger margins so this doesn't have much of an effect but there have been games which have had close calls and may and but this was before i got this board so maybe it would have more of an effect then maybe your experiences are different but i like it more for the toadstool tokens these bonuses are really cool and not to be underestimated and it's a nice little addition that fits with the setting of the game so this board you can take or leave i like it and i throw it into every game but it is modular and separate from the other part of this expansion so if you wanted you could just put it to the side and bring it in the future game it's entirely up to you it's cool but not much of a game changer i wish maybe the points in this the points on this board were a little bit more important making people focus on it more but here's the real reason you grab the enchanted forest the real reason why
this expansion is a must buy for this game more so than even nocturnal creatures you can throw this into the game and forget it was even an expansion which is all well and good but it's not a game changer this is because what you get is more rune stones yes you get eight more of these things so the previous time you only had eight and i said the replay value was a little bit of a hitch up because you were going to see them every single game now with this you have 16 runestones 18 if you've got the queenie expansion so you now have all these different abilities that can go off and how do you set the game up well take the original eight take the new eight pick eight at random and say those are the eight we're using this game they all work they're in the book and they're fully explained so you can check which setup one you like but here's the real good one to use you get a bag you take two of every single runestone and you shove them in the bang and then at the start of the game you put one out on each of the eight room stop space broom stone spaces sorry and then as one gets taken you replace it with another one for the bag at random so now you have all 16 to 18 different abilities potentially available in a game but they'll come out at different times you might not see an ability in the entire game you might see both copies of the same ability turn up at the same time you might only see it turn up once so you're thinking i really could use that ability but if i don't grab it now somebody else might nick it and i may never get the chance you know you may think um i want this one but then oh another one's turned up so that's okay it's safe but then there's only so much selection out there but then it could be a case that i
really desperately need this and it's like i must get it now i'm just gonna now oh it's gone i've got to adapt and then you may never see the other one it's such a cool way to do it and i use this setup every time this is easily the best way to set up the game now with all the runestones and the runestone abilities are really cool i think i've got them all here but i'm just going to go over like the sort of majority of them uh one here for example whenever you play a card that costs gems to use you discount by one gem very nice uh you've got um i'll come back to a couple of these ones actually because i do want to mention those uh one of them i have a slight issue with but uh let's see you've got one here oh this one's really popular when you play both cards like the two cards you can choose to resolve one of them twice and the other one not at all that's a really cool one to have you've then got whenever you roll the die you can pick which face it's on that can be pretty powerful if you know if you've got a lot of cards that involve rolling the die let's get the rest of them out of the bag here right here you go you can get maximum free artifacts fortune to turn instead of two people sort of look at this one and go that's not particularly powerful uh yeah you try this one and see if you if you've got a decent gem income get this runestone it really does speed you up uh at the end of your turn you can discard as many cards as you like in your hand and redraw back up the four because normally you don't do that very handy uh what else have you got here uh without all of them yeah i think that's all of them but here's three in particular i need to kind of talk about because two of them i'm fine with one of them i'm a little bit dubious about here's a good
one when you forge an artifact you get and that gets you a bonus so the three points the forge token or the roll the die you get to draw a card okay that's pretty cool you know you get to draw more cards for just 14 artifacts i like it i like using it you've then got one which says whenever somebody else forges an artifact and gets the bonus you get a little bonus as well so you can get a forge token a gem of your choice or a point it sounds powerful and it is powerful but it's not game breakery because the opponents still have to forge those ones with the bonus you know that's fine i haven't got a problem with that but here's where it gets a bit ridiculous so much so that whenever i play this game if i'm playing with more than two players this runestone is actively banned from the game i think it's way too powerful so you might think well that cuts a bit of the variety down not really i mean i've still got 15 runestones to pick from 17 when i get the queen expansion one less is not going to kill me but this runestone says that when another player forges any artifact not one that gives him a bonus any artifact you get a forge token or a gem of your choice in the two player game this is not too bad there's only one other player forging artifacts but in a three or four player game this runestone is outright broken like completely broken this one lends you so much gem income it's ridiculous the last player to use it completely wiped the floor with everybody with this one runestone alone because if you imagine three other players could be forging artifacts on that round that's three extra gems you
get most cards could even get you two and yet this one basically gets you free for doing diddly squat and it's with any artifact not the ones that just get you the bonus like the other two i mentioned no this is any artifact and the rules do not stipulate they explain every single runestone so it's very easy to tell what they do but it does not stipulate that it's re restriction is one per round when another player is performing the action the player may take any one general or no wild gem if the other player forges more than one artifact the player still only gets one gem so yeah if they force multiple artifacts you don't get one per artifact whoopi do the gem income for this is just too much i am probably gonna use it in my games but i'm gonna house rule that it's once per round so you know if i if so and so next to me takes the broomstone i forget an artifact they get a gem if any of the other two players at the table do it in that same round they don't get an extra one and then when it gets back to them it resets i'm probably gonna house rule that in because otherwise i won't use that runestone because it is proven to be way too powerful most of these other ones require you to do some work in terms of like getting the right cards or getting maybe a couple of runestones together but that one on its own just completely broke the game on that one and i think it was just way too powerful and needed a slight tweak i think that house rule that i've come up with will solve it for me but i'd be curious to know if anybody else has used that runestone and encountered the same issue but that little blemish aside this expansion is a must buy i mean the familiar board
is already good but to have all those runestones and increase the variety of the game there's no reason not to get this you know i mean you can you could play the base game a couple of times to see if you like it with the normal eight runestones because you'll still get a decent amount of play from those first eight runestones but if this is a game you start enjoying you need to hurry and find this expansion to get those extra runestones because they are really cool abilities especially when combo with some of the older abilities you just it lends itself to more strategies more interesting ways to play so yeah two expansions for this game one that is pretty much an auto include and you'll forget it's even an expansion it's so easy but it's not a game changer and then you've got one with two modules that you can separate one of which is fine i always use it but it's not essential but then one module that is essential and you really want it for this game so it's really hard to say which is better but personally i would say the enchanted forest mainly just because those extra runestones are a godsend to the game but they're both solid these are what i want expansions for a game to do introduce new elements if you like but make them simple but mainly i just want more of the same so this gave me more cards and some cool ways to get bonuses and this gave me a little new mechanic with some bonuses but gave me more of the good stuff with the rune stones they're fantastic and with both of these included in the game runestone's elevated to a 10 out of 10 for me i mean it's a 9 out of 10 with the base game alone because of the slight hitch up with the replay value but as soon as you throw these two in it's a 10 out of 10. and if you're going
to improve the game for me anymore by bringing out more expansions just give me more cards give me a few more runestones give me some more of the toadstool token some more the wisp tokens maybe and i'm totally happy this game doesn't need any more mechanics it can just always benefit from more variety so yeah love these expansions they're easily like sale of distinction level expansions they're definitely worth getting particularly enchanted forest if you're a fan of this game love it to bits so that's it for me on this beyond the base game review of the runestones expansions i've now covered everything that there is to know about this game in my two videos so hopefully you now understand why i love it so much and why i believe it's an underrated title so that's it for me i'll see you on the next broken meatball video if you like what you see then please comment on the video and leave a thumbs up it means the world to me to know that you appreciate the content don't forget that this channel is sponsored by zatu.co.uk when runestones comes back into stock maybe they'll have it and you can grab yourself a five percent discount by using my code in the description failing that just go buy any game you fancy and use my code and get that discount games are getting more expensive and we need to start saving some money if you're interested in other content you can check out the runestones review that i did i'm surprised you haven't watched it already if you're tuning in to this video but of course you can also watch my review i did of cryptid a very cool light deduction game from osprey games so without further ado i'll see you next time and remember it's only a game bye for now