Skip to main content
Loading video...

We "Fixed" Ti4 (PDF in Description)

Transcript 13:51

We did something about this game that we've played a lot, and we've played a lot of it with every single permutation of odds. We practically played it every single month of last year, practically. The first problem we kept running into is the obvious one, that is Twilight Imperium is just so long. We're very experienced with all the rules after all these years, but yeah, the game length didn't really get any shorter. And so, could we do something about that? The more interesting second problem is that of the agenda phase, where you vote on agendas near the end of every round. See, it can be really cool when the right agenda hits at the right time. When you're new to TI4, these agendas are so novel and the mechanics are so novel that you're okay with a couple of them with it. Like where it's super obvious which agenda will win, or you get an agenda phase where both agendas don't impact the game at all, so it feels like meaningless formality to vote. This video is two parts. The first shorter one is seeing if we can make the game faster by implementing the included galactic events from Thunder's Edge, called rapid mobilization. We didn't make this up, right? It's just implementing this variant. The second part of this is through one of our own rule tweaks, which is accessible via the PDF in the description. It's completely free, guys. This is trying to improve the agenda phase. It's not fully tested, but we reckon this homebrew variant should be released to the public sooner rather than later. Just see what you guys think about it. Lastly, while we did test this with every single expansion in our single three-player game, you could probably test our agenda fix with any permutation. That is, you could just use it with the base game.

Let's hop into it and we'd love to hear what you guys have to say. So, let's start with this rapid mobilization variant from Thunder's Edge for our three-player game, and it's supposed to make the game faster by changing setup. And if it'll make the game faster, and actually it made the game overall marginally worse. I'll first go down the list of changes, then explain in depth. You first start with the fracture in play, which is the side map from Thunder's Edge that tended to spawn anywhere between round one to three from our experience. This has neutral units defending slightly stronger planets all the way to one that if you own it, you have a VP. The next step of rapid mobilization is to place one infantry onto each planet next to your home. So, you now start with those planets and they're readied. Take your second space dock and now place it on any planet you control. And then you also get one flagship and three fighters in the system. Then your faction breakthrough starts totally unlocked. Lastly, research one tech. So, this initially sounds a lot faster because you don't have to take starting actions to get initial planets in your slice. Where you normally would have to go through round one or early round two motions to get them. And you now start with way more stuff, right? The problem we ran into is that yeah, sure, while you do have technically more stuff, it doesn't mean you're further along the path to getting more points. Like the objectives, they'll flip over at the same rate. And while it may be easier for someone to get Mecatol Rex round one because now you have your flagship potentially further away from your home system, that's not giving points to everyone as a whole. Something I personally kept witnessing is that you might be able to get two or three objectives in a single round now, like in round two, but you can only accomplish one objective per round because that's how the rules are.

So, in reality, there's little difference in point scoring. So, to look at all the goodies, it's like everyone starts the game with a good round and a half. Like you have two to three systems worth of planets all completely readied. So, to do that from round one, you'd probably have to do some type of warfare plus diplomacy play. Okay, so that's already two strategy cards required for general use, and you can probably only get one other system ready through this. Then you had immediate round one production to create your flagship and three fighters. So, that's like 10-ish resources. And along the way you're able to do the secondaries of construction and technology because you got that tech and the additional space dock. Oh, and you spend additional resources for Thunder's Edge to get your breakthrough unlocked. Okay, so now let's go to the breakthrough. Everyone starting with one is quite odd because sure, it might make some factions start better than others, but most importantly, it pretty much eliminates the need to pursue the planet of Thunder's Edge, which is still in the game. Cuz normally you put a point into Thunder's Edge to get said breakthrough.

Now, no need. So, if you actually want to get Thunder's Edge, you'll most likely have to do the effort of all the unlocks, which is wildly inefficient. So, why even have this in the game still? Then this variant really hurts the exploration mechanic. So, exploration isn't completely gone, it's just that the amount you do has been completely decimated. It almost feels like it shouldn't even be in the game at this point because if you draw a relic fragment like this or or that, there's a very low chance you'll get the remaining relic fragments, much less be able to trade with someone for those remaining relic fragments cuz they might not even be in the game. A couple last things that are a bit more minor, having a slice with less planets around it is certainly worse. So, you have to pick the right map and then probably draft locations and factions and all that. Or how if some factions start with additional tech or their flagship right away, that could matter a lot more. Or just how you don't have room for interesting round one Rune of Ring that can inherently lead to interesting ground to outcomes. Or how having the fracture on the board early isn't really helping the game in any way. It's just hanging out on the board until much later where you can actually kill those neutral units. And then the setup for it is done by the the speaker, I guess.

Normally it's whoever triggers it, but now the setup triggers it. So, yeah, this mode doesn't feel like it was tested very well. I've heard differing opinions about it online, so essentially, our advice is just use this at your own risk. But now let's get into our variant. So, local TI4 legend Alex came up with this variant. And man, I think his genius is coming into fruition here. He called it the Landsraad variant to make agenda phase more consistent. All you need to do is create a proxy agenda card called Lord of Rex, which we'll explain soon. The rest of the setup is dead simple. You just remove all minister cards from the agenda deck and treat them as exhausted or in another pile. These will be manually selected later. After everyone has picked their strategy cards at the end of the strategy phase, you reveal three agenda cards face up into a public zone, which will be voted on during the upcoming agenda phase. But you play through an entire normal action round before getting to vote, so you can get ready for them. If someone uses politics to look at the agenda deck, they're looking at the cards for the next round.

At the end of the action phase, the speaker will choose two out of three agendas from the public zone to keep. Unpicked ones go to the bottom of the deck. So, now at the start of the agenda phase, before voting and in speaker order, any player is allowed to grab a minister from the deck and allow it to be voted on if they are A, the speaker, B, have control of Mecatol Rex, or C, spend three influence. You can only refresh one minister card per player per phase. And this can only be done up to three times. So, speaker order matters again here for a max of three ministers to ever vote on per round. And even if you own speaker Mecatol Rex and have a bajillion voting power, you still can't take out two ministers to vote on. Then during the agenda phase, everyone can play action cards and do transactions normally until the speaker calls for voting. There will at a minimum be three agendas to vote on unless discarded through some other player effect. Then we took a page from the hidden agenda galactic event to make voting silent and simultaneous. You just secretly write down your votes on a piece of paper like a silent bid. You hand the results over to the speaker and they will tally the results and announce it. So, what about this Lord of Rex card? This is an agenda that is a law and has elect player on it. It basically gives you a victory point at the end of the agenda phase as long as you hold Mecatol Rex. If it's discarded for whatever reason, it returns to the public zone to be voted on again. Some extra random rules before the analysis, the Argent Flights votes are public and known before the other players vote cuz someone did pick Argent Flight for our game. Also, we're still aware that this variant can make Riders kind of wonky because you can play a Rider to commit to not voting for an agenda at the start of strategy phase because that's when the agendas are revealed. Fast forward to the end of the round when you actually do the agenda

phase, and the speaker can just discard the agenda you Ridered. Our inelegant but serviceable solution is that all agendas are counted as revealed after ministers are added. And if you play a Rider, that stops you from voting on that agenda, but not other agendas. And we know there will probably be some more question marks that come up with faction abilities, so that's just how it is. So, why is our homebrew variant so good and we're risking public humiliation by releasing this fairly untested variant to the public? Well, firstly, you're cycling the agenda cards a lot faster for your general faction and board states and just general enjoyment. You take out the ministers from the deck, so the deck is thinner now. The speaker can make deals with other players to also keep and remove agendas from the public zone during the course of the action round. And you will just in general see a lot more agendas. And also, you just can't totally be certain about voting, especially with three plus things to vote on now. There's quite a bit of mind games that happen. You can split votes in all sorts of ways here. In normal TI4 voting, what happened is that people would frequently abstain votes on the first agenda if they knew that they weren't going to make an impact to the results. And maybe if this agenda wasn't that interesting. And then so, you would end up hoarding votes for the second agenda where hopefully there was an agenda that mattered. Now, you know exactly what's voting on and there's no abstaining at all. There's just so much uncertainty. The voting is a lot more important because the cards will be better on average because of the culling. And sheesh, getting to pick from seven plus ministers from the game start that can let you draw more action cards, they can help you with combat or help immensely with tech. This gives a lot of agency. Like you don't want to select a minister that you personally wish you had and then two other players conspire to take it for themselves and then the minister is gone. You just

can't get it anymore. So, sometimes you might want to wait to take out a minister you want. The last pro of this variant is that Mecatol Rex is just a lot more important. Getting it on round one will result in a minimum of two ministers being flipped at the end of the round. So, later on round five, the Lord of the Rex card will be voted on. If you play a game and for some reason Mecatol isn't taken until round three, then Lord of the Rex might not come up before your game ends. Unless people start paying three influence to thin the minister deck. In fact, an interesting late game vote could be voting for a straggler to be Lord Rex that currently doesn't have Mecatol Rex so that they can take Mecatol Rex and could possibly come back with more point generation. And so, for now the concerns, well, yeah, Mecatol Rex is stronger, so maybe that could lead to more snowball-y gameplay or some faction interacting in a weird way, so we don't know. Then more importantly, the voting becomes a lot more crunchier and complex with a minimum of three things being voted on in every round all at once. Like in normal TI4, the entire group would be focusing on one single agenda, so there's a lot more of a structured way to centralize your organize your voting and screaming and shouting and deal making. If there's four agendas all at once, you'll have different people prioritizing different things. The vote splitting is real. And in our game, we had to keep getting up from the table to look at the cards as they are small. And I'd imagine in six players, you'd either have to take notes or have really good memory, or write them all on the whiteboard or something. Then this voting system makes some cards and abilities just easier to do. Like deleting laws is super good or maybe choosing a certain law to apply to me instead of you. And then the secret objectives involved with voting are easier just cuz there's more agendas to

spread around now. I know firsthand that electing myself the minister just greatly benefited me. Then the final issue is that you just have to write down your votes and have the speaker tally them up, which thematically can be a cool responsibility but in reality you might need some calculators with multiple people and agendas. So yeah, that's it. What do you guys think? Again, the PDF is below so you can just access this and start playing it right away or just start analyzing it for yourself. I mean, if you do choose to play your game with our agenda fix, we would be really honored cuz that's like many hours of your TI session dedicated to this thing we just came up with. Like I've never met you guys and you guys just trust me with all these hours of your game time for a game as grand as TI 4, crazy. So again, yes, please please let me know what you think and any problems that might come up as you play it or how we could change it because I'll just update the PDF as time goes on. Yeah, let me know.

Oh, yeah, of course. What do I personally think about it because I didn't come up with a variant after all, right? Well, I think the agenda phase is just way better overall. I mean, that was my main complaint with playing TI a lot is like wow, the agenda phase just kind of ends up sucking sometimes. I already thought hidden agenda was a big step in the right direction with obscuring votes and now it's obscuring votes plus more interesting agendas. So good job, Alex. And I really like the fact that there's ministers to pass around so that everyone feels like they can get meaningfully consistently rewarded by playing the politics game well. Whether through abilities to get the votes themselves or by manipulating people. However, it is a lot to take in compared to normal TI 4 because with agendas flipping over during strategy phase and then with the ability to choose a minister or delete agendas, this just adds way more decision-making, which is surely a good thing but not so good when I was playing a faction I was already unfamiliar with. And it does make the agenda phase longer and the build-up to agenda phase longer cuz there's more to think about, but I don't think these are bad things. It's just longer. So yeah, the game being shorter won't be happening soon anytime for us.

And it's possible that this made rapid mobilization be longer than actually intended to be, but still this variant isn't really making the game shorter in general. So yeah, I wouldn't play this with newcomers at all. Probably I'd only play it with like sweaty TI 4 players like me or more namely Alex who is really good at TI 4 now. He's like really good.

Yeah. What is it?

Oh my lord. Oh, no. No, no, no, no. Space kitty.

went down but that's really That's soul. So yeah, I'd personally just do hidden agendas with most people in the planet. But the existence of this variant I think is really cool for me to continue to dwell upon how I should play TI 4 with all the bajillion ways nowadays. What a time to be a TI 4 fan. Oh, yeah. For the performance of the game I played, I got totally wrecked. I got completely just wrecked. I played a Deep Rock variant, Deep Rock Scholarit, and I got completely smashed. It was awful. It was probably the worst TI 4 game I've ever played. You know, I have footage of it so we'll just cut to that cuz I don't I'm getting like bad chills talking about it right now. But it was cool to be a minister of at least something when normally ministers in our game would be more of a rarity. But yeah, it wasn't faster. I was like, "Oh, you know, this faction kind of sucks." We looked it up after the game.

Oh, they're top five. So what do I know about TI 4, right? I played a lot and still trash. It was kind of cool at times. We had some good moments. Um the new variant is I think is cool, the one that we homebrewed, but the um the rapid mobilization not very good. But like I'm really curious to play these guys again though. I mean, that's the TI 4 thing, right? Like it's it sometimes like it beats you to the ground but then you reflect on the game it's like, "Wait, that was actually kind of cool. You can do some cool things with this faction." Um but yeah, this this game was really long though. Like I like halfway through I just knew it was over. But you got to try.

Progress saved