Skip to main content
Loading video...

Reef Board Game Review - Actualol

Transcript 6:56

last year brought us a Zul an abstract game with chunky plastic pieces it sold over 300,000 copies and won the spiel des jahres award this year plan B games released their next abstract game that comes with chunky plastic pieces and a tough act to follow this channel is viewer funded if my reviews have helped you decide which games to buy over the years please consider pledging at patreon.com forward slash actual oh one year of support is the same cost as one board game not every game can have a theme with such bankable mass appeal as portuguese tiling reefs abstract pill is made easier to swallow by pretending we're growing coral reefs consumer and publisher have a mutually beneficial pact to never publicly admit that these themes make no sense so that we can continue to fund or plastic without it needing to be formalized as a fetish you start with a sea bed a coral of each color and two cards turns are incredibly simple either take a card or play a card we're in ticket to ride territory take a card or play one you don't even have to tax yourself with both at once this round you can get to grips with taking a card then you've got a whole round to come to terms with the stresses of playing one it's so easy that you know those people who just stop right in front of you and you're walking on a busy street even they could manage it and you know those people who play their music on the bus so everyone can hear it well they couldn't manage it even board games have limits when you play a card

two things happen first you get the coral at the top and place on your board wherever you want after you've done that you score points if you've met the goal on the bottom of the card if you have three greens in a row you get four points you're looking at the reef top down so it doesn't matter what's underneath private goals are always great to give players of focus but in reef the challenge isn't in meeting a goal it's about working out the best time to do it and by how much because you can score a goal more than once if you've got a visible green coral you get one point if you've got eight you get eight points on the face of it it's easy to get eight green coral on your board just play four cards that give you green coral it's easy but it's not efficient you have to make every card along the way worth playing every card has the potential to score and if you're clever you'll be scoring off all of them your strategy isn't one long-term goal it's lots of mini goals that you can chain together you can have four cards in your hand and the order you play them in is crucial that card will give you the oranges you need to score that one which set you up with a level three stack for that card imagine you're picking people up and dropping them off around town you don't want to go straight to take that person over to the other side of town immediately keep them in the car whilst you do some smaller trips on the way as you play cards your future plans diminish so you have to keep taking new cards to make sure you always have something you're working towards I've seen players focus on one big goal do you ever think they can to get loads of points from it but then their hand is

empty and they have no idea what to aim for next because none of the cards available work with what they've got if they picked up those cards earlier they could have made allowances for them on their previous turns it's tough you've got to keep four goals in your mind and work out in which order you should play them if you've got a sea bed of greens having to place those pesky two orange corals at the top of the card first is going to drive you mad you do want those oranges for another goal but you want to place them after you've scored the Greens not before and it's not just the order you're having to plan the spatial logistics of where to place those coral there's plenty to think about when it's not your turn and when it is your turn Reef is a brain burner and it's definitely given me analysis paralysis as I desperately tried to visualize in what order I can chain my cards the feeling when you pull it off scoring card after card in a perfect run is great so next game when you're struggling to recreate that magic you feel the pressure that carly Rae Jepson felt sat in a recording studio trying to write the follow-up to call me maybe but don't fear her next album was a classic anyone can play reef it's easy but it's also easy to be terrible at it's a step up from Azul both in depth and the point difference between a good player and a non gamer if as all is a game that gamers can enjoy with newbies reef is a game that gamers can enjoy but will make some newbies feel stupid there's no doubt that reef is a clever design it does a lot with very little it has a satisfying challenge

that will set your brain alight and some players will love it as I played the game I found myself getting lost in trying to find those chains only coming up for air at the end of the game afterwards my girlfriend told me she hadn't looked at my board once why would she it's of absolutely no consequence to her game in reef your influence on other players is minimal if you really want to be mean you could take a card that another player would love to score but you'd be wasting a turn to take it and then a turn to get out of your hand so would it be worth it what's worse is that I'm not sure we'd spoken to each other a big part of why I play games is for the social interaction and sadly reef doesn't encourage that it's not simply because there's no direct interaction between the players it's also because I'm so consumed by the challenge of planning my next few turns that I don't have time to talk and if I did I'd forget what I was planning and then slow down the game for everyone please understand this isn't a criticism of the game this is my personal response to it it's the same reason I don't play heavy euro games because I stress over every turn in silence and have no fun if I talk I either feel bad for slowing down the game for everyone or rush my turns and make bad decisions making me question why I'm playing the game at all I didn't have that problem with the Zul because you can't look into the future with such certainty and the options on your turn aren't as plentiful some people will relish that they can focus on their strategy without it being ruined by their opponents I prefer to play a game that's against the other players at the table not just alongside

them if you're looking for an abstract game with some real depth that you can get stuck into and you don't mind a lack of interaction reef is great it's not for me but I like that Plan B are making attractive solid abstract games with approachable rules I'll just keep my fingers crossed for one with a little more bite to it there's a link to where you can buy reef in the description below if you liked this video please subscribe to see more videos like this and if you want there to be more actual law in the world pledge support at patreon.com forward slash actual I'm John Perkis thanks for watching

Progress saved