Skip to main content
Loading video...

Earth - A beautiful kitchen sink of economics & ecology - TCbH Review

Transcript 5:57

it's been a conscious effort in mine since beginning this Channel that I wouldn't compare one game to another in a review using the shorthand of this is just better this just sounds like a bunch of pedantic wankery but to commit some pedantic wankery of my own here's Earth a game that's like yo what if I had the engine building a terraforming Mars with arcanova's naturalist bent wingspans action selection and follow through with just a hint just a smidge of takanoko because component stackery is cool and those are four hot names to drop but influence does not necessarily mean excellent so without further comparison let's take a look at this planetary kitchen sink earth like traveling on a horse with no name in Earth you'll be immersed with plants and birds and rocks and things as you essentially terraform your personal Island to suit the needs of a random four Critters and two ecosystems set up on display these make up the broad Strokes of what you may want to pursue but you'll also select an island climate and personal ecosystem for yourself dick hating some sorting features abilities and goals each turn a player selects one of four colored actions atop their player board performing that action wilts every other player gets a lesser version of that action than all players activate abilities of that color amongst

their starting and constructed cards in their Island initially a paltry song but eventually a dizzying Cascade of powerful abilities on every turn one of the cooler bits of design trickery about this game is the activations on every player's turn it's a subtle thing really but it adds just the right amount of indirect player interaction not only does it start to influence what cards you put into your Island either focusing on what you want to lean into or broadening out to better capitalize on other players but you start to develop a keen awareness of just what sort of tasty goodness they get when choosing your action for a turn it doesn't totally dictate the way that you play but it's an nice way to web the players together in a type of game that is typically pretty independent among the four actions you can plant new cards into your 4x4 restricted Island which yes proximity is a thing for a variety of reasons paying the cost of each card in soil which the next action is composting where you just get some soil and add some cards to your face down compost pile a stack of discarded cards from your hand or the deck tucked away for points but then there's the two remaining actions watering and growth the former adding cubes to the floor on your Island and netting a lower amount of soil the latter drawing cards and stacking the cute little tree trunks Worth fat points if fully grown at the end of the game but this is really what

the game is all about the tight network of interactions between all things at the table I mean everything in your island is worth points right but a good chunk of cards you play will be habitats giving passive powers and a huge amount of points from everything to various tags and played a positioning of cards in your Island and those compost cards trunks growth cubes they're all worth the point of Peace at the end of the game but they also play into various animal and ecosystem scoring you could be racing toward and you better believe there's a host of game effects that use those same cubes Trunks and compost as currency in one way or another not to mention the stock three Cube to two soil trade you can make it anytime this internal exchange the relationship between yours and other players action choices the triggering abilities on an otherwise simplistic action selection system it all gives this feeling of a vast interconnected Network which is both mechanically tasty and thematically quite appropriate that said this connectivity Bears a heavy burden Earth is is a game of tension and pressure by the halfway mark you might find here serving a dozen or more Point proliferating Masters muddying what may be the otherwise focused thrust you set off to begin with and for being a game all about playing in the dirt there's a certain sterile quality to it multitudes

of cards filed into abstract equivalents with mechanical Precision they're definitely cards you want but rarely one that feels like was born for your Island this game and as a product your gameplay is much less about Parts than it is the greater whole there is a Brilliance to Earth vibrant and harmonious An Elegant display with a vast ecosystem underneath and while it wears its influences on its sleeve like nature it adapts what works Cuts what doesn't and improves along the way I don't think it surplants its Forevers though who might be a little more specific a little more leaned into different niches but I don't think it means to either Earth is impressively cohesive an economic engine builder with a genuinely well thought through ecological theme one that stands confidently on its own that's our review but let us know what is your favorite naturalistic ecologically themed game and what's your favorite engine builder put it in the comments below to help everyone out because you've been such a great audience you've been such a great community and you've always been a great support to us here and so I want to say thank you and I've been Jack for the cardboard Harold

Progress saved