War Chest: Discussion 2.0
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked today I'm doing the discussion over War chest uh which war chest is a tactical Skirmish game where you utilize different units and different ships to uh control various points on the map and and you might be wondering if you follow my channel for any extended period of time that I already did a discussion over War chest and basically my feelings on the game were relatively lukewarm uh at best and not great at worst I but there was like there's something about the game that I I remember saying in the discussion that that I wanted to like this game which is very rare for me because it's like normally you should just like a game like you shouldn't have to want to like something but it's like if you it's either you like something or you don't like something uh but with board games there's a lot of factors that can go into why you might not like something could be the person you're playing with could be how you learn the rules could be that you misinterpreted uh you know strategy or whatever it might be and with war chest for me there were some elements that I still think aren't my favorite in the game um but on replaying War chest I now knowing that that's in the game have
come kind of Full Circle and I think that this game is really really good I do enjoy this uh a lot more than I did uh the past you know by the by the past discussion um because these designers uh Trevor Benjamin and David Thompson are really good designers so it's like there's no way that cuz I I know there are other games it's like there's no way that they just weirdly missed out on this one but made those other ones awesome so what were those things that were in the um like in the original like the the discussion that I had talked about uh well every unit in um in war chest comes with a certain number of chips so like the Scout for example uh has five chips and basically you need chips to be able to do anything with your unit you want to put them out on on the board you got to you got to you know draw the chip now everyone has a bag of their chips everyone has four units uh and you start out with two units of each type and your uh coin your sigil basically um and basically it's it's random on who you're drawing and who you're getting to activate but basically to do anything with them you need to have the chip in your hand face up you discard it to move them you discard it to attack with them you discard to user tactic you uh can
place them out on the board you discard it to control sections which is how you win the game but the Crux of that is that every time your unit gets attacked um it gets removed from the game so ultimately if I have you would think oh I have five Scouts meaning that they can survive five times well that's not true you should really in my opinion unless someone can again let me know in the comments if I'm missing something because there's still a strategy that I'm not quite sure on in the game um but if if a troop has five units you should really consider them as having four you know always consider whatever number it is as one less because if let's say I have a scout out on on the board and the other four Scouts are killed well that Scout doesn't do anything anymore like because you have to have a a coin of the type to be able to activate them and that to me would be fine if there was another alternate method that for you to use in the game uh like because so now that just sits there that's a unit that's just there and if it's not on a control spot or it's not in the you know if it's just somewhere random on the board and it died well it's very annoying that while you have five units you can have one out
on the on the map hell it even gets even worse if you choose to bolster bolstering is whenever you have a unit on the map and you have and you basically stack another one so it's a two stack which basically means it takes two attacks to get them off the the board that just means you have less actions to do but I I will say that's not really a negative uh it was a negative the first time but I actually kind of like this because you are actively making a decision on I'm going to get less activations with this unit and I'm trading for more defense or more Health uh some units really benefit from this more than others I think um like the knights for example the knights can only be attacked by units that are that are bolstered so if you bolster like your own Knights then that's causing your opponent to get rid of more actions to uh to bolster their own so they can take down the knights but even if they're doing that then that means that you still have Knights as a higher strength you're not going to get to activate them as much but you can use them for defense and this is what uh really opened my eyes about war chest because I will say the opening recommended game game it doesn't do you a whole lot of favors in my opinion so like with player a they have The Swordsman Pikeman crossbowman and light Cavalry and then player B has the Archer Cavalry Lancer and Scout now th all those units are
good they all have their own uses and strategies depending on who they're with and the that does enough to kind of one teach you the game but two it teaches you how to pay attention to what your opponent has and try figure out what your side has as its strength and weakness and counters to what your opponent which is fantastic in a two-player Skirmish game um the first time uh that I had like done the discussion we just didn't really see that like we weren't really like like yeah there's a counter it's like okay the Pikeman for example if they get attacked by an ajon unit they remove a coin from the attacker so it's like you TR you make trades with them okay well I have archers I'm going to use my archers who can shoot two spaces away to deal with the Pikeman um so just things like that but what it doesn't really do which is kind of I wish the game kind of did was try and help you understand why you would bolster and why you would sacrifice more actions just to have one extra Health on on a unit um and hell sometimes you might not even uh want to bolster like the scouts for example they can actually normally you have to deploy on a region you control you can actually deploy the scouts adjacent to any unit so a good counter
against crossbowmen who have to shoot in a straight line that's uh empty um if they're about to kill one of your units you and you have a scout you get to go first you can actually pop the Scout in front of them to obstruct the um you know the the line of sight so there's a lot of ways that units are actually used that aren't inherently understood whenever you're were playing the game and that's what really made War chest sing for me uh upon replaying it because what happened was AEG went on their like expansion Extravaganza on Kickstarter and I was like you know what I'm going to give War chest another shot I'm gonna get this and all of its other expansions like it's like I don't even like as of right now I don't even like the game and then I I I was like I get everything because why not and then uh here I am talking about how I think this game is fantastic because you kind of have to go into this game at least for me with a very chess mentality because when you're playing chess there are games of chests where some of your units are now useless and what I didn't understand stand going into war chest the first time was that that is also the case here there are times where your units are just useless and uh or you're not drawing them at the right time to make them useful so then you have to figure out alternate ways to make them useful uh and so my my initial
gripes with the game were still kind of there in the replay of teaching my friend the player a and player B what they recommend you start with um because there's also kind of like a there's no alternate way to win necessarily the that particular game came down the exact same way the first time I ever played this game came down where it was like okay all I'm doing is passing because all I have is uh you know one chip left of a character or of a of a unit so I can't you know I can't do anything with it I can't claim initiative again I can't control I can't use I can't move them I can't deploy them because if I do deploy them they're not doing anything while they're there so all I'm doing is passing and it kind of came down to who who can move who has units that can still move cuz if you can move that means you can activate them which means you can control uh and I was really disappointed I'm like damn that's same like two different you know players I'm playing against but the same you know starting suggestion ended the exact same way and I'm like that kind of [ __ ] sucks um but then then uh I was like you know what let's let's try it again let's actually do what they suggest or not what they not what they suggest what the rules are which is where you Shuffle uh you just give everyone four units um and that game was really kind of what solidified
this game as as great to me because one even though you have the exact same map and exact same starting position your strategy and how you are going to utilize your units felt radically different um and every every single like there's there's 16 in the base game I think 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 yes there are 16 in the base game and all you and uh only eight are ever out and there's no like oh you know like there's no like rules on who gets what it's just Shuffle these 16 cards give four out so what happened was my side funny enough was literally Knights and all the horses like I like I I kid you not it was purely random but I got the knights I got the light Cavalry I got the Cavalry and then I got the Lancers um and then my friend got the royal guard the crossbowman the IGN and the The Swordsman and the way that these units just they have such basic abilities but how they're utilized is what is really awesome cuz I went heavy on light Cavalry they were the first ones that I like completely recruited because I wanted Mobility so I wanted them to be able to move around and either get in
the way of the units or you know be able to quickly get to control spots and then control them and while they're moving moving around and you know harassing the other uh units I have my Cavalry moving and kind of doing light attacks out of the entire game I barely used my Lancers because they have to move and attack in a straight line and that's kind of difficult to do at least for me it was like well they can only attack by using their tactic so they have to move one or two in a straight line and attack in a straight line but what I ended up using them for was Whenever there was a like an area that I controlled if I got two Lancers in like my hand then I would PL plop one down and then have him go and attack when so he was very just situational and that was awesome um and then you start to see synergies of like who would be really good with what oh the um like the knights would be awesome with the end sign because the end sign allows uh other units to perform a move the I mean the like the the footman can have um they can have two two separate units cuz normally you can only well if you have like a scout for example out on the board you can't have a scout somewhere else you have to that's your only Scout unit but the footmen can they can have two footman units deployed at the same
time and it's like oh well that's really interesting you can just and then just keep like an ins sign with them so you have even more Mobility it it just really started to open up on how tactile this game was similar to chess and how certain sections of the board become highlighted it's not just here's the map it's okay now we're vying for control over here this is what these are what you're dealing with this is what I'm dealing with nothing's happening over here and I think a large part of that is because you do have random chips coming out so if you also pay attention to what you have removed of your opponent and it's like okay okay I have my light calvalry and my Lancers in my hand I could utilize both of them but if I don't activate my light Cavalry now cuz like in my in the last game I played my light Cavalry was my heavy focus and they were bolstered as well but it's like I didn't want to even lose a chip because that was the sole focus of my game that as they if they started to get dwindled down I'd have nothing so what ended up happening was every time he would move crossbowman in a chance to even attack them I would pull them back like I rushed forward and started trying to take control over his starting locations but every time he had crossbowman moved into position so I'd actually Retreat and bring them back um and but it's like well I killed some
crossbow men and crossbowmen have five yeah they have five units well two are Dead one he hasn't recruited and there's two left which one's being on the board and we just drew our three cards and I have initiative so do I risk it did he draw his did he draw his crossan and so that's that's a lot of the game is hoping that maybe they didn't draw the unit so I can actually activate I can activate my Lancer instead and hope that he doesn't have the crossan to activate and kill my light Cavalry and then after I do my Lancer on my next turn I can do my light Cavalry just that happens a lot you start paying attention to what your opponent hasn't recruited what they what you have killed how many chips are in their bag because you always draw three like there's never a chance I mean there there's a very rare chance where you can't draw three but almost always you're drawing three chips and it's like how many does he have in his bag okay if he didn't okay he didn't activate his crossbow in this round and he probably has like two or three chips left in his bag so he's going to get them next time and you do the exact same thing for yours like if you're drawing and you have you know eight chips to pull from and you draw three and you're like [ __ ] I didn't get my my knight that I needed to activate Okay how many Knights do I have in the bag okay there's two so chances are I
should draw them and sometimes you draw into multiple units of the same type and it's like sh it's like dang it well I wanted to activate those units but I can't and that's the kind of Randomness that I like in skirmish games is it's not okay I did all this moving and now I hope I succeed in attacking uh in this game it's similar to kind of like War the ring where it's like at the start of the round you're given what you can do and it's like dang it I really wanted to activate my Knights but I didn't draw them so what did I get and how can I utilize what I did draw in in the best possible way and that the same thing is happening to your opponent but it always even in a game where I was constantly taking um control points I never felt like I had the upper hand even though my friend was like dude you have me backed up against against the wall and I was like I don't feel like it I don't feel like it's like I just for some reason cannot seal the deal because one thing about this game that does kind of suck is the only way that it mentions winning is when you place all of your control markers and you have six that you have to place so this game is a tug OFW of I took that from you you're taking it back or I took that for I took that control spot from you you're taking another one from me um so it can kind of drag which did happen in the last game where it was like I feel like I'm
constantly like I've killed a lot of your units I have have I have taken a lot of control markers but I have like one or two control markers left like oh I have one I just need to do it oh I didn't draw my unit that I needed to control okay and you just took one back so now I'm back to two and it does kind of drag a little bit I wish there was an alternate way to win besides oh you can't do anything I guess I win which I guess it's kind of how chess Works where eventually it just comes to uh either you checkmate which is kind of like the control markers here or you just stall out and it's like yeah your opponent can keep evading you but they can't win so that is kind of like how it is here where it's like okay I can still move units you cannot so I will eventually be able to grab all the control markers so we'll just call it here now one thing about this game that I actually do not like is these Royal coins I find them to be very very weak and that actually bums me out because that was one thing I mentioned in the original discussion that I do feel is still the same here in that the Royal coin can only be used to do face down actions and your face down actions are claiming the initiative which is huge like making sure you get to go first uh when you're trying to do something is is huge recruiting which is taking units that are available putting
them in your Discord pile so you get them next time or passing and surprisingly passing which is normally in a lot of games for me something that is like never going to be done but there there were a lot of times that I was passing to wait and see what they were going to do because I had units I could activate and it's like okay let's see I'm going to leave my light Cal there I'm going to use my Royal coin to face down and pass cuz it doesn't have to be the Royal coin it could be any token can be used as a face down action um but it's like okay he didn't activate his crossbow men which probably means he doesn't have them so now I can do what I want with my light Cavalry so you actually do pass more often than you would think um but that is the only thing you can do those are the only three things you can do with your Royal coin and I really do not like that because to me this is the only coin you have now to be fair to be fair there is the Royal Guard so one unit can actually you can discard the Royal coin to move it and I feel like that's why that they don't have any other uses for this because I hav't have a unit that does use this in a special way um but I really wish the Royal coin was a wild cuz to me having Knights say there are four of them and really if one's out on the board and actually let's just say two out two are out on the board and one's dead then I just have this one to
activate those so if for example these two units get killed I still have a knight like thematically I still have a knight unit I have a troop of knights but if I deploy them I have no way to activate them I think that that's super stupid like that makes no sense to me even thematically or mechanically it's like there are times which again might be let me know like what I'm missing on this aspect but the knights for example can still be good where it's like okay I'm just going to put them on a control marker that I control and now they're just going to be there for defense cuz you can't take something if there's a unit on there you have to be on top of it and the Knights for example can only be attacked by units that are bolstered so they're they kind of just puppy guard that's the only only use for a single unit chip that I can think of and it's very hypers specific to um well the knights for for example it feels like but I really wish that when you drew your Royal coin if you could use it as a wild to still make one unit available I feel like you should be out of units when all the chips are gone so if the knights or if I have one chip that's a knight that's there and I draw my Royal coin I should be able to discard that to activate like and only to activate like hell like not to not to bolster or anything like that but like to move to attack or to control I think
would make one the game go by a lot quicker and force your opponent to actually wipe your units out if they don't want to deal with knights anymore they should have to get rid of all four chips not three of them um because other if you don't deploy them then they just become a face down chip uh or a chip that you use for face down and kind of like muddies like muddies up your bag with dead dead chips and you know throughout the game you don't need to recruit anymore you're probably pass you're either passing or maybe claiming initiative but sometimes you might not have to claim the initiative so that's still a negative for me I really wish the Royal coin allowed you to activate units that were out on the map as a wild um but that's really my only gripe with it like the the tactile nature of this game the the way that you just Shuffle um the the unit the unit cards and just give each person four and reading what you can do and reading what your opponent can do and trying to figure out how to effectively deal with that uh really shown uh re shined shown really showed up uh on on replay of of War chest um and the and their chips and these
chips are really good like they they have a really good weight to them I love the the design of the now granted it's like the light Cavalry and the Cavalry are very very similar but they're colorcoded um so I guess if you're color blind at least the icon is different but they are it like that's those are the only units that are like the exact same uh pretty much but yeah they also have a really cool like um where was it yeah setups inspired by famous battles I think that's really neat uh just to have those and you get a little history lesson on those battles and who who has white units and yeah this is just became one like an awesome awesome like two-player Skirmish game where you just you look at a unit and you're like oh that's really good like for example the uh Warrior priest after the warrior priest attacks or controls you draw One coin from your bag and immediately use it to take any action that's amazing that's super good um pikemen are annoying because they basically have retaliate and they kill if oh you attack me a Jason well I guess I'm also killing you so we're just going to trade uh so they just become annoying when when placed out uh yeah it's this one really like I I really like flipped on my feelings for it so very rare uh redo of a discussion again let me know
in the comments uh how to how I should look at the one chip maybe there's maybe the way it's designed that way for a reason which I mean it obviously is but like maybe like a lot of chips just suck when they're down to one but then there's some that are still really good I mean to be fair you have other like the end sign friendly unit within two spaces they can move to a space within two spaces of the end sign so hey I have one Scout left on the board I don't know why I keep using Scouts they're just there okay but hey yeah I can't activate them myself but I do still have a lot of things for with the end sign so I can activate I can at least have the Scout move around which in this case the Scout would suck to move around but let's say you're down to one Pikeman you can have the inside move the Pikeman uh around to get into a position to at least force them to attack uh or maybe not attack you just kind of start deterring so there are ways to kind of get around the one chip I just wish there was a little bit more freedom when that does become the case but other than that on a scale of 1 to 10 I'm now going to put War chest up to an eight I I think it was originally a five I can actually look it up and tell you if it was uh originally a five War chest War
cheet yep I put it put it right out of five and so it's getting a three-point bump because I just something about it just clicked on and because I understood what the game was how how close or how it felt close to like chess um that it's like yeah still don't like like still have some gripes from previously uh the previous discussion but now uh now it's just it's just working so I'm very excited to see what the expansions bring I do have all three of them now and uh I'll be doing discussions over each one of them at some point and hell maybe I'll do a ranking on the units that could be fun um but yeah so that is my thoughts on war chest let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and sub subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time update is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you