Top 10 Games from 2024 That Faded for me
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. and 2026 is here, which means it's time for that series that I do at the beginning of every year where I look back not on last year, but on two years ago at 2024 and I do a whole bunch of lists. The best games of 2024, revisited a year later. The games that have faded for me in 2024. That's this video over here. Hidden gems of 2024. There's a bunch of these videos. You can check them all out. I never know which order they're going up in. But we're starting today with this one. uh the 10 the 10 games of 2024 that faded for me. I will note if you do watch the series, I generally do 15 for most of these, but I only was able to get to 10. I kind of got to 11 and then just picked the top 10 uh for me. I just don't have so many games in 2024 that I can think about and say, you know what, those have dropped for me a little bit over the p over the course of the past year, year and a half. So, we're going to go ahead and dive into those. And I'm going to start with two things. Number one, a very very very important reminder is that this does not mean that these games are bad.
Several of these games I still own. Several, yeah, like three or four of these games I still own. But it does mean that the high of where where I first felt about the game has shrunk for me a little bit. I am trying to rank them in terms of how big that shrinking is. But again, the tricky part to remember is that the number one, meaning the game that arguably faded for me the most, is still a game that I own and play. And this does not mean bad games. It just means that I was here and I went down a little bit to wherever. Wherever wherever could have been. Sometimes they left the collection, other times they didn't. Also, thank you to Allplay for sponsoring the channel. Allplay is a site where you can get a variety of different things. Uh, but one of the things you can go get your hands on are going to be games. Go to allplay.com and you can combine shipping from a variety of the publishers that they support and you can get a whole bunch of games from a bunch of different people at a great price. It's not a typical store you try to think of when you're like, "Oh, I'm going to check out Games or Miniature Market." You can also check out AllPlay for a whole host of games you can get all for one affordable shipping price.
But that said, let's go ahead and dive into the the 10 I almost said 15, the 10 games that have faded for me from 2024. These are all 2024 titles that have gone down a little bit for me. Coming in at number 10, we have Spectral. Spectral I debated whether to put on this list because I'm not even sure if it really faded for me or if this one's more about the fact that in my group I am the one who probably likes deduction games the most which means they don't get played as often as I would like. Uh core of discovery is one of the reason one of the reason I like core of discovery so much is because it is a soloable deduction games makes it easier to table or even just the cooperative nature of it has made it more appealing to the people in my group. But competitive deduction games, I just find they don't get played all that much. And Spectral, as much as I was very high in it when it first came out, and I still enjoy it very much today. It's one that after a few plays, it was a little harder and harder to get my group to uh to buy into it. And I found that I didn't love it enough that I was willing to power through trying to have it and just play it with other people whenever it came up. So, it is one that again, I debated whether this one really faded for me, but we put it down on the list as one that has faded a little bit. Coming in at number nine, we have The Gang. The gang is a spiritual successor to the crew. It's not the crew. It's just a spiritual successor to the crew. It is a cooperative poker game where you're trying to kind of figure out who has the best poker hand through a degree of confidence as the cars are slowly revealed. It is very gateway friendly, also very fun. It's still a very good game. I just find that for me personally as time went on I just I would never pick it over the crew except for the situation in which you are trying to play with non-gamers who a hand of poker might be vastly more familiar than
trying to explain cooperative trick taking to them. So it still has its perks. It still has its reasons to pull it out, but it is one that over time I found that I personally will wouldn't pull it out over other games except for those specific nuance situations. Coming in number eight, we have Cortisans. Cortisans from Panosaurus. I loved this game when I first got it. I still think it's excellent. It's a very fun little kind of almost a stock taking game to a degree, which might not seem like it's that kind of game, but it's kind of game where you're kind of investing into where things will fall based on how you try to play your cards. It's very charming. Has foil gold foil cards, which is always very nice. When I first got it, I played it a lot, and over time, I just have found that it has hit the table less and less. It is one of many amazing smallbox games from Panosaurus, some of which I still love and play on a regular basis and some of which have shrunk a little bit to the background. Cortisans has shrunk a little bit to the background. Coming in at number seven, we have Ironwood.
Ironwood from Mine Clash Games. A delightful delightful asymmetric two-player experience with solo modes for both of the asymmetric factions. Ironwood is a puzzle of trying to play either as the the Iron or the I never remember the names. the iron themed clan and the wood themed clan with their respective goals of dominance over the mountains alternately trying to get the various secrets out of the forest. They play very differently. They has excellent card play. Still an excellent game, still one that I have and like, but it is one that has shrunk a little bit for me over the over over time. It's just one that I I don't know necessarily what it is about it. I do find two-player games in general that fall into a certain longer range, and that longer range can even be just as long as an hour, which Ironwood is in that 45 minutes to an hour range. I find they're a little harder to the table. For me, I find two blur games most to the table when it's either cooperative or when it's in that half an hour or less range.
Ironwood is excellent. I still like it. I still have it. It has shrunk a little bit for me. Coming in at number six, we have Tier Nanog. Tier 9og is an excellent uh point optimization game, one based around cards, and you're trying to gather draft these cards. It's kind of open table drafting, but with an interesting puzzle as far as how you place your pieces and what order you claim those cards, being mindful of the order that other players can claim the cards as well. Combine that with the scoring criteria of the various cards in play, and you have an interesting puzzle of trying to optimize based on the variable scoring criteria and based on the table and the way other players are trying to gather cards. Very well done game. I just found over time that it's one that I with it when it comes to these points scoring optimization games, there are a lot of incredible games out there. Some that I love and will not stop playing and others that I tend to fall for, but then over time I slowly drift towards playing my old favorites again and again and again. Uh for whatever reason, I just find that category I default to some of my old favorites. Usually, most commonly, you'll hear me say Calico and Cascadia.
A newer one that has still done very well for me is Spectacular. there. The newest one on the table is Whisper, but that's still too new to know if that one has staying power. I love these kinds of games and I enjoy them a lot. I just find that sometimes they they hold their own and other times they fade into the background and Turner Dog did fade a little bit into the background. Then there's Galactic Cruise at number five. Galactic Cruise is excellent. Still is excellent. I just played a game of it the other day, but it is one that I'm starting to question whether I need it personally. Because as much as Galactic Cruise is an intricate Euro experience that is highly rewarding, I find that when it comes to these Euro games where you're trying to optimize around what you do, I have found that over enough plays, sometimes I find the games sing for me. They are such a challenging puzzle of how to make it all work that can feel incredibly rewarding as you do so. And other times it feels a little bit more like work. Galactic Cruise for me has started to feel a little bit more like work in the sense that I'm going through the specific motions that you need to do in order to launch your cruise ships. The optimization around that is still a puzzle. It's still a puzzle as far as how to best optimize your worker placement, combining the various rewards, how you're going to upgrade and place your gears and various things. There's a ton of uh cards and abilities and all these things that you have that keep the game fresh. So, it still is one that I am charmed by, but is also one that I fallen into the patterns of of going through the sequence based on what the game needs me to do to launch a cruise and not based on how I personally am approaching my engine. When I think of games like STI or Galactic Cruise, STI sings every time I play. And Galactic Cruise has started
to feel like a sequence that I have to go through, a launch sequence, as you will, because that's what the game is. Still excellent, still amazing, has gone down a little bit for me. Then we have Things and Rings coming in at number four. This is an excellent game and I cannot say enough nice things about it. But the problem is it was a five out of five when I first played it. And by first play I mean like my first like 15 games I was like all over it. I loved it. I love the deduction process of it. It is I mentioned earlier with Spectral that I like deduction. That's true with Things and Rings. There's a there's a puzzle of trying to figure out what the rule set is on the table because that's what the game is. It's figuring out the rule set. You place down a card and then the knower, the person who knows all the rules, places that card somewhere else and you're like, "Gosh darn it, I thought it belonged in this ring. Turns out it belongs in that ring and that ring. What's going on here? What are the rules at play?" Through enough cards being played on the table, you'll figure out what the rules are or you hope to figure out what the rules are. And it's a fun little challenge of a puzzle that I absolutely adore. Again, this is one of those things where like even though a game shrinks for me, I don't want you to hear the wrong thing. Things and rings is incredible. Things and rings is amazing. I love it. I still play it on a regular basis, but it has gone down a little bit for me from the absolute I can't wait to play this every single time I can to hey, I'm still happy to pull it out. I don't see it going anywhere anytime soon, but it has gone down for me. Coming in at number three, we have Harmonies. Harmonies is one of those games that like Cascadia, like Calico, those points scoring games that I find myself retreating to my old favorites. Where Harmonies is different is I think Harmonies by many people is actually considered to be better than Cascadia has replaced it for them. But I found that again over enough plays, I will still happily play Cascadia every single time. And then harmonies, I just find myself reaching for it less. It's
still excellent. It's still incredible. I just reach for that game less because hey, there's only so many times I can play any There's only so many games I can play across the board and choosing which ones are most most satisfying when they hit the table. Cascadia still does it for me. Uh looking forward to Cascadia Alpine Lakes, which is also as incredible. Harmonies is very charming. The chunky bits are very nice. It is one that though over time I just rather play Cascadia. They give me similar vibes and I just rather play Cascadia. And that was always true, don't get me wrong. But over time, Harmonies has gone from, "Oh my gosh, I'm so happy to have another of these incredible, exciting games to it's good. It's very, very, very, very good. It's very good. I just would rather play Cascadia." Coming in number two, we have Aridia. Aridia Pass tread. This is a complicated one because I don't know if the game itself is I don't think the game itself is the problem. The game itself is excellent. I have so much high praise to say about Aridia. I give it 4.5 out of five and it's a rating that I am reluctant to shrink from. The problem with Aridia is Ardia is one of those campaign games that I find if I'm not heavily involved with it right now, then I find it's harder to get back to it.
It's hard to remember what were my characters doing, what were we exploring last, which areas of the board have we discovered. So, it's one of those games that the gameplay experience itself is topnotch. One of the best campaign games I've ever played. An intricate experience, a a testament to what uh uh what's it called? Um, oh my gosh, Cody from Far Far Games has done. It's an incredible, incredible experience. But it is one that I have shrunk from in terms of if I don't know what's going on, I have a hard time understanding where things left off. And so that has hurt the game for me, the the inability to step away for a month and then come back to it knowing what's going on with it. And that has certainly made it shrink for me over time. And then number one is a game that I still love, still have, and don't anticipate it going anywhere anytime soon. And that's Slay the Spire. And the reason for that, Slay the Spire, the card game, like the the the game based on the video game that's thematically based on board games, but is not actually based on a board game. The board game instead is based on the video game. Slay the Spire is an incredible game. I still have so much fun playing it. The problem I have with it is that most of my plays of Slay the Spire have been solo. I've played it cooperatively.
It's still fun cooperatively, but most of the time I end up playing it solo. And the tricky part there is if I'm playing it solo, then most of the time I almost want to default to just playing Slay the Spire digitally where I don't have to deal with the setup and tear down. The game itself does such a great job adapting the digital source that to a certain extent you're like I could do either. One of the best perks of Slay the Spire is the ability to play it cooperatively, which I don't do quite as often, which has held back the game a little bit for me. So I still love it. I still think it's excellent, but I definitely was more over the over the moon with it when it first came out. And as time has gone on, I'm still very happy I own it. And I don't think it'll go anywhere anytime soon. I have so many hours both in the video game and the board game. But as time has gone on, I find that I still default to playing the video game more so than the co more so than the board/card game. And that has certainly affected how high it has been for me. Those are the top 10 games of 2024 that have faded for me. Again, many great games in here. Over half, no, not over half, around half of these, four or five of these I still own and still recommend. They just have gone down a little bit for me as far as where they personally are. Hope you found this video entertaining or helpful in some way. Until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. And as always, I hope you have a good one.