Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is William Yorick Broken? (Arkham Horror: The Card Game)

Transcript 51:07

Hello everybody in YouTube land and welcome to another video here at Playing Board Games. Russ is with me and he's trying to take me to Italy.

He's like, "Do you want to go visit Italy?" You can't just attack the keyboard, buddy. There's nothing there for you. Yeah, Russ is hanging out with me. Today I'm going to be talking about William Yorick and this is not coming out of nowhere. This is in response to a comment on a video that Daniel that I recorded with Daniel on Daniel's channel Quick Learner, which if you don't know about you should go check out. I'll have a link to the video in the video description. But the conversation was what makes an investigator broken in Arkham Horror. So I was joined but I joined Daniel in this video to discuss what made an investigator broken and I I also realized I'm wearing the exact same outfit that I'm wearing Jesus Russ. Hey buddy, come on.

That I'm wearing the exact same outfit that I was wearing in this video.

Um that's a very funny coincidence here. Um but in this video the thesis that I presented from my perspective for what makes an investigator broken is when an investigator changes the rules of a game um uh changes the rules in the in the game in a way that is well I mean just intended unintended from the original point and broken so to speak. Like it breaks an idea of what the game is. So for example I presented Amanda Sharp. She breaks skill cards, right? She makes it so that skill cards always can just you know, be played over and over and over and over again. I talked about um uh Luke Robinson his ability to teleport around the map. Like he breaks what movement is, right? Will Yorick I presented is he breaks the idea and value of the assets, right? A lot of the times, pretty much every investigator except for like Tommy Muldoon, when an asset is destroyed, like when an asset is defeated, it's gone. It goes away.

It's never coming back, right? Um except well, Tommy gets it back at a delayed thing, but York is able to take these assets and then play them again in the future. And uh I thought this is very sound logic. I think this is all accurate, but uh there was a comment chain in here that I uh well, I wanted to kind of like talk about because I think that it's only fair if we make a video uh providing discussion that uh the viewers are able to share their own opinions, and I think it's only fair if us in the video are able to share our opinions back with their comments. So, I'm going to be talking about this comment here and kind of explaining in further detail uh why Will York is broken.

Even though up into the point of last year's tier list, I didn't rate him in S tier, which I do think is a fundamentally flawed way of looking at uh the idea of what broken is, but we'll get to that in a second. First, we're going to just scroll down and read the comment. I'm always Daniel and I do a little fun thing. We're always we're always reading your comments. And we're always there to uh figure, you know, uh to to kind of figure out, you know, what these people are talking about. All right. So, first off, uh this guy called me Dustin in the whole comment. So, that's why uh Daniel said his name is Justin, just for context. And then mis-typed sorry, but that is the only irrelevant thing in my post. All right.

We're going to just start there. If you do not know the person's name that is talking, I think that you're your whole the whole thing comes into question. I think just like I'm not upset that I was called Dustin, but I think that this shows right here that you're not really actually listening.

It's like when people mistyped Brin's name and Brin's name is all over the videos. It's like what it's in the title, it's in the description. It's just so it's one of those things where it's you're fundamentally half in half out. So it's like one of those things like it's like you it's just like off the bat not off to a good start.

[snorts]

I love Brian from BBG. Yeah, Brian from BBG is great. All right, Justin mentioned three broken investigators in the list he had Yorick. LOL. Which no one has placed as S tier ever, not even Justin himself. All right, this is a great place to start. We're going to stop here. Uh Brin has placed Will Yorick in S tier multiple times. Uh Brin is a big fan of Will Yorick and he has placed Will Yorick in S tier uh in previous tier lists. I checked this out to make sure that this was all accurate and it turns out it was. It was. Brin did put the some of these in the S tier, right? So uh also yeah, no one has ever is a very bold statement to come here. Uh we have people in chat right now saying they would place him in S tier and it is true. In all fairness to the credit to this user, um I have never placed Will Yorick in S tier. There's always been dialogue and whenever I've ranked the investigators, that S tier is um uh S tier is like uh S tier was like never I never put Yorick there, but he always was just like he he was always on like watch, right? He was always at the risk of being broken. It's things that we would always say. Like he's just like knocking on the door. It's like I would say Daisy is like she's one like incredible tome away from just like busting the game wide open and she's honestly getting pretty close with like the Grim Memoir that came out like a few years ago, right? Um

uh this is um like a case that we explained for York. And also, I want to give some further context for what S-tier means in one of my uh tier list videos cuz I think we have to do some further context here. While I never placed York in S-tier, the thing that defined my S-tier was the amount of effort that is needed in order to get a good start on the game. Like, how soon can an investigator start earning tempo? That's kind of like my

[clears throat]

my metric for my own personal S-tiers, right? How often can um Yeah, how how quick How many turns does it take to start getting positive tempo again and again and again consistently across the course of a campaign? That's like my first metric for S-tier. That's why you see me rank investigators with five book quicker than uh like uh higher than other ones because they can just move quicker on the game with less effort, right? It's one of those things that has kind of stopped Will York from being in my personal S-tier because he does require more time. However, Will York is incredibly backloaded in his tempo, right? In his value. Well, for example, let's just say Rex Murphy can get clues really quick and just move the game's pace really quick. If a scenario requires you to wait, there is no investigator that is better at that than Will York. Will York could literally go all day. He's freaking Captain America, right? He even has a shield he can pull out of the garbage to do it, right? Albeit that card is kind of bad in Will York. Will York, also like Daisy, anytime he gets assets, he just improves. So, let's talk about the context for my last tier list video where I put York in A or A+, right?

Uh we look at these um the stuff this was all released and recorded before Chapter 2 came out. And I think that Will York received some incredibly dangerous cards in Chapter 2, which also further enhances the uh the fact that it he was always on watch, right? Like he was always just he always got good assets, but he always got assets again and again and again. This is again I'm I'm I'm kind of arguing up the point here that S tier for me doesn't necessarily mean broken. I said in this video that I recorded with Daniel that Rex Murphy is not broken in my mind, but he is still S tier, right? S tier and broken don't necessarily mean the same thing in my mind. They might mean the same thing to this commenter, right? But to me, an investigator can be broken can break the rules of the game in some way and could end up being kind of bad.

Like it could happen, right? It's one of those things where like I guess yeah, who was the Ash Ashcan Parley Ashcan Pete was my last one who can control enemy movements. But like if there was an investigator who I don't know was just able to stop an enemy attack once in a round, right? Or like one not once in a round, like once in a while, right? Like just had like dodge built into their kit in some way. They would be broken, right? But they're not actually like winning the game. And that's to me the Will York issue, right? What stops him from being S tier is he's broken because he's changing the value of assets, but he is not necessarily winning the game by himself. The winning the game is always going to come into Cluver's. It's why also Tony Morgan, I don't consider him broken because again, I think it's hard to be broken when you're just killing enemies, right? Like it's hard it's hard to like be like like like be broken yeah, broken when you're just killing enemies. So like uh Tony Morgan is just killing enemies, but Will York is killing enemies, but then also just turning off Mythos cards because he doesn't care about taking damage and horror. He doesn't care about discarding cards. He doesn't care about discarding assets, right? But he's still not grabbing clues in a way that's crazy. Unless he taps into some of the new survivor stuff that make it easier for him to get clues, right? And I think that's what this fundamentally comes down to with this comment is I think that the me and this commenter have a different definition of the word broken.

And ultimately, that's okay. That's that's ultimately that's okay. And that's why I am going to speak with a little bit more kindness

than this commenter did. But also, I'm not, you know, I'm happy recording a video on a Tuesday for Arkham today. So I'm having a good time. All right. Let's just take a look at what York got within this um within chapter two so far that I think are relevant cards for his ability. Canteen. This card here is in tandem or just with two copies outcompeting Mr. Patterson, the Cherished Keepsake, which was already an incredible card for Will York. He can now upgrade into this and heal six horror across this and then when it's empty, replace it with another canteen from his discard pile. It also has a willpower icon. This break brain icon is incredible for allowing the players to commit this for will will tests and then just get out of this like ahead of the game, which is kind of crazy. He gets to put it in his discard pile and then just heal a bunch of horror. Canteen is insane healing for the cost and Will York can get 12 what? 18, 24 healing across the scenario easily because he is allowed to be aggressive with the amount of horror that he takes because he just doesn't care about that. So, this is one of the cards that Yorick got that he didn't get this year.

Um overall up on this the allies not too many, Fedora not really. Extra rations. Here's another card uh that Will Yorick got that is also pretty good with his ability. Something that we've said in the past in our videos was that uh if a card discards Will Yorick goes "Wait a minute. Can I break this?" And the answer to that question is obviously yes. Will Yorick is able to just get insane value when things automatically discard. So, four supplies if there were no excess supplies on extra rations discard it. Spend one supply and exhaust extra rations heal one damage for your investigator and ally you control. That seems pretty good. Now, Yorick instead of just only taking damage on himself, he can heal his allies that take damage to do things. Some examples of this, Beat Cop two, Greta Wagner three, right? So, now he is able to turn this uh his recursion into extra damage into clues when he's defeating enemies, right? It took guard dogs. Yeah, it took guard dogs to just deal more extra damage so he can get attacked, take the horror from the attacks, and then heal that horror with his canteen, right? Like these are all things that are pretty okay if you do it four times, right? But Yorick could do this eight times, 12 times, 16 times.

And this one also doesn't take up a slot, which is also really good. The thing that was holding Yorick back for a very long time that I think was stopping him from not being in my mind incredibly broken is the fact that he could not easily recur events. Yorick is actually probably one of the survivors that has the worst usage when it comes to events, right? York got Sorry, sorry, when it comes to resourceful, right? York can't really use resourceful that well because he wants to recur his assets through his ability and save on stuff that way. He can still do good things with resourceful, it's true, but resourceful was never really York's thing. And that's one of the time where most people bring back skills and events to get things done. Now, with Hunter's Instinct, York can bring back level zero events. So, number one permanent investigator uses three supplies. If there are no supplies on it, discard it.

As a reaction after you engage an enemy, spend one supply and exhaust Hunter's Instinct. Add a level zero event in your discard pile to your hand. So, now

[clears throat]

Will York can grab any level zero event from his discard pile. Like, let's just say for example, toe to toe, right? Like, we could just grab toe to toe. We can then kill the enemy that engages us, take the horror and damage on ourselves, heal it off or put it on allies that we want to die anyway, and then we can just play an asset from our discard pile. Now, you might be thinking, York doesn't have economy. How does he do this? York has incredible economy. He has Schoffner's catalog. He has hunting jacket, a card that just absolutely turned York into a a resource generation machine, right? Like, that is just absolutely insane. Now, level zero like, yeah, this is only level zero events, but then in the Miguel deck, they released the Hunter's Instinct level two, which also discards itself, even though this one doesn't say there was an errata that that this was supposed to discard itself. And as a reaction after you engage an enemy, spend one supply and exhaust it, add a level zero to two event in your discard pile to your hand.

HOLY CRU- HOLY CRAP! HOLY CRAP! THIS is insane for York, right? Because now York

[clears throat]

can grab any event from like his whole guardian splash, pretty much every survivor event, including the survivor event that came out that we just talked about in the video that released today, which is bought which is um uh which was scrape by, an absolutely insane survivor card. So, like this is just like it's all adding to the thing where again York is just getting so much good juicy stuff that I think the scale is now too far into it. And I'm going to talk about my uh ranking coming up again in the future, but this is all part of the thing that is just slowly adding up over time that has made York kind of a sore like a sore thumb a sticking point. Like this is just something that um is really really it's it's death by a thousand cuts for Will York. It was one of those things where he's always been powerful, he's always been good. But now his ability, especially with these cards like Hunter's Instinct and the extra incredible [snorts] soak and healing that we have here, like bandages was already really good. Uh and now he also gets like more bandages that he can just trigger at will, right? Like he can do all of these at the same time. It's kind of kind of nutty. He also of course got Loner um which is not really good for his ability in the sense that like you don't want to recur multiple times, but it's like the survivor pool goes up. It was these cards here that like the my analysis for York started to try

to hit those things because the reality is as well to go with this is that I don't try to I don't try to rush through my evaluations. Um I try to spend time playing the cards. I like to try to watch other people play the cards. I like to try to assess it from the best perspective that I can, right? So, it's one of those things where um it's one of those things where like I I I try not to say things in a reactionary way. I'm obviously guilty of it because I am human. But I think that realistically, I think since Hunting Jacket came out, I think there's a good argument that Mr. William York should have been in my S tier. And I think that I didn't really appreciate how good that York that card was for York. Like I knew obviously it was strong in York, right? But it's like one of those things where like in retrospect um uh in retrospect, it's one of those things where it's obviously it's obvious looking back, but like in the moment I was like, "Yeah, this is just a good card for York." But I think I really underestimated, especially with the insane card draw that survivor's been getting lately, it's it's like it's it's hard to it's easy to

look back and now be like, "I was wrong with my previous ranking for York." And it's unless things change, like unless like something crazy happens in the next month, I think this this guy is going to be on S tier S tier in my future list. Uh the in in the chat, I'm not convinced that York is a broken invest because a lot of things we're describing are occurring don't get us a win, but instead prevent a loss. I think you are misconstruing the point again. I think I I don't think you're wrong to believe what that is, but I think that York breaks the game enough, like he breaks the rules of the game, that I think York is broken. But he's not broken in the way that people traditionally view as broken. Yes, he doesn't win the game, right? He doesn't win the game, but he turns off so many aspects of the game. He basically just turned like we can agree that Gloria is a strong investigator, right? We can all agree that Gloria is very strong because she controls the mythos phase, right? York does the same sort of thing for himself.

He doesn't care about the mythos phase. He turns that off. Like how Luke Robinson doesn't care about enemies, William York can just not care about an entire aspect of the game. He's happy to draw enemies, and he can face tank any [ __ ] encounter card, right? That's why Yorick is broken in my mind, and that is because of his ability to turn assets into repeatable value in a way that they are not intended to be repeatable value. That's why Yorick is broken, right?

[snorts]

Like He always Yeah, it's it's one of those things where He's Yeah, Yorick has Rego games I think is saying this really good. The other thing that you also think of it um is that Yorick has plus X hand size works as number of cards in your discard pile. That's also another way that he's breaking the game. His hand size can be up to 25 cards, right? Um and then yeah, so this thing I thought we already don't fear the Mythos phase, sticky-out tongue. So, this is a great way to when you're losing an argument, try to deflect.

Yeah, we I I as a player am not scared of the Mythos phase, but that's because I'm good. Like I can make like any sort of investigator handle the Mythos phase because it's just with the amount of experience and play and playing and deck building that I've done in this game, right? But Yorick is the one that I need to try the least with to not be afraid of the Mythos phase. So, like if there was a scared of the Mythos phase tier list, Yorick would be like S tier for not scared of the Mythos phase, right? Every other investigator would be on that tier list at various levels, but Yorick is the one that's scared of the Mythos phase the least, right? So, it's like that's why Yes, I'm not scared of the Mythos phase. Most investigators I'm not worried about, but Yorick is not scared of the Mythos phase. He doesn't have a Mythos phase. All right, let's go back to this comment cuz I think this is kind of like talking about I spent a lot of time talking about why I never place Yorick as S tier, and I think that uh again Yorick is with my own person personal definitions of S tier um is a little bit is different than it was, but I think in retrospect I'm not really I was kind of wrong with my previous rating and especially now with these chapter two cards, I can't I can't not put Yorick in S tier. He's kind of just he's kind of just there.

All right. Also, your premise isn't exactly correct. The skills and events are only to be used once and if assets are gone, they are gone. This is just a general rule of the game. All games have exceptions to general rules. It's not enough to say, "Ah, that single card is broken just because it does something that others can't." Yorick recurs, so he never has enough time or recor- resources to recur so much to break the game. All right, let's go back to

Let's go back and let's look at uh Hunting Jacket again, shall we? Let's look at Hunting Jacket. So, this was a card that uh I saw a bunch of players uh break the game with. Break the resource thing with with Yorick. They were able to recur this multiple times throughout a scenario. It soaks, it gains resources, and Yorick has the card drawn now in his kit to do this. So, Yorick can use Hunting Jacket to get ahead. Of course, there's also Schoffner's Catalogue, which has always been worth the resources in your Yorick and you're also able to easily recur this over and over and over again and pay what you want. Not to mention, Yorick's whole plan from the get-go was to use Cherished Keepsake, a zero cost card to recur. So, Yorick in theory always has a card to recur. So, he doesn't have the the resource like the he always has the cost to pay for something that he wants to play from his discard pile.

Now, I would agree uh last year that Yorick never had the time to break the game. I would agree with that in the past, but now, as mentioned, he got Loaner. This card here is an incredible level zero card and it's an asset that Yorick can play from his discard pile. But I'm also pretty sure that Yorick got Yorick can play Down for the Horizon. He's on this list, right? No, he's not. That's good. Okay, that's good. I thought he was, but he's not a drifter. Thank god. I was like, yeah, cuz he can't play. He's just a warden. Cuz I thought he could could have that card, but Bruno's playing that in someone else. Thank god for that one.

But yeah, so like I would have agreed with this person's point that Yorick never had the time to break the game, but Loner has given the Survivors way of um the Survivors the advantage to um take the time to now do whatever they want. Survivors weakness was action compression, and they are starting to get ahead on actions because of cards like Loner. This was another card that Daniel and I talked about um in a what are Survivors a problem now? Are Survivors starting to become the strongest class? And I do think that with chapter two oh and Drown City, Survivors are looking to be the strongest class in the game.

Stronger than Seekers? Yes, I do think so. I I that's my personal evaluation. Hi, buddy. That's my personal evaluation here. So, uh and I think that this is just one of those things where it's made Yorick even stronger because yeah, Yorick was gated by time, but he's not really gated by time anymore. And he is not good at finding clues. He doesn't actually advance the game by himself. He gets some clues, but it's not that easy. And once you add cards for clues, you remove the cards that make him broken. I think that this is a fair point. I think this is a fair point, but I don't think that this was the thesis of the video. I think that this is a fair point. He is not good at finding clues. You do need to add cards that break the game plan if you are trying to get clues with Will Yorick.

Uh I'm currently actually playing uh a Will Yorick Clue Will Yorick Flex Clue deck in a run through Dark Matter on hard. Um this is not an assessment of Yorick because it is a a gimmick run. So like I'm not using this to assess Yorick, but I wanted to see if I could and I want to revisit that Will Yorick Flex deck um a Will Yorick Flex deck in the future. But I I do think that this is a good point. However, I do not think that this is actually an argument against the point that I was trying to make in this video. In this video, I was trying to say that Yorick is a broken investigator because he breaks an aspect of the game, right? And then also yeah, Daniel just said in chat, "Hunters Instinct can recur a single copy of Look What I Found six times." Yes, that is true.

Uh like that is also something that Yorick could do now. He'd have to find the resources to do it, but he only had a hunting jacket to put his cards on, right? Like like recursion is Travis has said this on the channel many times. Recursion is a broken mechanic in pretty much any game that offers recursion. And I think that because it's breaking again a fundamental rule of the game, which cards can only be played once. Cards can only be triggered one time. Like for example, Isabel Barnes is very likely to be a broken investigator in the future because her recursion changes the value of skill cards, right? I think that this is one of those things where this user is um see seeing that one definition of broken as like uh higher than S-tier, right? Rusty, want to not sit on this cable?

Like they they think that broken means higher than S-tier. And I think that is a fair assessment to have in your own personal definition of broken, right? But again, I don't think it's necessarily true that broken means S-tier. I think that broken means taking aspect of the game and changing it. And I mean like again, I think that Will York is S-tier now. Like I do think he is because what I've seen what people have done with him with the new cards and seeing these new cards in action, he is way too good. He is way too good. He is He just like again, like you just turn off the mythos phase. Like he just doesn't care about that entire aspect of the game and that is dangerous. That is dangerous, right?

Um No, it isn't true that York isn't scared of anything. He isn't scared of discarding only. And even that is not trivial because his economy is a great to have resources to play everything again. Let's just go back and look at hunting jacket. Let's just go back and look at hunting jacket here. This card gets six resources, right? Is Lola Hayes broken because she breaks the rule of deck building? I'm not trying to argue, I'm trying to understand your perspective. Lola Hayes doesn't break the rules of deck building. Oh yeah, he also she also got bounty. Yeah, bounty is another insane card for Will York, which you can also recur with Hunter's Instinct. So actually York's economy is like sorted and then some. Uh is Lola This is a good thing. Is Lola broken because uh her she breaks deck building? So she doesn't break the rule of deck building.

To me an investigator that breaks the rule of deck building would be an investigator that can play any card. Like if it said deck building options, do whatever the hell you want, right? You Lola doesn't break the rules of deck building. Every investigator has a unique deck building rule, right? Like if Lola Hayes's deck building was um yeah, Suzy probably comes the closest. Yeah, filing is 100% on that. Suzy is probably the closest investigator that comes to actually breaking the rule like what deck building is. But they have those other stuff that's like you can't really really work, right? Um but like it's I don't think deck building like I think the only way we could have deck building if it was a 30-card deck with whatever you wanted, right? That that I think to me would be an investigator that breaks deck building. And I know that uh it sounds like I'm like being a little I know there's already someone who's probably thinking, "You're just being picky, right?" But is there anyone else that does what Yorick does?

Is there another investigator that can play a level like a level three asset from his discard from their discard pile? Like that's like that there isn't really, right? I can't think of anyone that can do that who can do it again and again and again, right? Agatha? Yeah, Agatha, but we talked about Agatha. We did talk about Agatha in there, right? Where Agatha also was on our watch list, but she also has a few some guard rails for it. Um but Salvage plus Hunter's Instinct. Let's go! But it's like one of those things where uh it that's like to me like again where my thought process from Yorick was is that he is his ability to recur assets breaks the rules of assets and it turns off a part of the game. So, let's go back to this.

Um Yeah, so only catalog for items and many times you don't have the resources to recur the catalog first and wait. I I I I I feel like this person is missing um is missing the um the value of like the Hunter's Jacket and Bounty now. Like I think they are they are speaking from the perspective of not knowing about all the cards that Yorick has in his card pool. Because only Shop and only Catalog for items is true in Edge of the Earth, right? It's only true in Edge of the Earth. Um and that is just not the case anymore. He has Hunter's Jacket, he has Bounty, right? Even E-cash 2. I'm going to say it again. I'll have an excuse to put E-cash 2 in a video. E-cash 2 is just also card drawn things and now he can recur that with Hunter's Instinct 2, right? So, like that's a lot of things.

That's like a lot of things that comes there. And And even having an investigator even even having an investigator's missiles mythos resistance doesn't mean he's broken because again, he can't advance the game. He can just resist dying. So, uh This kind of is like uh this kind of counters this, right? He says no it isn't true that Yorick isn't afraid of anything. He can just resist dying, which is like how the game tries to kill you.

It's how the game tries to win, right? It's like like it wins in two ways, agenda, killing you, right? Those are the two ways the game tries to beat you. And the way that they beat you by agenda is by slowing you down. How do they slow you down? They take away actions. They make you lose assets. They make you lose cards. Yorick doesn't care about two of those. A Yorick with Lone Wolf doesn't care about the third one. They try to kill you with damage and horror. That's the killing wing. Yorick doesn't care about that, right? It's one of those things where again, like Yorick just turns all of that off. Um And while he it's this statement is here, it doesn't mean he's broken because he can't advance the game. This is where there is a difference between my definition of broken and your definition of broken. And again, that's okay.

That's fine. But I'm not talking about solo ass [ __ ] Yorick here.

I'm not talking about some crazy person bringing solo Will Yorick to the table. I'm talking about York as part of a team composition of two to four investigators. And if this one guy is just basically if the team is drawing one less mythos card a turn, they're going to win the game.

They're going to win the game. If you're drawing if you are two players drawing one mythos card, that's insane. That's insane, right? That's kind of where like it it it comes in because he just turns it off and that's why in my opinion York breaks the game. Is is I actually William Will York could be good in solo. I actually have no idea cuz I don't play solo, right? Maybe it's a definition thing, but Gloria does all that before all investigators, not just one. So, that's my argument for them being in different tiers. Uh but does she do it for all investigators? Does she do it for all investigators or does she do it for one?

That's the question. Does Gloria use her ability for all investigators? I don't think she does. I think Gloria is I I think that realistically one investigator is getting a good card from York's from Gloria's ability. I think that one investigator is getting a good card. I also think that Gloria's true ability is that she's discarding the the the the bad cards. That's to me is Gloria's true strength. Not that the fact that she can give out cards in the order that she wants. It's very I mean Gloria is also in my um uh Gloria is also in my um broken tier anyway, right? I think Gloria is turning off the mythos for two to three players around. Yeah, potentially. I I I could see it, but I don't think so.

I think she is giving the most advantageous cards, but she's not turning the cards off. I think she is putting To me, Gloria is putting her finger on the scale as opposed to just like turning off a card completely for like multiple investigators. I think Gloria's again, to me Gloria's biggest strength is discarding the card. That's to me is Gloria's big thing where you can just delete cards, right? She can delete Ancient Evil, she can delete things that would hurt other people, but I think she's not turning cards off for other investigators. I think she is giving an advantage. Again, we're splitting [ __ ] hairs here cuz Gloria's also in my broken tier, right? Like she like they're both they're both broken but for like different reasons, right?

Gloria is able to turn the Mythos phase into the favor of the players, which is very powerful. Yorick is able to turn off the Mythos phase for himself. And this is also again, the thing that makes Yorick bro I'm getting lost in the weeds by chat. The things that make Yorick is broken is the fact that he can recur assets, which gives him the ability to turn off the Mythos phase. That's one of the many things he can do with his um repeating um his repeating uh like things, right? So he can like soak forever, he can do all these things. Like I feel like I feel like Filing is an agent of is is is not working for the greater good right now.

We're getting lost in the Gloria sauce. But again, I I I'm not here to argue that Gloria is more broken or less broken than uh Yorick. I think Gloria is more broken than Yorick. I do think that because I think just deleting cards generally of with a selection is a lot better than deleting the card you draw if we're going to look at like this in an individual perspective, but just because Gloria is more broken doesn't make Yorick not broken, right? Yeah, he can just resist dying. Again, I think that like this is something that is this statement right here I don't think you understand how dangerous this is for the game. Right? Like if I bring a Yorick deck at this point, I know I cannot lose.

I will not die. Right? I know that it is impossible for me to die. Right? And that is not good. Like that's just not good.

That is to me, we're starting to get to the point where things are broken. Anyone thinks Tony Morgan is okay? Tony Morgan of 15 to 20 XP is completely broken. I've seen it in action and it was ridiculous because bro rogues have several broken cards, too. Uh Will Yorick I'm sorry, uh Will Yorick, Tony Morgan is S-tier. Tony Morgan is incredibly strong. But talking about what I was talking about in the video, to me what makes an investigator broken? Tony Morgan hits none of those things in my own personal ranking. I would call Will I would call Tony Morgan busted, right? I would call Tony Morgan a busted investigator. I would not call Will Yorick I might call him busted, but I think that Tony Morgan is [ __ ] busted, right?

But I do not think he is broken cuz what does he actually have that makes him broken, right? Like I'm just trying to think. He has five fist which I suppose breaks the rules of what the rogue class was for weapons, right? Um but now there's Michael McGlen that has that. He has absolutely incredible deck building, but again, I don't think that makes him broken for me, right? He gets the additional like resources and actions to fight things, which is really good, but like a lot of rogues are getting extra actions, right? Yeah. I I Derby K, I think you're 100% on that. That's a great way to put it.

He broke the rules of the class, but not the game. And that's to me why Tony Morgan isn't a broken investigator, but he's [ __ ] busted. Right? All right, there's a thing with my concerns that York shifted entirely to tempo and in that that's enough to be broken, which it probably is then he's broken. My group's pretty regularly take Oval or the Great Work, which is them saying that they are effectively not going to die. What I mean by the above is that I'm not sure that York is the only person who is very resilient. Okay, so this is that's a great point. Cuz that's a great thing. So, the question is the question that becomes the question that I often ask, how much harder do the other investigators have to work for that resilience? And then, how much value are they getting outside on top of that resilience, right?

Cuz I think that to me is the defining line between that, right? It's kind of like uh what I often talk about Rex Murphy. Why Rex Murphy is so good is because he is the tempo that other investigators try to seek out in the cards that they um in the cards that they like want to play, right? Like he just has all of that stuff, right? Um like he just has all of that advantage without needing to do the work. And I don't want to really dive into that answer right now for Will York, because it doesn't really change my evaluation on the theory of what makes him broken, right? Where that's where we find that dividing line between everyone it goes back to that tier list to talk about for the not die tier list, right?

Spectral Shield plus one of the nine charge assets in Mystic is functional immortality. Yeah, that's that's a great combo. That's a great combo, but you need to find those two assets. Are they doing anything else, right? Like are they they doing these things? Like I think that the spectral shield and one charge assets is very good, but that's also like spectral shield is it exhaust?

Yeah, the first time it's so it doesn't exhaust, but it's the first time each round, right? So it's also like I mean yeah, you're like this stuff is good for chip damage, but it's not good for burst damage, right? Yorick can uh Yorick can deal with burst damage and chip damage, right? It's again it's that question of the different levels of um uh Oh, this was the tabooed. Yes, that was tabooed. Yeah, well I mean I'm talk I I talk about with the taboo list to taboo list evil damn them and playing Arkham for 10 years all my I'm not talking about cards not on the taboo list here, right? Um come on. Are you Are you YOU'RE TELLING ME YOU'RE PLAYING UNTABOOED and you're playing Sharon's Obel and great work and you're wondering why you're winning?

No wonder. No wonder. But yeah, it's I think that like it's again like I think that I'm not saying that these are bad combos and I'm not saying that this is a bust that this is not a busted combo because I think that spectral shield is a dangerous card, right? But then it comes down to the question of how much are these How much are these cards um like are these cards doing just that? Are they doing anything else, right? And I think that that is like the defining line that I'm not going to be here to define it for you. Like I'm not even like I'm not even like I'm not even going to say that this this commenter is wrong for not thinking Will Yorick is broken. What I think they are wrong in in saying that I am incorrect that my assessment is wrong for Will Yorick. I do believe Will York is broken. I stand by what I said in this video, and we actually even got We haven't got to the line yet that made me want to make this video. There was one line that this person said that made me want to make this video, and we're going to get to that here. Um but yeah, I think Tony Morgan is busted. He's not broken for me personally, but if he's broken for you, I think that's totally fine.

So, uh someone said, "That is a good point. How can an investigator be broken but not in S tier?" This is something that I talked about in this video, and I hope I gave an explanation for my own personal logic for it. But then they said, "It can't. They just say things without thinking well about them sometimes." So, this was um this was the comment that made me want to make this video. I can assure you that I think about everything that I say about Arkham. Sometimes I get tangled up because I'm reading chat while trying to uh like record a video, and my mind sees an interesting comment or a word or a funny joke, but I can assure you that everything that I record for Arkham, I have spent time thinking about what I'm going to say, or I'm I have There's some passion in what I'm going to say. I truly believe that Will York is a broken investigator.

With the Chapter 2 cards, he is now in my own personal S tier. And the reason for that is because, again, as I mentioned in this video with Daniel, which I go into big detail about the ability to have assets come back after defeated breaks a fundamental rule of the game, right? This is stuff that's not supposed to happen. Some people in chat were talking about Scavenging 2 earlier. Scavenging 2 is an example of a card that I would consider to be broken because it breaks a fundamental rule of the game. Right? I think that Travis would agree with me on that thing. Uh at least on the scavenging assessment. I'm not sure his thoughts on Will York for that. But I think that This was This was the only part of the comment that bothered me. This comment right here. And that's why I wanted to make this video. I'm I'm actually I'll be honest. I recognize this commenter.

I've hidden them from the channel. I do not like even long ago. This guy's always been This poster has always been There's there's sometimes where they like they leave a comment and I'm like, "You're an angry person. I do not want to read your comments." This person's been gone from my channel for a while. So unfortunately, we are not going to um We are not going to um have any more further conversation after this. But I I I just had to talk about this even further because I I I believe what I say. And I want to to to go with this. And I think that I'm have I've been having a great discourse here with Evil Dan in chat here, which is I agree largely with the comment but don't agree with its tone. And I think that that is totally fair, right?

I do think that this is Nothing of what they're saying here. I mean, I do think some of it is at this point wrong, right? I think that like um the the resources. I think at this point this is the only thing that I think in this comment is is wrong because York now has bounty. He has hunting jacket, right? He has more than just Schoffner's, right? I think that this is the only only catalog for items. I think that this is the only thing in this comment that is wrong. And I want to underline and end the video with this statement. I think everything else, all the opinions that this commenter has, I think is totally fair, right?

Because I think that you're you're you're fine to be what you want. You're fine to define your own I guess this is also wrong.

And also when he called me Dustin, that was also wrong. But like everything in here you're you're fine to define your own terms for broken. You're fine to engage with the strength of investigator different than other investigators. Like everything that this person even like the thinking Tony Morgan is broken, I'm going to I'm not here to say you're wrong for thinking that, right? I'm here to say I think that's I personally don't think he is, but you're more power to you, right? And like even thinking that like I think it's a fair assessment if your idea for broken does not involve if it does not involve clue tempo, I think that that's also fair, right? Albeit I do think that parallel ash can Pete is a broken investigator and he doesn't have any clue tempo, but he turns off enemies and that's really good, right? It's like it's it comes down to just your own personal personal um evaluation of it. So ultimately um I'm going to just say more power to you, but you should check out your your ex-economy, man. It's If you're living in a world where you're just playing Schoffners, your mind is going to get [ __ ] blown, brother. He can do so much cool [ __ ] with Cash Now. It's insane.

All right. Thanks for watching everybody. I hope you enjoyed this video. Uh yeah. I I had a fun time I had a fun time discussing it. It went longer than I thought. It's like what's that one that one tweet from that from that [ __ ] poster where it's like and I was not mad. Do not put in the newspapers that I was mad. That was me making this video, but I will say that one last comment that we we scrolled down to, that made me mad and that made me want to make this video. So thanks for watching everybody. Have a good one, and as always, a GG's.

Progress saved