Skip to main content
Loading video...

Oath: A Discussion of the Clockwork Prince - By Board Of It

Transcript 11:19

hello everyone tally and farrell here from board of it today we're going to be discussing the clockwork prince which is the ai that's recommended to use if you want to play a game of oath solo or with two players we do have a full review of oath which we'll link in the description box below so we should say that we've only played with the clockwork prince three times and i was with us together but we did actually play it literally three times in a row so it gave us a good overview um and essentially the way it works is you use the back of the chancellor board and it has this kind of setup and you have this sheet which you move tokens across and it kind of follows arrows and that shows what action so it's like kind of a very logical layout of you know does it want the uh does it want to control the most sites okay well then it's going to master troops it's going to trade for favor two muster troops and then it's going to try and attack when it's ready and then take the site and then it kind of continues right in this loop i like that it's called the clock like prince's mind yeah that's a big jumble there and in his mind it's quite nice i mean the thing is this is quite terrifying when you look at it for the first time it's actually not that bad to follow um but yeah i'd say first comment is the rules one of the problems that we didn't mention in our main review is that there's like seven different sheets of paper with all the rules and there's player guides and all this

and all of the rules are just like on this double-sided a4 sheet in tiny font and i don't know why it just didn't have a little separate rule book or stretch it out or because it seems quite like crammed in um but anyway it's not it's not like too bad to learn but so why don't you tell about our experience with clockwork prince yeah we basically just found that it didn't particularly behave like a real player would yeah and it seemed to have this issue where it was either extremely overpowered and there was nothing we could do to fight it it was it had a lot of warbands it had like what 16 or something on its board at one time in a in a normal game of oath if you weren't using that that's just so unrealistic it would never happen that um a player could ever muster that much or it was kind of underpowered because it had already dumped all of its troops on the sites and once they were on the sites they don't move back to the board so when he comes to muster again there's nothing there and he just gets stuck in controlling these sites there's nothing you can do about it because he's got 16 on there there's no way you can beat it but then it can't do anything else either so it kind of just played not very realistically and we've played with like other ai bots before like the ones in root yeah and we really really like the clockwork um expansion for root we do actually find that it simulates the third player

pretty well yeah whereas in this case it it really didn't yeah i mean just touching on the break like you said i think underpowered but also fine it basically totally breaks down and gets stuck in a loop and that's the thing because it's like in one example um the goal was to control the most sights and as you say because it dumps so when it wins a battle what it's told to do is dump all of its wallbangs equally among all the sites it's trying to control but if it's only attacking one this means that it dumps everything it has on its board onto that one site so after it attacks two sites it's like out of warbands and it couldn't attack so it just got stuck trying to gain favor and trying to muster but it can't muster because it doesn't have any war bans so it looped and all it did was steal all the money out of the favor bank so it ended up with like 15 favor on it and yeah it was it basically meant that there was no third player attacking the winner of that game or whoever was in lead um which would happen in a real game yeah once it gets towards the end of the game and like one person is going to satisfy the win condition all the other players go after them to stop them whereas the clockwork prince didn't it just it yeah it just didn't simulate a real game in that way at all and like you said yeah it had loads of had so much favor on its board but nothing it couldn't do anything with the

favor it was taking the money so we couldn't have it but not doing anything with it yeah it was making the game more frustrating for us because he got like stuck and yeah touching on the overpoweredness as well that's the thing the way it works is that it really collects a lot of resources and warbands and things very easily with no real issue for it to get there's no barrier for it to get the stuff right it just accumulates incredible amounts and it's things that players could never accumulate in a real game and it just makes you feel really frustrated because honestly in like the second turn of the game a player might have one sight and then the clockwork prince will show up with 12 warbands and roll like you know 14 dice at you and you've got like one defense you've got no hope it's like embarrassing really um but yeah so that's the thing and it i think personally for me it just felt really frustrating because it didn't feel fair like it's one thing it's not that it has particularly play like another player but you people want this sense of fairness and it just never felt fair because if it wanted something from you the way it works because there's no barriers it will get it from you and that was the issue that's true i mean yeah what i would say was that i think this is a complex game and it's quite like obviously a lot of effort to design something like this i think it's about as it is well done and like the system it falls is fine

it shows us that there's definitely problems like we say overpowered broken and neither of those are things you want or make you feel good or help you to enjoy the game yeah so the bottom line i guess is kind of you definitely this isn't something until maybe the kinks are worked out that you want to um have to play at two players or solo yeah i can't imagine just going into this game and playing with that straight away i would be i was confused playing it you know regardless without the clock quote prince um and yeah if you had to include that as well because i think another thing is that the board is is quite different and honestly like i mean you controlled it right but i don't really know what was going on because the board is different and it's like i don't know would you say it's asymmetric in some ways because it has this kind of different way that it works whereas the other players it's not asymmetric and it's like powers i don't know i just i didn't really know what you were doing if you maybe that's you know the more you play with it you could get more people to control it so they understand but when you were following the clockwork prince's mind you know the the flow i was just sat there like i don't know what's going on here but sure but yeah i think it's interesting that you say about maybe more players control it because i don't think you'd actually want that because it is a little tedious to learn and then that's to have to put more people through that site yeah but i guess only really two

people would need to know how to use it so one that's true yeah i think the bottom line is essentially it's uh it's a good attempt but yeah it doesn't quite work there's definitely much bigger issues here probably because of the complexity of the game then there is in the clockwork um expansion for root i think that's really well done yeah and it actually really feels like other players are playing with you and it just doesn't feel the same here i think if it's working it feels frustrating it's bottom line and then it can very easily not work and i think because the clockwork prince can either play as a chancellor which i think is the optimal way for it to be or it can be an exile and somebody told me this on boardgamegeek but i don't know how verified it is um but apparently the exile aspect was added later and it wasn't as maybe fleshed out and they kind of added it as a way to continue your chronicle if if you beat the clockwork prince so then it's not chancellor again yeah and that one is definitely the one that is more likely to break as well yeah um do you think it's like because some part of this strategy of this game is being a little bit sneaky and keeping your like cards close to your chest about what you're doing and obviously there's no like human element there for doing that that maybe that's why it doesn't quite like fit in as well

yeah and you have to be a bit scheming and um hiding what you're what you're doing from other players and obviously it can't do that so yeah it's a good point but yeah so it was a bit of a miss for us i mean the thing is we did play with it three times in a row so it can't be that bad yeah but and we mean literally in a row like in one sitting but um yeah so if you were only going to play with the clockwork prince it's maybe not it's not worth to get the game right but then you know it's fine because we will play it with more players and we have and we we tried that out and but it wouldn't be our only way of playing oath and if it was then yeah you know i would definitely recommend it i would definitely play with it again it's just not optimal i think it's just you want something that works every time especially if you're paying this kind of money for a game and it doesn't um i wouldn't be surprised though the thing is i guess if you stick with it i'm very sure there'll be fan made like variants of this uh probably pretty soon and there's also a kind of errata i guess you could say although it's a fan one i don't think it's official yet that they say rather than dumping all of the wall bands on one site to treat the board as a site so then you put them evenly so if you have 10 only five go on the site and then you keep some back and it allows it to work more efficiently um yeah i've got to recommend they basically say use that if you're playing it for two player and use the original if you're playing it solo but it's just these kind of

things i like i don't know it's something that fans did very quickly and it wasn't picked up in play testing and but yeah but that's our basically i just little opinion piece on the clockwork prince like we say we haven't played with it hundreds of times so you could also call it a first impressions yeah but thanks for watching and if you subscribed because of the earth video and you're here to watch this thanks a lot for your sub it really means a lot to us and for everyone that watched oath and is watching this and we'll be back on sunday with a normal review bye

Progress saved