Azadi Review: Even Weirder Than Shasn, If You Can Believe It
Transcript
Hi everyone, I'm Tali. This is Farrell and we're Board of It. And welcome to our review of Azardi, which is a standalone expansion to Shassen. We reviewed Shassan a few months ago and we fully recommend checking that video out as the core of Azardi is Shassan. So here we'll be mostly talking about what the differences are. That said, we will include a rules overview for Shassan. So you have some idea of what's going on. In Aadi, what's going to be happening is you'll start out fairly cooperatively. You're all going to be rebelling against the oppressive regime you live under in the hopes of reaching Aadi or freedom. However, once you reach a Zardi, there can only be one ruler of the new nation. So, you then fight it out to see who that ruler is, turning the game competitive. Now, please note this was a review copy sent to us by the publisher.
Shassen is based around campaigns such as UK 2019 to 2020 Brexit or USA 2022 to 2023. These decks flavor your campaigns, putting you in situations or dealing with questions relating to the issues of this period. On their turn, a player will begin by being read an ideology card. Now, these will pose a political question to the player and their political question will match the campaign you're playing to some degree. So, in this one, it's the Brexit campaign. And this question here that I have in my hand is asking, would you support a campaign to return historic treasures to their countries of origin? Now, they're pretty much all of the cards will have one side that says yes, one side that says no, uh, with a kind of comically flamboyant or outrageous kind of way of writing that answer. And in this game, there are four ideologies, uh, that loose representations of certain ideologies in real life, such as capitalism or the idealist, and answers kind of lean into, you know, it's all about the money or it's all about kind of making the world a better place. Um, and each side of this card will be one of those ideologies. And based on which answer you pick, you'll then have a card of that ideology. And you'll get resources for the most part matching that ideology. Uh, as you collect more cards of the same ideology, you will grow stronger, I guess, in the sense of the word in that you'll unlock powers. So,
at the beginning, you'll start generating more resources of that type. Then, you'll be able to manipulate resources in some way. And finally, when you have five cards of one type, you get a level five power. And these will let you manipulate voters, particularly voters who previously kind of weren't able to be manipulated. So, they are very strong. Mainly, you'll spend these resources on voters. Voters will go onto the main board with the aim of filling up enough spaces in a region that you have the majority. When voters are not in the majority, they are easy to be messed with. But majority voters are harder to manipulate. That is until level five ideology powers come into play. For example, the most common form of voter manipulation is gerrymandering, which you have gerrymandering rights if you have the most voters in a region. then you can move one voter in or out of that region or amongst adjacent regions. But crucially, you're not allowed to move majority voters. Now, majority voters is a term given when one player on their own has reached a kind of majority in a single region. So, these are kind of preprinted on board. So for example, this has 11 spaces and when one player has six spaces, they become the kind of majority party and their voters flip to the other side marking them as majority voters. Now these are important for the
endame because the game will end once all regions have majority voters and these are the only things that matter in terms of scoring. At the end of the game, every majority voter is worth one point. So, players just count up the majority voters they have across the entire board and see who wins. In AADI, there are a number of campaign decks which are based upon mostly historical revolutions like the Russian Revolution or the American Revolution. These cards provide the questions that you'll answer on your turn, reenacting the tough decisions made by the revolutionaries of the times. of note here is that there's now a non-player faction, the Imperials. At the start of each turn, they will attack players who have two or more cards of a certain ideology, forcing them to give up some kind of resource.
However, the active player can then choose to put Imperial voters onto the map in exchange for resources. This is a really compelling decision because if the imperial voters form a majority, you'll get further away from Azardi. But being able to pick your own resources is really powerful. Now, reaching Azardi is measured by players reaching a certain number of Azardi points. These points can be gained by forming voter majorities, which can now be done through two-player coalitions, which incentivizes cooperation. Another way of gaining points is through the resolution of tyranny cards, and these are triggered when voters are placed in volatile areas. These present different situations and offer two different ways to solve them, as well as new rules which help players achieve this goal. As players resolve these tyranny cards, they will gain a legacy, which is a type of resource. They'll gain powerful new resistant cards, and also add new areas to the map. Tyranny cards will also trigger Imperial orders, which are cards that sit on the map and make it difficult to interact with the region that they are on. By spending specific resources, players can gain infamy tokens, which are another type of resource, from the Imperial Orders. And once all of the infamy has been taken, the Imperial Order is removed, and players gain an Aardi point. Infamy can be spent to manipulate certain rules of the game, allowing players to carve out an edge. You can also lose a Zardi points, either by the Imperials forming
majority or by rebel majorities being broken. Now, if you don't reach enough Aardi points by a certain point in time, all players will lose. But there are different difficulties you can play the game at. So, you can set it to the difficulty you like. Now, when Aardi is reached, you will basically get rid of all of the imperial components and you'll be given a foundation card, which is based upon the most prevalent ideologies amongst all the players. You'll vote on which side of this card you want, all the players together, and it will introduce a new rule for the rest of the game. You will also then be allowed to access your monument, which if you remember those legacy tokens, you generally spend those to put your pieces on the monument. And the more pieces you have in the monument, the more powerful that special one-time use power is. Like Shassin, once you move to the competitive element of Aadi, all that matters is who ends the game with the most majority voters. So most majority voters at the end of the game, you win.
As we said in our review for Shassan, it's strange, unique game, and it will certainly be something you either love or hate. We do however though think that Aardi addresses some of the key issues that we found in Shassen very well. For example, the early rounds being sometimes boring because you can't do too much because the resources you're given are relatively random or the fact that players can just luck into level three and five powers whilst other players are left behind to flounder. So, the first point is addressed by the fact that now you can parlay with the Imperials at the start of your turn, eg putting out voters uh in exchange for resources. And there are some elements that we really like such as the fact it's quite a spicy balancing decision because you don't want them to form majorities but it gives you control over your resources which is vital and it just allows you to do a bit more in those early phases. The second part is the fact that you will need to form coalitions to get Aadi points. And to do that, you have to trade your most prevalent card uh or kind of if you have multiple suits, you can choose but with the other player for their most prevalent card. So it means if somebody has already got three or five in a specific uh suit, if you will, ideology, then you're trading away your most powerful card and breaking that, which balances things out, and that's quite nice as well. However, even though Aadi does take some steps forwards in correcting some of the things that we didn't like about Shassin, it also makes
a lot of weird design decisions. So in Shazin you had the ideology cards which were very over-the-top and rambunctious in their answers and this fit well with the satirical take it was going for on the current political climate and also the fact that it was bullying itself as somewhat of a party game in the way that you answer these questions. However, they've kept the same rambunctious answers in Azardi, which doesn't fit as well because these are based on real historical revolutions. So, it it feels a bit strange having these outlandish answers. Then on top of that, they seem to on occasion randomly put in more modern concerns such as should you uh legalize abortion, which was really strange to find in uh you know the deck of the 1776 American Revolution. And we've seen these a fair few times among the the different decks. And it just feels really strange that in what is essentially a historical simulation, you have these really over-the-top answers and then these random assortment of modern kind of problems and questions thrown in which takes you out of that historical immersion. And I think it would have just worked a little bit better as a more straightfaced historical simulator. The next strange element of Azadi is the arc. It has a
very strange arc because in most things uh and games you're going to start small and then it's going to gradually build and crescendo. Uh and even if let's say the game doesn't introduce more complexity as it goes on, you generally are able to do more. Whereas in Aadi, it starts almost at its peak because right off the bat, you're under pressure and you're dealing with tyranny cards, Imperial decrees, Imperial attack cards, you're parlaying, uh, and you have all of these rules that leap out onto you from the very beginning. So there's a lot of decisions being made. There's a lot of table talk.
There's a lot of pressure. And then once you reach Aardi, you essentially start playing a kind of very stripped down version of Shassim because all that's really left is maybe your foundation card, which is something that will give you a let's say kind of gamebreaking rule to incorporate into your new nation. But these really have a lot of variety in in how much they impact. They can go from something that most players will ignore to something that fundamentally changes the game uh and everything you you're kind of thinking in your strategy to win. So, it's just a very strange arc because you you go from this very rich decisionfilled uh pressurized experience that's a lot of fun and then you you just have this kind of really paired down very thin area control game at the end and then it just kind of ends and yeah, it's just a very strange arc. The final bit of weirdness that we'd like to touch upon is you would think that since Aadi moves into a competitive experience at the end where there can only be one winner that the beginning of the game would be very semi-ooperative working together and then breaking those alliances, looking out for yourself but maybe contributing something sometimes. But how it actually
works is almost fully cooperative because at least in our experience it is reasonably hard to reach Aardi. Uh in fact out of uh all of our games we've failed half the time and reached Aardi the other half. And when we did reach Aardi we always reached it in the last possible round and I think most of the time on the last possible player before failing. uh and we have played it at different difficulties. So, it's a game that forces you, if you want to not lose a game, to work together. And it becomes a fully cooperative experience and actually quite a good one with a lot of engaging and complex decisions, a lot of table talk, but it it's just very strange that you have this almost fully cooperative experience that then moves into something that's completely competitive.
I it doesn't have this nice ramp up of of semi-ooperative nature which then you know nicely segways into this competitive element. It's just kind of you play a cooperative game, you shake hands and then you play a competitive game and it's a very strange and and disconnected experience. Final thoughts. Aadi is quite a hard one to summarize. I think being uh so many different parts as it is. I think we really enjoyed it as a cooperative experience. I don't know how well we find it as like an overall experience moving from cooperative to competitive. I don't know what your thoughts. Yeah, agree. I really enjoy playing it and it is really fun, but just the balance of when you go from cooperative and there's so much going on and there's actually a lot to think about into the competitive part and it just seems to be a little bit onedimensional there. Um, yeah, I don't know. It's still very fun. I think the questions that keep going around the table kind of keep it engaging and and fun, but the actual mechanism of trying to get the majorities there just does become less fun after all of the excitement of the cooperative. Kind of a game of two halves in a way. But yeah, I I do really like it and it is very tense and we have a lot of fun playing it. So yeah, exactly. I think again uh this
would be something I could just play as a cooperative experience and sack off the the second half if you will or you could alternatively you could kind of jerryrig your own version of sashin with this using the questions and maybe putting one of the foundation cards which change the rules up kind of in from the start and some of these cards like randomly then you could kind of give it a go and then focus on that um competitive side as well. So, I think there are a lot of options, but yeah, it's it's kind of a weird one to to recommend really cuz it is very good as a cooperative game, but as the whole experience at selling doesn't quite fit together. But that is our review of Aadi. Please ask us any questions you might have about this or Shazin. Please uh like, subscribe, comment. Uh it would really help us. And we'll see you next time. Thanks for watching.