Skip to main content
Loading video...

Broken Meeple Podcast - Episode 102 - Stuff Happened

Transcript 54:43

you're listening to the broken me show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken meeple YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top 10 and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game hi everyone Luke Hector here well blind me it's been a while and for some reason this platform has undergone some changes so you might notice some weird visual of X or mainly you just might notice that it's a bit brighter for now like the camera is picking up a lot more light than it used to in a room with curtain shutting a light bulb on but hey it means you can see me so um whether that's a good thing or not that depends on you but yes hello episode 102 it has been a while so the first part of this podcast has got to explain a few things uh you know it has been some time but there are reasons for that the last one I think I did was the Essen preview one I think it was like episode 101 where just before Essen I decided right I was going to preview a bunch of stuff well and that might have not even been a full podcast that might have just been a sort of summary but the thing was was that I had to go to won itself so that coincided with the normal two weeks of doing this podcast and So that obviously I wasn't going to do anything that weekend then I came back from Essen on the last day with Co which knocked me

out for an entire week so you know I'm fine for it now so don't worry but the problem was was that I had to basically you know obviously be out of action for that time then I was recovering from the covid in terms of getting my energy back up and dealing with a B log for work so I had to just basically go through hell at work trying to catch up with everything not to mention there were one or two milestones at work that I really had to get past because they were stressing me out to the point of like chest pain but you know so a lot of stuff's been going on now things are a little bit better at the moment you know there's a light at the end of the tunnel November is going to be a bit of a work slog but I reckon if I just keep my head down and keep at it things will be fine and then by the time I go on this Cruise in December everything's going to be a bit more hunky dory but the but it just meant that you know going to Wesson and then recovering from covid and then two weeks after that there just hasn't been time to do a podcast you know or enough health so that's why you've had a bit of a break for a while and spoiler alert there's going to be another one coming up because obviously I've got today and then I got two weeks time and then I think there'll be a room for another one so three episodes total because what was the third today so the next one will be the 17th and then the next one would be the first of December so there's only going to be three episodes before this year ends because obviously after that I go on the cruise and then don't come back until after Christmas you know so you know I come back before Christmas and then go home for Christmas and then in the new year I return so you going to get another podcast of me for a fair while after that anyway so you better

enjoy these three episodes but yeah that's the thing there's just been quite a lot going on in my life you know healthwise and workwise and and and Convention wise CU I think maybe the last time I could have maybe done an episode would have been last weekend but then I went to Handy con so I was away for another convention and I've got gridon coming up this in fact oh called blamy yeah next one is the 17th that's the same weekend as gridon uh that might cause problems with that episode I might have to to do it a day or so late maybe maybe do it on the Monday but we'll have to see it's quite a busy period in the Autumn I do a lot of conventions I do a lot of work I do a lot of stuff so as much as the Autumn is quite fun for me and I'm so glad that it's not heat waves and I can wear a T-shirt and not overheat um I have to kind of you know take it easy I mean I haven't even you know done my hair or anything on that today but yeah so just a lot going on but all in all things are on track you know so we'll start resuming and certainly there's been a lot of games I've had to play the only thing that's slightly bad with me wise now is my throat I think it's never fully recovered as a result of both Essen and Co because I can only talk for so long before my throat gets a bit sore and I've been doing a lot of recording stuff lately so I think my voice is getting a little bit exhausted so I might have to just be careful with the link for this episode but I wanted to get something out cu some of you obviously wanted more content from me so generally I mean the channel has done quite a lot since then I mean we're on 24 a half th000 Subs you know less than 500 Subs to go before we hit the 25,000

Milestone so that's going to be a good a good day but there's also been just quite a lot of content I mean you know since the last time I did an episode what was that mid September you know we had the yeah podcast episode 101 so we had the full uh preview for Essen then I went to Essen um but then before that I had a couple of reviews for invincible castle combo and Temple code came back from Essen did a full review an aftermath episode of what was included in that so you can certainly check out that if you want the full smm report and then I had to get started on all the pile up of games where there is just so much to cover I mean I got Arctic nocturn setti Cascadia R rights Black Forest Tea Garden du for Middle Earth release yesterday the Seven Wonders du replacement and I've got unconscious mind is being um edited as we speak as well as the expansions to it the even full expansion needs to be edited uh what else have I done uh let's go to Japan needs to be edited so a fair few have been recorded they just need to be edited but I've also got other stuff to play like I'm playing through explorers of navor at the moment um I've also got uh you know ever shade which I'll give a little bit of a brief sort of preview at the moment but I'm going to do a preview video for that so that is currently underneath this desk being played at the moment inventors of the South tigis just arrived in the post so people are wanting me to review that hopefully it might have to be first impression I mean if I can get enough plays of it I will but it's a big game it's complicated so

if I'm going to do it before I go on the cruise it's going to involve getting it played rather promptly but even with that not in mind I mean I've got you know um other ones down there I bought Reef project recently by Bor and dice to see what that was like obviously I said explorers and the warrior needs to get reviewed uh I've got little ones like conies and Tarot the original game from yellow Asian tigers craft vag Station to Station from alicat games a few Emperor S4 stuff like Midsummer Night's Dream um uh kimono memories or whatever it's called the newish one you know there's quite a few things that I still need to play and review so it's going to take me a while to get through all these oh yeah veil of oh yeah the even shade even fall expansion that needs to be edited uh the artifacts expansion for veil of Eternity yeah I'm I'm kind of busy kind of kind of busy so there's a lot of games to get played there's a lot of reviews to do and the hope is that I can spread them out for the next few weeks and if there's any left over hopefully I've at least got them edited and ready so that I can have them upload while I'm on the cruise because while I'm on the cruise I'm barely going to have Wi-Fi let alone any decent like ability to do any blogging so the the cruise is a complete reset no blog no work no nothing now that's not to say I will be devoid of the internet hopefully I'll be able to get some basic Wi-Fi and keep up to date with things but but certainly there'll be sorry a bit of a cough there but there will be certainly no uh recording editing work anything like that while I'm on the

cruise that is my official giving the middle finger effectively to 2024 which has certainly not been the best year for me let's be honest um and saying this is my end of 2024 and then I and then I go back and then officially end it with Christmas for the family and then we can start 20125 fresh new look fresh well not fresh you know fresh new look on life fresh New Perspective and some improvements at work should have taken place by 2025 as well so you know it it's looking to be a much better next year this year's just been a bit of a write off unfortunately but yeah thanks for everybody who's been uh commenting on the vids and sharing the content and that b means keep sharing it on social media stick it on Facebook groups whenever somebody asks a question like oh has anybody done anything on black forest or what are people's thoughts you know go share the review out and get it get the word out you know I'll always appreciate that but yeah no hiccups really I mean some decent views for a lot of those videos even the speed reviews are doing quite well for a speed review obviously I mean speed reviews only get so many views but I mean Tea Gardens done pretty well dual for Middle Earth is climbing but obviously my two main reviews seti and black forest are doing very well so you know that's a good thing um but yeah no real push back really although I just want to get one thing a little bit clear actually yeah when I rate games and things like that cuz there's been a little bit of push back with some of the ratings I've given lately firstly a it's a subjective opinion I mean come on but also B you need to understand that when I give ratings for games this doesn't work on a like a positive is a point and a con is

another point right so every game has cons there is no perfect game there's always going to be flaws in the game even my top five favorite games of all time have flaws but it's not the case that when I review a game that a con is a minus point you know I don't every time I mention something slightly negative I'm not saying right that takes it from a 10 to a 9 that takes it from a 9 to an8 it depends on the whole feel of the game the bigger picture and whether the flaws I've mentioned detract a lot from the enjoyment for me so you know there are times when I say like oh yeah here's a few negative things I had about this but there's a degree of negativeness you know there's negative flaws where it's catastrophically bad a flaw and then there's flaws where it's like this irks me and makes this a little bit annoying but you know what I can get over it and so you you need to understand the degree of the con I'm making but that also goes for pros you know I might say a lot of Pros about a game but that doesn't necessarily mean the games a 10 out of 10 it just means that there's some good stuff here but you know some games may only excite me up to a point and another thing to also bear in mind is that the my top 100 in all those games which I'll have to think about come 2025 for BL me um is that they don't necessarily follow all right I now just list all my 10 and now I just list all my nines I mean for a majority it's a bit like that but some sometime I've got to rate games based on their individual merits so for example I've rated Arctic and castle combo with n out of 10 now that's not to say that those games are suddenly going to be in my top

50 of my top 100 all of a sudden you know there may be only so many times I you know want to play those in quick succession or that and there's a lot of good fillers but for what they are filler games 30 minutes that get the job done they are worth the nine out of 10 I mean technically you could argue that love letter is a pretty high rate For What Love Letter is as a micro game it doesn't mean I want to play Love Letter every 5 Seconds you know it's it's you've got to think that there is a difference between the two so yeah there's been a little bit of confusion with some ratings lately and and granted seti was a dubious one I mean it was a low 10 or high nine if you don't agree with me but giving it a low 10 and by all means just assume I said the words High nine I mean either way I'm still giving it a seal of Distinction whether it's a nine or a 10 shouldn't really matter it's just an arbitrary number it's whether it got the seal or not that's important and one way or another seti would get for me a seal of Distinction you know you any flaws that might take it down from a 10 to a nine do not detract from that point so there's there just that little bit to get across but yeah you know plenty to look forward to so given that I've been away for a while do I have anything much to talk about well games wise yes just not sub topics I'll have to think of something good for the next episode but now this one's just going to be pretty much a games I've played episode where I just talk about some games I play be they previews or upcoming kickstarters or games I've never heard of before so it's quite a nice little mixed bag in this one and I'm just going to go through them in turn really so we're

going to start off with Baghdad the city of piece which the title might as well mean nothing because this is about as abstracted a point salad game as you can get um you know minor little bits that might cater to the theme but otherwise this literally could have been any city in the world world and slightly changed but that's just from a theme perspective this is the new upcoming Kickstarter from alicat games and it's the same designers that I believe have done some other particularly big games lately uh just looking at what's recent um yeah everyone keeps talking about Shackleton base a journey to the Moon I have still not played this um you know they've did sanor autoban MV you know they've done some pretty good pairing of games you know this sort pairing of games and this is another one that they're doing this is a very straightforward Point salad game and this is pretty much a fully mechanical game and bear in mind this is all looking at prototype and tabletop simulator components but it's a pro it's definitely a a point salad through and through you do mechanical little mini games and these get you points but I actually found this to be a pretty good fun smooth experience it could do with maybe being a couple of turns shorter to make it just that little bit more tight particularly with you know some ways that you can kind of cheese points in the last round but all in all I enjoyed this one the rules are not complicated at all basically it all revolves around this board which is cut up into different segments that relate to different things you've got the cards you've got you know books you can collect you've got the architect uh

Palace pieces you can build you've got your own little side buildings you can build you've got the sailing of ships you know it's it's one of those style of Euros but the idea is is that if I can find a picture of a player board uh preferably one with cards that would be nice I guess not but essentially in this picture here you've got your own player board and there's spots where you take tiles from the main board put them on your own and it can trigger bonuses that's all well and good but you'll notice there's all these symbols in the various spots and that's because these cards you play a game a bit like the by counts of the West Kingdom conveyor belt basically so you have like uh free slots below your board you put the cards in them and they then sort of move along the conveyor belt and as they drop off they trigger other effects there's one little ship sailing thing that does when you play the card and that's about it but otherwise it's when they drop off and some of them might even have a little mini goals that if you have this when it drops off you get another bonus so you got a plan ahead but I love VI counts of the West Kingdom and I love that mechanic and now this is effectively a simplified tweaked version of that mechanic for this point salad so when you play the cards they've got symbols at the top that power the various actions so it's like right if I want to go help Med if I want to go give medicine to these Beggars or whatever then fine I've got to get a bunch of medon symbols on mine if I want to build I need Stone symbols if I want to sail I need ship symbols and you know you play the cards how you like and try to power the actions and you've got little bonus tiles and that you can grab to make life easier um and then on top of this you

move around the center board with this kind of Rondell uh system where you move your guy to the next quarter you pick up a tile depending which tile you pick up one it's next to is going to get cost money or cost favor and you know these allow you to do these various mini games like collecting books or building buildings or building architect Palace pieces and you essentially are just trying to get the most victory points it is a point salad through and through but you obviously want to be efficient and there's different ways to combo things for various bonuses like doing well in one segment could combo well to do well in another segment and then score me points in that way the variable setup and all that you know as you would expect it's just a very neat smooth light game that's the thing it's a smooth light Point salad yes the theme is barely there yes it's basically a mechanical game but it doesn't take that long to play as long as you haven't got AP players presence for sure or you know preferably that they're not handling kids at the same time but the you know you have a very simple rule set you have a simple concept and if you've played this type of game before you'll pick it up in no time and I love that little conveyor about mechanic I just found this a nice you know say pleasant but a nice smooth experience now is it enough for me to want to back back it myself hard to say but I could see myself maybe grabbing it on retail um you know to you know play it a bit CU it doesn't take that long and it's a simple one to teach and you know you can have fun with it you know creating little Combos and I do like a nice Point salad and this one's not going to take me like two and a half

hours three hours to play you know you know the conveyor belt system was done in V count the West Kingdom love that game it's still a 10 out of 10 for me but that one's a bit more ruleset and a bit more harder to get to the table and play in a short space of time whereas this one would be dead simple and you always get a new card every round so you all the cards you use have got one use you know once they fall off that's it they're done so you always keep collecting new cards and you're trying to you know maintain what it is you're trying to do with the new card you get so there just some cool little nice neat little mechanics in here that just make this a smooth experience uh so you know I don't think I'll be doing preview vids on it but I have played it I enjoyed it and I'll certainly keep an eye out for it when it's you know closer to release you know at some point in 2025 I suspect you know it can't take him that much longer to get the kickstarter up and running I think it's going to be early 2025 and it does have 2025 as a release date so something tells me this will be a games Expo or Essen release next year or something like that so yeah keep an eye out if you just like simple Point salads cuz it's quite addictive all right moving on the next one is I want to talk about a game called roll Roa ra honestly Publishers can you name your games things that we can pronounce and are easily recognizable r a u h a all right it's clearly got some meaning it's either I mean does it say here what that

actually is no it doesn't actually say what that is in the blurb well that helps um I'm sure there's a some law thing behind it or whatever and I'm sure somebody in the comments will explain or I'll just Google it afterwards but you know basically it's a mechanical game so who the hell really cares about the title but this is from g games who apparently were the same people who did a pretty famous game a while back I mean I'd barely even heard of this publisher and then I look at some of their other games and it's like oh yeah I'm not seeing much there that's great but I did notice that they either I don't know if they were the ones who pioneered nid valer but they're certainly big on the names for who actually did it and I wonder if Nidia was brought from some else cuz I think I've still got the game on my shelf even though I haven't played it in ages but if that's their own design and not just ported over from another one then you know something to be proud of cuz that's done quite well but all these other ones like Artimus Odyssey Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Turtle Power Cards Danny Sano it's like yeah these are not games I've heard a great deal about but this one that I played at a recent club night is not a bad little game it only takes about an hour to play uh it can do up two to five players and simply you are basically creating this like free by3 grit of biome cards on your board in order to score VP like I say very mechanical but you have this little marker that goes around the outside of your board for the turn orders and after you've taken a card and placed it on it activates that row column so you got to plan ahead uh

the cards themselves have different biome symbols and when you put three in a row the same type you get the special power of this entity or demon or whatever that basically gives you some cool ability until someone takes it off you so it's got that thing uh the placement of the cards either cost you crystals which is the currency or they're free if you put them in certain spots on your board so you can kind of uh gravitate for that but the main sort of thing is that it's basically an engine builder point game you know it is dry as a bone and the artwork is questionable I mean I do like the fact that it's like combining beige with the dominant color of the card or something so it does have a quite a cool clean look to it but yeah there's nothing to write home about but the idea with this is that you've also got like a kind of like a left and right drafting thing so like the first time your marker is on a moon or a sun symbol around the edge of the board and basically if it's on the moon you look to your left and go right I'll scoop up all these cards pick one and that's what I'm going to play then when it moves on to the next column it will be a sun or star or whatever and then you look at the right hand side of you at those cards and draft one from there so it's not quite I pick you choose but it's basically a sort of semi pseudo drafting mechanism of like right I'll look at these I'm going to take this one I don't reckon you'll take these ones later but I know you're going to take this one do I want to take that off yours should I sort about do about my one and you know that that mechanism is pretty neat although the problems that we did have is that it is kind of luck of the draw as to whether you get stuff that works with your engine like you might collect a bunch of a particular symbol and then nothing that

scores for that symbol comes out of the deck and there's not really anything you can do about that there is no mitigation for the cards it's just you know sucks to be you um but the game was dish I mean getting these little powers can be quite cool although it's a bit annoying to put something down get a power and then your opponent just happens to put down three of the same straight after and nicks the power off you I mean that's kind of you know a little bit of a downer and you put these purple tokens on there to score them multiple times so that's pretty neat you know you get to try and score certain tiles multiple times but yeah the the game was fine I mean it was quick it was easy and it didn't take that long to go through but there isn't really much of a theme here it is purely mechanical and luckily the draw does play a bit of a part in whether you'll do well with getting the right cards for your engine or getting these particular bonus powers and some of the powers are definitely better than others I mean some will just get you straight up points or income which is really useful and others require you to spend a lot of something in order to get something good but those ones you're not going to be able to trigger anywhere near as much as the other ones which just get up straight nice income so yeah it's it's fine it's a neat little game I mean I was quite surprised about it being neat because when I looked at it I thought oh this is going to be rubbish but no it was fine you know I i' probably give it a six out of 10 you know it's above average I don't think this is one I would say you know I recommend everyone to go and get but the persons who taught it to me um only paid a tener for it I think for a tener you got a pretty decent game there that I would play again for the sake of an hour

but yeah full price I wouldn't play full price for this and it's not ranked that particularly highly I mean what ranking is it at the moment uh it's definitely in the thousands 3,212 so it could be worse it could be a damsite better so yeah it's that bad you know it's fine it does the job you know and you're talking about an hour and best it free I agree we played it at three and I don't think I'd want to play it with four and I certainly wouldn't want to touch this with five so yeah two or three players seems pretty good for this one but yeah does the job just nothing spectacular it's nothing overly new but it's just something neat and short which at the time given that we just played explorers and no warrior with the expansion was kind of like yeah we just need something quick now bit of lovely coffeee all right let's um move on to the next one then so Minos dawn of the Bronze Age okay so I've played this a couple of times but I don't have a review copy yet although this has reminded me I also need to chase up um Tim Eisner for my canopy Evergreen review copy because I was hoping to get that review before Christmas and if it doesn't get sent to me anytime soon it's going to be tricky to fit it in but you this one is another one that I'm expecting at some point you know they weren't giving them out at the show or at least I didn't get one at the show but they are with their newsletter thing supposedly sending them out after the fact hopefully I don't miss that newsletter as far as I'm aware I shouldn't I always check my emails but who knows if they've sent it already actually no I feel like I've responded to it already I don't know it's hard to keep up with correspondence but this one

I have now played a couple of times I played it once at Essen self-taught from the rulebook and I played it at hycom uh recently so we played another free player game then and they were both free player games games there are good and bad things to this and at the moment my first impressions rate this at about a 7 out of 10 but there are some uh potential issues here because on the one hand this game looks great on the table it is a very pretty color game um it also you know it's got clean Aesthetics uh graphic design is not bad could be better in some places but it's not too bad and you know it's one to four players it says 20 to 150 minutes we're going to get back on that uh and it's got some clever card play it's got a nice looking sort of board some chunky pieces and lots of artwork on cards it looks more colorful than pretty much most of their fair but it gives off a very misleading um presence because people think this is going to be a relatively light game oh my freaking word is it not a light game this is not a windmill Valley this is multisteps above windmill Valley this is a very heavy thinky game and you wouldn't believe that just by looking at the board essentially what happens is you play over four rounds and again it's pretty mechanical I mean the theme is whatever and nether here or there and what you have is if you remember a game called coimbra you positioned dice uh

different color dice on actions and depending on whether it was low number or high number give you turn order and your first choice of a card for example well it's the same thing here which granted is excellent because I do love that aspect of coin coin had some balancing issues with the scoring which is one reason that one kind of died but you know in terms of the action sequence to move dice if I can find a picture here we go yeah with these little like wooden bits that you put the dice into that bit is really cool and it's the same here you go on action spots you draft the dice if your dice add up to nine or more in the same color Grays are wild then you get to level up tracks so that's already a consideration but mainly you're also going right well hang on I want to do this particular action but then if I put a I mean they've done it wrong here I don't know what they've done here I think some of these just set up for the photo but this is not how it works the idea is that the lower number goes on the left hand side of the a oh no is correct I'm looking at upside down um but basically the lower the number it goes on the left hand side of the action the higher numbers go on the right now you have to do your actions in order from high to low but the action is better on each bit if it's the lower number because if it's on the left it's worth you get more action points than you do on the right so there's a decent amount of planning and thought that has to go into that aspect which is great but the other bit I really like are these cards because you draw and play a lot of these cards and they've got costs and then they've got a seven wonders style resource mechanism for discounts you know you get the resources and some

are temporary but some are permanent and it's a case of if you have the resource you get a discount in money in order to build or play a card but these cards give you loads of cool effects nice but what they also do is that they've got this crown symbol at the bottom and basically you can slide them underneath your board and then every time you retrieve a die when we do the actions depending on where it comes from like on the card this one says retrieve from a build action you draw two cards and get two points so you get to trigger this little you create this little engine of retrieving Dice and triggering all sorts of core bonuses and you will generally Crown quite a bit especially if you focus on it it's your strategy then you're going to Crown quite a lot of cards but on top of that you got this little area control thing here where you don't actually fight each other you just basically build stuff across the board you try and occupate and occupy and dominate by majority of meols but otherwise you don't actually fight each other it's just a case of I built there first really so it's not a particularly interactive game other than people being in the areas you want to be in and you know nicking your actions on here other than that you don't really do much with other players there's a few other little side effects as well free tracks that give you bonuses and income some shipping tracks which is another thing you can build and you've got stuff on your board you can build like Farms cities Towers Etc so you know there's quite a lot going on as you can see and you know whatever you do with the cards and you know resources are quite tight you won't necessarily be swimming in these resources to build stuff and you certainly can't do everything in this game so you've got to be a little bit

careful but the card effects is easily the best part of the game I love the cards and I like always focusing on this strategy when I've played it you know yes the area and that's sometimes to my downfall because you can create a lot of decent points with the craning of cards but the area control bit just seems to be the dominant strategy one of the paths on the tracks um scores you more victory points when you occupy areas and it's basically presence and domination so if you have presence you get so many points if you dominate I.E you have more than the other players then you dominate and you get more points but one particular track that you can level up increases the point value of this and with Towers you can increase it further it is possible to just completely dominate the game by occupying a bunch of areas leveling up that track and just simply going well you can't kick me out and I dominate a few areas and occupy these others here's my 40 points or something that I just gained from a region scoring phase you won't get that kind of points level from crowning cards or other bits so it's you know a little bit hard to say that that strategy is not dominated you know area Control Plus the blue track is somewhat lucrative the yellow track I don't think is very good I mean it gets you some builds but that's about it but other than that a couple of goods and it lets you level up your special ability tile which is kind of like a side special power you have that you can make better as the game goes on but certainly I have not seen you know anything and the red is all about crowning cards which is my favorite track but even that pales in comparison to what you can earn from the

blue one it's kind of insane that being said still a fun game overall now where's the big problem with this game yeah you remember I said 90 to 150 even that is pushing it this is a 3.6 free weight game now I don't pay much attention to this rating on Board Game Geek but this is a very heavy game I mean somebody has put a vote for medium light that person is lying or he is trolling because there is no way in hell Steve this is a medium light game anybody who believes so is mad even even to call this medium I think is pretty high I mean I don't like the terms medium light and medium heavy but this is heavy or it's medium heavy it is not in any way less than the word heavy okay this is a lot going on and you've got all these effects to trigger you've got the area control thing as well you've got to think about the planning of the dice there's a ton to do and the problem is this makes people think about their turns turns take a while you've got to plan out all the dice allocations then you've got to do the whole leveling up the tracks with the dice then you've got to take one off at a time and resolve the actions with multiple action points this is not a 90 to 150 minute game this is barely a 120 to 180 minute game four players with this I could see going past the three hour mark every single time because let's face it the free player games I've played have all taken Beyond

3 hours this game is long there is a lot of down time people have got to think on their turns and it is difficult to plan ahead in this one because if somebody takes the thing you want or something like that it's going to mess you up like crazy and you've got all these effects to trigger from the palace action so you could have a turn that takes forever this is not a quick game and I think it goes on far too long with far too much downtime for me to get you know a really good sense of enjoyment out of it which is a shame because I do enjoy a lot about it the cards are kind of like the bulk of the mechanisms and I I love the coin BR mechanic so I like that in itself but I might even have to just drop that uh I don't know why I'm on my own personal thing but I might drop that to a six for now I mean this is First Impressions but that length is a big killer I mean there's a decent amount of rules you got to teach this is not a short rules teach um not quite as bad as some other heavy games but certainly not light either and it does look the business I mean it is well produced for a retail copy game but that is a long time to play this game and I worry that this might literally only be a one to two player game three even I think is too long I mean look at this community one to three best with two now granted not a lot of people have voted on it because only so many people have played the game I what we got here vote 17 how do you have total voters with 17 but then there's 9 15 14 I don't quite get how this works but you know not recommended a lot of people do not recommend this game with four I don't

even know why they put more than four that's not even physically possible and then people actually vote on it why you morons um but even then free very few you know very few people in the list are saying like oh this is best they say recommended with free I don't even know if free is recommended because you usually have two people sort of getting each other's way in the area control and then one person just gets away with it but yeah this does feel like a a one to two player game which is not to say that means there's no market for it but am I going to want this game for a solo game only I don't know and I don't play two-player games often but three takes so long that I just don't want to try this with four I am like dreading the time when I might have to play this before it could be one of the worst experiences of my life and there's no other way to speed it up because it's not a game that you can speed up really so there is that detriment that it has and it's quite a big solid detriment where like half the player account I'm put off from trying it but it does have I've only logged one player of it I need to log in another one actually cuz I know I've played it twice um in fact why don't we do that now I usually forget to do this slot but let's see handy con was yes I played it on the Saturday so there we go um but yeah I don't remember to log my plays very often to be perfectly honest um about half the time I forget here I I don't get BG stats as a thing with the app I just don't get it but anyway I agress so yeah the the thing with this

is that that length is a big killer with the rules teach the rule book's not particularly great either I mean I you know tried to self te it from the rule book at first and granted I was starting to susceptible to Co at the time but man it was a bit of a SLO to get through it from teaching from the rule book and then you had to add the massive length for the game as it is it's not a short Affair it's not an easy Affair and I'm worried that that's going to put a lot of people off because you're going to see this really colorful cover which does look amazing and you're going to see you know in terms of artwork and you're going to see this beautiful looking board and all these wooden pieces you're going to think oh yeah this is quite a lightish game and it really really is not so um we'll find out more in a late run I think this is going to be one that I review in the new year because by the time I get a copy I think it'll be too close to the cruise and I won't be in a POS I mean unless it arrives in the next week or two tops and then I can give it the beans in the same week maybe because I have already played it twice so that's already you know part of the way there but I have a feeling that I'm not going to get it for a while and it will be probably a 2025 January review so it might take a while but you know we just have to see right and let's say finally let's look at lands of evershade now I am going to do a full preview of this so I'm not going to say too much here now but lands of evershade is a game that I demoed with Paul Grogan at Essen this is awaken realm's new uh story driven narrative game it's sort of

rpg-esque story based and you know new setting new gritty World artwork fantastic it's the same artist I think that did tained grill or if it's noty similar but it's like looks gorgeous and it's obviously you know going to be heavily story based now I have it right underneath here I have been playing through I think I've pretty much finished now I'm almost there the first adventure and you know we got given basically it comes out in in like multiple adventures and you'll have each Adventure is essentially free acts with chapters and each chapter can be played separately so that you're not spending hours and hours and hours on the same chapter like you might do in some of the other games it's meant to be more able to deal with bite-sized chunks now I can't speak about the save function because technically there isn't one in the Prototype we are playing a prototype at the moment so all of this is prototype components but we had enough to do like most of one adventure and I'm certainly not going to be spoiling sping plot elements in the preview or at least not I mean there will be some combats I might spoil to illustrate how the combat works but I'm not going to spoil anything about the ending uh chapter or anything in fact we got told specifically not to do that but this is basically one of those cases of create a character go through the story and instead of um uh what do you call it like a spiral bound book like you might get instead you have this tracker piece in the middle that you can put a timer mechanism on and Mark out story bits that you get given but you have these

sheets that you basically put on to either side so sheet five here gives you a city of white well and it gives you some special rules and you can move around this map and explore storybook numbers so you know storybook 600 storybook 500 think the tainted Grail um adventures book it's basically that system but then you've also got um can I go over here you've got sheets that are can I get to the right hand side probably not uh well whatever but you can see there on the top right that's a combat scenario sheet so all your characters are on there and they're fighting in a combat and you know different things are happening on different Maps story book stuff there's an app which you can use instead of the main uh book but then they've also got voice narration so just like with the tainted Grail one they'll have voice narration for this and like ISS Vanguard and stuff and the voice narration is topnotch the writing is topnotch I mean it's the same style of writing that you got with Ted Grail so you know all of that is really good from immersion Factor the whole setting is quite interesting actually I mean I don't want to I can only sort of explain so much but to put it simply basically you've got this landscape which is protected by a sort of cloud Veil above it because the sun got to a point where basically the sun just erodes whatever it touches so if you stand out in the sun you'll burn to a crisk you Decay you know land and buildings just basically fall to ruin or something you know the Sun is just basically a killer now you're not

vampires but anything would die in the sun like nothing would survive in it it's not vampires or it it's just Sun bad Don't Go Near it and the veil is kind of um failing in some places you get sun sort of breaching through like um that particular place I showed you was uh White well I think it's called Uh city of whitewell um can you see that picture yes so you can see that there's a big pit in the middle there and there's like a be of light coming through that's one of the bits where the veil's lifted so the veil doesn't work in this small very small bit of its Veil where light can get through and over the course of a couple of centuries or whatever the light has basically drien drilled a giant hole in the middle of the city and you can't go anywhere near it in like Dawn till Dusk you know because you will just incinerate so it's like a cool setting I mean it's not quite as dark and gritty as tainted Grail but it's still a fairly dark area there's still like some dubious decisions you might have to make with your party and there's obviously you know monsters and characters and different races and things like that but yeah this one seems like another cool setting now how does it differ from something like tainted gril well a lot of it is going down more the kind of DnD uh players's handbook thing so you actually get a player's handbook I wonder if I can reach it here and show on camera so you've got this thing um as a separate thing for creating your character and when you read it um is prototype in

the moment so it's not fully for but it's give you it gives you all the details about the law and whatever shade is it then takes you step by step through creating a character so you got races you've got Origins you've got professions you've got secret Origins uh you've got advancements and things like that and depending on which like profession you might take there could be two different paths for that profession so if you're a hunter you could be a Tracker or an Archer they function very differently but they are still Hunters um you've got different races so you've got the like burim which are like big half giant orc things best com elf which is kind of like an elf I mean they're certainly they're certainly borrowing heavily from D andd licenses I mean the DG is basically a dwarf an elf is basically an elf there is a human and the Bulgrim is basically an orc you can tell they've been heavily influenced by natural Fantastical stuff but you can do some good variety with these I mean this is a dwarf fighter that they've got here which you might think is pretty typical yeah dwarf fighter high strength whatever you could happily create a dwarf wizard if you want to or a dwarf Druid or dwarf Archer I mean you don't need to stick to stereotypes they give you a lot of flexibility with your origin and your like your profession and like your lifestyle type choices so you want to be an Arcane Academy trained battle wizard Paladin dwarf or something then by all means go ahead and do it you know and this is just the stuff that's in the book I mean there was what four races four

professions uh eight um skill sets or eight like uh lifestyle choices like are you a citizen are you a uh a Hermit that kind of thing and that was just what was in this book for the Prototype there's going to be more there's going to be more races there's going to be more professions you got a lot of variety with the character creation and in advancement you've got different you gain experience and then you gain advances and you get more skills based on which tree you want to upgrade so there's a lot of character creation and customization much like a DND game so there's definitely more emphasis on that because you had some character creation and customization in tainted Grail and uh you know Isis Vanguard but it was more limited like you had the character and then you tweaked a few things about it but that was kind of it you didn't do a ton of customization well here you get quite a bit more you can really like play this with fundamentally different characters from time to time but you know and that all sounds good I mean it's got great story great writing good artwork and a good character customization this I particularly like though this is a skill um you roll d10s basically for a lot of your checks and it's one of those things of roll based on your attribute plus one die if you have a particular keyword so close combat Warfare investigation City born that kind of thing but this hot bar here on the right is how the combat tends to work you have the items that you have and some of the things you collect will give you these attack and defense cards and you slot them into your hot bar and

you have to rest in order to jiggle them around so you have to kind of create your hot bar effectively but when you're in combat the card tells you exactly how the ability Works tells you its type tells you its keywords tells you its damage what you roll what its range is it's got the little grid there so all the rules are kind of in front of you you don't have to check the rule book that often now I had to a little bit when I was playing this prototype that's because the proty rules are still in effect and not everything's written down but with a lot of information in front of you it should minimize how much your rule book checking but the combat Works in a similar fashion to uh you know a typical DND game so you know you've got Miniatures on the map and you've got range and line of sight although it's done a lot more simpler than usual so you don't have you know R line of sight is basically you can see everything on the sheet you know you don't have to think all right you're in my way and and you can't see me uh if you're there and things like that you know it keeps it very straightforward so you haven't got to mess around with that now yes you can see everything on the map but there is still cover and if you're next to cover then it might increase your chances of resisting damage or your chance of the hit or or stuff like that so cover still plays a part but you're not out of the line of sight of people like people can still hit you from afar so you have to kind of kind of inject your own sort of workings as to how that works but you don't suddenly get like massive impassible things like blocking your line of sight now that being said it

does mean that you do take quite a bit of damage but what happens is you have defensive cards on your hot bar that you can trigger in order to survive the combat so if I can find that uh setup again is that the one I need this will do can I yep here we go here we oh come on stupid stupid Google here we go this is going to work yeah so so for example you got attack charge heavy strike sorry but then you've got Dodge and endurance and stuff and so as a defensive reaction if somebody hits you then you can dodge you can try to roll and mitigate the damage um you always hit there's no role to hit in this game so you and the enemy just hit it's a case of how much damage you successfully do and the same from them they will do Max damage to you unless you use a reaction card to mitigate it but but they flip over when you use them and there's a a bag draw system for initiative so you draw white and black tokens the black is the enemy The White is you and then you've got these dual ones that you have to alternate each time you use them so it's up to you how you want the initiative to play out with those but your cards don't refresh until you activate again so if you go first in one round and then go last in the next round you won't refresh your stuff for a long time and I do notice that this does make combat quite trick um you can take a lot of damage and you don't have that many hit points now all you need to do later on is rest and

you'll get all your HP back so it's a lot it's easy to heal yourself but in combat if you're not careful with your defensive cards and your positioning you could get swarmed and just completely owned without even by like basic goons Elite enemies will hurt you like crazy and you only have so many ways to mitigate the damage now a lot of these areas have Arena actions that you can do so for example uh slight spoiler alert you're lowered down on the lift at one point and you're on two sides and as well as attacking each other there's also ways to push the planks off so that they can't approach you from all three different areas there's also ways to push people off the lift so they automatically get killed uh there's also ways to uh shoot and take out one of the ropes holding the lift up in which case it could tilt the thing and people could fall off so there are ways in combat to try and mitigate the difficulty curve like just trying to straight out take out enemies one by one including Elites is liable to just get you killed you've got to use those Arena actions you've got to use the you know you've got to prepare for fights so when you're exploring the underground take note of stuff you find because that stuff you find could make the upcoming fight or battle a lot easier but if you go into a situation unprepared or you just glance at stuff and don't you know don't take the time to research or whatever you could find yourself in a bit of a pickle um and I was playing two-handed it's

very easy to play two-handed there's not a lot of piloting you've just got two Miniatures and a character sheet effectively and like some cards um it's nowhere near as complicated the combat as say Ted Grail was you know Ted Grail had a pretty complex like card system it used some people like it some people hate it but this is very straightforward you just choose you two actions when you activate the cards are what you can do it tells you what they do you don't roll the hit you just do the damage roll your checks it's really it's a very streamlined experience and I think that's the main thing I'll say about evershade in general it's got the same great immersion writing story and all that lot that you expect from awaken Realms but this feels like a better entry point I mean yeah there's a reasonable amount you know there's not tons of rules but you've got a handbook to guide you through character creation you've got the sheets that tell you most of what they need to do you've got the normal story handbook and then you'll have the normal rule book but a lot of information is written on cards and you know it's it felt like it was an easier one to learn now they've got to finish off bits there were bits in the rule book that weren't explained or weren't clarified because it was a prototype rule book so I had to kind of house raw a few things now and again particularly when it came to things like combat but for the most part everything was kind of there and I've enjoyed my time with it so you know I'll do an official preview video when my voice recovers and I've

got to do it soon anyway because I think the kickstarter is coming out in about 10 or so days so I do have a short space of time to do it but I'll explain more at that point but yeah so far this is impressing me I played a game with Paul Grogan at Essen we had a good time I wonder if they've actually put it on their website uh I have no idea uh if they have if they have put up essn video cont content and bi all means watch it because then you get to see myself and Paul Grogan have fun with the scenario uh me joking around a bit and Paul sort of failing rolles and stuff so it's all pretty good but yeah I I enjoyed it I'm very keen to see where this one goes I think this could be one of the easier like well I I think this could be one of the most accessible games that awaken rounds has put out for their story ones like it doesn't require anywhere near amount of rules and prep and pilotin as ISS Vanguard does it isn't anywhere near as grindy or you know rules and tend or anything like that as Ted Grail this is much more streamlined much more like accessible and I think for a lot of people this could be their ticket into a really good story driven game because all that stuff is there in Spades very excited to see how this one pans out I'll let you know in the preview uh when I do it but yeah definitely keep an eye on this one if you're looking for another story based game at some point uh when are they going to release this is it planned to be 2025 um I think they're at a stage they could yeah looks like it 2025 so we could be looking at

an Essen release for 25 uh depending on the kickstarter so yeah yeah keep an eye on this one hybrid RPG board game experience one to five players I think five players might be a bit much to be honest with this one I think playing it with two or three would be good a full party of four great that supposedly you will be B to play this true solo without having to use two characters please because the other games weren't very good at true solo compared to two-handed so you know as much as I love them I did play them true solo but they had problems with true solo this one needs to get true solo right so you better do it unfortunately the Prototype didn't allow for True solo so I haven't seen it for myself but yeah some good stuff there all right that's it 52 minutes and my throat is really going so I'm going to wrap it up there get this one edited and out so thanks for everybody who has been patient while I've been away uh you normal service will resume up until the cruise and then you'll have to wait until 2025 but yeah you know I some cool stuff coming from Essen and some cool stuff on the horizon more stuff to play I got a lot of games to play I am trying to fit in the time and it's it's doable I mean you know I can play solo here fine and I go I've got several game clubs that I can go at but sometimes I have to invite people around and basically just say look we're going to play this game and give it the beans you know can we have your thoughts and stuff so there's a lot of stuff and obviously handy con was great cuz I played a lot of games there and gridon is coming up so I'm going to play a lot of games there so yeah there's definitely you know a lot of time being spent on these

games but it's good to uh dive into some because we've had some belters we've had some mediocre stuff but uh all in all not too bad now one thing about that normally I do a top 10 of the year I will still do a top 10 of the year but usually a lot of people like to get theirs out and December which kind of the norm for once I will not be doing that uh because I'm not going to do a top 10 of the year on the 7th of December that is too much to edit too much to do on top of the games and that's just too early to do that so I will delay my top 10 of the year until 2025 January okay we will do that before I think about top 100 or anything like that but you know I I mean come on you can wait a few weeks can't you it's not like it's going to kill the views or anything you know 2023 will officially finish in full before I do the top 10 list it's just got to be a thing this year there's just not enough time but yeah that's it for me on this episode of the broken me hope you've enjoyed uh listening and uh you know thanks for being patient thanks for your support thanks for the kind comments I've certainly received quite a lot of those lately with all the health and covid stuff so you know I'm very grateful for that but I got to go and sort out more stuff and obviously play more games finish this never shade game and finish the unconscious mind review that I know a lot of you have been waiting for so uh keep in mind there's a lot of stuff coming so just uh bear with me and you'll be rewarded so take care and remember it's only a game bye for now

love you all

Progress saved