The Four Doors Review: The 4 Darkness of the Apocalypse
Transcript
Hello. Welcome at the Dice Tower. I'm Wendy Ye.
And I'm Chris Ye.
And today we're going to be reviewing The Four Doors. This is a cooperative game designed by Matt Lecock, uh, which is one of the most recognizable game names in cooperative gaming, as well as Matt Riddle and Ben Pinchback, who
they've, you know, Fleet the Dice game, three sisters, a lot of name recognition on this box.
Sure, there's definitely like heavyweight designers for sure. So, I'm going to take a second. I'm going to show you how this played, this is played, and uh, then we'll come back with our thoughts. The Four Doors is a cooperative game where players are trying to collect these four relics up here to be able to trap in all the darkness and have it be removed by lighting this lighthouse. Um, all right. So, what is going to happen in the game is players are going to try to remove the darkness from closing the doors of the lighthouse. Uh, because there are three ways to lose this game. One is to have the doors closed and then eventually disappear so that the lighthouse shrinks down and is gone. The other way to lose is to have this little pawn marker get all the way over here to the death symbol. And then finally, if there are just literally no cards that can be reshuffled or redrawn.
All right, so let's start by talking about the general like play of the game. So on a player's turn, players have uh up to three actions on their turn that they can take. Um and those actions are a few different things. They can move um adjacent spaces. So they can move up or they can move down. Uh one action per movement. They can choose to illuminate. So they would take a card from hand. Let's see if this one's up here. They would take a card from hand. They would find the matching lantern for the color of the room that they're in. and that lets them remove a card. The next option is to draw a card or do a search action. You do have a maximum of five cards allowed in hand. So if you ever have more than that, you need to discard down. The next action on the list is give a card. So you can pass one card to a player at your door, which means if you are in the same location, it is your turn. you can choose to pass a card to a player so that they can gain more relics. Now, the last action of the game is to find a relic. So, if you are in the correct color space and you have four relics, not including the spells.
So, even though this is green at the bottom, it doesn't count has to be specifically the relics. You can trade those in and then you can choose to uh gain that relic. It will give you an ongoing power that you can use as an action in the future. At the end of the turn, you're going to draw up two cards and then we go to the shadows fall phase. This is where we draw cards based on whatever number this pawn is at. Right now, we're at number two, so we would reveal two cards. Um, and if one of those cards were to bust the area or they would uh overrun the area, that means you have more than three. You don't place this card out. Instead, you place it in the hollow and then you flip that door over to closed. Now, this one happens to already be partially closed.
So, instead, it would disappear along with all the cards that are around it and the lighthouse would fall down. Now, we would lose the game immediately if we had not gained the fourth relic or sorry, the purple relic because that one is necessary to win the game. there's no way to get it because you have to stand on the spot. However, if for some reason we had uh been able to have collected it earlier, we would be okay. We could continue the game. All right, I want to point out a couple more things. So, every player does have a special ability that their player cards give them. They let them do something. Um, this is all cooperative, so everything can be seen in front. You know exactly what everyone has. And finally, I want to clarify the two different types of cards. So, we have the relic cards, which can be traded in four at a time to get the relics. And then we have spell cards.
These can be used at any time. When they are used, they are often placed in the hollow, which means they are trashed and gone from the rest of the game. And they have some sort of uh one-time ability or some sort of big benefit. Now, there is often a difference between the bottom color, which is what affects where it comes out, and the top left corner, which is where it can illuminate. So, this card over here can illuminate red, which means it can be used to remove red cards. However, it cannot illuminate purple because those are different. So, it can be traded in for purple relic or illuminate red. All right, brief review. So, players are going to be taking three actions on their turn. Then they'll draw two cards be placed in front of them to be used later. And then they're going to have the shadows fall time where the bad stuff comes out and you'll see if you survived and if doors started to close.
If players are able to get all four of the special relics before the end of the game, they will then climb to the top and they will illuminate the world with the four relics and the game will be won. And that is briefly how you play the four doors.
All right. So, starting off with production. Um, I feel like it's fine. It's got linen finished cards. It's got some holographic. The I personally don't love the holographic cards. They're a little bit hard to read. Um,
unlike the treasures of your rescue, but it's pretty cool on that like top of the lighthouse.
I do agree. The lighthouse is fun.
Yeah.
No. And and this is interesting because this is from publisher Happy Camper Games who's done games like Trio and Combo and so games I really like a lot. Uh and then this is this feels quite like a GameRight production, you know, with like the wooden pawns, the artwork, good artwork, I think,
but the style of it is very much reminiscent of like Forbidden Island, Forbidden Desert, other Matt Leok cooperative games.
And it's not in a tin can, so that's a pro or a con for you. It does come with a cool clasp though.
Magnetic clasp box. Good choice. But it's funny because it feels very much like like is it one of those, you know, Forbidden Island, Forbidden Jungle?
It definitely co-op games.
It has a lot of the same story beats as a lot of the other Matt Leok games that we know and love. Um, it, you know, it has like a bad stuff phase. You draw a certain amount of cards at the end of your turn. You know, you take three actions. like it very much has those same points to the point that I did have to look in the rule book a couple point a couple times and be like is this a rule in this one or is this a rule in a different game like how do I clarify that
and maybe you've not played you know pandemic or any of those games that we're mentioning here so we'll review this on on its own uh merits and stuff but if you have played those other games you're going to see immediate comparison points and we will we will address those as well
this is interesting because I feel like this game is kind of an exercise in design. It feels like they took a lot of the other Matt Lecott games and they said, "Okay, we really like the spells. How can we make the spells more involved?" And then, "We really like the the way that the cards flip out, but what if we took two decks and we combined them into one and we made it work?" Like, it it feels like they had a couple of these like ideas of how to make it different while still having that core Matt Lecoishness to it. Um, and so it it feels like an exercise in design.
Yeah. And I think it's a very clever one. Yeah. All just the the powers on the cards, the set collection, all that stuff. It's a well it's a well tread formula. Uh, but yeah, I agree. That's kind of the main innovation here. Innovation is not the thing that's going to drive, I think, someone's interest in this game because it feels like it's going down similar paths. I have a sneeze. I'm going to try and subdue it. Um, but what what there is, I think, is this. There's a few good tension points throughout where those spells that you talk about. I really like that idea of I can spend this like a normal card. I can get rid of it and stuff or I can spend it for its great ability, but it goes into the lost pile. It's gone for the rest of the game, right?
Barring one thing that lets you, you know, one or two things that let you pull from there. But like that's a nice feeling of sacrifice.
And it's a it it decreases the deck, so it actually makes the game end faster and it can make you lose faster. Um, and there's those luminous flux cards, which I didn't mention in the overview, but you actually need a specific card when you get to the top of the tower to play that to be able to flip it over and light the beacon. And if you accidentally throw away enough of those and then enough bad stuff comes out that you lose some other ways,
then you're like, "Oh, we can't win the game." Because I think there's I think there's like eight of them,
I think. Yeah.
And you're like, "Oh, they're all in the trash pile and the you know, the gone the lost pile." Yeah. There's enough of them that you can hold on to them at a certain arc, at a certain point in the game, you're like, "Oh, we shouldn't." Because it's a great ability.
It is.
It's also the game-winning card. I think that's a nice little like counterbalance. You don't you're not going to if you're dealt one early in the game, you don't need to feel like you need to hold on to it because you might never see one again, right?
There's more. So, I think it kind of balances that well. On the on the opposite side of things though, for a cooperative game of this style where stuff builds up in the different zones and can eventually explode or it could eventually, you know, break if it gets too much piled up. I think there's just too few zones. There's four color areas each with two sides.
Yeah. So, there's basically eight spots. Whereas, when I look at all the other games that are similar to this, there's a lot more than eight spots that it can explode. And so there's there's moments where in fact the last game that we played literally right before my turn when I was I had like the person who could clear out three cards at once. Right before my turn something like exploded. Right before my next turn something exploded. I was like I'm literally going right there. But there's no way to there's no way to look ahead in this particular version because the cards are all in a single deck. There isn't that element of we know what has come out. so far and we know what's back on the stack and so the looking ahead and the reduced spaces I think just makes it feel extremely random.
Yeah. More punishing when it happens because it just kind of feels driven by that randomness. Uh you can track all the information. You can count every card in the lost pile, in the discard pile, in an player's hands around the table,
but it's trickier to do it. Uh, in part because there's just multiple types of cards all in one that one deck and everything.
Super clever innovation, really cool way of doing it, and it kind of simplifies a little bit of like shuffle up this deck, you're ready to go. But I think that ultimately it feels like a little bit of a sacrifice of that quick ability to read the game state. And I think it reduces the amount of conversation that happens at the table. And that is what I really love about these cooperative games is being able to have everyone discuss and be like, "Okay, this is what I'm thinking of doing on my turn. Does this seem like a good idea or is there something I'm missing?" And someone else is like, "Well, actually, this one over here is back on the deck, so we should try to not worry about that one now. We'll worry about another one first." Like, there's there's so much good conversation that happens in other games, and it doesn't happen in this.
And very specifically, we decided to pull out Forbidden Island last night right after we replayed this and we compared the two side by side and it was night and day for me.
It really was. And and for me, say, you know, saying whatever else you will, I think that cooperative game of this style for me is elevated if players are all talking and contributing.
When someone says, "Okay, well, I'm going to move down here and clear this out." Everyone goes, "Yeah." and then on my turn I'll get a red card and I'll move there. Okay, if that's the level of discussion happening that I don't I don't think there's enough to chew on in the game.
And so going from this game to, you know, to Yeah. We've played for Island for over a decade now, I think. Uh, but still having that same satisfaction because of that element is is the thing that kind of, you know, really locked me in in saying as clever as Four Doors is, I don't really like it, unfortunately.
Yeah. It's It doesn't hit the points it's supposed to hit, or at least that I think it's supposed to hit. Um, and so I mean, do you want to start with our final scores?
Yeah. Yeah. For me, unfortunately, this one's a five.
It's not a poorly designed game. In fact, I think it's a very well-designed game. Uh there are certain things we talked about I really like that it's like an action that you can draw a card, whereas if you go to some of the other Matt Leok, you know, co-opter games, Pandemic and stuff, there's more turns where you're waiting for cards to come to you that you need to win the game. So, I love that there's like little innovations like that. There are some positives uh changes in here structurally. As you as you complete a task, you get a card that gives you a special ability. So now yellow cards aren't useless for the rest of the game.
There's some great touches in here, but the overall structural change of making it just the four locations means that there's less to talk about, less to plan cooperatively together, and then there's less interesting turns where sometimes you go, I move three spaces, done, you go now. So yeah, it's it's one that I there's just such an easy alternative game if someone says, hey, Chris, do you want to try playing this one? Hey, have you played Forbidden Island? Because I'd like to teach you that one instead. So, for me, that's what a five is. Not bad, just not one that I am feeling any drive to come back to.
I am I'm at a very similar level with you. I'm going to give it a 5.5 because I feel like sixes, it's fine. And this is just a little bit less than it's fine because if someone really wanted to play this, I'd probably sit down and play with it with them. Though, I would probably say, "Hey, have you played Forbidden Island? I would, you know what I mean? Like I would rather play other games for sure. So, I'm gonna say 5.5 for this. Um, but very similar thoughts. Very much the same. Um, I I just want there to be more fun. I want there to be more table talk, more predictability. And honestly, even the theme is just very okay to me. Like, it's not as cool as some of the other ones
going through.
Saving the world from diseases,
right? Or the island chunky treasures. Yeah. Like,
oh, it's even lacking in that. So there you go. That's our thoughts on the four doors.
You might disagree with us and if you do, please go ahead and share your thoughts below. We'd love to read through them and and gives other people an opportunity to see, oh, there are people who do enjoy this game or have uh, you know, strong thoughts one way or the other. So yeah, excited to see what you have to say for that. But thanks for coming out to this review here with us on the Dice Tower.
I'm Wendy Ye.
And I'm Chris Ye.
And have fun opening the doors and getting the mistiness come out.
Magnetic doors. Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from the Dice Tower. Hey, you want to learn more about us, communicate with us, we have a Facebook group, we have a Discord channel, lots of different ways to get involved with the Dice Tower. You can find that in our linkree link below. So just click that and we'll take you and you can communicate with us on Facebook, join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of the Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Bassel.