Skip to main content
Loading video...

Earth Siege: Arrival (D+) Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip

Transcript 3:44

sell, but I'm trying to figure like All right, let's just give this one a grade. As always, the theme of the show is I'm trying to grade how they did in presenting their Kickstarter project. With the do I want it, the can you do it, and the how much is it. By the way, if you enjoy this content, please be sure to click on the subscribe or consider sort of supporting the Patreon cuz I'm going to run or I'm I'm doing a Kickstarter later this year where you can buy a Kickstarter critique for people. But, do I want it? Yeah, I do. I'm the target market though. Like I love this lane, 1 to 2 hours, 90 minutes, asymmetric, different path like next time I want to do this, I want to go this lane, I want to go this lane. Yeah, I like it. But, if I'm not, I don't feel like you did a good job. If this is not my bread and butter, solo or two players, then I don't feel like they sold the two player grade either.

All right, sorry. I don't feel like they sold the solo grade. Like that's one thing I'm looking at now like I don't feel like solo was sold incredibly well to me. So, do I want it? Yeah, I do, but I I yeah, I don't feel like you did a great job selling it to me. Can you do it? Yeah, you showed me did 5,000 games earlier, um which is great. I would put that up higher, honestly. And that makes me worried less about a lot of things. So, can you do it? Yeah, it looks like they provide good customer service, too, which is always great. And then how much is it? That's really the bugaboo here, right? Cuz I feel like my thought on this would be drastically different if there was a $60 game here. It's like Yep, buy the cardboard, 60 bucks. Like doesn't feel like a great value, but it's there, I can get it. But when you just jump to 90, and it's just pure deluxification, pure unnecessary but awesome deluxification, I'm like, "Eh." It just leaves a bad taste in my mouth, I think, as a consumer.

And then when I go and look up like your track record like of do people love your games? And it's like the other two that were in this lane you know, 9,000 but but then again it's a war game, too. So, it's like I I don't know. It doesn't feel great. So, how much is it was rough, and I don't feel like you sold the deluxeifications well, didn't see the play mat hardly at all, didn't feel like there was 200 pieces of wood, some of which were huge, until you told me, and I feel like that could have been done in a video like even or like early on. So, the final grade is is rough. I think it's uh Rule booklet's there. You can make an informed decision. There's no gameplay, which is disappointing.

Back of the rule booklet looks great, used it well, 38 pages. Solo is uh not too much, okay. C minus D plus range. Yeah, there's no video. The main image like without a main image, I'm coming in here, I'm hoping to I'm hoping to draw me in in some way. It's There's no video, either. It's like you're bringing in your customers like the one to like for the people from Kickstarter, and I don't know. I just don't see I want to be excited and I don't get there. So, I'm going to go with the C minus D plus uh Yeah, D plus.

Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for Earth Siege Arrival. If you feel like a uh D plus is fair, and if you have a suggestion for an upcoming Kickstarter, Game Found, Indie GoGo project, please be sure to drop it in the comments below so I can get that one covered and

Progress saved