Mandala Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about mandala which is an abstract card game that came out in 2019 this is a strictly two-player game designed by trevor benjamin and brett gilbert and published by lookout games this game only takes about 20 minutes to play and it's pretty simple in its rule set i don't think the theme here is going to help whatsoever so it's purely a mechanical abstract game where i'm gonna have to explain the rules for you to wrap your head around what's going on here so the setup looks like this where you've got this big board which is actually a kind of a towel a fabric cloth board in this case and you've got two mandalas which are these big circle things here that are divided into three sections so you've got the mountain area you've got your opponent's field area and you've got your field area and that applies here as well and each player on their side of the table they've got these different squares here called the river numbered from one to six and you've also got your cup here which actually starts with two random cards on there which is going to be all your points at the end of the game each player is going to get given a hand of six cards and in turn you're going to take one of three actions with the idea of trying to get as many points as you can either by the time this deck runs out or until someone has played their sixth color on their river so the three actions are pretty simple so let's start with the first one
so the first option is to take one of your cards and to play it on one of these mountain spaces so you can play on either mandala so let's say for example i played on this one here and whenever i play on the mountain i can draw up to three cards to replenish my hand so let's say here i've drawn these three cards bearing in mind i'm capped at eight cards so whenever i draw a card in the future now um i'm gonna just forfeit that because i'm blocked at eight the second action is to play any number of cards of a certain color on a field on any mandala so for example i could play these three orange cards on this mandala here and this field is basically your claim to the cards in the center so you are basically bidding with a certain type of card to claim the ones in the middle now there are some restrictions on what you can play on these um on these areas because you can only ever have one color in each of the or sorry over the three fields so because there's an orange here i could not have an orange card here or here and the same place all the colors so again i couldn't play orange cards here because there's already an orange card in the middle and that's called the rule of colors which is kind of a i think to restrict you and can actually play quite a pivotal part in what cards you can play and how you're going to manage your hand and the third action is to simply choose one of your colors and discard as many cards as you want of that type
and draw as many back from the deck here which is pretty simple so let's talk about how you actually end up scoring points here so as soon as the sixth colored card goes in one mandala then that mandala is destroyed and points are going to be distributed so the first thing you're going to do is as soon as that six cards played you're going to calculate how many cards you've got on each player's field so this player has four cards this player only has two therefore this player gets first choice at which set of cards they want from the center so for example they might pick these three set of greens and then then they are going to allocate that card or at least the first card of that color onto the number one slot here and put the remaining cards in their cup now what that means is that from now on every green card this player collects is going to be worth one point and then it's going to go to the other player so they might choose these oranges and the same applies they put it on that one spot that'll go in their cup and then it'll go back to the other player which will take this star card here and it will be worth two points for each card they have here now bear in mind the first card you play in each of these river spots do not count towards scoring they are simply a place holder and a marker to show how much that card is going to be worth to that player all of the remaining cards used to bid for those cards in the center are going to be discarded and a new fresh shoe cards are going to be placed on the mountain to start bidding again and that is essentially the rules for the game as i said you're gonna keep
playing until somebody has played all six cards on there on the river like this or until this entire deck gets depleted and the following um mandala being completed triggers the end of the game and then of course once that end trigger is done you're going to go through your cup of cards you're going to allocate them to their relative spots here like so all the way through all these cards and then calculate your points bearing in mind that each card of a certain type is going to be worth the amount associated to it here so as you can see from the rules run through there the mechanisms themselves are extremely simple you're just either playing one card in the center drawing three playing as many cards as you want of a certain color on either yours on your side of the field or discarding cards however if there's ever a game that has more than meets the eye this might just be it there is a lot of depth here and a lot of things that might not become so apparent when you first read the rules you really do have to play the game to understand how everything works together because it's actually an extremely clever game and you have a lot of things to consider so of course you always want to make sure that you have cards in your hand but in order to do that you're going to have to play them in the mountains and that basically makes more offerings to potentially other players to get a certain amount of cards and on top of that as well of course you want to be bidding your cards of certain colors uh in order to claim those cards in the first place or at least to get priority but when you do so you could be throwing away
quite a few points because you know if you are bidding with these cards here for example like i have done here then that's you know that's essentially giving up nine points for me if i um where i could have collected them so it's a really good idea to collect a certain color initially and then try to use your lower points cards to bid for the cards in the future and there's an additional wrinkle as well where you want to be bidding with the cards that are more valuable to your opponent because even though a certain color might not be worth anything to me or a lot to me for example the my orange card here is worth five points to me whereas the orange cards are only worth one point to this player so of course they're going to be wanting to throw as many of those cards away as possible by bidding with them or discarding them to stop me from having them and this is an absolutely compelling decision here and on top of that you've got the additional restrictions where if there's a certain color locked into an area you cannot use it anywhere else so because um you know because i've got my ones here this player might really be looking for these cars meaning that they cannot play in the mountain because it's already locked into a field so that one simple restriction adds a whole new layer to the game and can really mess up your opponent if played correctly there is a lot of meaty decisions here for a simply a 20 minute game and the fact that this game does have so much depth in that very quick time stamp i think is fantastic this might just be one of the meatiest games i have in terms of its time length
to crunchiness almost ratio uh this yeah this is way up there with the greats there isn't really often these kind of games that can get can get this much strategy and this much tactical play done in 20 minutes you normally find some simple dice game or some simple set collection game but this one has so much going on with that simple rule set i love this dynamic scoring i think it is fantastic where you know from game to game things are going to be worth different amounts of points and it's just everything every single card you play in this game is important and keeping your hand topped up is important to give you more options you're going to be collecting different types so that it gives you more flexibility but you want to be collecting same types so that you can use them to bid but of course people might lock you out by um by claiming certain spots as well so yeah there really is a lot going on in that 20 minute time stamp but i think that's fantastic additionally despite being so much going on the uh analysis process analysis paralysis in this game is pretty much non-existent it's a very breezy and quick game in terms of people throwing stuff down you know smashing a bunch of cards down trucking one in this mandala or that mandala discarding cards but you are thinking about everything you do so there's not many games that have kind of this thought process but still tick along so quickly which i think is a great triumph as you'd expect with this strictly two-player game the player interaction is pivotal here and it's embedded in everything you do of course as i said not on you you're trying to collect the best cards to you
you're trying to stop your opponent having them as well and sometimes you know you have to weigh up you know you might think well i'm going to take this card that's worth a few points to me simply to stop my opponent having it because it's going to be worth a hell of a lot more points to them so i think this has got a great level of player interaction and a great level of replayability as well because every game is going to be different it's going to have a different tempo based on the cars that come out and yeah it really has that tactical element to it as well as some underlying strategy and building towards the cars that are gonna be worth the biggest chunks of points i think the production of this game is good uh the cars themselves they're these square cars which aren't the easiest to shuffle and things but they're pretty um they're pretty well made and they they're all well differentiated so if you're colorblind for example you can easily tell them all apart there's six different ones and you're not going to have any kind of scope to confuse them with one another and i suppose the biggest thing about this game is that the board itself is this cloth mat which i suppose is a bit of a gimmick they want to make this game stand out and i think it does that pretty well um i personally would have liked to have seen a board or something because this i don't know i don't it just doesn't feel right for me but i'm not i'm not massively against it and i can see what it's trying to do um i think the the board itself once you once you know what you're doing it's all pretty simple you know you've got your little play area here you've got the mountain you've got your uh your river here so it's pretty simple what you do is not confusing and it's well laid out um and the visuals as well are pretty
good i mean of course they're very generic just these kind of well these mandalas i suppose um and the board are itself so the box eye itself i think is a bit generic and i think a lot of people aren't going to be gripped by this box and i know i've heard good word of mouth about this game hence why i picked it up whereas if i saw this on the shelf looking like this i probably would look right past it so bear that in mind but of course if you're probably watching this video then it's going to get you into the rules and what this game does well the game does have a great sense of progression because of course you're always getting new slots allocated and your strategy is going to kind of pivot on a switch and you're going to have to um you know try and collect those bigger cards and you're going to start building towards those you're going to start off smaller start collecting these cards sometimes just laying them down as placeholders so you can use them to bid and then work towards getting the big points um but also i love the fact that um there's that tension of the end game triggers because the deck is pretty thick so i think the game ending this way is more unlikely than if somebody plays their sixth card and that tension of when other people are going to do that is quite strong and you might really want to win a bid to stop them from getting their sixth color down and ending the game so yeah i love that tension between what the other people are doing and you cannot just ignore someone and let them get away with doing what they want to do because they can catch you off guard so i love that underlying tension you have to be on guard and be ready for someone to do something at any time so overall i'm genuinely
blown away with mandala i think this is an amazing two player card game one that caught me off guard i wasn't expecting it to be this good again i'd heard good words about it but i've heard a lot of good things about lots of games i thought were just okay this one is is amazing honestly this is one of the best two-player games i've played in quite a long time you know this is up there with the greats if not better than some of the classic i think this is better than games such as lost cities i think this is a modern classic i think it's absolutely phenomenal there are so much decisions to be made in such a short time frame that hidden layer of depth and strategy and tactics is absolutely fantastic i love this scoring system it is something that i haven't seen before and i love it when games just throw a little bit of a spanner in the works make you think a bit differently about this kind of gameplay and this game has that i can't really feel uh i can't think of any game that is quite comparable to this one it does feel different it has a different pacing it's engaging it's quick the tones are fast and snappy but still meaningful the uh yeah it's everything got bidding it's got set collection it's got this kind of commodity speculation all in 20 minutes which which is just outstanding and you know when i played this the first time i was thinking okay just three simple rules uh this is probably going to be pretty flat lined and not going to be that great and by the time you know the first
couple of turns done in this game um i was just like oh okay now we're talking this is actually got a lot going on and has a lot to think about and is certainly the type of game that i enjoy so funnily enough it takes a lot for me to enjoy an abstract game and it takes a lot for me to enjoy a strictly two-player game this one is both of those and i think this is remarkable so certainly one of the surprises of the year for me again i was expecting good things but this completely blew out the water and um yeah is is outstanding so highly highly recommended if you like playing two-player games and if you like a thinky card game uh mandala is certainly one to check out so this one gets a strong shield of quality i'm venturing on giving an elite shield so maybe it'll be upgraded the more i play this one i'll see if it has that long term legs but uh yeah certainly check this out if you like your two players and you like your card games thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation and i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time