Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mycelia Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 19:18

hey everybody today I'm taking a look at my cellular this is a one to four player abstract strategy ball game that takes 40 to 60 Minutes to play the game is designed and illustrated by JJ Neville of splitstone games and this game will be launched on Kickstarter in September 2023 and I've been kindly forwarded a copy of what a prototype version of the game here to share my thoughts on now before I get to my thoughts on my cellular I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyander.co.uk who are my go to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so I've set up for a two player game of my cellular here and to start the game you'll build this modular kind of star-shaped symbol out of these triangle tiles and you'll be placing your starting mother Mushroom on one of these inner triangles you can see how I've got the white player and the blue player now sometimes if there is one of these towels have these bug symbols on you'll also Place one of these bug tokens and we'll talk about what they do very shortly additional components that consist of additional triangle tiles you have a deck of these mushroom cards and that's going to be the way you get points which is by fruiting these mushroom cards by putting spores on these relevant colors on the main board of building networks caching them in and um basically fruiting these mushrooms you have the additional bug tokens here you have this die which is

going to show the direction in which these spores um are kind of seeded onto the board and again we'll touch on that shortly and each player's personal setup will look like this we're at the start of the game you'll be given a hand of three mushroom cards to start with just to give you something to aim towards and you'll have these kind of five placeholder boards here which will show um kind of um what corresponds to what you've built so say I ended up building this drumstick truffle Club I can put on my one slot here I'll put this little um token on the board to show that represents my Drumstick truffle club uh you'll also have a bunch of these Spore tokens which kind of show your influence on the board so on each of your turns in this game you can take any combination of two different actions out of a possible six now some of these actions are pretty simple and we'll start with those ones and some of them are a bit more complex and um kind of the meat of the game I suppose so one action you can do is to simply draw a new mushroom card and add it to your hand you can either take one of the face up ones or you could take a a face down card from the stack there another thing you can do is you can place one of these new tiles onto the board to expand the map accordingly another action you can do is to move your mother mushroom now when you do that you can move one either one or two spaces at least as a base Rule and you're going to do that by moving edge to edge or straight edge to straight edge like so so if I was here I could

say move to here like this that is no issue and there are some rules though when you cannot ever pass through another player's mother mushroom so you can actually end up blocking people if you get cornered now one of the main things you'll be doing is sporing your mushrooms and to start with you're only going to be able to spoil your mother mushrooms but as you build more of these fruited mushrooms you could also spoil these so you can see here that each of these cards not only has the kind of um influence you need on the board in order to build the card it also has a number value here which shows how many spores that particular mushrooms kind of um spreads on the board this symbol here is the victory points they're going to be worth at the end of the game and there's also going to be a Decay action at the bottom which we'll talk about very shortly but let's talk about how the sporing action works and we'll talk about sporing the mother mushroom so the mother mushroom is the only one where you can sport kind of infinite and an infinite amount of times and it always spoils to a value of two so let's just say I wanted to Spore my white mother mushroom here I'm going to roll the die which is going to show the direction the wind is blowing so in this example you can see that the dye corresponds to going south here and what you're going to do is you're going to either you're going to start with putting a um a sport on the tile you're on and then you're going to put the next spool on the adjacent tile to the direction the wind is blowing now if the value is higher so let's just say I did end up let's just use the mother mushroom as an example if if I could spread four which I could do

um it would first spread like this as I've already explained and then it will start to kind of span out like this so it would go here then here and so on now let's talk about how to fruit a mushroom so you can see here that I've got some influence on these three tiles um that is the perfect requirement for this liberty cap because I have two of these kind of yellow symbols and one of these kind of little spaceship symbols and because that is a a fulfilled contract now and all of those spores are connected with each other in a network now that is going to be eligible for me to score this card so what I'm going to do is I'm going to remove those spores from those tiles like so and I'm going to build that liberty cap on one of my kind of card slots here so let's start keep it simple by putting it on the number one like so and I'm going to put this little fruited Mushroom on one of the three tiles that I've taken from but let's just say I put it on here like so now this is going to be a new place that I can spore from and obviously it will um let me spread a lot more influence onto the board and it's also going to secure me some victory points now when fruiting a mushroom there are some other things you need to consider in terms of networking so a general rule is that the bigger or the more powerful the piece um it's going to Trump the lower pieces in terms of um connecting pieces or even taking other players pieces so basically if I wanted to Spur to fruit a mushroom I need to have all those

um spores connected with each other in a network but your mother mushroom can actually act as a bridging piece between your different spores so even though these spores aren't connected with each other because my mother mushroom is in the center that's actually going to make them eligible to be used in the same network also if I have a bigger piece on my opponents or when my opponent has spores I'm going to take those spores for myself so you can see here that I have this some fruit Mushroom on a spot where the blue player has theirs that sport actually now belongs to me because I have my fruited mushroom there however if my parents decided to move his mother mushroom to that spot he's going to Trump my fruited mushroom and therefore this is now going to become his and they're going to end up chaining all these together so it's quite a dynamic board State and you need to consider quite a few things in order to make sure that your spores are all connected and are going to be eligible to be cashed in to create these fruited mushrooms now each of these fruited mushrooms can only be spoiled twice and once you've done that you've got no choice really but to use the Decay action and when you use that decay actually you're going to take that exhausted mushroom you're going to flip it the other way around and you're going to tuck it under that relevant card slot like so and then you're going to get a and either a an instant ability or an ongoing ability for the rest of the game so this one here says I can remove all spores from one tile and you can see that could probably sabotage my opponents if used correctly and there are a ton of different DK abilities in

this game which we'll talk on in a bit and the end game trigger is once is once a player has decayed a card in each of their five action slots and the first player to Decay a card of each of their action slots will receive this bonus token to get them five extra points now I believe the only thing we haven't covered now are these insect tokens now if you ever move your mother mushroom onto these insect tokens you're going to collect them into your personal Supply and these can be used for three different reasons and the first of which is to spend a token to refresh the card row the second of which is to cash in two of them in order to force your opponent to move their mother mushroom or you could even move it for them and the third one is that each pair of these at the end of the game is going to be worth an extra Victory point so let's take a quick look at some of these Decay abilities just to give you an idea about what is possible so you've got this instant ability here that lets you pick up three cards from the deck and you can choose two of them this one here gives you a permanent ability to make your mother mushrooms sport 3 spores instead of the regular two you've got game two spores and put them on multiple tiles and explore two additional tiles uh you've got this ongoing ability where if you pick a card from the deck you can pick two and discard one uh randomly steal a card from your opponent uh place the wind die in the preferred directions that's a very powerful ability but when you see this mushroom kind of downward symbol it means that only applies to

that particular mushroom uh your mother mushroom now spores three which I think we already talked about that one uh moving opponents mother mushroom up to three spaces you can repeat the same action twice which is one I particularly like and my favorite out of all of them is that you can Spore your mother mushroom and a fruited mushroom as one action and as I said earlier that two Action System will continue in player order until somebody has decayed a mushroom on each of their five slots the game will end immediately and the player who triggered the end will get those five bonus points you're gonna calculate who's got the most victory points and the play with the most points will be the winner okay so let's share some thoughts on my cellular and let's start with that action turn system I'm just having two actions on your turnout of a possible six it's nice and simple and to be honest you know four out of those six actions are so simple that um you can get them done in a heartbeat so it's not like there's a lot of rules overhead here and you can pretty quickly internalize how the game operates and how it works and I do like the fact that you cannot do duplicate actions unless you get that particular upgrade because it means you cannot just Spam the board with spores I did really enjoy the importance of the mother mushroom and it's probably my favorite part of the game about how to perfectly position that at all times you know because there are opportunities that kind of spring up where you can you know move your mother mushroom onto a place that's highly populated and you can Trump your opponent's fruited mushrooms you can steal all their spores on that

particular spot you can use it to chain networks together and you can even prevent your opponent from sporing particular fruited mushrooms because you've you are on top of it which can actually prevent them from ending the game meaning that they might need to use things such as the bug tokens to move you out of the way so it's a nice little tactical puzzle here and you can block people in you can do lots of different things with that mother mushroom and again that's my favorite part of the game because it does have so much importance on how to position it another thing I enjoy about this game is the Decay mechanism that idea of tucking cards behind your board to get instant and ongoing benefits is a very nice touch and it feels quite interesting in a game like this because you generally find that almost pure abstract games like this um don't use mechanisms like card tucking or engine building and I thought it was executed to a high standard you know the actual abilities on the cards are well they range from pretty simple to very powerful you know that just the ability of moving a mother mushroom an extra step can be a lifesaver you know being able to Spore more efficiently and being able to you know move the tiles around the board and still spores all these things can come in very handy if you trigger those abilities at the right time now something that could be polarizing and frustrating at times in the game is the randomness of the die roll here um because of course you do not choose which way the spores spread but you can take calculated risks here and I do like the fact that the first Spore actually starts on the tile that you spread from so you are guaranteed yourself at least one particular symbol that you need but

again if you are taking huge risks by spreading spores next to your opponent's fruited mushrooms or their mother mushrooms you know that you are pretty much rewarding of just giving your spores to your opponents which they're going to use against you essentially now I personally don't mind it at all I think it adds a bit of wildness into the game it makes it a bit less predictable and a bit less kind of rigid um just a little touch of wildness actually helps game for me but I can see if you are a big fan of abstract games and you want a more deterministic kind of experience then that could leave you frustrated they play interaction in the game is strong as I mentioned that kind of trumping mechanism of the mothers going over the fruited the fruit are going over the normal spores and that's always creating a back and forth of stealing spores off each other trying to find little hot spots on the board because I didn't mention that these kind of black tiles are Wilds which are of course extremely useful but they are naturally going to do gravity all the players towards them meaning that you might want to put one of your fruited mushrooms on there start sporing in there to make sure you've got lots of spores on those spots but of course somebody's going to sneak in there they're going to put their mother mushroom there and claim them all for themselves you might want to force them out of the way so yeah there's always this back and forth and little opportunities kind of arising on the board that you might want to capitalize on you know do you want to get into that back and forth you want to find yourself a little corner of the board that's untouched and focus on your own thing that way and there is that pressure of trying to keep up with your opponents because it does have a somewhat sudden death feel to the game um because you know that idea of as soon

as the five slots are completed then the game is gonna immediately end so you need to be kind of looking over your shoulder making sure that the game isn't going to end abruptly at a time where you're not prepared now this game does accommodate one to four players and I have not tried the solo mode so I cannot comment on that but my favorite player count for this game by far is two players because I think it moves at a much uh brisker Pace I do like how Dynamic the board state becomes at higher player counts because there's a lot more kind of Breaking Chains and positioning those mother mushrooms to you know sabotage other players but I do think it has the tendency to drag on a bit too long when you get into that three or four player counts until my knowledge there's nothing in the rulebook that compensates for scaling so I think it would have been nice if you are say playing with three or four players maybe remove one of these player slots so that it's the first player to do you know four card tucks rather than the five I've just to prevent it from outstanding it's welcome okay so let's talk about the production for the game here and you know I need to be fair here because this is a prototype copy and there will be some changes with the final version and I believe there is going to be two versions of the game you can buy one of which is going to have laser Cuts wood pieces and the other one is going to be you know your traditional cardboard now I am a colorblind person um it is quite difficult for me to differentiate the different tile types here now they have gone to efforts to try and put some symbology on these tiles so that

somebody who's colorblind can differentiate them like for example you can see the little symbols um for me these are far too small and it was a bit of work to almost um you know cross-reference the board state to the cars themselves because not any other symbols small on the cards they are also small on the board now I have spoken to the designer about this and they are going to be enlarged for the final version to make it a lot more playable which for me would be a big Lifesaver just for the ease of play for this game but on top of that I do think the ball state becomes quite busy I'm not quite sure if this kind of like Celtic pattern in the background helps with the visual ease of looking at the game so it is a little bit congested there and it's a bit of an eyesore I think um but that instead of complete contrast to that the card artwork is absolutely stellar and this is the the artist of this game is the design of the game so this is clearly a very talented guy um the artwork here is just absolutely Sublime and I'm you know I cannot praise this enough I think it looks wonderful on these white backgrounds it really does pop and there's this wonderful scientific mushroom pictures look amazing so full props um for that okay so let's share some final thoughts on my cellular and there are a lot of things I like about this game and particularly when it comes to the board positioning and you know the idea of chaining your spores together cutting people's networks off blocking them in um you know claiming people's spores for yourself a good back and forth there and it's been a quite Fierce competition on the board

I also do like that car tucking I think that's an extra touch that really does help the game and adds a little bit more interest into just giving you little booms as you go um negative wise you know I already mentioned the production issues which should be um easy fix and again that player scaling I think could have been worked on a little bit but that's an easy house rule to overcome in terms of just making it move at a more brisk Pace by maybe getting rid of one of these Spore spots now the other criticisms I have are probably more personal preferences um in terms of the end game trigger I tend to usually find that these kind of sudden death end game triggers and as soon as something happens it will end for me that almost always encourages the rush strategy and I'm not quite sure because you know I'm not terribly experienced with this game I've only played it a few times but each time I have played it that Rush strategy seems to be hugely beneficial um and it's you know it's always determined the winner so whoever finishes first is going to win but I'm not sure if that's going to be accurate in terms of um you know consistent plays I'm not sure but it's just to get a personal preference it's not my favorite way to end a game and also I kind of find myself always leaning towards just spamming the board every single time I think it'd be a bit of a fool if you're not at least sporing every single turn um and I don't normally find is rather than the building towards a certain card a lot of the time I've just Spam the board and then hopefully that would correspond to the cards that I have rather than the other way around um the more I played this one the less that's been an issue because I found myself being more and more efficient with it but it's just something that I know it's just something I noticed in

these kind of resource games where you're collecting different types and you do have a ton of resources on the board I normally find that I just flood the board as much as I can and hope I have what I need rather than getting building towards something which is a bit more satisfying but again I'm probably wrong on that in terms of repeated plays and if you want to play completely efficiently but overall it's a very interesting design I like the way the board game changes um I like the way it develops and opens up and again the artwork is absolutely Sublime and you know for me as not a huge fan of abstract strategy games this one does have a lot I like about it and I'd certainly play it some more like even like that random that random Touch of where the um where the spores blow um because I think it adds a bit more excitement into the game and can create some pretty funny moments when you end up you know blowing all your spores into your opponent's hands and they're going to end up building one of their mushrooms to use um against you so that's my cellular I'm certainly an interesting design um you know best of luck for the kickstarter launch and again if you like pure abstract strategy games with a touch of wildness and then I'm pretty sure you'll like this game so that is my Celia

Progress saved