Memoir 44 Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the ball games 4k YouTube channel and this is channel where we look at various title top games card games or games role-playing games all that sort stuff and we give you playthroughs reviews and other stuff and we generally talk crap about board games and tabletop games in glorious 4k resolution and in this video we'll be talking about their own ancient some people say war game some people say it's not a war game and we'll be talking about memoir 44 released in August 2002 2003 maybe 2004 who knows can't remember we'll be giving you a very brief overview of the rules because this one can turn into a bit of a spoil and beast and we'll be telling you what we do like what we don't like and then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not memoir 44 there's still worth playing in 2019 and Beyond and if you know where please consider subscribing to our channel assist us in helping this channel grow so it can bring you more stuff and leave a comment in a relevant section down below and we'll see you after this
board games for K sorry memoir 44 this is a very very light entry-level war game and we think it's a war game some people claim it's not a war going but we don't care we don't care what you think this is a war game right so what you're going to be doing with this one you're gonna be taking one of two armies essentially a two-player game out of box and in the core box you got the Germans and the Americans and you'll be picking a scenario setting up the board with various bits of terrain putting your armies on designated spots put in different bits of equipment different sandbags or barbed wire and stuff on the board and then depending on the rules of the scenario somebody will go first and what you'll be doing your beat join us a specific amount of cards and putting them on your little card tryi the board of service this is dissected into three parts you got the central part you've got the left flank and then you've got the right flank here so each card will have an instruction on it will tell you where to activate your troops what flank was what portion of the boards are activated and then it'll tell you what type of troops that you want to activate and you've got our infantry which your little ground troops you've got your artillery which is the little things of fire ballistic rockets and stuff and then you've got your tanks and all that sort of stuff and the the cards will generally tell you to move one of them and then attack quite cool there might be some other cards that give you special instructions like air right and various different things but generally speaking the cart will tell
you to move and then attack and or you'll do your each unit it's got a specific number of movement points and you'll move them and depending on the terrain you may have to stop you may not be able to go through them and once you've moved in your attack and again each unit will have its own special attack criteria and it you always have to have line of sight between yourself and the target and depend on just on the terrain and various other factors line-of-sight may not be possible or even may reduce the amount of tactile city role but generally speaking each type of you now has a different type of attack die that you want to roll you pick up that many dice you roll them and end normally roll without so many units that get destroyed on the other side you've got infants if you go infantry symbol that will destroy that number of infantry you got if you want number of tanks you'll get number of tanks you've got the little green stars the pictures scenario specific and they may do different things depend on the scenario and then you might have the the dependent if you roll the retreat symbol and that unit will have to betray and then when they retreat back the opponent decides where they have to retreat what will happen is the scenario will tell you when you complete specific scenario by subjective so you'll be taking medals and people in on the middle trap on your board and again so part of this another scenario dependent rules will tell you how many medals you need to to get and the first player to reach that number of medals will be the winner of memoir 44 and Buddhist gain there's an absolute plethora of expansions you've got the Mediterranean expansion you've got the Pacific Theater expansion you've got the
Eastern Front expansion you've got the winter Wars expansion you've got the overall expansion that allows you to simulate multiplayer battles up to eight players and one person will take a commander and then the other players will take one flank and the center or a six where the commander will turn Center and you'll play out on these huge massive maps pre-printed maps and with with pre-printed cetera terrain and you'll your bail out on that way so you've got the breakthrough maps which are these sort of extended versions of the standard maps and this there's so many different different expansions and different ways to play this so it's it's all sort of modular you can chuck in what you want Chuck to take out where you want and it's all scenario dependent so once you've completed the specific demands at a scenario you are the winner and then watch for so what do we like so the first thing that we got talked about this one is that it's a very light ball game and again we don't care what you think whether or not you think this is a wall cone because in our opinion it's definitely a war game and it may not be that you matches the height of your GMT magnum opus but for me it allows me to play with my kids and it allows me not to get bogged down in these in these walls and it's very very quick game and that's why I like it because it suits kids and adults and it brings your kids together without this and this immense behemoth of a strategy game forcing you to learn all these different rules you know everything's on cards all the different laws are on
cards and it's very a tackle box it's very easy to digest even for kids so the second thing about meanwhat 44 is the amount of options available to you even a tackle box is absolutely astonishing to me I think there's 10 scenarios in the base game and there's loads more online I mean there's so many scenarios available you've got the two campaign books you can pick up which let you go through these specific historical chronological events and then you've got a locator you got all the Pacific Theatre that takes you put into the Japanese front and that and then you've got the you've got the Russian Soviet scenarios that you can get and you've even got like the scenario builder from the days of one who are aligned which it allows you to make up your own scenarios and then put the maps off yourself so as the fact that this how many expansions for this one is it's astonishing and if the fact is still being supported it's absolutely amazing so the first thing that we got to talk about with this one is it's got the perfect blend of luck and strategy and the fact you've got dice rolls and card random cards all means that it's caught it it's very very random and it's hard to predict what's going to out in the bar that simulates the fog and chaos of walk on it so you've got you got your water's coming through by the card deck between your boots on the ground and what where you are on the battlefield and you've got your commanders making decisions no bar bug control then the summit gets lost between there and in here right so that that card draw that randomness simulates the the fog
or from your commanders and also the chaos about when when you get down to a modern micro level there's a really good blend of skill and luck to the fact that this game is effectively scenario based means that these scenarios been should have well it should have been tested which will more often than not ensure that there's a good balance between the two sides because it could have been the case that they just give you the pieces and then you know you may cut your own battles you just have one battle where the fact that this sum this game differs from other sort of similar games like the attack or well what's it called it now strategic or whatever any of those sort of very simple wargames means that you're gonna get a good a good balance of gameplay between its two opposing forces so the final thing that we like as lies about things being on time talk about what because I've watched this this review would go on forever and you don't want that deal the last one we're going to talk about it's the fan made content make possible body firstly by the days of plunder online and then you've got also got the option to build if you're so inclined if you're that much of a geek you can build your own custom terrain and we've done a little better you know sawing up a few bits of MDF nough stocks and some flocking on there to make the hills and order and some other stuff that we've seen some of the pictures we've seen online of all of some people that are played they've made some amazing amazing bits of pieces for listeners it's almost like you know that song heroscape sort of thing where people take the the core ideas aside and it allows you because it's like a sort
of a sandbox kind of thing is but not not in the game but it just presents you with a set of tools and you can go mad with it as much as you want so that's another thing to be applauded about memoir 44 the fact that it hasn't changed over time hasn't got a second edition and it stayed true to its roots working a bit very beginning and it's possibly an out now for like 15 years or something and people are make people are still support are still playing it that is probably the major thing for me is that 15 years after it's released it's still being supported today so what don't we like about memoir 44 so the first thing that is a pain in the butt about this game is it can get quite fiddly but most physically because the bits are quite small when you're trying to get their little men on on the hexes and sometimes when you've got like you want to get four tanks on a hex they just don't fit on there properly you know I can't get quite fiddly physically on the board that's a pain in the bump and secondly it could be fiddly with the amount of rules that you got remember I know they'll come on cards boy but there's so many different balls further you've got rules for the different armies and if you were using an expansion side of Japanese kamikaze rules and all that sort of stuff you've got all these different rules flying about and it's the rules of scenario dependent so the more stuff you add the more stuff there is to remember and looking for those little badges to play the badges sit on the board you know for the French Resistance and we're a real pain in the bump because you've got to
move them with the army and you've got a search for a more weak we put them in a you know like a like a coin collection book you know so we've got em all we've got on all in air but you know that makes it a lot easier with all the badges in as much of an order as we can put on it so that might be a good idea if you haven't fooled by that and might be a little bright way for so yeah there's so much stuff that it does get a bit of a pain to sort it all out to put it up and tear it down but yeah it can get quite fiddly by physically so the is it the second thing I think this yes the second thing that we don't like about their waffle is we talked about how the randomness that card tool and the dice sort of fit that sort of fog and chaos of war but on the flip side it could mean that you're never going to get a break quite so you you might shuffle the cards off and draw your cards in there and it may be the case that none of the cars you really need to make progress in the game come out and your opponent gets all the cars that they want you know and I know it's a case of sort of making best use of the tools that you've got in front of you but the random nature of this one may mean that you are stuffed before we get home okay so the final thing that we do not like about men wife for is it is looking a little bit dated why I mean look at the Box boy I know you might like to cover but that to me looks like be something that 2004 and it could do with a bit of a refresh but I think the fact that you you've got so
many expansions and people clamoring for reprints of our Eastern Front last year when they were and I'm banging down on Days of Wonder stalker come on hang out and reprint this one and they did they reprinted when the walls I reprinted Eastern Front they sold out immediately and yeah they I don't think we're ever going to see a proper second edition areal because it's so been so well supported so Lobby said we applaud the fact that it's been well supported since 2004 but it's also sort of going to detriment because I don't think we're ever going to see a second edition and if they did print a second edition that wasn't really compatible with the previous versions I think the probably of fans would go absolutely ballistic and I don't like pun intended way so to summarize memoir fault for is it still worth playing today and in the future and quite frankly this is the definitive entry-level war game end off why there's nothing can compare to this one this is the top-notch entry-level war game if you're looking if you never played these or GMT war games away and you don't they look it to intimidate you and you want something that scratches the hitch but isn't too daunting then this game it's the first pork or I'll tell you we bailed off on this one from OC's before it just looks like just like the old rule game you know in the 1950s or some of that but we took a punt on it we
picked it up cheap and now we've got everything here we've got everything for this and my kids love it I love it and it's even better if you could pick up the arguable expansion because Baptist opens a game up into this massive epic write the overall pranks along games like Twilight Imperium right for that sort of epic feel because it just takes the going on to another level you've got six or a year sat around a table everyone's doing everything but trying to work together right this games is so customizable you tear tasty I mean you can start off with a corset and just take it easy with a few rules few bits that's right and then you can chuck in the various expansions you know then you can go through the break through board if you want a longer game and then eventually you can turn into this massive beast you know it's a completely customizable to the level of difficulty you want you want to delve into on this one so so yeah I mean memoir 44 it's an essential gun absolutely essential if you haven't caught it on your shelf then do yourself a favor and God pick it up today because it's for us it's 9 a 10 this is a fantastic fantastic experience fantastic game and absolutely essential purchase in 2019 and it will last forever so like we said if you're new here and please consider subscribing to our channel leave a comment down below and we'll see you next time you