Tammany Hall Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to our channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play throughs unboxings i generally like to talk a lot of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general and in this video we'll be talking about an area control game that's recently had a quite a nice reprint we're going to be talking about tammany hall and this is a game where you'll be trying to take control of different regions by influencing immigrants you'll be taking part in elections whilst trying to slander your opponents to get victory points that will allow you to win the game so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview the rules be telling you what we do like we don't like then we'll come back and we will tell you whether or not tammany hall is still worth playing quite a few years after it was first released so remember if you knew it please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you after this bollocks so tell me all how'd you play this game so first thing you're going to do when you're setting this game up you're going to stick the ball down in the middle of the table final thing and then what you do you're going to populate the different zones with a certain number of immigrants right zone 1 is going to have two irish immigrants that's gonna have two english immigrants that's gonna have two german immigrants and zone two and zone
three are gonna have the same type of people stuffed in there but they're gonna have less of them right and these are gonna be used to populate the different zones on the board different points in the game you notice there's three different zones on the board you're going to start by trying to influence zone 1 and then later on in the game zone 2 will open up and then zone 3 will open up at different points and the point in the game that this happens depends on how many people you got playing the game so each player is going to take 20 ward bosses these are the larger meeple top and you'll also take three slander tokens which are the grey speech bubble type tokens right so this game is an area control game it consists of two phases the first phase is the castle garden phase and what you'll do you'll reach into the draw bag and you'll pick out a number of cubes equal to the number of players plus two easy even for you stupid [ __ ] these cubes go in the castle garden space and this leads us on to the second thing you're gonna do it's gonna take some actions there's two types of actions you can do you can do the campaign action or you can do the settle action if you're gonna do the campaign action you can place two ward bosses in any two wards when you place a wall boss has to be placed in an active ward if there's no immigrant cubes in a ward it's considered an active and therefore you can't put a wall boss in there but why would it be a stupid thing to do anyway wouldn't it and then once you've placed your wall boss in any active board you'll be able to choose a cube from the castle garden space and you'll be able to chuck it in any active ward on the map and you've got to remember that
you don't have to have a wall boss in that space where you're chucking the immigrant cube right once you've done a certain action then you'll take a political favor token that is the same as the immigrant that you dumped into that ward right there's a couple of extra subsidiary actions that you can do but these can only be taken after the first term after the first election right so bear that in mind the first thing you can do is you can use a slander token you can give up one of your slander tokens that's worth points at the end of the game and you can slander an opponent you've got to choose an active ward where you've got a ward boss and you'll spend a political favor that matches at least one cube that's in an adjacent territory that matches a population cube in that ward and that will allow you to throw out an opposing ward boss in an adjacent space and not only that you can also do this again so you can go to another adjacent ward and then you can spend another two political favors to do that again right so this is really a handy way of getting rid of your opponent's influence in adjacent water so the next optional action you can do is you can use one of the city benefits you'll get one of these at the end of each round and they give you a specific benefit if you become the man it's just going to give you free victory points but there's several other office benefits that you can be given by one of the opposing players you might have the council president and this means up to two times per turn you may place a council president token on any ward that does not already have one and once the token is placed there's basically going to be a lockdown in this ward it means that no one can go in and no one can go out you might end up with the deputy mayor in which case each turn you'll gain one political favor of any color
or you might have the precinct chairman he gives you the resettle action each turn you may move one immigrant cube from any ward with at least two cubes to an adjacent ward with at least one cube so these office benefits are quite powerful it's quite agonizing when you actually become the mayor because you're the one who is going to be distributing this so it's quite an agonizing choice knowing that you're giving your opponents some really nice benefits right so once each player has taken a turn then it will be the end of the year and this is when an election will happen elections will happen at various points throughout the game and the first thing you're going to do is you're going to clear a castle garden if any immigrants hasn't been placed on it and you'll hold a walled election you'll go through each active warden turn following the arrows around don't worry about the numbers on the walls you follow the arrows all the way around and then each player that has at least one ward boss in that wall will be able to bid a certain number of political favor tokens to try and win the election everyone will take the number of these flavour titans in around and you'll do rock paper scissors blah blah blah everyone will reveal and then you'll top the amount of war bosses you got in there ward and then the amount of favor tokens and the majority will win if there's a tie no winner is declared all war bosses are removed from the ward so if you win the election then all the world bosses except one from the winning bidder will get removed right so once you've carried out the election you'll go to the phase of naming the immigrant leaders so starting with the irish population each player will encounter the number of irish people that they've got in all the water that they won and the majority will then gain three irish influence tokens and then you'll go to the english and then you go to germans and you go to the italians you do the same thing right
this is a good way of building up your influence tokens for the next round next thing you'll do the final thing you do is you'll get one point for each award that you won the player who won the most awards would then be granted the title of the mayor and they'll get three victory points the mayor will also like we said before will then gift one office benefit to each of the other players right once you get to the end of the term you've done the election then you'll populate zone two then you'll populate zone three and then you'll have the final election once you've completed the final election then you will tot up and do a bit of final scoring each immigrant population will gain two victory points to the player who has the most unspent political favors of that population this isn't referring to the number of cubes that's on the board this is just referring to say like the irish the english or the germans or italians you know not the actual cubes he got on the board and then each unused slander token is worth one victory point it's probably better to use it in it but yeah it's worth one feature point and the player with the most victory points wouldn't be the winner of tammany hall so what do we like about tammany hall so the first thing that we like about tammany hall is the way that the map increases in size the further into the game you get at the start you're just gonna have zone one which consists of a couple of wards if you do get a benefit if you take over towards enzyme one you get like a free population token or maybe a free immigrant cube to dump somewhere but as you progress further into the game the map opens up meaning that you've got a choice of whether to double down on the investments that you've made inside one or do you branch
out and spread your influence more thinly but in more locations right that's a really good choice to make because you don't know what immigrants are going to be arriving in castle garden for you to distribute into the new zones dear so that leads us on to the second point that we like about tammany hall is that there is a really clever mix of public and private information like we said when you set the game up you're going to be sticking some immigrant cubes on the side of the board and these are going to be populating the new areas first of all you're going to be taking a certain amount of cubes often populating areas but then also to counter that knowledge that you've already got you've got the random element of picking the immigrant cubes out of the bag so you've got a nice balance between public and private information that you've got to basically gamble on are you just going to double down on like english political influence knowing that there's going to be a decent amount of english population going out but are you going to wait and see what the bag is going to give you and then make a decision from there so yeah we really like the fact that there's a really good balance between public and private information in this game right so the final thing that we like about tammany hall is the slander tokens add just enough take that into what otherwise wouldn't be that much of a backstabbing game the fact that you get rewarded for not using them means there's also another choice there between kicking out some wall bosses hoping that they're not going to get repopulated when your opponent's turn comes around or do you hold on to the slander tokens in the hope that they're going to just edge you past your opponent again
because all the games we play this have been now bitingly tensed walls in have been very very close it's another clever gamble when you decide to use the slander tokens if at all so what don't we like about tammany hall so the first thing that we don't like about tammany hall and this is more of a nitpick more than anything it's to do with the fact that the political favor tokens are single-sided right i'm pretty sure that the first printing of this the the original printing there wasn't any kind of design or stickers or printing on these tokens at all but they've only printed them on one side which sort of defeats the object really i mean what with my ocd obsession i find myself getting annoyed and having to spend time flipping these over to the side with the crest on right so it really does get inside my skull and uh you'll probably be alright if you're not a lunatic like me but probably most of you are so just be aware of that when you dive into this one so the second thing that we don't like about tammany hall is it's kind of difficult to make sense of what's going on towards the back end of the game this game spreads out so far and so wide that it's incredibly difficult to calculate all the different permutations of who's doing what and where stopping your brain from spiraling into a quagmire of confusion right this issue gets worse the higher the play account if you're playing with free players it is sort of manageable but when you get up into the realms of five players then there's going to be so much
competition for places you're gonna have to sort of calculate how many wall passes you've got whether or not people can come in and dump you out with a slander token it seems to us that each time you place a cube down or you place a wall boss down you are in fact more often than not gambling upon the success of that placement not really knowing whether it's going to have any effect right so that can be a little bit of a problem if you're not adept at keeping an eye on a lot of moving parts at the same time right so the final thing that we don't like about tammany hall is that this isn't a game that is going to impress cuba folks right you know where you are the people that can't stand the traditional dry euros from the 90s all the way through to the mid-2000s you know the el grande kayla style games this isn't going to impress you at all because essentially that's all it is it's just shoving cubes around a map trying to position bits of wood into the best location possible at the most opportune moment right and i suppose if you really do have to find criticism in this game it does sort of feel like a relic from a bygone era now even say five to ten years ago this might have been considered modern but now things have moved on so much there's so much plastic in games there's so many different types of mechanisms but it's safe to say that if you've moved on from that genre of euro games this is not going to be on your birthday wishlist so to summarize is tammany hall worth your bother today and in the future
so we're going to say yes absolutely this is without that one of our favorite area control games that we've played in a very long time it's a superb area control game that delivers a sense of nail bite and tension as the game develops round by round it can suffer from a case of [ __ ] it let's just see what happens at the end of the game but all in all this is worth your serious attention if you are a fan of these dry euro cube pushing affairs and we are a fan of both of those types of games we love dry euros and we love pushing cues around so for us this is a fantastic area control game and if you like those types of games we wholeheartedly recommend tammany hall for you so there you go that's tammany hall remember if you are new here then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you next tuesday you