Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 30:30

thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and Brad and I are doing a discussion for expeditions the sequel to Scythe uh yeah yeah sequel like very very loose loose terms uh this is specifically the Ironclad Edition which the only difference is metal mix uh which I have they're they're awesome the best part like um so if you're a fan of my channel for any significant amount of time you would know that Scythe was my number one game uh for many years till it was uh dethroned by sleeping gods and then kind of has slightly Fallen uh over the past few years um so you can imagine my excitement whenever I heard about this one like as a sequel as a sequel to scythe and uh you can now imagine my extreme disappointment when here's the thing I don't think this game is bad like I I there are elements of this game though I like but I kind of find it boring and that's that's my main issue with it my here's my number one comment about this game I'm not a fan of Scythe I don't I'm not I don't care for science yeah either because I was hoping well no it's just not okay I was hoping this was gonna be different yeah but well it is

different right of it but think about how long this game took uh hour and a half hour and a half to two hours right yeah if you're gonna spend that much damn time just place ice yeah I mean that's a thing it's like it's like it's in the world of scythe and it takes certain visual aspects of it yeah but it's like if you're gonna spin the best time just play Scythe I I agree yes and like I said this game is com it is different from Scythe it's not like I'm saying right right might as well play Scythe because this is basically that that's not the case it's just that I find Scythe to be far superior in in almost every way there are things about this game that I do like better than Scythe but that's because Scythe doesn't have it you know the card play that's in this game is not inside there's a war it's themed about war but you don't actually really fight all that much um it's a euroesque war game uh and I mean let's get this out of the way scythe and Expeditions has some of the it's the best artwork it's good inboard gaming uh if you're not familiar the story of Scythe is the game was built around its artwork um so that goes a long way and just because of that that's why Scythe kind of took off so it's it's like with with Expeditions it's kind of like it's not a tableau game it's like a card tucking game uh of

slight Resource Management uh like multi-use cards for a limited amount of time slight worker placement but not really because it's also on your cards I will say I think this game is unique I haven't really seen any game like this in in the sense of how you use your cards but for me how you use your cards isn't exciting like you know I never in in a game with multi-use cards which when I say multi-use cards you can play there's like a plethora every card can be played for either its resource which there's only two resources in the game guile and Power um and you only need guile and power to uh to Vanquish areas which you're clearing up corruption and uh you're really only doing that to kind of free up extra action spots uh and put out a uh uh star so you get you can get a resource you can eventually some of them are quests that you can fulfill uh but that's just kind of another way to get other resources and then it's a work replacement spot and then it's called melding for meteorites I I mean to me this game is all mechanical yeah no theme yeah I mean the art is nice to look at and stuff but like you literally

are like I had no theme in this I agree so ever yeah it feels soulless oh I'm gonna get these resources to move this track and I'm going to spin those to yeah get this card scored yeah and you know it was just like there was no because the huge thing about this and obviously I'll be comparing it to Scythe I have to it was my favorite game I still adore Scythe every time I play which I don't play Scythe a whole lot anymore but every time I do play Scythe I'm like yeah I remember why this was my number one uh but I couldn't ever pinpoint exactly why Scythe was my number one for so long everything was just you just clicked but a great example is in this game there are quests there are three types of cards in this deck that you just shuffled so it's completely random if you're trying to get quest to be you know to do a star for quest uh and they're not coming out it's like okay I guess I'm just not doing that but I mean alternatively you can do the items you've got a star for an item or the meteorites uh but when you quest it says what you're doing Place eight uh possessed animals talk with the Protectors of the cave clear the blockaded bridge I didn't read a single title I did but here's like you said it's all mechanical but you don't have to read any of them but in Scythe when you go do a quest you see the art and you choose you have your choices and it's like and all your options are based off of what's in the picture so you kind of get into the theme a little bit I'm not saying scientist is the most thematic game in the world like you felt like you were in the world though exactly and you don't

hit in this no uh the the art is just there it doesn't feel interconnected you don't feel like you're doing anything within the alternate your robots it's kind of like here and to be fair this is also kind of annoying uh it is technically a sequel to Scythe but it um it technically I'm not gonna read it just in case but the very first line of the theme on the rulebook is a major spoiler yeah interesting yeah I saw that and I was like that's kind of annoying it's not a spoiler for me because I've played that but if you haven't I mean I might be making something out of nothing but it is just the fact that it's there and I know of the that expansion I was like really you said it's a sequel to Scythe now this I guess you're including all the expansions and I haven't played through I haven't touched any of the expansions or Fitness or anything so I don't know if this is something that gets brought into that and you don't need to spoil it but one of the weird things I thought about this was the supernaturally kind of stuff that kind of came in like with the possessed people and and the weird forests and there's you know like there was like supernaturally kind of stuff and I don't it so this that's not from Rise offenders but it does say um this is in Siberia where a massive meteorite crash near the tangusta river Awakening ancient corruption okay so that's where the meteorites are coming in and I mean I think that's cool that's a that's a it's an alternate Europa it was already kind of sci-fi-ish anyway

with the mechs and I thought the kind of doing the almost Cthulhu colorless color out of space kind of thing jump in it is really neat but you do not feel that at all the entire time the corruption are just numbers of tokens we draw from this bag and you go there and you're like oh I have five guile I'm gonna go there use my bear to Vanquish it spend my five guile to take this oh and now I can do a meld if I go to the weird Forest I can do I can get a purple worker or I can meld if I happen to have a meteorite um yeah so there's because here's the other thing that I have about this game is I feel like in in scythe it everything is open knowledge like to what almost anyone can do at any given time except for combat but combat you can be like okay like let me look through the discard pile right hmm like and you can kind of try and get in their head on what they're gonna play when you're when you're fine that's really the only Randomness here you have these tiles that are shuffled um out on the board and you don't know where anything is I mean at least the quests tell you what level they're on but it's like man I have 20 total power and and guile I really want to find that level 20 or the 20 location I don't know

where it said oh hey you opened it up for me thanks man right well and and another thing about this game this could be a positive or negative depending on how you look at games but with with the exception of taking spots this is a solo game yeah I mean yeah ultimately I mean there's I mean there's nothing that I do besides taking a spot yeah right uh interacts with you that's when you were taking your turn I was just kind of not really yeah you know yeah um you could I mean technically it's like you could take a car that I might want but right yeah it's just pretty much or you can do a Corruption of a spot that I want but yeah you're not directly interacting with someone the only kind of interaction you have with another player like you said is there was area control because you were putting out uh uh buildings there's none of that here at least I have a lot of map tokens yeah you're oh well there was also the race for the quest tokens because those were limited right inside here it's like it's just cards and these map tokens are they do nothing unless something specifically says to do something with them so so what is interesting about this game well at least for me I didn't find really anything like super exciting but it's like on your turn you you it they kind of wanted to replicate that action selection in uh in Scythe but

it's very very shallow uh it's like okay you can either move play a card or gather and The Gather is do the location action so unless at the beginning of the turn you get to do all three but ever since then turn after turn you have to move your Cube around to where you can only do two out of the three so if you move it on to move you're gonna play a card and gather you're gonna but you can't keep it there so next turn you either have to refresh or it's like okay I'm gonna now move and gather but I also found that kind of extremely arbitrary where you can kind of just keep it hopping back and forth between locations um because if I wanted to be a dick on that 20 I literally could have sit there you could have you could have stayed there uh eventually you would have been doing you would have had to refresh because you would have had no cards left to play and you have to play cards right so but yeah but I could just choose a refresh and stay there I mean no it's true you know what I'm saying it's like it's well because then you but after that refresh then you would have to move right if you can't you just no you can't go back okay no you can't just hop back and forth all right you have to go to a new location so you can't you can puppy guard for a little bit but like that's that one that you it's just kind of like ah you're delaying the inevitable like while you're doing that I'm gonna now start going around and getting a bunch of workers so I can do this star yeah and the other thing that I kind of find it really dumb or bizarre is there are specific

locations that uh you have to go to to actually play stars out some people might like that right some people might like the fact that you have to uh go to a spot to boast and that's how you place those out but I almost find a like you just as soon as you guys I assume you did it achieved it yeah yeah it almost made the game longer because then you had to go find those locations and then hope you could gather well first you had to Vanquish it yes then you add then you would be like oh I did it now I can finally I've been holding on to four quests and four meteorites and four items and you know seven workers all right time for me to hop back and forth and sandbag my four things I hope game's over it's like I I just find that weird instead of like I guess you could just keep an eye on your opponent and be like okay that's what he has but we haven't found any of those locations I just don't like that as a game mechanism especially whenever it's like well it's the sequel to Scythe oh well then Stars should be placed out immediately when you complete the thing no gotta find those three locations that let you do it one of which is blocked until someone can actually pop 20. and then they get a basically a three star out um yeah like because you would think in theory that the multi-use cards would be super cool

um but the items which are like how you become unique like I didn't find them you know as like Pat like passive abilities it's like okay yeah that's the thing you got anything you liked about the game besides the art oh I mean I came at this just like I said at the beginning I I don't like scientists yes I was hoping for something more and it's when I would rather play Scythe that's true you know what I'm saying like that's true um it it's a game I mean it's not it's not the worst thing in the world I've ever played no I mean we played we played Star Wars Rivals earlier that was very that was clearly very Star Wars Rivals better than this yeah come on yeah come on come on hey it only takes 15 minutes that's true but you'll be miserable those 15 minutes I guess you were miserable for an hour and a half for this it wasn't miserable it's not it wasn't it wasn't well that's what I'm saying is like it's like what's what's worse a genuinely badly designed game or a painfully average game you know it's like at least it's kind of like would you rather watch a shitty movie like Sharknado or the Meg it's like or would you rather watch a movie that that gives you you feel nothing you're like man do I have depression from watching this because I feel nothing watching this and I would say that that's the lather is the worst because at least in a bad game

you can make fun of it you can have a good time just laugh like like same with a bad movie so my argument is that well I got nothing out of this like I'm not mad about it I'm just disappointed it's it and I didn't come in being like this is going to replace Scythe or this is gonna be just I knew it was different uh I had seen you know kind of how it was played but and and it's like I like Jamie as like a designer so it's not I don't think there was any like malicious cash grab oh no on site because it's like well it's been it's been what six years yeah since I've came out so I think he was trying to do something different clearly he didn't want to do another war game but it almost feels like he didn't know how to use this world like like clearly and it's like well he didn't want to do not a Dungeon Crawl but like he didn't want to do like a RPG or any type of Storytelling I can tell you though like a sleeping God's desk kind of game in this universe that'd be pretty dope yeah uh and after the success of like his expansions with rise of Fenris being amazing it's kind of like well where do you go from here it's like well make something different like you don't have to just do something else this could have been I feel like if this didn't have the site name on it maybe it would have been it wouldn't have it's not gonna be as it wouldn't be compared to it so maybe people would

have came in and kind of liked it more I don't know I'm not sure unless you have the really heavy hardcore Scythe fan voice like anything about the world and like you know yeah but that's the other thing it's like the world is based off its art like as far as I'm aware there's like no lore around it like I've there might be somewhere the artist might have actually written stuff about a world but I I've always gotten that stuff from the uh from scythe uh and it did kind of feel like it came down to most people in scythe and in this game are going to be relatively close to each other because these aren't really hard to do not that the goals in Scythe were all that difficult either it is essentially a race game um because it's like I mean you can win without getting all your stars out in scythe and you can do that here uh but it does kind of do a popularity hey I did all these Quests for you so like so I have the most quests and because I have three or more each of my stars is worth 10.

but where you get a lot of your in-game money is from melding and that kind of felt like in the games that that we've played that it's like well I melded more than you so throughout the game I gained more money than you so I'm gonna win and that is the rip your conditions which is the same as inside if it's the wealthiest so like in this particular game you and I were head to head in fact you were ahead on Stars and then it's like okay well we tie that on Stars so and Quest so that does nothing but I got like 20 coins throughout the game because of the melding I melted four times and you melted once that was the defining factor I don't find that exciting not that it's bad it's just not exciting what do you think of the card work replacement thing that's new I don't think I've seen that anywhere it was weird like because all your cards are known to everybody that you're to the left of your boards your deck yeah or your hand with your hand whatever and then you move them over when you do the play action and stuff it was fine I mean I it was different yeah but your workers were just kind of there but yeah I mean I ran into that part where I only had the one red worker you know so we did go different paths in this game where you had a bunch of workers uh and you had a bunch of cards um so you get a lot of options of

actions that you wanted to do and I had done I specifically went after quests and then melding so I had like no cards by the end of this game I had my character and my companion and I just had the same worker so I was able to cycle those through but it's like well my character can't Quest anymore and my companion can only Vanquish but I don't have any resources so my cards aren't doing anything for me so how else do I get a star out oh okay I can go and get seven workers or something um uh because we both basically went from opposite ends like and where it's like seven workers or five map tiles eight cards seven corruption and then the other end is kind of the harder ones because that just takes up more time uh to Quest and all that but it's it's different like I commend them for that like multi-use cards I haven't seen anything of a worker placement where you actually there were you could not ever interact with someone else's cards or workers like you can't use your workers to block a spot it's like nope these are my very specific things that I can use like I have this mind Stone meteorite card if I go and place a yellow worker on it I'll get a guile and they can place a worker on an active card to activate its ability and if I have two uh mended meteorites I can gain

um a power per Place worker and then for this one I get a dollar per placed worker Max of three whenever it slides in uh I will say I do like that whenever you quest or you meld it uh it does stack that's that's nice that that can feel good um but I'm stretching really yeah for like the metal Max are awesome like the one I have right now is Odin's wrath and it's a Viking ship with that's [ __ ] dope like who would ever think of that as a design yeah uh

yeah the location I have a feeling the solo is pretty much just going to be the same game just with an AI guy probably running around yeah I mean it's been a while since I played the solo variant for Scythe I remember it being pretty good uh I don't here's the thing is I don't really want to try the solarium because it's not like I don't really like this game to be like oh baby solo will be better it's like no we just got done playing a two-player game I felt like it was solo the whole time except for the one time where like in this game where I was like man where is the 20 oh hey thanks man you you went there it's like I was planning to go there and hope that it was there because I didn't I was on this side of the board so I didn't want to have to Trek all that way but you went there first it's like oh yeah neat um I don't know the action selection I see what they were doing it's very watered down Scythe has a lot more going to I mean the one of the best things about sites is that upgrade system that as you do better your top actions get uh like get better as well as your bottom actions and it's like that's so that feels good nothing here necessarily feels good it's just like yeah game was made

yeah I I don't know I don't know I uh I'm I'm just taking taking a good old Gander oh here is another thing to actually kind of find annoying which might sound weird coming from someone who loves Scythe this game takes way more table space than it should like I feel like with the metal Max or the plastic Max I mean they're big and they're detailed and they're sexy but with the way you tuck cards underneath your uh your board um like this is a four by six table and there's not a lot of components here but yet every time I had to talk I was had to like push things away or move things because your hand is a row of cards your active area is a row of cards so you basically have to have imagine playing this with four players it's just like oh sorry like I mean theoretically you could just hold your cards yeah and then play them yeah it's not like you have to keep them secret for anybody or it doesn't matter if you do keep them they're stealing cards or anything like oh hey what can you do I'm never gonna look at another player's active hand if you're like huh what can they do nothing that I can stop the all those cards he has that's what he can do yeah anyway I'm gonna look at what I can do uh so that's what I would do is like just actually make your hand a hand of cards because a lot of stuff references stuff you control or hey complete the quests that you can that's in your hand or active Okay well if like if it's in your

hand you can just keep it in your hand you don't have to have a you know Tableau of your hand to some weird design design decisions uh I think that's it I think that's all I can I can really really think of I mean did you think the market of the face up cards was neat that's really what it was it was just a market just because like these five cards that are out there right now four of them I couldn't use yes I didn't have the workers which I know can be rectified by going to the spot and stuff so yeah like the the Crater Rim lets you sweep and clear up the spots it's it's essentially a market like in any kind of deck builder or or card game but they they have locations that when you go there to gather it's like take a face up card or you can only take a an adjacent card so they tried to do some area finagling with with the face up cards but I mean Gotta Give him credit he tried something different this game is different there's a lot of stuff that I almost feel like he's on to something you know that it's like there's there's something to be said about the way that things are done here I just feel like if you're gonna do something with multi-use cards and and unique like passive abilities or stuff like that that you got to make them you gotta make them cool like in a game like this where my [ __ ] mini is a viking warship with

crab legs I want to feel like I'm doing something with that could have been on the Storm you see I could answer your boat right there yeah it's right there and I could have discarded cards and and uh and got a card yeah that's really it's like your your metal Mech like doesn't feel badass like in Scythe of course you have your character and then when you have your mechs out it's like oh I'm gonna use these for war or resource marching yeah they're just they just look good here scale of one to ten what are you giving us Expeditions I I'm gonna give it a four a four yeah it's like I said I mean I think if I was going to give scyth a rating it would probably be a five okay because you know because I'm not a huge fan of that yeah Scythe is better than this in my opinion it's just meh yeah from all into the purposes I mean yeah I almost it's like I I wonder because you haven't played you've just played base game Scythe yeah I wonder if any of the expansions would sway you with a solid because I just didn't like the like how the game played out like it was just weird to me and yeah right well well I played this multiple yeah I play yeah let's do that and then you'll like it and then you're like five plates about five or six times yeah with different groups and I just never just doesn't click yeah that's fair so yeah so that's just kind of one of those

games that it's like if someone would be like why is it you're number one I'd be like I don't know I don't know I just loved everything about it uh for the longest time um yeah it's like I kind of I agree with you on a four especially for the price point of this game this game's over a hundred dollars um a little over 100 with the metal mix the Ironclad Edition which doesn't even come with the [ __ ] metal coins you have to add that as an add-on with iron it could have been it could have been made out of iron um but I think because I'm a little [ __ ] for scythe and it has scythe's name on inside there's a 10 out of 10 game for me I'm gonna I'm gonna give it a a I'm gonna give it a five like I think like if someone I would never play this like at max player count five players that would be [ __ ] awful uh does the board get bigger with more players no oh so this is it this is it wow yeah yeah the size the the board is is the size it's based off the base camp um so it's just more people in your way and longer interesting yeah uh so I've enjoyed this game at two uh BGG

says um best at two or three uh so I I kind of keep it at that uh I'm gonna give it an extra point yeah I'm Gonna Keep it out of five I think gameplay wise it is kind of a little bit below average of the four but I'm gonna bump it up a point because the art is so good I didn't know that's fair but yeah that sounds disappointing I'm I'm sad boy I'm sad boy now but that's uh that's our thoughts on Expeditions let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribing have a wonderful whatever type of day that's for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved