Beyond Solitaire Podcast 120: Eivind Vetlesen and Paul Wright on Europa Universalis
Transcript
thank you this is the last episode of season six and the Pod will be on break for a little while but no worries I'm hoping to start season 7 in Late July for now it's ad break time the Beyond Solitaire podcast is proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations as usual they are up to amazing things right now cartini from Darkness to light designed by Sharia ayawandini and published by I am game design is on Kickstarter ion and clgs have partnered to produce a curriculum guide for the game so go show it some support additionally at last there's an official launch date for 500 year old vampire Jason Cox's Cooperative role-playing game that is suitable for both game night and the classroom look out for it on back or kid on July 18th I am excited and you should be too and last a quick plug for myself if you enjoy this show and want me to be able to do even more work related to historical gaming show me some support on patreon.com Beyond Saltair it would mean a lot to me for now though let's get on with the show hey Gamers it's Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and this week on the Pod I have two very special guests I have Ivan vettelson he is the designer of Europa universalis the price of power how are you doing Ivan I'm good thank you for inviting me I'm happy to be on the show and looking forward to talking to the both of you fantastic yes and I have uh my other guest Paul Wright you might have heard him before talking about reacting to the Past he cultural historian who loves educational gaming European history and
Europa universalis uh both in video game and board game for him so I had him on it to help me ask the full range of insightful questions because I've never actually played the video game how you doing Paul good thank you for having me yeah it's wonderful to to have you both on here so Ivan why don't you just give people the rundown of Europa universalis the price of power so for people who have no idea what this is um I guess just it's a video game now it's a board game and what it's about yeah I might still mention that it was originally actually a board game uh way back in 1993. uh it was a board game made by a guy called Philip tibo and um and uh and it was picked up by Paradox and Filipino actually was involved in making the video game as well uh that they made the the first one I think came out like just at the start of 2000 maybe at the end of 1999 I'm not quite sure and uh since then it's got run through four uh iterations uh and uh Europa Universal is four is is now an old Beast already uh I think it's been around for about 10 years um and um and uh we we um well uh it's been my favorite video game basically ever since it came
out and uh my dream board game project so uh when I ran into one of the Paradox uh staff at Dusseldorf airport uh after uh Essence peel in I think it was 2014 and I started basically the dialogue uh with them at that point and it turned out that they had been thinking about making board games of their video game IPS so um so uh eventually I pitched uh uh to do a game for them first I pitched for Crusader Kings uh they came back to me when they had made all the plans for Crusader Kings asking there isn't any of our other games that you might want to pitch for and I said yeah my my favorite game is actually Europa so uh so um that's how I ended up doing this game instead and uh to be fair I think my initial pitch was a much better fit for this game in any case so we we just wanted to um make a board game which is as faithful as we could possibly be to uh to the um experience of playing the video game meaning that you can do all the same type of things that you can do in the video game you can go exploring you can develop your realm you
can uh experience the historical events in in some shape of form uh obviously not going to happen the same way every time you play uh you can play a game of warfare or you can play a game of diplomacy um and uh that's the essence of it obviously making a board game from a computer game as complex as uh Europa you need to make some changes you need to simplify things you need to make it so that players are not going to sit there calculating fractions and uh stuff the whole time so uh so it's a wholly different game but you will recognize uh a lot of the concepts from the video game comment from the video game to the board game will help you uh but it's not a prerequisite it's not a requirement we we made a game that we think and does very well on its own as well interesting so Paul as a cultural historian you know you've played both versions of the game and you're also a European history expert um why have you found Europa Universal so captivating across forms and you know what kind of perspective do you have on as a historian before we get to some of the nitty-gritty of what this game can do in terms of commenting on history thanks Liz I I love this question because I came to Europia versalis the
computer game first obviously I had not played the original board game um and I came to that computer game with a great deal of skepticism I didn't think a computer game was going to be able to simulate the complexity particularly of the early modern world and early modern period that I was so interested in I just played it to give it a shot thinking I wasn't really going to stick with this game which has now become part of my life as it has for so many other players I was so impressed with the range of options again as Ivan suggested for how you can play you can play The Diplomatic game you can play the military game you can play the political game the dynastic game economic game and all of the above you can blend all of these approaches and what particularly captivated me about the original game was that you could choose to play basically any realm on Earth you could choose to play you know Castile and work your way towards forming Spain and of course that comes with its own challenges and Pleasures but you could also choose to play the florentines in Italy which is my area of interest and focus as a scholar uh and if you're doing that you're basically starting with one area to work with and you are outnumbered by the rest of the world starting in Italy and you can have that experience you can play any realm any power you want anywhere on the planet and I thought that the model for
the simulation was so detailed so rich had such a learning curve that it was more and more attractive to me because of that it was not a game I was going to uh Master quickly and then move on from in fact I have never mastered it I am continuing to struggle with the game constantly but in the most Pleasant and intellectually stimulating of ways so I fell in love with the game been playing it for years and when I heard that there was going to be a board game implementation I was yet again skeptical and I will be honest when the kickstarter campaign came I did not back it initially and that's not the fault of the kickstarter it was a wonderful Kickstarter but I just thought there's no way this can work there's no way they can pull off anything approaching what was done in the computer game and because of a couple of factors I was a late backer one is the fear of missing out of course but more importantly I started reading the development Diaries I started looking at the rules I started realizing pretty quickly that this was one of the most ambitious adaptations of a previous property right in any medium that I'd ever seen and I think Ivan is under selling or or stating the degree of challenge he took on here and the ambition of what he was trying to do which is all the better for him being so successful in the implementation I think the pressure in
putting this game this computer game into board gaming terms uh must have been enormous and the fan base for the video game right was going to be the most scrutinizing and critical potentially and while I'm sure there are fans of the computer game who may quibble with the implementation what I've been so happy to see is how many of them are falling in love with the game all over again but now this time as an analog board game how many of them feel that it was a faithful implementation within the you know confines of a board gaming experience and I'm also happy to say that in my current Grand campaign game Ivan wrote me asking how it was going it's going wonderfully uh two of us are veterans of the computer game and adore it uh and two of us knew nothing about the computer game uh and came in and they are heavy Gamers I will say that much um but they fell in love with the game just as much and we are now halfway through the Grand Campaign which takes you all the way from 1444 to about 1821.
um and we are just having a blast and we are learning the ins and outs of this system which is just extraordinary I mean it does not have every last little thing that uh the original computer game has but if it did that would make it too unwieldy so I think what Ivan and his development team have done is extraordinary in reducing uh the computer experience to its Essence to the most important elements that fans would want to see and creating what I think is one of the great strategy board games I've ever played uh I say that without reservation thank you very much that's uh it's very nice to hear um so I do one step in there this game is heavy so yes it has been streamlined from the computer game there's a lot going on so Ivan like how did you pick and choose what you were gonna keep and how much of it well we tried to identify some things that we uh we definitely wanted to keep and that we could build on uh from the computer game um obviously we did not want this to be sort of Catan Europe by Universalist Edition sort of uh it needed to have depth otherwise there wouldn't be no point in using the intellectual proper property behind it uh it is a game for gamers even in the computer gaming world it's a game for people who go in depth into both strategy and history and so we
knew that we needed to have um uh depth in the the feeling that you were actually reliving some version of History we needed to have those historical events feel uh plausible uh feel like they were both linked to the history of the realm that you're playing but also linked to uh the the gameplay the the progress that you're making and I think that was the biggest challenge to make those events is relevant for for the players uh all the way through the game because this is a game of four ages right you're playing as you said from basically the the end of the battle of Varna in uh where the Crusaders fail at uh trying to uh stop the ottoman expansion in Europe and all the way until the death of Napoleon basically and in that time the the face of the Earth sort of or the world changes so much and we don't want to Railroad it right we don't want to have people do exactly the same that happen in Real History we want to let people carve out their own piece of history or go in the direction that they want we do give some encouragements to sort of follow a semi-historical direction for for your realm because there obviously are a certain
um natural predispositions for each of these uh Realms so uh the events for the first age it's sort of easy uh you're pretty much aware they were historically and you can kind of guess what people have been doing the first couple of turns but as soon as you get beyond the second age it it was a real challenge to make it both uh historically relevant and relevant to sort of any development the game develop development the game that we uh could foresee okay that was deriving a bit from your question probably uh talking about the historical side uh but from the computer game um what we saw that was I think I'm I can say is a little bit underdeveloped in the computer game it's the it's the Monarch power concept uh it's sort of a side note in the video game it's a sort of uh Mana that just keeps uh streaming in like a like a passive income that you you don't necessarily pay that much attention to the whole time uh it but it sets a timer for when you can do certain things uh we decided to take that concept a bit further in the computer game no sorry in the board game adoption and make those your action points that you use for any any type of action that you uh perform in the game basically so it's divided for those who play the
computer game obviously they know but it's divided into administrative administrative power diplomatic power and uh military power and those are the three sort of uh main directions I would say that you can go maybe so you can develop your strategy around one of those three types of Monarch power uh there are some other resources as well we do have money in the game uh so um so trade isn't a little bit on the side of that you could say but um but then in the then we looked at all the actions that you can do in the video game and we try to sort of make them into short actions because we knew it would be a long game but we didn't want the downtime between player turns to be uh um too frightening uh we wanted turns to be quick so we tried to distill everything that you can do into shorter actions that are well combined I would say they're complex because there's so many uh of them a couple of them uh do have uh some sort of implications that make them a little bit complicated but mostly each of these actions in their own right it's quite a simple uh thing to perform you're spending one of the three types of Monarch power sometimes a bit of money as well and you move your army one or
two spaces or you you move your Fleet to a certain destination or you uh collect trade from a trade node etc etc so it was trying to make all these um pieces into uh rather simple uh each individual element uh we try to make as simple as possible and I have to say uh of course there was um huge task much bigger than I could have possibly anticipated beforehand I think uh the fact that I knew the game as well as I did was a huge benefit I said obviously uh but more even more so the fact that we through our development diaries that Paul mentioned uh which we did for a year before we did the kickstarter was able to um sort of build uh a crowd build a certain level of expectation uh get some of those people into our Discord server and uh get them involved in the development of the game we put out a tabletop simulator version of the game about three or four months before the kickstarter launched I think it was so we already had a great deal of feedback from uh those fans that got involved at the early stage when we went live on Kickstarter but uh that really took off with a Kickstarter I should say you know uh having more than 4 000 backers uh we that Community
grew uh a lot uh during the course of that Kickstarter and some of those people really got heavily involved in the play testing and uh development of the game and um I I owe them a lot for all the the hours that they put into it I think that comes from the fact that the the original uh intellectual property had such a dedicated fan base uh I think you know the average play time on a game on Steam is like I don't know 15 to 30 minutes per game or something like that and then you look at Europa universalis and you have like 70 hours or something like that on average and and several players have played it for several thousand hours you know uh and some of those players have put down a thousand hours in our tabletop simulator version of the board game as well um because they were so um intent and so invested in making this game the game of their dreams uh the game they wanted it to be um I wouldn't say that it that we've changed our course massively like yeah we've sort of been following the the path that we laid out from the beginning but certainly we've uh we've been able to get so many details
uh way better uh by involving all these people there are some things that Ivan was saying that I wanted to build on um and I think really speak to the strengths of the game uh one would be what he said about Monarch power um particularly in the computer game if you're playing uh a great power as it were um eventually those points uh which are counted on a much larger scale in the computer game they just keep rolling in and you keep doing things with them and that's part of the addictive nature of the game too it is um there's a reason I only uh block out time to play the computer game when I know I'm going to be able to give it all the attention it deserves it's not something I'm going to just step in for 15 minutes right it's going to be hours of my time um but the board game implementation does a really great job of creating more urgency around the Monarch power than I experienced in the computer game you really are trying to manage these cubes that represent power which are not only that power but are also used as influence on the map and for other purposes as well so you only have I believe 30 of these cubes and you have to keep them in Balance you have to decide where your priorities are so it makes every turn uh rather agonizing right you need to think about what you're going to do next very carefully and as I've been said uh they did a
great job I think of keeping the flow of the game going nobody's waiting too long to get to their next turn you might be anxious for that turn but it's going to come your way pretty fast and I think for such a long game potentially if you're going to play the full campaign it nonetheless moves at a very quick Pace once you're actually playing it I think that's a really incredible achievement on the design level I also want to say as far as learning curve because you mentioned how heavy the game is and yes to a certain degree it is going to be heavy much as the the computer game is but I have also found and what really drew me to back the game finally the game has so many scenarios so many opportunities to play Not only different Realms uh throughout the map but also to play smaller scenarios with smaller Powers so if you want to learn the game gradually because you're coming at it with no experience of the computer game there's some really nice kind of self-contained scenarios there that do not overwhelm you the way the grand campaign does I've lost track of how many scenarios there actually are with the game they're quite a few and there are a lot of fan based scenarios that are being written and that's been intriguing to me I mean I want to play all of those not just the grand campaign I'm just the sort who would dive into that campaign by nature and what Ivan said about historical contingency right the mission tree for each realm in the
computer game is an important part of the game as it is in the board game but in both cases you can diverge from that mission tree and do other things it is still a sandbox and at the end of the day you're going to take your realm where you want to try to take it may not succeed but you can try so I like the decision space in the game it is not uh railroading you into anything it is a simulation of sorts but it also allows you to diverge from the historical record in the campaign we're playing right now I'm the Holy Roman Empire I've started out with a major diplomatic push trying to consolidate the Empire get back some Wayward provinces that have left it and shouldn't have and I'm trying to avoid outright conflict and so far I've been doing very well but one reason I'm doing very well is the Protestant Reformation has been late so it's right around the corner and I know it's going to be my biggest headache in the game but I've had this space this opportunity uh to grow my power without that headache and so the game can roll out in ways that are consistent with the history but don't roll out precisely the same the timing of what happens can also be very different oh that's really interesting yeah no I just want to say uh yeah the timing of the the events is uh is always going to be around the time where they happen
uh sort of uh in real life uh but it both depends on the players uh because there's some agency and where when those events get played uh you have a say in that uh but there's also uh you don't know if it's gonna come out uh at the beginning of the round or the end of the round or the next round uh so uh is always going to vary with that you cannot land for every eventuality I think uh for these things so the games even the if you play the same scenario several times it's going to be different from one time to the next uh different both because of players you play presumably with different players with different priorities but also because the events might happen in a bit of a different order um the game the deluxe edition of the game comes with 13 scenarios and and an introduction introductory scenario as well and there have been a number of uh as you say fan-based scenarios already uh published as well and some of these scenarios also are Solo exclusively experiences uh but pretty much every scenario in the game can be soloed some of them are better suited than others I would say and I thought you know you have to be crazy to play it with five Bots and do the grand campaign solo so we we thought
you know two Bots is probably enough for most people to handle that's what we included in the game we soon learned during the kickstarter campaign that people want to play I did it with with five Bots uh so we had to make an add-on with three extra bortex that let you play uh with every every opponent in the game as a bot basically oh that's funny and obviously we put a lot of time into these Bots as well to make them behave in a in a way that feels sort of consistent with the realm that they represent and um and that also feels like you're facing uh a player a bit of a different type of player they're not as easy to get it and do your bidding uh they're less diplomatic than your human players but uh nonetheless they simulate uh quite closely what a human player would do I should say turns should be quicker once you learn the Bots than human players but uh and they they cut some Corners here and there uh you're not that interested in what kind of advisors the bot would have in their government sort of so you skip some of these uh steps that you have for a human player but uh we put a lot of effort into making the solo really solid and we had David turkey on board to um to help us uh get that solo mode uh as Titan and good as we could that was another
reason I took the plunge I initially thought the solo mode might be an afterthought it was not they put a lot of care and effort into designing those Bots it is an investment to learn how to run them especially if you're going to do a larger campaign but I found it really uh pleasurable to run the Bots uh not that difficult once I learned how they work and I think that was another reason I jumped into the game because I'm also a heavy solar solo gamer and that mattered to me a great deal and there's at least one person Ivan I'm forgetting his name he's implemented an online browser uh based program that will actually help you run the Bots yeah yeah uh um I should remember his name I am he's Brazilian as far as I know uh yes my apologies for forgetting um yeah I should have known I probably know him better by his uh Discord uh Alias than his real name uh I can I can definitely find that but uh can't remember off the top of my head uh but yeah he made basically uh uh a browser based I guess uh app which keeps track of uh all the stuff that you do with the Bots and basically it would be a virtual bot deck and also keeping track of the resources you still need to reference the charts uh to to sort of implement those actions on the board but it works very smoothly as far
as I've seen um yeah so yeah there's actually been a lot of fans making all these little neat little uh quality of life improvements uh for the game uh someone recently made an app to show you all the different um key provinces when you're doing trade and the game uh little things like that we're coming out with a new uh tabletop simulator module uh probably next week actually um which uh should improve things a lot which also lets you basically um play any variant of the scenarios uh that come with the game as well so I have a question also by the way please send me the guys information so that we can put this in the show notes for those of you who are curious about this browser base syllabot that's really cool so we've talked a lot about sort of the intricacies of this game and about how historical events happen but maybe in different ways what can someone who is playing Europa universalis learn about European history and what are they going to come away with from playing this game so I think if I can talk first uh a lot to say about this particular topic as well but uh from my side the way I see it is a board game obviously doesn't replace a history book uh um but it in invites you to a different type of learning which I think can be a
very good Aid if you're interested in a subject because making decisions related to the actual historical events that you're trying to learn about makes you remember them in a different way it makes you think about those events in a different way you you go okay so why did I choose it to do it like this and it makes it easier to remember some of these things if you have an experience that you can relate to you have experienced this event in some way it lets you sort of uh put that in some part of your brain which is a bit different from reading a book I think um so I think it can help in that sense but to talk about this game in particular each and every one of the events in the game has some bases in real historical events uh each of the playable Realms in the game of which there there are 17 featured Realms that have their own historical events they have two events for each age of the game so uh for all for uh ages that would be eight events basically dedicated to to that particular realm and we've tried to you know take the most um sort of the biggest events that the most impactful events where where that Nation had to make some type
of choice at least uh and uh and make that into an event that is relevant to the game and most of those events they have a choice of whether to implement an a option or a B option where very often a would be the most historical outcome of the event and B is what could be if they had chosen differently uh and uh quite often there is also a sort of a more aggressive way and a more diplomatic way to to implement the the consequences of those events and I think if you just take the title of the event and and Google it afterwards or go on Wikipedia you most of those events you will be directed to the right place and you'll find uh you you'll be able to read it more in depth of what actually went on also most of these historical events that are Nation specific they have historical rulers on them and that sort of also gives it a sort of time stamp that you can uh go and look at the reign of that particular Monarch what did they achieve in the time uh of them governing I should say that these monarchs they don't necessarily just represent the actual person they actually they represent the legacy of that person the administration of that
person to some degree at least the the part of the administration that was so sort of intrinsic or uh non-separable from from the realm or the monarchy that you can sort of so so that character is more than just the character but having those historical characters I think makes it easier to relate to these events and relate to the the particular age that you're playing so did I um answer your question I'm not sure yeah uh and then Paul like as a professional who's you know students may have played this game and come into your class um what how do you view Europe universalis as perhaps someone's biggest exposure to European history so I do have students who have come to either uh well the computer game and maybe now in the future the board game uh before classes um some of them come to these games after my classes because I mention the games and I encourage them uh to follow up and and to give them a try um to add to what Ivan was saying I think what is to me most instructive about these games to anyone who's interested in history uh whether it's a scholar a student or just the Casual uh student of History um is the fact that it so honors um how over determined any historical phenomenon really is by which we mean right how many different factors are involved in shaping what happened and in shaping the decisions that faced leaders at various points that to me is a huge
takeaway from the experience of both the computer and the board game there's nothing you'll do in it that does not have multiple factors conditioning it and also so there's nothing you'll do that won't have incredibly complex consequences arising from it so everything you think is purely a game for example comes with its own set of new headaches and this is true in both the computer and the board game so if you're Castile for example and you're forming Spain and you're colonizing abroad and developing this massive economic Empire and you have all this gold flowing your way um you now have the problem of administering that Empire which includes the reaction of native peoples on the ground it includes the economic headaches that come with inflation and the unwieldiness of that Empire so everything that seems a no-brainer thing to do sure it's going to benefit you but it's also going to be an incredibly complicated problem you want to take over the papacy okay you can do that but now you have to run the papacy and now you have to sometimes respond to the demands for Crusades or other things relevant to the religious struggle part of the game and so I've always loved how the game uh invites you in invites you to try different things and then to learn the high price you paid to do that thing I mean that's why the uh the
subtitle of the board game the price of power in May to certain people uh sound like oh this is a game all about getting power and just doing everything you want well not exactly because everything you do comes with a price and everything you do reverberates and when you start considering the impact of what you're doing in relation to what everyone else is doing things get even more complicated because they are all facing the same kinds of challenges or in some cases incredibly different challenges um one thing the computer game models and comes out more through events I would say in the board game is the dissolution over time of the feudal structures you know of the clergy the burgers and the aristocracy and the balance in which those different elements of society uh the balance in which they live or fail to live is complicated and challenged by the development of capitalism and development of of the history that we know from early modernity to something approaching our world and so navigating the different needs of those groups is something that every uh leader in Europa universalis has to learn to do you're often being torn in multiple directions by your own people and that I think comes out in both versions of the game it's just implemented in different ways yeah it's certainly a major feature of the fourth age in particular where sort
of uh the revolutionary ideas come in and sort of rip the ancient rashima part uh and uh and we try to um that's something we want really wanted to do in the computer game it's already there but in the board game we try to to um to make it so that the fourth age is something different from the rest of the game we we didn't want you to just be continuing to doing exactly the same stuff and feeling like it's just uh uh painless uh continuation of uh what you've been doing it doesn't take away everything that you have but you will have these sweeping changes uh that come into the game and to some people will will scare them a bit I think yeah because you lose control a little bit and uh what I the way that I thought about the fourth age is uh you're basically you need to harness the chaos and uh sort of uh try and uh roll with it to some extent and if you do you can let your uh realm sort of descend into chaos and from those ashes comes Napoleon or uh whoever you know and and you sort of uh turn into a something else a bit of a uh Phoenix and we want to add to that as well um the way in which vassalage works in both versions of the game uh and the way
in which annexation is accomplished in most war games right you simply March your troops in you take over end of story this is mine now it doesn't work that way at all in European universalis if you were to invade and Conquer and try to Annex you can do that but it comes at great price diplomatically the rest of the world is now terrified of you and sees you as a threat that needs to be contained uh you also have to what have what is known as a causes bellai a cause of war in order to do most of this aggressive action and getting that is not always as easy as it sounds and even vassalizing other Realms is a long drawn out process and it can require Royal marriages uh the laying of diplomatic influence a host of other Maneuvers that of course your Rivals are going to try to interfere with and and so it's no simple matter to even draw someone into your orbit as an ally or a vassal yeah so this there's this real politic aspect uh of the game and you have it in the computer game as well it depends though if you play multiplayer or solo uh there are certain mechanics in the computer game to represent coalitions and that type of thing uh when you play it solo but uh in the board game it also comes to life obviously in the table talk between players and I think that's really a an important aspect of games like this uh um that part of the balancing is in the
that sort of uh diplomatic uh action that happens not just in the game mechanics but between the players and we sort of try to encourage that with the mechanics that we made in the game we also get want to give space for the players to to give life to this and you know the different types of players uh and I think we cater for different styles as well to some extent with having different scenarios and such but some players will play this really Cutthroat uh other players will sit in their corner and try to build their own little Empire and not interfering too much with each other but it's you know I I am I guess my gaming background I I come from uh gaming groups where we play quite Cutthroat and we've been playing war games and that type of uh stuff uh I wanted this to have uh a more fluent uh or a more flexible sort of uh take on the whole uh war war gaming aspect because we're playing through almost 400 years of History here and no realm was in a state of war with another realm for 400 years but pretty much no realm went through 400 years without being in a state of War either so we wanted Wars to be temporary sort of or uh something you start and finish and after that you there's nothing to prevent you from
being friends again with that player uh and you'll be encouraged by historical events and by your missions and by whoever is in the lead in the game to turn your attention to uh to another place uh the next time you you go to war uh and um yeah I think you should really try to avoid having the sort of one Nemesis throughout the whole Grand campaign because that wouldn't really benefit you neither you or him or uh not the fun of the game either to be honest one of my favorite lines from The Godfather is uh blood is a big expense uh so if you go to war with one another it's going to be very very costly you cannot sustain it uh for too long without ending it uh and that is absolutely the case as Ivan said you you need to be ready to adapt diplomatically to um being peaceful or perhaps even working with uh former enemies and part of the game too is psychological depending on who's around your table um right now as the Holy Roman Empire in my campaign I'm trying to convince everyone that France is the problem and I think objectively I'm right uh but but it doesn't seem that way because I'm in the lead right so if someone's just looking at Prestige they see me as the problem and it really is a matter of that give and take so your personalities uh will cause your mileage to vary as they say yeah that's funny so I have a question so we talked about sort of like the real
politic nature of this right you've got all these marriages they you know in a game there's not a lot of feeling behind all that necessarily uh and one aspect of that that always fascinates me in Paradox games generally like Crusader Kings as well um is the presence of religion and sort of the way that religious homogeneity is treated as a net good for a nation uh and the kind of decisions that go into like picking what religion your realm should be and whether you should convert to different things so like how do you layer such personal well what we view is very personal choices right um there's there are a whole lot of like little Wars of religion issues uh going on in actual Europe um but you know how do you make assumptions about how religion should operate in society for just as one example this is a rich game and and how do you decide how to treat them and the consequences of having particular Creeds um in European universalis clarification uh the quick clarification right your your state religion that you choose to adopt as a leader may be entirely different from what your people seem to want so you may not always be in control of that yeah that's that's the number one thing is religion is not something you're in complete control of uh it lives his own life uh it will depend on how other
players interact with it uh the religion of your neighboring Realms will affect the the religion of your people uh and um it will be affected by um both uh some level of Randomness and the other players agency in this but you also obviously have the possibility of trying to bend the population to your will but to be able to do this you need to have a certain level of control uh and it's gonna cost you resources that could be spent on other things so in if you're playing the grand campaign and starting in 1444 most Realms will be Catholic here because there is no protestantism at that time the big exception being the major power uh of the Ottomans who's obviously a Muslim Realm so first of all that that prevents the Ottomans basically from entering into Royal marriages with uh the other players uh so they like in here I stand they they're a bit of a different beast and they're uh they're also I guess wanna together with France the ones that are usually sort of heavily focused on the military side uh of the game France can go other
directions as well the Ottomans very often go on that militaristic expansion and in that time period you know they they were the threat of uh that that made people shaking their pants all over Europe uh they sieged Vienna twice in this time period which is quite extraordinary when you think how far it is from Vienna to uh to um Istanbul several religious conflicts in the game uh and uh and you started as Catholic but there are these events in the game that will make protestantism uh appear uh in the second age of the game which is also called the age of reformation because that's the big sort of thing uh that went on and the Protestant religion has this uh infectious uh quality that makes it sort of spread like a wildfire uh and uh it's hard to prevent that from affecting you at all it will historically like in history usually start to spring up in Germany or in the northern part of Europe but it could also spread southwards and I've seen Catholic uh Italy turn into Protestant Italy yeah you know so it could happen but it's more likely to affect the Realms that were historically affected by and suddenly if all of your realm has another religion that what your state
religion is uh they're gonna feel less uh content with their Catholic Monarch yeah uh ruling over them so you'll see unrest popping up uh in your realm so you get this motivation to change your state religion if you cannot sort of curb the or control the religion of you population um so I guess it's it's not a personal choice as much as it is a choice that's uh that has to do with the the actual um situation in the game how political of you no kidding I think it's I mean it makes sense though if you look at actually you know at actual history right I mean religion is never a fully personal choice if you're also Harris is worth a mass as uh King of France and when he switched from protestantism to Catholic Catholicism Paul how do you feel about all this you know as from your position as a historian so I think you raised an interesting question that um is a gateway to other questions and I'm sure Ivan and the whole you know EU Community has been wrestling with for as long as the game has been around so the first order question right uh the game in a sense Privileges and alignment of your religion as a state religion with the
people's religion right so homogeneity in faith is generally speaking going to be better for you right as the leader of the realm and so that raises questions about whether diversity of Faith or diversity of any other kind right is in fact a greater strength and the game doesn't necessarily model it that way um I guess the larger uh kind of question that Springs from that and to be clear my answer to these questions has never uh prevented me from loving this game or playing it in any of its forms right but the eurocentric kind of focus of the game is something that that people have been talking about you know forever um I remember a number of people from the development team in the computer game being at a conference I extended and they were on a panel basically talking through those issues one thing the computer game can do um is you can go anywhere on the planet you can play any realm there is so it doesn't need to be a eurocentric game uh if you don't want it to be you can play in Asia you can play in the Americas wherever you wish but the board game is certainly designed in its first iteration at least to have that focus on Europe because that's the bulk of the map Western and Eastern Europe and everywhere else in the world is a bit more abstracted into what are called distant areas where there will be you know various efforts to explore colonize
Etc and Ivan was just corresponding with me I think yesterday uh on this question because I had asked you know at some point would you consider developing uh another map that would in a sense blow up uh the so-called distant areas and to give them their nuances and their specificity um and Ivan's response and he can elaborate right uh was that that might entail an entirely new game right that would put the focus on those other parts of the world and whether it would be called EU or not I don't know but I think it's a fascinating question it's the question that people have been wrestling with as long as the game has been around but I think for the most part the designers certainly both the computer and the board game have been wrestling with those questions honorably I would say they are not easy questions so I didn't mean to to blow up from religion to yeah oh no that's actually you know I never asked just a question Paul it's okay well enough I'm quite happy for you to go into that you know and uh it is uh certainly a eurocentric game it sort of comes from the title as well that we can sort of just we couldn't start by doing Asia universalis uh the reason why we sort of have abstracted down or uh some other level of detail um for the rest of the world is simply that there is so much you know and uh
even though you have playability at some level yeah you want to keep it playable yeah so so I want to say that first of all one of the stronger ideas that you can develop in the game is tolerance so uh develop tolerance and you'll be uh more accepting of different religions uh in your realm and so that's one way but you'll have parts of your uh sort of realm in some of the events that resist that tolerance because uh that wasn't always the most popular choice to make uh among the majority of uh of the population um so we you know we're trying to portray uh history from a sort of uh we're not we're not passing a judgment uh we say we try to sort of uh simulate in a way that feels like it this was close to what actually happened or could have happened this way uh we don't we don't want to go back into 1444 and say now you need to play this realm in the 1500s with the morals of the 20th century uh person uh or 21st century person because that would just not produce a result that reflects how history actually evolved and it would not I think it's more useful that you actually get to learn something about what the motivations back then might have been uh why things developed the way they did
so so that's one part of it um I write a little bit about it in the in my introduction to the game in the in the rule book um so uh so we don't want to condone the imperialistic um nature of uh Europe at the time but that was part and parcel of how politics evolved in that time period and you cannot sort of get around it without uh and completely rewriting history and you wouldn't learn much about actual history if you did it that way I think when it comes to the rest of the world I would be very interested in making a game that's focused on a different part of the world uh around some of the same mechanics but to to give it sort of uh uh to treat it respectfully and uh and uh justify uh the choices made yeah I think we would have to adapt some of the core mechanics of the game to to the different sort of uh cultural situation that you have in other parts of the world because Asia was very different from Europe you know uh Europe came out although Europe is not homogeneous it it comes from most of the countries in Europe comes from these
sort of um feudal societies and uh and there were certain ideals that they shared and and you can base some of the mechanics of on that sort of thinking whereas uh for China or Japan there will be different sort of priorities that would also affect the mechanics of the game and that's why I think if you're doing Asia uh I don't know what you would call it you would not call Europa Universalist but you could sort of call it something a Europa universalis uh a game in the Europa Universal series or something like that maybe uh but it would be a long development process basically to to uh to do that Justice uh because you would need to research the history of each and every one of those Realms they want to be portraying can I build on that for a second um the this is one way in which the computer game franchise is understandably right ahead of the board game because the board game is in many ways in its infancy right and I could see an expansion of the board game to do some of the things the computer game has managed to do on this subject namely the DLC expansions for uh European universalis the computer game many of them are focused on entirely different areas of the world entirely different cultural paradigms religious challenges technological challenges so there are DLCs for uh Ming China there are DLCs
for India um so the board game can't possibly have caught up to all that yet but that cultural Nuance that specificity does come out in the computer game once you add those expansions I will also say that at least in its current form um Spanish Conquest in the new world just to take an example you have to think carefully about your response to the people who are already there and it does not have to be a brutal and aggressive response you can take a collaborative approach to the people of the so-called new world right the Americas you can uh have some ethical considerations actually in how you uh work with them as opposed to Simply conquer them and this is not entirely a historical in the sense that there were thoughtful theologians and Scholars and even some leaders here and there who had real concerns about what was happening uh in the so-called new world and expressed in very eloquent terms their opposition to that on a very human uh and I would say also Christian level so that in a way has slowly made its way into the computer game experience I think there is a sense of ethical dilemma in the game you may at the end of the day not behave very ethically but you will be confronted with those ethical choices and I think maybe the board game just isn't quite there yet right it hasn't
expanded enough to to factor that in it doesn't have that level of detail uh right when it comes to Colonial expansion and you cannot necessarily see all the ethical considerations uh behind each of the decisions that you make either it doesn't necessarily you know you don't have the option to to perform a genocide either you know but there is something you know that there's something going on in sort of background here that you don't exactly see what what goes on it's much more abstracted in the board game it's more abstracted yeah but um but yeah there is an interaction which is bigger in the computer game there is some some of it in the video no in the board game as well and you will you will see this colonial uprisings happening and you will also see at one point uh Nations uh liberating themselves from European uh control in the new world so um but that's definitely something that we could go deeper into with the uh you know with another expansion or a new game uh based on the sort of same system and I I could also see you know if we make a game for uh for the Americas or if you make a game for Asia uh that you could you could make it so that the ones that really want the whole world with the same level of detail uh
probably combining those games into one but uh that that makes an already a massive Beast even more so so I I think it would have to stand on its own feet uh and that that would be the main priority so yeah and and with with making a game for uh with more more detail for the colonial uh uh for for the um colonization for the Nations of America you will see these ethical considerations come more into play and and that also would require us to tread more carefully because okay because then you would make more direct decisions relating to all these issues I would be very excited to see how that would work personally we'll see you one day yeah I I don't think it's going to be the first expansion that we make you know sort of after a process of making a game like this which is taking four plus years you know it's you're a bit like okay um can we do something a little bit easier so uh first expansion uh we make is probably gonna be giving some more depth to to what we already have so giving uh giving the
players the ability to play uh more of the Realms that already are in the game uh more historical events more flexibility more scenarios within that part of the world which we already have um and then we're also thinking about um making um a sort of uh let's say stepping stone uh a game where um which is clearly based on the same concept but a bit stripped down version uh which is going to be a two-player dual game uh most likely so we're working on developing that uh which will sort of uh give people a way into this gaming Universe hopefully and we're the more focus on a little bit of that tactical maneuvering that you will get in two-player game uh and um with uh shorter scenarios so one that you can play if you're just two people but want to have some of that feeling from the European Solace universe but maybe you don't have six hours to put down for your play session what you don't have six hours no kidding uh speaking of we have spent about an hour together and I don't want to take up too much more of y'all's time but I do want to kind of do some wrap-up
questions so it sounds like Evan you've got some plans coming ahead uh Paul do you have any final thoughts on Europa Universal Australia things before we just talk about what we're playing right now uh well I would just say I'm really thrilled to hear that expansions are in the works and it sounds like um maybe missions and events that are specific to some of the other Realms and even some of the smaller Realms uh seems like a great thing to add to an already great game I mean this this game has so won over my group which is not easy to win over all the time they're old school heavy Gamers and wargamers but boy they have taken to this game and I could see it being a regular in our rotation uh for years to come that's cool yeah yeah really happy that we are actually able to catch some of those uh players as well you know uh I think the game sort of um falls into our category which is not that easy to pitch and hold maybe it's not really a traditional war game it's not really a Euro it has elements from both uh those types of games um so it's it's a sort of hybrid but I think we've been able to carve out sort of uh Niche for ourselves and uh we're hoping to be able to continue to deliver content that people will want and the two I have in the group who have never played the computer game uh of
course now they're really thinking seriously about getting into it they're also worrying about getting into it because they know how many hours they are going to spend playing that as well I am after becoming a father uh of two I sort of had to scale down a little bit or not because it's a type of game where you you sit down to play for an hour at nine o'clock in the evening and suddenly it's four o'clock in the morning and that doesn't really work yeah I've been there sorry yeah amazing also we are also signed up to do another Paradox uh game uh soon um and uh that's going to be Victoria oh okay great so that's that's another game that I'm really excited to get started can the start point of Victoria link to the endpoint of Europa universalis says is true with the computer games there is a little bit of a gap there in the computer game where there's 15 years between the official end of year four and the beginning of Victoria I I do think that we need to focus on making Victoria a game and it's on right first sure and and then I'm certain that someone will find out someone will do it uh uh bridging that Gap but the way I see it it's um Victoria has some things that are really different from uh from European results is more of a game of the social developments of the development of
ideologies and and also the development of Industry so it's more of an economical uh engine so has to have a bigger focus on the internal Machinery of uh realm and less of the sort of not tape not painting aspect of um nice so when you aren't spending hours and hours in hours on this particular set of chunky board games what are y'all playing for fun yeah I'm happy to play any kind of game really that type of gaming that got me into gaming was role-playing games that's been a while since I did uh now but we're we're looking at publishing a role-playing game for the Norwegian market so some might get into that again as well so all types of gaming really we had one of uh Rainey canitzia's colleagues visiting our office last week yeah and most of his games are obviously more of a more more of that zeroe mechanics uh more streamlined so but I I do enjoy games that have a certain level of player interaction uh I think it becomes much more interesting yeah when you actually play together and not sit there with just your own little puzzle uh I I enjoy the Clashing of mines
nice Paul I know one thing we're playing for fun yes we're playing uh online Republic of Rome that old Avalon Hill classic um a game that like Europa universalis um actually encourages a fair bit of role-playing too right because you get very drawn into the mindset of the group you're playing um the other games I'm playing right now um both are very different than European rivers house but both are very chunky in their own way in the best sense one is hegemony which was just released uh the game about class Warfare which alongside European universalis these are my two favorite games this year that I've encountered and I will find it hard to find others that will be these two um the other one I'm playing is Scarface 1920. uh which is a decidedly interesting and social game about gangsterism in Chicago in the 20s where attacking people much like in Europe you're universalis attacking people uh willy-nilly is not the way to go you need to actually be a little bit diplomatic with respect to the other gangs and it's as much an economic game as it is what you would think a game about gangsters would be yeah yeah we do enjoy playing brass here at the office that's another game uh we're into I just got Brian baru excited to try that game and we're also getting hegemony because we're exchanging games with the hegemony guys at UK games Expo
so uh that sounds like a nice pairing of games yeah so I I will not be at the UK games Expo this year but my team is going there so Victor and Kali from our team is going to be there so hopefully we'll meet some of the listeners there at that convention and then um if I'm being convinced convention found online for the curious uh well we're at agargames.com that's a e g i r games.com uh that's our website it's uh gonna get a faceless soon hopefully but you can find us there uh contact us there but we're also active on Board Game Geek uh contact us through the forums on boarding geek and we'll try to get back to you since we can and we also have a very active Discord server and I would say me and Victor we're in that server every day to uh reply to um to our community who's become a really uh um tight-knit uh Community but also a very very welcoming Community I think the tone is very friendly on our server and if you want to dip your toes into the water you can go on that server I'm sure you'll find something that are happy to teach you the game uh on tabletop similar hopefully soon we'll also have a vassal module for the game but at the moment you'll have to live with tabletop similar for for all the goods and bads
of that uh I put this in the chat I didn't want to be remiss and not mentioning the person who developed the app we were talking about the solo bot assistant that's Raphael Oliveira you can find him on BGG I also recommend for anyone dealing with the learning curve of EU um the boards on BGG are excellent and Roberto and Aaron in particular are are always there to answer a question which I've found incredibly helpful and if you want to reach me I'm at paul.r.rite at villanova.edu and happy to talk to anyone about anything gaming related fantastic gentlemen thank you thank you so much for coming on the show and having this lovely conversation about this game I'm actually thinking about using some of my summer school money to get a gaming PC and this is like confirmed I think that decision for me um rip the rest of my summer we'll see you in five months Liz when you get one with an anti-glare screen so you can bring it outside yeah I can touch grass and play a game at the same time um it's been great being on your show uh thank you for inviting us uh yes thank you so much yeah absolutely and for those of you out there I can be found anywhere online is beyond Solitaire so please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming
foreign