Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 21:25

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for five minute mystery which is a sequel to five minute dungeon which uh we've actually done a run through on the channel for uh when this game was announced i was like well that sounds weird uh like a premise i'm like how are they gonna make that work and with the hype of five minute dungeon being so good uh and then of course they made their curses expansion i was like well i'll back it i mean it was relatively cheap and uh oh my god is this game great like i think this is so much fun and uh the i would have never thought of this idea right live very unique um just the the plethora of scenes and all you're doing is matching the scenes or matching the symbols five symbols and then you're just like boom and checking and then you just grab an item and match it to a culprit it's the most simplest thing but it's so fun right you're invested the entire time uh similar to five minute dungeon where you are invested the entire time there's no i don't feel like there's like a lull here at all because i think the rule where you have to pass the codex is that reason it's one of the biggest reasons because it's not one person just constantly fiddling with something right everyone gets a chance to kind of do it uh and that also plays into the difficulty of the game because you're like okay yeah i'm moving it i'm moving it and then okay he has a newspaper then

everyone's looking but you have to pass it on it's like [ __ ] do both move them and do both uh what do you guys think of five minute dungeon oh i love it all right i guess what i said yeah i love this one more really yeah i do yeah i just think it's i don't know i it's just it's cuter i love the animals um i like that we're just matching um i mean we're always simple matching either way just in a different way um but i like this way better yeah i just love the animals i feel like with this one uh to tie into what you were saying i feel like this one everyone is engaged yeah like the entire time with five minute dungeon it's like there's there's usually that sense of if you're not fast enough you're not really getting to play right you know it's like oh we need three triangles or what we need free trials

uh and it just clicks with all of us i i like that but yeah with five minute dungeon don't be wrong i love that too but it's like oh we need three arrows boom got em okay we need uh running man got it got it someone could just always have the answer and everyone's like i'd like to help kill things too and then you you find you run into this situation where it's like uh okay we need you know a running man a sword and a shield and no one has it and it's like what do we do it's like a screeching halt this game doesn't have because that one's a little more class heavy it's like well you know that if you have a lot of swords like but you're uh throwing away all your swords early and you know that like because you're gonna play that game a lot you know what's coming up and you know the final boss has like a [ __ ] ton of swords and they're all in your discard pile because you played them early right so right that game is definitely a more gamers game in in the context of comparing the two this is not i feel like this is very more family friendly that everyone can be involved this is i mean i wouldn't play five-minute dungeon with a child uh but this one i feel like you could because it's literally hey hey you know kid look at the look at the symbol some kid hey come on come over here uh devin what do you think what do i think i'm sorry this is fun it is it's super quick fast-paced kind of what you want definitely unique um you know i don't like the neck craning you know you only get the one card that's a that's yeah a big negative for me yeah i'm like i can see like say two player one personally the

codex one person handling the card that'd be a lot better but it's like you have a big table you definitely need a smaller play area for this one that is true um i that's a good point yeah yeah that's definitely like right yes tiny card i mean i know they sized him up pretty good i mean it's still fun but it is kind of a nickel for me yeah because it's also just kind of awkward like looking at it from this angle because you're like oh geez like yeah they're not already a mess right like they made the card super atmospheric it's almost like an eye spy those old i spy books that's kind of what it feels like so not all of the symbols are obvious um and if some of them might actually be part of the decor or bush was actually the square right and and i i agree with you while i think three i would never play this with four i would play five minute dungeon at any player oh no i'd actually five minute dungeon if you want to play with four here i think the less the better um for that very reason because with two people yeah one person can do the codex or uh or it's just kind of it's two people having to kind of look instead of three and you can be side by side and and looking at it at the same way oh yeah like if it was like right here yeah that's true um but at the same time i will say at least with three it never felt like we were kind of stepping on each other's toes we all like okay someone found the circle someone found the triangle i found the square and then we all and it's super quick you you go through a lot more scenes with more people

than with just the two um so it's a double-edged sword you have one central that everyone kind of has to get get out of my way uh so we were getting really close to each other um but yeah i mean i don't even know what that shot there was probably garbage the whole time but i i love these and what's really smart because whenever cat and i first played this i was like i didn't know that they made duplicates of the same picture oh yeah and i was like what's stopping someone from just memorizing oh hey i know this one we've seen this the circle on the square before but then you come to another one and you're looking for like wait a minute where is it we had one right in the row where you're like wait did i not discard this yeah and it's like oh [ __ ] it's just different yeah um but they're not these are challenging but not too challenging right but there are some where you're like where is the square like we are not seeing it all right there was one where we ran out of time and we were just like no we're finding we're we're i'm lost i have no idea where it's at and it was like yeah on the side of a bookshop uh what's fantastic is the the way you find the culprit i think them giving out these suspect cards to each like you hand out an even number of suspect cards and it's just okay let's match you know that oh he has a hat we know for like it's just it's so clean they don't have to make this big bombast again with a lot of cards and a lot of tokens there's so many culprits here

that even if you even if you did the same culprit each time the fact the way the items are going to come out are going to change you know how you're looking it's like okay so oh he has a hat okay well and and who you have and it's like oh i have everyone with a hat yeah it's simple enough to also um just like swab your hands with another player if it's getting stale yeah because now all of a sudden you're saying okay i'm looking for a fresh fresh set of eyes got new people right the timer is fantastic like i think the case is like the the other one they actually had like different voices and they had that big and but whole eyes guys yeah they they actually got someone who had a you know a voice uh recognizable voice i like the walrus though he's funny they they made it they made it cute they made it uh very atmospheric um and what do you guys think of the cases having individual times meaning some of them have six minutes some of them have nine minutes some of them have three minutes it's called five minute dungeon it's called five minute mystery breaking and that's why i'm giving the game a one yeah that's fair well i mean name recognition yeah right same company right i think it's fine it's not like dollar general where things are sometimes a dollar this is generally five minutes um so we played on rookie which was three easy cases and two medium uh they have two others they have a hard

and they have a oh what they call it master mastermind uh which let's take a good ol gander at some of the hard ones so they have a lot of cases too uh where you can just oh you have some time to fill what are you gonna say oh and i i saw the rules how they had the red herring tiles yeah so then now they're just cluttered yeah so it's and what's cool is it's just one of each so it doesn't bog it down but if you draw it it just oh and it's a literal red herring but yeah it just means oh that we didn't find anything for that uh and with time being so crucial that it that sucks uh let's see so there are uh you have one two three like how the cases are really unique they are one person and right i find two people oh yeah this time you get two clues this time yeah this time i would take your suspects put them in a stack uh kat and i have done one where we had to catch two culprits uh the other time we played it's hard finding two culprits cause it's basically like okay now i wonder you know we didn't do you know dumb we are why didn't we take one item and try and match them to both culprits we never did that we only took an item and we're like oh this is the one culprit we never tried to see if it matched with the other one i guess we probably didn't think that we were allowed to do you i don't see why not we have two culprits uh tell me once you get in that moment you're not thinking you're doing yeah so there's six easy ones

six seven eight nine nine uh medium two three four five hard ones and four uh mastermind so one of the hard ones is the sleepy walrus seven minutes players cannot talk or look at the reference cards the player with the codex cards which i think is this one oh yeah and uh the player with the codex can not look at the scene cards oh that's gonna be good that really had to sharpen our description right or just really get our code words down super plus whenever you guys play in half battery i'm like i'm lost plus mine is better you know plus minus that fair enough that's and you just have to catch one culprit uh one of the mastermind ones is called the sad walrus place all the suspects in one face down deck when you solve a scene instead of taking a clue take three suspects and examine one unused culprit catch one culprit damn wow yeah so and some of these i think the mastermind only came if you had if you got the specific kickstarter off i don't think the mastermind come with it it's only a mess oh this is a kickstarter yeah oh well yeah this is the one that doesn't reek okay uh yeah so and you can i mean you can mix and match you can honestly just shuffle this deck and then just grab five random ones but rookie has two easy two medium one hard detective one

easy two medium two hard and master is zero easy two medium two hard one mastermind so it's always five cards which i just feel like is super is manageable and fun because the the just the variation would make this game just a blast uh and then of course they add uh they had purple cards so if you want to play with five or six i can't imagine playing with five or six people like you mentioned with the yeah with the with the cards overwhelming yeah because everyone wants to look at it yeah it's kind of like playing the sherlock holmes or detective games everyone wants to like be involved but it's like that's not like so one person really should just like have the and then explain it to the one person with the codex but then everyone else just has a deck of suspect cards everyone's just kind of listening to that moment um yeah i mean other than that so they have a bunch of different ways for this game to have variation um i feel like i'm talking the the whole time well i mean yeah i mean i mean that's the thing with a five minute game not not a whole a whole lot to cover other than i really like it you can play it solo one thing when kat and i played the skin was making me frustrated because i'm like is this skin or is it scales do sharks have scales or skin well shark skin so i'm like okay but then re-looking through the rule book this time it they put the suspect backgrounds clarify they like the scales matched like like the the skin it matches that

so you can easily i didn't even notice that i didn't know which obviously we didn't but um but looking through it again i thought that that was uh that's a very nice addition i think this game is great yes i i very much enjoy it i'm assuming you like five-minute dungeon better i well i mean this is right up there yeah they're right in the same line i just think i mean i might like playing that one a bit more but at the same time it is kind of frustrating and it's so card heavy like it's set up and deconstructions

and you're like worried that's like the cards are just gonna get destroyed and also this would be a lot easier for most people to pick up right yeah i was thinking i was like this is a game that like i i would honestly bring this to my co-workers and be like this this is something that we could play as a group like this yeah yeah um it i mean it does play up to five so i wish there was oh no i think it plays up to six yeah the the mastermind uh let's see red hair and clues now of course i can't find it i think it's in setup um but yeah if you add in the the purple yeah five five or six players i just can't really see playing this with six like yeah it would you would have to kind of bend the rules maybe and be like okay someone's gotta hold on to the dial right maybe you can team it where it's like if you're playing with say four or six it's like okay us three or us two we do the codex and you guys do the the suspect cards and you kind of team it up that way maybe two people are like looking that way you have yeah two brains you assign roles okay okay us two we do the codex so we'll swap back and forth you guys swap the scenes back and forth uh and then you two of playing with six you do the items yeah that way it's not like six people just yelling yeah because there's only five there's only five it's like that's just way too much yeah so one person finds one it's a little unfortunate that they didn't manage the player count that well the lower player count like two or three

i think three max is good whereas five minute dungeon uh almost any player count but just consistently i consistently i've always done four um and four gets pretty fun but yeah it is very card heavy and you're just like constantly just got it boom and you never really get to look at the art at least here you get to appreciate the characters and stuff but you're just like oh boom got it boom got it boom and then you never really get to enjoy it but they're both great uh but i'm with cat i like this one uh quite a bit more especially because i like the mystery themes right yes yeah this couldn't have come out at a better time i remember uh the first night we played this i was like i'm just smitten i think it's great it's so unique i can't wait to tell you my radio never would have never would have thought of a way to do this um so i'm curious to see oh yeah that is one thing i do want to say real quick is the mechanics behind this and like because it's essentially also a portion of like uh the old game guess who which is is a very impressive puzzle um any anyone who can put together a puzzle impresses me in general right but like the whole it's like how do we make sure that nothing overlaps it's like how do we not accidentally it's like how to you know like oh [ __ ] they're actually both wearing hats we missed it right it ruined someone's that is kind of a slight negative for me is the items and things aren't a hundred percent clear it's like oh he has a necklace i don't consider that a necklace

um i i get that i understand but i mean that's a very slight negative so i don't really care oh there was also one where um the art design wasn't very uh prominent in her purse blended into her uh who was that that was a bird it was a bird i don't think so that was a problem abigail abigail see if you can find her purse real quick if you're not looking for it like or it's really oh that's a sneaky burst yeah it was very sneaky because i omitted it i was like no she doesn't have a purse again in the moment if it doesn't totally pop it's kind of yeah it's kind of sneaky like his like his bag is um you know teal against orange orange you can tell yeah uh but i do see marie the lovecraft octopus is of course my favorite second cat actually has the octopus that was just normal it's like oh my god you killed her through cards you're freezing he's got a purse too i'm always freezing okay oh and this uh this chameleon is licking your eye they just have characteristics and if i think conor reed did both i'm 100 sure he did both i am very excited to see if he does more i think this five-minute stick could go for probably not a bunch of different themes but i think he could probably pull one or two more different kind of five-minute mechanics out yeah i mean this this one was crazy maybe like a two-player five-minute war or something

four player five minute war uh but yeah with with seeing five minute dungeon uh and the symbol you know the symbols of that one being a hit and this one being so unique i am i'm intrigued to see if there's gonna be any other types of five-minute games yeah they come out yeah five-minute buck bug how my hands up go to jail cat all right so uh scale of one to ten devin oh i mean it was well put together really unique premise yeah i am i'm right there with you uh i'm gonna give it a nine as well uh yeah yeah and i'm pretty sure that it uh wasn't expensive either um and the the codex is relatively well put together right that's a that's a nice little uh deal there so it's it's i like i like 3d things and stuff like this so while uh i'm gonna look up how much it was but kat go ahead and give it your score do it and i'm giving it a 10. i knew that i love this i think this is great fantastic five minute mystery man van hoot and maurice i think are my top two top two faves love them suspicious owl and a blind rat i paid 50 bucks total worth every penny yep and i was with shipping and i will say like the insert looks very nice the box looks very nice the arts fun they put love into it and you can tell too much um yeah there's yeah so nines two nines and the ten i

knew you're going to give it a ten there was no way you weren't um but however the standard edition actually has a better cover yeah the mastermind edition is this the standard edition is that it actually it actually shows the museum with the fox above it i kind of like that one way better than this one's simplistic that's the mcguffin in his hands oh you know i bet it is too maybe uh but anyway uh that's our thoughts on five minute mystery let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved