Champions of Midgard Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to chairman of the board today I'm talking about champions of Midgard which is a 2 to 4 player worker placement game which takes about an hour to an hour and a half to play now the game is a pretty kind of stand out work placement game in respects to how it's been received it's very highly rated on BoardGameGeek I think it's in the top 100 and it very much fits that kind of gateway game kind of niche where another kind of relatively similar game Lords of Waterdeep fits in a lot of people regard this one as kind of a Lords of Waterdeep killer I'll share my views on that in a bit but the theme here is very very different to Lords of Waterdeep that one's very much Dungeons & Dragons themed game this one is a kind of Viking themes game and the kind of twist on it is instead of collecting your normal wood stone gold or that kind of stuff in building buildings this one you are collecting food and wood but you're also cutting different warriors and those warriors are represented by dice you've got three different colored dice you've got white dice you've got red dice and you've got black dice and they kind of range in they're kind of what they kind of specialize and you've got white dice which are a little bit more defensive red dice which fit more well-rounded and black dice which are a bit more aggressive and you're going to use those dice to go basically setting them off and fight different monsters so you can either fight like these reoccurring monsters that appear at the top of the board and there is a bit more predictable now you've got a troll for example that you fight and you know if you if you fight and defeat the troll
you can give like a negative token to someone else and they kind of accumulate throughout the game and give negative points to other players likewise I think if you all fail to defeat this trial that everybody gets one of these negative tokens so a bit of a kind of communal kind of objective there to worry about throughout the game all the different monsters will have a very simple set collection mechanism where you've got three different kind of colors and for each set of those colors you've got you get an additional few points there's your standard kind of objectives that you gotta throw at the game like secret missions and you can accumulate more of those but more endgame scoring but the kind of main focus of the game is this kind of idea that you're going to fill these ships off and send them off to the sea and fight these more powerful monsters out on the sea so to do that basically you have these different boats and those boats have different capacities say for example and one of the boats already on the board I have a five capacity that means you can put any five resources on those so you could put so for example three die on there or three dice on there and maybe two food because when you send these dice off they need a number of food to feed them on their voyage so it's quite thematic in that respect so yeah you've got a feed them as you're saying but sending them off but also when you're not only sending off to fight these monsters on the way there may be some kind of obstacle in the way for example you might encounter like a Kraken which can really affect your resources because it's another fight you maybe haven't prepared for or it might say I'll get rid of one your food or get rid of I think you can get
rid of wood or dice and stuff like that so um yeah you've got to kind of plan for contingencies throughout the game and that is an aspect that I'm a bit mixed on and with these kind of Euro is it it's very euro and America she can kind of splice together in this game you know in this mechanisms it's very very Euro II in terms of its worker placement but that that fighting the monsters because you fight the monsters using dice rolls as I said you roll in those dice you're trying to match a certain attack point value to kill the monsters and they'll fight you back and kill a number of your dice in return and those monsters are what give you your um maybe your victory points it gives you coins it gives you more mitigation tools in form of these kind of horns that let you reroll dice and those those if you don't spend them they're worth points at the end of the game but yeah that that is kind of what makes this game different to other games it's that kind of splice between those two different genres of games you've got the e as I said the the euro II kind of resource management the Euro II worker placement and the dice rolling combat of the American genre of games and as I said that is where I really kind of I'm a bit jarred on this one because I really like you know I love euro games that's where I really kind of the point that I really enjoyed this hobby I like being able to planner like me in to strategize accurately and this does really take that out the John robic it all out of the game because you know luck is a quite a
strong factor yes you've got mr. gating factors you can overcompensate by taking more and more resources on these trips just to make sure you've really got enough to do it and also you've got like the horns of stuff as I mentioned which that you re-roll dice and stuff like that so you can kind of put more contingencies in place more mitigation in place but at the same time you know you might just be absolutely battered by bad luck and someone else might just constantly keep getting points in and once you fall behind is quite hard to recuperate that because I said you you've literally just completely pissed those dice away if it doesn't go your way and you could have spent quite a few times accumulating them now that's something that really doesn't add no it just doesn't sit well for me it gives me a bit of anxiety in terms of planning things out or what's always overcompensate for going things and I don't know yeah it's just like a personal thing that I don't kind of get along with now that being said I can really see the appeal why some players would like this that kind of risk on how much you're going to take are you gonna have enough can I can I kind of get away with taking less than I really ought to and maybe go on a couple of boat trips and stuff like that you can also buy your own personal issue boats that nobody else can kind of grab off you so there's a really lot of cool things that go on in this and I love the idea of having to feed your people on the voyages and I just would have really liked that factor to be more kind of cut and dry now that being said I think the there is an expansion to this one which does mitigate that kind of risk a lot more because if you lose died in battle
they kind of build up up over something else now that because I've never played with that expansion boat it's some kind of eager to do because I think it could increase my kind of view on the game quite a bit but yeah that is where the game kind of sits on its you know stands out from the rest of the crowd is the is the dice rolling aspect to it and the way those dice are used I think the the theme or the way the whole theme wraps together is really really well done I mean that I said this is the concept of it's cool it's just not that boring kind of collect collect collect build click because although it is that it's very different in respect that you're building your kind of warrior force and send I'm off to see to fight which is just a better twist on things isn't it yes I do like that I love the theme I love the look of the game it looks really really good I mean the boats you've got different variability in different cards to come out you've got the dice are really nice and that personal dice you know little custom for the game there you know that they've got left all the different kind of weapons on them the card art works really cool we got lots of creative different monsters again I can really see why this game is so popular but for me it's that kind of that luck factor that risk factor that doesn't quite sit well for me and it could obviously skew things off in terms of the game's balance the said the the mechanisms on the staff are very smooth it flows very nicely uptime is really good there's there's eight rounds in the game and those do really
fly by it doesn't outstay its welcome whatsoever which are all things I really have considered and you know I do give the game props for that so as I said I think it really is a kind of a personal thing well I like to be more meticulous in my planning and be more accurate in my planning and this game doesn't really allow that to to the to the point that I really you know enjoy I said yeah the interaction between the players is okay I mean some of those positions are quite fiercely sought after especially collecting dice and some of that I mean the dice to accumulate the more people don't take them but you'll find that everybody does take them each turn there's this good kind of competition in terms of getting on those boats and buying new boats for yourself and getting the monsters that you want because the monsters do build up resources as you as you don't fight them so you know if every round that you don't fight a bad guy they accumulate a coin and the coins can be used for a lots of different things yeah so there's there's a lot going on in the game and as I said the the the kind of lucrative miss of the different places is quite it's quite good it comes through very well I don't like the the troll when you fight the troll everyone as I said you can give negative tokens to other players and that just kind of has a bash the leader kind of effect or it can kind of lead to more metagaming where you know if you don't want someone particular to win you just keep giving these negative tokens which can really hurt them at the end of the game said replayability pretty good
because you've got the different monsters you've got the different setups you've got different cards you have different bonuses you at different endgame bonuses so you know there's a lot going on in terms of Fermi's replayability the components are really good you've got different kind of player boards there are different powers on them the power seemed relatively balanced from what I've seen you know they're not ultra strong ultra game swingy but they're um you know that they're interesting enough to you know to make a little bit of a difference and so I love the theme of the game I think it works really well and setup and teardown time as well nothing to really complain about so yeah overall um as I said it's a game that I can see why it's so popular I can see the finer there but for this point in my kind of gaming career I like something a bit more kind of strategic a bit more you know a bit more autonomy over your decisions and not be at the mercy of the dice as much as you can be I might be over playing that a bit or overstating that a bit but it can definitely be a factor more so than I would like it to be I said this is a solo game I think it's better than your average worker placement game but that being said this there's so many more were complacent games that I'd rather play than this one it's a great gateway one and to be honest I think I prefer Lords of Waterdeep to this one I think it's a bit simpler it's a bit cleaner and it's just a bit more interesting my opinion I like the way that you can buy buildings and stuff in that one this one you can't do that but
yeah I can see why they're compared but I think a lot of what he just gets the edge for me yeah so that's that's champions of Midgard it's definitely a solid gateway game definitely try it out if you want to see those euro mechanisms american-made mirror trash mechanisms hit together you know it does it well is it for me not quite but that be said I can still completely see why this is a decent game it does get a decent decent verdict for me and yeah my opinions on champions of Midgard want to check out if you're into your kind of gateway games not too much of a learning curve from this one and you know what it is fun for what it is please quickly doesn't house tears welcome turns go by quickly so yeah a solid decent game but not quite for me so that concludes my review of champions Midgard if you have enjoyed the review please like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye