Skip to main content
Loading video...

Skara Brae ►►► Why do I like this more than the West Kingdom & South Tigris trilogies?

Transcript 1:02:14

Hey everybody. Today on Roto Runs Through, we're taking a look at Scarra. But before I get going, please turn your subtitles on to the Cllingon channel so that when I make rules goofs, you'll know what they are. And if you've done that, well then welcome to Scotland, everybody. We are about 5,000 years in the past, and the people of the Orcne Isles are doing their best to uh help humanity thrive and survive. Homo sapiens are large and in charge. And over the course of this game through four rounds, we are going to be furnishing, cooking, crafting, cleaning, trading, uh, and doing a whole bunch of gathering to try to get ahead. Now, I'm going to show you how this works today in a two-player run through. Down here is my little uh, civilization society. Up here is Jensen's. And um while we pretty much start out exactly the same with most of the same actions plus two stone knives, which are a very important resource, there's one difference. Uh everybody gets a randomly chosen special ability. Jen, her tribe, well, they're explorers. Me, we can recruit more help when we need it. But we could have been mustering, innovating, building, spinning wool, tending land, or hunting boar. every time you play, you're going to get one of these and that's going to really kind of give you a uh direction or you know a specialty to focus on. So otherwise we are ready to go. We are in the first of four rounds and the first

thing that happens every round is our tribe grows. We get another worker. You can see there's all these workers up here. In the first round we have one worker that we will be able to send to do various actions. In the second round we will have two workers. in the third round three and in the fourth round we will have a huge tribe of four workers who can get stuff done. Okay, so the next thing is we reveal all the different opportunities that are available to us in a two-player game. That means three rows of four cards each and we're going to be drafting for these cards as the game gets going. All righty. And let's see what we got here. Another roof. Oh, utensils. Okay. and uh another field worker. All righty. Okay, cool. And now the game can begin. I am the first player because I'm on top of the action stack. Jen, the purple player, is in the second spot. She's the second player. And in a two-player game, there is a neutral player that acts as a player grabbing opportunities that we might want to grab. So anyway, the neutral player is last. That's totally random. I am the first player. And um at the what we're doing each turn is we select and resolve. Let's go ahead and zoom in on this so you can see it. We select and resolve cards, place and resolve workers, and then retrieve our workers. That's what a turn looks like.

And in each round, we are going to get three of those turns. And so the first thing is me as the first player, I select one of these four cards. Then Jen as the second player is going to take one of these four cards and the neutral player is going to take one. Then we'll go to this group of cards. Then this group of cards. Once all these cards are gone, we will have finished the first of four rounds. So anyway, I am the first player. And so what I'm supposed to do is move over here to indicate, you can see these little arrows, that I have taken one of these three cards. I get first dibs. But um what do I want to do? I would I mean there there are definitely good cards here. No doubt about it. I like this fisherwoman who goes out and does harvesting in the fishing area, plus can generate one additional fish. That's pretty nice. And then we've got this uh woodsman, or I guess it's a woods boy, who can harvest stuff from the woods and catch a bunny rabbit. That's nice. And then we've got this uh field worker who can harvest stuff from, you know, the s the countryside and can turn two stone into a sheep. That's pretty cool. And then there is a roof which is worth two points. And the more roofs I have over my village, the less hungry mouth I have to feed. It is good to have roofs both for the point and to ensure all my people get well fed. So I get first dibs on any of them. But here's the deal, folks. Remember how I said when I was dealing these out here in the third row,

which will be we'll be getting to these four cards eventually. There's a utensils card. There are only, if I recall correctly, only four of those in the game. Out of 80 cards, one of the the rarest cards in the game has shown up. And so, I would like to get that card for myself. So, there is a risk that I can't get it if I go right now. Go ahead and just grab something out of the first row by declaring, "Hey, okay, I'm going to go. I'm at the first and this means I come over here. That means I'm going to take a card. But I don't have to take a card. I have another option. I can come up here. And what this means is I'm passing. I'm not going to grab any of these cards. And then after Jen goes and then the neutral player goes, then I get to go. So I will get last dibs on this row. But guess what? On the next row, I'll get first dibs. And I mean, know there's some nice stuff here. But if I then pass again and then the neutral player goes and then Jen goes, then when we get to the third row, I'll be first player and I can get that. And I want that. This is the rarest card in the game. And I can pretty much guarantee I can get that card if I'm willing to give up first dibs on these. And I am.

So, I'm going to temporarily pass. So, it is Jen's turn now. she could take one or she could pass as well uh and then let the uh neutral player go. Here's the deal. If Jen goes uh and then the neutral player goes and then me, we can see I'm first and Jen will be last next turn. So, if Jen doesn't want to be last grabbing the second row of stuff, then she might want to pass. Then the neutral player will go, then Jen will go, then I'll go, and Jen will be second going into the second round if she really cares about stuff here. So, this is a huge part of the game. There's a lot of brinksmanship. Suffice to say, I'm going to pass. And now Jen has to decide. Would she rather have first dibs on this stuff or second dibs on this stuff? Hm.

Let's see. Um, you know, roofs are a bit more rare than, you know, your average people, but they're not that hard to get. Plus, there's roofs we can get anytime we want. They're just not as good because they're only worth one point instead of two points. But Jen does like that fisher lady. She does like that she could go fishing. That means she could feed her people right away. That's pretty cool. Um, but the same thing is true with the bunny rabbit. But actually, oh, getting a sheep right out of the gate, that's better because a bunny rabbit and a uh fish, they provide food, but as you might imagine, a sheep provides more. So, I think I think Jen will opt to go first, right?

So, she's drafting right now and she will go on ahead and take this. Okay. So, she is the first to grab a card. And now she has to in play. And oops, I forgot these cards. They go underneath here. So, I got to scooch everything up a little bit. Uh, actually, I just got to scooch all this stuff up. There we go. So, Jen's got room to place her first gatherer or villager. So, that this guy goes right over here. He works in this area to gather stuff. Okay. And um now whenever you grab one of these cards, as it says right here, select and then resolve the card. So Jenna is going to resolve this card right away. And this card, right now, Jen has one of this gather in the uh the field surrounding the village icon. So that means she gets to activate this power here once. And um that power, if we were to look over at it, is get one stone or one wool. cuz you can see there's stone and there's sheep in the countryside surrounding the village. So, Jen, because she only has one of these icons, gets to grab one stone or one wool. She will go on ahead and take one stone and she will put it over here in her storage. And now she gets to activate this power, which is convert two stone into a sheep. And you say, "Well, that's no good. She's only got one stone."

Well, she's got a trick up her sleeve. There's a few different things you can do with these stone tools, these uh knives, and one of them is when a gatherer goes out, you can spend them to gather one additional thing from the area. So, Jen could spend one of her two starting knives to get a second stone. Just like that. And now Jen's got two stones. So, she will activate that power and convert those two stone into some delicious sheep. All right? which will feed her people soon. All right, so that was it for Jen. Now the neutral player goes because remember I passed. I got to wait till the end. The neutral player always just takes the leftmost available uh card. So this roof if anybody wanted it. Too bad it's gone. And now here I am and I've got these two to choose from.

The fisher lady or the wood kid. You know, Will Scarlet or um I can't think of a famous fisher one. Um right. So, which one of these two do I want? Him. He will gather me some lumber, which helps me build stuff. She will either gather um seaweed or shells, which has a variety of uses, and he will get me a bunny, she'll get me a fish. I think I care more about the fish right now. So, I'm going to grab her. And oh, yeah, I've got I do have to move more stuff up. Let's go on ahead and slide Jen up here so I can slide all of my stuff up. Uh, I should have thought about this before I started filming. All righty. So, I've got a fisherman and she is the same trick is going to go on here. I've got one of these icons. So, it says, "Hey, I can get one shell or one seaweed. I'll get a shell." All right.

And now I also one time get a fish. And that's just for free. I didn't have to do any conversions. And this creates a problem for me. Look at this delicious fish. I'm out of space. This is where I store all the stuff for my village. There is a solution for that. All I've got to do is just slide this. And in fact, I I there's no choice about it. I have to do this. I slide this over to make room. And now I've got fish. And it's as simple as that, right? Well, here's the problem. The more prosperous we are, the more stuff we collect and store, the more midden we create. m i dde. This is nor what we in our modern day world would call trash or garbage or refu. The more successful we are as a tribe, the more midden we start to create. And this midden will not only clog up our space, but it will make us lose points at the end of the game. So, this is a problem. Um, the more stuff we collect so we can be more successful, the more men we're creating, we're even losing points. We're getting up really high. Um, and the thing is once we get rid of this stuff, this token stays up here. It doesn't automatically collapse back down. So, you want to keep your production under control and not go too overboard, which I just did uh right out of the gate. But that's okay because I'm going to feed myself for it. Okay. So, anyway, um, now I should say remember on a player's turn, they select and resolve a card, which we both just done, and nobody took this card, so it's basically

gone out of the game. And we also place and resolve our workers. Remember, each of us has a worker. And after Jen had selected her card, she didn't have to wait to see what I was going to do. She could go directly to worker placement. I was just kind of in a card mode right then, so I kept going. So, but anyway, Jen and I simultaneously can go on ahead and place our workers. I could gather, she might clean, I might cook, she might explore. We've got a bunch of stuff to choose from. And um what is Jen going to do? Well, uh, let's go on ahead and zoom in on her options, shall we? So, she doesn't have much in the way of resources right now. Most of the actions other than gathering. Gathering is simple. gathering gets you grain from um you know the from from the farm, lumber from the woods, stone or whatchamacallit uh wool from the area around the uh village and from the waterfront a shell or a seaweed. So Jen could do any of these gathers, but they're kind of weak.

They're not going to generate much. It's much better to send gatherers out because they can gather stuff and do extra bonus stuff. So, what else might Jen do? Well, the thing she'd really like to do is explore. That's her special power. But everybody has the same cost to use our special power. We have to spend two food, two bones, or one of each. A bone and a food or two food or two bones. And then Jen could go exploring. She does not have any food or bones at all right now. So, what else is she going to do? Well, you know what? She just got that sheep. So, I'm thinking it might make sense for her to come over here and cook that sheep. She could totally do that. And how does that work? Well, by default, when you cook, you generate one to four hearth actions or cooking actions. And you spend those actions on this little menu right here.

Now, Jen has a sheep. She could cook that. That would cost her three um cooking of three of her four, I should say, cooking actions. The problem, of course, is she has four actions and she'd only be spending three of them. So, she'd be wasting one. And if I know my wife, I know she does not like to be inefficient like that. So, ideally, she wants to have a grain or a shell on hand as well, cuz then she could spend three of her actions on the sheep and then her final action on one of these two and get a little bit more food. So, does she do that right now and be inefficient or does she go over say come over here and gather a shell then on a future round when she cooks she's got one two three four things to cook and that would be more efficient but that means she would be putting off um the uh you know her ability to get the benefits of cooking and the benefits of cooking a sheep are right here She will get one hide, one food, one bone, and one wool. You can see that's much better than a bunny, which is just one food or one hide, or a fish, which is one food and one bones. And here's the thing. Jen is thinking she might choose to be inefficient and cook right now and waste one of those hearth actions. In fact, I think that's what she's going to do right out of the gate. She already burned one um knife to get that sheep.

And now she's going to waste one of her hearth actions to cook this sheep and get herself a bone, a wool, a food, and a hide. All right. And as you might imagine, that's a problem. Jen uh has just got uh taken up a lot of space. So now she is producing excess waste just like I am. That'll happen at the end of the round after each of us has taken three turns. So anyway, but what this means is next uh turn, Jen could spend that food and that bone to explore, which is what she's thinking she's going to do. She would like to start exploring before the first round is up. Okay, so that was it for Jen. She has selected and resolved a card, placed and resolved her worker, and then the last thing she does is she retrieves her worker. All right. So, she's done for this first turn. Um, and now it is me.

I'm still thinking about what I'm going to do. I've got this fish. See, here's the deal. I've got a fish that only takes two hearth actions and a shell means again I be wasteful just like Jen was. And and a rare turnabout for me. I'm choosing not to be wasteful. So, I don't think I you know, and by the way, we don't block each other. Jen's got her spots. I've got my spots. We're playing three-player game. Everybody has their own action spots. So anyway, what am I going to do? Well, I can't recruit as much as I would love to. I would love to recruit right now because that for the rest of this round would give me an extra bonus worker. So every turn I could be doing two worker actions instead of one. But even if I cook this Well, the fish will generate a bone. Yeah, you know what? I could I could cook this fish that would generate a fish and a bone and I could recruit. But I just don't want to be wasteful like Jen did. So, what else would I do? Well, um I could clean, but I don't need to clean yet because I don't have any midden. Uh one of the best ways to get rid of your mitten or your refues is to clean it up. I've got the resources for it, but no, I don't think so. I could engage in trade, but that'd be very expensive right now because when you engage in trade, you have to give up two or more matching resources. And the only matching resources I have are my um whatchamacall uh can't think of the word. My knives.

Now, here's the deal. If I'd wanted to, when I was harvesting shells, I could have given up a knife to get a second shell. Then I'd have two shells and I could engage in trade and get a benefit. Whoa, that's interesting. You know what? I think like Jen did, Jen spent one of her knives to be able to get that extra stone so she can get the sheep. I'm going to spend one of my knives when I harvested these shells to get a second shell. And then I'm going to engage in trade. And as it says right here, when you engage in trade, oh, sorry. There we go. Um, you have to give up a certain number of the same type of good to get the rewards. Now, what are the rewards? Well, that's on my little board over here. At the beginning of the game, my trade is at zero. I'm getting zero points for all the trade I've done. But I to move up one step, I need to trade two matching items. So, I'm going to gauge trade two matching items. These two shells I harvested. And now I've got one point at the end of the game, which is not great. But you can see if I keep engaging a trade which costs three of a kind, four of a kind, four of a kind, five of a kind, six of a kind, it gets expensive, but it also takes me from scoring zero points at the end of the game to 20 points at the end of the game. But also, I have another thing to consider is when you trade, you move your trade meter up. Okay, so I've done that. And at that moment, if you give up

a knife, you also get the trade bonus. And the trade bonus for this first step is a cow. It's a whole mumu cow. That is totally worth it. I'm giving up my last knife. I started with two knives. Now I've got none. But oh, I've got some cattle as you might imagine. That will keep me very well fed. Okay, so there we go. Uh, and that was my first turn. So both Jen's still got one knife. I used up all my knives. I've got very little. Jen's got a bunch of stuff. We have finished the uh first turn of three turns of the first round. Now I move on to the second, which means we just move this back over here. And as predicted, folks, I am the first player again, which means I get first dibs on all of these people. But once again, I'm going to pass cuz I want that utensil. What is the rarity?

I think it's four out of 80. One out of every 20 cards is one of those. I know it says in here somewhere. I'll ask. Yeah, here it is. Um, right. So, of the 80 cards, right? 60 um 16. Yeah, there's 80 cards out of this deck. Only four of them are utensils. Eight of them are stone balls, and we didn't see any of those in the first round. And eight of them are roofs. And so, we've seen there two roofs came out, but most of them are settlers. So, anyway, those are settlers. I'd be happy to get one, but I'm not going to worry about that right now. I'm going to pass again, which means in the third draft, I will get whatever I want and I'm going to take that super rare utensil. Now, the neutral player goes next and they say, "Oh, I just take the leftmost thing." Boom, it's gone. And now Jen could pass, but then she's going to go again immediately, so she might as well. Does Jen want a fisher one? Does she want a farmer or a farmer? Now, here's the deal. What Jen really wants is another uh field worker? because if she puts it over here, she would get to do a double gather and then a bonus action. So, she's probably planning on getting this green or this green in the third draft.

But right now, in the second draft, Jen is going for either a fisher or a farmer. So, this fishery is exactly like mine, will generate genish in addition to one shell or one seaweed. These farmers, they're different, though. they will generate grain and in addition to that they can generate a bunny. So Jen's got more to cook or you can spend three grain to get a cow. Now one I mean so that means Jen she couldn't possibly do this if Jen still had both of her knives. She could harvest one grade in both knives to get two more grain and then get the cow. But as it is that one makes no sense. So it's really one of these two Jen is going to take. Does she want the fish or does she want the bunny? I think she will take that uh settler and now immediately react or activates it. She gets one grain and see now she can be more efficient with her cooking and um then she goes on ahead and she uses her worker. I'll come back in a second. I'm just going to figure out what I'm going to draft now.

I would like another fisher one, please. Because now that lets me activate this twice. two shells, two seaweed, or one of each. Uh, each for each one of these icons I got. I can do that. And then she's going to give me another fish. So, what do I want? Do I want two shells, two seaweed, or one of each? Well, shells have mollisks or something in them because I can cook them and generate food. Seaweed um does not, but seaweed is an essential ingredient for upgrading my cooking ability and my gathering ability. You can see each one of these actions has a little uh placard on it that says how what I've got to pay to be able to upgrade and turn my cooking action from four hearth actions into six or turn my gathering action um from hey uh what is it uh a stone or a wool into a stone and a wool or instead a bunny rabbit. So though that would be a nice upgrade to get. So I think I'm gonna diversify. I'm gonna get one shell and one seaweed. Okay. So that's what my double over here did. And then I got that one fish. Okay. And so now while I was doing that, Jen was figuring out what she wanted to do. And we already know what Jen's going to do. Jen's going to explore. It's kind of her thing. She will spend that one food and that one bone she's got to do her explore action.

what that is. She gets to draw two and keep one card. And she got what you're most likely to get um when you draw two and keep one. Um it is two different settlers. Another farmer or a woods person. All right. So, Jen gets one of these. Now, if you look closely at her explorer, there's a little reminder that if when you're doing this action, you take a settler, you do not get to activate their card abilities. And that's kind of a bummer both for Jen because she'd like to get a card that would let her do something right now instead of just being a mouth defeat that she'll be able to use later, but um for me too because I want to demonstrate herself. You've already seen how gatherers work. What if it had been the next two cards she drew or the next two? Come on, just give me There we go.

Yeah. Okay. Let's say it was these two cards she drew, right? Okay. Just because I want to show you something else. I want to show you something new. All right. So, let's uh go with this. So, Jen has a gatherer, but remember uh her explore action says, "Hey, when you uh get a new gatherer, you do not get to activate." It still means though that if Jen now does another, she's harvesting three at a time. So, that's something. But she won't get anything. But, alternatively, she could take this roof. And let's say she took that. So, she took this roof. Now, the roofs, they're supposed to be Oh, shoot. I just bumped everything. I needed to set my camera further away because I have run out of space to hold stuff. Actually, if I push Jen up a little bit more, you don't need to see all of that. There we go. It looks the same as mine, which I've also bumped. Let's say Jen gave herself a roof. This is right underneath here is where you keep your roofs and your balls, if you find any of those, which we'll talk about once they come up. So, anyway, so Jen just gave herself a roof. um which gives her two points at the end of the game and it means she has to feed one less tribe member when it comes to the end of the round. So Jen went exploring and she found the materials she needed to build a roof and make a stronger um village for her people. She's pretty happy with that. Okay, cool, cool, cool. And um now here I Oh, wait. No, I've already Yeah.

What did I do? Oh, I took the second fisherman. I just didn't mark it. So, what am I going to do? I've got two fish. I could engage a trade, but remember, I need three of a kind now. So, I can't do trade again because I don't have three of anything. I think it's a good time to go cooking like Jen did last time. But I'm not going to be inefficient like Jen. I'm gonna spend all four of my hearth actions and cook this. Cook some burgers, which means I'm gonna need some space because when you cook cattle, you get two food, one hide, and two bones. A bippity lippity. All right. And as you might imagine, that's going to take a lot of space. So, I've had to move up to where I'm now producing two midden, which is not great, but that's okay. So, that was it for me. And remember, at the end of your turn, you take your worker back. All righty. They do not take up space. I'm just putting them here. I mean, they could just easily be, you know, off to the side like uh like that, let's say.

Okay. So, um we have finished the second draft. Resetting. Boom. Just as I always planned, I am first dibs. And this time I am not gonna pass. I'm gonna get that utensil. And you know what? I need space to put my stuff. It's supposed to be below here. I'll just put it right there. I've got utensils. One of only four in the world. It makes it very valuable. Now, um, the utensils give me two points. They immediately give me a hide, which means, oh no, I'm even more successful. Now I'm producing three pollution. Oh, that's bad. But we'll worry about that in a second. And this also says whenever I cook, I get plus one hearth action. And whenever I generate midden, you know, um, garbage at the end of a round, normally I'm going to generate three, but I generate one less, so I only generate two. So that's handy. So that was that. And now Jen gets to go. But if Jen goes right now and is first dibs on these remaining three, then she will be the second player. I think either way Jen can get a blue, which is what she wants. Although, wait. No, I'm sorry. A green. But here's the problem. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. So, Jen can get a green either way. I think she's No, she's going to get one. She's going to pass. Wait for the neutral to take one. Why can't I? The neutral will go there. And now here comes Jen. And she can either get herself a second roof or another green um gatherer. She'll take that. That roof is gone away. And

Jen will be first going into the second of four rounds. Now, Jen has two harvest, so she can get two stone, two wool, or one of each. Jen needs two stone because once, right, she's got the two stone, she's got the storage spade for it, so she doesn't have to expand her storage. And then she will immediately use that action and get herself another sheep. Okay, so that was it. And now we do our final um action when we're only doing one action. Now me, I've got the bones. I've got the food. I could go on ahead and do my recruit action now, which means I'd get a worker, which means this round, this this turn, I'd get to do two actions. That would be great. But now is a terrible time to do it because this little symbol here says at the end of the round, after the three turns have been taken, I have to return all. So, I want to um get these recruits at the beginning during that first turn of a round. So, this recruit will stick around for the entire round. So, I am not going to recruit right now.

What am I going to do? Um, geez, I got a lot of food to cook and I could cook up five with five action points. I could cook up both fish and this shell. That would be pretty cool. But that means I'd be giving up three things to get one, two, three, four, five things. um which means I wouldn't fill up anymore, so I'd be safe and I could cook all this stuff cooked up. But on the other hand, having two fish means if I can just get one more fish next round during the draft, like you saw me do, if I can get one more fish, then I've got three fish and I could trade it um to get three points and um well, I'd need a a knife to get a deer. So, I could do more trade if I keep saving up the fish.

What else could I do? Well, one thing I I can't do to great effect is craft. Crafting means paying the resources at the bottom of any of my tiles. Oh my gosh. Uh I this was upgraded for some reason. It shouldn't have been. So paying the resources at the bottom any of my tiles to upgrade them so my gathering becomes better or what have you. That's been wrong since the beginning. I'm sure Paul will probably point that out in the cling on subtiles. You should always watch cling on subtiles turned on. But most of the build actions require I mean all these require stone. These ones down here don't. They require bone to upgrade those. And I do have two bones. Now I'm planning on using my bones for the recruit. But I got a bone and a hide. I could upgrade my recruit action so that when I do it next round, I still get the recruit, but I also give myself more flexibility with my workforce.

But you remember I was just saying, boy, I need another fish, right? If I upgrade the gather ability, then I can send workers here and get fish. Then I've got enough fish. Yeah, let's do that. I am going to craft. And I got to spend I got to spend one bone and one Oh, no. I don't have lumber. No, I never harvested any lumber. So, I cannot upgrade that. I would like to upgrade that. So, I have another source of fish. Do I just go on ahead and make more food and just cook up a storm? Um, maybe. What else could I upgrade? I could upgrade so I'm gathering two or two or two or being a better recruiter. That might be nice. That might be nice, but I can't upgrade any of those. Or again, I could just cook or I could just gather, you know, just get a grain or a lumber so that I could upgrade this later so that I could just have this as a source for fish. Uh because uh fish can feed us, but I could also engage in trade. Having two fish, but fish is a more valuable thing.

Trading them away. I want to trade away shells or grain ideally because that's lower quality stuff. Oh, but you know what? There's something else I could do. I could furnish, I could improve the quality of life of my village. This requires um a parole or a uh a hide multiplied by the next level up. In the same way, the trade track moves up and is worth more and more and more points. Um furnishing is just a way to convert hides and wool into more and more points. Maybe that makes sense because I got these two hides. How about I do that? So, the first uh time, well, actually, I'm sorry, the first time I only have to spend one thing. So, I only have to spend one hide or two wool. The next time I'd go up, I need to do go twice.

So, it could be two hides or four wool or one and two, if that makes sense. Let's go on ahead and furnish just make a nicer village for my people. So, actually, let's go ahead and move this one. I've spent that high and I get to move up one. Now, what does this mean? This means I'm increasing the value of my villagers for in-game scoring. Um, well, I haven't increased them yet. Every single villager that I've got that I've collected, you know, Jen's got three, I've got two, is worth either one or two points as they level up. But there's something else going on here. You can see there's a second row. You are incentivized in this game to get more and more of the same type of gatherer so they can become more and more powerful, right? You're also incentivized to go over variety and get um a lot of each type because oops if you've got a full set for every set you've got of each type at the end of the game. That's what this one will do.

So if I do my furnishings, a full set of uh people is worth an additional two points. But it could make it all the way up to where a full set of the four types of gatherers could be worth six points. So if I like did one, two, three furnishings and these were who I have in my tribe at the end of the game. I've got one, two, three, four, five, uh, plus six, that's 11 points down there. And this is not a high-scoring game, folks. 11 points is a pretty big deal. So yeah, let's go on ahead and start furnishing. I will spend one of my two hides to bump that up. And now I'm incentivized not only to specialize, but also to get variety because it's another source of points for me. So I furnished. And meanwhile, while I was thinking about that, Jen realizes she has no food and she has three people to feed and it's the end of the round. And for everyone she can't feed, they leave.

They're gone. She loses those cards. Now, because she's got this roof, she only has to feed two of them, but she still has no food. So for Jen, it's a no-brainer. She's going to cook that sheep and that sheep takes three of her four hearth actions and she will cook this grain which takes one of her um four heart. So that's a to that time she cooked efficiently. So for the sheep she gets a food and a hide um and a bone bone bone bone and a wool. And for the grain, she got a food. So, you guessed it, folks. Jen has storage problems.

All right, there we go. So, she had to move up as well. So, she's now to the point where she's producing two mitten just like me. Right, right, right, right. Um, okay. So, uh, that was that. Did was this up here? And did I bump it back down by accident? kind of feel like or maybe I was just talking about that in an example. H yeah, I'm pretty sure I had so I must have bumped this down by accident because that's the important thing. Yeah, that's what it was. It was I had two um two hides, right? And then I paid one of the hides and I slid this down. Uh-uh. That's cheating. This does not slide down automatically. Once it's moved into a spot, it's locked there until I do the cleaning action to bring it back down. Um, so again folks, turn on those cling on subtitles. I'm sure Paul will point out that I goofed that.

So anyway, we are now here. We are done taking our player turns. This is a reminder of how we can play settlers. Um, you know, how we can use knives to get their stuff. And um, here we are at the end of the round. At the end of round, if we have any end of round um, abilities, we activate them. Neither of us do yet. Um, then we feed the number of people we have minus the roofs. I need two food. I've got two food. No problem. Jen needs 1 2 3 minus one. She needs two food. She has two food. No problem. Easy peasy. Okay. And um now we generate our mitten. I generate three because we have pushed ourselves hard and fast. One, two, three for me.

Fortunately, it doesn't make me extend even more, but that can be if you, you know, when you're generating four or five or six or seven, you might imagine if you ever fill this up completely and you're generating seven, you just keep your extra stuff off the board. You can collect as much as you want, but you're generating seven midden, which is negative seven points at the end of every round. But that's okay. I could fit my stuff in. Jen generates two and she can fit hers in. So, things haven't gotten any worse. um over in Gen Town. So, there we go. Um we've done that and now we go on to round two, which means um everybody gets a second worker and things are going to start ramping up. Uh because, you know, basically this round there are going to be three more turns with three more drafts and let's see what comes out. There's another roof. Ah, here's the ball I was talking about. You'll get to see that in action. I'm glad about that.

And oh my gosh, a second ball. Wow, these are fairly rare, too. What was it? There's only eight of these out of 80. Only one out of every 10 cards. So, those are very valuable. These are the way that we get knives back. And as you can tell from that first round, having those knives gave both Jen and me a big, you know, uh, leap up. Anyway, though, so here we are. Jen is first. I am last. Jen could snag any of these and she says, "Yeah, I'm not messing around. I want a knife. She's taking a ball. Okay, that's worth two points. And whenever you grab a ball, you get a knife for every ball you've got. She's got one ball, so she gets one knife. Okay, if she had three balls and took that, she would get four knives.

Although, that's unlikely because there's just not that many. All right, so that was Jen. The neutral player says, "Oh, I'm going to go." And she's takes that. And now I could pass. It doesn't matter. I'm going to be first in the next round. Do I want a roof or do I want Carpenter Boy? Well, you know what? Because I I think I I'll I'll take Carpenter Boy because remember, I'm trying to get variety because I've invested in furnishing. So, I want to have a full set of everything. So, Carpenter Boy generates one lumber for me. Thank you. Because I've only got one icon. And says he goes out and catches a bunny rabbit. Oh, so we've got some more stuff to cook. and I can just barely fit it all without having to expand into the negative in-game victory points section. Yikes. Okay, so we've both done that. The nobody took the roof. Wow. Okay, but anyway, now we've got two workers and let's have me go first. I think for starters, I am going to recruit. And that means I'm going to spend two bones to activate my recruit ability. My recruit ability is get another worker. I've got for this whole second round, I've got three workers. I get to do three actions every turn.

Boom. Nice, nice, nice. So, what do I want to do with my other two? Do I want to cook? Um, I got a rabbit and a shell. I mean, and I I have five total cooking. Oh, wait, folks. I forgot. I'm cheating myself. I was at the three bitten, but remember my utensils meant I only had to produce two. I'm cheating, you know. Gotta watch that. And again, I'm sure Paulo pointed that out. Turn on those cling on subs. All righty. Do I want to furnish? Well, I can't furnish because now I need two. So, I need two hides or four wool. I do not have enough. So, I can't furnish. I still don't have any stone. So, I can't upgrade any of these buildings. You know what? You know what I'm gonna do, folks? I'm gonna go big. I'm gonna cook. I'll have my little recruited character cook. And again, I've got five hearth actions to spend thanks to the utensils. So, what am I going to cook for five hearth actions? I will cook a fish and a fish and a rabbit. Nope, that's two. Uh, and this shell. So, that takes two and two and one is five. This is what I'm cooking. What does that get me? That gets me a bone and um one, two, three food.

Hold on a second. Oh, no. It gives me two bones, right? Because I I cooked two fish. Yeah, baby. Oh, that's going to be great. So, I cooked uh two I got two bones. Uh and I get three food for one, two, or one, two, three. One, two, three. And by the way, if you can't quite tell, these are like, you know, pots of food or a croc of food over a fire steaming and all that. All right, there we go. So, nice, nice, nice. You know why that's nice, folks? because I've got a third action now. And you may have noticed, I haven't mentioned it yet, the first worker we had has a big head and a tall body. This is a special worker. This I mean, normally when a worker goes out to a spot, you block yourself. You can't go to that spot again. But the big worker can the big worker can go to occupied spot. And if I come over here to recruit, I could spend the two bones I just made and recruit again. And now for this whole second round, I'm going to have four workers that I get to use every turn. Now that worker can't go to cook or recruit because it's a regular one. So it has to go someplace else. What am I going to do? You know what I might You know what I might do?

Everything slide over. It might be time to clean up my act. If I come over here, this is a list of everything I can spend. I can spend hides, seaweed, um grain, and wood to clear out mitten and or slide this back down to keep my um you know, my rampant growth under control. Um plus, every time I clean, I get a free roof. So that's fewer food, less food I have to generate because basically this isn't just cleaning. This is basically radically improving the uh village. So I could do that. I can't do trade because I do not have three of a kind of anything.

I can't do furnishing because I don't have uh right. I could go harvest stuff. I could I don't have any bones and I don't have any stone, so I can't craft anything right now. Um, yeah, you know what? I just might harvest some stuff. I think that might be the thing to do. Oh, yeah. In fact, I think that's about the only thing I can do. I don't have enough to furnish. I don't have what I need to craft. I could clean and give up this and this and this and that would be three. And whenever you clean, you have to give up different things. So, if I give up three different things, I can do three cleaning actions. Sure, what the heck? Let's do it. Let's clean up. So, I will give up these three things from that list of things I can give up. And that gives me um three cleaning actions and a roof. My roof is not on fire. So, now I've got utensils and I've got a roof. And that's worth these are worth three points here. And um I get to do three cleaning actions.

How? All right. Let's go ahead and collapse all this stuff down. You can rearrange this stuff in here if you I could just go one, two, and get rid of a mitten. Or let's get rid of both mitten. One, two, three. All right, that looks a little bit better. That's a bit more space conscious. So, that was it. That was a huge turn. And after I draft my second card and my third card, I'm going to have big turns again because I'm going to have four workers while Jen is rocking two. But don't feel bad for Jen because she if she sets herself up, she can go explore and draw cards faster than me. Um, plus if she upgrades this, which would cost a bone and a and she could do that right now, you know, I think, yeah, Jen is going to craft and she is going to spend a bone and a hide to upgrade her explorer ability. And so now she draws three and picks one. And if she ends up taking a gatherer, she doesn't get to gather, but she does get to activate their special ability. So, let's have her go explore. All righty.

Although, again, to explore though, she needs two food or two bones, and she doesn't have that. So, she's got to go get those bones and food. Oh, by the way, you know, I did give her a knife when she got the ball. Shoot. Shoot. Shoot. Um, right. So, what is she going to do? She doesn't have anything to cook to get some bones and food. Well, maybe she shouldn't have explored then cuz she did just use a bone to do that upgrade and a hide. H maybe that wasn't the right thing to do. What is Jen going to do with her two actions? You know what, folks? Not quite sure, but I think I'm going to stop right there because that should give you a pretty good idea of the feel of Scarab Break. And now, if you'd like to hear some final thoughts about the game, well, let's just cut right to it, folks.

Of all the games in the extensive library from uh Garpill Games, you know, founded many, many years ago by publisher designer Shim Phillips, um this is probably my second favorite of everything they've ever done. The best one is still the new um uh North Sea Redux, Ship Rights of the North Sea. That's my favorite. This is my second favorite. My third, I don't know. Uh probably Raiders of the North Sea. It's hard to say. And that might be a surprise to some people because um in recent years, ever since Shem was joined by um designer Sam McDonald and the two of them started working together so closely, Garfield Games is mostly known for the amazing um what's it uh the uh Tigris the South Tigris trilogy and before that the West Kingdom trilogy. As I understand, they're about to start a new trilogy set in the east in Asia. Um, so that's all very cool. Oh, yeah. And of course, they previously had done the North, but the North Ship, Raiders, and Explorers of the North Sea, those were done without Sam. It's when Sam came on board and started working with Shem that Garpill started getting known for bigger, crunchier, heavier um Euro style economic simulations. There's so much more stuff going on and you know if you've played or you watched any of my videos of the South Tigers games the three most recent from that design duo

you can see I mean they are reaching Vitalarda levels of depth and complexity and while it's awesome and it's been incredibly successful for them I mean people are just loving all those games for me I kind of well I am very very happy to see a game like Scar Bray come along. Um, where I guess it's just Shem working without Sam, much like in my favorite game of his entire uh, collection, the ship rights of North Sea Redux. I guess it's when Shm and Sam come together that they really start ballooning up the complexity and all the different um, you know, uh, special rules and and and all that. do you get those incredibly popular games? But for me, to a certain extent, and more importantly to my wife, Jen, those games are just getting too topheavy. Uh, you know, they are so overboard with so much stuff going on, so many moving pieces.

It's not that they aren't brilliant design. I, you know, they are very nicely done and the iconography is generally very clear and it's easy to play along, but there's just so much to absorb, so much to think about. Um, you know, a game like this gets back, I'd say, to Garfill's roots. Even before the North Sea game when Shen was just starting out, he was doing very, you know, practically gateway level um, Euros. And of then, of course, Raiders of the North Sea, which is a relatively, you know, it's a little bit more complex than a Ticket to Ride. It's maybe a gateway plus style game. That one in the field is Yurus, and that really put him on the map. Um but shortly after that when um Sam came on board uh the two of them really started ballooning in depth and complexity and are making games that are brilliant but tend to not be for me and Jen. I think of all of the West Kingdom and the South Tigers games, the only one I kept was um uh was it Paladins of the West Kingdom? The third one of the West Kingdom. It's not Paladins. nothing like Paladins. Anyway, I kept that one. Um, mostly because generally love the cool 3D mountain in the middle of the board. Plus, we both love Rondell's so much. I um so I'm just all I can say is I'm very very excited to see something like this. This I I've been talking a lot about other games.

Why don't I talk about this one? What is it? This is one got to be one of the industry's ultimate goods conversions. I mean, a game that comes with over 300 little pieces of wood representing what is it? How many? 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 representing 16 different types of goods, trade materials. Well, you know, that's a game wearing its heart on its sleeve. It wants you to be all about harvesting stuff and then converting stuff into other stuff. And, you know, there's a lot of games that do that. This game does it, too. And this game does it very well because it's got two I think really brilliant tweaks to the formula. One is that usually in these kind of games you want to get a whole bunch of stuff and you know harvest a bunch of stuff and then have a bunch of stuff and then do big epic conversion turns. You know for peak efficiency sake you don't want to have to spend three of your this game you only get 12 turns.

You don't want to spend three of your 12 turns um you know you know converting things peace meal here and there. You want to get all your stuff and then do one big super conversion. Um and you can do that here uh in in a lot of ways. But the problem is the more you hoard stuff, the more your storage fills up. And the more it fills up with stuff and it won't automatically contract, the more waste wastage because you're not being um, you know, efficient with your storage. The more your storage expands and therefore your little village, your society expands, the more quickly your villagers are producing cast off, waste, refuge, and you've got to deal with that. I love a game. They don't call it that, but they might as well call the clean action recycling. Recycling all your garbage to clear all this stuff out. And at the, you know, and at the same time build roofs, I like to think of it as, oh, our waste off, cast off garbage that's just taking up space. It's be it's being recycled into better stuff. That is a crucial element of the game. Although it doesn't have to be if you go on ahead and take a lot of waste, but you think you're making enough points ahead of it.

But really, you do need to kind of keep it under control. But more importantly, if you can keep it under control in the first place, never expand very far in the first place, you don't have to worry so much about the recycling if you can come up with the right combination of people and the right order of actions to be peak efficient. Um, you know, don't do quite such big conversion things. Do more smaller ones. That means you have less actions to do other stuff, but you don't have to spend time cleaning. That is excellent. I love it. Thematically, I love, you know, the real story, the reason the miden kind of looks just like these little uh green mounds here is because apparently in real history talks about this a bit in the rule book. Uh all this stuff was taken and turned into big mounds, and you can go to the Orcne Islands today and see them. And future generations of these people would then take these big mounds of garbage after they've been there for a generation or two and hollow them out to turn them into new homes. So bringing that theme here, the idea of generational recycling is really cool. So I love the story this game tells, of course, but then on top of that, I love this. This is so simple and so elegant. It reminds me of how the original raiders or of the North Sea came up with this simple little idea of oh hey you put a worker down in the worker placement zone to do whatever action you want to do as a Viking and then you pick another one up and you do that action too and players shared a communal um group of villagers or

workers. That was a huge innovation in worker placement and it rightfully deservedly won the spiel to Jarus or maybe it was the counter spiel. I think it was the speed of Jarus for it though because it was so good, so smart, so groundbreaking. I'm not saying this is quite as groundbreaking as that, but it's really good too. the idea of, okay, I mean, I love a game that gives me opportunities for advanced planning and the fact that when a new round starts and I can see what I what cards I'll have access to for my next three turns and I could decide, well, like you saw in the run through I did, wow, I could happily take any of the ones in this turn. I think I'm just going to pass so that I could set myself up to be first next turn or the third turn to get what I really need. But therefore, I am sacrificing while other players get to go ahead of me. But then that makes me first. That is so th this is so Shem.

This is so clever. It's so elegant. It's so simple and easy to gro. Um but it is so such a big turning point around the game because it means you have some control of being able to advance plan what you want to do. I I love it. And then you know on top of it it is you know some people might think of it as busy work but for me I love the idea of taking a whole bunch of this stuff and then you know okay I got I cleared all that out and I converted into this other stuff and you know running those little computations. Okay I just need one more stone. Am I am I going to spend one of my workers? That's the other thing too. This game definitely escalates over time um as you have two three and then ultimate for the last round four workers. You know, I say you only take 12 turns, but that's misleading because the last three turns you are each one of those turns is five actions. Get a card and do it plus four workers. So, that's 15 turns in the last round. So, um you know, it's a reasonable length game. And don't don't think it's it's incredibly short, but it really ramps up nicely.

And I do have to say one thing I'm a little bit less uh enthused about is that first round where you only have one worker. I got to say that first round is a little lackluster. The game by the time you know as soon as you have two workers, but then when you have three and four and you are getting so much done, this game feels so good and it's just kind of annoying to have to go through that first round. Honestly, I'd be happy just to drop it and say this is a three round um nine turn game. Although again, it'd be way more than nine actions you're doing just to get to the fun stuff faster. and just say, "Hey everybody, draw three random cards as part of setup or draw four random cards and get rid of one and that's what you got in the first round." And then boom, go straight to because I just want to turbocharge. I want to get to the fun stuff faster. I mean, you practicing whatever your special power is. Whether it's exploring or recruiting or mustering, innovating, building, hunting, hunting more. I mean, these are all cool extra things you get to do, but you don't really get to start doing them until later in the game. I want to be playing with these toys right out of the gate. And so, I mean, that's my one big complaint about the game, and it's a minor complaint because, to be fair, most of everything in this game, most of the action is simultaneously. It's just that draft for the cards, and that can go by fairly quickly, too. So, you'll get through the first round in 10 minutes or so, but still, that's 10 minutes I'm having to wait to get to the really fun stuff. There's one other thing I wanted to mention as well. The

solo mode, unfortunately, sadly, jettisonens this, but that's I don't know why they didn't need to jettison this. This could have totally worked in the solo mode. But more importantly, the solo mode adds objective cards. And these are really cool. And I kind of wish these were in the multiplayer game or you or you know I've actually seen threads on board game geek people talk about right how can we integrate these into the multiplayer game because they're really really cool to have extra things like um um oh man so many of them. Uh basically get getting to do extra actions by spending extra stuff or giving yourself goals to get more and more points. I mean, these are very very cool. And these become things in the solo game that you have to do or you lose, right? And um I I think you know they'd be interesting in the two-player game if everybody had one of these right out of the get going. And okay, I've got to get this done before the end of the game or else or actually it's not that you lose, it's that you lose points. If I by the end of the game, um you know, if if I'm not down to only two miden at the end of the game, I'm going to lose five points. having one or two of you know I mean gez each player getting like two or I mean you know it's it's funny I start out saying what a breath of fresh air this is to have Garill games giving me a less complex game but then I find myself wanting to bump up the complexity by saying oh you know what I got dealt three of these and if I don't deal if I don't end the game in this situation I'm

going to lose a bunch of points so I've got that goal chasing after as well bringing a bit more complexity back in okay maybe I'm a hypocrite But um I I I they're just there. They're just, you know, and in the same way I don't understand why the solo game got rid of this because it could so easily work in solo. I don't know why we can't use these in the multiplayer game. Minor complaints because make no mistake, the game is a lot of fun without it except for maybe that first round. That first round is a little hoham, I got to say. But man, there might be some easy solutions for that. But on the whole, like I said, I mean, don't get me wrong, I think Shm and Sam working together make beautiful music, but I think maybe the two of them egg each other on and let's throw something else in and something else and something else. So, they become these big kitchen sink games. And maybe the two of was it did Sam do cuz another one of my favorites is uh Circadian uh not not not the uh you know uh the the Circadian game. I think that was Sam on his own without Shim and that one was another sweet spot game. That'd be in my top three from them as well. Uh yeah, interesting. I don't know if I ever run into the Modesfield. Now that I'm back in Europe, I live in Ireland now. I could see the Med Spiel and maybe I'll ask. Um, but regardless, I guys, don't get me wrong, keep doing what you're doing. I'm excited to see the next trilogy as well, but don't forget to throw some of these into your catalog also because oh man, these hit a real sweet spot for me and

my wife Jen these days. And folks, that was Scar Bray. I'm gonna say thanks very much for watching. Have a very nice day. Talk to you later. So long. Bye-bye.

Progress saved