Great Western Trail: Argentina - Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for Great Western Trail Argentina uh which um is the second game in in the trilogy that they announced a couple years back I know it's it was the second edition of gray Western Trail this one and then New Zealand which New Zealand should be coming out this year I want to say like 2019 is when it was announced that sounds about right because and I have done the solo variant for the second edition to Showcase that and I've also done a run through and discussion for the first edition uh first and second edition of virtually the same game they just kind of cleaned up cleaned it up updated it to where it's not as racist right or I guess time appropriate but still uh it's virtually the same game with in my opinion way better art right so the question whenever this was announced was okay Argentina but you're still calling it Great Western Trail what what are you doing like right what and and like how are you gonna change it is it gonna be roughly the same game or is it gonna be drastically different and you're using the Great Western Trail uh IP because you see that happen all the time oh yeah where it's like it's that's basically the same game right uh so the biggest question to ask is why are you so bad at this game no no I'm kidding uh is it worth getting Great Western Trail Argentina when you
already have Great Western Trail or which one should you pick up if you don't have either those are the two prominent like if I if I ever did any like any more editing I could put those two questions up boom boom right those are the two questions to actually probably answer because that's I mean I think both of us Great Western Trails is 10 out of 10. it's just period yeah uh it's in my top ten yep it is not in my top ten but it's high up there out of right do a top 100 I can actually tell you exactly where it's at this time around but it's an incredibly solid game um some are some argue it's Alexander fister's best game you you say so I'm I'm a tosser between this and Maracaibo which I understand because I feel different but similar and I think it's the card play in America but right but I mean watch I'm gonna look at my top 100 and be like oh I actually grow with controls higher and it might be right um for me this is better um one the theme definitely gets me um the gameplay is super solid like one of the things oh it is my um my number so spoilers if this comes out it's my number 16. okay Great Western Trail second edition so it's not not this one but um if I were to rank these on my top 100 I'm lumping them together right so one of the things I do like about this is once you understand the iconography it's very very intuitive
everything every rule technically is on the board yeah um on your sheet on your sheet on the board so once you understand the iconography then it's super simple to play this game yeah um so clean there's never like like one icon we've seen that's kind of like well we can't find that right but it's kind of in this action like whenever we looked up on the back of this and it was like the action I was looking up was um was this one move your train back to discard it's like okay well that icon's right there right so versus this car with an X symbol yeah and so we've taken it as it's a destroy just like the other one is from your hand from your hand so it makes sense um but it is the one that is different that's not really explained or at least we haven't found it partially because realistically skinned through the rules just some new stuff that was it yeah um yeah so my my statement on this is it's basically Great Western Trail yeah it is it's it has it does have a few differences some minor some major but at the end of the day we were able to first time ever playing this game just kind of skim it and be like okay yeah those are those actions are saying those are the same oh here's the new stuff right and then we just understood that and played it with no questions right um so I don't know it's uh it's an interesting one it's like if you really like Great Western Trail I don't think this game brings enough
differences to Warrant owning both so again Great Western Trails top 10 for me this is still a top ten or still 10 out of 10. I'm not going home both yeah and because our own Great Western Trails second edition I'm not going to go pick this up right I could probably argue you could definitely do this one instead yeah it's kind of like don't own both but if you don't own either I would actually I would lean this one I don't like the art as much I think it's way too yellow right uh it's not the the first one is very pleasing I love the art I love the art on the cover right um because years ago my mom used to date um a guy her uh his dad was a famous Midwestern artist and he did Art just like that so I grew up around that and even though I'm not the yeah let's let's Saddle Up Cowboy kind of guy I still like really appreciate that kind of like Midwestern art right um I I probably agree with you this to me feels like there are more strategies that you can do than Great Western Trails Great Western Trails once you start understanding it becomes a game of efficiencies and understanding timing this is more like yes you still have to understand those but you can be looser with them and you can do something that's completely different than anybody else at the table is going to do as a strategy yeah and still be fine yeah
like still can be competitive because there's a lot of games where in Euro gaming that if you do a strategy that's off the wall you can't be competitive right here at least you can go off the wall and be competitive so do you want to know what my strategy was going in I'm like this is all I'm gonna do the entire game my entire strategy was to get as many points as possible off of cattle that's what I thought it was and so when you start complaining that I took um Cowboys I was like and it went out the window by like round two right I'm like cool okay so well also not necessarily by your fault we were only getting one Cowboy a turn right and the way we did our actions in a row meant you were going to go to Buenos Aires before me to be able to pop back and hire it and I was like well clearly I know you go Cowboys as well right um because that's where you can get a lot of points I think I still we got the same amount of points but you had a you had a fatigue yes so we both still got the same amount of points in Cowboys you got I think like eight points by the end because you bought two yeah and you were able to hire another cow yeah um but that was my initial strategy like I wanted like the fattest deck I wanted to never touch trains or buildings and just have like all the cows right that didn't happen so then I had to revert back to the old tried and true okay I'll beat you by going on the train right and which is always my go-to strategy in Gray Western Trail anyway uh
and I might have actually gotten to the same exact spot or it might have gotten further I think I actually got further I think I might have gotten a little bit further which was funny um yeah but I uh well with also help was the fact that the two things that came out this time was getting gaining a grain or sailing is one cheaper right and I got both of those and that's what I was trying to go for but I just wasn't fast enough in the drains and there was one that I saw that I was I wasn't going to get this person up but the one that was right here was a point for three to five cows I'm like that's amazing oh that's that's what I'm doing right that's what I'm trying to do so at least that and that got me like eight points right um so this is I mean I can almost just say go watch my discussion on Great Western Trail because it's not going to change that much no so let's talk about the differences yep uh okay so grain grain is now a resource that you have to manage in some way right in our first game I was like God damn the grain is really tight right and in this game I was like oh well that could have also just been because sailing was too cheaper for me so I was like I just got to always just any grain I had it just accumulated so grain is only tight if you're planning to do this because like in Great Western Trails where you basically pay forward if your train isn't Far Enough by stop signs that's what grain is oh yeah but this is just a
consistent like so it's always one it doesn't matter if your Train's past the seven point it's always one yeah so which I like it's like hey that's that ship isn't going as far like thematically it makes way more sense right hey that's that ship isn't going as far so you just need to give this much feed for your cows you're sending right and so like I even saw you were paying a lot less attention than you did the first game on which ships were sailing to which locations which again plays the fact that I have way more tokens out here than you do because I still was focusing on that yeah your points for that was 31 right to my 15. and I was only able to get this because I never had to spend grain right and I also got a [ __ ] ton of points by going to the point ones yes on the sailing and so um to me I kind of actually like this a little bit better because it's easier to calculate yeah farther ahead than you are in normal Great Western Trails but at the same point like this 18 by normal time in Great Western Trails I'm basically never paying anything for this you should yeah it's either you're paying very little money right uh or and you're but you're going there almost all the time right yeah and here I'm probably paying this one to go if if I hit this multiple times I'm probably paying money to go to the spot that's almost a strategy in and of itself just going for that 18 and always spending the six because it's 12 points I don't remember how much it was is it still 12 uh it's nine or twelve it might be nine I think it might be nine actually yeah so it's worth more
but yeah if you can get a bunch on there like maybe three right three if you could pull four it's worth it that's a bunch of points right um and so to me it's those little hiccups in it that are just different yeah um I like the grain um I think I think it's not too complicated nope um at first you're gonna be like so how do I get it because you think oh I'm gonna help these Farmers but oh well they're only gonna give me one and that's expensive and they're six dollars six to eight to ten and you're like why would I ever do that especially when it only cost me two to pay for a grain so their grain is three times more expensive yeah it's not like it's a continuous income yeah one time yeah and like thematically when you put the Farmers on here it's that you're investing in their Farm uh but yeah it's like God because yeah you're right it's not a consistent income I mean the only time is it consistent is this last building up here you get one grain performer the farmer you have and you get rid of fatigue Ryan let's see any from your hand so you have to have that fatigue in your hand in your hand yeah with it which that can suck which I can suck uh let's see so and because nothing else really gives you anything like I'm looking at the buildings on the a side anyway none of them really give you any benefit for having those Farmers now this one right here four points for each set of four you have I mean that's good because you need Farmers for that right so the other way to get grain which is so I normally don't go heavy into buildings and every time we play this now I've gone way more heavy into buildings than I normally do
and it's exclusive because this building for every spot with a grain the other one is trees that give you money for every building in a Tree location or in a farm location or a Farm location yeah you're getting a grain so here I have four buildings in those grain locations means every time I hit here I'm already halfway up this track yeah and remind me again why you went for the 14 not the 20 was that to also hit uh so yeah objective objective so the objective was a wash but I will have to spend this one to get the 20 and this was worth another eight points and so the 14 point made more sense that yeah if I could have had another Ram this 8 will become 20 which would have made him a lot more yeah there was actually a point where I was able like I had eight grain and I was like oh man I could actually but then I looked up I'm like oh I'm not even there I I can't even and it's nine so you have to have one in this double spot that's why and I mean you can that's obviously there those those buildings that bring those out or those ships like I could have actively just gone there right if I wanted to go that strategy uh real quick your Farmers on the 2B side give you a coin for every farmer you have okay that's the only building ability that matters for Farmers besides this neutral one right so uh I mean so I like the grain aspect I probably like the grain a little bit better because there's two spots to use grain one that you can just pay coins if you want to exchange it for drawings and one that gives you normally coins and slash points yes um to do it a lot of points and a lot of money like like this one down here likes probably saved my ass on being able to
do a semblance of my strategy because I was like oh okay I'll just go south and get 12 money but I I have I think I had one here so it only cost me four and because I was sailing was cheaper for me I didn't have to it wasn't that big of a deal yeah I was able to accumulate it and so every time going the boy in those areas basically going down to zero right we're like I was pretty much going down to zero every single time right but I had invested in enough buildings that going down to zero wasn't as yeah you go to one location get four grain right it's like okay I uh I like the fact that these so so the grain like I said like we said is very very important right it's uh probably single-handedly most important thing otherwise you're always strapped for cash and you can't keep shooting over here yep so now they added these uh cities okay I don't know what that's supposed to be I thought it was where your where you're shipping the cows off but I don't think that's the case maybe that's where Farm is opening up like you're farming there I mean I think it is shipping cows is it but well I guess it might be I think it's you basically hiring the ships to go out to do it versus here you're just loading ships with yeah yeah so I think this is also a really cool element yeah uh so basically I mean everything they added I I think it's great right uh this is just really cool because in unlike in the original Great Western Trail like I feel like this is a
lot less tight on money like your only main source of income in the first is by selling your cows right which is perfectly fine that's the theme you go to Kansas City and then you're like okay I got 10 and then 15 and that's your money to last until the next round right here it's like oh yeah I'll spend some grain to get 12 money and you get that in flush of cash so the next round you can actually do right you get to do that before so it's like man I'm gonna sell I'm gonna get 12 money and then sell 15 worth of cattle so that's 27 and you're golden right because then you can buy two people and buy cows because normally the problem is in like Great Western Trails is you either buy two people or you buy cows yeah it's never both yeah although yeah I will say in this one it does seem harder to get people yeah um like you were able to do it and it could also just be just because I always pop them off right on the trend like okay hey here's your stop but yeah it's like I mean you did drop four guys so I did yeah so I would have had two um I would have had two uh uh conductors and then two Cowboys right uh so so at the end because again it was the last action but before that I only had two more guys than you did yeah it's rough I'm trying to I mean that would also be a stripe but that's not even I don't know if that's even a worthwhile strategy to trying to fill out everything it's I I don't think it I mean your farmers get you a free token to Liverpool to Liverpool and then the 10 one gives you
two sorry not Liverpool um rather damn and then the 10 gives you a free one to Liverpool and then your conductor lets you move your move your train twice and then the other one I don't know what that one is pay five to place a token on a location um very last one I assume oh yeah maybe I don't know I've never actually I mean I've never I always spend them so I I have my first real gripe with this game yeah go for it um okay so I like it gained five pesos and upgrade a station behind your engine got it okay okay my biggest gripe is with these so they're labeled one two one one two yeah in brown gray and black darker gray so I like the fact you have flags as the flags tell you when those ships leave yeah I love that just numerically because they're always going to stay in the same order go one two three four five for each location yeah and just put the one two three four five up here so then it's simple easy I can go over here plop it down I don't have to say is that black or is that brown right it's black right and like the example in the rule book gives oh when you go to the uh to the whatever Rotterdam location you get a um an objective card right and I'm like oh so the color is I thought one of the colored flag men it was lahav or something right and it it's
not it's not so yeah I don't know why he went with that stupid flag numerical system it's overly complex but they just need to be just you know one through five and the anchors just need or just have the anchors to be obvious colors so have a red blue or do turquoise um magenta and something so the colorblind issue isn't a problem or if you want to go the yellow green purple because they're kind of off use of those colors why not have that anchor be yellow that anchor B cream that it could be purple so it's like oh okay so clearly when you move across the yellow spot that's lav right so something like that would have been way more helpful um it's really my only gripe you can solve the problem by just in essence knowing which one goes to which because eventually you will understand that I think it's number 15 as always for this spot and number 11 is for that spot yeah okay now I know so now I can go and solve the problem but right still and these are double-sided which is nice um I personally would have liked I don't know because other Zach said that the rails to the north expansion can be used on all of them I don't know if he just thought as much or if someone said that I have no idea how that would work I don't think so because the zero starts over there and it matters for how it Trails out yeah so I really don't think it does and so if that's the case I don't know if he has plans on doing like
a like each separate game gets one expansion right because I think a great expansion for this game would be something akin to rails to the north but with these right because have more cities to go right go to and you just shuffle them and maybe if that's why he did some weird ass scoring for an expansion to where it's like because then then it would matter you could just shuffle all three and then boom place them out right or at least have like multiple Brown anchors and you should probably have one out yeah so hopefully that's the case because I would like to see more of these they are double-sided for some replayability but I can't remember if it has to be all A's or all B's normally they do with his stuff as well because your buildings have to be all bees are all these right and every player has to have the same one that's right so yeah so I love this I mean the a side is definitely you really just get coins or or uh points sometimes both the other side is a lot more a little bit more complex going to the right side that lets you go up three on ribbons right uh lets you take a three Cal a level three cow yep lets you move your train twice so obviously there's a little more strategy there which I enjoy and they have a new orange cow basically it just gives you tons of science at a fairly cheap price so you can get your Farmers quicker yes and in this game I thought the farmer taking was actually a lot more lucrative yes uh not it's because they're always going to be out and it makes it seem like going and just attacking Farmers but the theme is you're going you're helping them right because you have your cows with a scythe number on but the thing is because you're having a number that you have to
be to it feels kind of like yeah hey this one gives you plus three sides [ __ ] up some farmers and they're attacking you every time you go on to them yeah so it's yeah it's it's a little thematically odd but yes the orange cows instead of the orange ones getting more expensive or better better age yeah this one is just their seven side which is gonna get you almost anything if you do your white you can take you can take out any farmer right you can help any farmer because I think it only goes up to eight so the thing is so that's seven sides that's a level five cow that's those are purple cows are the ones that have seven sides as well but they're just not worth as many points right so they are literally for there at the very beginning to use to basically get Farmers but that's yeah I mean at the same time though if you don't put the farmers down they're two points a piece right so if you're just but then you're riddling your deck with fatigue because now they have fatigue cards that are worth minus two points um if they stay in your deck right they also dirty up your hands so that's all you're drawing and I mean I like the fact that these aren't like like oh God my I can't do anything there are there's a way to go and get rid of at least one and you wipe them from buenos areas each time right like so if your entire hand is fatigue cards rush to Buenos Aires and just burn them all yeah yep which again is also cool because there's another incentive to move your train up which is why I think they have this constant zero because that's the only time you would have a constant zero oh yeah if you had
a hand of nothing yeah yeah that's true and how much is that you get two minus two so it's not terrible like no what was it minus six something if you go to KC every time and here and you get slapped in the face so it's minus two but realistically you're if you have a whole hand of that it's minus eight uh two minus um twelve yeah one somewhere in between there so I'll take minus two points eight yeah yeah you're not getting any money so it's kind of a dead dead trip but at the same time like I said the further you move your train up instead of the incentive of being able to go further because that doesn't matter right uh it makes shortcuts and you can still make money over here kind of like all the all the punishing aspects of the original Great Western Trail aren't really here right like and that's why I say if you're gonna pick if you don't own either pick this one like Yeah The Grain might feel a little bit tight on your first playthrough but it's like I've played Great Western trailers yeah I've played Great Western Trail with multiple people who just could not get ahead right because it's very punching and if you play your first game and they just don't understand that you need to do better each time then they're gonna have like negative 40 points by the end and never want to play again right so this doesn't really happen I can't you'd have to almost really try to get negative points all you do is take objectives and never complete them right but even then you
can't take that many objectives and they're not worth that many negative points no no they're really not so you would like seriously have to try again ever buy cows uh just help farmers but even then the farmers give you two points for helping them right so one farmer cancels out one objective card that you didn't every time yeah huh yeah it's pretty hard to have mega points but you know probably a decent score somewhere close to 100 at least yeah yeah like like Zach said at the end of the run through my final score for the first time was 131 right and I got 137 so that's that's a level five cow difference right um in a completely different strategy than you did last time exactly and yours was basically the same score right one point difference um and kind of doing a different strategy because again they didn't get Cowboys and wasn't able to buy cows yeah yeah I mean and I also went and bumped up my my movement a lot quicker because I was like okay I want to go buy cows real quick and because you started going through it quicker forced me to start going through it quicker yeah to try to keep up which is this game is you have to thank people and normally like I wasn't doing that to be like he's gonna do nothing I was like my whole strategy buy cows go sell them buy cows myself and if I had a shitty hand and I'd have to be like okay now I need to go here and try and draw right and do my trains because like I gotta do trains right oh that's what this is okay so if you
get your cow or if you get your guy here you go back to the orange yeah I was I'm like what the hell is this yeah you go back to the orange marker I think the other one just tells you a number to go to so I actually kind of like that I have a symbol now for it I do too yeah because it's like it's very straightforward um and that's eight points for seven coins so that's that's another and it's only was that seven movement eight movement uh two four six eight yeah eight movement so eight movement which is not that hard to get you trained no especially if you just hold on to if you have three train operators that's not hard yeah exactly like if you're able to pull four yeah at some point which I had the ability to that would have been disgusting but I was sticking to my sticking to my cows right uh let's see I think that's pretty much it I mean we kind of touched on the sailing I I agree I also like the sailing more than the trains it's not as punishing because there's no bonuses for having to get you know cities next to each other right um because even some of those it's like like one of the pairings that Great Western Trail is a negative it's like a few negative points yeah um but you still get something with it uh yeah this one seems a little bit more open yes I guess in terms of strategy versus like like because like we said whenever I was going to Buenos Aires I'm like oh I only got 10. oh okay well there's an eight right there that's three points right and cool so that's
what I was like this does feel less punishing more open to strategy more open to different strategies but the counter for that to me is where Great Western Trail is about who is playing more efficiently um this is less of our efficiency versus kind of just going for something yeah so the two questions I posed at the beginning should you own both no I don't think so but I think we agree if you don't own either get this one yeah or you say okay I would probably get this one no I would say if it's between this or the second edition Great Western Trail and rails to the north then I'd say get the original with that expansion right but that's not inherently Fair even though I could also make the argument that this box feels like it came with the rails to the north expansion which with the cities yeah but I think without those cities that I would 100 oh yeah no that's that's very very true your brain would only matter for that the fact that these are in here that's that's part of the game yeah um yeah I would 100 switch I would go just straight up Great Western Trails if you didn't have these cities yeah so so I don't know I don't know if I want to keep both because now I am in that situation where I have both and it's like do I sell one of them right or do I because I like both of them at at like basically equally do I just keep both and just and just have them because it's like if I'm selling this one I have no reason why except to say I have the original but
there's a lot of stuff of this that I like better than the original right it's a very weird situation to be in because normally it's kind of like oh I have this kind of game I don't need another one right and this one it's like I have the exact same game just a different theme but there's a little bit more stuff I like about it see your case like because you already have two and you know you're going to get the third one me as a completionist at that point would just keep them right because then I have the trilogy of it yeah and it'd be really nice if like vertically the art like right like Blended together yeah that'd be really nice maybe it does I don't know probably doesn't it's Western enough that it will blend somebody together with itself I can see where it wasn't a trail I don't have to search for it we'll find out if it does then I'm just gonna keep both and be happy unless unless oh the Box uh is made a little bit different this is the sheen this is a little Sheen to it um nope unless the New Zealand is nighttime it's not it's like day
well because the New Zealand's actually really blew as you can see it on the uh side there they put the oh yeah you're right you're right but it does get me excited for New Zealand yeah like uh because I I'd imagine it would be the take do exactly what this one did but with sheep right so I don't know but yeah on a scale of one to ten what are you giving it's ten it's a ten yeah um like it's it's so good right it's so good and it just just reminds me like that I'm just in this wheelhouse of Euro games like I wasn't overly stressed trying to make sure I remembered every single rule I got to do what I wanted and I was engaged the entire time right and and there were active times where both you and I like I think I knew if you had gone to Buenos Aires you would have gotten the two points yeah and so I was like fine I'm gonna get I'm gonna do the same thing I'm gonna go to that guy well so I what I was trying I should do is for it not to end because I wanted to go one more time so the fact I had to go to Buenos Aires was the hope that I didn't hit I hit another one of these guys so you'd only be able to place one not because I didn't want to get the two points because I want to go back gotcha for this twin hit for the 20.
yeah I knew that was going to be the make or break would you have had the grain yeah yeah because this is plus three and all I had to do was get back up but if you had to rush it I could hit this almost I could hit this once for four and I could have gone another guy it would have been really really gotcha because I could have also moved six so I might have also but then well then you would have had one last turn anyway yeah yeah uh no I just need a one turn like just that one yeah and I was sitting here and I was like I need the game to end right so uh and yeah you pulled the engineer or the uh the Builder the Builder it's like I'm like yes yep I was assuming for the two I honestly didn't care it was literally just to try and get that 20 points because the 20.12 um bad enough for me to finish it then yeah yeah it would have been um uh just the 20 points there would have been one well because you wouldn't have had the eight right so it was like 12 points difference so oh you might have still lost actually because if if we take what the score is now minus your eight you put you would have been at 110 plus the 20 put it at 130 130 and that would have been minus the two so you would have been at 132 I've been at 135.
yeah if everything stays see if everything stayed the same so I think it would have been like a three-point difference with that 20. so but oh well uh yeah it's 10 out of 10. uh really just [ __ ] do whatever you want get both don't get either um I will say if you if you didn't like Great Western Trail you're not gonna you're not gonna like this no it's it's the same game but yeah you got anything else nope all right well that's our thoughts on Great Western Trail Argentina let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you