The Hegemony Podcast - Drive Thru FM #38
Transcript
hey everybody uh a little bit of a different thing today uh I'm going to going to do this podcast and I'm going to talk about geminy now I have had this thing sitting on my game table for a little over a week now I've played the game numerous times I've played it at all the different player counts I played with some of the expansion stuff I played the base game uh played multiple times and I am having a really hard time trying to talk about this game I really want to talk about this game I'm not actually sure how much I like the game I do like it quite a bit but I have some problems with it and none of these problems are really things that I think like I'm trying to you know uh warn people away from the game or anything like that because I want to do the opposite of that I want people to try the game if they haven't already tried it and I want them to check it out but it's kind of one of those things where you know if you watched the channel or listen to the podcast or anything like that you know I usually just do videos on things that I enjoy and then things that I don't really care for I kind of stick them in a podcast episode here and there just to kind of cover some of the other games that I've played that didn't quite you know it wasn't necessarily that they're all a bad game although I've talked about games that I think are bad games and but I've talked about games that are just like you know this okay you know we kind of miss the mark for me here and there and that's kind of what goes into the podcast and I've been really kind of
debating what to do with hegemony um now if you're not familiar with with hegemony I'll just explain it here in like one minute it's basically it's a one to four player game you play as either it's almost like you're playing as an idea you play as a capitalist as working class as middle class or as the state or the government so that's your role in the game it's like you are the state or you are the capitalist class or the working class and that's what you do and that is actually super interesting it sounds kind of boring I I could see people being like well that's kind of boring you're playing as like this this idea almost but the way that it comes across across in the game is you're playing like as those interests so you know it it works really really well in this game so the game is driven by card play and you can play a card for like the event written on the card the action on the card or you can just discard the card and take one of your kind of like basic actions so if you're the working class you can um you can go and like employ your workers at different business business that have been made available by the other players because all the other players can have businesses the capitalist class is that's all they really do is they have businesses the middle class is kind of like a combination of the working class and the capitalist class because they can have their own business and they have their own workers and they can send their workers to the businesses of their own or to the capitalist businesses and the
state or the government have their own businesses you know they've got public universities and all kinds of other different things and these are all represented byy cards on the board and you got little worker meeple type things uh that you can send out so you play the game over five rounds and everybody's got I think a hand of seven cards and then you play five of them and you keep the others and then draw new cards for the new round and there's a good interesting decision space about okay do I play this card because it's kind of like a more effective you know basic action with maybe some pros and cons or some drawbacks or something like that or maybe it's just not you know the right time to do this so I'm just going to you know now I have a decision here to discard this card which I know could be super useful at some point but you know it's not guaranteed that the extra effects of the card will be useful so all of like that part of the game really is very interesting like if you've played I don't know like a Twilight Struggle or you know maybe like a doe Imperium or something you've got that kind of hand management stuff of do I play the card for this or discard it for that and that kind of thing going on and then you've got this other kind of like economic engine going on underneath nothing like Twilight Struggle or doing Imperium but that sort of similar game Loop in a way is kind of there um and then everybody scores differently right so if you're putting businesses out as the capitalist you're trying to put them out you're trying to you know set wages as low as possible because each of the businesses you can
kind of move the wages back and forth based on different restrictions in the game and they're trying to just generate a bunch of money and then you collect all that money then around and then you move it to like your your treasury I forget the actual word for it but you know you put it in your um I'm sorry your Capital because you you you collect money like during the round then you move it from your Revenue to your capital and then you get taxed on that of course but um and that's kind of what you're doing you're going to score points on that whereas the um middle class and the working class they will kind of score based on their sort of prosperity because as you you know you get some money on that side you're going to buy health care you're going to buy education tokens that you can then spend to kind of like increase your population or upgrade your population when you do that you score some Prosperity points but the middle class also will score some points for their businesses at the end of the round and the state it works even differently um they can do different actions in the game that will give them kind of like favor with all three other classes and there's a little sort of favor track the game calls it a legitimacy track and you move up one space on three different tracks one for each of the other factions and then you score like your lowest two combined and then after everybody scores they kind of like reduce you know what they were scoring so the the state will actually have to lower the legitimacy score the um the prosperity score of the working
class and middle class will get lower the middle class actually drop a little bit faster faster and you got to kind of build them back up and that's kind of like your core like action round of the game but very importantly after the action round you're going to have this election phase and so there's different colored cubes for the different factions and though you can take action to put more of your cubes in and that kind of stuff and there's this on the board there's this like little grid of electoral type of issues and so you can take an action to say we're going to have a vote on this so we're going to move that left or right think it's a three 3 by3 grid so there's well there's some others on the side too but and So you you're moving stuff either left or right in its particular row so you've got three rows of three and depending on what the issue involves the working class might want it on the left or the capitalist class might want that issue on the right and when you move that and you have a vote that's going to affect a whole lot of different things on the board so the amount of like new workers that come into play the way the taxes are levied at the end of the round that kind of stuff or the amount of like business business deals available to the capitalist class and all these kinds of things so all of your worker placement kind of stuff your your action kinds of things where you're you're either giving money or paying money or putting workers out or building businesses and then consuming some workers all of that really revolves around this election phase and there's these purple cubes uh which don't match any of the different player colors those are influence cubes and so like the state
can be giving those out or the state can even sell those um and those come into play when you have an election and then you know there's like a tiebreaker everybody does like kind of a quick blind bid to uh submit influence to kind of Swing the vote either way um so everything is really revolving around um that election phase and that's also very very unique and interesting as well to see how that kind of works and then you of course you like you also pay taxes and stuff like that at the end and the game comes with and it's really crazy because it's feels like you're doing your real taxes almost but I don't want to that to scare people away because the game uh in In Praise of the game there's a ton of different player AIDS each faction has like a huge player Aid and then like a little mini player Aid and once you kind of get to know the game you don't really need the big one anymore just the little one to kind of give you a reference of like oh what are the actions I could do oh yeah I can do that but they also help you pay your taxes so it makes it very easy to look at because when you pay taxes you're like okay where is this particular issue on the the election track what's the tax rate okay how many buildings do I have or how many workers do I have what's my population what's my revenue and it kind of varies based on the players and then you just do a quick calculation and then you pay your taxes of course the taxes always go into the state player so that's kind of where they get some of their income and they can even like you know throw in like a I think I'm making this up a little bit but there's a card that does this I don't know if it's a vat tax or something but it's a card you can just go tax everybody in the middle of the round and then you of course
lower your legitimacy with all the factions because nobody wants that um so yeah so that's kind of how the game works there so the state is trying to keep everybody happy but also stay flush with with uh revenue or or capital in the state coffers because if you take a certain amount of loans because whenever you can't pay for something in this game you take a loan and then the state only can have a certain number of loans based on what where a particular issue is on the Electoral thing and if they don't if they they go over that by the end of that round then they have to um uh they the IMF has to get involved and like everything kind of resets it resets all of the um electoral St tracks to like a certain configuration uh the state's got to like pay off all their loans and kind of reset and they they lose some legitimacy and all that because the state government kind of just goes belly up and all that stuff um so that's what kind of keeps the state in check from just you know overspend spending so to speak and making sure that they you know tax enough and they don't spend too much um and so and the game has a lot of really interesting Concepts where I like that it doesn't shy away from this because there's a tendency and it's even like on the flavor text of the cards for example for the working class for example to go a little bit socialist right because um I know this is like in real life that's not necessarily the
case that you know all the workers and the labor in the world want to unionize and go socialist but there's certain things that you know Primal Concepts that a a workingclass person will want so it's like okay good it doesn't it doesn't shy away from the fact that you're playing around with socialism a little bit I like that and then there's like very anti-socialist you know Pro capitalist things that the capitalist is doing the state do really care which is nice because it's like oh the state just wants to make sure they can stay in business business as the state regardless of whatever um you know ideology is out there they're all kind of screwy anyway right because there some some ideology always leaves somebody out right I mean so they're all they're all screwy in a way and then the middle class probably the most interesting class I think because it's a real interesting balance of you know prosperity and worker Healthcare and education all that kind of stuff but also trying to get to the point where you're making some money on your own business is so it has a real good dichotomy and I think and this is kind of part of where the problem starts to appear is that I think for my money the middle class and maybe the state is probably almost like the most interesting you know factions to play whereas the capitalist and the working class is not as interesting because you kind of have you kind of have like a a
somewhat of a direct path to how you can get things done but having said that uh getting back to the elections that is where things really hinge on the on the Dynamics of keeping the game Dynamic I should say because like I said at the beginning you know work in class you want to get your workers out you want them to get paid you want to get enough money to um you know upgrade your Prosperity get grow Better Health Care better education and all that kind of stuff and there's there's a little bit of like a feeding phase as well where the working class and the middle class have to have food to feed their people and of course they can buy it from the state or the capitalist class or even the middle class can have their own thing and the um the the middle class can have their own thing and the working class can build farms actually and they generate their own food there so it's kind of like a um uh communal Farms I think the card's called you can build two of those but you have to have a certain number of conditions set up just to to construct those so the path of a capitalist in the working class is is pretty straightforward board but it it does stay dynamic because of the election phase because that's going to change how things interact on the board because you're not just like you know you're not just like looping the same thing although sometimes it can feel like that in my opinion with the capitalist and the working class you're like okay I just got to get Workers out get them paid you know and the capitalist like I guess I got to get business out I got to lower wages because I don't want to pay too many wages I don't want to pay too many taxes I got to keep taxes low I just want businesses and I want to automate those businesses because there's ways to automate that you can put out a car doesn't require workers or if you
upgrade like a card and maybe it requires one or two workers and then you can upgrade it to Automation and then it generates even more so you don't need as many workers there um but the conditions of the electorate were going to change that and that's where the game really really shines I think in a way then the part I don't like about that is it's a little bit of a grab bag of things because when you do an election you draw out five cubes everybody votes beforehand you say I'm either for or against this change on the track and then you grab five cubes and then the color of those cubes will go to basically like who showed up to vote right and then then you can you can blind bid your influence your purple cubes after the election to see maybe you can swing the vote a little bit so it's like you get a kind of sense the electorate and then you can kind of then you have some more actual voting with the players and it works really well but it can be a little bit random and so if you win your your cubes come out of the bag you've spent your political Capital right if you lose that that particular vote your cubes go back in the back so you got a greater chance of you know winning the next election but where I kind of come down on this um where I'm very in the middle because I I really enjoy this game I I recommend people give it a try um and you know especially if you've got a friend that has it I definitely give it a shot it kind of comes down to some issues I have just kind of like I guess the what it ends up being for me is very much just a three and a four
player game which is fine um there's nothing wrong with that I mean there's some some games that are exactly one player count they're either just a three-player game or just a four player game or just a two-player game but it's a little bit disappointing because I got some of the expansion stuff so I should say they sent me a review copy a while ago end of last year and then I went and picked up the expansions because the first couple plays of this I enjoyed and I really wanted to try this you know solo and that kind of stuff and and and uh with some of the other expansion stuff so I just have the one uh what's it crisis and control expansion I didn't get the um uh the event historical event cards but I have played with them A friend of mine has that so we played with that as well and I do not like the solo game I'm just going to work walk through the player counts here the solo game I think is is not fun um I tried there's two solo modes there's like a basic one which is to me just kind of all over the place and there's an advanced one which to be honest I only played about half a game because it's so cumbersome to run it's just not fun at all and it takes up a ton of table space I think there's even apps out there that kind of simulate it but it's just it takes up too much of my headp space to to then want to go and actually play you know whatever my role is what I'm playing as um in the in the game I just don't really really like it at all and the two-player game is just uh working class and capitalist class that is not that that interesting it's it just doesn't really work you kind of
you need the other classes involved and so I'm not really speak I played it one time I don't really know that that's that's worth doing now three and a four player game those I like so in a three player game Everybody Plays except the state you still have a state you can still bankr up the state and that's kind of an interesting thing because even in a three-player game even though there's nobody actively driving the state then if you get things in such a situation that they're going to go bankrupt and the IMF has to come into play that gives the other three players there a tool to kind of monkey with or even threaten in a way and that I mean three player might even be my favorite way to play the game because I really like that his interesting because you know okay well if this gets bankrupt all these you know electoral things are going to reset this is going to move here and these businesses are going to close down from the uh state government and so you got to kind of play with that um so that is actually pretty interesting the three-player game as how that works now I can see some people are not really liking that so then the four-player game of course everything's in play but again I think a little bit because of the kind of the asymmetry there's something about the asymmetry that bugs me and especially when the state comes into play because it feels like you're playing and this is a good and a bad thing it feels like you're playing a totally different game than everybody else it's almost like you're playing a negotiation game as a state and the other players at different time times may or may not really be interested in having any kind of
negotiation with you or really dealing with you at all like you just are sort of like a punching bag as a in a way as the state and you're just kind of doing stuff and just handing out favors and that kind of stuff and it doesn't really you're not really engaged in that way so like now having played all the different four factions it it's it's strange because it feels interactive but it's only because of the election there's other parts of the game where you know there's a certain kind of level of unfairness in a way um like as the as the working class if I get some workers out there and then like the capitalist class builds it you know depending on the action that they take they can take and just gobble up the working class but as the working class I want to get certain workers in certain buildings because then I can unionize and that's one of the ways that the working class is going to win is by when they unionize they can score more points and stuff but it feels kind of unfair if you've got this plan as the working class to go and you know have your workers all snatched and it totally kind of screws up your strategy now it's realistic right because working class is not it's not a hegemony right it it isn't one people are individuals they go work where their money is right they're not all all always on the same page so thematically it makes all kinds of sense right and that's a lot of what this game is it's like thematically like oh that's really cool that's really cool that's really cool but then when you're sitting down to like try to win and try to have a strategy there's little things like
that that come in and you're like dang it like I can't you know I can't work around this so this gets even more exacerbated because like so in the state side you have these events there's always like two events and these are like crisises and catastrophes and things like that just different you know shifts in The Winds of life and those things happen and the government has to deal with those um and there's different you got to do like sometimes you got to pay money or do different things and then that will increase your legitimacy uh with different factions but if you don't get to them then it will drop legitimacy with one or more different factions and sometimes those come up and they're like they kind of make sense and sometimes you're like I just I won't be able to do this one so that's just going to harm me and I found that the expansion events because there's another deck you can just swap the decks out is even worse on that way um and that this will kind of lead me into the expansion idea cuz like the expansion stuff I didn't like it all I don't like the solo stuff I don't like the new events uh that the government gets I don't like the the historical ones because they're just really like unfair to a large degree and just random and chaotic and that's kind of the thing that's the interesting this is again why I'm doing this is the interesting conundrum because I do kind of feel like the base game after a while gets a little bit stale like it gets a little bit predictable once you've played you know and I've played this a few times now and played every single faction So you you're going to get some plays out of it before you get to that point for sure but once you get to that you kind
of feel like yeah okay I've been down this road before you know um once you know a rooll and get into it like you kind of know exactly what you have to do so it becomes less interesting the more you've played it and the one thing I was hoping for is that like oh the expansions will kind of add some some flavor and stuff like that but the way that they come off and this could be just also like lack of experience with it cuz I haven't played a ton with the expansion stuff but it comes off of just like a little bit of unfairness and that will kind of Swing the game especially if like all players at the table kind of like know what know what they're doing they're kind of equal equally skilled that kind of stuff oh and the other thing yeah the hidden agendas just kind of see randomly if they're good do them if they're not then don't because some I got in the one game I played with HD agendas I got both I'm like these are both awful the one was was just objectively terrible to do I was like I don't want to do this this at all and then the other one I was like I'll try to go for that one and but I'm like okay and we calculated out I you said by going for that you got eight points but you cost yourself 20 you know what I mean so I was like why did I even have this because I wanted to do it just because I got a hidden agenda I want to try it out and by the end of the game I'm like I know that screwed me that we calculate it out so you basically cost yourself 20 points by doing that and I'm like yeah I know I was like this is awful like I would better have not even have drawn these um but somebody else did one and it was like yeah it just happened to work and it was like an extra eight points for them and I was like that sucks you know because it just kind of worked out um
and so the expansions I would definitely just stay away from all of those and just play with the base game um and I think the base game will give you a good handful of plays um and there's nothing wrong with that right and and I think for me this is one of those games where you know I usually play a game a few times before I review it but um this is one of those where I kept kind of going back at it trying to kind because it's this is also like a tricky one to sit there and talk about and you know having my notes here it's much easier to kind of just do this on audio with how things you kind of work in the game instead of like throwing up on a video and it it didn't really quite work out that way because it's like these really sort of elusive abstract Concepts that you know It's tricky because like I said you're taking on a role of an idea and it's kind of interesting the the thing I really love about the game is like I'm sitting there inhabiting the Mind space of a workingclass person not not even necessarily like a person that is a workingclass person but is somebody that believes in the working class and when you're in the capitalist space you're like you believe in capitalism you believe in the middle class you know you believe in that balance of those and the state you kind of believe in you know in organization and structure and predictability and everything is going you're out of your way so when you're in that kind of mental space that's super cool and fun because it just kind of
puts you in empathetically in a lot of different spaces and I think that's really neat but then on the other side I'm like okay now I'm trying to win the game I'm trying to play the game it just kind of like starts to unravel a little bit and sort of the purpose of what I'm sitting there to do after having experienced all the different factions and kind of the mental space which is really really awesome it's like okay now I want to try to win this and I was like oh man this is just kind of going to happen and I don't feel like I have exactly the kind of control I would like to have in some of these things I mean there's obviously good and bad moves and things that you can do but it a lot of it feels a little bit more chaotic than I would like for for what the game is is is doing and a lot of it is like I said driven by the election side of things and that's really that negotiation around the election kind of really is the game and there I think there's some skill and stuff involved with that and so the way that the winds kind of Swing there is going to help out and dictate some of the game uh you know because that's that's G to that's going to dictate how much money you either have to spend or don't spend in different phases of the game um and so once you kind of done that a few times that gets a little bit like okay so we just kind of played we did everybody did the right thing and then the election kind of swung this way or that way now I think there's definitely still room for like Improvement you know on my side and some of my friends that have played and kind
of playing around that space But I think for me at the end like as much as I really like that thematically and how it kind of binds all the factions together in a gameplay sense I think it's a little bit like like that's not really my cup of tea right kind of the the drawing of the cubes and the blind bids to swing the influence and that kind of stuff because things can just go I mean it's still a random B draw and I don't think it's a bad design either I don't think that's terrible I think it makes sense it works thematically and it's interesting but it's also at the end of the day I'm just like oh man I don't really feel like I'm going to be in the mood a lot of the times to do this because that's not really what I'm sitting down to do at the game table but I think you know my group is is is mostly positive on it like I am I think they're probably even a little bit more positive on it um that you know not everybody I mean there's another fellow in the group he's probably right in the same space that I am we've talked about it a little bit and uh and yeah so it's just going to be kind of find that tricky fit and that tricky Niche but I think it's worth experiencing I I think it's worth people trying it and taking a look at it um I would avoid the expansions that's my only real recommendation just play the base game and I think you're fine and play it with three or four players three's good you know it's nice to have the state in there but again the state feels sort of I don't know I'm not sure the state is my least favorite faction it should be my most favorite like thematically it's interesting but the best faction is probably the middle class but then it's
nice because you've got that three-prong thing you've got the capitalist and the working class and the middle class kind of like in the middle and so that Dynamics really really cool and then you can Al you can kind of and you can just all beat up on the state you know because if there's no player there then he can just you know manipulate it like your heart's content and like I said three player might be my favorite player count because of that and the person there's no person there like having a bad time you know in the game it's just some voiceless entity there anyway so I just wanted to kind of share some of my thoughts on this it's been sitting there I've been like I got to do something about this because it's just bugging me I've got some other games to review and stuff and this one I can't just let this one sit it's going to it's been bothering me honestly uh figuring out like how to talk about this game so uh hopefully this kind of just overall kind of broad conversation is helpful to somebody uh helpful to me to get it off of my chest um but anyway that's a little bit of hegemony um so hopefully folks found this useful thanks