Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 13:33

Become a paleontologist and create the most prestigious exhibition of extinct dinosaurs and massive mammals in First Giants.

Thank you for joining us at Tantrum House Studio D. I'm Melissa Dell.

And I'm Kevin Delp. Today we're taking a look at First Giants, a competitive tableau building game for two to five players published by Space Cowboys who sent us this game to review.

It's designed by Matthew Dunstan and Brett Gilbert. These two also designed Elysium more than 10 years ago and First Giants is a re-implementation of it.

Now we'll explore that a little bit later in the video, but first we'll give a quick overview of the game and then divide the rest of the video into our four C's, our thoughts on components, critiques, accommodations, and then conclusions.

In First Giants, players are collecting fossils from different dig sites and building up a small engine in their study. The cards you collect can trigger abilities, give you amber, earn points, or combo with other cards.

But here's the catch. Eventually, you want to move those cards out of your study and into your display area for scoring. And once they leave the study, those cool abilities are gone.

On your turn, you do one of these two things. You take a card from a dig site you haven't visited or recall your workers to gain amber and display fossils for points. When you recall your workers, you'll have the option to move cards to your display area.

And this is where a majority of your score comes from. You are either collecting sets of cards like all twos of a different color or creating a run of all the same color. Set tokens give points as they overlap between the cards. If a set or run is complete, those tokens flip over and you'll get even more points.

The game end is triggered either when the deck of cards runs out or when someone takes the last set token from the supply. And whoever has the most points wins.

All right, let's move on to our four C's starting with components. The artwork on the cards is this watercolor fossil journal type feel. It's really clean looking um on the table. They're not screaming for attention, but it has this really good aesthetic that I think off it's pretty well.

Yeah, and I think the iconography is easy to understand. It's simple, like you said, kind of streamlined and clean. So, it's easy to understand what the cards do, especially once you learn the icons.

And you have wooden components in the game. I'm a fan of wooden components. Uh the player pieces, uh there's four. You have these four tokens uh that you're placing out on the board. They all have unique shapes, unique designs, and of course unique colors. So, yeah, I I like that in the game as well. And the amber is glass, so it's an upgraded component.

And then, the setup is pretty easy. It's a card-based game, so there's not a whole lot of setup. You do need the right number of the set tokens at the beginning for a pool. Otherwise, pretty simple, and the storage is nice and neat with the boxes that come with the game.

All right, let's move on to our critiques. This is a pretty streamlined game, so a lot of the cards are similar to each other. You're getting resources, you're getting amber, you're getting points. I mean, it's pretty simple, so you know, in a card game that you want a lot of different things going on, this is probably not the game for you.

All right. Yeah, uh and it can be sometimes a little difficult to complete the sets that you're working on because the cards that you need just aren't coming [snorts] out. Maybe I need a purple three, and it's just not coming out. Or, when it does come out, it's at a site that I've already visited, so I can't go there until I recall my workers, and there's no guarantee it will still be there afterwards. There's also a bit of a race aspect, so if you're having trouble getting the cards you need, other players can swoop in and beat you to those bonus tiles, cuz basically whoever has the most of that specific set has the tile, and then whoever completes that set basically locks in that bonus scoring tile. So, you have to watch out for that in our games.

I had started a couple sets, and then people kept swooping in and taking those tiles from me, so.

Yeah, I think you really got to know when to move them down from the study into [clears throat] your exhibit into your display. The timing of that, I think, is key and can punish some players.

Yeah, but you have to be able to get the cards first even.

That's true, too. Um, I think this game could feel a little samey after a few few plays because you're just trying to get sets or runs, and there's it's it's not like there's a lot of numbers, there's only one, two, and three. So, you're Or was one, two, three, four? No, it's one, two, three. Yeah, it's one, two, three.

of each color.

color.

But, um, the

Yeah.

um, the each one does a little something different. Each two, so it's not like every two has the exact same value.

scoring wise, you're getting Are you getting all the ones? Are you getting all the twos? Are you getting all the threes?

And so, the amount of amber you have to pay equals the value of the card. A set of all threes, five threes, scores exactly the same of as a set of all ones, but it costs a lot more.

Mhm. Yeah, so I I think that's okay, cuz the game plays pretty fast. So, I'm just saying it feels a little samey, but it probably even though this is our critique, it's I think it's okay it's an okay thing.

Okay, well, let's move on to our commendations.

I'm always a fan of games that keep uh moving. And in this game you only have four choices uh on your turn at the beginning and then that those uh choices diminish as you're cuz back to you because uh you have to place your token on an an area where you already don't have your token. So, I think that um helps people with little AP. What do you think?

I yes, I sometimes get a little bit of analysis paralysis and the options are reduced, so that is helpful. Although, you can always choose to pull them back and then have more options next turn.

Yep.

[snorts]

Um one of the things that I enjoy about the game is there is a little bit of tension and strategy with the cards that you have collected and they're in your study and maybe they're working really well for combos, they're giving you points or triggering when things happen. How long do you keep them up there and when is the right time to bring them down? Am I chasing after a specific bonus token? Do I need to pivot to a different strategy because of what other players are doing? Maybe I have one two down and I'm I could go either for the twos or that color and Kevin starts going for the twos. Well, maybe I go oh, maybe I should do the color instead of

the yes. Try something else. Um so, for a light quick game, there is some good strategy and tension.

I also like games with uh player interaction maybe might be the right word. It's not like you're hurting other players. In this game you're actually helping other players. There's one ability um that has these or one cards that have dinosaur icons on them. I think they're on all the ones.

Well, only on ones.

They're only on the ones and um when you have that in front of you and someone else takes that card that has a little dinosaur icon, it activates your card as long as it's in the study. In your study and it feels like really like down to full and then you know, beneficial.

You get an emperor.

You get points, and you get points, you know, especially if you have the dinosaur cards that have the dinosaur icons on them. So, that feel good. Also, the other card ability that I like is taking a card that has the same

color and from the same family.

same family of cards. That's cool because like, "Oh, I'm going after yellow. Doesn't look like anybody else is going after yellow. So, hopefully, I can get into the yellow card." which activate this card, and activate that card, and you sort of like It's not a like combo combo combo, but it's like a little bit of a like, "Oh, combo combo."

Little bit of a tiny tiny string.

Yeah, a little tiny string, and then Yeah, going back to the tensions like, "When do I take those cards and put them down in my I want to wait as long as possible." But then, another person be like, "Oh, Kevin's going after yellow. Maybe I need to get after yellow so I can get those into my exhibit early." I don't know. There's just there's a little bit of that going on.

Yeah. So, you're kind of reading what other players are doing and figuring out how long you want to keep your combos. Another thing that the game does well is the rulebook has the icons on the back page, so easy reference for what everything does. There's also a separate appendix booklet that goes through every card in the game. It has some information about the different families of prehistoric dinosaurs, reptiles, animals. So, there's a lot of good information in that appendix book.

I think the game flows really easily. You don't feel overloaded with a lot of rules going into the game, and you can take I think meaningful choices in the game, and sometimes you feel pretty clever as you're doing it.

Okay. Yeah, I would say that this game is easy to teach and get to the table. It's a quick game, so it would fit well in that casual 30 to 45 minutes of trying to get something lightish to the table, but like Kevin was saying still has some meaningful choices.

All right, let's move on to our conclusions. So, we mentioned at the beginning of the video that we were going to compare First Giants to Elysium. Like we said, over 10 years ago from Space Cowboys same designers. Right away, you'll notice that this game bigger.

Yes.

Longer. It's an hour to play maybe a little bit longer than an hour 30 minutes. Two to four players for Elysium, two to five players for First Giants. So, some just initial comparisons. So, in Elysium you are getting cards and building up your powers and then sending those cards to your Elysium to score points and you're losing abilities in the process. So, there's that and you can sort of see there's that core in First Giants, but I think First Giants is maybe a little bit more approachable and stream lined with getting cards and putting them in to your display to your Elysium.

So, you would say they have similar DNA?

Yeah, similar DNA. Thank you. Got it.

I will admit that when I first played First Giants, Elysium did not cross my mind at all. It wasn't until I saw

10 years.

Right. It wasn't until I saw the designers and and that it was a re-implementation that I made the connection. I don't think they're trying to be the same game. It's not like, "Oh, we're remaking Elysium." Because of what Kevin said, it is much more simplified, streamlined, shorter. It's hitting a different player demographic, I think. Because Elysium had more variability with more families, more combos, a lot more stuff going on. Personally, from a game play's perspective, I enjoy Elysium more because it has more going on, more variability, a little bit more strategy. But, I think from a practicality standpoint, First Giants is something that I would get to the table more and play with more people. So, I think it probably was a good direction for uh the company to make a more streamlined, simplified game that has some of the same feel.

So, uh it's [clears throat] not going to replace Elysium for me.

No, we'll keep both games. And And I would say, too, for my perspective, yes, easier to get to the table, First Giants, plays in half the time, you can play more players. And I think that's where our group currently is.

Right. The evolution of our

Our group we have on our game nights, we have more players that we're trying to get around the table. So, we're looking for that five or six-player count games. So, that hits that spot right there.

shorter games, you know, half an hour to an hour.

Right. I I'm trying to think. Yeah, I also liked Elysium, but man, now that I can sort of compare the two, it's a little bit more restrictive

Mhm. [clears throat]

in how to get cards and, you know, what cards are available. And And whereas First Giants, there's a little just more freedom going on, I think.

flexible.

Yeah, that's more flexible. So, I think I like First Giants a little bit better right now. I'm not saying I don't like Elysium. I just think First Giants is a little bit better. Now, if you enjoy games where timing matters, you like a little race uh going on, um I think um that tension between getting the cards down into your display,

Your Elysium.

I get your display, um when to do that, I think you'll really enjoy First Giants.

So, let us know in the comments, have you played Elysium? And what is your favorite set collection game?

Thanks for watching. Please like and subscribe.

Progress saved