Skip to main content
Loading video...

Luthier Review: The Classiest Game of 2025. Is It Sharp, or Flat?

Transcript 29:54

Hello and welcome to board stupid. My name's L. I'm Matt and this is our review of Luthia, the art of the instrument. Luthia takes you back to the golden age of classical music, classical western music at least with this wonderful production where we are famous Luia families making amazing musical instruments. Uh, and if you would like to find out what we make of this game about making instruments, yeah, you hit the subscribe button. Do that. It sings a song inside my heart. I don't know how it works, but it does happen. It does happen. Exactly. You compose the music of my soul by subscribing. Uh, and then that should we dig into this review? Yeah, let's go. Cuz it's a beefy one. It's a beefy one. Rolling dice.

It's a vibe for stupid we will use for you and me. Here's what you should play and see in Luia. You're a prestigious instrument maker in the golden age of western classical music, vying to earn the favor of nobles and composers through the masterful craftsmanship of your instruments. Each round, you'll secretly assign your numbered influence tokens, think of them as workers or members of your luia family, to various action spaces on the board. Then during the resolution phase, those spaces will trigger in order with the highest value token taking priority and claiming the most powerful rewards. You're going to be gathering wood, metal, and string, hiring skilled artisans to boost your workshop, and competing for highpaying commissions from those demanding patrons. Your timing and bluffing are crucial to outmaneuver your opponents and gain the edge. You will complete instruments to gain prestige, unlock bonuses, and earn endame points, all while expanding your workshop and reputation across Europe. Luia blends tactical bidding, resource management, and interaction into this wonderfully thematic musical experience.

Okay, Matt, we tried to condense what this game is into our normal 60-second highle overview, but it's a beefy one. It is quite difficult to do. Uh there's a lot there's a lot going on. So let's dig into some of that in more detail about what this game really is. And as we briefly referenced, at its core, this is a worker placementish game combined with hidden bidding. Hidden bidding. Yeah, exactly. And that I think it's one of the most um particular mechanics of this game. And in general, like I haven't seen many doing this kind of like work placement uh with a with a bidding incorporated. And um it works really really well. Yeah. So as opposed to some other games where you might have open bidding with the worker placement where you might bump people out or push people along or they'll have to pay something like in maybe Sig with these or in Panama or even in Galactic Galactic. This instead is everyone plays their workers face down. Uh and then you have a resolution phase where people begin to reveal them and then they'll all be resolved in a certain order and that actually creates this really interesting interaction. Yeah. Because between the players Yeah. Because if you are going to play a more powerful worker, uh you are going to be getting first pick of all of the cool stuff.

Yeah. Uh and that might upset you if you've played a less powerful worker and the cool thing that someone is going to be doing it. At the same times you it's really important who's going first, who's going last cuz actually it's one of those games where going last is not a bad thing cuz you can see where where all the other people have placed their bet/worker and uh if you see that it's you want really to do an action and no one put the worker there. You are the last one. You can throw in the the very one yourself. Absolutely. So, let's talk about these a little bit because I actually really I I like all of these different options and the game does give you lots of options and they're all interlin in an interesting way. Yeah, it's again it's a quite as you can see it's a quite wide game. Uh there are multiple section multiple uh mini section of the of the board. You will have your patron board. You will have the um performance bar uh piece. So you will have the where you actually bind the the instrument where you repair the instrument and then you got the central board that is the uh it's the orchestra where you place your instruments once built but again not finishing that you got a market uh you got the the first player track awards. You got your own personal boards. So there there are a lot a lot of things moving on on this game. However, everything feels with with with a reason. Everything's got a reason. Everything has purpose. Yeah, I agree. And actually, Palverson have done

what they've did with Distilled. This is the the folks behind Distilled where yes, this is a very sort of classical modern Euro type design. Uh but they've managed to weave the theme into all of the rule explanations, all of the rule book into everything throughout the game play quite well. Even though this is, you know, just various mechanisms blended together, but it's done really nicely, I think. Yeah, absolutely. And uh let me open up a small paragraph about the um all the study that the guys did behind the scene about the so all the character all the patreon all the lutter families uh the instruments and all of that. The guys have literally hired musicologist to actually tell them like this was this, this was that, this person was doing this, this person was playing this instrument, this leader was specializing this and you will find all of that in into the game and I find that something that is a super cool place in the rule books there's like uh biographies for everyone that features here. You got Mozart and Beethoven and hand all these people and that's all I think it's a fabulous thing. No, it is cuz when you do like a a sci-fi or a fantasy team, it's pretty easy just to throw like, oh, this this is this this is that uh while actually bringing in like real historic person. It takes an extra extra work that was not needed but is mega cool that is so well interwoven into the uh into the gameplay as well.

It really is. And let's talk about that interaction between these like the theme that they've done here and the the mechanisms that they've been implemented. As we said, you are luders making instruments. Uh and you will literally be doing that at the guild for example, you've got these plans, these great ideas of making instruments and they're going to be roughed in on your tool bench cuz each player has their own playerboard which is your bench where you're working. Exactly. So it's divided in two sections or on the left hand side you put in the the ones the the rough version of the instrument you will have to pay um a certain condition to move it on the other side. That's where you're going to refine the instruments. Yeah. Polishing and blah blah blah and then you pay even more and then you basically finish that instrument. then the instruments could give you just points. But what you want to do is having one of the Patreon to actually assign an instrument to uh cuz uh all the patreons are basically the dudes that going to pay pay you for your instrument for for your for your hard work and um basically what you what you're trying to do at the end of the game is is trying to fulfill as many patrons as possible cuz the patron is the easiest things to give you uh more bonuses and more point. Each patron will request different things. Someone wants a violin. Someone's wants you to a piano. Some of them wants a piano and you to uh fix their trumpet that's broken. And then they also want you to do a performance in the Exactly. Some of them are very demanding. Yeah. But at

the same time there is this uh very cool uh mechanisms that is the patience of your patron. Okay. I want to side paragraph here. I want to talk about that. That's one of my favorite things. That is one of after the bidding stuff is that's a very cool thing. Yeah, absolutely. As we says, all of the patrons have their needs, right? But who who doesn't have needs? But they are going to be kind of like tety and a little bit impatient with you and you need to keep them satisfied. So each patron will give you gifts. Yeah. Over a period of three rounds because they're rich. They're rich and famous. They're famous. So each round passes. They're like, "Have something extra. Please make my instrument. It's been a few weeks." And you're like, "Okay, don't worry about it. I'll get to it. You can move their patients queue back in a few different ways. You can satisfy one of their sub requirements. Yes. Um or in the salon where the patronons hang out, you can use a particularly high value worker to again just talk to them and be like, "Don't worry, I'm a nice guy. I got you, man. I've got you, man. Don't worry. I know it's been a few weeks."

Like Matt was basically absolutely rinsing this rich guy. The rich lady just weeks after weeks, I'll get it done. Don't worry. All I need is a couple of very demanding lady. It was giving me money at the a lot of money at the start of every turn and I was basically just given a little bit every turn to get back into my grace and and kind of like milking more money as possible to help fund other instruments. Yeah, exactly. So it's it's it's very cool because then you can have up to three patron at the same time and if you pick right uh they can kind of like interact with each other. Exactly. Because one at the at the start is going to give you money. Another one's going to give you some some resources that then you can use to fulfill a third one and and so on. So it's um there there is a lot going on but the this mechanics about the uh the patron losing their patient. Of course, if after three turns you haven't fulfilled any of their needs and points, you lose prestige. Goodbye.

Yeah, exactly. Cuz then no, they going to work with you. They tell their friends not to go to bother, which is an amazing thing. So, you make the instruments for your patrons, but as we said, some patrons also want you to do a great performance in the orchestra. So, let's talk about this whole section of the board. Yes. So, this is cool. It's basically where you're using your instrument to Yeah. or you give it to a famous performer of the day and they'll perform with your beautiful instrument there with their stratabari violin. Uh and this has this kind of quasi area control type thing going on. Yeah. If you are the first to make an instrument, you can take the first chair in the orchestra orchestra and get a cool bonus. At the same time, if you want to if you repair instruments or if you do a performance, you got ways to influence this board. But the instruments are king.

Basically at the end of the of the game, you want as many instrument as possible in the first chair position and you're going to score points based on how many first chair you get. So that is uh more way of making of making points. But yeah, it's a little cool more territorial control. Yeah. Yeah. Um but going back to the performance one, this is the um it's going to be the only section where you're going to roll some dice. All the rest is very deterministic. is about this this cost you this resource this cost you this money you need this this and that um while the performance of course because you can have some stage fright you can have some stage fright there could be I don't know you might have that guy that you hate sitting next to you playing you feel like angry that they took first chair they're like I deserve first chair and yeah so you're chucking the dice for that yeah you're chucking dice and depending on the scoring that on your dice you're going to get better or worse um um results money resources or or the chance to put tokens again in the orchestra influencing the area control. This is another way to get tokens. Exactly. But uh let's talk about trucks cuz there is a truck that you can climb in the performance section is the more you perform. So with with higher value to talk to workers on that um you going to climb up this ladder that means it's going to give you more dice. So you make you roll the dice makes make that section of the board uh easier. Yeah.

Same thing you're going to have one on the opposite side for repair. Yeah. The crafting and repairing. Yeah. because you can be really good at repairing that. So, you can go up to the repairing truck that's going to make you even better at repairing and give you more uh more rewards. Makes your uh creating instruments easier, gives you better bonuses when you create instruments, but let you do two at a time. Yeah. Which is a really cool bonus as well. So, there's some really cool stuff by going up this track as well. And then you have the final track which is in the balcony uh of the orchestra, obviously. Uh, and this is another place where you can put your workers where you are going to be uh given the opportunity to commit to certain public goals like who's going to create the most certain types of instrument or have the most performances in the orchestra. And if you go there, it will let you claim one of those unlocking a bunch of other stuff. Uh, and you're hobnobbing with all the important people so you can get a bunch of money that way as well. And modifying the the first player track so you can decide where to go um if if you want to change it. So yeah, a lot a lot of pieces. There is a lot on the board.

There is a lot to to keep track all the time. Uh what we have me we just mentioned was the market. The market is another action that you can do where you just buy um uh resources. It's very cool how is it done because you got a deck of card that will tell you how much the resources cost. The resources are um uh animal leather, uh wood, iron, metal. Metal metal. Yeah. iron of whatever whatever metal shiny stuff basically. Uh but each round the the cards of the um of the market is going to change. So the price of each elements are are going to change. That means that if you see that the metal that is the most prestigious and more more costy bits uh for in in a round is really low, you might want to invest a little bit more coin for the next rounds when it's going to be more expensive. So um up on the market as well is really it's another really uh cool out they've done on it. Yeah. So I mean there is so much to this game uh with there's apprentices which we I don't think we can even really cover.

There's like a lot going on adds a little bit more to your workers but yeah but yeah in general there is a lot going on but it is relatively okay to gro it wasn't too difficult to absorb I don't think but we'll cover that I think in the uh final thoughts. Matt, do you want to talk about this theme and how it makes you feel? Let's go. Well, we can say that this game has a production level pretty good, isn't it? And this this is not even the this is the retail version. So, whatever you see here is the retail version. There was the Kickstarter version. If you got that one, well, lucky you. That was uh that was a lot. Even the the dice tower is an actual mini organ that will play sounds whenever there was like an actual conductor's whatever that's called the stick.

Look at that. All sorts going on in that kickstarter crazy edition over. But um if we stay to the retail edition, so if you haven't backed it and you want to go and buy it, is it worth your money? Uh yeah, I think so. There is so much in this box. My god. So let's just let's start with the artwork. Uh Vincent Dut, who I love deeply. Yeah. Uh just I love you, Vincent. I I love his artwork. It's so nice and it is so beautiful. So, it's so warm. It is, right? It's a really beautiful um It's evocative, amazing design. I think it's so beautiful. And at at the same times, the design and the UX of the of the games, they go very very well together. Cuz I I have to be honest, the first time that I saw the board, I was like, "Wow, this that's that's busy busy busy." Uh but actually when you then sit down on the table you're like ah no that's this is that this is I paid for this I get this and uh everything is actually pretty clear.

Of course there are small icons there. I need to wear my glasses too. It is what it is is my eyesight is going downhill like like very very rapidly. Um but no everything from the cards to the board to the player boards. Um, it's very readable and um, everything done in a very good quality like cardboards and all the wooden pieces and uh, the different wooden pieces, the the wooden chips and and all the rest is is an it goes extra. It could have he could have had less, but I'm glad that it's not. Yeah, me too. I think it's fabulous. You have um very uh, unique pieces. Uh we will mention that in this first printing that we have there are a couple of uh missing tokens I think and they may be a print error uh which we'll reach out and confirm. Uh but but it did not um did not affect the game. So that was just FYI if you have a first edition just to check through everything. I'm sure the guys can ship the ship anything extra if there is anything. We're talking about literally like a me. It's a piece. Yeah.

Yeah. A piece. Okay. Wayne. Um, let's start saying where do you think the complexity of the game sits in our complexity meter? In the complexity meter. Yeah. Probably up on screen now. Uh, this is I think has to be an expert game. For me, this is an expert game like somewhere in the middle of the expert category. It is right in the center. It is of that typical style of game that you see a lot of in the last sort of six or seven years I think where you have these big wide modern inverted commas Euro style game where it's lots of different options and all of them interlink in some way or other. They'll either be mini games or they'll be the same thing kind of interwoven in different ways. Uh, and when you have that type of game with lots of interactions and lots of different choices, if you're it is for me that's an expert. Yeah, it I I do agree with you. It's probably on the lowest end of the the lower end of the of the expert, not to the not to the max. It's not put this We've had this discussion a few times. It's below the Galactic Cruise level for us in terms of complexity.

Yes, it is. Is it below set 30 or above 30? Uh, probably I would say slightly below set. You think so? Just because just because it's on set it's got a lot of like mini games going on. Well, this feels pretty like organic and all this but let's say for for the discussion to be at the same level of something less like setting. It's an expert game. Oh, there we go. I think that's that's entirely fair. Yeah. And in terms of who this game is for, Matt, me and you have musical backgrounds. We've I've loved music forever. Uh me as well musical education and I grew up playing music and I absolutely love it and the the whole theme of this speaks to me. I think it's brilliant. Uh I play instruments and I love the idea of you know how you build instruments and the history of that and how they came into being. So this whole thing is really cool. So I think if you are a board gamer uh that likes a a like a heavier Euro game uh Euro style game and you have an interest in music, I think this has got to be one for you, right? Yeah, it is. I think um it's it's always easy or easier for the the theme to go onto uh fantasy or space or abstract or or whatever you want to do it. Um so someone's doing stuff about just like an history of classical music and put it in a in a very fun board game. It's quite it's it's pretty cool.

So, uh, yeah, but again, if you are one of the the fans from the recent Galaxy Cruise or or SetI, uh, this is very much up your street. Yeah, if you liked those games, for sure. I think you're going to like this for sure. Um, while we're on that particular conversation, Max, these are three kind of heavy, kind of wide games. Yeah. In this modern style that have come out in the last year, two years really. Where would you rank those three? Oh, that's a hot question. That's a hot one, isn't it? Um, oh yeah, that's hard. You should have asked me before. No, no, no, no. I'll throw this out. Yeah. Okay. Um, I will say in my number three goals, uh, Galactic Cruise. Uh, because it's the the the heaviness and the and the time that you need to invest into. Um, I probably set you on the second place because I love all the mini games, but um, I do prefer when the all the the things are more interconnected. So at at today probably Lutium could be like the top one of the most recent three buy hair. Yeah, but just so we're talking about like details. If I play seti tomorrow, I might tell you another way.

I prefer or if we have a great game of Galactic Cruise, Galactic Cruise might go up. But um they are absolutely like in in in all the games there are they are all absolutely excellent. But this as a team, it just like probably speak more to my heart and I know that for you as well. So yeah, so that's really the reason why. But I think the point of that discussion is to say that if you like those kinds of games, you're going to be interested. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. The games is solid. The mechanics works. The mechanics are interesting. Uh the the patreon and the rolling the dice to performs or trying to put your tokens in the right position to have more points at the end. Everything works. It's um it's it's not boring. It's it keeps you entertained.

Absolutely. It certainly does. Okay, Matt. So, let's talk about your final thoughts, general feelings, uh how you felt about the fun of the game, levels of interaction, general general vibe, length of the game, all that sort of stuff. Again, as I said, it's a it's a very very solid game. Um, it's a game that I would recommend of if you like the general, yeah, absolutely go for it. If you if you like meat uh Euro games and you search you're looking for something a little bit more, this is absolutely um a recommendation. Um, in terms of interaction, I really love the uh the beading the the the um the worker placement/ the bidding. I find that really really cool and and keeps the the game play interactive.

Again, at the end of the day is a is a wide euro, wide modern euro. Yeah, you there are some some points in the game, especially toward the end when you're just trying to maximize what what you're doing. there is a little bit less of surprises happening. So every player will start just like trying to reach and um funneling down their path really. Yeah. But that is um a critique of the general. It's not a critique of the game. Um cuz actually the fact that you can get different patch toward the end and they throw you like a a new challenge that you can maybe achieve it at the last turn that is is quite interesting. Um but the level in interaction is not mega interactive. Something like Eterna is significant is is constant interaction while this one is the bidding is interactive. It comes and goes, isn't it? And then Yeah. Cuz sometimes you can since you can do the bidding on your own board as well when you're building the the the instrument, it might just interact with yourself some sometimes. Yeah. If that's Yeah. If that's two, if that's two of your four actions, 50% of it is not right at all.

You're just doing your own thing. Yeah. I love that this game is always giving you options. Um, and they all seem interesting and they all seem mutually beneficial in in a way. So, you always want to get new instrument plans. You always want to perform. You always want to find new patrons. You may also always want to be repairing instruments because this is the quickest way to get points. You just spend resources for points. Basically, this like it's real. There is no one path to victory. So it's the the width of the game always makes sure that well I might not do any performances but still winning the game because last game. Yeah. Because I haven't done any any of this and I I focused on building instrument for the right patron. So making sure that I I bought the plans for that specific instrument for that specific patron. So that's was the pieces that I was going. But you were just a few points behind it that you were doing a lot of loads of performance. Yeah. And that goes to show you need to make sure you kind of have a plan in mind and that's what I really like when you're making or repairing instruments or doing performances. It should all be in the service of patrons.

Yes. Because that will there right? So, and I think there was a point I think that's probably why I lost is because I think there was an instrument that I just had to build and it didn't really go to anybody and there was a performance that I did that wasn't for anybody but those things could have been to a patron. Yeah. Yeah. But that it's the focal point. You are you're building instruments for someone, not for yourself. Exactly. Exactly. You are the luier. You are not the performer. And I think that's a really wonderful thing. Everything kind of points you towards this. And if you can maximize these um they will tell you what you need to do. So I I think that's really really lovely. Uh I do love the interaction as you say from from the bidding. Um and the game even if you go somewhere and you feel like okay everyone else just has taken what I want it you have still options you can take like you know you've got different secondaries or like booby prizes that you can take from the different actions where they might not be your favorite thing but they'll give you something. Um, I love that in each of the spaces when you spend like a a really high level value worker, they will all give you something extra which is typically going to be like you said pushing you up the tracks and the tracks are all awesome. We didn't talk too much about the balcony one, but there's some great stuff here where if you go far enough along up this track, the later cards in all of the different sections become free to you cuz we didn't mention instead of paying the the first couple are free, but then you have to start paying to get access to the higher level ones. But legend gives you then because you're hobnobbing with all the rich people like why not? You're a cool guy.

You get access to all of those stuff. So, um, love it. Uh, yeah, I think it's a fabulous game. Like I said, I think it's a beautiful production in a theme that really speaks to me. Mechanically, it's it's more than sound. It's wonderful and it is interesting. Uh, this has got to be a strong recommendation from me. I think I think it's it's really good. Fair enough. Yeah, strong recommendation from me as well. That's u it definitely deserve it. So, those were our thoughts and that was our review of Luia Luthier of the Instruments. Uh, but what did you think of this magnificent game? Have you managed to play it? Did you pick it up at UK Games Expo being one of the first to buy this retail copy? Has it been delivered in your region yet? Probably at this point there. This should be out on the shelters of all the shops and online shops by the end of July. So depending on when this video is going to come out, it's going to be when you watch it.

Yeah. Uh it it might be already on the on the shelf of your local gaming store or local web store. We store local web. I guess local depends on the IP of the game. Maybe. But let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Are you a fan of music? Do you like the theme? Uh how do you feel about the ranking of those games? You've got Seti, Galactic Cruise, Ludian, lots of other it's quite it's quite difficult. Yeah, cuz you throw me like under a bus there cuz I didn't I was not like Yeah, but there's like but there's so many I think the point of that is there's so many of these excellently designed yeah yeah yeah perfectly designed not even excellent perfectly designed they're brilliantly they're brilliant games and there's a few of them that are coming out this year they're you know it's like which which flavor do you like exactly yeah it's a lot about flavor as well I guess what the flavor that you like um and my flavor flavor is uh when you all check out the patron. You can go check the patron out. Uh that always tastes great. Uh and it again sings a wonderful taste good for you as well because he's got a lot it's full with a lot of like content. We got a lot of interviews from the UK GE.

Yeah. And we we just planning more and more content that just going to go in there. There's a lot of like video podcast stuff where like just me and Wayne and uh and other people just ranting or like having a chat about this or that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. After dark. Oh yeah. Yeah. Spicy. Uh but other than that, the uh subscribe button uh is always here. Yeah. It will make a beautiful sound when you press it. Maybe, maybe not. Uh that one. That one. You can always check out the rest of our videos. Yeah. Try it. Check out the rest of our videos and we'll catch you at the next one. Here's what you should play and see.

Progress saved