Luthier: The Art of the Instrument

Video igyt-7pJiyQ kovray Review at 0:25 sentiment: positive

video_pk 64793 · mention_pk 158287

Click to watch at 0:25 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Stunning art and table presence that are very inviting
Strong theme integration that makes complex systems intuitive
Highly replayable due to patron variety and asymmetric families
Accessible entry via a rehearsal guide that helps new players learn the flow

Cons

High complexity with a potentially long playtime
Large table presence and space requirements
Prototype status; final components and balance may change

Thematic elements

Crafting, performing, patronage, and the pursuit of first chair in a classical-inspired musical world.
A family-operated workshop where luthiers craft instruments and musicians perform, competing for prestige across six rounds.
Theme-driven engine-building with asymmetric family abilities; emphasis on timing and plan execution.

Comparison games

Wingspan

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Engine Building — Endgame prestige is driven by patron bonuses, instrument outcomes, and chair positioning.
engine_building — Endgame prestige is driven by patron bonuses, instrument outcomes, and chair positioning.
patron_powers_engine — Patrons grant ongoing abilities and round-start bonuses that shape engine-building.
priority_bidding — Action order is determined by a bidding-like mechanism, altering round-by-round strategy.
Resource Management — Manage money, inspiration, materials, and apprentices to craft and repair instruments.
resource_management — Manage money, inspiration, materials, and apprentices to craft and repair instruments.
Worker Placement — Place workers to take actions and vie for priority during resolution.
worker_placement — Place workers to take actions and vie for priority during resolution.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

Vincent Detroit has spoiled us immensely yes, as he as he typically does.
the theme really integrates with what you're doing.
it's a complex game, but the theme integration makes it easier to understand.
the decision space between those two is constantly present and really key.
you get better and better as you play the game.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video NwkUGdqrKSc Board Stupid Interview at 0:16 sentiment: positive

video_pk 42104 · mention_pk 127767

Click to watch at 0:16 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Stunning artwork by Vincent D Trit
Historically accurate biographies and lore
High production quality with deluxe components
Rich, multi-layered mechanics blending worker placement, bidding, engine-building, and area control
Strong musical theme with thematic integration

Cons

Relatively high complexity (BGG weight ~3.0) may deter casual players
Deluxe edition price may be steep; standard edition available
Hidden bidding can slow early plays until players learn the system

Thematic elements

Instrument making and restoration as the core craft within a patron-driven society
Golden Age of classical music; patrons, nobles, composers and performers commissioning instrumental works
historical flavor with biographies of famous musicians

Comparison games

Distilled
Cask Strength

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Area Control — Crafted instruments are placed on specific workshop locations; first chair tokens on locations determine end-game scoring and area control.
Area control and placement consequences — Instrument placement influences area control; taking certain areas can grant long-term advantages and scoring opportunities.
Biographies and character boards — Each famous musician is represented with a character board and biographies researched by a musicologist to flavor actions and scoring.
Dice Drafting — The value of each worker is known only to the owner, affecting turn order and resource access during resolution.
Dice-based performances — Performances are carried out with dice that improve as players upgrade their black dice over time.
Engine Building — Once patrons are satisfied, their cards are tucked under to build an engine for ongoing benefits for the rest of the game.
Engine-building through tucking patron cards — Once patrons are satisfied, their cards are tucked under to build an engine for ongoing benefits for the rest of the game.
Hidden bidding / talent-based draft — The value of each worker is known only to the owner, affecting turn order and resource access during resolution.
Instrument crafting and placement with area control — Crafted instruments are placed on specific workshop locations; first chair tokens on locations determine end-game scoring and area control.
Patron management and time pressure — A patron cube moves on a track providing gifts but also representing impatience; if it reaches the end you fail to keep the patron happy and lose points.
Worker Placement — Family member discs with skill values 1-5 are placed face-down; resolution reveals order of action where higher-skill can outrank lower-skill players, creating strategic bidding.
Worker placement with a hidden-bid twist — Family member discs with skill values 1-5 are placed face-down; resolution reveals order of action where higher-skill can outrank lower-skill players, creating strategic bidding.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

the near final copy of luir the art of the instrument
kickstarting on July 16th
the most unique mechanic is it's worker placement with a Twist
it's a 3.0 on the BGG scale
this is representative of what you'd get in the standard edition
incredible stuff there looks like there's a lot going on here
Deluxe everything is wood everything is screen printed it's got dual layer boards
every single player will have their own Storage Tray for the Delux
favorite Spirit Dave has to be Whiskey A
I came up with this still when I was living in Scotland actually so that was a big influence of it

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video QUSiomnDdig Board Stupid Review at 0:00 sentiment: positive

video_pk 41012 · mention_pk 124416

Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Rich theme integration with real-world music history biographies embedded in rule explanations
Elegant combination of hidden bidding and worker-placement that creates meaningful interaction
Multiple pathways to victory; no single dominant strategy
High production value and beautiful artwork; tactile components and varied tokens
Strong player interaction during bidding and patron management; dynamic end-game options

Cons

Can be dense and complex for new players; a learning curve exists
Some components can feel overwhelming due to the board's breadth and the number of tracks
First edition had token print issues noted by reviewers; potential minor setup hiccups

Thematic elements

Instrument craftsmanship, patronage, performances, and prestige within a classical music milieu
Golden Age of Western classical music in Europe; noble patrons and master instrument makers in a historical context
Historical/biographical flavor with real-world music history flavor and biographies woven into rulebooks

Comparison games

Galactic Cruise
SETI
Distilled

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

hidden bidding — Players secretly assign numbered influence tokens to action spaces; during resolution, higher-valued tokens act first, determining access to the most demanding rewards.
Multi-track board with instrument chairing and performance — A central orchestra track and multiple side tracks (patron board, performance ladder, repair/crafting tracks) influence scoring, tier access, and end-game bonuses; first-chair mechanics drive end-game scoring.
Patron management and quest fulfillment — Patrons provide goals and rewards over three rounds; delaying fulfillment reduces prestige, rewarding timely progress and interaction with patrons.
Resource Management — Gathers wood, metal, and string; hires artisans; manages resources to craft instruments and fulfill patron requests.
resource management and production — Gathers wood, metal, and string; hires artisans; manages resources to craft instruments and fulfill patron requests.
Worker Placement — Players place workers face-down; a resolution phase reveals and orders actions, creating interaction based on revealed strength and timing.
Worker placement with face-down reveal — Players place workers face-down; a resolution phase reveals and orders actions, creating interaction based on revealed strength and timing.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

I think it's a fabulous thing.
Everything has purpose. Everything's got a reason.
There is no one path to victory. breadth of options keeps the game dynamic.
The theme is woven into every rulebook, rule explanation, and biography in the game.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video UlGYAtC7bog The Board Gaming Doctor Analysis at 0:06 sentiment: positive

video_pk 38008 · mention_pk 114211

Click to watch at 0:06 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Brilliant blend of worker placement and bidding mechanics that creates rich decision space.
Strong thematic integration with instrument-building, patrons, and performances.
Smooth and approachable for a Eurogame, with clear, learnable rules and good player interaction.
Dynamic market and escalating opportunities encourage strategic planning and adaptation.
Notable interactive tension for a Euro title, especially around turn order and resolution.

Cons

Dice-driven elements introduce luck in performances, which may frustrate players seeking deterministic outcomes.
Some players may feel the theme is not as immediately thematically striking as Distilled, despite solid integration.
Being a Kickstarter project, production and art may vary across copies and availability could be uneven.

Thematic elements

Building, repairing, and performing with musical instruments to attract patrons and gain prestige.
A European workshop/patron-driven setting where instrument makers craft instruments, perform for patrons, and navigate a dynamic social economy.
Theme-forward Eurogame with emergent narrative through patrons, performances, and instrument progress.

Comparison games

Distilled
Ruck dawn of keev
N of aier
Viticulture
The Gates of Luoyang
Glass Road
Lacosa

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Compound Scoring — Public and private objectives, along with patron interactions and instrument quality, contribute to final scoring.
Dynamic resource market — Resources (animal parts, wood, metal) have fluctuating costs each round, forcing players to manage finances and timing.
Instrument construction and repair loop — Players build and repair instruments to satisfy patrons, advancing along tracks and earning rewards for quality and performance.
Objectives and scoring mix — Public and private objectives, along with patron interactions and instrument quality, contribute to final scoring.
Patron tableau and area interaction — Acquiring patrons to your tableau influences scoring and progression; central board areas offer action advantages and can be contested.
Performances and dice outcomes — Performances use dice with tiers; players can mitigate dice luck through upgrades and track progression, affecting scoring potential.
Resource Management — Resources (animal parts, wood, metal) have fluctuating costs each round, forcing players to manage finances and timing.
Six-round pacing with phased play — Gameplay unfolds across six rounds, each with planning, resolution, and upkeep phases that structure game tempo.
solo AI opponent — An AI deck simulates a second player with predefined preferences and round-based behavior, providing a solvable solo challenge.
Variable Phase Order — Gameplay unfolds across six rounds, each with planning, resolution, and upkeep phases that structure game tempo.
Worker placement and bidding mesh — Players place bidding tokens face-down to bid for actions; actions resolve in order of bid strength, creating strategic tension between planning and timing.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

This game is split up into six rounds.
The planning phase features the uh worker placement and bidding uh kind of mesh together.
This is a really brilliant worker placement SL bidding system that is utilized in this game, combined with traditional Euro style mechanisms.
The market is very smart as well.
It's easy to pick up and play.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video wCehF9vna5o Board Gaming Ramblings Review at 0:08 sentiment: positive

video_pk 33951 · mention_pk 101141

Click to watch at 0:08 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Stellar artwork and components; thematic integration is strong
Rulebook is clear; helpful rehearsal guide for teaching the game
Interesting triggering order mechanic adds strategic depth
High interaction with three or four players
Multiple viable strategies and paths to victory

Cons

Prototypical components and rulebooks; can be heavy and long
Two-player variant with dummy/solo option reduces interaction
Some luck elements in card draw; mitigated but present

Thematic elements

crafting musical instruments to attract patrons and earn points
Orchestra hall / instrument workshop in a historical European setting
thematic, aspirational performance culture with patron-driven scoring

Comparison games

Distilled's prior titles
There is discussion of using a dummy player (Atoma/Ultima)

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Blind bidding / triggering order — Actions are revealed in a row order; higher numbers go first; players can influence by building numbers.
Instrument building & finishing — Construct instruments for patrons, moving them to finishing benches and scoring bonuses.
Market / round track — Markets change each round; players buy resources and influence options.
Patron contracts / scoring — Fulfill patron needs to gain points and bonuses; patrons can leave with negative points if unhappy.
Replayable actions and personal boards — Each player has personal actions on their board affecting triggering and scoring.
Resource Management — Gaining resources, paying costs, and repairing instruments with resources.
Worker Placement — Players place workers to perform actions; order determined by action cost and triggers.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

the game is fun
the game is fantastic
it's a heavy game for me
the artwork and components are great
interaction in every step

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video 3xbjaVnQGU8 The Board Game Garden Discussion at 1:46 sentiment: positive

video_pk 29594 · mention_pk 86929

Click to watch at 1:46 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Beautiful art and components (prototype) by Vincent D Tray
Unique blind bidding mechanic and multi-layer planning
Strong thematic integration of patrons, orchestra, and instrument crafting
Engaging market and upgrade systems with meaningful choices

Cons

Prototype components subject to change before release
Complex rule set may be heavy for new players
Long playtime and strategic depth could be daunting

Thematic elements

Patronage, music composition, and craftmanship in a workshop setting.
A Renaissance-era family instrument workshop where patrons request handcrafted instruments and performances.
Historical fantasy / artistic ambience with focus on patron relationships and orchestral goals.

Comparison games

none

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Area Majority — Control of orchestra chairs yields endgame VP and strategic benefits.
Area majority within the orchestra seats — Control of orchestra chairs yields endgame VP and strategic benefits.
Blind bidding / worker placement order drafting — Players secretly choose actions with chips and reveal/resolve in order of their strength, creating tension and order.
Card Drafting — Draft instrument cards at guild; upgrade chips and gain synergies.
Card drafting and instrument upgrading — Draft instrument cards at guild; upgrade chips and gain synergies.
Inspiration and upgrade tracks — Tracks to unlock abilities and upgrades; affect cards, tokens, or performance capabilities.
Patron timeline and requirements — Patrons have a timeline and require instruments, repairs, or performances; failing costs points.
Personal player board resource tracking and instrument finishing — Two-step process (roughing and finishing) to complete instruments and earn VP; tokens placed in orchestra.
Player Board | Main Board — Two-step process (roughing and finishing) to complete instruments and earn VP; tokens placed in orchestra.
Resource Management — Market phase with horse-and-buggy action to buy/sell resources (wood, animal products, gold).
Resource management and market actions — Market phase with horse-and-buggy action to buy/sell resources (wood, animal products, gold).
Track Advancement — Tracks to unlock abilities and upgrades; affect cards, tokens, or performance capabilities.
Worker Placement — Each player has a personal board with two spots and there are five central spots in the middle for actions.
Worker placement with two personal spots and five central spots — Each player has a personal board with two spots and there are five central spots in the middle for actions.

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

I really enjoy the theme of this one and I'm excited to show you guys this one here today on the Board Game Garden
The Art Is by Vincent D Tray so you know that it is absolutely beautiful
this is going to be a game coming to kickstarters
I think is really unique and very cool
I have played this both on TTS as well as in person now
This is the best thing I've seen in a game, it is so much fun

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video c6ooCeyWLRc The Broken Meeple Review at 1:50 sentiment: positive

video_pk 8394 · mention_pk 24711

Click to watch at 1:50 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

Gorgeous Vincent Dutrait artwork and strong themed presentation
Guided rehearsal book for setup and teaching the game value
Deluxe edition offers substantial physical quality and components
Good variability and replay value through family tiles, patrons, and objectives
Thoughtful, thinky planning that rewards long-term strategy

Cons

Punishing and lengthy play sessions, with potential AP and slowdowns
Dice-based perform actions introduce luck and can feel swingy
Balance issues with objectives and patrons; some elements feel overpowered or underutilized
Rule clarity can require careful study; text and deck interactions can be dense
Standard edition lacks inserts and dual-layer boards, reducing quality for a very high price

Thematic elements

Crafting and performing instruments for patrons; orchestral competition and patron-driven scoring.
A workshop where artisans repair, perform, and build instruments for patrons in a historical European musical setting.
Historically flavored eurogame with a thematic emphasis on instrument creation and performance.

Comparison games

Wingspan
Galactic Cruise
Lost Ruins of Arnak
Mine Clash
Star Wars Rebellion
Civilization

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

Card/Chit Market — A market board with fluctuating prices; accessing certain cards can be costly and may require deck-searching and resource spending.
Family tiles and specialty workers — Family tokens create varied setups and can affect resources, tracks, or instrument types; specialty workers grant unique ongoing abilities.
Instrument construction and repair — Build and finish instruments on a bench, progressing through roughing, engraving, varnishing, and completion.
Market and card access (deck mechanics) — A market board with fluctuating prices; accessing certain cards can be costly and may require deck-searching and resource spending.
Orchestra (area control) and First Chair bonuses — As instruments are completed or repaired, markers advance on an orchestra track; first chair bonuses drive scoring, which can be overridden by later instrument builds.
Patrons and commissions — Patrons require specific instrument types or actions; completing them grants bonuses and points, with diminishing returns as patience runs out.
Resource Management — Manage money, animal products, wood, metal, and inspiration tokens to fund actions and builds.
Turn order based on worker value — Highest value worker goes first; players can use apprentices to top up value for bonuses.
Worker Placement — Players place markers face down on action spaces; in resolution, tokens flip and act in a defined order (ascending value).
Worker placement (action tokens) — Players place markers face down on action spaces; in resolution, tokens flip and act in a defined order (ascending value).

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

the artwork is gorgeous.
This game is definitely going to get your brain cells firing because you need to be able to plan ahead quite a bit in this.
I think this jumps just about into the category of heavy game.
There is a decent amount of replay value in the box as well.
The solo mode is decent. I had fun with it, but it's a bit above my station.
would it have killed the game to give me a woodwind instrument at this point?
If you fall behind at the very start, round one or two, kiss your game goodbye.

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Video aVZs0G5iuHE Rahdo Runs Through Review at 0:00 sentiment: positive

video_pk 4181 · mention_pk 12258

Click to watch at 0:00 · YouTube ↗

Overall sentiment (raw)

positive

Pros

innovative two-stage tension in worker deployment and activation
strong thematic integration with artwork and theme
excellent AI automa that elevates solo and two-player play
clarity of iconography and accessible rules despite depth
beautiful art by Vincent Dupre and thematic consistency

Cons

table space required and a dedicated score track on a second board feels clunky
length can be long for some players; desire for a shorter version
prototype components; potential layout tweaks before final print

Thematic elements

artisans crafting instruments, patrons funding performances, and a focus on music as a social currency
19th century Europe, instrument making and performance
two-stage process with dual goals (creativity and performance) and tense decision-making around patronage

Comparison games

Distilled
Kis
Mires
Wingspan
Wingspan: Worms Span
Agricola

Mechanics (from transcript analysis)

apprentice tiles — upgrade workers using apprentices to improve actions or enable two-step actions
automa solo/2p mode — an AI opponent with sophisticated rules that mirrors a third player in single and two-player games
Card Drafting — draft cards from market to acquire actions and resources
patron cards with special powers — seek patrons to gain endgame scoring or unlock powerful abilities
Public and private objectives — board provides shared goals as well as private personal objectives
Resource Management — collect and spend wood and other resources to perform repairs and projects
resource management (building materials) — collect and spend wood and other resources to perform repairs and projects
two-phase action economy and scoring — initial deployment choices create tension; later resolution and scoring determine final points
two-stage worker activation — deploy workers in the first half of the round, then activate actions in the second half, creating tension as priorities shift
Worker Placement — place workers into locations where others may try to anticipate and react; actions are revealed in a later phase
worker placement with hidden actions — place workers into locations where others may try to anticipate and react; actions are revealed in a later phase

Video topics + discussion points

No key topics recorded for this video.

Quotes (from this video)

"This game is really, really different and really unique from most other worker placement games."
"freaking awesome"
"the two-stage process that gives you double the tension"
"I am really really impressed by it"
"thematically strong"
"one of the best AI opponents I've ever seen"

References (from this video)

No references stored for this video.

Luthier - Board Game Review - We Are The Music Makers

Welcome Friend

Create a New Guild