Atiwa Roundtable Review - Friendly Ties Podcast
Transcript
hello there and welcome to Friendly ties today we're going to talk about a game whose theme I know that you've been raving and ready for we're talking about bats in Ghana we're gonna do a tiwa today yeah so we uh picked up a tiwa at John and you actually played this like a handful of months ago and I somehow didn't get on the train yeah but Anastasia showed it to me last week and and introduced it in such a way she's like I don't know if you're really gonna like dig this I kind of like I'm not so sure myself and then we played it and I was like what do you mean this was awesome and she's like yeah this was awesome yeah so I played this for the first time wow like seven eight months ago or so at board game geekcon uh it's one of the new UV Rosenberg games uh it's a work replacement game and it I I immediately liked it and from when I first heard about it I thought it was kind of interesting theme like bat cultivation uh in Ghana like I I have no concept for to understand what's going on there and then I read the rules and was like wow this seems too simple like you know maybe uberzenberg's kind of gone with you know swung back away from like all the heavy stuff he's been doing and is this really going to be that interesting uh but then I played it twice at board game geek on because the first play was just like ah I'm really enjoying this and I played the second time with four players and I distinctly
remember feeling like I like this more than I feel like I should and yeah so I raped it about it a little bit to YouTube but it's taken all these months until we actually are sitting here talking about it now in June um and in a station I played it a few months ago and and I remember you were you were pretty shrunk about it and I was a little bummed because I was I'm a little bit of a I I'm like really high on the atiwa train to so to speak uh it yeah I'm enjoying it more than I thought I would and so when you said that you played it with Nick and Nick liked it and you want to make an episode I was like yes I have already played this five times let's go yeah yeah I mean it's funny you know you ever like played a game for like uh for like a games like you're like pitching it and you're like I don't even want to play this like why did I suggest it like I don't like that's kind of like I don't even know it was like I was like oh this is like an easy pick I guess it was like late we needed something like not too long and I was like okay like you haven't played this and I know you wanted to but I wasn't you're right Nick like I wasn't I wasn't excited I wasn't like not excited I was like I was just like it this one didn't stick with me after those I actually played it twice I played it once with you John with our friend NJ and I I love u a and I have loved a lot every Way's games but this one just kind of felony place for me that just wasn't like I was just kind of like take her to leave it I was like that was enjoyable I feel like I've seen it all I don't really feel like there's more to see I don't know and I gotta say
like playing it last week with you Nick like it was just lovely it was like lovely I just like picked it right back up it was actually I think easier than I expected it to be it's a pretty light game just to give everyone some context it's not this is not fields of Farley this is not if he's for Odin this isn't even holler I've seen people compare it to hallertau and I think hallertau is more complicated than this oh for sure where do you where do you think this Falls I mean I guess this is like a gricola level but even I feel like a grickle is more no I don't know it's less than than a great Club too yeah but it's not light right like I wouldn't throw this in front of someone who's like I like ticket I like uh Splendor and I'm like let's play a t-well like that's a mistake like no no no this falls in the medium range of of what I would call complexity yeah maybe like glass Road level I think yeah glass Road's a great comparison I think yeah it's kind of there but you know for us you know we play a lot of heavier games so it just it just it was just a nice lovely Breezy game and so this is definitely a game that for me has improved with plays and I don't say that often like I I don't I don't like to think that I dismiss games uh too quickly but I do feel like my first impression of a game is either I'm good and I like yeah I could take it or leave it I loved it or like maybe I didn't like it and I I know that but I want to explore it more because I can see that there's something I might like but it's kind of rare for me to have that kind of shrug feeling on a game and then have it
grow for me and so this you know this one kind of surprised me with that you know you can compared it to holler towel holler towels like wild and chaotic right lots of cards like this game has its system there's very mild Randomness in it which I guess is the the incredibly want to come out yeah and that's that's about it you know it's it's just what the just what the terrains are and you have kind of a choice of which of those you're going to pick up anyway I I think that uh if you master this game it becomes unfun because you just play the same thing probably each time but for Cults of the new folks which I think the three of us you know skew Cult of the newish as individuals it's really fun to explore and pick apart the puzzle and like see kind of like what what can I do that's most efficient here and for me without sitting there and being like ah this is worth that and this is worth that you know just kind of like viewing everything a little bit more like in Gestalt and being like all right well here's how I get some stuff and I would like to trickle up more income for my stuff and I want to make sure this stuff happens there's a lot of stuff going on and that's enjoyable yeah I mean 100 when you first glance at the game it looks like the simplest worker placement game ever you know you got the board in the middle of the table you put workers down uh everyone has three workers per round you can't even buy new workers and when you put a worker down it's next to a spot with a bunch of icons on it and you get the stuff the icon to show you and the icons are simple if it's a bat you get a bat if it's a goat you get a goat if it's a family you put a family down it's incredibly simple but I think the reason why the game is kind of Enchanted me is
because of this seemingly secondary system that actually is the Beating Heart of the game and that is that uh everyone has a board in front of them with I guess it's I think five different tracks where you got wild animals and then trees and then you have fruit and then you have families and goats all these things in line and you have your own kind of supply of them and as you like add a goat you take a goat from your own area and put it onto your board removing it from your board and revealing kind of an uh a number usually that has some effect in the game um you know almost like something much more complex but like eclipse or you know other Euro games where as you pull things off you build up an engine but what this essentially is is an ecosystem and I find it so satisfying to play with because every single round okay you do your work replacement I go you go they go I go you go they go until we've all played our three workers but then we all get to do our own little bookkeeping and in this game the bookkeeping in my opinion is the fun like I mean the working placement's fun as well but yeah like yes it's time to do bookkeeping you know you do income and that's simple but then you run your wildlife and you check to see like how many wild animals do you have if you have enough then you gain a new um tree and you put a tree down in front of you you have a little area with a bunch of cards you can expand and then depending on the number of trees you now have you get fruit and then you put the fruit down and then depending on the number of fruit you now have you gain bats and and and now is the key word there because you do the wild animals first and they might make enough trees to make it so you get even more fruit
and now you put enough fruit down to go to the next tier to put even more bats down and and it's just like here's some stuff here's some more stuff here's some stuff because you got stuff because you got stuff and then you have to feed your families because it's a newbie Rosemary game and it would not be a new way game if you didn't have to feed your family that really wouldn't be really they're worth a lot of points but man they they will plow through some fruit some goats some wild animals even bats if you if you let them and a trickle-down economy is is so rad though and it is really satisfying it is I don't I I can't explain why being like whoa well I have these animals and so I'm now making four fruits instead of three fruits because I have an additional tree I don't know why that feels so good but it really does and it's I think it's because that like step-by-step thing so you if you've like looked at it and you're like I took this spot it just it makes you feel so clever even though it's like you get plus one of this thing yeah yeah it's really easy to execute but you feel like a mastermind when you like yeah one extra tree to unlock one extra fruit to get one extra bat in you genius it does feel so good and for those of you out there that are like me that you can't stand it when you miss one thing or when you don't have room for something and you waste it like I hate wasting resources it does come with this
like slightly double-edged sword in that you are creating producing this like wonderful you know system is ecosystem of things but you do not have Limitless storage and that is another component of the game you know that you are you are in control of the storage you're building but the terrains that you take or the Landscapes that you take what's the other tile called the terrains yeah locations so you take the trains and and locations you are you have those are different work replacement spots is taking these tiles and placing them out but you can pollute them and lose spaces and you can they the spots on them have restrictions and so you can't place certain things on them and so as much as you are there's a bountiful resources it seems like it can be exceedingly frustrating if you don't have enough room to take something or you think you can take something and you didn't have a space for it or in taking something it kind of messed up the way your ecosystem went and that kind of thing in fact you know I just lost the game that we all played tonight because I didn't have room for a single bat and that bat was worth one point and that was the game like in 105 point game I lost because I didn't have space for a bat that I had earned that I had made but I had no home for him yeah you had 29 bands but you only had space to hold 28 of them therefore you lost or
didn't win but there were other factors in that that we'll talk about a little bit more about but that's just it's just a piece I don't I don't mean to be a Debbie Downer because I could not agree more with what the guys just said like I feel exactly the same way it's the coolest part of the game it's so satisfying but it does it can trigger that and that feeling and I think that's that that's that's what the game is about but it can be frustrating actually I quite like the storage mechanism mini game whatever you want to call it as well for those it's it's very elegant right you get a bunch of tiles that are three by threes but you don't get to use the top corner so there's eight spaces on each of them which means they can hold eight things but different tiles have different they're different types of tiles so um the the haunted house which is one of the funniest of them has a house that live there and that's all it could really store whereas The Mangrove is wonderful because bats and wild animals and trees can live there and there's a lot of wild spaces so you have sort of a lot of flexibility in what goes on on that board uh on the other hand there's the plantation which only puts trees but also it's worth a couple points because they acknowledge that you know it's a little bit more limiting and I really dig that like that's it's it's not such a limiting factor that it's hard to manage in the game like it's pretty easy to get access to additional storage but you care about what your what you're
deciding to pick up for that reason so I I like that the challenge that that adds because it again it feels satisfying but isn't actually difficult and so this game does a lot of that for me like striking something that's like again I feel like a mastermind but let's be honest I'm just like these things just go slightly differently in the refrigerator at the end of the day I have played this game five times and I genuinely never occurred to me that it's just a storage building game uh you know like you said you haunted house uh it's a card you place it down it's got this house and the bats around it there's a cave there's you know all these different types but but yeah you're right it's just expanding your fridge or your Warehouse or whatever and you can only put this certain thing here and this certain thing there and yeah during that um you know administrative phase or whatever and you run your little ecosystem it's just showering you with stuff that you gotta put into Cubbies and maybe that's part of why it's so fun because the game it's it we need to steal it down it's just get stuff spend stuff get stuff spend stuff which is Euro games in a nutshell but but it like it really leans into it it's like that's literally all you're doing and here's some here's some fancy thematic reasons for why you can hold you know seven bats here and only two bats there but you know three goats because they're behind a fence you know yeah all that all that stuff in it interlocks very nicely right like where the storage goes where the incomes of the various pieces are and it and it
does so in a way that you know normally when I look at a game it's like oh there are six or seven different resources you're like oh that's gonna be that might be a lot of management here here it's all very yeah Anastasia called a breezy earlier and I just couldn't agree more again for a gamer it's not something that you would just like show to anybody and play with you know people that are not into games but for gamers it's a very Breezy pickup yeah quick to play too we played a three-player game in an hour and 15 minutes earlier it's Breezy in that stance as well it is and I do think that I do think that this is the kind of game that if you are familiar with worker place I do think this this game can kind of hit multiple levels at once and and what I mean by that is like this is a kind of you know multiplayer solitaire game like obviously like any work replacement game the interaction on the spots is really the only interaction in the game and I think that Nick and I were kind of talking about this in the game we played last week like some of the spots didn't seem all that valuable but as I've played it I've now played it four times it's spots I never used it I didn't use in the first one would even considered using I'm using now in this game like and so you know I know that about Olay games because I know him as a designer I know that like pretty much every spot that he puts on the board has some usefulness it's there for some reason for some strategy for something but
I I hope you guys use the pay gold for two we all used it you know for Two Goats we multiple times this game I would have never used that I didn't use that in any other game that I have played and so I do think that the way that the tiles come out and the way that there's this really interesting mechanic that changes the way the worker placement spots are in every game there's seven rounds and while the spots are pre-printed on the board you place these tiles on top that move they like they go out in a row and then they move every round so the spots the worker spots work replacement spots actually change as you're playing the game and they change from the initial setup there's always this kind of like variety at play and I think that makes for very interesting and dynamic worker placement experience like there's not a lot of other games that I can think of where the worker placement spots are changing as often as they are changing here and still being so functionally Dynamic like you're like oh that's really interesting but it's also going to move but it also some of them will stay stagnant for several rounds and then they'll move so it it's it's very interesting they're all resource generating uh for the most part however they create for a new Dynamic and I do think that that's something really engaging here um although I'm I'm going off of kind of my point which was to say I think the gamers of all levels could access this game at different places kind of where they are I think you could play this game and take the spots and be like I sort of see
the larger puzzle and still have a great time and I think you could take a gamer like Nick who is obviously very experienced and very very talented and he can have a great game because he can see really get into all of the machinations of it and and play that out and really enjoy it as well I mean I don't know about you Nick but I know you keep saying it's a medium game but do you not think that like someone who's played I'm trying to think what like an entry-level work replacement is but that this could be like not a Gateway but the next step after that for sure I mean I only I only wanted to be clear in saying that it wasn't light because I wouldn't want to just throw it on the table with someone be like hey there's going to be a little bit of a lift for learning this right like if it's their yeah second worker placement game ever you know there's there's there's a lot of like Little Numbers in this game right ones and twos and threes and fours uh and not everybody likes doing that much counting or bookkeeping and if you're not a board gamer uh you know this a lot of this game when we played is kind of like heads down management and if you have to yeah you know at the table go around and do everyone's income phase separately because people are not feeling confident you know the game's gonna slow down a significant margin like this is right this is a pretty close to a heads down um Euro at the at the pace and way that you know we're playing at and I think that's where it's probably most fun or most satisfying um and I think most folks can get there pretty quickly you know if they have if
there's just one person at the table who knows what's going on like that's that's plenty to to do that yeah I would agree I mean I I think maybe this is a little bit old but a lot of people used to say that like the standard intro worker placement game was Stone age uh and I was just thinking that I was like I literally didn't say that because I was like is it still Stone Age it just shows how long we've been in this but uh it was for me it's viticulture that's always the one that I'm like I think video is more popular in Spanish I've never actually played viticulture
came out around similar times and honestly I'd say a tiwa is pretty similar in weight to those games um like you just kind of they punch a little bit differently stone age has dice rolling and a tiwa doesn't a tiwa instead has a little bit of you know this and to this into this but I don't know it feels I mean to a certain extent I think my two-way games have been faster than my games of stone age uh like looking back it's been a long time since I played that game but um like thinking back to it I think that like what viticulture has going for and gosh I haven't played viticulture in years but what it does have going for it is the theme right so a lot of people understand in terms of Gateway you know work replacement a lot of people understand oh this is how you make wine or when you explain it you know in the seasons and the things like I think that you know even Lords of water deep is another great example you know they kind of understand the you know if they're even remotely familiar with DND and even just the way the colors and the tokens work like it's just it's you're you're able to kind of conceptualize that and while this game is dripping literally in the theme that it is these bats in Ghana it's not quite as intuitive I think because it's a slightly different culture right like he's capturing that idea of a symbiotic relationship with bats bats that live in your house that you take care of that you know nurture and you know their droppings feed into the ground I just want to pause and just point out that when John told me about this game at BGG con or you know via the
interwebs from btg con he described it to me as bats pooping and then people eating bats and their poop and I you know I don't think I said it's like there's a lot of bad poop in this game though like that was I mean I want to go find what he wrote because it was like they just were like talking endlessly about bats and their poop and I was like wow that just does not sound engaging to me right so rather than dripping in theme you mean tropics and theme I just I I this is that was a I was a personal turn off um and I still don't know that I like like it's a cell for me but it is he does create a really beautiful ecosystem here with the badge and trying to find very cute and creative ways to bring in the haunted houses of tile that Nick pointed out but there is something really beautifully captivating in the ecosystem between and now I understand it the bats and they you know they go off and then they eat fruit and then they're droppings plant trees I mean it is literally droppings in theme Here Yeah Yeah thankfully there is no uh bat poop resource that that's been abstracted away um the other small thing I want to say about uh accessing this game that I I quite dug but I worry about the replayability side of it is the breeding aspect of this game so it tells you hey
on turn one two three four five six and seven like explicitly like these are the things we want you to have and if you do you get a bonus thing um for my first game playing I was like oh okay great I'll make the things that the game is telling me to make how wonderful um right so it's nice to have those directions the only my my only criticism of this thing is that there's no variability in it and I can't help but wonder if there's a version of this game that did have some variability in what those like round by round goals are yeah but maybe it would just be a different game if that was the case so um I I I I miss that opportunity for playability but I dig the here's where you should be here's what you're aiming for it's like okay cool well now now that the game has told me this I at least have some targets to work towards yeah I mean I think it is fair to I don't know put like a disclosure here and say this game feels the same every time you play it and if that's a problem for you then this might not be for you uh for me I played this game five times I've enjoyed it five times I bought a copy I own a physical copy I don't plan to get rid of it we play tonight and I had a great time and I want to play it more but that's because I know I'm coming back to The Well of fun like I know exactly what it is um every time you play this game you're gonna be reading bats every time you play this game you're going to be putting on families maybe one game you make more bets than the other or maybe this game the one we just played Nick and I leaned hard into putting a whole
bunch of families on our boards Rose Anastasia put half as many families but went crazy on bats I love my bats don't touch my bat and then the score was I had 105 Anastasia had 104 Nick had 102. so like these strategies all kind of coalesce and and so I enjoy the subtle differences I I will agree with you Nick though I do kind of wish that their had been some Advanced breeding mode where you know maybe there's like random tiles for the first two rounds of the second two rounds with the and then rounds four five six seven or whatever just to like have a little bit of variability there but to me the variability of the game comes in with your opponents and those terrain cards because you know we mentioned there's terrain and there's locations and locations are always the same it's it's essentially small town slightly bigger Town bigger Town town they have different names but those are always the same but then there's this row along the top of the board with um with terrain tiles you you bring them out I guess they're cards but whatever you Shuffle that up and you bring those out and new ones come out each one of the seven rounds and and while yeah you are just you know essentially doing glorified storage uh building for the stuff you have the options that it brings definitely changes one game to the next I mean in that game we just played there was a round where I knew I was going to be um in the breathing phase getting a new family and I needed a spot to put that family and there was a Terrain tile randomly it didn't have to be out there but it was that could support one family so I went there and got that as well as some other benefits instead of spending
that action going and building a small village which would have cost a lot more of my stuff and so I was able to capture the the I guess the initial randomness of that card being out there and being exactly what I needed and that had a ripple effect if that card wasn't there I would have built a small or medium Village and that would have changed what I did later on in the game because of the decisions I did earlier so I think there are Butterfly Effects that make one game play differently from the next to a certain degree but nowhere near as much as you know zulkin or you know many other modern Euros where you know one person's doing thing a the other person's doing thing B and we see we we compare our scores like we're all doing thing a in this game yeah every you do everything to at least some degree yeah yeah and I mean arguably that's not all that different than a gricola right you you are you know you can say what you want about the cards that the card play in Agricola but like you are essentially the same action spaces are gonna come out you are fundamentally doing the same things you're going for the same point areas every game and so you know each time you play it is about you know how you use the spots how you deal with your opponents and how you maximize your score right and that's kind of what you've got going on here I think the same could be said for filter of rlay too I mean it's again the dynamic of one of the things that this game doesn't have quite as interestingly as maybe some other ways other games is maybe
that dynamic in the worker placement amongst the opponents because there are so many worker placement spots that you while you do feel like there are spots that you want that someone else is going to take there's no like resources gathering on spots so when you go here you know you are able to then use you know add things to to other things it just it it this what the dynamic aspect of the worker placement spots is what I was describing earlier where the spots change throughout the game every game it's very subtle and I think it's important it's because when you think about it there's what I'm going to count them right now 28 worker placement spots not counting the additional four at the bottom which are like kind of the second best to take right spots from you know and those were a three-player game right yeah that's 32 if you even if you count those so 32 spots and we have nine in a three-player game yeah nine workers a lot that's a lot of open spaces and in a two-player game you only remove one two three four five six seven of those yeah so you know that's a lot of spots yeah so same time those spots are not created equal like numerous times in this game we put a worker down and the next person was like ah totally I shouldn't have got there first totally and I don't want to say that it's completely open either I think there is a lovely tug both at two players and at three players I think
there is a lovely tug um it's just not a brutal tug which actually I think is is is great it's a plus for me for the game it's not there is something else to do but there are spots that are at any given moment better for you or better you know they're just it's it's a work replacement game yeah and there's you know let's say I go on the spot that has the goat and the tree with the fruit in it that Nick really wanted well then he'll just go onto the spot with the goat and the the family or whatever like there's another way to get a goat it might not be the way that he specifically wanted but again that changed like me getting in the next way will be another ripple effect that you know yeah you have to deal with that will yeah you know change things a little bit and some of the spots are lesser versions and and it is this is a game about efficiency and so oh yeah I kind of want to Pivot us into like the the AP discussion of this because you can not you cannot have a conversation about this game without at least acknowledging the massive potential for AP that I think is here that's interesting that you say that I have not really run into it and I feel like I can get suckered into AP just as much as as the next person but I in my place with this one I found it like sometimes I I think a little bit but I wouldn't say I I ever get like concerned about the amount of time I'm taking on one of my turns I think that because there is what feels like a solvable puzzle here yeah you know like you guys are talking about the breeding the breeding doesn't change on one level I think that probably plays into the theme to a certain extent but I
also think it's it's sort of designed you can almost see it that it's like designed to help to be like cool you need to be building the bat colony and then you need to be focusing on your people like there's There is almost an arc because suddenly like halfway through the game you're not breeding bats anymore and it kind of makes it sort of clear that you know you want to have wild animals at the beginning and then by the end it's like they actually go up and then go down it's like it's there's almost becomes this there's almost like a clear path it isn't clear but it feels like if you played it enough you could see it where you're like yes I should have a lot of wild animals and then I should eat all my wild animals because they're not as valuable as having my goats and I should not eat my goats I should start you know getting goats later and I'm I'm sure that you know that kind of follows a process of how this society and how this ecosystem would be created in that way right you'd start with wild animals and then later you'd have domesticated goats and blah blah blah blah blah like so I see that but the fact that it is static means that I can know that that I can say that to you that you can start thinking about that that I could tell someone who's playing that and suddenly I'm thinking about that then I'm thinking about needing to have the exact amount of trees and then I don't want to have too many trees because if I put all my trees out then I won't be able to maximize how many fruits and my bad seed and then the how many fruits that I eat I need to make sure I have at least six fruits so I can maximize my fruits and have spaces for my three bats I need to have like you there are so many things to think about in terms of where do your resources go is every level
every line of your engine going are you taking the right spots I mean the last two rounds of the seven rounds I could have sat and stared at that board I kid you not for 10 minutes trying to figure out if I had the time to figure out exactly what I wanted and even after so we quit so we played this game it was lovely Breezy hour and 10 and then you took my phone took a break oh John I didn't take a photo y'all hopped off we took like a dinner break y'all hopped off and I just stared at the game like 10 extra minutes analyzing if I could have done my last two workers differently to have scored one more point until I figured out that I could have in my out of my three workers my second worker I placed it somewhere where I got one point and I could have done a different action and I could have gotten two points and I would have won I hate that I hate that that is possible I hate that I know that I hate that that's how the game ended and this is what I mean like the fact that I know that makes me want to spend so much time looking at my turns I want to be a player that plays Breezy and I can be but it is like it is like tantalizing in front of me and he's beckoning you to to run the numbers there are gonna be players who are going to want to do that I I caution you now heed my warning it is there disagree with me Nick no no I agree with you I actually think that it and and that side of the apness of it is
unfortunately very boring there's really nothing that interesting about being like Oh that play was two points and that play was three points and wait but I have to figure out if that's two or three because if I get those things then the Cascade is gonna happen then I'm gonna eat that guy so it's actually not worth the one point that I thought it was okay so that's two and that's two well okay let's now compare to this next action yeah that is that is a little tedious I think I think uh it has the danger of walking into that trap but if you're willing to play it a little bit more Breezy you know nothing bad is gonna happen you're just gonna wind up losing by a point sometimes yeah and I think the game is I think the scoring of this game is generally going to be very tight um I think because the ecosystem is so interconnected and because I don't know uae's just a genius with all the numbers right now I don't know how he does it but yeah yeah it's you could view this as a good or bad thing I think some people would be like oh the game is very tight you know I do all these strategies this game is very balanced right I think I could hear some people saying that for me it's a little bit more on the negative side in the sense of like you can't really shoot yourself in the foot you can't really do anything amazing either so you know it's it's mostly about getting these like tiny little edges over the course of the game uh and I like the game it's fun but if you're looking for something that could be a little bit more bombastic or a little bit like your decisions are very impactful this game is a bunch of
like minorly impactful decisions yeah I actually want to sling some numbers around because while I have been very high on this game and I am I I really enjoy this game it's honestly one of my favorite games from last year uh I I do have a little bit of a raised eyebrow with regards to the scores uh like tonight we just played a three-player game and I thought I well I did win but I won by one point but I thought I had it in uh I mean I could have had it just saying like but I I thought I was blowing you out because I had a plan and a plan was coming together and I was doing this I was doing that I was sure I was going to win by a reasonable margin and the game ended it turns out Anastasia I thought the same thing and Nick also thought the same thing we all thought that we were winning uh maybe they didn't think I was winning oh no I didn't and I didn't think I was going to blow you out but then the scores were you know 102 to 105.
um in the in the overall span so I've played this game five times and the average score it's been 99 points and the average winning score is 106 points and I've played this in my five plays my scores have ranged between 102 on the low end and 110 on the high end so in five games my score has varied by eight points in a game that scores over 100 points and I just think that is I can't help but start to wonder is it too balanced like is is everything you're kind of doing worth about the same number like we said um Nick and I both you know had all of the families out which uh gives you a ton of points that Anastasia didn't but then Anastasia had a bunch of bats and then our scores ended up being virtually the same and it just it just has me like I can have a lot of fun with the game but I also I yeah I worry how much how much of the win is me or if it's just you know this tiny little Ripple difference when just about everything is worth about the same amount of points well and that's my problem with the AP right like if every if if you know that there's a game where you can lose by one point how can you not over analyze your action I mean you can you totally can it is possible to not over analyze your actions but it's a lot harder too than in a game where the swing is going to be 10 and 20 points in this game when you know like 10 to 20
right you know like looking like like really extrapolating out like not even at the point values like the difference in these scores have been minuscule from percentage minuscule I have a hard time seeing a blowout where somebody gets twice as many points as somebody else totally and your resources are points right like yeah you're bad so just to be clear in terms of what is kind of the Point area so people can get a sense of this your gold is points and you can you spend gold in a variety of ways throughout the game and so you are always kind of choosing do I want to spend points or do I want to keep points and your bats are points after the first ten and so you know that's a similar thing the trains that you take are points and some of them are negative points and so do you want to take a negative terrain you know because it gives you more spaces that are good for you do you want to take one that gives you points and you know we talked about the Resource Board how how much you can clear that board also points so that's why you know families are a significant amount of that but then your families need to eat and then by eating those resources go back on the Resource Board so there is another kind of calculation there that you need to like work through your brain it's like cool I'm getting all these points for families but if I have to put resources back then those resources are now I now have getting less points because my board is less clear and I think that all of that you know that first game it gets easier the more you're familiar with what resources you're going to need but it's still quite a bit of computation that is possible knowing that this game is going to ultimately end up in a swing of what
were our scores in our first game John I'm curious that was my lowest score I had 102 and you won with 105. are you kidding me nope okay I want to say in the three times I played with a combination of the two of you 104 105 105. okay some point kind of absurd yeah yeah I mean at the end of the day I feel like that's a bit of a damning criticism of the game but it doesn't take away from the fact that I've had fun the whole time I've played it every time I play even if my scores can end up being virtually about the same it's just funny yeah it's it's I think it's a fun game to play I think it is a mistake to try to master this game like you'll ruin it if you play it too much like you should pick it up and play it once and then like three months later be like I like a tiwa I'm gonna play a tiwa again and then you could do it again six months later something like that you know you you should give yourself a little Gap because if you get into this game I think you'd I think you'd solve it I mean I I guess I should I feel like I'm making a judgment of something that I've played twice yeah but it feels like it extrapolates to that yeah and it is one of those games where like you can put it down for six months and then bust it back out again and it it'll take you a handful of minutes maybe five minutes to get back up to speed because of the Simplicity of the icons and that kind of stuff so it says the professional board game teacher yeah that's true yeah no help but I do want to say to this Nick I think what you just said a perfectly explained what we were talking about the
beginning of this podcast which is like Anastasia how could you take a game that you were kind of struck on right and then play it again and then have such a like honestly a Lovelier time and I think that's because in that first play or even those first two plays I play two times you know within a couple of days of each other and I had that feeling of like I could solve this and I want to solve this and it's kind of starting to to like take away from the game for me and then stepping away from it for a couple months and then pulling out I was like what a lovely night it was easy to remember it was easy to teach I don't often teach the games amongst us and so I was able to teach it to Nick pretty quickly this is not a game I want to solve but this is a game that I could easily pull out and feel like over the course of like a year that I would like feel closer to like solving that puzzle without actually trying actively to solve it because I think you're right it would it it that Quest alone ruins the game my alternative explanation is that I'm just so delightful to play with that uh it's Nick actually come with every copy of the game by the way so I think I kind of want to close my feeling on this game by coming back to something I've been telling most people when they ask me about it and that is a this is a game I like more than I feel like I should and I think part of that's because I am a board game professional I started my YouTube channel out as a board game reviewer I've reviewed dozens and dozens of games
I can't help but like turn that part of my brain off and I feel like the reviewer side of my brain has a big side eye to this game like oh the scores are really too tight is this game overly balanced and oh is it actually that interesting but then I look at the other half of my brain that's just like we you know like every time I play like I'm gonna move these around and I'm oh I get free fruit and and I just it punches above its weight for me like I I can't quite explain it even after five plays why I like it so much more than I feel like I should but I do and I guess that's what really matters yeah I mean it is it has been very satisfying to play it's it's fun to do the little management things I don't think you know for folks that are very Discerning about what they're going to pick up in their collection I don't know if this is for you but if you're someone who's a prolific board gamer who has a big collection I think this is well worth your time it's it's gonna be fun the couple times you play it uh and it's while it doesn't necessarily do anything truly Innovative or new I think like how the resource management goes and the storage components are it does feel I don't think I've quite played this game the worker apartment placement part I could do away with but the but the like stuff you manage on your own board is nice yeah yeah yeah I think I'm having a similar reaction to it that you you are John it's like a lot of the things that
are kind of clear to me about why I have a game in my collection or why I like a game I are not in this game like there's there are pieces of it that make me be like like kind of give me pause like it's just it's not as there isn't an element of it that just draws me to it I can't say oh this this one piece is so unique that's why I have it you know I have a lot of games that I hold on to where I love to play because they just have some element that I think is so cool there isn't really that here the theme I think is really interesting but it's not a theme that I gravitate to I don't think like that's pooping is not necessarily a thing that I'm like cool yeah let me like pull that one it's not viticulture let's just put it that way it's a different kind of culture we're all growing things and nurturing things all agriculture here but um it's just not it's not a thing that I would like pull out and be like hey do you want to play this this game about bad to the poop and then you eat the bats but nevertheless it has been this very enjoyable play it is it is a puzzle um it does trigger my AP the scores are super tight makes me want to analyze every little thing but it's it was just so fun to play it last weekend it was fun to play it tonight there is a joy that's just moving your pieces and the cards come out and they kind of make you smile and it's it doesn't do it in a lot of the ways I'm familiar with with gaming it's just a lovely little experience I do want you mention the theme not appealing to you and it did appeal to me when it came out
I like I like games about animals um because largely because my partner is more inclined to like a game about animals but I will add with this one the theme of this game after playing it I was like oh I want to learn a little bit more and they had some stuff in the rule book and I like read somewhere that I don't know if this is true but I read somewhere that Hue like wrote like an essay or an article about like what he had like learned um yeah it like made me learn something about the world that I did not know before which I can't say for a lot of games and so I I 100 I quite dug that no yeah 100 and I and I actually think that is such a boon to this game drawing attention to Ghana trying to draw an attention to the bats how important these fruit bats are like the fact that I can now understand and explain that entire ecosystem that you are playing that out and I do think that's that's really special and unique here well that's going to bring us to the end of our discussion on atiwa I hope that you all enjoyed listening and uh let us know how you liked it if you want to head over to to the YouTube version of this recording you can drop some comments in there and let us know what your experience with this game is or if we piqued your curiosity thanks everyone