Arcs - Board Game Review - Game Of The Year? Is it Really?
Transcript
oh this will be
fun hi everyone I'm Luke you're watching the broken me a show where I RAV and rant about board games but usually more the latter pleasure to be meeting you quite a pleasure oh yeah we're doing it we're doing arcs the most trending game of this year so far and before we even get started this is not a sponsored review in any way shape or form I bought this out of my own pocket literally got some zatu back stock I had to pay about one and a half T probably even say close to double the price of this game when it hits retail to get a copy of this so I have gone over and above what I should be paying for this just so that I can get a review out before Autumn Christmas time when it is meant to come out on retail and I'll get stuck with all the s and stuff at that stage so this is entirely off the cuff as a review but I had to find out I mean go blim me the shut up and sit down effect it kind of Gres me to a bit because you know they're the most popular board game channel out there fair enough I don't personally like their style that's just me but the the influence they have where literally they can just simply say a few words they can just go this game is amazing suddenly as soon as they do that everybody on on the internet goes absolutely Fanboy crazy and then proceeds to do whatever they can to get and play whatever game it is it's their influence and they have this influence fine but I know to not just trust that sort of thing I had to find out what this game was all about
now this one is done from leer games and it's done by Mr Cole v i Am no idea if I'm pronouncing that right it's a German surname it you know I'm just going to say Cole from this point on but my history with this designer is kind of well it's somewhat sparse because honestly the main games signature games that this guy is known for is root o Pax Premier and John company those are like the four biggest games on his credit list now I won't go near John company to save my life cuz everything about that game tells me I'm going to hate it um I have not played o o looks too impractical to get played though I've heard it's this Mammoth game that's going to need the same group all the time to play it constantly and it's just that's not practical for me so I haven't gone near it I have played Pax Premiere it's okay nothing amazing I don't really care for the theme I like the asymmetric sort of uh you know like the wind conditions can change that kind of thing that's cool and the card displays fine but honestly I think pxs Renaissance is a better game so I don't really go for Premiere as much it's probably my second favorite packs game though um but that's not saying much cuz most of the other packs games I don't like and root I'm just kind of met on I mean Root's okay and I love the app the app is fantastic but you've got to teach four separate games to get it played and it's just that's that's annoying again not practical and not all the races are fun to play I mean you know the Vagabond just seems to just choose one side and do nothing the cats are boring the birds are okay but a bit fiddly you know
probably the underground movement the woodland people or something that's probably the most fun race out of the basee game but you know you've got to hope you get that faction I this gu this guy games don't tend to work for me but there's certainly a lot of Mega fans of root and packs out there so this one was certainly on the hype list for a lot of people before shelen sit down mentioned it but the second the review came out and said this was like their game of the year bearing in mind that the person reviewing it is a major Cole Fanboy you know absolutely loves these games you know everybody has gone nuts so I have gone into it pretty much completely blind other than the fact that it is made by Cole and that it has a pseudo trick-taking element other than that I didn't really know anything else about its mechanics I just had to go right I'll dive in it was at the gamees Expo but it was like booked up for loads of time and I didn't really like the look of it so I wasn't that desperate to get into it but now I have to find out is this a true game of the year or is this just another one of those instances where hype has gone out of control what's the matter Colonel Sanders chicken AR is played over a series of rounds made up into five chapters now the game can be won anywhere between 3 to five chapters but it depends if players can reach a particular Point threshold otherwise the game just ends after five chapters each chapter is played out with a series of six rounds typically six rounds where every player has six of these different Trick cards in their hand and these come in four suits numbered one to seven let's say we're going with a four player here you
reduce it slightly for Less players and each round a lead player will play a card for the lead card this lead card will dictate the suit for this particular round and each card has a series of actions that can be performed a number of actions that you can do another action points shall we say and potentially an ambition symbol we'll get on to that in a minute then once they have concluded their actions with this particular card the other players in clockwise order then choose to play a card from their hand based on what the lead card was so they can either surpass which is to play a card of the same suit that's a higher number in which case they get to do all the actions like they did or they can play a different suit face up they'll only get one action but they get to do it off the card that they want to do or they can just play any card face down and they'll get one action only but they'll do it off the card that was the lead card and this is how a typical round will play on top of that the person who played the lead card May declare an ambition there are five different scoring Ambitions that can take place for a round Tycoon Tyrant warlord keeper and empath and the idea is is that there are threee scoring markers which will chop and change in value as the game goes on and as soon as you declare an ambition let's say I want to go for Tycoon I need to have a bunch of these materials and fuel symbols in my display Okay cool so we're going to go for that and if I get first place I'll get Five Points second place gets three points three of these Ambitions can be declared during a round and sorry during a chapter and once the chapter is done and all the cards have been played you resolve these individual scoring elements and then rinse repeat for the next chapter draw six new cards
and you know clear off the Ambitions new scoring objectives could be set for each chapter the actions themselves are fairly straightforward and they do come in this uh relatively good sort of little guide booket that everybody gets in front of them but these can involve moving around the map building new ships and buildings uh collecting resources of planets that you have control over and there are also Guild cards on the side of the board which give you special powers and abilities you can have actions to influence these by placing little agents on them and securing them in order to take the cards that have your agents on them so there's a fair few actions that you can do but what the Crux of the game is all about is that you have these six cards in your hand and you have to adapt to what cards are being played because this is very much a tactical game and not a strategic game you will also occasionally get into fights with other players where you will basically see how many of your ships are in the combat choose any number of different dice some are better at hitting damage but more risky some are very safe some attack buildings specifically and the idea is is that you will roll the dice as necessary and in a specific order you'll resolve the symbols and that's it the defender doesn't get involved it's pretty much roll and see what happens the game carries on for up to five chapters as I said because there is a points threshold depending on player count if you meet the threshold game will just end immediately otherwise play through five chapters and see who's got the most points at that point everybody got that that might have seemed like a bit
of a basic overview but honestly that's actually one of the plus points of this game there isn't that many rules to it if you have played similar games that involve a trick- taking mechanics some of this will be familiar although to call it trick taking is a little bit misleading I guess it's a very pseudo form of trick taking but there are some similarities like playing a card and it's better if you can follow the lead suit but there's not a ton of rules I mean the rule book is not particularly big and you know you'll be able to get started into a game you know relatively quickly and there is a fairly decent not brilliant but fairly decent guide Le that everybody gets which kind of takes them through the most important rules like the summary of all the actions how playing the chapter Works in terms of playing these cards and what the difference between surpass copy and pivot is and how you score at the end of a chapter these are very good little reference guides although we will talk a little bit more about the rules a bit later on but that being said when I was learning this game before I was going to teach it it didn't take me that long to get through the rules this is probably one of you know in terms of a game that can take as long as it does it's not that rules intensive there's not a huge amount you need to know you just have to really understand how the card system works and then everything else is kind of stuff we've seen before the meat of this game revolves around these cards so the idea that you've got four suits different numbers and different numbers of actions so the higher the number the less actions you get and also the fact that you want specific card to declare the Ambitions because you can only
declare an ambition if the ambition symbols on the bottom of the card so there is that aspect and you can only even do that when you're the lead player so turn order particularly going first is of critical importance in this game you can even discard cards to try and seize the initiative so that you're going first in a future turn it's very difficult to convince people to do that because you are effectively losing a turn to do it but you should do it at some point because if you really critically need to go first season the initiative is the best way to do it second place that's a fancy word for losing the meat is all about adapting to these cards and we'll get on to some negatives for that a little bit later but this is still a fun little mechanic the idea that you have got these six cards and you must try to adapt to the hand that you've got and you can pull off some you know cool little combo turns every now and again if you are going first you're going to get the full fruits of your card so it's like well great I'll play my you know I'll play my four Administration here well that's giving me free actions I can do these I can pull off some really cool thing here where I can influence a bunch of cards or tax some of my planets get a bunch of these resources in that is exactly what I need but even if you're reacting what someone else has done you've got options cuz you might be able to surpass them in which case great but do you want to maybe you really desperately wanted to do a battle this turn well I need the aggression card to do that but each just played to construction well I could play an aggression card and then just do one battle action maybe that's worth doing or should I play my construction card that surpasses it could possibly take
the initiative next round and then build stuff but kind of hoping to battle now and if I don't do it now he's going to do it and it's going to hurt so there's a lot of cool aspects to do with timing and sort of tactical response with this game this is by no means a strategy game in fact to call it a strategy game would be misleading in every shape of the word because you cannot plan in this game to save your life you've got to adapt to what the cards do and again we'll get on to the limitations of that later but this is not a game where you go right this round I'm going to do this right this game I'm going to be the warlord all the time and it's going to be like nothing but killing things you can't the scoring the scoring conditions change every chapter another aspect I quite like because I do like it where you've got variable scoring throughout the game um and you know the cards you get are going to be different and the guild cards you get are going to be different so you you cannot sit there with a game plan and expect it to work out I like your plan except it sucks so let me do the plan and that way it might be really good you are going to have to be flexible and for the most part I tend to like tactical games you know not always you know there are you know some exceptions to the rule but I tend to gravitate more towards the games where you do have to react or adapt to various situations but it depends on how well you can do that or how well the game lets you do that more and that a bit later The Guild cards lend to a little bit of freshness for each game there's not a huge amount of them and I do wish there were more because there is a bit of a rinse repeat with some of these cards like there might be six Union cards and they all do the same thing
it's just which resource does it work with um but the idea with these is that they do lend themselves to you know some cool moments where you can go I could really do with something to boost me there as like oh that card is pretty sweet yeah if I get that that's got a cool power on it might be able to use it you know maybe I should try and get that ASAP before I start taxing these planets and you know these only come out four at a time and the deck is a little bit bigger than this this isn't all of them but there still isn't that many of them in the game but these just add like a cool almost like an opportunity moment you see these come out somebody buys a I wasn't interested what's this new one it's like ooh I quite like the sound of that one you know I'll grab that and once you do grab a few of these each you are starting to differentiate yourself a little bit more there are some leaders and LW cards that you can use to give everybody a little bit of player a symmetry I don't think it's a big problem to make it into your first game they recommend you don't but honestly these aren't that complicated so I would throw some of these base ones in there there is an expansion pack called leaders and laws to add even more asymmetry although that to me seems like a bit of a cash grab because it only adds like 22 cards and it's literally a stretch go stripped out of the kickstarter to sell separately which seems a little bit hm I'm not a fan of that I mean it's literally 22 cards that you got to sell me for 15 plus pound you know just put it in the base game and add a little bit more value to it you know cash art is always subjective in the eye of the beholder now this particular art
style has been used in a few of leader games already I think it works okay in Fort but I wasn't the biggest fan of it in root and I'm not sure it works here either and the artwork is very much of a mismatch I mean on the one hand you've got their typical artwork for a decent looking alen character on a character card okay fine I don't think it's Stellar artwork but to each their own but then when you look at these Guild cards you've got artwork on some of them and then on a few of these Vox cards you've just got basically a kids's hand drawing you know from a Sketchbook or something and it's like what what you ran out of Bud and you couldn't afford artwork for these ones was the point you know we can see it's a different type of card at the bottom and frankly they didn't function that much differently than the other ones so it's like you know could you have not afforded art for these why is it all handdrawn the map itself is also relatively clear to see where everything is so it's a easy to follow map but it's not that particularly inspiring either I mean the map is fairly tedious and boring there's just basically a circle of sectors each one just you know has a different type of resource planet on it and a few gate in the middle that allow you to kind of get to one side of the board a little bit quicker but that's kind of all there is to the map I mean you compare it to something that empires of the Void or even like some of the other games where the map builds as you go along this is just set in stone but some of the areas are cornered off and sectioned off entirely in three and two-player games which a looks a bit weird when you set it up but also just makes a fairly uninspiring map look even worse also everybody complains about some of the graphic design parts of this which is
mainly the planets themselves you know if you are colorblind you are going to have to rely on you know the symbols to get you for the resources but the resource symbol for each of these planets is really small and in some cases really hidden I mean the amount of times you look at a planet and can't quite tell it's a weapon resource Planet because the rocket ship that they use Blends so much into the drawing of the planet that you can barely see it so it would have been nice if they just made those a little bit bigger or just something I mean you've got a lot of wasted space here a lot of wasted dead space that's not doing anything you could have enlarged the symbol just a little bit to make it a bit clearer to see but why is it still blurry that's all the resolution we have making it bigger doesn't make it clearer the game is also very interactive with other players this is generally a good thing because it means that it's not just a solit game you've got to get in each other's faces you've got to think about what they're going to do whether they're going to play a certain type of card whether they're going to react to what you're doing are they trying to steal a card you're doing is they have they got a base that you might be able to go after that's undefended there's definitely definitely you know no solitary nature of this game though that does come with a bit of a caveat this is also one of the most brutal games you are going to play in a while you know you are constantly in each other's faces stealing cards off people you know grabbing cards before they can even if they've spent several turns trying to claim it themselves physically going up and blowing up their ships and bases you cannot play this easily I mean I have done but you cannot play it easily as a turtle with you know a pacifist attitude
because it's not going to be great when people start coming your way you can certainly play relatively defensively but at some point you are going to get into combat and there may be an opportunity for you to do a sneaky raid and you're going to want to take it you can't just be entirely on the sidelines but this game will put you in situations whether because of lack of the draw or you know what cards other people play as lead suits or just the fact that you could be ganked on by loads of other players and you could be in a situation where you're just not going to recover or at least find it very difficult to recover you've got a bunch of ships at the start of the game but if these get blown up early and you don't have construction cards then good luck good game you're not going to have enough ships to defend yourself people will just wail on you more there is no real catch-up mechanic in this like at all you know if somebody starts off well and keeps doing well unless all the other players start ganking on him then that player is going to continue to do do well there's not a huge amount you can do about it unless you get a specific Guild card to say help you with it or people pull their resources to do so but that's not something I've seen in this game and it's not something I don't think you could do very easily given that there is no binding deals there's no real cooperation in this game and certainly is fully competitive so there is definitely an essence of a runaway leader issue and certainly that if you're not comfortable with beatdowns and being on the back foot particularly
for a long game then this game is not going to be for you God sake why is it we can't learn to live together you're right Norman some flaws I'm going to mention a little bit later are compounded by this one the back says 60 to 120 Minutes that is wishful thinking this game easily with three players can easily surpass 2 hours or certainly get on to two and a half with four players you're looking more closer to three hours and for your first game you might want to add on at least another 30 minutes to an hour just to get through your first first game and if you've got new players it's going to slow the game down as well because they've got to get used to how the the tactics work and it's not as I said it's not the most rules intensive game but the problem that you have is that this game being pretty much solely tactical and reactive in the way that it works means that you can't plan your turn so you know you might have six cards in your hand it's like well I would quite like to uh you know do an aggression this turn then maybe do my admin and then do my mobilize you can't you've got to see what gets played as a lead card you know it's like I want to do battle this turn and I want to do a lot of movement okay what's the lead card it's an admin ah okay so I can only do one if I'm lucky and that's you know not exactly going to help but you know you are very much geared by what lead card gets played what cards are in your hand and how other players you know perform their turns I mean you might have an idea that all right this turn I will tax these planets and all be well but by the time it gets round to your turn in turn order people might have already Ram
raided most of your stuff it's like oh wait well that's not that great anymore I better think of something new to do and this generates a lot of analysis paralysis you know you cannot play this game quick super fast turns or anything like that you've got to think about your next move you've got to have a plan B and a plan C but the problem is is that you don't know what your plan B and C is until the other turns have unfolded so the downtime in this game can be quite high in terms of doing your turn you I mean you're not really involved on anybody else's turn other than the fact that somebody might go I'm attacking you here's some dice right give me your negative stuff you're certainly not interacting on a positive nature on anybody else's turn so I could be waiting to play my card and I'm sitting there going all right come on get on with your turn get on with your turn because the person before me has being screwed over by the lead card and now has to think oh great well now what am I going to play I was hoping you'd play a construction card and it does lock up a little bit well we're waiting now this rule book I said that it wasn't a rules intensive game and that you could probably get stuck into your first game relatively quickly that is a plus Kudos but this is still not the best rule book ever it's laid out in a bit of a weird way you know it starts off fine you know a few Core Concepts and then pling a chapter and in standard actions but where it then sort of drops the ball is that it gets into like other actions you know after you've already declared the end game and it's like and
and it's like well hang on a minute I kind of need to know what a Prelude action is a lot earlier in the book but for some reason it's miles at the end it's like why would you do that and then there's some fine print bits which are again fairly important rules that are just put at the very end a very tiny glossery at the other end and an index on the back and you might be thinking well that's not too bad is it well put it this way go on Board Game Geek there are over 300 threads in the rules section for this game 300 I am not joking it is there you can go see it this game does generate a lot of FAQ moments the their interactions with some of these cards are not laid out well enough in the book and obviously I didn't expect them to have like a whole list of every single card and what it does although to be fair some games do do that so if they can do it you can do it as well go to extra mile but the problem is is that a lot of the common interactions with some of these cars just aren't mentioned in this book and so it's or or if they are mentioned they're laid out in such a weird way that you'll easily miss it you know it is still not really 100% clear from the book how these Guild cards that have um icons on them that say oh yeah you can keep this one at this time or play it or you keep it at the score and it's like it's not 100% clear how they work but then you've got lots of other interactions with the characters and the guild cards that you know that are in this deck and even some of the scoring conditions it's just it doesn't lend
itself well to a smooth experience the amount of times that we've had FAQ moments in the game some of which I can get answered some of which I'm still to this day not entirely certain how they work you know the the book mentions about when you ransack somebody's card in a raid to you know grab you grab a card that's got their agents on it but it doesn't stipulate that zero doesn't count it says any number of their agent AG well does that include zero in which case can I just pick a card that doesn't have it I don't think you can but it's not explained well enough in the book there's no specific thing for it and there's just a lot of these FAQ moments that just kept popping up and if the rule book was robust enough then you wouldn't have 300 Freds on Board Game Geek so yes you'll be able to get started relatively quick but you're going to be asking a lot of questions and I do mean a lot I don't get it I don't get it I don't get it right let's get on to the big one and this is where there's a lot of contention between the fans of this game and the non-fans you know there is certainly big arguments to be had the luck factor of this game the randomness factor is one that is heavily contested among people who have played this whether good or bad now in well let's throw a little bit of a context here in terms of Randomness a lot of it stems from a few things firstly The Guild cards themselves the these Guild cards come out randomly and there is clearly some that are more powerful than others I'm sorry some of these are just like
basically solely here so that you can get an icon for a particular winning condition great but some of these here are incredibly powerful cards but also very swingy cards the ability to for example to declare an ambition when you're not the league player is insanely powerful I have put that to Serious good use a Vox card that says when you take this everybody has to provoke outrage of your choice bear in mind that when you provoke outrage which is usually when you kill a building you have to basically say that I can't spend the resource for a Prelude action for the entire game and you also have to discard all cards and resources of that type from your display if somebody is doing particularly well on empath and has a bunch of empath icons to grab that card particularly if you grab it pretty soon after it appears on the display and suddenly clear out their entire board that is not only extremely punishing and brutal but again it's not a balanced card it's like severely swingy but the main aspect is that people cry foul with regards to these Trick cards the fact that you get six of them at random you don't have a face up display of these cards which I kind of wish there was I would have kind of liked it maybe if there was a face up display and you had an action where you could buy the card so you could buy a specific card that you needed I mean that'd be pretty cool but for the most part you just get the six and that's it you're going to make do with it and the argument is that there is always you know never a good hand there's only a bad hand you got to do the best with it I'll beg the differ sir yes okay you've got to adapt to a
hand but there's clearly better hands than most or certainly better suited hands than what you have currently for what it is you really need to do I've had a bunch of my ships blown up okay I'm going to need some construction cards CU they're the only ones that can build ships okay otherwise my bases are undefended and I'm just going to get stuff stick stolen for me on a regular basis right well I just draw six cards here and I don't have any construction cards what am I supposed to do about that you can't do anything because you can only play a card of a different suit or copy the lead card so you have to hope somebody plays a construction card for you to have any construction that round and even then you're only going to get one action to do it with which might be build a single ship whippy you've got six turns a chapter and one of them is going to be to build a single ship ship that doesn't feel fulfilling and or fun nor is it going to solve your major problem another aspect is the Ambitions you've got five different Ambitions here although to be honest there's really only three you've got captives which is nicking Agents of cards you've got the warlord which is getting trophies in combat and then the other three are just clones of each other get all of this particular icon no difference between them it's literally just pile up on an icon so really you've only got three different Ambitions not five you know a little bit of extra variety would have been nice but you know let's say I'm doing really well as the fuel Drinker character and I've got a bunch of fuel I'm clearly suited to doing the Tycoon one while we're starting a new chapter
I'm the league player great let's uh declare Tycoon then none of my cards have Tycoon on it you know in fact I've just literally on this one I've got two relics I've got three warlord and one empath so I have to do one of those as my ambition nobody else is going to declare Tycoon because I've got all the stuff so why would anybody in there right mind be dumb enough to declare Tycoon so I've got one thing that I'm good at maybe two but I don't have a single card to allow me to actually do it so a lot of the stuff I've got in front of me is wasted now if I've got to adapt to something that I'm bad at I am clearly in a worse position than somebody else who's like well I got a few of these Relic tokens oh look there's a relic card yes I'll just declare The Relic ambition right now right cool we're going for that I'm already in the lead for that happy days they're in a better position than you are and that was entirely down to card draw nothing else there was nothing else to allow you to be in that situation other than just bad luck of the draw but then also you know you have the fact that a lot of your turn is dictated by what another player plays as their lead card I could have a bunch of you know low value cards with a bunch of actions on them well great you know I can do a lot of actions the problem is low numbers you're not going to surpass any card because most cards are going to be of a you know higher number unless somebody declares an ambition but that's only Rarities but then also you know just because I've got these cards that I might like doesn't mean that the cards that get played ahead of me are going to
help you know it's like I really need somebody to play aggression or mobilization admin admin construction it's like seriously I need you to play other cards I'm I'm getting this one action a turn now you can argue that you should discard a card from your hand to grab the initiative the problem is that sacrifices an entire turn of the round you only get six typically so now I only have five if I have to do that and you might be seizing the initiative literally for a single turn before it's nicked back off for you again if you're really fortunate you know you could have this for several turns in which case you're laughing you know nobody takes it off you but you know you've got to be really certain you want to discard a card to seize the initiative you know the games I have played maybe it's been seized by that method most I've seen it three times in a single game and that was a one-off I think most of the time I've only seen it happen once or twice and I know a lot of the fans are going to cry out foul saying I on this should be happening like three or four times a chapter what's going on well it's not an easy thing to convince new players to do and honestly a lot of the times I'd rather just deal with the fact that I'm not necessarily going first I mean I've won more of the games and I've lost of this but you know some of that is also down to the fact that I've got more experience than some of the newer players that have been taught but it's yeah I don't find that I want to discard cards in my hand to seiz the initiative as often as some people might make you want to believe and it just it carries that site problem that you know some people will say this is completely random and the fans will say this is not random it is entirely tactical there's no
Randomness I am definitely more siding towards the random side but more in the middle closer to the middle I think the call this game entirely random is a bit strong it definitely has a high random element though because you are drawing your six cards that start at random which is going to dictate a lot of your ability to do stuff in the round you know your ab your turn for the round is going to dictate by who what the lead card plays you have no idea what they're going to play so what do you what do you do from that the guild cards will come out at random so you don't know which ones are going to help suit you are they going to help other players but then on top of that combat is dice rolling so you might have spent a lot of time building up a you know nice Armada now I've gone to your place now I'm going to lay waste to your people right I'm going to roll a bunch of dice I got four or five dice here great and you roll like bunch of Blanks on the blues or you roll a ton of self hits or interceptions on the red dice which means you just get hurt first or maybe you're trying to raid and you want to Nick some stuff you roll and all you get is oh I get to hit your building once I get hurt and I get intercepted you know you can have combats fizzle completely and given that you only have six turns on average a around sorry a chapter to have entire like two or three turns potentially wasted like the setup and the execution it hurts it just adds to that brutal factor and you know you have some control over what you're going to do in terms of right well I I can choose which card I play but in terms of having
interesting things to do or meaningful things to do that on the other hand leads more towards the random element wait my cheating unit malfunction ARX is going to be one of the most talked about games in the gaming industry for at least the rest of this year you know we've had the most influential Channel talk about how this is game of the year and if you go on Board Game Geek and look at the other reviews that there are there's certainly a mix of love it and don't like it but you know there's a lot of reviews if you can call them reviews where they're not really telling you what the game is like they're trying to compare it to things like skateboards realtime strategy games and I don't know custard for all I know it's like this some really weird creative pieces on there they're interesting reads by all means give them a world but they're not really reviews and it's like you know can you tell me what the game's like to play what its mechanics are like how long it takes or are you going to be talking about skateboards I don't know it's kind of weird but you know for me this one is definitely a little bit of a mixed bag and I'm not getting Game of the Year Vibes to for like in any way shape or form that being said I can understand why some people would still really like this I mean this definitely feels like a game that is made for the coal fans if you are a fan of Cole's games rout Pax mamir John company if those games sing to you then by all means jump into this because I think you're actually going to have a pretty good time with it and I've had some fun with this it's not like oh I I you I don't hate this game you know
I've had some fun times with it but there are definitely some bits that really hinder the enjoyment particularly for how long the game is but you know it's definitely going to be an argument between one side who love it and one side who hate it because the people who do love this are very vocal about it you know you see it on Facebook all the time but really this game is meant for two types of people one the coal fans or two people who like long brutal punishing games with high interaction you want to get in people's faces and mess them over and watch them squeal then by all means this game's for you and if you like Cole's other games this game's also for you if you don't fit into one of those two categories though I strongly urge you to stay away from this game because you are not going to enjoy it I definitely kind of more somewhere in the middle you know I like some aspects I like the little bit of asymmetry you get although I wish there was more I do like that the scoring conditions change each chapter but again I wish they were more interesting you've only really got three different ones you know even though there are five I do kind of like the way this card mechanic works but I do wish I had more control over what cards I had and some more control over what I could do if the cards that get played as a lead card are not the ones that I want yes you can discard cards but discarding cards hurts and if somebody doesn't have to do it then they're in a better position in you and some of these Guild cards I like the fact that these Guild cards come out and give you some cool abilities but there's definitely an
unbalanced issue with the fact that some of these cards are literally just taken for the icon and some of these abilities are just downright broken in how you can really abuse them you know the rules I like these little guides that you get these guides are cool but then the rule book as much as it's not that rules intensive still leads itself to such a ton of FAQ moments that it just makes her a very clunky experience on top of the fact of it being like 2 and a half to 3 hours plus long the fact that the AP factor in this is very high because you've got to react to everything so you can't plan anything out at all so you know you're waiting for people to do their turns this game is only what I mean you always play this pretty much to chapter 5 you're never going to play this to chapter three it's not going to happen chapter 4 or if people let you get away with murder but you know to finish this in chapter 3 everybody would have to be death dumb and blind is is really going to be a five chapter game which means you're looking at a 2 and a half to three plus hour mark it's a lengthy one for sure so it's kind of a mixed bag for me I got some enjoyment out of it but I do think this has been overhyped by people who you know fair play love this game but are now trying to convince everybody that it is the game of the year and should be respected as such I think this is a niche game that's going to appeal highly to a small group of people and fair play this is the game for you but game of the year no there are some much better contenders this one RX gets a five out of 10 for me it's an average game I have
some fun with it and I have had some good times some good little moments some cool little card plays that I felt good but if you're on the back foot in this game this game is not enjoyable in the slightest and if you're not comfortable with the high random element and the fact that it's brutal and punishing it's going to affect your enjoyment as well and I got to admit I don't really go for Cole's other games and I like I well I like the card system but I don't particularly like how brutal and punishing this game is I don't tend to go for brutal or punishing games uh but I I'm I'm willing to accept a little bit of brutality if you can recover well and this game really does not let you recover you know if you get put on the back foot you're going to be on the back foot for the rest of the game compared to somebody who isn't and and they're just going to walk away with it really it's got some good elements but there's just a quite a bit that gets in the way and certainly for the cost I paid it is not good value for money it's adequate at best even at the normal retail value it's a it's okay for me I'm glad to have tried it but I do stipulate that this is really for a small Niche group of people and if you fit in that group get this game you're going to love it but if you don't stay away so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please f on YouTube and thumbing up on Board Game Geek when he goes live on the page don't forget to check out the other content I've done wild Gardens Daybreak quite a few reviews I've been putting out lately by all means check out those let me know your comments below although please let me civil about this because I know the ark Mega fans are going to dispute a lot of what's been said I've listened to a
lot of you already on other Freds and other posts I get what you're saying this game is not for everybody though and it certainly probably just wasn't for me but you know if you dispute some of the bits then by all means let us know your thoughts because this should be a nice Fair impartial comment section but again keep it civil you know what do you think about Cole's other games Pax mamir o you know r that are you Mega fans of those are you actually somebody who doesn't like Cole's other games but you like this one in which case I'd be very interested to know why that's the case cuz that I think would be quite an interesting read so take care and remember regardless of whether you're willing to get rid of half your hand to seiz the initiative it's still only a game so bye for now