Skip to main content
Loading video...

River of Gold - Mercantile adventures in Rokugan - TCbH Review

Transcript 9:05

what does it mean to be Innovative is it something completely new made whole cloth without any sort of inspiration or direct opposition to something that already exists or is iteration taking familiar elements remixing them and presenting them in an unfamiliar way enough that's the question that kept on popping into my mind as I was playing River of gold the new midweight Euro economic game set in rokuan the surprise surprise setting for a blast from my past the Legend of the Five Rings the legendary ccg and RPG see the game is essentially a linear worker placement like Parks or taido where you have two boats that are sailing down this titler trade route and most turns a player moves one of their boats a number of spaces and activates the four surrounding buildings when your boat falls off the map a new trade ship deploys at the top of the board continuing the cycle okay so the circular nature is a little bit different but it's not exactly Uncharted Territory well the second of three possible actions that you can select for your turn is to build a building spending your sweet hard-earned coku and taking one of the buildings from the for on display and placing it along the river giving you an immediate build buing bonus usually influence in the

region that it's built which itself is a track that increases in each region giving immediate benefits and bolstering your endgame scoring but just like say Lords of Water Deep these new buildings that coming to play give benefits to the players that visit them incentivizing boats by everyone to stop in those locations and there's an additional reward for the owner of the building when that building is visited okay so we're starting to see the economic Network at play you have the boats that are traveling along you'll activate the surrounding buildings to gain resources and money or you'll build buildings that are going to give you sweet sweet passive income as well as giving juicier spots for you and other players to visit all of this is dictated by a custom die numbered one through six and featuring the six regions and your action is either move a number of spaces equal to the die build a building in the depicted region or deliver to a customer card in hand affiliated with the dice's region granting immediate ongoing in endgame rewards and the game is played until all buildings for your player count run out of Supply either by being built or scrapping the top available anytime a boat Cycles off the board and most points by way of those claimed during game standing with influence in a region claimable Go Cards distributed at setup and number of completed customers not to mention delicious bonus scoring from their unique types not unlike Concordia

wins the game so again how Innovative is it and how Innovative does it need to be the DNA of great games over the last 10 plus years is all over this thing but it's the unique combination of presentation of those ideas the amalgamation that gives it a unique identity and makes it feel unlike anything else a big part of this is the freedom which is a weird thing to say when your turn is dictated by a D6 but end of every turn you roll and plan do you move one boat five spaces build in the marshes deliver to a customer in the marshes or do you spend Divine favor to rotate your dice up or down granting a series of other options Divine favor is enough of a cost that you don't use it frivolously but not so much that you hesitate to take advantage of and that's what this game is all about the propellent drive of taking the best series of turns after turns getting better and better rewards it's not super sequential in the Strategic sense it's not like you pick a plan real early and just lean into that especially because you're continually reacting to a die roll and the board state which is ever changing but like the Great River of Ru G itself there is a really nice tactical flow also I love the beautiful Arc that comes out of such a simple structure both with the river becoming far more populous and lucrative as players add

buildings but your customers unlock powerful effects from monks increasing your Divine favor and letting you have additional rewards from buildings to Merchants that trigger abilities with every boat completing their journey to Nobles that upgrade your ship that trigger powerful abilities upon their movement all in a tight package where you find yourself wishing that it were just a hair longer but that's much better than the alternative of wishing the game had ended 20 minutes ago and all of this analysis so far is using my quasi objective critic hat but I'm going to have to remove that for a second as we step into the realm of nostalgia to take a look at presentation and theme rokuan the setting of The Legend of the Five Rings was one of the longest lasting true comp competitors to Magic to come out of the early ccg boom one that enveloped my teens in early 20s hitting as many as two sanctioned tournaments a week in competing in several regionals this setting inspired by East Asian mythology and in retrospect a significant amount of heavy-handed orientalism has endured evolved and thankfully become more thoughtful through the course of the mountains of fiction and game entries generated for the last 30 years River of gold does not need need to be set in rokugan the class struggles between peasantry and the powerful ruling class Waring Samurai struggling over territory

but also dutifully protecting against the shadowlands the mystical monks in shugenja tapping into ethereal magic and the duplicitous courtiers leveraging honor deception and propriety to steer the Empire toward their goals none of this is pertinent to this game and yet that can be kind of cool in its own way too this is a mer game set in a marshall world with just enough of the trappings to be distinctive while not expecting players to know the Deep Lord to appreciate the beautiful production with the fine gold embossing throughout there are little things I take issue with the choice of two-player powers for each Clan feel very much like an afterthought both with relatively slight mechanical impact with only the barest link to the history or ideology of the four representative Clans crab crane Scorpion and mantis you're at Tomo's Alliance for life and the overall missed opportunity to take advantage of the settings bureaucracy via taxes levies and tffs in a trading game but overall it provides Vibrance and dimension to a world I love that is normally Larger than Life clearly I really like the game it's beautiful easy to learn and has great momentum but it also has a share of flaws in addition to the criticisms I've already mentioned there are times where it feels like just every move is good and yeah while some may be better than others having every single move Propel

you and the game forward feels like it can remove some degree of tension and that's going to be a problem for some people also for a Euro game made in 20124 it's practically inexcusable to not have a solo game fortunately the good Folks at the BGG solo Community have already been working on this so you can play this solo if you're willing to do a little bit of print and play but that really should have been a consideration in the box from the get-go but in the end it's just really nice not Monumental and not particularly Innovative either mechanically or in its kind of casual adaptation of the setting but in both it tries to take these disperate elements and present them in a new way with a wonderful result that sails confidently on its own and that's our review let me know are you an l5r fan have you played the original game have you played the RPG have you played the Fantasy Flight reimplementation of the ccg or any of its offshoots put your favorites and your clan affiliation in the comments below and as always thanks for watching thanks for supporting thanks for being such an awesome Community you know that I've been Jack for the cardboard Herold

Progress saved