Descent: Legends of the Dark Review - It's A Big Price To Pay
Transcript
you'd think this would be a bit heavier hi everyone thanks for tuning in to another episode of the broken me pull remember if you like what you see please remember to leave a thumbs up and a comment it means the world to me to know that you appreciate the content and of course remember that the patreon campaign is always ongoing if you want to support the channel even further so yeah we're taking on the monstrosity today and i'm a little bit late to the party with descent legends of the dark and well to be fair i wasn't actually planning to review it because to be honest what essentially happened was i thought you know what i don't think i've got time to devote to this one i don't think i want to pay the big price for it now and i couldn't get a review copy for either so i thought i'll just leave it be other people were reviewing it and i thought you know what i can't do everything and then at the very last minute as bidet basically said we gotta spare cappy do you want it okay fine so i had to basically find some time to devote the hours into this box because it's a quite a lengthy one to say the least but i thought you know what people wanted to know what my thoughts were and even though i'm late to the party hopefully my opinion is still something you want to hear now i'm going to stipulate before this review starts though that i have not played the entire campaign of this i still have to finish it but i have played the majority of it i believe the campaign is something like 16 to 18 like 15 16 odd missions and i've done at least 10. so i've done the majority of
this campaign and i just need to do a few more to finish it off and that's good enough for me i think to do a review yes i can't comment on how good the ending is but if you're not enjoying the game after 10 plays like 10 scenarios i don't think you're going to enjoy the game for the last three or four you know come on i don't watch a three hour movie to hope that the last 10 minutes are good so now with that little caveat set in motion we can get on with it get on with it forge your own legend together with friends as you adventure across the vibrant fantasy realm of terenoff in the cooperative dungeon crawling board game descent legends of the dark powered by an integrated free companion app descent legends of the dark puts you in the role of a budding hero with their own play style and abilities together with your unlikely companions you'll begin an unexpected adventure an adventure told across the 16 quests of the blood and flame campaign throughout your campaign you'll face undead lurking in the mists demonic barbarians stalking in the wilds and even more terrifying threats with 46 pieces of 3d terrain and 40 hero and monster miniatures to draw you into the game your greatest adventure is yet before you your objectives will change from quest to quest as you follow the overarching story of the campaign core gameplay mechanisms such as combat fatigue skills items and more have received completely new interpretations with legends of the dark while a new approach to scenario layout and 3d terrain creates striking multi-level scenarios as well as the classic deal of throwing dice and killing monsters the
unique selling point of this one is that your characters your skills and your weapons and armor have double sides to them allowing you to flip over between them during the mission in order to either remove fatigue or just switch between different play styles depending on what the mission will throw at you the app also brings new changes to gameplay introducing enemies with adaptable strategies complex status effects and also the ability to develop your heroes based on the choices you make in scenarios in between scenarios you will be able to craft new items upgrade your weapons and find out more story points about the various characters within the game because of these various differences dissent legends of the dark is not compatible with journeys in the dark or its previous expansions 16 scenarios await you do you have what it takes should you even get started let's find out in more detail so starting with duration these scenarios do take a long time to play this is not a pick up and play easy to get into like oh i just want to see a quick adventure let's get it out and beat up some monsters hell no this is long very long and i'm just i'm not even talking about the scenarios i'm talking about the whole thing in general firstly i've played this campaign entirely solo but i'd also played the first couple of missions several times with different groups at different multiplayer accounts i played the demos at the uk games expo i also played with a friend of mine in their kind of smaller campaign to just get it going until someone replaced me and then i played through this slot solo and
regardless of the player account the game is long you are taking at least a good 90 minutes with a solo scenario typically because the so the scenarios are quite long in what they do and with more players you're going on for two hours three hours it can go on for stupid lengths of time a friend of mine plays a four player campaign at a games club on my games club night and there are times when the place is shutting down after a four hour window and they haven't finished the scenario huh oh nodded off for a bit though it's ridiculous how long this game can go with four players when you factor in the the stuff in between missions and all that wow this is not quick much like other dungeon crawls of this nature and it's not helped by the fact that you have to spend a long time setting this game up like a long time wow i mean you put stuff in the box i'm actually scared to get it out of the box again because you not only have to i mean firing up the app is easy but it's that terrain that terrain is a double-edged sword yes it looks sort of cool we'll get on to more detail on that later but it looks sort of cool to be on the table and visualize what you're doing but when you've got to assemble that all the time in every scenario it gets very repetitive and tedious very quickly and that takes a decent amount of time in fact you kind of roll your eyes at points when you've been for a scenario for an already a good hour or so and speaking from a solo perspective you've already been it for a lot of time you
think right we've got to the end this is the last bit on this site current layer of terrain we're good and then suddenly it's like act two of the scenario you're doing now set up this multi-layered monstrosity of terrain and pillars and overlays and stuff it's like ah give me the box you know it does get repetitive and that takes time it it's not a pick up and play adventure and then you've got to pull it all the way in the box and that takes a while because you've got all the terrain pieces that you've got dump in the bottom of it you've got all your character sheets the fatigue tokens you've got obviously not lose the different cards you've got whatever skills they've got you know the app tracks a lot of this stuff but you still have the physical cards and the components and everything that you need to get out so i would have liked this to have been a much quicker affair not only in playing the game but also in just setting up and putting a thing away when you're done moving on to ease of play you get two books in this thing one lore guide and i'll give you five bucks if you actually have read this all the way through because i certainly haven't but you know tearing off is a pretty generic fantasy world if you ask me but then you've got a pretty sizable rule book here and it does look a little bit daunting but it's written pretty clearly i didn't have many faq moments there's a lot of pictorial examples in here and to be honest most of it is taken care of by the app when you play the first mission it is a tutorial mission although it does go on quite for a long time but it teaches you the basics of interacting
with bits of terrain fighting an enemy what weaknesses mean how your character works what fatigue does how to build various bits of terrain the story choices that you do and then it runs you through the bits in the city once you're done but every rule that's in the game is represented in this rulebook as well with examples so and you've got the quick reference on the back it's not quite as simple as other games that have tried this but it's still relatively straightforward i wouldn't throw a new gamer in front of this in any way shape or form but even a reasonably light gamer who hasn't played that many adventure style games could probably get into this with a little bit of maybe slow play on their first couple of scenarios but then they'll they'll get into it the tutorial is a good solid length mission that goes over a lot of what you're gonna find in the game and so props to that and a lot of that comes down to the app itself the app is a great design and definitely the kind of like the highlight of where the focus of this game is the app tracks your inventory and there's you know you've got to have your cards out but it tracks what you should have in terms of potions and that it tracks all the materials you've picked up which you use to craft different recipes it's an easy to use interface you basically just sort of click like well not click even you just sort of tap hold drag an arrow to various things from a character to say i want to do this this character the elf whoever wants to attack that enemy wants to interact with that bookcase and it's
pretty easy it's explained on screen you can get little tool tips to help you as well it comes up with little music and that it's a very good design now you can't just learn this with the app and the rulebook on their own you kind of need them to work in a symbiotic relationship with each other in order to really grasp the game the app will teach you the majority of what you need to know but you're going to need the rule book to fit in a few blanks here and there now for tactics and strategy this is where things kind of take a little bit of a downhill turn it's not the most in-depth adventure game i've ever played here very much even though you've got this app and you've got like all little weaknesses on enemies that you can exploit which you know they're safe so once you know that a bandit is weak to piercing you know that for life basically but other than that it's basically go forward kill things in sight occasionally you get a puzzle thrown at you or some little like hint of an rpg element thrown in but they're pretty minor and not difficult to figure out at all if you're paid even the remotest bit of attention but in most scenarios it's a case that you go forward oh there's an enemy i better go blat it you know you're not gonna run away from it and you're certainly not going to like leave it be it's going to come and get you so you might as well go kill it first when you get a group of enemies it's the same strategy to basically gank on one enemy take it down gank on the next gank on the next it's
the same strategy and tactics throughout pretty much the entire game no matter how much this game tries to throw at you wow i mean the tutorial mission is perfectly doable not very difficult at all even the boss in it is fairly straightforward to kill wow does it take a little bit of a difficulty spike as soon as you start doing the first couple of missions though i mean the second mission i was in it's like are you kidding me i've gotta fight that thing with basic stuff it's like that's insane and even the few missions after that you start noticing that the difficulty really does ramp up honestly play this on normal mode and stick to that don't play this on hardcore or insane or whatever they've got on there above it because i think you're just gonna get punished unduly the enemies get to crazy levels of hit points and resistances and even just the damage they deal so you're chucking dice and killing enemies okay so where's the unique part well it's all about the flipping of the cards and various other things your weapon has double side so you've got a melee weapon in the ranged weapon perhaps so you might go in with a bow but you also have a nice couple of daggers that you can use and what you have is an ability called prepare which basically allows you to start thinking about flipping over the cards or your hero character sheet and as you use various abilities you might have to put fatigue on various cards that you've got and then once you have a chance to flip the card you can essentially go flip the card and it allows you to remove the fatigue but also changes what the card did and this is
a decent area but the problem is you don't do it that often uh depending on what character you are the elf characters are basically golden like the archer has basically inbuilt abilities that allow him to flip over his cards on a regular basis so he's always doing the flipping and stuff but other characters struggle with this even with that mechanic it's not the most engrossing of things to do just like oh i can just flip over my card every now and again you can set up some interesting combo turns with a melee weapon and a ranged weapon say like you know you've got a ranged weapon and then you move and then you flip your card and go in for a melee strike you know that can look that can be cool when you do it but that's they don't happen as often as i would like and flipping over your hero character sheet is mainly just what like little variation of ability you have i never really felt that the mechanic was that great and because it's not that difficult to implement if you're playing this solo you are meant to be only playing with two characters i don't see why you couldn't play with a furrowed if you're already that way in kind moving on to aesthetics this is again hit and miss and for a game that costs 130 pound or whatever it costs in your country i don't think okay is good enough the app looks great the art style is very divisive i'm fine with it but i would maybe prefer a different style i know some people hate it i know some people love it it's definitely going to be an
eye of the beholder no d and d pun intended you know for this one but the problem is is that as much as i like the way the app looks and i don't mind the artwork the component quality is good but the terrain is a bit of a hit-and-miss affair for me it's 3d and you get to see it out on the board fine you need to spend a good couple of hours assembling the rotten stuff when you buy the game though i warn you of that i spent the whole evening after work basically having to punch out all these cardboard bits and then assemble them all with a little chest here a tree here a multi-part dragon statue here it's like takes a bit of the time and then you got to stuff it all in the box and hope it stays in one piece but it's still not the best quality cardboard though that they use especially with the treasure chest that you got like fold over and then put together the ends on so they stay together they seem a little bit flimsy and a little bit like basic but on top of that the art style on the terrain is kind of what i would compare to a low texture rpg game from the 90s it doesn't look very good at all the underlays literally are just a flimsy little bit of a paper card that you slip underneath bits of terrain to create a lava pit or a poison area it's like poison it what does the poison area even mean it's just like green underlay i don't know the water looks the best but even then it's pretty basic the rest of the terrain just looks really muted and bland though the stone pillars and that are just basic gray the gray floors don't look interesting you know various
bits of terrain like bookcases and chess are fine i don't mind that and you get little weird extras like a little potion cauldron thing uh you get like a book you know evil book understanding like don't read those kind of things you know if you know what's good for you and those are cool like the little pieces here and there but the big scale stuff with the exception of that dragon statue which is pretty cool but the general room stuff that you build does look like low texture quality rpg stuff and the game costs 130 pounds this is not a cheap game and it's not good enough to just be okay in this regard if you want me to fork over a three digit sum of money for this game that's not even a kickstarter project i need stuff to be like out of this world i need stuff to be great i have got games on well some of those games are in the bag from the convention i was at recently but there are games on my shelf that cost less than this that i think are better produced i mean have you seen what else creak games puts out you know you gotta admit you can do a lot with 40 bucks but this is 130 it's a lot of cash and for low texture quality terrain i felt a little bit underwhelmed by that aspect especially as i knew that i was gonna have to spend ages assembling the rotten stuff as i was playing a game you can tell that a lot of that price went into the app which granted is the best thing about this game you know i want this app technology in other games i just feel that the visual 3d terrain bit could have been a little better quality
now we get onto immersion and this is a hit and miss one as well it definitely is thematic it definitely puts you in that world the 3d terrain is definitely a visual aid to suck you into whatever adventure it is and i've got to applaud some of the design choices they made on some of the scenarios there's a one in particular that involved a dream state i won't spoil anything from the story but it basically involved a dream state where you kind of control two different aspects of a scenario at once and the way it linked the two together i thought was pretty clever even if the aesthetics of the 3d terrain didn't help to really bring that into the forefront but i thought this was a cool idea and little tricks like that they pull in some of the scenario design was definitely a plus point it definitely feels like your typical dungeon crawl smash the door down go and kill the dragon with your big slowy sword you know that is definitely represented here where this lacks a little bit though is the writing this story is a pretty generic story with a lot of tropes that you've seen before in fantasy films or fantasy series or even just like you know i mean gloomhaven's story wasn't particularly great this isn't particularly great either but the writing feels a little amateurish at times say something stupid like oh the power of love oh yeah these characters are written with the very basic tropes that you've seen before and as i'm going through these scenarios i mean i've still got a few to finish off there's 16 in the bags and i've done 10 or 11 i think something like that so i've still got about five or so to play i'm not that fussed about what happens
next though there have already been plot twists that have happened and in a really good film or a really good game that i'm invested in i should be like oh you know shock horror and here i'm just like nah that happened okay fair enough and there's a lot of reading you got to do in this when you're in between missions and you go in like the screen basically brings the characters and sort of highlights who's talkies like you know as basically they all play red light green light with the screen but with this you know you you read all their stuff and you you can make silly voices when you're reading it as a group when you're in it solo you're just reading the basic story but there's a lot there to read and it's not the best writing if i play tainted grail or this war of mine that days of the siege campaign oh i love the stories in that the tainted grail story and setting is so good and rich and dripping theme the arthurian legend style the days of the siege campaign for this war of mine is still one of my favorite campaigns i've ever played the story is so gripping the the stuff that happens to you is like meaningful you know the choices feel meaningful you know everything has repercussions and you feel bad when stuff happens that doesn't go well for you here you make story choices along the way but you don't really notice a great deal of their impact you usually get thrown up a couple of choices of in a speech like um i wish to go take out this enemy because dot dot dot and then it will say to avenge my fallen comrades or because my com because my new friends
need it or something like you know it gives you two choices you pick one and you keep doing that several times and yes it does have an impact but you don't notice it a great deal and certainly there's not a huge like oh my god colossal difference between the two outcomes to make you think oh i can play this over again i'm going to get a totally different feeling character and story so it didn't have enough impact for me so immersion in the middle it's a very basic story kind of basic writing but it does put you in the theme of the typical kick the door down and black monsters and if that's all you're after and you don't really care about the story then well you're in a good place here so longevity you're paying 130 pounds for this box and you want it to last you a long time well it's going to last you a long time to play through the campaign i mean 16 scenarios when it takes a minimum of 60 to 90 minutes just to play through a scenario solo let alone if you're playing with other people you could easily be getting like well i mean as a solo player probably a good i'd say 25 30 hours out of this game i would say as a solo player you're going to get way more hours than that if you play multiplayer just for how long the scenario takes so you're definitely getting your money's worth in terms of the first campaign play i'd be surprised if anybody wants to play through this campaign a second time though the story is not gripping or varied enough in order to allow for repeat plays yes you've got these minor
differences that are done with those like choices i mentioned a minute ago and you could choose different characters to play more often than others but it's not different enough i'm not going to play for a second time and get a completely different story compared to the first take tainted grail back as the other example i played through it as a general goody two shoes like i'm gonna be you know the savior and knight i'm gonna be a nice person you know and i will side with these people as i go through i could play through the same scenario with a different character be evils or get out side with the evil characters at certain stages and major changes will happen from the story to warrant a second playthrough here though once you have played it you're kind of done and i'm not a big fan of that when it cost 130 pound in the first place and the box has uh was is on this rulebook i'm not picking up the whole box again there it's not there is it on this lid here we go yeah see this phrase here we go act one act one so they've already announced an expansion for this i forget gray hawks or something or whatever and that's going to be compatible with this terrain so it's good that they're releasing more content but an expansion means more money more backs it's the slower the rings journalism another thing you know it's like you've got your base box now we've got to pay extra for dlc campaign stuff but then there'll be an act two coming out at some point which will no doubt probably be a box just as big as that with different miniatures different
terrain different stuff that you've got which is probably going to be another 130 pounds on tap so this game will have a lot of expandability over time obviously but it's gonna cost you an arm and a leg to keep up with it and how are you gonna store it you saw how big that box was when i held it first it takes up a good chunk of the top of the shelf here it will take up an entire calyx square by itself and yes it will fit in one of those but but the only thing you shoving it can you imagine having two or three of those with the expansion stuff shoved in it whoo that would be a lot of storage space for it but yeah you kind of play it once and be done really you'll wait for the next expansion and then you'll kind of be done so with my final summary this is tough because i have enjoyed my time playing this game but i'm less inclined to want to get it back to the table to finish it off i know i will finish you off i promise you i'll finish it off but i'm not as excited to do that and that's a problem i have enjoyed the time i've spent but there have been things that have got in the way you know i like the idea of just kick the door down and kill stuff with weapons and that i like leveling up characters in between missions crafting different hilts for your swords and bows that allow you to do potent percentage chances of status effects and that that's cool i like the fact that the app is a technological achievement that brings musical into like musical immersion as well as tracking a lot of the fiddly bookkeeping stuff great
but the chore of install making all that terrain every game is irritating i know i pretty much just lay out a basic sheet with where the monsters are and leave it at that really i can't even be bothered to stick stuff on pillars enough staircases and all that stuff there because it just takes ages to set it all up all the time you know but on top of that the flipping of the cards is fine but nothing special the writing is a bit amateurish but again not bad but the scenarios do take a long time to play so it's got a lot of negatives that aren't huge by themselves but they do mount up but then there's good stuff to say about it as well but i'm going to struggle to give this one a seal of endorsement and i think my final verdict is going to be a 6 out of 10 for descent i've i don't regret playing it i think it's good i think it's above average you know above average style game but i don't think for that price tag it's gonna win that many people over a lot of fans didn't even want this game really but i feel that the hate train on this was not really deserved but then i also feel that 9 out of 10 and 10 out of 10 is probably stretching the mark a little bit because that's overlooking a lot of problems that this game has but a lot of fans exist for this game and that's fair enough you know it's definitely enjoyable but maybe you might want to wait for it to come down a little bit in price or maybe get it as a group between you like pay a bit of money each and then invest your time into it but
yeah this isn't exactly the adventure game that's going to suddenly take over like 2021 and be the highlight of the year i've played better games this year and it just felt like a pretty expensive above average game and for that price tag i don't want above average i want blow my mind this one doesn't do that so that's my detailed review of dissent legends of the dark do you agree or disagree with my views let me know your thoughts in the comments particularly with regards to paying a lot for the game itself and the expansions in future do you like the art style and the aesthetics or did it not work for you do you prefer the second edition of descent compared to this one have you played both let me know your thoughts in the comments i'm interested to hear that's it for this video if you like what you see please remember to leave a thumbs up it means the world to me to know that you appreciate the content don't forget that the unofficial sponsor of this channel is zatu.co.uk if they got it in stock and descent is taking your eye then perhaps buy it from them fill a gap in your shelf and get a decent cast and if you want to check out more content on the channel you can continue with my top 100 with the 50 to 41 segment or you can listen to my latest podcast where i go on a little bit of ranting about the june board game in that show as well so that's it for me i'll see you on the next broken people video and remember as always it's only a game bye for now