Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hegemony is CRAZY Asymmetric (and why it's good)

Transcript 29:53

I can't review this board game I just can't give it an in-depth review I just can't it's too crazy hemony is a huge Rising Game on BGG with good reason it's a game about IRL Society with everyone playing different classes and yes this is actually class Warfare the game as such this is an inherently sensitive topic we're talking about I mean even the word hegemony is a pretty loaded one I'm not taking any ideological stance here or whatever I'm just reporting on what the game is this is is not a review I better not be seeing any comments down below saying whether or not this is a good or bad review because it's not really one we're not really going in depth about the pros or cons or balance or whatever so you can call this a overview a Impressions video after two plays or rant etc etc but don't call it a review in the way we do it here at Shelfs side also our two plays were at four players so we're only talking about the four player game which is using all the factions which truly I don't think is enough to scrp crash the surface of this crazy game this video is brought to you by ascension. G this is a private free toplay World of Warcraft server so you can play for the horde it revolves around being classless where you can pick your own munic hero by combining abilities from all classes I gave it a quick run and it was a fun mix of nostalgia with some added quality of life stuff like the game feels so much faster with the draft builds where you can just learn preset ability builds to combo together I used the wind Berserker in the starting area and it was so fast and you can go even faster with the

leveling draft builds the new season also has tons of new modes including the Wild Card mode and when we tried it out it was super busy it's where you get random abilities as you level and you can roll a load out right when you start and you can roll it once you've rolled your initial build you can refine it by playing through the end game and prestiging that is basically infinite replayability so check out the link in the description below to play Ascension wow Destiny's Dawn for the new season now back to the review video remember I it's not a review it's a video pajam what is it the board game that is in hemony you're one of the four factions of classes in modern day Society you're trying to get the most points AKA prosperity and your own different way regardless of faction each round will have you taking turns of playing one card from your hand using its ability or discarding it to do a faction action then you get a free action everyone gets five of these turns involving a card from your hand then the round ends then you do upkeep like possibly feeding your workers and paying taxes yes paying taxes I'm not making this up however the similarity between the factions ends there so let's get into how unique each of them are and as we get into this I'm not making any of the stuff up okay this is how crazy IRL the game is to start we have the state which is trying to gain the most legitimacy via dealing with each of the factions like providing health care and then trying to match the policies to each round's randomly drawn political agenda you may have to push these to the left or right yes very thematic and then there's the capitalist trying to get the most Capital every round that is cash money after it gets taxed this slot mostly gets money by producing goods via their businesses and

selling them to other players or exporting them to the international market but wait someone's actually got to work at those businesses so then we have the working class they are playing a worker placement is game by deciding which of the businesses to work at the states capitalist ones or the middle class ones the workingclass gets their money via wages through working for them to win they're trying to do well for their people mostly by gting Healthcare from buying it from other players that have it produced finally there's that middle class which is also playing a worker plac mensh game kind of like the working class difference is they just have less workers that tend to be more skilled meaning the non- gry ones oh yeah and then they also have their own businesses meaning they can work for themselves or anyone else they're kind of like the workingclass and capitalist combined where they have the means of production and our labor as well so they can produce stuff but to fulfill all their needs including Healthcare to get their points they may need to buy it from other players now that you know all four factions remember that everyone has their own goals of which other factions can either help you or hurt you like the capitalist can sell cheap healthcare to the working class but they can also provide the most expensive healthare by jacking up prices price too high well then go to the middle class for healthcare or with a certain government policy State Healthcare is free oh by the way this buying stuff from others is usually via a main action you usually have to discard a card but sometimes you can use the Ability on the card instead for something similar to the train action now for voting which we didn't mention yet if someone wants to propose a bill as an action a vote happens for it at the end of the round everyone first says whether they are for or

against it then you take out five cubes from the bag then make two piles those for the four voters and those for the against voters lastly everyone can secretly spend a resource they have called influence and that contributes to the final result if there's a tie those in favor win that's round at the end of the fifth round you see who has the most points oh and everyone except for the state gets bonus points by having more of their political trackers and their column so try to get it aligned to you notable cool stuff not Pros now for all the the cool stuff that was tucking at me to make this video that again is not a review like for instance I'm not even going to talk about components much in this video moving on as we discussed each of these factions is insanely unique and thematic like if you want a symmetry in a game this game is uh has got you covered from a physical point of view there's completely different player boards pieces and part of the board they each interact with and decks are slightly different with a little bit of crossover each faction has different ways of winning so let's start with the working class and middle class who are the most similar since they both have workers but the working class will get so many workers definitely a lot of unskilled ones every round and they have immigration to deal with on top of that yes that is a literally thing in this game that affects all laborers as such the working class really needs to find ways to feed all of its workers be careful for rampant unemployment but also since they have the most workers they can have some leverage on the game and we'll get into that more then the middle class is a little less extreme but has to worry about their own businesses where they get to set wages choose to open some that might have openings for the working class to work at or sell those that no one can work in so both of these laboring classes are

playing a working replacement is game where while their workers don't come back to them every round they can decide to move them from business to business as an action let's say new doctor's office opens up you want to work at well let's move to work there middle class moves and working class deze move each of these workers corresponds to the right type of job I'm assuming these ones are like media pros and then the ones over here are some type of agricultural Pro you can even decide to trade the unskilled gr workers to these by just getting some education which is a good in this game you can buy oh yeah and then both these factions can protest for higher wages if they think their payday is too low let's go to The Other Extreme with the capitalist who don't have any workers but rather they're all about that money remember money is a VP for them at the end of a round it just has to survive taxation first so a big part of the capitalist is playing a money manipulation game to change your tax bracket you can change the price of goods accordingly sell or buy business businesses or screw it let's just buy a private island for points and these tycoons aren't directly beholden to labor complaints because they can automate their businesses automation exists as an investment in this game the state is a much different story where they're actually very reliant on what others do and if you look at the state's actions here it's the smallest Range out of all of them essentially the government is trying to be buddy buddy with everyone in the game all the factions to try to move their legitimacy up and then try to coax people in the right direction to get their events completed and then see where people are leaning politically so they can move

these trackers up and down to do their political agenda but but the state money is vastly different from everyone else not just because it's in the middle of the board but if the state goes broke okay like everyone else the government gets a loan but if they do that twice at the end of the round the IMF aka the international monetary fund will come in and say what the heck are you doing to the country this is inhumane how could you so so yeah since the state is the equivalent of too big to fail they are relieved of their debts but then the IMF changes all political policies to what they want uh-oh this could even mean liquidating public businesses oh yeah the state also loses half of their legitimacy bonus with every player which hurts their VP advancement okay so that's the big catch of agemy right each faction is extremely thematic and asymmetric but now we'll get into how they all interact with one another in very thematic ways cuz the state in working class are butt buddies as the working class wants the state to get bigger to provide them with free healthcare and sometimes more places to work at then as the state provides such Healthcare to the masses they get super legit the capitalists get crazy Returns on Goods being produced and sold to other players if they don't want to sell to the foreign market they can get even more goods via access to Imports but they'll be paying the government a little bit because there's a tariff on that oh and then you can vote for the Tariff to go up or down also anytime the capitalists want more things someone has to May make that so they're beholden to the laboring players continuing to work at their businesses the boss man can't

be too stingy with salaries the middle class is in the name that is straggling the middle they don't want things to be too crazy to the left and right of the political tracks they're balancing deciding to work for the state or capitalist to get wages or should they just work for themselves to get their production does the working class have too much unemployment and you can give them some jobs maybe the state can pay for your businesses oh yeah we got to dial in on the state going broke which which is a huge deal in this game remember how we said this resets the political policies through the IMF coming in well remember these political policies are the Perpetual passes of the game so that is massively disrupting plans like did you want to vote on something at the end of the round well too bad your proposed bill is now thrown out by the IMF you can't vote this round anymore whatever the IMF decided for you that's going to be it this round where you Reliance on getting a bunch of cash from state jobs well actually uh these State businesses are now gone cuz the state can't afford them anymore so all these people here are laid off if you're expecting to get wages here too bad were you happy about low taxes over here well now taxes are at the highest tier uh so you got to pay through your nose at the end of the round pay a bunch of taxes to the government who needs the money so treasury going to zero big deal and there's so many ways for other players to manipulate the state's money to avoid that or get to that if you want to drain the treasury every faction has a way to call in government favors for them to pay for stuff or just vote for high minimum wage then go work for the state in drov because the state has to pay those wages or they can vote to open up a ton of State businesses and then the

state has to pay for each of those when they open easy way for the state to go massively broke if you're trying to protect the state treasury you do the opposite vote to shrink the government by closing businesses or only buyer goods from the states nothing wrong with public education or vote to raise taxes or keep them high essentially hegemony is super inter play among all these different parts of society all these different classes you're trying to get the best for your class while trying to squeeze out the most out of every other class don't squeeze the government too much because then they go broke and then that can disrupt plans but then maybe you want them to go broke to reset the IMF every turn can be decisions on what goods are prioritize making so maybe you make or close businesses maybe you're pricing each of the three Goods differently maybe you're deciding how to move your workers if you have workers and then of course you're always worrying about this policy track there's even more stuff we can talk about these policies and just to summarize what they are these are how big the government is minimum wage taxation cost of public Healthcare and cost of public education but we also got these two on the side we have to worry about immigration is laborers coming to the country every round which can hurt or help the working in Middle Class depending on how many more people they're okay with having more people can be more problems then you can even affect foreign trade policy which really affects those exporting Goods that is the capitalist anyways between these seven policies you're always looking when's the right time to push it towards your desired area if

you're not the state you want to see maybe you have the state support with their agenda this round and then it really helps that the middle class is always trying to have stuff in the middle so you can count on them if one of these are on the extremes pretty much everyone is involved with the vote because the end product will affect them in some way after sussing out how much or how little each player wants to policy push in their preferred Direction you have to see if you have enough phoning cubes in the back more is better then you might want to acquire more influence via radio stations or straight up State corruption ha you want to get those purple cubes for more value after you see results and we glanced over briefly in the initial overview but all non-state players get endgate bonuses for having the marker on their preferred alignment so come mid to late game you're frequently looking at what policy you can slowly move over to your side or keep it there which again can get really disrupted if the IMF comes in oh no all these cool things I'm bringing up just culminates into a believable feeling country with a massive capacity for tons of banter and thematic stories examples let's go our first game had so much unemployment via unchecked immigration where workers were sitting at the docks in droves and could not find a job and then there was so much Healthcare that needed to be provided for them but then there was a lot of representation in voting because lots of people the second game had the workingclass being insanely self-sufficient by getting their own Farms early game so then the capitalist couldn't get them to work for his farms in both games the working in Middle Class are yelling at each other about

why they're taking each other's jobs actually in one game the middle class and capitalists were actively trying to bankrupt the state to close down jobs for the working class who were massively winning then at the corner every game the capitalist will complain about taxes and try to pay the least amount possible and then the citizens don't appreciate their food they're going to export all the food they create overseas to North Korea or something imagine game States where people are not really wanting to work for the capitalist companies but they're still working there so the capitalist enforce an extra shift to squeeze out labor now then when those workers leave no worries just sell the business and then having less businesses helps you evade some taxation or the middle class just leaves the country they migrate out because conditions are just so bad the country isn't what they thought it'd be after the IMF came in like the second time this year the last super cool thing is that it's clear the replayability in this game is quite High granted there's not a huge variance in initial openings as your government policies starting quantity of labors and money are always the same but as you draw cards from your deck and interact with others a lot of different things can happen there's a lot of decision space again we've only played the game twice and I've only tried two factions and in those first games it's like you're only scratching the surface if you truly want to get good ideally you'd want to have a very good idea of everyone's deck then it can take some degree of comfort to take actions that are outside the more common ones like protesting selling companies buying stores storage and then getting political cubes concerns now these aren't cons because I haven't done a deep dive into this game if I would if we're making a review remember this video is not a review anyways the owner

of this game has reported to me that the rule book sucks and I read through it and uh yeah I can uh confirm a lot of his misgivings for one there's zero table of content so jumping around to topics is pretty frustrating like how how how did they forget to put this in oh wait it's at the end of the digital rule book you snuck that in at the end there's also a huge lack of labeling sections properly like it say go to IMF intervenes for more information okay where the heck is that oh it's under the section that says additional rules so why not give us a page number at least the ginese rule book is just unfortunately much below average when it comes to presenting info if you say carry out elections show the political tracker when you say refilling the bag show the cubes going in it's just going to be rough learning hemony from scratch if we compare it to another heavily asymmetric game we've reviewed root that has all the central rules first then all the factions then if you really need to know more there's a lot of roots of reference hemony just has a faction explanation smack in the middle all the faction explanation everything in the middle of the rule book which is so bizarre because when you're reading it you don't even know all the rules yet by its very nature hegemony is just going to be an inaccessible game with even more asymmetry in the roots and more components and a longer play time so why not just give us more stuff to help something other than just this rule book like a how to play to get people started that gets me to the player AIDS which everyone gets one of which is a huge square box filled with text you see how the player AIDS look real wordy well

that's because they're literally just sections of the rule book copy and pasted with some parts cut out how lazy is this this combined with a smaller Aid is weirdly redundant since they're a little bit redundant you think you'd mostly use a small one as a quick reference but it actually doesn't go over the beginning and ending of each round so you have the default to the bigger one that has everything except for more in-depth info on scoring and Taxation which are Super crucial basically you're playing this hunting and flipping game and if there's going to be so many pamphlets you'd expect something explaining the other factions right nope not at all here but at least we do have a nice IMF intervention sheet my last concern again not a con is that the time you have cards drawn really really matters in this game they have so many different power levels see these on to the right that are super strong and then replace them with these ones that are kind of unplayable there's about two copies of each C in the game with no way to draw more cards besides the end of your turn where you draw back up to seven and then there's no way to tutor or search for cards in your deck so what you draw is pretty much what you have to use let's get into some massive differences that we've seen happen say the working class is able to get their two Farms really early well they're going to be really ahead because their greatest fear is feeding their workers wow who would have thought that giving the working-class their own business is really strong they have no no issue of filling the Farms up and would you look at that the farm is also green so they can use it to easily go towards the prerequisite of making a union which gives them points every turn as for the capitalist getting offshore companies is crucial and if you top te at the right

turn that's massive Point generation As you move tons of money to Capital if you never draw it h that's pretty hard for getting points those who have much more experience in hegemony have compiled this awesome spreadsheet that really shows how uneven the spread of strength of cards is cards can be stronger at certain rounds there are some that are always weak etc etc with this much interaction in the game we talked about sure there's some self balancing that occurs but I couldn't help thinking if there could have been some way to draw more cards or search for more cards something a little bit more in depth with your cards ah whatever this isn't really a review let's just move on to the recommendations now it's time for recommendations no score out of 10 if you want that I'll have my personal score coming up after this the geminy is so fascinating that I had to make a video on it despite not having enough time to actually review it the theme itself is pretty much the X Factor in implementation it really is class Warfare where you need to keep updating what factions to be buddy buddy with while progressing in your own asymmetric way and there's no shortage of cards that feel correct in their effects however while hegemony is a long game it's going to be at least 1 hour per player so that's 4 hours for playing all four factions it obviously doesn't cover everything about Society I mean how could it right the class always seems to agree with what's going on there's no internal class strife and then yes one class getting better doesn't necessarily mean that your class is getting hurt but hey in this simulation of a board game within a long game night it does the job now for the actual gamep playay well it

having a symmetry front and center definitely has some consequences it doesn't go deep into the worker placement because it's not really one hemony doesn't have combos where you unleash your class as you tie together some slew of cards or you have some massive Uprising to destroy half the board nope it's more of a steady progression of turns and with that it's not really a normal Euro or area control or even a normal negotiation game let's go back to the state where their interdependence on everyone else for voting can be a bit jarring they have the least amount to move around on the board lease amounts of action range on their turn and don't even have their own voting cubes to manage in the secret bag imagine this you're victim to other players constantly spending your government money via cards and you have to pass a bill to get more income via taxation or shrinking your businesses if other players really want to bankrupt you they can its Reliance on others makes it possible to play like a snooze Fest and accidentally win it is possible if you're more traditionally eurom minded this is the faction to stay away from I kept thinking of this BGG review that the owner of a hemony copy showed me where the reviewer played 150 Plus hours of the game and ended with the take the stories from aony much more fun than actually playing the game mechanics and while yes that's very subjetive jective it goes to show that how much of the draw of this game is how the mechanics keep drawing parallels to IRL things like the capitalist exporting Goods because the residents want low prices allegedly like Japan and there's probably a bunch of degeneracy with the government state that is like modern-day Greece which is where the designers of

this game are from my owner friend tells me that he likes to roleplay when he plays this game he claims the best mindset for it is like a very structured tabletop role playing game where you don't have that much control of anything besides your hand of cards which is really swingy anyways just have the most fun ranting about unemployment crises the taxes are too high again or the government never pushes policies we can never get a policy change or the middle class is being too much in the middle about things etc etc etc to quote this BGG article one more time he says that one amazing thing about this game is that he believes it intentionally simulates the never-ending problems of society and yes hegemony always provides conflict between classes because they're constantly opposed to one another with some collaboration sprinkled throughout again and this isn't the most gamified thing with there being literal tax multiplayers to figure out how to pay our taxes every round you know how some people complain that Euros are just as fun as doing your taxes well aony three out of the four factions you are literally paying your taxes every round for fun all of these possibly alarming parts of the game are also why it's so beloved by its Target group those who wants a heavy strategy game about each of their friends taking on a part of society and Wheeling and dealing to get their way while the themee serves as a very relatable backdrop for constant banter despite its heavy barriers to accessibility and that it's completely IRL theme might be a little bit uneasy to play on game night like maybe you don't like the feeling of uh workers getting laid off it has its Target crowd

in love plenty of glowing reviews on BGG and you can put yourself in that class of shoes and just complain about your faction getting the short end of the stick don't forget a geminy is long and a big reason why I couldn't do a proper review on this part simulation part Euro part negotiation game is because I couldn't see the timel actually going below 4 hours even if we played it more the more you know about each faction and how to counterplay others and as you memorize each card in the game the longer I think turns will actually take and you're going to have to be thinking about what cards someone else has to play on you at five rounds with 20 actions round for four players that's a 100 total actions that need to happen not including the voting so yeah four plus hours for those gobble up the theme and can stomach the time Hain could be one of your favorite games of all time and well worth the $100 on Amazon right now who is being played by the capitalist player Ha see what I did there remember this game Al life forget that this is actually a very IRL game of life it's very thematic and educational even if the game is not fun to you it could be funny maybe it's fun but not funny maybe it's neither fun nor funny and now my personal score Can Shed more light on this my scoring my personal score for hermany after playing the working class and capitalist class each once so a total of two plays is going to be a 6 out of 10 it is above average I think this game's learning curve is pretty uncomfortable for me I don't like reading such a word dense panflet but uh

halfway through the first game everything just like clicked for me the game is in fact fun the theme is extremely novel and the way it's implemented with your friends sitting across from you is very entertaining I've had many chuckle even just looking at the cards in the game and the fact that me and Prav are forever to be faded as enemies as me as a capitalist and him as the working class is uh is so so memorable the Voting is really nuanced too and I can see myself with a lot of room to grow in skill level as I can sus out people's intentions and make better voting proposals because getting VP from winning votes is satisfying and the end of the game is a fun rush to get all the voting in your column all while trying to rush your normal source of victory points pemy just feels like a very crunchy game that repeatedly has me in the giggles as I sto to go like H yeah that that's how this faction feels like IRL I I guess but I do think this game's pacing is pretty off for me it feels like the peak is at the end of round three or the middle of round four where people are frantically pushing towards their end goal as class Warfare lines are truly drawn but then the game keeps going luckily for me I've played a lot of many other long board games even longer board games so I broke it down to a couple reasons why it feels off one is that there's actually not going on on the board during this game the majority of progressed things are opening or closing businesses and then moving these trackers left or right again half the factions don't have workers so the worker placement thing or even if you want to call it that the worker movement isn't that interesting to me so once I'm about 2 to 3 hours into this I'm like oh yeah the board is uh pretty much the

same this goes hand inand with how there's not really much progression or cool turns that stood out to me mechanically thematically things are cool and funny but there's really any big pivotal combo or build that makes me feel big brained or impressed with the pacing next I find that taking a turn to propose a bill just feels like a very uneasy action to me like I suppose this would feel less bad the better I get at the game but right now spending a precious action for doing something that might have an outcome of zero feels terrible while I also have to worry about feeding my people or paying taxes I got really tilted when the IMF came in and took my voting marker off because it resets this policy track and then it's like oh wow one of my turns just went down the drain this happened in each game and again if I get better at the game maybe it won't feel as bad the last pacing issue is that it feels like there's not much room for player expression you're pretty much going towards your own faction's goal in its own logical way and as such there's not really cool novel plays I've seen in my head just better ways to play off each other and optimize when I compare hem to my other favorite game that takes an hour per person so again probably about 4 plus hours Sid Meers civilization 2010 it feels like there's always so much going on the game for the time you invest into it there's armies being raised and destroyed cities granting extra actions wonders blessing the world all while Tech is shooting everyone's capabilities up it's an experience where there are climactic swings turns are slightly unpredictable and actions are massively expanding in decision space with more units and techs another game that came to mind is John company second

edition now this one was funny because I've played John company twice and heemy twice and after playing hegemony I was thinking huh I actually might like this more than John company but after weeks and weeks of reflection I actually think I'd rather play John company even though John company is a little bit too much into the political maneuvering side for me to be a favorite where some turns feel like straight slogs if you're behind I'm not really playing hedge or Joko for the core mechanics I'd rather play ti4 or sit for that rather I'm playing for these interactive stories with a competitive backbone with John company I can see all the crazy plays happening while India actually changes in front of you with all the player expression and option space feeling huge now this sounds like a lot of complaints but I actually wouldn't be subjecting hemony to all this scrutiny if it wasn't so long if it was 2 hours heck I'd play it again pretty easily and it' be a seven out of 10 remember the theme is that immersive it's that interesting for me that if I can get it to the table no problem yeah let's have a game night for it as such I actually think hemony Is straddling two opposing thoughts for me like the middle class in this game if you will on one end it could have gone harder with the simulation and realism ideas by being a video game and when I look at the components the tax table you need to look at and player a text that would have been a much more replayable experience for Me Maybe the businesses feel like real businesses make currency more nuanced add more for the state to do add a real map etc etc on the other end hemony could have kept a lot of these ideas it has but just streamline it possibly to 45 minutes a player

instead of 60 by shaving off a around or reducing some policies or reducing some components is this physical streamlined version even possible is that what the designers want I don't know but py has its crowd I'm glad to have covered it in this way and I'm excited for more asymmetric games that are kind of tackling such Nuance like this thanks for watching the video that was a geminy not the review it is a video so uh yeah I'm super glad I get that out for you guys again we have so many reviews coming in so for me to spend 8 to 12 more hours playing this to make a full review uh yeah I don't know if that's quite in the the schedule for us it's not part of our policy if you will anyways thank you to our patrons right here for making these videos like this possible and again thank you to mad cardboard right over there okay that is it heemy that's the video uh I'll be reading you guys in the comments I'm very interested to see what you guys have to say uh yeah probably someone that's played the game more than me can probably provide some more input too okay bye-bye see yeah

Progress saved