Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hot Streak OR Magical Athlete? - Which One is for You?

Transcript 13:40

That's right. Today, Ryan and I are going to answer the age-old question, or at least the question on people's mind, some people's mind, over the last month or two. Magical Athlete or Hot Streak? The interesting thing about both of these games, actually there's a lot of interesting things.

of similarities.

First and foremost, published by the same publisher. Secondly, both race games. Uh now, race games can take a lot of different definitions, and these two are very different types of race games. Uh we're pitting the two of them against each other today, not to sort of crown the victor necessarily, um but it may be crowning the victor for you, because in my experience, first of all, spoiler alert, I love both. I think both of us love both of these things. But, as I've played them with different groups, and I've played these with a lot of casual gamers who don't play a lot of board games, and I've noticed uh some commentary from some of them on which one they like more and why, and I think some of that's kind of interesting.

Yeah, watch this video, tell us which one you like more in the comments and why, and also why it's Hot Streak, because I love Hot Streak so much. This is my winner only simply because the board literally folds. I mean, that's so cool. It does have some table presence. Table presence is one of the things I think these games both do well. Hot Streak, uh we had at the MVM event last year at Gen Con, and first of all, it looks good on the table, but the also the crowd is going to be cheering, so people are going to come over to see what happens, but I have to say, even though the board for Magical Athlete looks like a board from a 1970s board game,

does.

and it is a roll and move sort of game, the table presence is helped tremendously by all of these different wooden meeples. These meeples are amazing, and I think the one that I think most gets most attention is

The giant baby.

big baby.

Uh big baby is super thick. Super fat as it as it goes

That's what they say. Thick. Not fat. I don't want to fat shame him. Thick I'll thick shame him. And all of these things have different powers, but when people see these and when you play it you're drafting like a team of these. So it's really fun to see their powers and then see their meeples. The table presence is pretty good on this one, too. It's got a cool art style and I like that like it almost feels like an old Saturday morning cartoon. It feels like Schoolhouse Rock-ish. Or like what was that Wacky Racers kind of vibe? Not necessarily with the animation, but just the idea that you have all these different characters that are all wacky and wild. It feels like some cartoonist in the 70s when they were high came up with this artwork. This feels like you know, maybe Sergeant Pepper's like the cartooning cartoony stuff from Yellow Submarine.

That pretty much nails the artwork style in this. Now again though, I do still like the characters from Hot Streak, but you only have four. You use all four at the same time, but they're cool. They're um they're mascots and they're people wearing mascot outfits. And the best part about these is if you look close enough on each one you can see where their eyes peek out. Yeah, but they've got the mascot eyes, but they've got the human or whatever you want to call them.

just hiding out. Uh and this again like going back to the presentation, I like the way these minis look. I mean I do like these cool wooden pieces, but the fact that there's so many more to Magical Athlete than just these four that that's pretty cool. They they put a ton of characters in a Magical Athlete.

nice bonus. I think I want to say I could have this wrong. I'll correct myself below if I am. There's like 36 or more characters in this game. Like Ryan said, there's only four in this and in in Hot Streak you don't play as the characters. And that's brings me to one of the big differences. In this game you have a lot more ownership of your characters. It's it's your team. You're It is a roll and move, but when you move the card does wild things. But, they're your characters that you're moving around the board. You can win the race. Hot Streak is like a betting game. So, these four characters are the ones that are racing, and I do want to say, these miniature These figures are probably the best figurines just about in any game.

They're awesome. Uh, what was that deck-building robot game also from WizKids?

Yeah, that also has a

That had some great the little robot minis. Um, but in this game, you're betting on these four characters, and this brings about two slightly different experiences at the table. And this is one of the main things I've heard from casual players is some of them have enjoyed Magical Athlete more because they felt they were the ones playing the game because you have a turn. Each player has a turn. On your turn, you're rolling the dice, and you're doing your thing. So, you feel a lot more ownership.

You want your character to win. Like, you want to literally win the race.

Now, with that said, you also want one of these four characters to win the race or place in different ways, or you can place other bets, but you're really just betting on these races, and then there's a deck of cards that have cards from each of these racers in it. And then between each sort of heat or each sort of race in a game of Hot Streak, each player is going to be able to add some cards to affect potentially how the race unfolds. So, you could start putting cards in the deck that make Gobbler here turn around or mess up so that you know a little bit more than everyone else, then Gobbler has less of a chance of winning, or maybe you put cards in that make it more likely that he's going to win. So, that's your involvement as the player. With that said, I do think Hot Streak ends up blowing up into a much more boisterous table when it's being played. When Hot Streak is being played, everyone's like, "No! Oh, come on, come on." That doesn't happen as much in Magical Athlete.

Well, because the Magical Athlete I I I think part of the difference, Magical Athlete is is very much a luck driven game. I mean, it is you're you're rolling your die, you're doing some powers. You do get some decisions to make when it comes to using those powers. Sometimes those powers can you you choose how they're carried out. Um whereas in Hot Streak, you're not making any decisions during the game. So, it's it's a a completely different feel and you're right. Like in Magical Athlete, you get your guy, you want your guy to win, you're cheering. But in Hot Streak, many of us might have bid on the queen or many of us might have bid on the hot dog guy. And when he's doing really well, we got three or four people the table cheering him on where the while the fifth guy goes, "I should have bet different." I think that Hot Streak gives you more control over whether you as a player win or lose. Because the fact that you can you can kind of not only influence the deck, but you're also looking at what cards were played. And if you're a gamer like me, which is something I don't I think I like about this game. If you're a gamer like me, you're looking at the results of the last match. You're trying to remember the cards that were played.

You're looking at what's in your hand and you're looking at what other people bet. You can look at all of that data, collect it all and go, "Okay, well, enough people are voting for this guy that I think they all put his cards, positive cards for him. So, I'm going to go along with that bet, but maybe I know that I've foiled their plans by putting in a card that makes him fall." That's a level of strategy that you don't have to apply to Hot Streak. You can just bid on your favorite one and still win the game.

Yeah, yeah. I was going to say cuz all of what Ryan just described could easily just go out the window. Because even if you put in the cards that you think are going to affect things, the order in which those cards come out can be wildly different and it can make things unfold differently than you might expect. Someone might move before another one falls down and the next race, that one falls down before the other one moves. So, the way it unfolds is quite differently. What this boils down to is kind of like a mutual programming game.

Yeah. There's a deck of cards and you're flipping those over after they're shuffled one at a time and you watch it unfold like a program. Whereas this one, like Ryan said, is something Both of them are luck based for sure. This one definitely feels more luck based in that A, it's roll and move. So, you're rolling a six-sided die. You're going to move one to six spaces. Now, like we said, some of the characters might say, "Oh, well, this character, if I roll this, I actually get to do this instead." Or every time a character lands on a space with another character, this happens. So, it's fun in that your character is benefiting from sort of its powers and you feel some ownership because you drafted those characters. And in many cases, too, it should be said, this isn't just unfolding on your turn. Some of the characters have powers that trigger when other players are playing, like the ones I just mentioned.

So, there's a lot more, I feel, involvement in this one.

And in your actual cuz you're actually taking a turn. Especially when you're taking your turn, but even when you're not taking your turn, I found the people at the table are like watching what happens on the turn because some of the powers can trigger off turn. Whereas this one, it's it's just a different pace game. There's a phase where you're

Betting changes everything, too.

you're drafting these bets effectively and then the race unfolds and you're basically you've you've placed your bet.

Mhm. And you're just watching and hoping the right things happen for you. Yeah, and that again, that leads into that collaborative aspect of this one where, you know, in Magical Athlete, you might have a a turn where everyone's getting really excited or something that you do really impacts the the leader and everyone at the table gives you a high five. Uh whereas Hot Streak, like when you get to the point where you're at the very, very end of the line and like everyone's cheering, like that that's such a cool collaborative feeling. Like you and I are the only ones that bet on the queen. So, like, we have our own little like secret pact here where we're just like, "Come on." Like, you and I are like cheering for a particular turn of cards, whereas the two other players are not. And you get into this little like, I don't I don't want to say tribal, but you get into this little like you know, these little connections of your of your group. It's a lot of fun. Like, you play this game with a stranger you've never met before and you find yourself high-fiving them at the end of the round. You're like, "That was just an exciting end."

I would say that the high-fives, as Ryan has put it, happen far, far more in Hot Streak than they do in Magical Athlete. You're going to be having a lot of more outbursts uh with this. This one um it has some outbursts and it's the highs and the lows. Something bad can happen and you go all the way back. If this is pretty more personal, right? It's more personal. This has got some classic stuff. I would say this. In this one, when things go bad, they're probably going bad for a few players at the table. So, you have some friends, like what you were saying about the the the sort of clicks that happen at the table. This one, when something bad happens, it's usually to one person. So, I will say this, if you're a player who doesn't like big setbacks, this has some of those.

However, I think this game is so light and so fun that they're the kind of setbacks that you even if it's happening to you, you're like, "Oh my gosh, this is crazy." Like, I had a turn in Magical Ath- not a turn. I had multiple turns in a row where on the flip side of this board, there's like special spaces that do things. And I had a number of turns in a row where I'd roll the die, I'd move forward, I'd hit a space that made me four backwards. Same turn back It just It kept happening. It kept happening. Even on someone else's turn, they moved me forward and it moved me to that space and it moved me four backward. And it was It's funny when it happens.

uh Yeah. I I I wanted to say it was frustrating. It wasn't frustrating. It was kind of hilariously frustrating. Uh so, that's the kind of thing that can happen with Magical Athlete. And when it happens over here, it's happening to not just you, generally speaking.

Yeah, I mean, on paper, Hot Streak is definitely the game I should enjoy more. Uh, when you look at Magical Athlete, again, just by the rules, okay, it's a roll and write. We're rolling and it's completely

Not a roll and write.

Or not Sorry, roll and move. It's almost completely luck based and I shouldn't like this game at all. But, because like you said, because it's so zany and and silly and quick, Yeah.

you know, it's it's it does not overstate it's welcome. You're rolling these dice, you're doing these things, but everyone is subject to that same luck. And it's not like some games where you're just like, wow, you're just rolling six after six after six and we just all watch you win. Like, there's crazy zany things that are happening all over the table and it almost reminds me in that case of like Dodos Riding Dinos, you remember without the dexterity element, but you'll get to certain points where like just crazy things are happening at the table that bring you that that that take the game to another level that it wouldn't be if it was just like a simple roll and move. Yeah, so when everything is said and done, both of these games are in the category of what I would call dumb fun. These are games that are just stupid, silly fun and I mean that in the nicest way possible.

way way possible because they're both fun. Yeah, it's [clears throat] they're games that you should have and to answer your question of like which one should I have? Well, hopefully we've shared enough about both to give you some guidance. Ryan picks Hot Streak.

I like bidding games. I like that feeling of like, I'm going all in on Gobbler and like, oh, I This is last year's Ready Set Bet, for sure.

For sure. A little sillier and a little more fun, maybe.

Well, I like this better. I like this better than Ready Set Bet.

I still love Ready Set Bet. I don't like the I don't like the chaos of the real-time betting. I like betting first. It almost makes this game feel almost more strategic than Ready Set Bet.

definitely more strategic than Magical Athlete.

And it is definitely more strategic than Magical Magical Athlete, but both are chaotic fun. If you have any questions about them at all, and like Ryan said earlier, if you've played both and you have opinions, share them in the comments below. We'll get down there and talk to you till our hearts content about it. Until next time, make sure everyone has fun at the table, and we'll see you then.

Progress saved