Magic has changed A LOT since 1994 | The Command Zone 642 | MTG EDH Magic Gathering
Transcript
this episode is sponsored by one password when you're trying to grow your business you need security that can keep up and one password's award-winning password manager is trusted by millions of users and over 100,000 businesses they help create strong unique passwords for all your different accounts so you don't have to rely on memorization or Post-it notes and one password makes private and user-friendly password management easy for everyone with seamless switching between devices and features like autofill for quick signin to get a free twoe trial for your growing business go to onep password.com commanda
greetings humans you have entered the commanda your destination for all aspects of Elder Dragon Highlander enjoy your stay how's it everybody Welcome to a brand new episode of the command Zone podcast I here with some very old friends of mine well let's let you introduce yourself uh this is Greg I'm Greg I've known Josh since maybe fourth grade and now I'm a physician in Oregon and this is Ty hey I'm ty urin uh I known Josh since elementary school and I'm a marketing producer yeah Universal that's right you're an exec I'm not here in official capacity the reason they are here though good segue is because they are very old school magic players in fact Greg taught me how to play Magic back in 1993 and they haven't really played in like over 20 years or so uh so we're going to talk about what magic was like back in the day they're the OG's uh but before we get into it of course we've got to talk about our sponsors if you want to get your hands on any OG magic cards go to cardkingdom.com commmand it's the best place to go to get your magic product singles anything at all Card Kingdom is awesome because they have a huge inventory and that means when you add all of your cards for that new deck into a cart and you hit checkout it all arrives on your doorstep in one convenient package you're not waiting for a bunch of individual envelopes from different places to arrive so you get all that stuff all at once you sleeve it up and you're ready to go again card cam.com commands and then once you get those cards you want to protect them the game accessories brand that we trust our own collections
to here at the command zone is ultrapro if you go to ultrapro.com commmand you can find all kinds of cool products like sleeves deck boxes dice playmats wall Scrolls anything you need to make your game room or your Battlefield look awesome and also to protect all of your game pieces I personally like the Apex sleeves if you haven't tried these out they have the best Shuffle feel in the business they protect your cards they're very very durable and also they have cool printed backgrounds so if you want duskmourn or bloomo or something on the back of your sleeves ultrapro got them all right ultrapro.com commmand and of course the final way to support all of our content is directly if you go to patreon.com commmand Zone you can have access to all kinds of cool content uh earlier than everybody else extra turns and Game Nights our patrons get to see it ad free and a day early and also we release exclusive content like turn talk which is a cool exclusive series we do after every episode of turns so right now I think there's like 20 episodes on a backlog so if you sign up for our patreon you'll get access to all that stuff right away a whole bunch of of content and you'll also be supporting our Channel and all the content that you enjoy we really appreciate everybody that joins our community so again patreon.com command Zone okay I'm not used to doing that by myself usually there's other hosts here doing some of it uh guys thanks for coming first of all happy to be here very old friends I was thinking about it and both of you sort of sit at like the epicenter of for me film making and Magic uh cuz we played back in high school back in the very early days um and as we've sort of we haven't hung out a lot in the last decade or so but as we
sort of uh I don't know reestablish old uh connections talking about magic I was like I think this is something that our audience might en enjoy hearing about it just like what magic was like back in the day and I also think it's kind of fascinating like how much of that sort of has stuck with you over all the time obviously I've been immersing in it for the last 10 years but you guys still remember a lot of specifics about those days which I thought was kind of fascinating even though you know a relatively short amount of time MH so I wanted to start off with when's the last time you you really played magic uh Ty do you want to sure yeah um well I picked up uh I played Arena maybe like two years ago and uh for like one cycle yeah and as soon as the new cards came out I was like uh yeah I can't uh do you remember any of the cards that you were playing with in Arena um I had a I remember had a obos deck the black and reds spider odd CMC matters or odd casting cost or whatever yeah yeah that's right that's right and then if you make it work she does double damage yeah that was the one and you played for about how long then uh maybe like a month or two and I I I really enjoyed it and I read a bunch of stuff and then I just I just couldn't keep up it moves fast these days uh before that so you played for a month or so before that when the last time you'd really played man it must have been in college probably just like uh Greg playing with you or uh late ' 90s yeah definitely that might be when I played last like I remember like the tournament Josh's Stormbreaker deck or something that might have been like it I mean I got on Arena a little bit but I had the box I
got it back from my family or my brother who has it and had a friend um a colleague at work whose kid played so I pulled out the box and looked at my old rubber banded decks and said you go for it and you know got it back all separated and so I I looked at the cards for a little bit buted um that would have been like 2011 or 12 so still a long time ago before we had even started the command Zone at that point yeah so it's been a long time and Ty you played a little bit so that's interesting well let me ask you what do you remember about just the game in general from the old days like in the high school the the ' 90s days when we started when I first started I didn't know you know we opened the packs didn't have anyone to teach us we were trying to figure out what was what and how the turns worked I remember getting like a a great worm or something I for what the cwm CW a CW worm a66 I'm going to make a monster animal deck and just trying to figure it out and working through I think bring I think we played pretty quickly early on like we were discovering it together just how the flow worked without having seen there was no media for us to learn from so yeah I didn't learn with you you taught me so you had already learned I don't know who with your brother maybe must been yeah must have been my brother he said craw worm was a 66 ti do you know if that's correct uh is incorrect 64 I believe yeah good good memory yeah mark it down mark it down I saw you like twitch a little when you said 66 okay wait I got a force of nature yeah do you remember what that what size that was yellow and greenish glowing
coming out of the swamp it was power and toughness equal to your uh forests no that's a different card no 88 that it didn't okay it was 88 I thought it was four Le was the power and toughness equal to your see my braining what do you remember from the early days Ty um well I started in a different play group from you guys and so geographically we were 10 minutes away or so so we just again we picked it up from scratch um we got starter decks you know we had the little white instruction booklet that we just read and and started to put it together and I I remember I don't know just really being enamored with the game design and how cool it was to get the Mana from Land I thought that was just I I just thought the like the writing up at the lore of it was really interesting drew me in so both of you remember starting an with people that all of you were learning it's not like cuz I had you to teach me a little bit Greg so that's really interesting cuz back then you'd get those little rule booklets with the starter decks but I remember those rules were not very comprehensive and a lot of the rules weren't even totally spelled out and I think even one of the rule books said something along the lines like hey if you come to a point where you don't know what the rule is whatever you decide is okay as long as you're consistent right like it sort of literally said like hey make up your Ru just whatever you decide it is just make sure you continue to do that like everybody in your play grp follows the same rules kind of yeah do you remember how many yeah I guess we didn't say you eventually played magic with us TY but at the very start yeah there was at our high school there was at least two
separate play groups that we ended up knowing about there was actually there was a third one too yeah how many people did you start with Ty was it just you and one other uh we had a about three or four I want to say and we would play Two on Two do you remember where you got the cards um um no I don't do you remember GRE no no cuz they were kind of hard to get back there I remember later on going to a card shop like you know miles away like Oregon City or whatever miles away from we grew up yeah Oregon City I remember we would get cards or we all come from cambi Oregon and Oregan city was like a 15-minute driveway which when you're 13 or 14 is far you need to have you can't ride your bike there someone that could drive you there geography was a big barrier for my magic career I think cuz there just was no card shop that I could bike to yeah like you guys had yeah I think you could buy the packs so it might have even been at the grocery store was it Poss because eventually we got a card shop in cambi that did carry that was later yeah but at first it didn't right right right yeah did you have something to do with that did you bring in I might have cuz I did know both the card shop owners cuz I was into sports cards before that yeah so um I might have influenced them to finally get Magik cards by just saying hey do you guys have magic cards every day yeah I might have done it yeah it's possible that I had some you know I don't know for sure um so early days you're learning the game there's no internet so there's no place to really go to find out like how it all works so it's kind of amazing that you learn to play cuz there was a lot of arguments we had around too I remember Josh and I always like no but this means this and Josh would kind with no this is this I'm
like it doesn't say it that way that's how you're interpreting it it is supposed to be this and like it was never clear and we would we didn't come to blows but we would fight about rules yeah and it's interesting because these days you could always just pull out your phone Google it and you know I I've talked about this where it's like you know how you'll be like who's that actor in that one show and like now you just go IMDb find it out what it is but back in the early mid 90s you would just sometimes have to end the conversation with we don't know we'll never there's no way for us to find this out right now so with magic rules that seems really daunting do you guys remember any specific rules or things that like you either got wrong or didn't understand or argue about or found out like how it worked and we're like oh I'm not sure if this is specific but the Cascade of inst and interrupts and how how those unfolded and and you know like tapping a Tim and then like nope before you do that I'm going to do this interrupt and which you could do first in what order like those were the yeah those were the main I believe back then it was called something else or maybe they didn't even have a term for it but now we call it the stack and the way that it works is that uh the last in is the first out of anything that's instant speed they got rid of interrupts because even back in the dayup yeah interrupts don't exist because even back in the day interrupts didn't intrinsically work that different than instance so now how it works and I believe it did work this way back then but they didn't have it codified in the same way which is like you do something like Tim tap it that damage doesn't
happen just the ability Goes On The Stack so it's going to happen it's pending but if anything goes on the stack as pending everybody else has a chance do you want to do anything before that happens as long as it's an instant speed thing you can't like cast a sorcery at that time so you go well would like to lightning bolt the Tim okay cool the lightning bolt goes on top of the stack above Tim's ability does anybody want to respond to the lightning bolt somebody goes yeah I'd like to you know something else and then you get to a point where you say does anybody want to do anything else and some you go no and then it goes cool now let's resolve it from top to bottom so like the lightning bolt will hit the Tim but Tim's ability is already out there it's already been activated so that that one damage will still hit but Tim will be dead when the damage hits so yeah I do remember having a lot of because if people don't know back in the day there was another card type called interrupt and cards like fork and a few others had that on their typel line instead of instance and so we would often argue no the interrupt happens before the instance happen because why does interrupt exist if it's not faster than instant it broke the stacking of events that the only thing that could come up was another interrupt I think or something so you'd be like I didn't an interrupt and that has to happen now before this other stuff happened so if somebody cast a counter spell on something you could still cast a lightning bolt above the counter spell doesn't make sense with instance interrupts I remember arguing about that a lot I remember even the sort of discovery of instant speed like when we first started we were just casting instance like sorceries you know it would be like all right it's my turn lightning bolt you for three you know and when you guys I think were the play group that were like no no no before my turn we're going to do this and that and
we were all like wait before your turn the end of your turn yeah yeah we learned the end of your turn and the fact that like you always have a chance right like they don't get to just go my turn's over go you go no hold on I want to ask before I start my turn yeah I think we had read inquest or some books or something or some magazines or something by then and learned some of that stuff one thing I remember I don't know if you remember this Greg was we played giant growth as an enchantment oh yeah we would just cast giant growth onto it and be like it's got plus three plus three forever now mhm the best car ever amazing at instant speed one green I remember us arguing also about remember artifacts used to say mono artifacts sometimes and whether they were still active if they were tapped or not so like if a howling mine became tapped would you still draw the cards was it deactivated yeah oh yeah yeah yeah how do you think that works do you think that uh so if you tap like a howling mine you remember what howling mine does right draw draw extra card yeah I think it would still I think it would still work I'm going to go with that why would it be able to be tapped what would it do being tapped nothing yeah right you don't have to tap it for the ability to activate the H can't tap itself so something else would have to tap it like a twiddle or something I'm just using cards they know the Nam oh that's a good one yeah okay so let's say I twiddle it comes to my turn I draw the extra card for howling mine it's my howling mine and then I twiddle it so it's tapped and it passes turn to you would you draw an extra card or not do you think I think yes think maybe two out of five confidence I'd say no so you're just doing that based on his reaction to my
answer I no I if it's two out of five confidence doesn't that mean yes cuz three out of five is yes there wait hold on let's break this down 1 2 3 no and then there's 1 2 3 4 5 yes I'm still in the no just like a kind of a shrug okay yeah uh so if that if it's tapped and it has static ability you won't draw yeah that's correct so I was wrong yeah you Ty was wrong and gr was right so it's one one you can do that with like winter orbs and stuff and so you un tap and they don't or things like that there's tricks you can pull but I remember back in the day that was not clear and it was hard to find that information I remember arguing about that quite a lot let me ask you a question um about something specific do you remember the the mechanic banding I think think I do yeah I mean I remember the mechanic could I explain it yeah do you remember how this is a thing that they don't print banding on cards very often anymore every once a while it's kind of like a half joke they'll do like one and most players even players have played for a long time it's kind of a joke in the community that most people don't know how banding even works do you guys know how do you remember or can you explain how banding works I think I do you want to you want to try or do you want me to try let me start and three out of five confidence on this four May four have we heard hacking with banding you need to have all of the cards but one need to have banding I believe yeah so you can form a band on attack with all but one of the characters with any number of creatures but only one of them can be without banding right okay on defense you need one with banding to create a band so a band on defense only needs one
banding total and can be any number of creatures right if you have banding that's not all that's not the only way it works y yeah you have control over where the damage is correct to you like on defense so if you come at me with a singar Vampire thank you fly and let's just say uh you're banding which I think at that point you would also need to have all do you need to have all flying creatures in a band well you have to be find the block maybe you should maybe you should rise the who was attacking go a which is BR yeah and you have a benalish hero okay so a 64 is attacking you and you have a band of creatures blocking it that's just say aish hero good memory one of the abandon creatures aish hero and let's say three other tutus yeah right so what happens the 64 you block with your band it's four 22s one of them is a balish hero you can assign all six to one so you only lose the one or you can divy it up and so if it's less than six if it's three and you have two three two tws you can go okay they each take one they all live your guy dies so you have the ability to control where the damage is assigned you're correct in how it works and uh and then on attacks if you're attacking now how did the damage work the same way if you're banned and you're attacking a non-banned or yeah exactly well I guess if they would have to block with multiple creatures but then I think you would get to assign the damage you still get assign the damage you get back but you as play per usual is assigning your damage they can block with a single creature they can block a whole band with one creature right but
then you but you get to assign that damage you get to assign their damage the defender usually gets all right pretty good I would say most players couldn't get as far as you guys got uh which is an advantage to having played back then do you guys remember regeneration oh yes how does regeneration work well you your creature can die and then you pay a cost and it will come back to life with one key feature that's different it comes back tapped it tap back yeah now did the creature actually die it never makes it to the graveyard right I don't think ever so you can't have a can't have it hit the graveyard and then be like oh no no I'm going to regenerate it you have to immediately right yeah so back in the day and I believe it did work this way um it was like it died and then a like a trigger would go on the stack like a question saying do you want to pay a green or let's say Drudge Skeletons which is one of Greg's favorite cards um do you remember what that card does uh 01 one one dang it Ty that was the willow wisps oh oh yeah sorry that was my favorite 01 one black to regenerate one black one it seem so powerful yeah I like how do you ever get through that Greg would play like four of them in all the decks you're like H I can never attack totally you need to trample or something so yeah I believe it would like take the damage and then ask you basically do you want to play the black or not and if you did it would just become tapped not die uh now it's Works slightly differently they codified it a little differently which is it's kind of like a shield almost that you put on it you have to pay the cost before the
damage happens oh interesting yeah and then it puts a regeneration kind of shield on I believe that's how the rules got wed now cuz they've had to codify a lot of stuff back in the day it was kind of like you figure it out but then eventually they like well we got to know how this works for tournaments and things like that so when we started playing yeah Greg when we started I believe you were playing it was like unlimited Arabian Knights Antiquities were like most of the cards in your card pool and then eventually the dark and legends uh that was kind of the main dark was when I had started to put some maybe more money into it because I was like oh I'm sticking with this and the new stuff's coming out so yeah the dark was when you really dove in yeah okay so back around that time period which is when I just was framing it for them so they know about the time period what do you think was the strongest color so I don't know if I can answer this in a this take a little longer but and afterward give us your confidence level yeah it was just throwing out creatures throw against each other kind of fun and at some point we started really connecting the dots of how these cards played together so my first I had a green deck and I think I got a lord of the pit and maybe a sing gear something kind of cool and I'm like I'm playing Black all the way and one of my early memories riew of just loving black yeah yeah yeah and then at some point so it was just like oh cool cards cool cards throw them together and then at some point I think it was one of our friends at our school at our Gatherings that played a deck and I don't think it was you but it was the meekstone I believe
Andy right and the meekstone was brilliant because he made this deck of small creatures Tut two un under with things like giant growth for temporary bumps and we' bring out our big beasts and things and he then the meekstone would come out and we realize he built this whole deck which sounds obvious now right but the time this was the realiz you see it happen it was like wait a second his whole deck doesn't get affected by this thing and he's pumping them up and we're screwed we can't we can't untap anything and we're like oh this is how it works like that's why this card looked dumb because why would you play a meekstone you can't play your big characters and so that's where we started I think the meek Stone was where everything came together that this is how magic was supposed to work I'm getting Goosebumps because the meekstone is exactly my memory of the click in your head of like oh themes we all had that yeah Synergy that was the first time we probably we didn't know the word Synergy but probably the first time I realized Synergy yeah I remember the miar deck he had Royal assassins Black Knights hypnotic dark rituals Meek stones and he had assassins yeah for one thing he had traded for four of everything too and that was I think one of our first decks in our whole play group where he knew what he wanted to do and got four of's stuff H it's hard to explain but back in the day there was a restricted list which meant that you could only have one of certain cards so you had one demonic tutor one soul ring the things you were allowed to only have one of but everything else he had if he had it he had four of it and that was another
thing where he was like oh you need to be really efficient with it and I remember the mstone would dominant in our play group for you know a couple of weeks yeah I I totally remember that and that was the very first like aha moment I think and and that's funny you mention it and you know me for playing Magic so I'm glad you mentioned that but does that mean you think black was the most powerful color no I remember that happening and changing that like my awesome lord of the pit thing is like oh no that this is this is easy to handle yeah no I I would say early magic for me would be blue and mostly because it was surprises and the the surprise deck I was going to say that like a few deck but uh you know taking your creature messing with you countering your spell like just always kind of messing with your mind so they didn't have the blue was the most powerful yeah because it was unpredictable and could go against anything or it felt that way with what do you think Ty what do you think was the most powerful color I think at the beginning I liked blue uh but it felt like red was the thing we had to overcome because we were so simplistic that just Fireballs yeah it just was like it was better than what you were doing um but I definitely remember your guys play group teaching us the Synergy aspect I remember the tournament I don't know if we're going to get to that yeah we will for sure but by then you were playing synergistic desk so it wasn't the ter got you there barely barely we had just stumbled on like hey these two cards go together let's do that and getting four and then you know but we we still had people in our group with with like giant decks they just put everything in there and our friend Matt he always come with
like an 85 card deck yeah I remember I our head knowing like well you're lowering the chances of getting your best cards yeah yeah but that was still it took us a while to learn that too yeah you guys really really uh you know gave us the discipline well by the time you stopped playing which was only a few years later you guys you know probably stopped by probably like ' 96 97 98 somewhere there um 96 what did you think was the uh most powerful color I think I would having been educated by you in all your decks I would probably go with blue cuz that's what was kicking our butt at the time I think maybe that's also what informs me is the things that would mess me up the most was blue MH it's not what I played with the most but it's what I think most magic players right now uh in Commander would say that you know if you had to rank the colors blue is probably the most powerful still now yeah what would you say was probably the weakest color back then white yeah really was yeah it was hard to get there that's interesting because I think until very recently white would have been the answer as well for that still to this day although I think green was the worst back when we played cuz it just seemed like creatures were not very good but getting Mana it always seemed like green found its way into your deck because it was always like oh I have this cool idea it's a four drop or whatever and oh well here comes the Lan elves and you know of paradise exactly that's Paradise it allowed you play multiple colors a little bit easier MH yeah so maybe not much has changed as far as like the the top is probably the same and the bottom is probably I think you can make an
argument that red is is the weaker color now but oh yeah it's it's not green Green's very powerful it's probably second most powerful green and black are pretty close what are some of the favorite cards you remember playing Ty what are cards that come to mind of like the your the favorite ones that you used to like to play Tim definitely Tim um unsummon I don't know why that comes to mind it's just a real like just get them enchant creature just comes off like love it oh man I remember an early deck Greg had when you were playing your black deck and you had Unholy strength stuff and it just felt like how I can't win like that Black Knight has first strike and it's huge now we didn't know and until we learned about removal yeah yeah cards went through phases like where they when we learned what they did they became game changers then we found the counter to it so it always shifted you know that was the beauty of who found the counter to it uh control magic I hated I hated because I'd finally get out my card and control magic which is simple but taking arming the other person and stripping it from you um I loved my fallen angel I think I had one got it randomly just like the art like the idea that I could have a lot of minions and sacrifice to her for one big F yeah I remember you would do that thing where you would have a bunch of stuff out willowwisp and other things and then Fallen Angel would get through sack them all and I just you just hit us for 12 or something yeah it was more the Decks that I think of that I remember building certain themed Decks that for better worse I enjoyed or clung to
because I like theme or they performed wellish mhm more so than individual cards yeah I guess that's how I I think of it but it's interesting you mentioned control magic though that is a effect they don't do that as often anymore and I think control magic is still a very strong version of it as far as cost CU you're right I think they didn't really realize even in design how powerful it is cuz it's destroying their thing and giving you a thing and yeah so it's still actually you know a pretty powerful card in like a limited environment it doesn't get played in Commander So Much Anymore the simple count spell I just that what a beautiful card yeah I liked anything that kicked out a bunch of creatures like the hive or something it's like give me 10 one ones you know aot yeah then I got options spawn that green uh not throlls yeah thrs uh the spory thing the breeding pit right oh the Spore thing uh sapplings sapplings something that would like yeah just generate 01 tokens that was like a a release that happened right at the I have a lot of those for some reason and I don't really like them but yeah oh the Fallen Empires ones the ones that like got SP counters you had to keep track of a lot of counters counters do you guys remember what we used to use as counters on the cards we used a dice a 20 side dice no we didn't we didn't have 20-sided dice so like yeah I don't think T side dice were easy to come by at that point Doritos pennies we use pennies nickels and dimes a lot and then we also use like those little glass bead things the P from the game uh I had a game called bizaar and they had little glass
was wrong yeah we had this little tupperware container that we would like that had pennies nickel dimes and the glass beads and that's what we would use for the various counters yeah we didn't yeah we could have just used Dice from like yatsi or something but we didn't really do that yeah that was pretty Advanced it wasn't like you could walk into any game store and buy dice like it is was today it wasn't there wasn't a lot of just game stores in general okay well let's talk about the decks because the meekstone deck I remember being for us the first Big Deck in our group do you remember a deck in your group Ty cuz to this point what we've been talking about you hadn't really mixed with our group quite yet Ty yeah what was going on in your group do you guys do you remember any of the Decks that were sort of big with your with your play group I mean we were like Greg said we were just doing a lot of creature battles you know it was like Elemental decks versus the Green deck versus the white black deck do you remember any specific cards in there that were like you know problems I mean it was just it was just like Sarah Angel singer vampire you know the big Flyers a Elemental exactly air and water Elemental fire Elemental walls were like everybody had walls we had wall of yeah wall ofes and yeah we just crunched in the middle and then we did start messing around with you know mess with the game cards like um Armageddon or uh there's an egg Dingus egg Dingus egg or just you know ank maybe but we didn't know how to minimize the effect on your own deck it just sort of people would throw them out there and nuke the game like stasis all right you know what happens I don't know yeah right um but later became like theme of something your deck I think we eventually I think
the the combo we stumbled upon which is so dumb is karma magical hack yep which was our first like theme deck and it just tore through everybody walk me through that karma karma is a card that is two normal and two white and it's an enchantment and it does damage per turn to the number of swamps that you have to each hack this to each player that has swamps and then you magical hack changes any Plains mountains any any land type into any other one you whatever their deck was you just choose that color and game would basically end at that point cuz they'd be taking eight you know per turn yeah is that a thing that exists that changeed card Tex now like they don't do it very often but there's been a few different variants where you can do stuff like that for sure but magical hex I'd say still the emblem for that kind of strategy and you can still kind of do it there's slight of mind which changes colors yeah we we messed around with that and someone yeah that's what we did in the wake a bit it was like oh we can change the words let's do that yeah circle of Productions with slide of Minds was another thing that people would do ogers probably still do a little bit but it tends to just be like okay well I can't die but what else with the circle protection thing right yeah yeah I remember your karma magical ha deck which I was like oh that's cool yeah it was it it was pretty effective because a lot of people played Black so a lot of times we didn't even need the magical act we' just be like bam you go Karma you're like oh you have the Silver Bullet against my deck you just happened to well I do have magical hacks yeah there were those cards in each color that was like targeted their opposites that always drove me little bonkers death grip and life force life force and
yeah exactly those two and just and it felt like if you won with that it's like yeah you got lucky you played you play Black and you made the deck to beat mine rather than it's universally good I remember for a time we started like not we wouldn't tell you what we were playing before the game because of cards like that and that kind of got rid of those cards in our play group where it was like I'm not going to allow you to choose your deck based on knowing what my deck is just cuz you have one of those in it and so we started being like okay we're going to reveal our decks and then that caused us to take out the sort of um Silver Bullet cards stopped using those yeah kind of like we decided internally to not use those well I think it was just bad you weren't going to your you know chance of them actually doing anything in a game was much lower it was super fun though when You' bust out like a there was that one red I forget the name red Elemental blast yeah yeah and you just like have it you know and just be like ha I'd say that's still playable today because blue is so prevalent there's enough of it that you're likely to run into it in games and that card is so efficient and does a thing that red can't really do it another way you can counter blue things basically red Elemental blast specifically still definitely sees play yeah do we just throw it in speculatively like ah we're going to see a blue deck you know whatever yeah what other decks do you guys remember playing with or against that were like what were cool decks that you built um one of my first theme deck was I think initially it was black and red and I stayed with that for a long time and it was I'm not going to play with creatures I'm going to go with power and defend myself as best I can so was like will of the Wisps Drudge Skeletons like resurrectors or
some sort of like defense regat no yeah no attackers and then it was all the you know lightning Fireball disintegrate all the burn spells yeah the burn spells I'm trying to remember what else I did with the black well so then I had to work really hard to find a fork like that was one I got like my uncle to drive me I mean I don't know where I got it from maybe I hitch D with you but found like a fork to buy for like $25 or something like no it wasn't that much I don't think any cards were that much then the fork was the fork was restricted it was and it was like I don't know if anyone else had one I think I was the only one that had it for for sure you were the first one cuz I remember us being like whoa yeah and forking a you know 15 Point Fireball or even 10 it was like game over I died to a lot of fireballs for 10 forked from you I remember that deck you had survive survive survive and then bam as long as you didn't counter spell me I felt like that was the next deck in The Meta after the meekstone deck because it could beat the mstone deck because it was small enough you could block all his stuff with your regenerators and then you would just draw the game out until you had enough Mana to kill him mhm and I I remember that deck being like really tough to beat for a while so that in my memory in my Narrative of our progression it meekstone was the deck and then your burn deck was the response to it and the next boss deck in the in our play group was like okay now we got to figure out how to overcome this very light cre didn't have a lot of creatures and up until then we all even the mstone deck were creature-based decks and you built the first oh this is not about the creatures in it he's got a few but those are really just to stop the other
creatures but what he's really doing is all spell-based crap right and I think that's when you started going more blue and messing with the counter I think that's where that came up it's interesting because we we didn't have the internet so our meta was just naturally evolving and I think an arms race yeah in some ways cuz you were driving you know trying to get to the it's funny that part of this whole equation was not just do I have the first of all we're like 14 years old or whatever so just just having money to buy cards with but it was also the hurdle of like I have to get to where the card is cuz it's not like hey I just get it on and order it on the Internet or something you literally had to like get an uncle or an older brother of somebody to like drive you to Two Towns over where they might have it or you called and they said they had it I didn't buy many cards though either I also that that was like maybe one of just a handful that I actually paid money for it felt so important to me to have one fork yeah in case I get it oh I remember working I remember D what about you T do you remember any of your early decks um yeah I mean I think I remember going against the discard deck that you had I was going to say I I that was one of my last decks yeah yeah and that was kind of a that was an eye opener um because we hadn't really attacked like the phases of the game at all or the other resources in the game right exactly um I I don't know my one big deck that I only ever really could build was the Tim deck I guess and I went and I bought a clone or two clones and you know it was but was a lot of your cards uh yeah you built it with a bunch of my cards yeah cuz I just I sort of stopped
buying cards once our play groups merged cuz then I was like oh you have all these good cards and I just will make decks out of these and you know I I just didn't have like the Firepower to be putting together like a discard deck I don't think I had a rack you know um so yeah and then of course the draw Deck The Wave deck yeah the um we'll talk about the wave deck which is an interesting from a lot of levels but uh yeah the Tim deck people should know there so Tai built the first Tim deck in our playr I'm known for the Tim deck now in the community uh for the commander version of a Tim deck but you were really the first person that put a whole like I'm going to say standard it's not it wasn't really standard then there wasn't really formats in the way there are now but the 60 card version of it you had like pirate ships anduin I think you had Twi yeah yeah I definitely had a untap tap uh there was a green enchantment that let you uh in still energy yeah instill energies yeah it was slow but it was so fun when it got going and once you got going you were really playing with timing and there was so many little tricks you could pull that you would be like I can't play this it'll just he'll just kill it for free but if he doesn't then he's hitting me and I don't even know how to get out of this just the threat of it kept you from playing anything yeah but the threat of it was also like you become you put one out and all of a sudden everyone looks everyone comes it's like oh no you don't when we're playing in a group yeah that's when you know your deck is good when everyone's like oh we got to kill that deck yeah once you get like four out nobody can even lay a creature without your permission you're just sitting there going all it yeah hand of God you may I remember
you had a goblin deck too GRE oh yeah was pretty good Goblin deck was um just kind of fun I don't know if it was very good I got the the breeding or the Warren Goblin Warren or the breeding pit or something cple Goblin Kings yeah Goblin Kings helped and then there was also I think the the grenade or the bomb what was it Goblin grenade Goblin grenade yeah just sacrifice so being able to breed pump them up and suddenly if it got to like a critical mass where they were like all five fives coming out and every turn I'm cranking out two sacrifice two get three that it build but it took that one was one that if you let it go would become dangerous early on was not too big of a deal to deal with that wasn't a great one I remember your Vice deck which at some point came was really cool that's what inspired my rack or discard deck it played differently but building it around the vice opposite was one of my favorite decks but your Vice deck had how did you do that you would cram Cards into people's hands and punish them for it basically was that the stormseeker deck that this was the wave deck eventually but early on that so black Vice early on was a very strong card that just like tended to do a lot of damage so I would just put it into decks like when we were early playing just put black VI in there and early on it wasn't on the restricted list eventually it was oh it's restricted yeah eventually it was but they learned yeah that you could only have one but you know in our early days either we didn't know it was restricted yet or what hadn't been put on the list yet but we did know other cards that were restricted so I think it just hadn't been put on the list yet but anyway yeah it was a card that just says
if you during uh I think your upkeep if you have four more more than four cards you take a damage for each one over four or whatever so if they have seven cards it does three so if you get that thing out on turn one it's going to deal a lot before they can do much especially in our play groups which we're slow and not very efficient like people were often not doing anything until at least the second or third turn we learned later like hey do stuff early use your Mana efficiently but it took us a while so yeah the vice was very powerful shut out the Mana you would do power surge to lock our Mana out or pull or I don't remember what it Mana short yeah just shut us down so you couldn't act and then we just all take seven damage un summons I love un summons for that reason because that's an extra damage and it gets the creature off the board and then they got to recast it don't do anything else I remember you used to argue no but it's fun to play against cuz you get all your cards and you're just sitting there with all your cards taking 10 damage fun have lots of cards real that's why they know what how mind does cuz I so I think to me I slowly started being like Hing mind's good with vices I'll put that in oh unum's good with vices I'll put that in so I didn't like holistically ever be like I'll create this whole deck it was it sort of organically yeah over slow optimization over time you know what's Wild what I have like hundreds of magic cards memorized right name cost rules text but the moment I have to remember like three passwords I'm cooked that's why all my passwords are just pay the one dude we're recording this oh crap I'm ruined don't worry it'll be fine because we can use one password to get you back up and running one passwords award-winning password manager is the best way to keep your business's data and loging credentials secure you can set strong
unique passwords for all your accounts without relying on memorization or Post-it notes and one password makes security easy for your whole team it's super userfriendly with simple secure sharing plus it's seamless to switch between devices whether you need access from your phone or laptop it's always a breeze especially with features like autofill for quick sign-ins best of all once you don't have to remember your passwords anymore you won't accidentally say them on camera yeah I wish I've been using one password this whole time this seems great okay my new password is ristic the cut cut cut the tape right now our listeners get a free twoe trial at onep password.com commmand zone for your growing business that's two free weeks at onep password.com commmand Zone don't let security slow your business down go to onep password.com commmand Zone this show is sponsored by liquid IV seasons greetings Cool Cats this year I jetmir Nexus of rebels will throw the most perfect holiday party this whole crime family will come together as the Halo Fountain well look we may have used up all of our Angel juice at my meowoween masquerade but fear not I found a new source of hydration to keep everyone fully pumped liquid IV it's the best way to stay hydrated through the holidays with eight vitamins and nutrients plus three times the electrolytes of the leading Sports strength one stick of liquid IV with 16 ounces of water hydrates better than water alone so you can tear pour and live more never let a party leave you parched again whether you need to stay vigilant on Commander Knights trample the dance floor or double strike a pose on the runway proper hydration is a
must Halo was good but this P Cola flavorer is simply Divine hey how do they make this stuff no Angels were harmed in the making of liquid IV stay hydrated through the holidays with liquid IV get 20% off your first order of liquid IV when you go to liquid iv.com and use code command at checkout that's 20% off your first order when you shop better hydration today using promo code command at liquid I v.com I think it might need more card draw who are you talking to or is that just something you say oh no I'm on a call with Jimmy we're uh building a chatter Fang deck ooh I just added toski that should help right wa the card just showed up yeah with architex you can collaborate in real time from anywhere in the world changes show up immediately you don't even have to reload the page so it's perfect for brewing with a friend this is cool but isn't Jimmy just upstairs yeah but I'm I'm downstairs right now I ain't coming downstairs architect is the best place to browse brew and play test Commander decks just go to arc.com commmand Zone to get started that's AR ct.com commmand Zone I want to talk about your discard deck because I remember that deck being very strong and that was what Tai said a moment where I realized oh you can attack a different resource than their life total MH to win the game and I think that was another aha moment for me was you had you were like oh I'm just going to strip out of the cards out of their hand and then not only will they take damage from the rack but even if I don't get the rack out it's bad them CU they just don't have anything they can really do yeah it was painful when you got behind on the discard deck um yeah so it was black blue I had hypnotic specs I used what is
it one black to get three black dark ritual Dark Ritual yeah if you turn one dark ritual innotic Spector was like yeah turn turn one not expect her out I did use they were maybe a little underpowered but the Mind stab throlls when they got through I could sacrifice him for random card uh mind twist or something I restricted you only have one still good in Commander it's a little underrated on the blue end too there was a lot of the spell blast you know tap one more to that's what I remember as your sort of counter spell deck it had a counter spell package yeah and unsummon yep cuz you can unsummon it make it discard it lose it I swear there was an artifact that allowed you to like tap and make them discard it was kind of expensive but you could at least repeatedly do it I remember what it was I remember the last card I got for it and it was only I only found one of them was a time Elemental because I had a hard time getting rid of like someone would have a stumper card for me that was like sometimes it was a land or an artifact that would get out and I couldn't get rid of it and so the time Elemental would let you take any permanent and unsummon it and unsummon it yeah which is powerful because black and blue are not very good at dealing with certain types of permanence yeah yeah I remember that deck being quite strong and you you said you remember playing against oh yeah yeah I remember that one um yeah I remember you had one of you maybe both had like a discard discarded giant deck was that yours oh that was me Josh had Josh had the graveyard deck where he would discard for several turns yeah turn one and plop a here's nicod Deus or whatever in the discard pile like oh why is he discarding that okay whatever I think we fought about that one for a while like is this can you do
this then it have to like die before it can that was one of our arguments for sure I remember oh I totally forgot about this yeah so I had a deck and like just like they said turn one I would do nothing I draw my card so and then I'd go to my EP and have to discard because I have eight cards and I would discard something big and then I would animate dead it you know play play animate dead it and then they would argue you can't animate dead it because it didn't die right didn't never go to the graveyard really it did go to the graveyard but yeah yeah turns out that I was doing it it was it was allowed but I remember the arguments about it that's pretty fun it was allowed in the end it was oh yeah it's totally illegal it doesn't the the anything that animates something from a graveyard does not care how it got into the graveyard it just says is it in the graveyard if the answer is yes yeah turn three some giant would come out yeah I forgot about that terrible I also I I really loved you had a deck which I think was called the sooner than instant death deck oh yeah I think it might have been my favorite deck to play it was sort of like the meekstone deck although I don't think it had Meek Stones it just had it was like uh unstable mutation giant growth lightning bolt it tried to win in three or four or five turns or lose the quick pumps blood lust and blood lust it had C apes and scrip Sprite anything that was all one drops and all pump spells and lightning bolt type that was a really fun one I I was like the Decks that took cards that weren't on their face powerful which is why the discard deck is so great because it all of a sudden brought all these cards into play that you hadn't really you know the throlls and stuff you would didn't seem like that valuable but all of a sudden you have this entire genre
of stuff you're doing right it was really uh you know attractive way to play yeah I remember that the discard deck for sure being like a a pretty big Lynch pin so you had a couple of I don't know if those were backto back but if I as I think about our men in our playg group a couple of moments where it was like oh Greg had the the sort of Boss deck the deck that you had to like consider when you were building conect will I be able to beat that deck and then you had to try and be like I can't have big creatures cuz the meekstone deck I got to have some way to get through these regenerative creatures that he's got and then okay what am I going to do about all this discard so that's one of the reasons I came up with the discard a giant deck was because oh okay now if I'm discarding cards it might be good for me so that came after the discard deck okay yeah for sure so makes sense yeah that play counterplay though which still exists in play groups all over the world to this day I think is one the most fun things about games right is that like you do one thing and then they do this and then you do that and then you know you learn this move and then they learn that one you know that's the fun of it is just figuring out that you know post repost and as we played in groups too knowing how that it wasn't just like oh this is the deck that beats someone else's deck but it had to stand on its own legs in a group you know we started playing more and more in groups M which also had a whole another element of negotiating with other players which I don't know what people do now but it was like I promise I will help you this next turn will you help me take down Josh like you know yeah for sure we used to play a lot um of madeup formats as far as like the decks were the same we didn't usually change the rules of how decks could work
but we would change how we were playing so I remember playing a lot of games with more than one-on-one mhm yeah a lot of did you guys do that in your original play group tire was it yeah yeah we did we would play like you know two on two or we play freefor all if there was three of us you had a giant yeah yeah single sorcerer we played a lot where share your Mana pool and life total oh I forgot about that yeah and we would make up formats like we played blind magic I was going to I was going to say do you remember playing blind magic yeah we'll talk about that in a second cuz I don't even remember all the rules maybe you can help me piece them together but but it is interesting that by default uh we were playing multiplayer because magic for many years was mostly a 1V one game and only in the last you know six or seven years has Commander become the most popular way to play you know the normal pot is four players in a multiplayer game and therefore the soci Dynamics and the sort of politics and Intrigue that you're talking about Greg the werewolf or Mafia part of the game comes into play that felt really natural to me because I had come up playing a ton of multiplayer magic with us and that's just the way we decided to play it wasn't in the rule book that way right do you remember why was it just natural to do that or I want to say it was like there's three of us sitting around and somebody doesn't want to wait and so it's just like all right let's all try to kill each other I mean it's a very natural you know next step I think they had a multiplayer rule they I think they had something like that not the twoed giant not those details initially but they had like how you took turns didn't we didn't we pull it out of the player book we didn't make it up did we I've heard a lot of people do it I'm not saying we made it up exactly but I don't remember ever reading anything about it
but that we could have cuz it's been a long time so I don't remember everything yeah true yeah but I do remember all those little deals and stuff which we still do if you watch game nights there's still all kinds of hey if you kill that I won't attack you or hey if I don't do this will you just promise to blah blah blah like that happens all the time yeah grudges from game to game it'd be like no last time and I always did against Josh I feel so bad I knew he was a very strong player and always like how do I get someone to help me beat Josh basically was always campaigning against me you know honestly when I think about it now both of our play groups had the smartest people in the high school in them right well certainly me yeah Ty you and Jeff were two were the two eighth graders that were bust over to the high school cuz Tai is a year younger than Greg and I are and uh my freshman year I was in the highest math or freshman could be in but they started this new program where Tai and Jeff who also played in your playg group came over to take high school geometry your eighth grade year yeah and Andy and Kevin who were in Greg's play group with us were like valedictorian known as like two of the smartest guys in the school types Greg was valedictorian doctor now obviously like it was a game that smart people played I don't think we thought of it in those terms and maybe like nerds played was what we would say then MH what do you guys remember about that aspect of it do you remember uh yeah I mean I remember playing on the soccer bus and having the coaches sort of give us the side eye and
just like what are you guys doing and you know even to the point where it's like hey no magic on the soccer bus because they really understand it I think if it was uh Jin Ry or something they wouldn't have cared but somehow the fact that it was Wizard and and goblins and stuff it was objectionable in that way was that on the soccer bus or something else I don't remember that I don't remember getting pushed back from teachers or other or other um people like but I I don't remember that I felt like I had a dance between all those different groups I didn't care as much maybe but I do remember our chemistry teacher you might have been there um ask us do you guys think this is going to still be like we were spending money on cards and you think this is still going to be worth anything and is anyone going to be playing this in 5 years had the beard or the mustache and sorry I didn't mean to I couldn't do his voice anyway but he who that Mr sprag Mr sprag yeah y he was doubting nailed it I remember him saying it well when you say teachers that me that reminded me of I totally forgotten about this but your original play group was like all in the same Spanish class right or a bunch of them were a lot of us were in there do you remember that I used to sneak out of my second period I wouldn't sneak out I my teacher knew I was doing it but during channel one you weren't in that Spanish class no but I would come in and play magic with you guys and then I would leave so funny so yeah we had like 15 minutes of Anderson Cooper Lisa Lan Mountain Dew and Snickers commercial saying when you miss lunch have a or sorry what it was called channel one and
it was like a news program uh that played for like the first what 18 minutes of second period every day and during channel one I don't know how I convinced whoever my teacher was Mr Morlock no he was our Spanish teacher that allowed it because he thought that probably he didn't yeah so Joe Morlock who was one of the soccer coaches um Mr Morlock was the Spanish teacher so he would obviously allow me to come in and I I'm not sure who my second period teacher was but I would I wouldn't even go to my second period I would go straight to Mr morlocks class play magic with them during channel one and then leave and go to my class do you remember that I thought you were in our class no I wasn't in that class I was like I remember you playing Magic with us yeah cuz that's like some of those the meekstone moment happened was yeah I was there but I was not I would just be like okay see you guys tomorrow and I would go to my class funny yeah yeah I just remember like having him out in the cafeteria or really anywhere and just how I don't know like people come by and kind of give you like what is that magic like you know kind of you'd get the kind of quintessential like uh John Hughes jocks nerds Dynamic a little bit yeah yeah I remember a little bit of that sort of you know not a we we had a pretty good like group of like nerds didn't feel super nerdy at our school I don't think in the way that at least movies and stuff made away but I remember a little bit about that what about CU we did run into a little bit of the other part of this which is like the satanic Panic period that's kind of famous in Dungeons and Dragons and Magic as well where there was a certain sort
of uproar regarding some of the content like the Demonic tutor and the Unholy strength had the pentagram in it and so did the Demonic tutor you know at that that time there was people were scared of Dungeons and Dragons saying it was like people worshiping the devil or whatever that was all happening kind of around that time and we actually did run into a little bit of that as well yeah I mean we lost a member of our playg group his parents sort of requested that he not play anymore for those reasons and he kind of one day said sorry guys I can't play magic with you we're like we're like why yeah he's like well you know religious stuff okay yeah um I remember my mom like questioning me kind of like very gently just like you you know that this isn't like witchcraft right and I was like yeah it's just a game right yes uh okay you're good yeah Mom we're not actually like carving into our own skin or anything yeah yeah did you run into any of that Greg I don't recall that I remember hearing about for Dungeons and Dragons before I even played and the principal when I was in sixth grade was terrified of it and I feel like made an announcement to the whole school even or something do you remember that no was that Mr Ziva yes yeah it's funny I remember the names of teach but I don't remember I I do remember the the pentagram coming off the Demonic tutor's forehead and the card being like reprinted and it was like what and maybe a couple other little tweaks that they did to address it or to maybe make it less tany I guess yeah they definitely did alter some card art as I recall in later printings to
kind of like address it a little bit so it was enough to worry them as a company or a game I guess they weren't as big obviously as they are now but yeah that was an interesting time period where I got no push back for my parents though or anything like that yeah me neither my parents I don't even remember getting questioned or anything about it from my parents I think to be honest part a big part of it was you guys were involved with it my parents are like good boys yeah oh it's Greg and Ty how it can't be anything that bad because these are they're good kids yeah that's why all our spells worked well I I wanted to ask you well our staff really wanted to hear you talk about what kind of player I was back then and what kind of player you think I probably am now well I mean counter spells has to be a big part of the story like I just remember you being the counter spell Lord and you know and instance you know you were early on that I feel like that was a big part of your play identity what do you think joshu was always Nimble his play style always changed he was always doing something different so it was really hard to know he wasn't going to create the same type of deck usually it was Universal he wasn't usually focused on like to take one of our other decks down it was a deck that could handle that but was universally strong and you were really good at the communication between us when we're at the table playing to manipulate some other folks to get on your side so I knew playing you half of it was your deck but half of it was the The Talk game of like getting some help against Josh before he either forces coerces right or cajoles someone in you
know to his side it's like you didn't really want to make a deal with you because it was helping you out was probably risky it was going to come back and you know look like a good idea for you you're like something bad is going to happen if I make this deal with the devil here it seems innocuous like it's just a onew but he's got six cards over there and he seems awfully happy I don't know yeah I think Jimmy if he was sitting here could uh could commiserate with you guys about all that it's not not much of that has changed yeah so what do you remember about about my decks well I do remember at one point you maybe this is not about the decks but about your progress with magic you invested in trading I think most mostly for multi lands oh yeah and at first it was like oh that's cool Josh has a couple multi lands but then you had like a deck with all multi lands or are they called that is dual land dual lands okay yeah and that was like oh no this is now the game's really broken because Josh can play these two colored decks col yeah and it was sort of like uh I don't know what to do about that any deck that you got serious about it was a bunch it was all the Dual lands birds of paradise and you just put any old card in there you wanted and it was yeah it was like okay yeah that was ferocious yeah we didn't talk about colors but like most of the decks we've talked about we start out playing one color I remember Greg when we first started playing every deck was single color black oh just oh yeah that existed in the meta cuz I didn't have any cards at first so you would just hand me decks and it was like the red Goblin deck the green monster deck
the black whatever you know uh I believe you handed me the green deck first as I play that and we played in a game that was multiplayer I think the first game I ever played was more than one person like real game after you sort of taught me and everyone was just playing monocolor decks and then we learned later oh we can have two color decks and that it kind of stall that two colors for a while and I at some point I think just because I wanted I was like if I could get these three cards together then I could do this cool thing I remember you had a a green white blue deck it was like stasis Sarah Angel maybe yeah that might have been one of my first comex three was hard to get to without so three made it be you know as I was testing I was like ah the colors are allw screwy like I just I'll have the right cards but I can't kiss cast them and everybody had like a dual land or to cuz you would open some packs of Revis but if you just have one dual land it doesn't help you that much you have to have a critical mass of them so that was my thing I was like okay I'm going to go out and get dual lands and that'll just open the door to like if I think of any cards that I want to put in the same deck I'll be able to do it and then I've told this story on the show where I would just trade Sarah Angels straight across for dual lands I just let it be known and people would come up to me at school and be like hey I heard you'll trade a Sarah Angel for a dual yep and I think I did that yeah you might I'm pretty sure I did sorry I was about to say fools dude I got that Sarah though yeah I had like two bad lands and was so proud of them in in the fireball deck black red I think is what it was right and then Josh has like yeah 50 yeah I think I had over a 100 at some point it was insan if you haven't been
around for that long I've told the story in the past but I lost most of them in a flood at my parents house oh no yeah so the basement flood at my parents house and but the top shelf didn't get hit which held my decks oh so that's why I do still have some that were in decks but all the ones that I just had like in a box I didn't know this gone turned to dust yeah oh this is terrible had a MOX emerald in there too it was pretty bad um that's rough well they've been sitting there for years I never thought about them but when I got back into magic I was like I got to go back home I got all these cards and then only a few of them still existed um but anyway yeah I was kind of the first in our play group to start playing like a lot of colors and putting then that allowed me to start putting really weird stuff together like the stasis deck was one of my early um combo and of course it's a combo lock thing I think I read about it or heard somebody talk about it but what I would do is get stasis out and I would get either a birds of paradise or a lay Druid I think and put an instill energy on it nothing was going to untap but I could untap that and then that would give me the blue Mana to pay for the stasis forever so once I had that then I just needed something that could attack without tapping so either a s angel or a zeph or Falcon so I would just lock the game you're never untapping again and just I can attack with this for one to four every turn mhm super you have to wait for it a land to come wait for a land to get a two one nothing and then I thought I was so clever it was it was brilliant though like it was so clever it wasn't fun to play against but it was brilliant I remember I had a few unfund decks do you guys remember my ank of Mishra armagan deck oh yeah I Remember by name the ank what the ank do the an every time anybody puts a land play it
does two damage to them oh yeah yeah yeah this what I mean the universally like hits any type of deck anyhow yeah go ahead remind me again cuz I well yeah I would play all birds of paradise then I would play like a Zur orb and then I would Play balance what's balance do wipes all the like down to how many Whoever has the least amount of creatures you go down that many creatures whoever on the least amount of lands you go to that land so I sack all my lands Play balance and I have zero land so everybody has to sack all their lands if I was ahead far enough ahead I would sack everything so everybody would have nothing and the ank would be out and it would be like well if you play a land you're going to die but if you don't play a land you're going to die yeah yeah that was the early deck that became the wave deck because I realized that actually the most powerful thing about that was black VI and Howes because everyone's just sitting there drawing not being able to do anything go back to the woolly mammoth days totally do so let's talk about the wave deck because this is like I think a funny story and you've already sort of talked about it I think it was the best deck in our play group at the end and our play group didn't continue long enough after for another deck to eventually you know supplant it so it kind of ended our era everybody went to college we graduated from high school that's how I remember it and the wave deck you know got to be rain Supreme at the end right it definitely would have gotten you know somebody would have come up with the next thing but because it was the kind of last of that era that was the tournament right that was yeah we ran a local tournament uh in cambi and um I think it was a team tournament we did single sorcerer two-head giant or something pretty sure it was single
sorcerer yeah and so everybody had was in pairs and what did you play at that tournament Greg probably discard was discard discard yeah I remember I remember we took one game off you guys with our Karma magical hack Tech and we ran around like idiots I remember that actually you guys celebrating R around we we just sort of knew that we were had inferior we just were behind you guys at that point and we were like oh my gosh we beat the discard deck I didn't ever feel like it was that good felt like it was a great idea that wasn't quite you guys were mad because we had Karma and and you were like well this is just a cuz you were black based deck yeah it's against me personally and then we got our butts kicked by the wave deck and the wave had so I maybe I I was thinking of it as the Stormbreaker is that right stormseeker that was the deck with stormseeker in right okay so stormseeker is a card that it's an instant that deals damage to a player based on the amount of cards in their hand and I would Fork a stormseeker to win a lot of games was one of the ways that it won and it was the opposite of your discard deck basically it said okay everybody's going to draw a lot of cards and I'm going to punish my opponent drawing of the card so underworld dreams will punish them black Vice will punish them that kind of stuff and it'll have a counter spell package backup to protect its key pieces and that was kind of the whole thing and the interesting thing is it's called The Wave deck not because of what it's doing at all but because I had shuffled the deck so much that the cards did this wavy mhm thing they weren't like curved like this they actually literally went
like that you must have played in the rain once or something cuz it was only that was the only deck that looked like that I think it was just i s and ter yeah I think I just hadn't shuffled any deck before that amount of times like that deck was honed yeah and the funny thing is to this day like the the only like dual lands and stuff I've got left from that ER were in my box with my decks which had the wave deck in it so a lot most of my dual lands were in that deck uh most of the ones I was playing with anyway and so they still have the wave to them if I pull them out of the sleeve you can you can see it maybe I'll take a picture of one yeah I'll take a picture of one and we'll put it on the video yeah but that was the sort of culmination of all that I think of things I've been trying for a while with the Armageddon and the stasis and everything else and it didn't end up the final version didn't have armag stasis I think still had strip mines and some stuff to kind of wrath of God was that in there yeah it had wrath of God because it wasn't very creature heavy reversal of Fortune uh Wheel of Fortune Wheel Fortune Wheel of Fortune yeah yeah cuz the other trick was if you got underworld dreams out you would Fork A Wheel of Fortune instead of forking the storm Seeker yeah one of the things I learned from playing all five colors was that you could play all the restricted cards yeah that's memory of it it's like you know demonic tutor regrowth there were only so many of those floating around in the play group and they're all in that deck so yeah that's another realization I was had well the game had the game designers had basically told you these are broken MH you know these are too powerful because they had to create an additional rule for them so my thinking was like okay well if I can play as many of those as possible my deck will just be more powerful because I know those are too powerful because why El would they make this special rule for them and you already had so many colors you could just pick whatever the
awesome restricted cards were and throw it in there yeah yeah just play all of them exactly so channel did you have channel that actually got banned right in our time it was banned I don't think we were allowed to play Channel anymore too good and only we only had like a couple and I didn't play mind twist CU I didn't want people discarding things but yeah yeah so that was my recollection of um our playgroup as well those were fun times I mean those were what Magic's all about and still I think is all about when people start it uh I wanted to ask you cuz Greg you said you went and bought the fork for $25 there's no way it could have been that much money cuz I remember looking in the case and seeing black lotuses that were like 15 bucks uh but maybe this was it might have been like my brain is like yeah I was going to ask like do you remember like what your most expensive cards were what they were worth at that time cuz you said you were proud of the two bad lands you had yeah do you remember how much of those were worth uh maybe 10 I mean they were like $10 cards which now when I say it out loud it's like oh man but when you're 14 $10 was a lot yeah and you had two of them I believe one of them was unlimited too just picturing your in my head I think you had an unlimited well they were both white barded but unlimited has a slightly different look to it okay you can tell when they're side by side they're not the exact same and I you know that's quite a bit of money these days a lot more than $10 the unlimited one especially like you know it's maybe $1,000 for both of those now wow yeah yeah something like that I didn't really buy Cards though I mean I might have it
was mostly what you cracked PS We traded too right a little bit a little bit I was always afraid to trade with you cuz I knew I'd get the wor I deal I didn't mean you and me I just meant like a little bit yeah a little bit I was very I think risk averse so I would buy packs but didn't buy packs but not want to buy individual cards and was a little bit shy on trading the time Elemental I spent money on even though it's worthless I mean it wasn't a very good card but I kind of wanted it in the deck the fork I remember I think I I might have even bought two of them Ty do you remember having any like what your most expensive card was or do you remember seeing a card and being I wish I could get that and how much it was yeah I didn't have any good cards is my recollection uh and all they all belong to you and Greg no um I mean I remember going and buying a couple of clones cuz I was like chasing after do you remember how much they were I want to say they were like 10 bucks wow or or maybe eight maybe two but it it hurt you know it hurt um and um doppelgangers then for that same Reas the sble which were even better kind of for sure you change them right more expensive actually they're worse cuz the more man yeah right yeah um so those those come to mind and then we had to have four magical hacks so we had to go buy those I think those were cheaper I want to say that was like four bucks or something but still like each yeah but it's like it's an instant it does so little it felt it kind of hurt to like spend money on such a a thing that does so little I don't know I might be mixing up in my head too like cuz we played for a few years so maybe like I'm picturing the Black Lotus for $15 in the case like the first time I ever went to
the LGs and we're talking about two three years later buying some of these other cards it's possible my is wrong there were also a lot of cards in the case that were like 50 cents 75 cents and it's like oh do I want to spend 75 cents on that thing it's not that good but I kind of want it like there were low a lot of low tier and it was when you started seeing $5 for a card you're like oh that's a that's a good one our play group had a couple of older uh they were a year or two older but at the time that felt like a lot cuz you know the difference between 14 and 16 is a lot and them being like it's not a good idea to buy the expensive cards and I'd be like you know why you know Michael Jordan's rookie card is worth x amount why isn't it worth it to buy a MOX or whatever and they were like well yeah because it matters that the card for Michael Jordan rookie card is from the year of his rookie year but it doesn't matter if the Black Lotus is from the year of black lotus's rookie year right they just reprint it at any time and then I was like oh that makes a lot of sense so I didn't buy any of the like expensive ones like that was kind of talking me out of buying I think a moxen or something like that you got a couple though right didn't you buy I eventually got a MOX Emerald that's the only Power I've ever had but I just wanted to say that those guys like cost me like $200,000 or something mhm that's great I drivers though needed them it's true they had driver's license so I had to listen to them yeah I just bought like booster packs which in retrospect was probably like I just I don't know it was like whatever fun though right no it
was great it was great and we had so much fun but like I got a lot of spores like it probably would have been better just investing in like a some good cards you know than trying to I don't know collect the whole new set there's a dopamine hit though of going through those cards anything of gam love it it's not till you have like two large boxes full of basic land where you're like maybe mistakes were made here yeah right yeah I think that's people out there when they hear like oh old magic player they think like oh what cards did you have in your collection and like back then people didn't have I had a large collection because I got more into it than anybody and I was a big Trader and you worked at a card shop and I ended up working at a card shop and I don't know if I've ever told this story on the show um the way that they paid me was in cards and what I did for them was I priced all the cards and I also took all the chaff all the crappy stuff and I built it into precon decks and they could sell the precon decks and so I would just take like all the Elementals like water earth air get the right Mana couple other a pump spell and a counter spell and you know that's a 60 card deck that you can play that's probably better than most people make their in their first deck or whatever yeah and they they the deal was they would pay me you know a booster box x amount of time or whatever and that's how I got a lot of my cards the problem was when I started doing that the new set was Fallen Empires which is historically bad like there's like almost no cards from Fallen Empires that still see play maybe two what are some of the cards high tide okay oh was this with the no not is the only one that
sort of SE yeah had uh hom rids remember you had to like every upkeep put a counter on unless it would go like one counter two counters three counters two counters one counter two counters three counters I I probably have more of those cards than any other cards which is why all my cards suck yeah it's famously the set where they finally were able to print them enough that a lot got out there because up until then it just sort of always sold out they were hard to find and then it was historically bad like underpowered crappy cards yeah they were awful yeah yeah and to this day probably when I stopped playing Magic I was like okay cool build this like black and red sports deck and it's just like a non-starter you know and it just I don't know then I went to college MH I think college was still a little bit ways but yeah that was definitely like I had a lot of a lot of cards cuz of the card chop thing but what happened to your guys' cards I guess was where I was leading with this question is like do you still have them are they somewhere I have mine yeah I left them at my mom's house for many years and then when my son got to the age where it seemed like he might be interested in them my mom brought him down and then they were at our house so I I you know dug him up the other day and had a look but I still have them such as they are I think I think all of them how old's your son he's 11 I'm about ready to get started yeah he's newly uh you know being with you and and uh engaging with uh command Zone um he's definitely like Dad teach me how to play and so now I I actually need to ask you like how I need to what I need to buy you know get them going is the best way to learn but yeah you want to get some physical cards definitely yeah no screens how about you uh Greg what's uh what happened to your
cards I think they lived at my parents house when I was in college in med school and at some point my brother got back into it um he kept a lot of the decks still put together still in rubber bands still in rubber yeah still in rubber bands or the rubber bands had we didn't sleeve anything the decks were kept in rubber bands yeah yeah I didn't know about that for we didn't know the cards were going to be worth $1,000 yeah and when I started uh my where I worked now at this Clinic the one of the Physicians kids was into magic in fact I'd met him before he was like oh you work with my mom then he was like oh yeah my friend Josh is on the command or whatever somehow it came up and he's like you know Josh lequ and I was like suddenly he he was like he knew me who knew you and I was like okay um did you so yeah so I gave him all my all the cards from the decks but I didn't have all my Reserve cards I don't know where those went to I just like had the box of decks so there's some that are like missing yeah and then well he played with it for years and they got all mixed up and so I looked at it and I know things are in pieces so and then I gave him back to my brother and I think he has them now so we've referred to it but you know we eventually all of us stopped playing I came back eventually but was it just you know life happened we dispersed people went to college or do you remember why you stopped playing it was also the the friend group not the player group that we had not being there and going to yeah going to college and having different friend groups that had different interests and it wasn't where
I was wasn't magic and I didn't go out and find those folks either like it was probably just a transition time for me in that way I remember I driving up to cuz you went to University of Portland yeah we both did yeah and Ty and I and another of our friends Jeff we would drive up we we did this whole a couple times but drove up like and to play Magic and hang out maybe a couple times early on when you're were a freshman yeah that probably the the last that was play like the last few games I played you know until years later I played actually I did play again I forgot about this in med school so I must have gotten a hold of my cards because I had a friend that played the Star Wars ccg that I was thinking about and then he had not played magic and so I taught him magic he taught me Star Wars ccg you got back in play for a little bit so we did yeah we still lean more towards the Star Wars cards because it was his interest too so um but no I did have I did have some cards in med school I forgot about that yeah had time in med school to play Magic huh yeah from what I hear that's a rarity uh okay before concerning before we move on I did I forgot we didn't talk about blind magic so we would make up formats most of them were not very good but this is one that stood out because it was a CO also not very good it was a cockamamy scheme yeah do you remember how it worked okay so my recollection is playing in your basement and nobody can look at anybody else's cards and we all hiding opposite sides of the room right behind the couch somebody's over upstairs maybe or in the stairwell and you would just have to shout like okay I'm tapping two and I'm attacking Josh
okay this is like Calvin ball for magic yeah it was just make up the rules and we would play for hours and it would be like okay I'm going to block all right what is your thing and you give the numbers and then ultimately he was like oh okay he's got a sing gear over there all right okay now I know that but then you'd forget somehow I don't know how he came up with like okay I'm attacking you oh no what what is this no don't attack him he has the say you remember a crap oh yeah okay I eat that now it's 5 five wow I never played that that was yeah we did that quite a bit as I recall yeah we were just always trying to figure out new ways to uh to play it it was like the 80th day in a row that we played yeah how can we make this yeah yeah okay I want to move on to some questions here um just because I think people out there will find it interesting uh from your guys' OG perspective do you know what a two for one is a two for one no uh we're not going what do you think a two for one might be in Magic okay what's your confidence level no two for one ah boy killing two creatures at once I don't know I got nothing a trade like a two for one trade it's anytime you use a card and you get two cards worth of value at it so if one card killed two creatures that's a two for one or one card Drew you two cards that's a two for one I use one resource and I get two resources worth of stuff either taken away from my opponents or given to me value added type of card yeah do you know what Mana ramp is I imagine something that's more like kind
of exponential where one gets two two gets four something like that but I don't know what that would be the rate at which your the game is getting more Mana something like that per round like by round two you're actually what would be like a a Mana ramp card do you think um Sol ring the El the LA elves eles yep both are yeah it's anything that gets you head on Mana uh above what you would have if you just played one land per turn Okay so if you have access to four mana on turn three you've ramped by one okay do you remember what these cards do power sync that's a counter spell yep but you it makes you like if I cast it for four you have to tap four more Mana right in order to it it takes all your Mana if you can't pay the cost you're shaking your head no spell blast is the cost of the spell Mana sync is if they what yeah Power syn is you have to if they have no land left tap one more right exactly they have to pay extra whatever you pay pay yeah right it's blue and x and they the Spells countered unless they pay X more Mana so if you pay four Mana they have to pay three more Mana or their spell gets countered yeah it's nasty so you do it when yeah they only have one left and you know they can't all right do you remember what kurd apes are a red green if a forest is available then there are like two three but if it's not they're one one is a red card pretty good boom what was the Mana was it red green or red one red oh okay one
red for a one one if you have a forest it's it gets plus one plus two ah right yeah so if you bust out with the Dual red green then it's two three immediately yep you must have had some Apes uh I must have you mentioned this one so I assume you know it does but the hive you remember what the hive does I remember this was a favorite in early our friend Toby yeah Toby loved it but it was a favorite in in our early group when the games were slower is green and I think you had a it had a upkeep and it spit out one- one Flyers each turn do you remember the card no you're close it was an artifact so it wasn't green oh okay yeah it cost five mana and then you pay five and tap it and you make a one- one fly you know what I think it was in a monog green deck and it was like all the creatures with green to's deck it was green that's right you didn't have an upkeep you just paid for whenever you wanted to crank got a flyer yeah but you only once per turn it's a pretty bad card it's 10 Mana for a one- one flyer and then 15 Mana for a second or five more Mana for each subsequent one but every once in a while it would go off it was really good our members really good in like the four player games and he would just sit there and we wouldn't worry about it too much cuz like whatever one one greens and then all of a sudden you would have like 30 creatures it would be a problem and they all flying yeah yeah all right Wheel of Fortune do you remember what that does I know that one that I did is this where you everyone discards their hand and redraws their an entire oh maybe was it seven or was it the number of cards you had okay seven cards I think it's seven would you remember the casting cost of it two in a red yep three Mana total
pretty good I remember that as one of your favorites and just anytime the game is not to your liking just be like you know what let's just POR in this a couple other questions here so commander most popular format of the top most popular cards in the format there's a website that tracks all this stuff called EDH Rec three of the top 10 cards are from revised from unlimited from from Alpha from the original group of cards can you name those three cards three of the 10 to this day right three of the top 10 are from our era from revised you could have pulled them got to be soul ring soul ring is has to be one of them soul ring is the number one most popular card in the format there's two left in the top 10 regrowth maybe demonic tutor counter spell I mean as simple and basic counter spell is but that seems to of the game nights I've seen I can't recall a single two blue counter spell played not counting restricted cards or could it be restricted could be restricted demonic tutor is a good guess yeah demonic tutor nope okay not we we don't we don't guess that then okay we didn't level zero yeah um okay two more soul ring was five and the rest here weing would they be artifacts the dancing Scimitar I'm just kidding one of's favorite cards early on love uh brass man no gotta be like Fast Mana right like
one of these like Jewel I would say I would have said like dark ritual was awesome yeah but those are no that's that's just black though Bird's of paradise maybe oh well was that unlimited yep Birds Paradise close it is in the top like 100 but it's not in the top 10 what you said one of them already Dark Ritual that's in the top 100 as well but nope the brass man you've said a lot of cards that are actually um Demar tutor is in the top 100 you're you're dancing around a lot of the cards that still get played so you recognize that which ones are the sort of powerful long term which is good um counter spell oh okay it was is yeah it's in the top 10 and then the other one hasn't been mentioned this whole time and I think we actually kind of slept on it back in the day we didn't realize how good it was swords to plow shares oh yeah we didn't use it a lot we didn't use it a lot but that makes sense that was do again it gives you one white for it yeah it's one white to Exile a creature and then the creature's controller gets life equal to its power see because it's white that takes out a creature quickly and easily right yeah just one Mana take out any creature and it also Exiles it well in our day it was said remove from the game but it meant no regeneration you can't reanimate it from the graveyard anything like that I think and this is very common even to this day new players tend to um overestimate how good life gain is they tend to want to play Decks that gain them life and and life gain is it's not that it's always bad but it's not good unless your whole deck's about
it right and then they would you would overestimate how bad that is that you're giving your opponent life so a lot of people looked at the card and be like well I don't want to give my opponent's life but really removing the creature for very cheap and efficiently yeah is a lot better than them gaining even 6 Seven 8 10 life other cards that were kind of from our era that are still in the top 100 most popular cards brainstorm brainstorm is one of the most powerful cards of all time as it turns out that's a straw X right no it's draw that's brain geyser brainstorm is draw three and then put two cards from your hand back on top of your your library oh and it is a very Lynch pin card I don't I think we slept on that one too because I remember that card but we didn't run it much one of the reasons it's powerful is as a thing that we didn't really have available to us yet at that era which are things that shuffle your deck so what you can do is draw three put two cards back that you don't want and then use in fact that it will shuffle your library so that you kind of get optimiz in your hand you're not going to have to draw those two cards that you just put back and there's things called Fetch lands that didn't really exist in our day that are prevalent enough now that you can sort of reliably be able to shuffle and that makes brainstorm a lot better land War elves we had talked about is in the top 100 still it's they are they are the simple casting cost low cast simple cards that it's always going to be good it's a one Mana thing that gets you ahead on mana and right or the will of the Wisps uh will of the whis's not good anymore but yeah sorry well not yet wait for the counter strike that we're going to come up with uh fwar
Stone I don't even know if you remember that card but that's a very highly play card remember it but I don't remember what it does a floating cube thing with multi look like brain and multicolored yeah and it just Taps twoo colorless and Taps for any color of Mana that your opponent can one of the a lands can produce that's good but it's basically a birds of paradise kind of thought thing uh Mystic rora do you remember this card at all no I don't think we played this card at all I don't is it like a fish like a ramora yeah is it Mystic is it blue it's blue is it a card what it does it has a cumulative upkeep so it's from Ice Age you remember cumulative upkeep cards yeah yeah and what it says is um whenever your opponent casts a non-creature spell you draw a card unless they pay four additional Mana so card draw yeah it's it's card draw that's repeatable and it's actually a lot better when you think about a four player game because you have three opponents and a lot more chances for them to cast a non-c creature spell before it gets back to your upkeep and you have to pay that cumulative upkeep cost cuz it's one then two then three then four and becomes untenable you're hoping to just get some hits out of it yeah any of us have that card I don't remember I don't remember we did but we didn't look at it twice okay um because it was give me a little buff keep keep we just and we didn't know it was good and maybe it wasn't good because if your C if your opponents are casting a lot of creatures it becomes worse cuz it only Triggers on non-creatures and we were casting a lot of creatures we thought enough about efficiency back then either it's one blue Mana for this thing and so if you can draw even two cards for one blue Mana it's very good if you draw three or four it's insane but I don't think we thought about things in those terms and we I don't think we ever really got to that level of thinking
about the game we we got close though yeah I mean I definitely remember you know building the Tim deck and thinking like oh it needs to be faster and how can I get it faster and you know yeah I mean but maybe not to the level of like this is one Mana look at all I get for one Mana yeah I think we did think about speed and being being efficient and doing things early in the CU we learned after a while that you couldn't be slow you would just get run over you wouldn't be able to catch up but I don't think we thought about like okay for my two Mana I get this much resource back so that ratio I want to be X I think you're right I don't think we're quite making that calculation yeah Mana drain do you remember Mana drain this was in our era it's from Legends I'm picturing surge the guy I just power power surge what's Mana drain Mana short we had the rose on it and made it so you're had to tap all their mana and it pulled all the Mana man drain I don't remember yeah it was a counter spell I'm not sure if anybody had this in our play group I don't remember us playing with it either I think we would have if we anybody had it I think it's it's from Legends you countered their spell and then on your turn you get colorless Mana equal to the Mana value of the spell you countered art we did not have that you remember what the art looked like it's like a two little blue curly things I can picture in my head they've changed the art since so the original art is yeah I don't know that's the other card from our era that was in the top 100 there's a story I wanted to tell I don't know if you remember this but a thing I used to do was when I was sort of testing a deck yes I would Sharpie the name of the
cards on or like I I was like oh I don't want to trade for all this stuff if I don't think the deck's going to be very good so I would just sharp and it's it's called proxy and people still kind of do that now um and so I would just write on you know I remember I didn't have enough birds of paradise and I was building I think there was the ank deck and I was wanted to test it so I just wrote Birds of Paradise in Sharpie on four cards and I would test with that you remember me doing this oh yeah yeah yeah I went back and I was looking at the old cards recently because of this episode just trying to and I realized that I still had the Sharpie cards yeah I have some too oh I want to see yours I I have a couple yeah I have one that uh has meekstone written on it I think it's a swamp says meekstone yeah yeah do you remember what the cards are that you wrote on uh they were all swamps I think oh you were smart yeah I did some of mine on Lion's eyed diamonds which are like $300 $400 cards now it's the card where do you remember what L Diamond even is was it a white lion it is a zero Mana artifact that you can sacrifice for three Mana of any color but you have to discard your hand huh and you you were why would you do that that card's bad but it's valuable now cuz it's bad no it's valuable now cuz it's extremely broken to get three Mana for zero mana and you can figure out a way to get around the discard your hand thing yeah but at the time it was very very bad I can't picture that one either it has like a has like a lady on it I think and it's like a I don't know Well Done yep
yeah smart how many of those did you do I mean CU they were pretty common and I think they were from Mirage or something but like yeah yeah regrets why not a land why not a basic land regrets all right so I'm going to hand you guys this to look at and I want you this first grouping of cards here I'm going to show you kenrith trxa golos and cranco and I want you to try and figure out which one of these four is banned in Commander all right when golos enters the battlefield you may search your library for a land card and put that card into the battlefield tapped then shuffle your library that seems pretty good to me because um you can make him enter the battlefield like a million times doing different stuff you can do that like a bunch and then he has this extra thing that's good but he's really expensive so I don't know let's proliferate any type of counter on a a permanent or player you can add another one of those counters oh okay to any to any number so if there's 10 things with plus one plus counter you can give them all one or if somebody's got a poison counter you can give them one oh that was proliferate you were explaining when I wasn't listening okay proliferate added a counter that has a counter including players that could potentially many that could potentially be manipulated it's true but I don't know what that combo would it only does it at the beginning of your InStep that's only once per turn it's hard to spam that a bunch of times but if you have a million counters maybe you don't have to the something that's really difficult this one strikes me as not that big of a deal it's just creatures I don't know that becomes exponential it's
true am I reading that right yeah yeah because you get you get three and then you're going to get that's like folding pieces of paper yeah and you just have to tap it you just holy crap that's pretty good but again well no how many times could you untap him or untap him and play him and right tap oh yeah you just tap him it's him it's the goblin that's broken you think so I think so the math of that is starts folding quickly you have four goblins out you make eight you make 16 you make 32 in three TS yeah okay all right talk me into it I don't know no no no but that's my opinion that's my opinion I I mean this one seems like you don't have to have the same answer if you have different answer that's fine as well this one's though you know that means you know that means it's good which one uh atraxa tra yeah yeah she's gold so that and she's she okay Vig death touch is like the same as the Basilisk right yeah who cares okay life anything she deals damage to dies this I haven't really read this guy seems it seems like you can do a lot but I don't know if you can like break anything with it put Target creature card from a graveyard into the battlefield eh I'm still going with that the mob boss I think the math of that could get busted pretty quickly cranco yeah H I'll go with golos just to be different just so you cover your bases yeah okay golos is the band card yes nice attrax is actually the most popular commander in the format for many years now and the
other all of these are like top 10 most popular oh I feel bad for rag on some of them they're all so good my bad it tracks okay I'm going to show you another grouping of cards these are all from our era and I want you to put them in order of what is the most expensive to the least expensive to buy if you were to go into a game store right now and try and buy them so the cards are Wheel of Fortune Soul ring candelabra of tanos and manol feel like soul ring is pretty common so thereby driving it price back in the day is it common now I don't know but that's my working bit of Intel for that card okay manav VA strikes me as a candidate here to add three colorless yeah but it's only one bring it out and then you get three colorless Mana like immediately okay what um this one we didn't I don't remember playing with this but the calabra of tanos that lets you just switch your lands around so you're I to a degree you can right okay but we're talking we need to determine the price yeah so it's also going to be do with like I Rarity and mhm just Market forces I bet probably expensive I'm going to say these are the two most expensive do uh wheel and candleabra what do you think yeah ring is the cheapest have no I have no idea what solar ring how how easy is get a hold of but it was so important to have a solar
ring in every deck you made so even back in the day that was important it's still now yeah okay I'd say one two three four like that okay okay so one one calabra two manava three Wheel of Fortune for soul ring okay calabra of tanos is the most expensive it's about $800 uh Wheel of Fortune is the second it's about $250 at this point I think I'm looking at revised versions I believe these are both on the reserve list they're not theyve made a promise not to reprint these cards so the number of those that exist in the world are the number that are going to exist in the world and unless they break the promise at some point in the future which they show no inclination to do after that is manav vault which is you can find a revised version for about $9 at the moment this has recently spiked in price because of some band that happened uh that made this some people think this was a replacement for some of the band cards and then soul ring $150 maybe two bucks oh nice I'm glad they've kept that we just switched two and three but otherwise we pretty good pretty good pretty good all right nice job Tyler the next question I'm going to show you three cards we'll go by one by one I've blocked out the Mana cost and I want you to guess I'm not so worried about the colors if you want to guess the colors you can it might be easier based on the card color but about how much Mana you think uh each of these would cost so let's start with jarle and molani which is just a big creature it doesn't have any abilities how much Mana do you think that how big is it 186 an
186 so what do you think Mana wise just total amount of Mana that this would cost that you would pay for an 186 probably like seven I was going to say seven but it could but also if it is different colors they might you know if it's like a green and a red it has no other abilities too there's no card so you do know it's multiple colors right yeah I I would I'm going to say yeah gosh cuz like a six like a craw worm to bring back our friend is six Mana so it's got to be like yeah I would I would to pay 10 to get out an 18 to be blocked and easily Terror it or something or well I'll tell you it's got black in its color so it can't be te well it can be sord Supply it can it can that's why uh so you want us to guess what the casting cost total which colors just total cost if you want to guess colors you can but I don't think I think that's too hard I'd go with eight eight it cost uh black black green and three so six Mana total it is six creatures are a lot bigger now than they used to be in our day so you pay a lot less per power and toughness than he used to maybe not in the low range it's still about two Mana for a 2 two but once you get up to about four Mana five Mana stuff just tends to be a lot bigger there's so many ways to take out a creature with not bringing you any extra value than just a giant power which someone can block with anything yeah all
right look at this next card ravan Nimble P piler what do you think the Mana Coston is on this bad boy I know these treasure tokens get spicy first of all can you even digest what it does no okay okay yeah you should probably yeah well I mean okay let's see when it deals combat damage to a player create a treasure token Exile the top card of that player's Library until end of turn you may cast that card dang so I attack you Greg I hit you I make a treasure token which is just an artifact I can sacrifice at any time for one man of any color so I get one one one use mana and I get the top card of your library that I can cast as if it were mine but only I have to cast it this turn is Dash haste Dash is the ability to give it haste out of your hand but then at the end of Turn It bounces back to your hand I bet it's like two in a red that low I feel like it might be pretty low you're right no when you say it that way how about two red and a colorless two red and a colorless red red in one yeah it's just a red whoa yeah that car is broken that's pretty good it's one of the the best r one drops ever made yeah that's all right let's do one more this one is urza's Saga have you seen a saga card before I think in the one of the command Zone shows I watched had one I think when I I played on Arena they there was some sagas you have to kind like go through each step of it so the sagas the way they work is uh each chapter chapter one chapter 2 chapter 3
happens in order the first one happens when you play the card and then the next one happens right after your draw step so it'll be like you play the card you get the first chapter your next turn the second chapter the turn after that the third chapter it's counters so if you could proliferate or something like that you can manipulate it and you can move forward chapters you know if you have other synergies that allow you to do it but in general they go once per turn basically is it its own card to not like art it's an enchantment okay okay so first turn it gives you one white it looks like that's not that much um then oh I guess maybe it's pretty good search your library an artifact card with Mana cost zero or one and put it into the but damn that's pretty good too remember it keeps all abilities the whole time once it gains it so it can always tap for a Mana right oh and then tap off your second turn you can pay to tap it and create a a a creature that says hey my power and toughness is equal to the number of artifacts I control and it is an artifact so it's a minimum one one but if you had five other artifacts it'd be a 66 and then on your third turn you sack it and you go find an artifact that costs one or less like your soul ring or something uh but you can also still tap it on that third turn before it goes away to make a second construct if you want to or you can tap it for mana and Float the Mana it can't be that costly I was thinking that because you're not going to pay five or six mana on the first turn to like get one mana and the rest of the stuff's pretty cool but it's got to be like one or two two yeah yeah i' say two and you it's white that diamond Mana
symbol is actually colorless Mana there's some things that specifically want colorless Mana where you you can't pay colored Mana for it oh interesting well two total yeah we'll two Mana yeah it's a land actually it costs no Mana okay that makes that makes sense that makes sense I should have known none of these were actually straightforward about what we well I was trying to think like what was this one what was that one like it wasn't going to be three I know right why were we picking a number at all it should be like yeah negative five Mana all right we're just going to look at these cards one at a time and I want you to predict whether you think they are banned or are not banned b or unbanned or banned or legal I don't know we'll think we'll work on the name the first one is the one ring well I'm sure inherently it's just limited or restricted you don't know the story of this card oh because of the because there's only one of them because of the post yeah yeah so um so you can have one of these so post Bone's version that he bought is the one of one ring uh is a special version that did only make one of that but there are regular versions uh for the rest of us so so there's more than one ring out there yeah um so you're asking if it's banned restricted or anything there's no restricted anymore in Commander because in Commander you're only allowed to have one of any card that's not a basic land so there's no restricted there's either banned or legal okay so do you think the one ring is banned or legal you understand what it does I can I can explain it if not when it enters the battlefield you gain protection from everything until you're next turn if you cast it that means you not your stuff
but you can't be targeted or dealt damage that's um so what you need to be doing is getting it back to your hand and casting it a bunch and if you do that then you can probably avoid this burden thing being that big of a deal I mean the second ability is actually very good though oh wait yeah because then you get to draw cards if you have burdens I didn't get that for you yeah that's pretty good too okay I'm gonna say it's not banned yeah it looks really powerful but I feel like this is more not looking at the card but Josh psychology I think this is a fake out this is not a ban card though you think it should be we're go with not banned it is not banned okay a lot of people think it should be but it's not okay next card is true name Nemesis okay true name Nemesis this is hilar okay sorry go ahead yeah true name Nemesis I think they might have banned I don't know if they Bann things for this reason but it seems to me this one is an argument starter like you're going to pick a player that seems like it would just lead to a lot of yelling in the play group and perh for that reason they just decided it's not worth it yeah but it doesn't quite feel gamebreaking it feels like game true well I mean it's kind of gamebreaking but it's fight starting right yeah well the other question here is looking at the overall some of them have to be banned we can't just say no for all of them so is it the most likely to be banned is it one out of these four are there mult yes or no for either of these the band list has multiple cards on it so I think um we're going to go
through a few cards and more than one will be banned yes I don't know that that I would have that be banned yeah but it's probably not they don't ban stuff just for that reason I we'll say not banned on that one it is not banned it actually broke a different format uh because they designed it for Commander and in Commander it's not that bad because you have to pick one player and you still have to worry about the other two um it didn't really actually start that many fights but in 1 V one it actually was way too powerful so there's certain formats one called Legacy where you're allowed to play this card and well if your only oppon opponent and they can't touch this thing the rate for it is actually pretty good yeah yeah so if you ever stuck it you could kind of ride it to Victory all right the next one is called primeval Titan uh awesome but I don't think that would be B really expensive I mean yeah I don't think that would be i' would say not banned this card is actually banned huh really the thing that's easy to miss is it gets any land ah right so you could go get uh ursa's Saga for example for sure yeah and like you said with one of the earlier cards you can blink it you can make it enter the battlefield a lot right and yeah and there's been a lot of very powerful lands printed over time so the ability to get any lands is very powerful yeah this is a card though a lot of people think could be unbanned and maybe at some point it will be but currently it's on the ban list all right the next one is platinum angel that seems like it should be banned it doesn't seem right is there around this like you don't win or you
don't lose but you're out of life you can't lose and your opponents can't win so basically they have to get rid of this before the game can end in their favor correct or anyone can right yeah you can still be dealt damage and be sitting there at zero eight sure but then if they remove this you immediately die not banned yeah not banned it is not banned o i that that felt like a trojan horse like it seems like the type of thing that should be banned but it's right okay yeah there's a lot of things that basically it's like well can you kill it okay all right the next one if you scroll is Skull clamp cool oh that's probably banned no wait a minute do you understand how works yeah you you put it out there oh right so it's going to live on when the creature dies right correct yeah that's got to be banned yeah cuz you could just do that a million billion times yep we say it's Bann bned it is not banned ah this is famously a card that they changed last minute it originally gave a plus toughness boost but they gave it a minus toughness boost and what that means is for one Mana if you put it on a one one right it actually does the killing of the creature too which means for one Mana you kind of draw two per creature you're willing to sacrifice and is extremely powerful but not banned mhm one of the more powerful cards out there the next one is also one of the more powerful cards out there one of the biggest creatures ever created emol the aons torn take an extra turn after this one
good gravy that's spicy it has time walk right on it uh Annihilator it says Annihilator six you see that mhm what Annihilator is is when that attacks the the player that it's attacking has to sacrifice six permanence whatever the amount of nil lator is you have to sacrifice that many things oh I still don't think it's banned and I Josh trap it's not banned if it feels like it should be but no it's banned oh just just too big it looked like it should be banned time lock part too yeah it it maybe could be unbanned now it was banned quite a long time ago and games are faster now so maybe it's 15 is a lot yeah but you normally like if you if your only goal is to get to a lot of Mana you can you can do it right and take an extra turn I mean that just is brutal it means you play it and you are going to get one attack with it right never mind if you could give it t or something so it can't be countered yeah yeah all right the next one if you scroll down is to Fair's protection I feel like that's banned yeah I know I was leaning the same way it that in phasing out don't remember that they just go into like a different phase they just go over here and then they come back they don't technically leave like you if it said enters the battlefield you wouldn't get an enter Battlefield trigger but they're not there so if somebody cast a wrath of God and you phased out okay wouldn't get hit it's like phasing in Dungeons and Dragons whatever yeah so if you had if you did that phased all your
stuff out and then wrath the goded then that's a pretty good remember all your stuff is faded out so it's hard to do that because your lands are fased out oh right it's not impossible you can float the Mana first yeah I think it's banned yeah I still it still feels like there's a lot of room for some Brokenness to happen there I'd say banned too it is not banned okay we're not very good at this game no we're not you started out so strong okay we're going to we're going to nail the rest of these here all right the next one is getting into the Rock Paper Scissors losing thing out think just yeah was one step ahead it's always one step ahead I didn't think that hard about these guys this was what I was doing this morning just throwing some cards on there all right the next one is recurring nightmare that's not banned is it that's why it feels like it must be ah now we're all twisted up maybe it's banned what what um the only banned well I was say the only thing is that you get it back so it returns to your hand so you get to keep doing it which is nasty but however you have to sacrifice a creature you get it back and then you return a creature from your graveyard to the battlefield and you keep get to keep doing that with a casting cost of three I don't think it's I don't think it's banned how much can you possibly have in your graveyard okay I don't know I don't know I don't think it's Josh built a themed deck
around the graveyard at one point playing Josh magic is my recurring nightmare I don't think it's banned I would say it is Split Decision okay why do you think it's not banned I'm just GNA draw that means it's banned no no no no I'm gonna ask Craig the same question okay I guess I I don't see how it can kind of exponentially spin out of control at face value but I'm why do you think it's bned okay so dropping something big and pointing out pretty quickly and doing that twice like that feels pretty easy to drop some big creatures in your graveyard and quickly get them out for not much true but there's other ways of doing that made arguments about the strength of some pretty strong cards on here and then they've turned out to not be banned so I'm moving my needle a little that makes sense and saying it's not banned but I don't like Josh's countenance proba right I feel like it's a b what's your confidence level my confidence one one I'll go for two okay uh it is banned oh my goodness uh the thing is there are a lot of creatures that like create Mana when they come in so there's easy to get into like Loops where by bringing a creature back it creates the Mana to just keep recasting this and you can just do it forever bring everything back or there's creatures that oh every time this dies it deals five damage to everybody and you gain five life we'll just do if you can just keep cycling that thing and this allows you to to get into the cycle of like oh this so it is the recurring
part that makes it like the recurring makes the nightmare not not vice versa right okay all right field of the Dead the next card is field of the Dead okay anytime that does this enters the battlefield thing I was kind of a trigger because there's ways to game that where you can just bring it in a million times so could you cycle that Land once you get above seven or what is it you need anytime you play a land any land yeah if it's different than in the other lands you have then you'll make one and if you have some way to like get lands back into your hand and play them again then you're going to just that's hard to do well and you should know too that a big difference between when we played and now is there's a lot of lands so it's easy to fulfill the seven different names requirement it's pretty it's pretty trivial and you can do snow covered lands as some and those count as different ones um so if you wanted to build a deck and and you have 37 lands and they're all all different lands if it's two colors pretty easy it doesn't I don't know the mechanism but that feels like there's a hole for Brokenness there too I don't know what it is but I think there's something with that dropping land dropping land getting into an infinite Loop or a I mean that'd be it can you get into an infinite loop with that oh infinite Loop good word usage um he knows the terminology are are we going for band you demonstrate a loop they say when you demonstrate a combo yeah which I don't know that we had anything like that when we played that we ran into that uh there were probably some infinite Loops that existed I know there was cuz theault monolith with like um Power artifact or something will do it but we didn't know about them that I
recall that feels like it could be an infinite Loop infinite Loop trap let's ban it ban it banned not not bed we're on a real good streak here well you know I've been wanting to ban all these cards at this point I've realized I've been saying ban put Greg on the committee everybody okay all right one more to go it is profit of cruix we got to we got to nail this one and what is Flash instance speed cast anything in instance speed of cix does it sound like something they would ban well so this is only useful in like a multiplayer I mean not only it's more useful in a multiplayer setup where you are trying to protect yourself from more yeah like if you're playing commander and you're playing four people you get this every other time you get it three times yeah and and does that is there something there that is casting creature cards it means it's your turn you do something I'm like nope I'm going to block that cuz I cast my creature with flash and you get to keep on tapping B it brutal let's ban it let's get it out of here I just want to clarify you're not Banning the cards you're just saying whether they are or not yeah oh we don't have that power yeah sorry I'm not giving you that power look at the contracts and I'm going to I'm going to let this one go but maybe I should be I keep being wrong so I'm going to go with you no no no your gun your guns I got lucky I one out of five I was guessing I just want I just want to ban something so bad you want to B no I don't I have no desire to ban cards to be clear I say I don't want to get into any sort of a hornet nest oh you heard about
that no no no no not at all uh okay what do you think playable okay all right or BN we'll say legal it's banned all right this was no no surprise to anyone this was one of my favorite cards of all time until it was banned cuz it allows you to do anything at any time who wouldn't want to do anything at any anytime I think we've learned that Greg and I should not be consulted on what should be banned or not it's it's hard to tell what's banned and what's not especially I was just curious to get your perspective from like not having seen cars for years and years so thanks for playing along and uh thanks a ton for uh coming on the show it was really fun to talk to you guys about this thanks for having you our pleasure or mine anyway I don't know about you my pleasure as well okay great thank you yeah it's great I mean I I would say like it's been so important to me in my life and when I think back to all the fond memories I have like you guys are really prominent in them and I don't really remember I don't like you guys are in like a lot of my earliest memories running around the soccer field and playing the magic cards and running around with the camera and making movies like I did that with I wrote my first screenplay with Tai that's right uh we moved to LA together lived together on and off for the first five or six years here uh Greg was I made my first little movies with you um you know and we were running around by the river uh making our Indiana Jones movies or whatnot made our first feature film it was 90 minutes long we worked on all summer I think between sophomore and junior year um so I don't know it's crazy it's crazy I don't think I would be where I am today
without you guys so I just want to say thanks and uh hopefully I can pull you back into magic a little bit yeah I think so this is the first the first step in getting them back in yeah tricking them like I did at the magic like I did in the multiplayer games let's go play a couple well I can definitely say I would not be in the city or where I'm at without you and your influence in my life and I think that you know magic in particular just taught me how to think about games other games or just how to you know how to go about like you know strategizing or socializing the game and um yeah it was really it was really important really formative a lot of your what I recall from what I've I what I've gained from our friendship was partly around magic but all the other things we were doing that you were you you helped me learn how to argue and defend my point of view and because we went we were it was not it was not animosity it was friendship but we were like no no no this no no no this here's why so like really navigating that was something that for better or worse I took with me I think for better I think for better yeah we were talking about this at dinner the other night um the social aspect of magic and we did some other things that were sort of around that um but allowed for a lot of social experimentation when we were in our teenage years that I thought was really important to me in my later life just formatively about yeah being able to sort of test the water socially in different ways and then
games you know Game Theory doesn't form like governments use Game Theory to make decisions things like that so yeah magic really has that aspect of like if you if your brain can sort of make that translation sort of helping you navigate you know other parallel things that you encounter in life later on you know even not consciously and things like that so I think yeah gaming in general and magic in particular has been such a formative part of my life because of that so and discovering it together too like kind of discovering and figuring it out with it was again a different time period without the media that we can have access to now but it was a group project you know well it it gives you a language and a way to relate to someone else's intellect in a way that like Monopoly could never do and you know for us I think it was just a way to communicate and to like get to know how someone thinks and really get in there and like you know the nuts and bolts of their philosophy and you start to sort of see the patterns of what type of player they are what type of person they are um and it just gave us that that platform yeah so I think you know that's one of the great things about it still does that to that day I hope they're you know I like the idea that there's kids out there maybe listen to this now that are in the same position we were in back in '93 or '94 and uh going through the same things and who knows maybe someday you'll have a podcast and you get to sit back with your old friend who can barely see things in the front of their face anymore and talk about the good old days may we all be so lucky uh before we go I just want to talk about our sponsors one more time cardkingdom.com commmand is the best place to go to get your magic
product singles anything at all if you want to catch up on dusm or maybe get ahead on foundations or something like that card Kingdom has the huge inventory they're going to have the cards you want and the conditions you want and the versions you want and the great thing is they have super fast shipping and you add all that stuff to the cart you get it all in one convenient package all at once it's almost time for the holidays if you're looking for some gifts for some new friends or old friends maybe I'll get you guys some magic cards we like yeah a great way to get people back into magic that may been out for a while is get them some magic cards for Christmas or something like that so uh if you go to cardkingdom.com command that's the best place to go get all that stuff and of course once you get it you want to keep it protected you want to stay in in pristine condition you don't want to like Sharpie on your Li ey diamonds or anything like that so ultr Pro makes the game accessories that we trust our own collections to here at the command Zone if you go to ultrapro.com commmand you can find all kinds of cool deals that's one of the things I love about their website actually their newsletter is really really great because they'll email you about deals that they've got but you can often find like huge discounts on stuff and also they have like the Mana 8 product line which is really really beautiful if you want people to be like wow when they see your Battlefield ultrapro is the way to go again ultrapro.com commmand all right guys I wanted to say thanks one more time for uh being on the show hopefully uh we can maybe we can do this again you know not wait 25 years for the next one well we have to forget everything that we just talked about and play again learn to play again forget again stop and then we'll be back yeah I think we should sit down in these chairs when we're in our 70s and you haven't played still since the0 and just see what we remember even at that point I think I'm impressed you still remember
like casting costs of cards and things so I think you'll still you'll still remember in 20 years or so a lot of the art is a trigger for me too as we were talking I was like what does that one look like again I need the art yeah you can picture it in your head next time you can read us the quotes from the bottom of the cards and see if we can get those definitely memorize those I couldn't even do that yeah we play for I'm like I have no idea I don't know what that is all right uh big thanks to our whole team here at the command Zone uh let's see if I can remember everybody here that is let's go and order by room Sam Waldo Evan lindberger Jake Boss Manson lung Sebastian Salazar Josh Murphy uh Rachel Kendra Kina Cruz Rachel weeks I'm just going around the building Eric LM usually I've written this down um Jordan pigon Jamie block grov Gatti Eric LM Chris matista and and Jimmy Wong of course the ineffable all right thanks everybody for watching and we will see you next
time thank you for your attention for further inquiries send an email to command rocket jump.com or ask us on Twitter at jfwong and at Josh lequ see you later alligator greetings humans