Mosaic Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm taking a look at mosaic a story of civilization this is a two to six player SIV game designed by Glenn drover this one takes around two hours to play on average before I get started on my review of Mosaic I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go-to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so I've just finished a two player game here so this is what the game state is going to look like towards the end of a game so I'll just give you a quick tour of the play area and then we'll get into some thoughts so you can see here on the main board we have the map of kind of Europe and the surrounding areas here now some areas are going to be closed off depending on the player count so for example in a two-player game both these two areas are not in play and during the setup you're gonna have a bunch of these tokens randomly distributed on the board so these are going to be these different Traders which can relate to other actions in the game and you also have these tokens which will actually increase your production of certain things like for example this token would give you plus two food production as well as giving you a unique tray token and you also have these kind of cachet tokens here which will reveal when you end up building on them and they'll give you an instant bonus like in this example it will give you 15 money now as the game goes on you will be kind of I'm purchasing all these different cards and I have to say that this game does a fantastic job of you being able
to look at the game at a glance and see what all your available options are so despite some being quite an involved game and the actual breakdown of the actions you can take and what you can do is pretty straightforward so in the top left hand at the side of the board here we have the buildings that you can build so you have three different types of buildings you have these cities which can come in either the ports form or just the normal form you've got towns and you also have these projects now the projects will generally um act as a scoring mechanism so you can see here that for this Hospital I'd get one Victory point for every one of these symbols that I collected throughout the game at the end of the game you have these population cards here which will increase your population by cashing in food now your population will make you much more productive when it comes to producing Goods such as Stone food or ideas our ideas ideas allow you to buy Technologies which will increase your engine and your ability to do things and there's a ton of variation on what these can do like for example the agriculture one here will just increase your food production one that will kind of you know increase your tax production your climb all these different tracks you can do but there are a ton of different ones as well like for example ones I've collected here like this armor card which means that my military units cannot be eliminated so there is a lot of different things rather than just increasing your production to do things at the bottom of the board here you have the tax and tariff cards which will allow you to get more money basically however they will come with some unrest which will give you kind of negative points if you don't counteract that by doing other things and whenever you
build um either a town or a um sorry a city or a port city you'll end up putting these kind of taxes in this holding area which means when somebody else does use the tax or tariff action you will end up acquiring all of the money that's built up in that area as the game has progressed and some alternative actions are to build military units which will kind of add towards a bit of a an area majority thing when it comes to the different regions when you buy those units you are going to end up spending five for each unit you um you purchase and you'll put them on the different areas like for example you can see here in this kind of Italy area and I've invested in these military units my opponent has done these ones here and you can actually end up spending money to move them from border to border as well and you can invest in these new governments which will give you kind of them permanent powers or different kind of rule breaking things you can do and they'll generally cost you ideas and prerequisites of having the different symbols um and there's also a couple of different things which I didn't mention such as the Wonders so the Wonders um are quite expensive because they end up costing you well start off costing you 20 stone and five food of each additional one you build after that each one of those different categories increases by five but those wonders are really useful and you can see here that um throughout the game you've ended up building quite a few of these me personally ended up building quite a lot of these I've now do lots of different things such as giving you know pure victory points if you end up buying this pyramid um and different end game scoring criteria that this one says for the Sphinx I get four victory points for each Wonder in that region at The Great
Library which says I get five victory points plus two that every identical pillar symbols of your choice and those pillar symbols are these ones at the bottom of the cards here so not only do they synergize with a bunch of kind of different scoring cards like for example the ones I've collected here will say I get one Victor point for each of these Hammer symbols but um they will also be prerequisites to other cards you can see here in order for me to build this Plumbing card I would have needed a book symbol and one of these Hammer symbols let's look a bit further into my personal player area so this is my personal player board which will track my production of all the different things I can do so you're going to start with the bare minimum here but um your starting card is going to change that like in this game I had the farmer card which makes me a bit more productive when it comes to making food and it gives me a unique player power like for example this one says that when I buy a population card I get one additional population which is very useful because again they increase your production and it'll also allow you to well when you end up building cities you actually have to end up spending population which will obviously decrease your production going forward but will increase your presence um on the map so you've got your stone production you've got your food production you've got your ideas production and you also have your tax and tariffs at this area here will store all your unique Goods which again can be important and you can see here that as the game goes on you can end up acquiring quite a few cars this certainly is quite a sprawling game and these are all your additional resources such as your stone your ideas and your food here and additionally you can see these
different things I've collected throughout the game which are these kind of race objectives these civilization achievements which says you know if you are the first player to achieve 15 food production you'll get six victory points or if the first person gets six military units get six victory points Etc and there are quite a few of those as well and there are also these Golden Age cars which are another way to get victory points which will mean that you are racing to get to certain symbols so in this example I was the first person to get these uh six of these symbols which will give me more victory points and give you an instant bonus such as you know additional population and more production um you know free cities and Etc now one of the big ways to get points in the game is to try and control these regions and your influence in these regions is going to depend on a number of things and the first of which is your military units in those regions like you'll count one influence for each military unit you have but you'll also get influence based on the cities you've built in that region and the towns you've built in that region now cities can generally spawn anywhere but towns have to go off of where you have a city and when you build them and you end up building on top of these tokens you'll acquire uh those tokens so when those scoring trigger which will happen when um when these civil Empire scoring cards are revealed in each of these decks so in each of these different decks here the buildings uh you know the uh the Technologies the population and the tax and tariff deck once these cards are revealed the game will stop and then you'll do a quick scoring and calculating the influence in each of those regions the player with the most influence will score three
points plus a point for every city and wonder in that region and any runner-up will get two points so again there is quite a bit of fierce competition here and there will be additional cards and things which can increase your ability to harvest points through that area control part of the game now these Empire scoring cards will also act as one of the end game triggers because as soon as the third one is revealed that's going to basically again be the end of the game and you'll end up going into the end game scoring but an alternative way the game can end is when two out of three of the different tile types are going to be um you know gobbled up by the other players and that will include the um the Wonders the Golden Age tiles here or the public objectives these are civilization achievements so of course I have only scratched the surface with the game with that quick overview there um because there are a ton of things going on here this has the full feeling of a Civ game because there are so many cars and so many different things uh you can do but I want to go back to that fact that this game is so digestible because all the independent actions are really easily resolved and easy again easy to see what you can do at any time and I think that is a true Triumph how streamlined and digestible this game is because you can actually teach this game Ultra quickly I know you have one of eight actions you can do on your turn and they're all super simple are you going to produce your stone food or ideas are you going to buy one of those population cards are you going to build a building are you going to build a Wonder are you going to get a new technology by spending those ideas how are you going to tax or tariff
your you know the population are you going to buy military units or are you going to take a new government and even some of those options aren't used very often so that you're generally going to be kind of um buying um you know Technologies you're generally going to be buying new cities and things so you know a couple of those actions are the ones you're going to mainly use and I love it when games managed to truly streamline and cut back on anything that doesn't need to be there there is pretty much no rules minutiae or kind of fiddly rules exceptions in this game which is something I really look for um in gaming nowadays because this is kind of one of those games you were again despite getting that full Civ feeling you can kind of maybe even go for a year without playing this one and remember all the rules because again everything is in front of you and you know Civilization games are something I've always wanted to find my one I suppose um but they always tend to skew a little bit too heavy for me as in they are Ultra complex again tons of rules exceptions and fiddiness Etc or they are a bit too stripped back and a bit too almost abstract to the point where it doesn't really feel like a sieve game um so yeah this one actually is a really nice balance between the two where you can you get that full feel but still very simple to play and um you know definitely well developed and well ironed out one of this game's biggest strengths for sure is how quickly these actions are resolved because no matter what you choose before you know it it is your turn again and you know considering the magnitude of this game I think that is a real Triumph because normally games of this weight or this caliber will mean
that you just have to accept a certain degree of you know um AP or just you know waiting for other people to make the decisions on what they want to do and resolve their actions in the first place this one just does away with that which is quite remarkable and I think one of the biggest things about it is how good the forward momentum of this game is because you are constantly increasing your production and if you take one of those produce production actions you know especially towards the middle or end of the game you are completely showered in resources meaning that the world is your oyster ready you can do what you want to do and you don't have to spend all that time grinding towards making a big move you know if you really have your mindset on building one of the Wonders which are generally quite expensive you're not having to wait no six seven eight turns before you can achieve what you want to you can do a couple of production actions and then probably do what you want to do meaning that one of the kind of economies in this game is the action economy and not the resources themselves because you know every action you take is important which is just a really cool thing about this game is just how quick and snappy um everything is is resolved I truly love how this game doesn't have any rounds or phases to think about you really do just keep taking actions until one of those end game triggers um has happened and that means that means the flow of the game is fantastic you really do get immersed and you don't have to kind of have those tedious you know procedural moments so yeah I really love the way that works yes you do have to um stop every now and then only three times in the game to do one of those Empire scorings but that's a pivotal part of it and again very easy to resolve and before you know it you're back taking your actions I also love how
there are tons of ways to get points here you know are you going to really gun for the the Golden Age achievements the civilization achievement um are you going to build those wonders are you going to focus on those area control um points there are you going to build tons of cities because you are rewarded for doing that are you going to try and tailor towards the um the different technologies that will score you points or the projects are you going to try and build these farm towns which will give you points based on the trade goods you have so I love the kind of multiple paths to Victory here and everything seems balanced to me you know we had a game of this last night and we went very different paths to different things and I think it was about a point in it by the end of the game so yeah I love the way that you really do have a buffet of options at all times and all of them are viable and inviting let's quickly touch on the production of the game here so this is the retail version of the game there is a deluxe Kickstarter one which comes with Miniatures Etc I've not seen or played that one so I cannot testify with how good that one is this one itself though is very nicely produced I think everything is very clearly laid out um the actual symbology on the cards and the artwork is lovely um and yeah generally I'm happy with the way that you very seldom need to refer to the rulebook to find anything because it's also clearly labeled um on the cards now despite me generally being happy with the production there were a few issues we had um number one there is no scoreboard with the game which was quite a surprise to us because there is in-game scoring as well as end game scoring um so you're gonna have to write it down on a bit of paper or on an app or something which was quite
surprising Additionally you can see here that you can end up acquiring loads of cards which makes it quite difficult to monitor how many of each symbol that you have which can be important when it comes to things such as the um you know the Golden Age achievements it would be nice if there was a way that these cars could line up where you could see all the different symbols you have which is kind of a missed opportunity um for me a very small nitpick as well is that sometimes when calculating the regions it would be nice if you can just quickly glance and see how much influence each player has because it does become a bit you know mathematic and a bit procedural but counting all the different Pips and values and influence of all the different wonders towns and cities and military units Etc another thing that I'm not enthused about is the variable game length because during the setup these Empire scoring cards are you know semi-randomly shuffled into these decks at least you know the bottom end of these decks it means that sometimes those cards are going to be right at the bottom sometimes they're going to be towards the top or the bottom which can massively change how long the game takes you know maybe up to like 30 minutes or so so yeah it would be nice to have a bit more consistency and a bit more predictability about when the game is going to end rather than you know being completely subject to Randomness I suppose now that of course there is that second end game trigger as well which is when the tiles get I'm taken but even then sometimes there might be tiles here which nobody is really gunning for um which again might slow the game down especially if they're both um coming into play you know are there going to be
tiles that people don't want as well as the cars being in the bottom end of those decks so yeah I think maybe as a house rule going forward I might kind of um maybe take a few cars out or something just to guarantee the game is going to be a bit quicker now I don't want that to sound overly um overly negative because there is a lot of game here and generally games of this magnitude take longer than one and a half to two hours and just touching on that point a little bit more um during this last game that we had and because those cards were towards the bottom of so many of the decks it meant that I was kind of in this no man's land area for quite some time you know I was I thought I was in a strong position and was ready for the game to end however I could not find a way to do it so I just ended up kind of purchasing cards just for the sake of it and just to kind of um you know just farming cars that I knew would give me an extra point or two where it would have been nice if um you know the game would end when you still have a bit of purpose and still have some direction rather than just floundering there is a fair amount of player interaction in this game we've already talked about the air majority part of it and there are some military cards in this deck which can actively hurt other players but bearing in mind this is simple error majority and it's not destructive to the point where you know it's so take that ish if that makes sense and there is a massive urgency to get the cards that you want because if there's a great card up there you want to be beating your opponent to the punch and grabbing it which is of course is the case with a lot of drafting games and I also do like that race to get to the you know the different wonders the different achievements Etc again there is a sense of urgency that goes on throughout the entire game okay so let's share some final thoughts on Mosaic and
I have to say I am quite impressed especially when it comes to how finely engineered the game is everything in excess has been removed without sacrificing any of that sieve feeling this is definitely a sweet spot when it comes to what I'm looking for with this type of game I love how you can play the game without the game playing you you you can read the rules once and you're pretty much set for life because there are little if not no rules exceptions or any filliness or any kind of minutia that you need to remember it is all on the board in front of you at a glance you know the actual board itself has been so well designed where you've got all the costs and things on the board here you can monitor everything on your player board um Etc so yeah I love that you can pull this one off the shelf after a long break and still know exactly what you're doing without having to relearn it each time which is exactly what I'm looking for I'm really excited to see the different things you can find here because you have a ton of these technology cards you know you're not going to get through them all in one game yeah so there's just a ton of options at all times that action economy is fantastic you know how am I going to be most efficient and not waste any turns here because everything is in such high demand they're the best Technologies the best buildings um you know the population is scarce um you know the uh the racing to get the objectives and the ones you want so everything is a fierce um competition without feeling too nasty either you know even the level of area control what's an important part of the game it's not the be-all and end-all of the game and you can choose to kind of
forsake a part of this if you want to and focus on other things which is always great you know have a buffet of options and tons of different paths to Victory so yeah at the moment I really don't have much negative to say apart from those few little um issues when it comes to managing all your symbols and things because you do end up acquiring a ton of cards especially if the game goes on a little bit too long um but other than that I think the game is um is so well designed and I can certainly see why it's got some buzz and I think this one is going to actually have some legs because again those games that are I don't have much bloat that are pretty straightforward but still have that depth those are the ones that stand the test of time and I think that fans of Mosaic will still be saying the same thing in several years time so this one is definitely going to get a commendation for me and I think it might even be onwards and upwards for mosaic