Skip to main content
Loading video...

Palaces of Carrara Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 16:56

Hey everybody, today I'm talking about the Palaces of Carrara. Now this is a 2012 release board game by Wolfgang Kramer and Michael Kiesling. The game takes about an hour to play on average and accommodates two to four players. Now the idea of the game is that you are trying to collect different quality marble to build different buildings in different cities and eventually score those buildings and cities to score victory points and to try and beat your opponent and win the game. So Kramer and Kiesling are very prolific designers critically acclaimed in pretty much every fashion made absolutely just blockbuster hit games. And this one maybe is one that's flown a bit under the radar compared to some of the others, but I think a big portion of that is that the game isn't widely available in England or the US. So you know the most copies you'd find in this game are generally in German which is actually the version I have because again I couldn't find the English version, but the game is you know 99% language dependent or independent even.

So you don't actually need the English rules once you know them and you know there's very little text on the components. So you know you can get by on the iconography and stuff like that. Now as I said the game is a Euro style game probably a a medium lightweight game not overly complex, but it still does have a lot of decisions going into it. And those decisions are built or kind of condensed down to three very simple choices you have to make each turn. You know Kramer and Kiesling are very good at boiling down um you know generally quite involved games into very simple decisions and this game does that very well. So the first decision you can make is to collect marble. And the way you collect marble is very clever. It's basically done on this wheel bit of kind of divided into these different kind of quadrants and each of those different sections of that wheel is going to have a different price allocated to each brick type because there are six different qualities of marble that you can collect the black being the worst quality going to blue to green to red to yellow white being the most you know the the most prestigious type of of marble you can have.

And basically what you're going to do is you're going to either choose to pay the prices of the marble already on the wheel or you can rotate the wheel and pay the new prices because every time you rotate the all the the values of each brick goes down by down by one eventually making some of the bricks free. And every time you can build you can basically buy as many marbles you like from one of those different sections. And but also you obviously got to be careful because when you buy and make things cheaper you're also making things cheaper for your opponent. So you got to kind of weigh that decision up in your mind whether you're going to pay the prices as they are or rotate to make them cheaper not only for yourself but for your opponent as well. And the quality of that marble is very important because they that marble is going to kind of determine which of your cities you can build buildings in. Because like the marble with the six different quality types there's also six different cities you can build in.

Again the white being the most prestigious and the black being the you know the least prestigious. And the the difference between the two is that the multipliers of those cities are very different because if you choose to score a white city for example for every one of your buildings you've got in there you're going to get the amount of brick you paid times a higher multiplier than the lower cities. So for example the highest the highest city is going to cost you obviously the more expensive brick the white the white marble, but you're going to get a times three multiplier but whereas if you're just buying the in the black city you're going to get a times one multiplier. So the difference is quite significant. And now that doesn't mean that you have to play exclusively a certain type of brick to to build a certain city because the way it actually works is you you can build in a city with your lowest quality type of brick that you've collected. So say I had you know two white bricks a yellow brick and a blue brick because the blue brick is the cheapest of the type of marble I've used then I could only build in a blue city.

So that's basically the first action. The second action is I've pretty much covered is when you actually buy a city itself. So again you get to cash in that those types of bricks and collect a city and I think the city so the buildings even and there's a number of different types of buildings. I think there's six different types. So you got your like your libraries, you've got I think you've got like your barracks and stuff like that. And you're going to cash in the bricks and take one of these buildings off the board and place it in the the relative city. But when you place it you're not going to score anything immediately because the third action you can take is to actually score something. And what you can score is you can again you can score any of those city types and say I wanted to score the I don't know the black city. I would take all the all the buildings I've built of that type or in that city.

I'm going to use the amount of bricks of I've spent times the the multiplier of that city. So as I said for the black city you're going to score times one and then you're going to get that many victory points. But three of the cities that you can build in are actually based on cash because cash is quite obviously a very important resource in the game because you need them to acquire more more marble because the marble is is what you're going to need to get your points. So you're going to score multipliers based on coins in some of the cities but some obviously you're going to score times on points. So not only can you score the different types of cities which means you actually lock your opponents out of scoring those cities because only one thing can be scored or any one city can be scored or each type of city can only be scored once between all the players. So there's a bit of a tug of war there as well a bit of a a bit of a push your luck aspect or kind of a chicken aspect because if you're both building up on on white cities for example you can choose to score that city and then completely shut your opponent out of scoring it at all which can be pretty devastating.

But as I said not only can you score cities you can actually score different building types. So you could say say I had a a library built in the white city a library built in the black city a library built in the yellow city then I can choose to score all of my libraries and score all the multipliers that way as well. So even though you might actually lose your opportunity of scoring a city type you can still you know get some you know use out of it and still get some return out of those building types. And the um the game or the the end of the game is triggered on a number of things because there are huge stack of cards or different scoring cards that you can use. And there's going to be basically three different criteria that you're going to have to meet or or meet the requirements of to trigger the end of the game.

So the first one is based on or normally based on kind of money or something like that. The second one is built based on the different building types because when you cash when you kind of score one of your things you're going to reap the rewards of obviously not only the points and stuff but every building type has a kind of like a a little wooden token assigned to it and then you're going to basically try and collect different types. So it might say maybe collect three different pairs or you know three sets of unique tokens or something like that and that's going to be one of the trigger types and also you're going to score end game points based on that as well. And the third type is basically based on the building. So it might say have I don't know three cities with two buildings in or two cities with three buildings in. And again you're going to score more end game points based on that criteria.

There's also an additional criteria as well that you can choose to add in or not. Now before I go any further actually I should say that the the game does come with basically two variants. There's the basic mode and the advanced mode and the game does suggest that you initially play the game on the basic mode and ignore all the advanced stuff because it comes in a basically sealed envelope. But personally I would recommend going straight into the advanced mode because there's a bit more a little bit more you know meat on the bones to the game with that because again you can add so much more variability with all the different setups and different end game criteria. And you can also you know build eight level buildings which normally they only go up to five. So you can cash in eight bricks of a type and get these really powerful buildings obviously because they're going to amplify your multipliers, but you also get a bonus tile as well that you can assign to your player board which you know increases the multipliers that you get from cashing in or or using one of your scoring opportunities.

So I should say you only get score six six scoring tokens or scoring markers throughout the game. So you're going to be very careful about when you're going to use them and how you're going to use them. And you're going to be very careful about not being caught off guard as well because a lot of the bricks and stuff or your bricks and your tokens are kept behind a shield. So you don't really know how well your opponent's doing in terms of the end game triggering. So it's very easy for maybe someone to try and rush the game a lot quicker than you are planning on to and just before you know it you can completely annihilated you on points and actually ended the game before you actually had a chance to do anything. And that pacing is something very unique to this game. You know normally games are divided into rounds or you know have a certain amount of turns or something like that, but this one doesn't work like that at all.

It's basically as soon as those end game criteria are met and the person chooses to trigger that end of the game then the game is going to be over at the end of that round. And that could be you know very hugely on game to from game to game because some of those end game criteria are very kind of quite easy to achieve and some are a lot harder which means it will obviously be a longer game. But yeah it's it has a very interesting pacing to it and I love the way that it's boiled down to these very simple decisions. You know take bricks, take take a city or so take take a building type or cash in something or score something which is really really cool. So I do I do love the you know the mechanisms of the game. I love that. The the resource wheel is absolutely genius. I I love that. Just weighing up about, you know, is it worth it making cheaper making things cheaper for your opponent in order to get things cheaper for myself. You know, you'll run out of money very quickly, so you're going to have to, you know, at least focus on one of those scoring one of those cities focusing on coins because, you know, halfway through the game you're going to run out of funds and you're going to need to score one of those cities to get a bunch of coins to continue keep you going in the game and to keep you involved. Balance of the game is is you know, it's wonderfully balanced, but again, something you have to be very careful of is being caught off guard.

And um the way that the scoring works makes the scoring seem very swingy because obviously if someone's cashing in a city type and they've got loads of buildings there and the scoring at times three multiplier, they can they can get like 30 points in one turn where you've got nothing and they might score again and again and again and they might even go around the board a whole time before you've scored anything. But that's something really got to be aware of and once you've kind of played the game once, you can kind of twice, you can get your head around how that works and you've got to really focus on what your opponent's doing because it is extremely relevant and you can't just be in your own bubble in this one. So that level of interaction is very nice. Um Mechanically very simple, very very works very well. Balance is excellent. The decisions boiled into very simple concise decisions but are still really interesting. Um time investment is fantastic. I mean a game like this to take an hour at the most is is really good.

Um I I kind of like the pacing of as I said, the there's not really any downtime to the game at all because again, very simple straightforward actions that have no housekeeping involved to it. There's no fiddliness or anything like that, which is excellent. And replayability wise as well, again obviously include the advanced modules which give you all the different cards to change the different setups. Um yeah, the replayability is is excellent because there's so many different end game criterias. You know, the variability is you know, limitless really. Um And again, player interaction as I said, very very nice. Just that tension between the two. When you're going to score things, are you going to score things before your opponent does?

You know, do you want to get one of those eight buildings so that you can score the better multiplier? Um and stuff like that. So there's a good tension in the game and you know, the interaction is good for a Euro like this that doesn't really have any direct confrontation. So there's still a good amount of interaction there. Aesthetically, I do like the way the game looks. It's very clean, very bright, very kind of pleasing to the eye. But it's very simple. There's not like amazing artwork or anything like like it, but it's very clear and very pleasant. So no complaints there at all. And also component quality as well. The wheel works as it should, nice and smooth. There's no everything works as it should. The shields are very nice. They look like big kind of palaces. All the different colored bricks are very clear to differentiate. I know for someone who's colorblind, I can very clearly differentiate them all. The buildings all look, you know, different.

The different wooden tokens are good. So yeah, there's there's no complaints at all in terms of its component quality. And again, theme wise, you know, it's it's a very generic Euro style game where you're collecting bricks to to build buildings and score cities, you know, as you'd expect. There's not a lot of theme here, but it does work fine. And set up and set down time as well is actually really really good because um again, just give the cards a shuffle, do the layout and just all the the game comes with a you know, an opaque bag with all the different bricks in. So you just have to kind of draw you know, X amount and put it on the board and you're good to go really. So there's not really much set up at all. Um the progression of the game is quite nice because you can actually choose to upgrade your buildings by say I say I built a building worth five and but obviously there's the eight buildings available. You can choose to kind of pay the difference to to swap that five for the eight. So that's quite nice, you know, towards the end of the game you get better multipliers and stuff like that. So progression is quite nice. Um I love the way you've got to be a bit thrifty with your money and stuff like that as well.

Um and scalability as well, it works it works really well. I mean, depending on you know, at two players it works fine and at four players it still works absolutely fine. So no issues with scalability. And you know, something I bang on about quite a lot is games that are unique and to me there's not really anything like Carrara or Palaces of Carrara out on the market. It's very different and there's nothing in my collection that is quite like it. So you know, uniqueness is huge to me. You don't want just another generic, you know, worker placement game or anything like that. You want something that's unique and Carrara is certainly that. So yeah, overall this is a really nice game by Kramer and Kiesling. I do really enjoy it and I'm looking forward to playing it many more times. Again, I always bang on about how well these guys do at just simplifying you know, the the choices of a pretty you know, a pretty deep game because there are a lot of things to choose, you know, you know, are you going to score a certain type of building? Are you going to score the cities? Are you going to score all the all the cities that have a certain type of brick cost?

And these are all really important decisions, but again, you're only going to make one of those three simple decisions. Take bricks, take a building or score or score something, which is just absolutely brilliant and it's so easy to teach and digest and this one is very kind of you know, there's a very low barrier to entry to introduce this to new players and it's a great introductory game for kind of someone who's kind of interested in trying Euro games but find more complex games a bit more daunting. So again, this one is very light light medium weight and you know, it's certainly not overwhelming but still has enough going on to going on in it to satisfy you know, more saltier gamers and and I you know, that's something that's not easy to achieve. So definitely check this one out if you want something of that weight, something to introduce someone to but still has enough going on in it.

Again, unique, it's fun, it's fast, um loads of replayability in it. The resource market wheel is excellent and it's just good fun. Beware that obviously you're going to have to probably buy the German version of the game and also that probably in the first few games you're going to have a unanimous winner who's going to absolutely crush you or you're going to crush them because of the way the pacing of the game works and you can really be caught off guard. But that's all part of the charm of the game and I do really enjoy it. It gets a very good rating from me. I've put it at 7.8, so just missing that mark of excellence, but who knows with more plays, I could um you know, take it up a bracket. So that is the Palaces of Carrara. Definitely check this little little game out. So it's it's really enjoyable. I hope you've enjoyed this review. If you have, please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos, too. You can also follow me on Instagram and support me on Patreon. I'll put the links below. For everything else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.

Progress saved