Treasure Island: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlock. And Dev and I are doing a discussion over Treasure Island, uh, a game by
I don't have daddy issues the game. What?
I mean, isn't the book is it like all daddy issues?
I have literally never read the book.
Oh, I did way back when.
Um, is it when you had daddy issues?
It's when I had daddy issues. No, my daddy's president or was. He's dead now.
Oh, you're just like,
uh, Treasure Island.
Anyway, yes, we're talking about board games.
Yeah. Not not existential cra you're about to trauma dump on me. Um, so Treasure Island is a extremely intriguing game because it's the only game that I can think of that has that is entirely done in a sense of dry erase exploration. Um, that is kind of a one verse many semi-ooperative um, nature.
Yeah.
Which just completely sounds like it shouldn't work. And while the semi-ooperative nature I say doesn't really work um a whole lot, um the one verse many certainly does. And I I know that there's people out there who do have issues with this game because of the vagueness of the like the pinpoint accuracy that you might have to have. But um I think if you go into it just kind of not trying to be a dick of like oh no that's tech that's not in the circle like it's touching no uh you're going to have a lot of fun. And while I don't think this game is insanely balanced in in the competitive aspect, I think it is unique and fun enough to actually have a great time. So Devin, what do you think of Treasure Island?
Oh man. Uh, let's see here. So, yeah, I played in a group of four. Um, see here, Seth was the what was your character's name?
Long John Silver.
Long John Silver. And so, he's the one and I was part of the many. Uh, it was a lot of fun. We
had a great old time.
Yeah.
Um, yeah. Really, really unique game. Essentially, you're like given hints.
Yes.
Um, and then we with our own little personal maps are trying to figure out specifically um where you buried your treasure. Yeah.
Yeah. It kind of has a a hidden not necessarily hidden movement element, but a hidden element where the the Long John Silver character picks virtually any spot to mark on his map like, "Oh, I put it right there."
Uhhuh.
Um, and obviously it's not on the main board, but it's on your personal board and you just know where that's at. Uh now again that kind of can be vague because it's like oh what if you search in the circle and it touches the edge of that of that square like what if I just do a dot
you know it's
it's that's kind of where the the vagueness of the game can come in. But yeah, you just pick a spot where the treasure goes and everyone else is maneuvering around. But what makes this game interesting is the Long John Silver player has these clues. He has a hand of clues that he has to give out that kind of points everyone in the direction of the uh of the treasure.
Mhm.
And maybe I'm just bad at the game. Um but it definitely feels like there's a couple things I have issues with as being long. It feels like there's not a whole lot Long John Silver can do in the long time span it takes for the players to figure out where it's at.
Mhm. No, it seems like we really zeroed in on Especially if the players are sharing information.
They're going to get it in no time.
Exactly.
Yeah. If if the players choose to work together, I mean, obviously then it's kind of a crapshoot by the end.
Yeah.
Um who's going to win, but you know who's not going to win?
The single player. If Yeah, exactly.
And that's kind of what it comes. It's kind of weird that it's like, well, only one of you can win. So, you want you they should be competitive, but they're why would why would they?
I mean, yeah, eventually it's like I don't know. I mean, I guess if we really just stuck to our own information, it would be a lot harder.
Um, but then at the same time, it's like, okay, you want some of their information, maybe they want some of your information, you can trade them. Mhm.
Um, so you can also lie. Your single character can
only twice though.
You can only lie a limited number of times which can be verified with a unique player ability,
right?
Um, to see if that is a lie or not.
Yeah. Yeah. I mean, the players do have a limited amount of actions that they can do. And I actually like the fact that um the Long John Silver player is the only thing he does throughout the game is play a a a hint card and everyone else only gets a certain number of turns and you kind of hopcotch where it's like, "Oh, okay. It's orange this time. Now green's going to go. Now red's going to go. Now blue's going to go." And then then like So you only get what is that four 16? You get four turns pretty much for per player. I mean, you get a few more actions partway through. Once we get to this point, then we get two actions,
right?
But yeah, it's just one action the first go, which is essentially you get a move and maybe a small search or take a large search or you can move six miles.
Yeah, it's even including the unique abilities.
Yeah. Everyone has that's just insanely powerful. M.
So I I don't know cuz like the vibe I get when I'm playing this game, funny enough, is like Letters from White Chapel
is where the cops are trying to work together to figure out where um Jack's hideout is.
Mhm.
And but that's fully cooperative. A fully cooperative one versus many. It's not like the cops are like trying to be rogue cops and you know who glory
and be the one who who gets him. They're actively trying to work together and strategize and go over and and you're not doing that, but you're kind of doing that. So, at least as Jack, I have ways to throw you off my trail.
It's me on the timer um running around trying to get there.
So, it's kind of rolls reversed from this to that. But I mean, I'm kind of dealt long John Silver's turn or his strategy is made or broken by this the hints that he's drawn
where it's like there are times where I've played this where I'm looking at him and I'm like,
there's no way I'm not going to get it.
Yeah. Like there this is so obvious and I can't lie anymore. So, what can I do to try and throw them off? And I know the last game we played is I really tried to get them to think it was where you were at. So, everything I was doing was trying to point that you were on the right path.
No one bit on it. And it's like, all right, let me just tell you where it's at, you know?
Yeah. I would definitely, if playing this game again, I would definitely preface trying to I don't know, a little less cooperation. Yeah.
Um because like I mean everyone obviously wants to win
but at the same time it's like I don't know
having that what having the fact that like I'm also a competitor where it's like if you guys don't win then I escape and I know exactly where the treasure is at. So then it's like now you guys want to work together because if I escape then I'm going to win,
right? Um, so, so yeah, it's like this game is extremely unique, but it has major flaws, but it's still fun.
Mhm.
Um, but I don't see I don't see a game where Long John Silver wins, you know? It's it you guys have too many actions and you have too long
to figure it out because there's only a finite number of spaces whenever you're you know whenever you pull out a uh what is it when you pull out a disc and you cover a decent section of the map and it's like is it anywhere in there? No. Okay, then I'll move over here and do that. It's like that's a decent amount. And if you're the other character who can do the uh the outside of the board uh or the outside of the ring, then it's like geez. Like yeah, it took your whole action to search there. But if everyone's doing that, someone's going to quickly find it. Hell, I don't even need to give you guys the
the hints.
Um so I don't know. I don't know because I think I think Chris had some pretty good ideas on
Yeah, he had the best information. Um I mean he but he shared it. That was his mistake,
right?
Um because like he already really had the information that I had
and I was like offering to trade but no he already kind of had the bead,
right?
Yeah. And I mean what's really funny is the way the where I put the um where I put the treasure is the like in the same exact where like yeah I think it was over there in the same exact direction that um one of the other players he just went straight towards it and uh he like searched one tiny spot wasn't quite near it and then he kind
here wasn't it
yes he kind of went over there searched a little bit and I was like is he about to just find it immediately and he didn't and he kind of backtracked and I was like, man, yeah, like what? I I just wish that the Long John Silver player had a little bit more ways to get people off of of his ass or off his treasur's ass.
Mhm. Um because normally in these types of games, uh you have like a balancing aspect where it's like, oh, if you're seeing that the one player that Long John Silver or Jack the Ripper is winning too much, give the players these um you know, these benefits. Or if the players are winning too much, give the one player this. This doesn't really have anything like that.
And I imagine I don't know if this game really took off all that much. Um, Treasure Island Island. This game came out in 2018. Yeah. 7.2. Uh, which nowadays is bad to a lot of people.
Uh, if a game comes out and it's not immediately an 8.5 or nine, it's pretty much garbage. Um,
no, this was I mean, again, it was fun. It was a blast. I had a good time playing this game.
Yeah. And I mean, don't get me wrong, the there are ways like there have been times whenever I'm playing this game and I'm like, "Yep, that's where I messed up." That hint that I gave is probably what did me in. And that I always enjoy whenever I can go back and think, "Oh, okay. That's where I made the mistake versus trying to do."
Oh, it was definitely when you used that one compass that nullified two whole directions. That's true. After we just got like a pretty big hint. It was uh well no it was um cuz Chris had a compass that he he looked at and then I think I played a hint cuz I forgot what I had given to him.
Mhm.
So I was like so it basically cut
Yeah. cut it cut the whole map out except for one cone.
Right.
And we had that information and then shared it and it's like okay yeah we're all belining here.
Right. Exactly. Which again it's like they're really there's like you shouldn't be able to share that. you shouldn't be able to cooperate because it just just doesn't make any sense for you guys to share information. Even thematically, it doesn't make any sense cuz it's like you guys want my treasure. You're not there's no honor amongst thieves, so why are you guys working together?
Yeah. Uh, and yeah, so there are definitely pinpoints of like like areas of of um expertise for the one player. But even then, it's like you guys were honing in on it well before that even happened. And it's like that was by round seven.
Mhm.
It's like, okay, now everyone gets two actions from here on out. And the clues I have to give are even more specific. So yeah, I I don't know. I think I think this game could have cooked a little bit more. I think they could have really had something amazing. Um at least ways like maybe an expansion or something to kind of balance it out, give both sides like four or five different uh um modules
to to even it out.
But alas, they didn't. It's still unique though. I think it is kind of a a fun fun quirky game.
I don't know. I can play this Yeah. several rounds and have a good time the whole time.
It's one of those games that I could probably play repeatedly.
Really?
Mhm.
Um well, with that, uh on a scale of 1 to 10, what are you giving Treasure Island?
Uh perfect.
Perfect 10.
Uh I will give it
I do think the markers suck. Uh they are impossible to see on the on the actual thing.
I got an eight.
An eight.
An eight. I was very happy with it.
Yeah. Um I seems to be kind of the little running theme today, but um I'm slightly lower. Um
slightly.
I'm at a seven though. I think this game is good. Uh I I do enjoy I do enjoy both sides. Um, but man, yeah, the way this game plays and the the the uniqueness of it, it's like this this really could have been like a nine
if they if they had nailed home um like some key aspects of a game like this. Uh, so it it leaves me wanting more, but I'm I'm not going to get it. But there aren't many like treasure hunting kind of games. Uh, I know there's there's another game called I think it was called Tobago that we might have played years and years ago. Um, but it eventually the game slowly releases like logical information that you just kind of will over time narrow down where it's at. Then it's kind of like once all the information is released, it's kind of a race to get it. So, it kind of works like this in the sense that the game is providing the information and everyone is searching.
So, take out Long John Silver and that's the game and all the other players are doing what you guys are doing to try to figure out where it's at. Um, but again, I don't think that game did all that well.
Um, but anyway, you got anything else?
No.
Yeah. All right. Well, that's our thoughts on Treasure Island. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.