Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Stifling Dark: Discussion

Transcript 32:46

thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion for the stifling dark uh this was a game that was sent to me as a prototype and you know their Kickstarter was live and I think late uh Lake pledges are still available but uh yeah they took quite some time getting this to me um so yeah obviously I'm doing this review well past their Kickstarter time but I think you can still late pledge if this game interests you at all a little history on this game is actually last year so in 2022 at Gen Con they were kind of uh showcasing this they didn't have like any demos or anything but they kind of had well I assumed to be this kind of copy out for display so you can kind of see a little bit of what it was and it's a hidden movement game kind of in the sense of uh dead by daylight it but not made weird like level 99 did dead by daylight uh it has that Vibe so you're a bunch of like teenagers or the Scooby-Doo gang that are at various locations and you're being chased by some type of killer and the goal of the teenagers is to find evidence of the person that's chasing them and get out of the location and the point of the Killer is to I mean well kill someone and but this is actually a

little bit different so hidden movement games lately for me have kind of been you know a lot of Misses like the ones that have come out of late just haven't really worked for me uh ones I've played recently is um last Friday you know didn't really work a whole lot uh mind management I don't really care for and then uh Sniper Elite also don't really care for not because I think that they're bad but mainly because there's the hidden movement mechanic or genre it's like well there's like three or four that I really like and so if the new ones are coming you know that they're out aren't as good as those well then I'll just play the hidden movement games I like stifling dark surprisingly did not give me that same feeling there was there's something here and of course what they sent me is a bunch of prototype stuff so like it looks almost complete but like for example the rule book they sent me was just paper and this is of course nothing against the the company I'm not sitting here like well this game sucks because they couldn't give me a rule book uh but like it it was rough it was kind of rough to play an experience because the like the rule book isn't you know super amazing but they do mention that hey this is a very much a rough draft and their plan is to do three separate rule books you know you because what's cool about this game is instead of it being like a map like

letters from Whitechapel is just London Fury of Dracula is just Europe and they plan on doing separate locations and the one that I got to try was in like a sawmill and I think this is really really neat because there's not a lot of hidden booming games that are scenario based or not really scenario based but more of like oh let's pick this killer and this location and and try and see how that works together because in the Prototype you get the Sawmill as a location and then you get oh what is his name it is let me just be that weirdo teacher that licks their finger every time they touch a page and the and the Strangler the butcher is his name so not only are you going to get different locations you're gonna get different killers and different you know teenagers like that the players the many can play and I think that's really neat and what's also kind of cool is my initial thought was that this was gonna be like dead by daylight like I said where it's just the the many are trying to just run away and Escape uh and the Killer is trying to kill them and that's not actually uh the case here to me it comes uh a lot closer to uh the video game phasmaphobia which if you haven't played that that's like a ghost hunting game at least based off The Sawmill and the butcher that's kind of the vibe that

I got was that since they're trying to collect evidence they're trying to go in and be like okay here's evidence here here's evidence here we got enough and now we can we need to figure out our way of leaving so in The Sawmill one or at least the Prototype I got after the investigators gathered enough evidence they had to either choose whether they wanted to fix the truck um it was fix the truck fight the adversary so like actually try and try and defeat him or power the gate and that's how they were trying to escape so uh so there's there's definitely something here at least based off premise alone there is a really really good idea and I'm not raving about this game yet because again this was a very rough prototype so I we basically when when we played it we got the gist really and I'm really excited because I did back this game so I'm excited on where it's going like a lot of times when I play a game that I backed and it's like oh [ __ ] this is gonna suck uh hey maybe it'll be better when I have my own copy or I don't even get to demo it and it comes in I'm like oh this sucked uh luckily playing the Prototype even after backing it I was like okay cool this needs to be finalized this needs to be flushed out a little bit uh because there's there's bones here it just needs to be tightened

right now it feels like there's a lot of stuff that's still left to open because for example and again the rule book is you know whatever they printed it off for me uh it's supposed to be three different Rule books location what they say it's supposed to be yeah uh adversary investigators and scenario because all those matter what the investigators are doing how how the adversary plays and uh what the rules are for the scenario in this case it's like whoa hey what what do these things for The Sawmill uh but in in my my playthrough of that there was kind of a lot of what because in in this there's different buildings five different buildings garage Kiln Sawmill Lumber shed and the office and the investigators from the rule book said they start out with evidence and I felt that that was kind of weird um because there's a starting location on the board that's where all the investigators start and then the adversary can start in specific spots on this map and in the rule book it was like oh the investigators get to choose where where they get to basically get the evidence from so they chose the top two buildings well of course you would choose that because why wouldn't you so they had no reason to ever come up here uh because like they just need the evidence yeah and you can I mean you can find items and stuff that will be super beneficial

but yeah they just had to run to the office and run to the Sawmill and run to the garage and then after they got all that they were able to figure out in which way do they want to try and win the game so they have to roam around gather items and evidence and then it's like okay well we can probably fix the truck that seems the easiest one because we got this item that says we it's easier to fix the truck for us and there's almost two phases to this game and I think the first phase it almost seems like it wants to be in the investigators favor and the second phase wants to be in the adversary's favor because the first phase of the game of course since I read the rules and I knew the game the most I was the one running the adversary and the first half feels like you are just kind of hindering the investigators they have a lot of power you can't really do a whole lot against them until the second half where because you just have no ultimate control like it was very easy for the investigators to do a lot of stuff and then it's like oh boom they got all the evidence they want to fix the truck oh in that in that scenario I know where the pieces are so I can start trying to attack them and that's how you win that's how the adversary wins is they had to kill one investigator uh but overall I think that this game has a lot of legs to it and I haven't even named what the the biggest gimmick of this is which is the only reason I even looked at it at Gen Con

and it's called the stifling dark because everything is in the dark you have to play this game in the dark because this is glow in the dark that's not true none of that is true it is in the dark and the investigators this is this is a gimmick for a game that I think is fantastic I think it works really really well probably could be fine-tuned a little bit but I think at least for the Prototype they did they did a pretty good job um because they should if that's like their whole stick they have these flashlight tokens uh or these clear flashlight things because the spaces on the board are either bright dim or pitch black and Pitch Black uh it costs investigators two extra movement to go into and a lot of spaces Are Pitch Black unless an investigator shines their flashlight in an area and there's lines on these that kind of give you a line of sight reference oh okay I want to look at spot 125 the line is touching 125 back to my base and therefore I can see it it's not being obstructed by any building or anything like that this is super super cool like it really brings in the atmosphere of showing up to this location trying to look for investigation and or look for evidence and you're like running around the semi truck and then I mean your batteries have energy so you have to spend that to

shine your light so to see if you can see anything and when that scene then uh like if the adversaries there he basically kind of gets stunned and has to like Escape um if there's any items there that's how those get seen and picked up and dealt with it is very very cool and the adversary has ways to kind of hinder that they have abilities they can choose that's like oh using flashlight costs two energy this round and you can kind of strategize and look at what the other players have it's like oh you all only have one guess they're not using your flashlights let's turn because the flashlights are very powerful that's how the players get to see stuff that's how they turn pitch black rooms into bright rooms like The Sawmill is completely pitch black and it if you're spending all your energy running it's like okay well now you're exhausted and you can't run as much but another investigator shows up shines his flashlight shines a lot of the spots in The Sawmill now other players can run through there because they can now see it is very very cool and again gives really high phasma phobia Vibes uh just because if you're not able to see anything but like the the butcher has like his main stick is like he stalks then he gets off on like giving players that like I'm I feel like I'm being watched feeling and that's how he does a lot of his abilities because he gets a little track

it's like okay I'm gonna give you guys you know this condition that lets you know you're being watched and then I'll spend that to do my attack or something so it uh it works really well um and that's honestly one of the biggest things that Drew me to this game so and I also like the fact that the the players can't just keep their flat like that their flashlights go out at the end of the round they don't go out but they the the tokens don't stay so they have to consciously make decisions to use it or not use it if they don't use it then they regain an energy at the end of their turn um same with their stamina like they can spend stamina to kind of like to you know Sprint but they're limited on that too so if they really do that a lot then they're going to start taking damage and wounds are very difficult they do kind of a uh Mansions of Madness thing where you get face down wounds and it's like okay that could be that's just nothing but you can get face up wounds and face up wounds have an effect but they also might give you a condition in the condition you have to deal with before you can even turn the wound face down and this I really liked I thought that was that was pretty cool because it was very thematic like so for example you could get a well let's find one that actually has oh here we go disoriented you may not

use your major or minor ability and then this has a condition icon on it so they randomly draw a condition and this one says Darkness on your next activation you may not use your flashlight so to get rid of disoriented you have to basically follow the condition and then disoriented goes away I think that's really cool that gives an extra element of fear and I think that's what this game kind of evokes quite well if you really want to get into the headspace um that of like okay we're in this creepy ass Sawmill being hunted uh by we're pretty sure some dude with a hook that just wants to kill us and it it it's definitely on the right track and like I said I'm not like super raving about it because there was there was a point like I said in the beginning where as the investigator or as the adversary I'm like how the hell do I win because the the players can go back and forth they can do whatever they want like uh I mean okay we're gonna have you run we're gonna have you do this we're gonna do this and do we even do as many actions as we want until we all decide to stop but the adversary doesn't really get that like he just can kind of like he has really fast movement at least in the case of the butcher he can break a door and he might be able to use an ability and that's almost like the problem I feel like sometimes with hidden movement games is they take the perfect knowledge

that the hidden one gets is like oh I'm hidden so that's such a benefit therefore the investigators get to do anything they want and I see the idea there that definitely makes sense but it doesn't feel good when you're the one it's like yeah because there are a lot of times when I was playing this as the adversary I'm like yeah cool you guys get to do all that yep you found all the evidence you don't even have to come up here why did I even play some uh like I guess I'll just dick around in the dark for a little bit and kind of spook you and oh you found okay you found all the evidence neat and but then when they did find it and they chose because you get they get to pick it's kind of like oh we got all the evidence here are your three objectives you can either fight me fix the truck or power the gate they had an Evidence card they made it way easier for them to fix the truck so that's of course the one they went with but then that put like okay they need to find a battery a spark plug the keys and they're on these very specific locations so now I know what they're trying to go for and then it kind of flipped it on me or flipped the game to now it's in my favor and and then like the last game I played then it's like okay I won um because I kind of had the Disney Advantage now being hidden and knowing exactly where you guys have to go that

is huge so I'm not saying it's unbalanced it's just it gives a little different some different feeling uh from the players where it's like oh yeah it's all about us oh now we don't get to do anything so it's kind of like all right yeah I mean it was close so that's cool uh and what was also again the rule book is pretty bad at least what they sent me that there's a lot of things when you're just like I guess we're gonna go with that and I again that's not really something to hold on to but if they hopefully they don't just take what's written here and run with that and assume it's good because it's it's a little all over the place uh the other thing this is actually kind of a production issue which again prototype so take this for as you know what you will but this is the board I've been kind of showcasing and holding this is these this is the board for the adversary there's of course a screen and the screen is very tall with what they sent me um and it's very tall because this board is very large and there's going to be a board for every different location every scenario map but there was a lot of times especially when you're trying to do the flashlight it's like how can I get out of sight how do I get maneuver around that I couldn't like I this didn't help me like I had like I'd have to stand up to like look

and see where they were and what I'm hoping they do is I have little tokens or little you know cardboard pieces of the different investigators for the adversary because like the adversary to me or the one person almost wants to live in their board because it's a lot of information if I'm looking around and I'm looking on the right side of the board then the other players can be like well he's looking over there a lot so like that's probably where he's at and I don't want to do some [ __ ] Sniper Elite thing where I'm like rotating it off the side you shouldn't have to do that you should just be able to look at your board and know the state of the board of where they're at so you can make smart decisions because it's many people against one so there were many times where I was like I have like okay where are you guys at because I need to figure out what to do when it's my turn and it'd be really cool if there were little tokens of like let's say the players one of the players is Emily Emilia Webb little little bead that fits on the circles on the adversaries board so that when they're moving they can be like I stopped on 88 and I can put that on 88 on my board so now I can basically have a mini map of where they're at that's not currently here but it'd be really nice because I don't want to have

to keep asking or keep looking to and have to be like I'm looking over there rooted to fool them like I'm actually on the left side of the board but I'm really looking on the right side so they don't follow my you know line of sight my eyesight to figure out where I could be I just that's not fun and that kind of pulls you out of this theme uh like the the I think component-wise things need to be might like managed down to this a lot because there are a bunch of tokens that you get a bunch of uh like the items and the cool thing about the items is they are tokens with a different icon on the back you don't Shuffle the item deck they don't get the deck doesn't get randomized but these tokens do so the tokens are actually placed on the adversary board only he knows where they're at and and only until does an investigator shine his flashlight on now let's say I put one on 116 and they Shine the flashlight on it then do I take the item off 116 and place it on 116 on the main board because now they see it I which I think that's cool like I know uh my friends I was playing this with were thinking it's kind of dumb if you step on it like it's like oh do we get it if we move through it no you don't because it's not there it's like so we just kick it you know run and kick something it's like oh that's nothing I get that but it's like well like I assume the spaces aren't actually like only your body type like you're running through this massive

location you ran right past it in the dark and then it's like oh hey there's a flashlight um but but yeah there was so the tokens have the different icons those are shuffled placed out and then they're flipped and it's like oh okay and then you find the item and you give that to them uh and some of the items are cursed they're like they're really powerful but they have a really big draw uh drawback I thought that was neat to include um but yeah so there's like some stuff where like the adversary miniature or not miniature but like the standee was like really big that I had to play on I hope they don't keep that and I just think yeah like they need to kind of if they're gonna stick with the standees which are perfectly fine uh I don't think they will in fact I'd I'd be surprised if they didn't do Miniatures but I honestly think the adversary doesn't even need a standee to move on the board I think they all need minutes like minor tokens so here's my little token so I know where I'm moving um this screen I get I'm glad they made it tall but this board is so why or so big that unless you're sitting at a table like my size like half of this board can be seen by other players like I had an item down here at 316 and one of the players was like I just kind of looked over and I can see that and he's like I wasn't even meaning to I just it's there and I'm like okay so yeah it's and I get it prototype copy

but you kind of gotta go off of what they send you somewhat like it's I mean you can't just completely ignore it because then if they don't hear anything about it and they think oh what we sent them was great we'll just print that and just make it more look better it's like no there's there's some fundamental issues with it a little fiddliness like some of their stuff is fiddly a lot of tokens that were mentioned I didn't know what they were I'm like what I okay yeah I guess this token is is yours couldn't really tell and I get R and stuff will be more finalized this rule book is hopefully going to be fixed but I mean overall I think it's it's definitely a unique hidden movement game I like the idea of the different scenarios I like the idea of the different Killers um and that you can mix and match like the butcher isn't just stuck at The Sawmill you can take the Butcher and go the different scenarios play him differently if that's the one you really like I think that's really neat I'd be very surprised if they're inspiration for this game was not dead by daylight and phasmaphobia like that would be a shock if they're like oh we don't even know what those are um now it's also neat uh speaking of like the different characters is uh they have like a major and minor ability and I like that I think that's really really cool because it also tells you like the play style objectives so it definitely kind of again gives you a video game feel because the minor ability is

something they can always do they just have this as their special ability but then the major ability they need a token for and everyone starts with one but that's like a super ultimate that they get and then they have to find various ways to try and get those tokens back and there are some like uh certain items give it to you or um when when the all the evidence has been collected then the adversary takes like I think it's number of players minus one and puts them in a certain location so it's like all right if you guys want uh these tokens to get your abilities back I'm gonna put them right here and I'm gonna be in the corner I'm gonna be hiding there uh but you don't know that um but I think that's really so like it tells you like Amelia Webb playstyle objectives is her minor abilities increased movement and major ability is teleport that's that's super neat you can just quickly look at that and be like oh okay like you may treat up to three pitch black spaces as Dim when you move or Sprint onto them uh like I said Pitch Black spaces count as two you need two movement points per and dim is like in it's it's non-hindering terrain so it's like she can kind of move through three at least three pitch by spaces as if they were regular spaces that's really cool and her major ability is that she gets to place a token on an adjacent space and then on her next turn she can teleport she can like kind of like almost like Tracer in uh OverWatch you can just kind of blip back to it and

that's really neat so there's like a piece in the fix the truck thing that was close to her she could like run all the way to it grab it and then blip back to the truck which is neat and they had quite a few playable characters that felt very very different so honestly like I know it was like I've mentioned it's kind of it's kind of a little bit rough um to get into it based off the Prototype rules that they sent me but at the end of the day it was Innovative I felt it was unique and I should also mention that people are like wow he's like kind of praising it and they sent him a copy they didn't pay me like I don't get I don't get paid to do these um so I could if I didn't like it I'd tell you as much and send them their shitty game back but that's not the case here yes I think uh after after my time with it I'm very excited to get my copy I think this is a really really cool theme done very well extremely atmospheric their gimmick works like the flashlight thing I think is really cool I think there's a lot like a lot of tightness like make it a little bit more cleaner more usable for the players if you're going to be dealing with tokens at least make it easier for players to kind of do to mess with them make it a little bit cleaner for the adversary so he knows what's happening on the main board so he doesn't have to keep looking at it um and and yeah I think I think they definitely got something here so as of right now oh I guess I should also

talk a little bit about I've mentioned kind of the adversary and the investigators but the scenarios do have rules for them as well The Sawmill in this case has doors doors can be willingly Shut by the players and the investigator or the adversary has to break them down uh but the main rule are the very these two locations there's these computers that take up the investigator's entire turn like they can move to it but after they activate it that's all they can do they can't turn on their flashlight they can't run away from it and in this case it turns one building's light completely on so it makes that entire room so uh bright but then uh after the next round the the lights go out and it's like okay so now from now on that location is going to be pitch black so you get like a one-time use everything here is brightest we've we hacked into the computer and flipped the switch and then the Sawmill is just bright and then the next round it's just almost like that that Corridor scene just and like the the lights are coming off and then you see the adversary like the butcher running at you and you're like oh my God the lights [ __ ] can you just off yourself because I mean why wouldn't you um so that's one thing the next that's in here are windows and these windows are uh you can pass through them but if you continue moving then you take a wound just a face down wound like I said it's not the easiest

way to heal um the adversary can also move through the windows uh they don't hurt themselves but they create noise so it's like if I went through a window you would know but the adversary because they have these Sprint dice uh the butcher gets to move five and then he rolls that and this goes up to four so two to four so he can basically move either seven to nine spaces um like you can as the adversary run into through a window make noise and then run back out and then like circle around or something to make them think that you're in the building or something um but the adversary or the investigators if they go through and they stop on the other side thematically to me anyway it was like they opened it just kind of climbed through but they quit moving so they're not hurt and actually the last time I won this game was because what the player I killed chose not to stop he kept moving so he took a wound because he basically Dove through the window and cut himself and as soon as that happened I was like he is my Target that is that is who I am after to try and win this game because in in the Prototype I only had to kill one investigator so I was like oh oh is that it's a little bit of blood oh there's the weak one that's the that's the one in the herd that is uh Keen to my predator eyes but yeah overall I really really like it um I cannot wait for it to be finalized and and cleaned up so on a scale of one

to ten as kind of a you know prototype First Impressions um I think I'm gonna give it a a huh I think I'm gonna give it a seven and a half 7.5 like it's it's good it is good um and honestly some of the most the more atmospheric ones because this is very it's a really good horror themed game uh because I don't think Fury of Dracula or loves I mean they are technically horror um but they're almost fantasy a little bit I mean obviously Jack the Ripper was a real person but it was in the past and it's like well I don't even know who he was and yeah sure uh inferior of Dracula is not real and uh I I don't know I just didn't get the same feeling out of those games I'm not like freaked out if I'm like trying to because you're trying to catch Jack the Ripper he's not trying to hunt you uh Dracula is sometimes not trying to hunt you uh so this is the only one where it's like the adversaries actively trying to take uh take you down I think that that's that that can you can really get into the headspace of that so 7.5 right now I think it could definitely go it it will go up I think to an eight eight point five maybe even the nine if they knock the production and scenarios and stuff out of the park uh so this only has room to go up I think but

that's it that's my thoughts on the stifling dark let me know what you think of this game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time update it's for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved