Skip to main content
Loading video...

CloudAge Review: Alexander Pfister Does It Again! - By Board Of It

Transcript 16:44

hello everyone tallyanne farrell here from board of it and today we're going to be reviewing cloud age cloud age is a mysterious new game by capstone games which we first became interested in because it's co-designed by one of our favorite designers alexander feister now we say mysterious because beside the theme and the fact that it would exist at some point in the future zero information was given about it between its announcement and its release the rule book which was announced as coming soon on the cloud age webpage for several months wasn't even uploaded until after the game was released and i'm not scared to admit that i thought this lack of information meant that either the game was going to be horrendously delayed or that it wasn't a very good game and they're just basically trying not to draw any attention to it by not giving any information and hoping people forgot but we're glad to say that it arrived perfectly on time and it's a game we have very much been enjoying we've played a lot of it recently in cloud h which is four one to four players you'll be living aboard an airship which roams above a desiccated land this is post-apocalyptic future and basically you'll spend your time trying to scavenge resources so you can improve your airship trying to collect crew members and also battling cloud militia who are the bad guys responsible for the way the world is but in technical terms it's mainly a solid euro you'll be engine building a little bit of deck building and a lot

of resource management the game is played over seven to eight rounds each of which is separated into three phases you'll begin with an airship down here at the start of each turn you'll decide whether you want to produce water at the cost of energy and water is the cost of buying new crew members in the form of project cards then you'll draw two navigation cards with the higher value showing you how many spaces your ship can move and the lower value you'll take in resources your ship always has to end its movement in a city and if you haven't previously been to that city you can do a battle you take into account any ship upgrades you have that boost your combat value as well as any played cards that boost your value and if this still isn't enough you can draw navigation cards at the cost of energy and add that value to your total combat value if it exceeds or equals the city's combat value you win the battle and gain a reward regardless you place your cube in that city to show you've been there in the third phase of the round you get to take a city board action the first option is to build which lets you either upgrade your airship or put project cards into play the second option

is to gain resources and a navigation card where you pick which resource you want and then you in one of these sections and then you get the navigation card which goes into your deck then the third option is to plant growth tiles which are little tiles that come out of this bag and when you have them you can either put certain ones on the board to get vp or other ones just give you resources now in the city board whichever player does a main action it's pretty great because every other player gets a secondary action which is a weakened version of the main action now as you play cloudh you'll be scoring vps here and there and at the end of the game you'll mainly be scoring up mission cards which give you little objectives to complete and also the played cards around your airship cloudage also contains legacy elements ideally you'll play the campaign legacy which will slowly introduce you to the game and its mechanics and as you go you'll build up your own version of the map however you can also play a scenario which will introduce variable setup the legacy elements include a story about the world of cloud age and new tiles to add to the map in a very very similar way as it was done in maracaibo we like the feel of constant progression that cloud age has because each turn you'll be working on your navigation deck playing project cards and upgrading your airship this means in turn that the next turn

you take you'll be able to do a little better move a little further and just generally be a little stronger and in turn this then leads to being able to fight harder battles which give more rewards and then you can play bigger better project cards and the cycle continues and in all this cloud h never feels restrictive because there's always something you can aim for or something you can do in that moment it's also nice to have a combat design that's so simplified and rewarding it's quick and easy and we like the aspect of drawing navigation cards in order to boost your combat value as it creates a nice risk reward system whereby you can spend energy in the production phase to produce water or spend it on combat which allows you to go to harder combat areas and potentially getting a bigger reward even better if you fail nothing happens so you can also choose to reserve your energy plus combat is actually optional although everyone should really be doing it every turn in order to get a few resources one of the best things about cloudh is that it's simple to grasp yet still has that chunky euro feel and a reasonable play time it's consistently engaging over the course of an entire game due to very limited downtime essentially by experienced players the first two phases of a round can be played pretty much simultaneously as long as you pay attention to airship movement order then in the third phase of the round the

city actions everyone stays invested even on other players terms because anyone who's not doing the main action gets secondary action from whatever that first player does so you always want to see what they're doing and hope they pick what you want them to do it's relatively easy to get resources in cloud age and the more players you have the more you'll be getting due to those secondary actions we're really enjoying this as rather than being a really tight resource management where you have to work with what you've got it becomes a choose your own path game where if you want to go in one direction you will be able to afford to if you work at it but of course at the cost of other aspects now one thing that we really enjoy in games is a good dilemma because usually in a board game if you're having a difficult time choosing between a few different options in front of you you would hopefully think that it's because they all seem equally good to you i just think it's really great game design when you can pursue one route that you think will lead you to victory and other players around the table can sue other routes and they're all equally valued and cloud age is really great for this cloud age has a lot of different resources which can make it tough at times to pick which ones you really need in that moment as they are all very useful in their own ways as a specific example the project cards are resources you'll discard them in order to play other project cards which means that rather than saying oh i'll play that one later you might have

to decide between two you want to play and sacrifice one most of the project cards are also pretty useful which can make it really tough to decide which one to get rid of which is good design even better even if you draw a bad card or one that you don't want to play it's useful in of itself because then it's an easy choice to discard in addition when you take a city action in the third phase of a round and you go to the city board it's always diabolical you know you really want to take every action available at that board because they're all so good and in that moment it can be quite difficult to decide what's best for you especially when you consider that every other player is going to give you a secondary action and at least at times where you really have to weigh up and you take gambles like say you want to play a project card but you only have enough resources to play one so if you do the build action which lets you play two it's a bit of a waste so you gamble that someone else is going to do a build action and where you play that card and instead you go and get some more resources or something and then you really tense and you know it really cranks up the tension as you watch and wait what every player picks and it keeps you invested in everyone else's turn which is always a hallmark of a great game moving on to the negatives there is one issue with obtaining resources in the city action phase in that the city cards are hidden behind this cloud filter it's very poorly explained that the

abundance of the resource is supposed to be reflected in the remaining visible card art and as i can tell you farrell spent the first three games constantly moaning that he was only ever getting one of the resource he needed until we eventually figured out that you can somewhat tell by looking at the card heart however it is still sometimes impossible to tell and it can be annoying if you don't get as much as you wanted if you take that as your main action and you get shafted despite how much we enjoy cloud age one thing we worry about is the longevity of it because project cards are a resource you cycle through the deck over the course of a game so you see a lot of them per game and now that me and tally have completed the campaign we feel over familiar with the cards and this is a bit of a problem because a lot of them are either repeated or repeated but with slightly different attributes um and that's never a good sign and you know a second thing is the map boards even though they're double-sided for variable setup because the map is so indistinct in and of itself you'd hardly notice if you're playing with one side of the board or the other it doesn't change things that much and to illustrate this point i was literally just talking about this with tally and remember we've done the entire campaign and a few other games and she didn't even know they were double sided which shows how little you notice it

game to game and we have been changing these every game so all this kind of contributes to us wondering if after another 10 plays cloud age is a game that we'll want to get out or you know will it have given up all of its secrets at that point only time will a different note though speaking of components and this is a hill i will die on games that make you put the stickers on the components yourself you know it's a bit of a slap in the face to spend 50 dollars on the game to then find out you have to assemble it yourself and then if you know you put this tiny sticker on a tiny token and it's one millimeter off and then your game looks crap for eternity it's yeah i mean it's annoying and cloudage is guilty of this don't think you're getting away with the two through the ages you know you're guilty

hello everyone so when we were writing the script we discovered that we had differing opinions on the legacy elements of cloud age so we thought we'd bring something we've talked about a little bit before a debate style format to i guess both get our points across because they're so different so tally would you like to begin yeah so i quite like the legacy elements of this game for me they've kept me a lot more engaged than the ones in maracaibo and i don't know if it's just because we've been playing this like game after game like we were saying that the length of play is quite short so you can play multiple games it just kept me feeling a lot more engaged in the story whereas maracaibo i have no idea what's going on i forget game to game i don't really know i don't really care i mean it's nice to have the variable tiles on the board but aside from that don't really care where is this i think it's a nice little story i just i think it is just because we we do we have played this a lot in quake succession whereas maracaibo is like maybe one game a month and yeah it's easy to forget but i just think what i disliked about this legacy so i generally just like the legacy elements um in that they're very similar to maracaibo but everything's somehow like a worse version of maracaibo in my opinion here so if we take the tiles for example that you put down one main issue is that this board is very non-descript like every space is pretty much the same and all these cities they're just shown from above with like

an image of a cloud so none of them are distinct they just have these little names that are a really small font to distinguish them so none of them mean anything to me and then you know when you read this legacy card and it's like put this tile down here it just i don't care it doesn't really do anything like what's the difference in maracaibo like the cities aren't sprawling cities on the board like it doesn't really change it like the actions you do there change but then that's the same with these i don't know i would argue that if you take that tile in maracaibo where you can put a quest down you know the one where you turn the town to the city and now you get quest there that's totally different you can't do that anywhere else then on top of that there's the other one you know where you explore into the jungle and you get that really good action if your explorer has gone past spoilers yeah well i just think those are really different than say this one whereas you can like do an upgrade i mean you can do that over here like it's not that special really i think yeah i guess i don't care enough about the story and the legacy elements to to be that bothered i just think that it's this one's a nice little one to keep me engaged i'm not bothered about a big story and a big change but it's just enough for me to be interested yes but i mean i get that i think it's just i'm more disappointed that these tiles don't really you know add much and it's like also some of the ones that add there if you land on it you know you can leave a cube there and you can spend it at some point for a special benefit but that's not usually they're not that much better than

just doing a combat and getting the resources either i think i don't know i found them a little disappointing in what they give and also the fact that they just don't seem to mean much to me all right well i agree to disagree no no we haven't even gotten to the story yet and so in my opinion the story is really really i don't know cliche there's only one character which is sam it doesn't make any sense because he's our brother so like are we all related actually captains or what's the competition it's your imagination all right fine but sam's annoying we can both agree on that we both hate sam who's the main and pretty much only character of the legacy but yeah i just yeah i just don't think it's that interesting story i think it's pretty hack made quite like it oh there you go then so we'll have to agree to disagree with them no all right so this was so let's go to talk unresolved cloud age was a game that we really enjoyed it's a lovely streamlined euro and it's particularly good buy for people looking to increase the complexity of their collection but aren't ready for a big heavy euro yet or if you just like alexander feister games if you like maracaibo you're going to enjoy this one it's great at any player count and we're particularly fans of it at two player unfortunately the highly integrated legacy elements are a bit of a miss according to farrell and the artwork and components are a bit

drab but besides this there's really not much to dislike about cloud age if you enjoyed this video please give it a thumbs up we really appreciate it and subscribe to our channel if you haven't already for regular board game reviews always with a little hint of doggos and you can check out our clown age playthrough if you want to see it in action which will be popping up now

Progress saved