Ahoy Review - Leder's new asymmetric game of piracy & plunder
Transcript
avast me hearties and let us set sail upon the seas yeah yeah that's enough of that ahoy is both a declarative greeting and the name of leader games's latest release designed and signed by gregorian albright then further developed by nick brockman in-house it is an asymmetric game of conquest subterfuge and smuggling in an indelibly charming oceanic world illustrated by kyle farren as a two-player game it is a strictly area controlled joint between two similar but ultimately very different factions the sharknatious bluefins with their extra action dice vast armada of sharky patrol boats and more inherent militaristic capabilities versus the mollusk union helmed initially with one boat but wielding trixie one-off plans they accrue and distribute non-combative comrades on islands to establish control which is all more or less pretty straightforward it's when adding a third and fourth player to the mix that things take a turn no matter how many people are sitting at the table two players will always be playing that area control game but additional players are smugglers who can do all the normal things gain crew participate in combat move about the board explore new terrain to expand the map but rather than gain points from control of islands their points come from their unique ability to smuggle resources from crew in the market carefully taking them from an island they're affiliated with just as if you
are recruiting them but instead place them as cargo and upon completing delivery to an island matching the destination symbol you get points and an array of different bonuses from your smuggler track no matter how you slice it the general thrust of the game is that players start rounds by rolling their 4 or in the case of the sharky sharks 5 dice then take turns taking two dice actions at a time along with any number of free actions like recruiting crew affiliated with your local island to permanently add their powers to your faction most of the game is spent maneuvering your flagship around the board and speaking of which the board starts small but if you ever move off the edge another tile is flipped for you to orient putting out a fresh wealth die at one representing the points that the sharks or mollusks will gain at the end of the round for controlling that tile the thing is that these dice will increase throughout the game either at the choice of the first player at the end of each round in a two-player game or organically by a smuggler delivering goods at three or four players like most things in ahoy the emergent board and the associated increaseable wealth die is a simple but hugely impactful system it incentivizes control points adds dynamic character and provides alternatives to strictly combative exchanges and accelerates point accrual as rounds go on making for a really nice arc to the game if a
player has 30 points at the end of a round then the game ends and smugglers can reveal committed goods a way of racking bonus points by speculating which of the militant factions will control which type of territories after which the most points wins and this sort of impactful simplicity continues throughout yes allocating dice to your board sometimes having to meet restrictions is pretty easy to pick up but inflicted damage taking up those precious action spots until they can be repaired is full of implications in combat combat occurs only when a unit moves into a territory and either that unit or at least one of the units already there has armed cannons usually requiring you to manually arm with an action dice combatants each roll one d6 and the higher roll wins inflicting damage to the enemy ship and reaping your faction's combat rewards simple yeah but you can allocate cannon pips to increase your strength before rolling but will that leave you too vulnerable and maybe you don't want combat sometimes movement unencumbered is far more valuable so you don't arm cannons and focus on exploring after all if you don't arm cannons and they don't arm cannons there is no combat and this is working only with your four or five dice per round allocating only two action dice per turn meaning that it's hard to orchestrate a sort of grand coup without commitment and foreshadowing but that
grand coup is also kind of a misunderstanding of this game the thing about ahoy is that it's by far the most accessible of leaders asymmetric games faster playing easier to learn less temperamental at lower player counts and more broadly consistent among faction rules than its cave and forest dwelling predecessors but it's far from straightforward the presence of combat and control makes you want to hold territory to engage in stupendous master and commander battles to exercise subterfuge and pull off some grand orchestration with your comrade fueled plan cards but if you play with an unyielding grip on what you have the game will be surprisingly slow this is a game where control is fleeting where discovering new land is often better than fighting over what's already out where combat is a means to an end fast and decisive but most often a way of adding or removing a token or two on the map and with the teleportatious tailwind action that moves you direct to any matching dye symbol some of the comrade manipulation on the mollusk actions or crew or the massive number of deployable shark boats or even bluefin strongholds that always have cannons loaded and count for two for purposes of regional control exchanges are frequent tactical and tenuous one of the biggest surprises was how good this game played at two i mean yes our first game we both turtled and loaded for bear every turn hardly exploring because we didn't want to give
up our home turf it was fun overall but a bit of a slog once we stopped viewing it as a war game and instead a game of exploration where it's impossible to hold on to 11 territories at a time it really cooked and the game's fun brilliant poppy nature that still has plenty of room for awesome plays but makes holding on to any one individual territory much less consequential it really came to life but not so much as playing with smugglers the game plays great at two but shines at three where the smugglers have so much influence over the entrenched partisans choosing where to deliver organically upping the value of the islands participating in combat but avoiding area control it's completely different but adds such great dimension to the game and the fact that these three very different factions have this tight balance and agency is really impressive but the downside is that no matter how good the two-player game is without being able to play as a smuggler which would truly make no sense in that context the two-player version will still itch as somewhat less than also speaking of smugglers i'm no game designer and i'm sure there are plenty of well thought out reasons for it but the fact that the smugglers are identical and all but colored not even changing up the number requirements or grid just feels bland come on the rest of the game is so inventive and lively at least some difference between the two
would have been really welcome but if those are the weaknesses the strengths are so much more ahoy is a fresh and vibrant alternative to leader's existing lineup managing to feel completely singular while also totally at home with the studio's catalog of curiosities it's a game where no matter what faction you're playing or what player count you feel uniquely powerful be it the militant dominance of the sharks where one loaded cannon turns a sea worth of patrol boats into a vast web of obstacles and an extra action die per turn leads to aggressive up-ends or the mollusks who manipulate their non-combative comrades with ease whose greatest assets are what plans might lurk in their hand and the subtle but potent world manipulation and speculation of the smuggler who jets around and can net serious gains through delivery or successful combat each feels inventive and fun and like so many games of this type the asymmetry just makes you wonder about all sorts of faction possibilities but it manages a stability and cohesiveness on its own as someone who loves area control asymmetry and exploration this hit all the marks and did so with a poppy approachability and a sort of low stakes puzzliness which is totally welcome and totally legit and i just want to play it more and that's our review but let us know what are your
favorite asymmetric games and what do you think of ahoy let us know in the comments below and as always thanks for watching thanks for supporting thanks for being an awesome audience you know that i've been jack for the cardboard harold