Switch & Signal Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at switch and signal which is a one to four player board game designed by david thompson and published by cosmos games this one takes around 45 minutes to play on average so switch and signal is actually a cooperative train style game is all about logistics so the setup for switch and signal is going to look somewhat like this and this is one of the two maps that come with the game this is a reversible board and you can see here you've got all these different cities scattered throughout you've got denver here you've got san francisco and you've got chicago here and you can also see on these cities you've got these different resource cubes on them now the objective is that we want to be trying to guide these trains um some of which are going to start on the board during setup and some of which are going to be sat in the depot here ready to be deployed on the board and we're going to be trying to guide those trains pick up these cubes and then deposit these cubes in these different port cities so you can see here see here that new york wants one of each colored cube as does san francisco and if we do that before the timer of the game runs out which is when all these cards here get run through then we will win the game or if we're too slow and we don't get that achieved by the time this deck runs out then we will lose the game there are three different colors of trains that are used in this game you've got the gray ones the brown ones and the black ones and each of these colors have a unique die associated to them which determines the speed in which these trains move so the grey ones are the slowest and the die associated to that one only goes from a one up to a three
the brown ones go from a one to a four and the black ones go from a two to a five so they are by far the quickest of the trains there are also three of these special characters in the top right hand corner of the board here and these are special abilities that you can use at one time during the game and if you use them you're going to cover up them with this little token here to show that you cannot use them again and you're also going to have this rather large deck of action cards and each player is going to get given five of these cards at the start of the game and there's only ever three types of them one's associating to the signals one associating to the switches and one of which associates to moving trains so let's talk about how the game actually plays out so the first thing you're going to do on every player's turn is to reveal the topmost deployment card and that deployment card is going to have two different types of information on them the first of which is to deploy a new train and you can actually choose which color train to deploy so let's just say i chose this black one um just because they're the fastest and then what you're going to do is you're going to roll this pair of dice here and that's going to show which location that train is going to spawn out so this is number 10 therefore the black train is going to start at number 10 like so after that you're going to have a look at the movement of these trains so first off we've got the brown trains here now this means that every single brown train on the board is going to move an equal amount to depending on depending on what i roll here so i've rolled a four that means every brown train which is only one at the moment is going to move four spaces now when you move a train you are
simply going to move a number of spots of track um equal to the roll so it's going to be one two three now you can see here i've just run in to a red light now if it was a green light i could go straight through that but it's a red light so therefore i'm going to waste a movement which means i'm going to have to get rid of one of these time tokens that's a symbol of being inefficient when all these um time tokens are bled off the board then you're going to basically discard the top card from the deployment deck here meaning that the end of the game is going to be faster and of course once you've finished resolving the brown um trains you're going to move on to the black trains let's just do that you're going to roll the the black train die and then all the black trains are going to move three spots so again i'm going to find the one i want and go one two three like so and you've also got one here to go one two three so once you've finished resolving the entirety of this deployment card you're going to go into the main part of the game which is where you play your action cards so you can play as many action cards as you want during your turn you generally going to play most of them sometimes you might keep one back and you always draw five cards at the end of your turn and you have a hand limit of 10 cards but let's talk about what these cards actually do so the first switch is these um signal cards now these are very simple so all you do is you're going to take a a green token and you're going to move it to a another spot so for example i could move this one here like so meaning that this brown tray now has a green
light to go in to dallas so that's a very simple um simple way that the uh the signal cards resolve you've got these switch cards here which work in almost the exact same way which takes place which way you manipulate these junctions so you can see here we're in a bit of a sticky situation here where i might want to play this switch card in order to move this junction like this maybe in order to get this train through to prevent a collision here and the other one is to play a movement card which is where you move one specific train on the board let's just say um i had another another switch card i might want to do this first and move it like this and then play my movement card where again i'm going to select a train let's choose this black one here i'm going to discard my movement card and then i'm going to roll the black die because i'm moving a black train and that's going to move three spots i'd go one two three like so also at any time you can choose to discard any two cards in order to replace or to substitute another action so i could choose to get rid of these two tray movement cards maybe in order to switch this um this light to green like so now whenever a train goes into a city you can choose to stop at least on this map the other map you um i think you have to stop but on this map you can you can choose to stop and then to load up a train with the um with the good type you just have to discard any single card and then you can load that train up like so
putting the cube inside the carriage like this and again once you've finished taking your actions you're going to discard all the action cards that you've played and draw five new ones for your next turn and then it'll pass on to the next person who will then draw the next deployment card and then do the relevant actions either again deploying new trains onto the onto the board or moving the specific trains um listed on the card now there are other ways to lose those time tokens we always already mentioned you know being stuck at junctions or at um at red lights you know for each movement you can't take you lose a uh a time token and that also applies to if trains are backed up by other trains so let's just say you know the gray um the greys moved and they rolled a two and you can see here they've got nowhere to go so again each movement they can't take you're going to lose one of those time tokens now this also applies that if if trains have head-on collisions like this let's just say again the gray rotor two and for each movement they can't take if you're head-on you actually lose two time tokens so it's very bad um if you do or if you cannot avoid um having a head-to-head collision and then that train is also going to be removed from the board and put back to the depot also if you cannot deploy a train so let's just say you know the gray train was here on the 10 already and then i rolled another 10 to deploy a train and you know that sport i cannot share i'm going to lose another two-time token so you want to keep things off the deployment areas if possible let's talk briefly about what these three characters do so this one here
lets you ignore one of the deployment cards you know if you've got a card that you've drawn that you're really not happy with and maybe you don't want to move the black trains because you haven't got the junction ready for it and you're going to lose a lot of time tokens and you can choose to ignore that card and draw a new one by putting the old one back at the bottom of the deck and then again cover up that you've used that ability this one here means that you can look at one of the train types on the deployment card and choose not to move one of those trains you can't you can't choose to ignore all of them but you can least choose one problematic one and this one here means that instead of rolling the pair of dice and deploying the um the train on that spot then you can actually choose where to deploy it so if you're really after maybe a red red cube here in dallas and you need to get to new york maybe you can choose to deploy at the three here to be a bit more efficient and that is essentially how you play switch and signal so it's a very simple game in terms of its rules and the way it works mechanically um there's quite a bit going on so let's get into my thoughts on the actual gameplay experience okay so i actually really enjoyed how this game is boiled down into such few actions now you can either move the switches move the signals uh move the trains or you know pick up a cube essentially so very simple rule set and the gameplay all lies in the kind of pulling the strings and being being a bit of a puppeteer and orchestrating the way that these trains move in order to be as efficient as possible and doing that is very very difficult because you do have limited control due to the exact amount of these switches and signals
that are on the board you know particularly these signals where you know in order to do one thing you're gonna have to move it from somewhere else and the way that ties back into the speeds of the trains is quite fascinating to to be honest and because you might think you know the gray trains are chugging along at a very slow pace you probably do not need to worry about making a switch anytime soon because you've got a bit of time for it to move whereas the black trains are going along at a thundering pace and you might urgently need to switch this one before another train comes and needs that same junction so again it's all about this timing um timing puzzle and i do kind of like managing that it is a it is somewhat of a stressful situation potentially when you have build up in specific locations but you know pulling the strings and trying to get through that without wasting anything is kind of where the enjoyment lies there is a really strong degree of strategy in this game and you can do some quite accurate forward planning and because again you know the rough pace that these trains are going to move and that's not that's not going to be accurate information and i do like the way that it balances between automated movement from the deployment cards where you're gonna have you know very little control over what you move um you know sometimes you're gonna you have your fingers crossing you know i do not want the blacks black trains to move because if i do i'm going to waste a hell of movement i haven't got the current infrastructure to deal with that one but at the same time when it gets to your turn you still do have some mitigation on how you want to move these trains you know particularly if you have a bunch of these trained cars so if you really need to get a train to get out the way before another train
bashes into the back of it then you can give it that little um you know automated push into the direction that you want it to be but of course you're always restricted to the cars you have in your hand which means that you're going to have your your your hands tied at times but i do like the added element of being able to use two cards of any type in order to take a wild action so that's a nice little mitigation tool that you can use there i also enjoy how tailorable the game is to your needs you know if you're finding the game too easy you can make it more difficult for yourself by removing deployment cards from the deck you know to give you less time to complete the puzzle alternatively if you're finding it too difficult you could add more time tokens you could even add more signal switches here or you know even to make it more difficult for yourself you can add more resource cubes um to the different locations to to drop them off as well so you have a lot of potential here or a lot of capability to exactly tinker the game to how you want it to be um to fit your level of skill now despite there being a good degree of forward planning and strategy in this game there are certain factors that you can't really do much about at times which can massively impact the flow of your game and particularly if you keep on rolling the same sporting point for your trains and you know there's already a train there or it's a very congested and cluttered area of the board then you know inevitably that is going to work against you and it's going to make the game a hell of a lot more difficult but to be honest that added degree of pressure um doesn't really take away from the game from me you know there are big swings of luck you know
maybe you're not going to get the get the right card you have into your hand you know maybe you really needed a a switch card and just by just by bad luck you drew only um signals and train movement cards so you know that is going to happen but i never really felt that the you know those those things that are out of your control worked against the game it just seemed like another obstacle to overcome and to try to make them the best of a bad situation so i do feel like there are a lot of strong decisions to be had in this game i'm always trying to analyze the current ball state to you know be as efficient as you can as i said and to offer yourself contingency plans um in case certain things happen you know you never want to leave yourself in a situation where you've got um you know a fast train just stuck at a junction and you know to waste a hell of a lot of movement to do that you need to make sure that or prepare yourself to what could happen next because again you've only got so much control over the movement from these trains now that being said this is a pure cooperative game you can pretty much play with open hands here there's no hidden information there's no murkiness and everything is completely transparent so that goes back to this old argument of alpha gaming this game does have potential for alpha gaming if you have that style of group if you have a very dominating player who thinks they know best and wants to call the shots then again they can potentially override the player's turn and dictate what's going to happen now of course if there is any ever any discussion then it's going to fall to the um fall to the active player's turn to make that final decision but it's just something to be aware of
if you have that style of player in your gaming group the game does only take around 45 minutes to play which i think is spot on for this style of gameplay um does not stay as welcome whatsoever and it feels nice and succinct and that added pressure of the time running out and you know you trying to get your objectives complete is just wonderfully balanced so i do think they too work hand in hand very well and that also applies to the up time of the game because even if it's not your actual turn you can always give your kind of two cents on what you think should happen and give your opinion on the best plays um and so yeah you're always involved at all times in this game because as i said it is truly cooperative and you're always working together and always involved so one thing that somewhat concerns me is the replayability factor um of this game because there's only two maps of on the come of the game one of which is much easier than this one because there's only actually one port city it feels like once you've got that perfect balance of difficulty for you you know you win a few games you're losing a few games it's like where do you really go from that point are you gonna keep coming back to it um and you know at the moment i'm perfectly fine with it i've got a few more games in my system that's that's for sure but i could definitely see it on the horizon where i'm going to be at peace with this game i'm not going to have that really incentive to come back to it or explore it any further i'm generally happy with the production and artwork for this game i think it looks very nice and it's quite generic looking but i've got no issue with that at all um all the pieces are decent you've got these wooden um discs for the
switches and signals they're easy to pick up and move around the board which you'll be doing quite a lot and the actual trains themselves look nice and they fit in the um the cubes quite you know quite snuggly but not being too fiddly because i found that i find like with a lot of pick up and deliver games that they try to be a bit too intricate and it ends up just being um you know very fiddly to pick things up and put them down and things so again no issue at all the dice are decent no they're not great but they're perfectly fine wooden dice and the cardstock is is fine there's nothing special but it's certainly not going to um you know it doesn't feel cheap so generally i'm perfectly happy and content with the production for this game i think switching signals scales pretty damn well for some reason the box does say it plays two to four players when in actuality this is a pretty damn good solo experience and that's coming from me and i'm not a committed solo gamer at all i very rarely play solo games because it doesn't overly appeal to me but i could definitely see myself happily sitting down and having complete control over this logistics puzzle and having a great time doing it you know for 30 minutes as a solo game there really isn't much um better than this one so yeah if you like solo games this is definitely one to check out uh two plays you're gonna have that proper head of kind of um face to face cooperative really engaging with the other player you know having working out how to use your cards most efficiently when you can kind of sit back and let your partner do other things that you can neglect for now and that's quite cool you know you have that real engaging two-player experience three players i think maybe one person is going to has the potential
to get a bit more disengaged from the game and four players i would probably lean away from because you're not all going to be completely invested okay so let's get some final thoughts on switch and signal so generally co-op games are not my forte um i've kind of come to notice that recently where i've kind of noticed i don't really have many cult games in my collection at all and if i do have a co-op game i tend to lean towards lighter party style games but this one is almost like a whole new niche within that co-op bracket and i like the way it works so i like the way you can discuss which cards you have you know how am i going to use my cards and am i going to move a bunch of switches so that in your turn you can use all your train cards to move them through and i just do enjoy this whole logistics puzzle how to deal with the cards you're dealt not only literally but also with the way that the trains are up here appearing on the board which ones are going to move automatically and which ones are you going to move um you know by yourself um and just how to you know when to leave things in position when to switch them up or have i got enough time to switch it back before this train gets here am i going to divert this one out the way just to buy me some time just to clear some space and it's just such a tightly and finely tuned board game and i just love the balance of all the different junctions and all the switches and just how you cannot solve this game you know you always are on your feet always on your toes trying to keep an eye on everything to make things run smoothly again those type of games tend to work for me um while at some point you know sometimes the pressure does
mount it feels uncomfortable at times but i think by the end of it if you especially if you end up winning you feel like you've achieved something and you ran things um really well and like clockwork and i like the way that that works so i think the gameplay for switching signal is rock solid there's a lot to enjoy here a lot to sink your teeth into and it's a good type of stress now that being said i do think that the amount of plays that you get from the core box alone is limited i would love to see this game be supported by cosmos and maybe release more map packs all of which having a different kind of feature or uniqueness about them just to keep things feeling fresh and to give yourself something else to think about without kind of leaning too far away from the simplicity of the rules and the card system and that switch and signal system so yeah again i can see on the horizon that i'm going to be at a point where i'm content with my time with this one and i'm ready to move on but again i'd love to be convinced otherwise so i think for that reason i'm going to air on the side of caution and give this one just below a shield of qualities this is like as close as it could be from a shield of quality without getting one now i think if you if you like logistics puzzles you like co-op games that are simple you know that medium lifestyle thing but still having a lot to think about you know simple rule set but good decisions then this is a very good option but again i just want to see this game be supported just to inject a bit more life into this experience but a
really nice game and again one of those rare occasions where i'd happily play this one solo i know this one probably would even be one of my best or favorite solo experiences that i've played yet so that is switch and signal