Skip to main content
Loading video...

TOTAL DISASTER! Inis: Big Box & Nemed Expansion Kickstarter Campaign

Transcript 14:38

We've been absolutely furious about this campaign for the past week, and I think we need to talk about it publicly because Inus is genuinely one of the best games ever made. But this Kickstarter experience has been such a systematic disaster that we have to break down what actually went wrong here and why we're so angry.

Yeah. And the really infuriating part is that it's not just one thing going wrong. It's this pattern of failures from top to bottom that feels deliberate. The game itself is a masterpiece. We both love Inus, right? But the way Madagot and Colossal Games handled this entire campaign has been absolutely contemptuous toward their backers. We're one of the people who got hit with the wrong Legacy Edition components. So, this is an armchair criticism from the sidelines. We're living this nightmare right now, and it's been months of broken promises.

Exactly. And we need to explain what happened because people reading the comments might not understand why this is such a massive betrayal of trust. So here's the situation. Inus has gone through multiple editions over the years. The original first and second editions have this specific artistic style, specific color palettes, a whole visual and aesthetic identity that players built their collections around. Then Matagot decides to create a completely redesigned third edition with new artwork. Now, that's fine if you're buying new, but what about players like us who already own the original game,

right? So, they released the seasons expansion in the new art style, and now Nemed is coming. If the new expansion only comes in new art style, it doesn't match your existing game. It's visually inongruent on your shelf. Your collection looks disjointed when you play it. And that's where the legacy edition pledge was supposed to solve this problem. For players who already own Inus, you could back the legacy edition, which meant you'd get the NMED expansion with the original artwork style, so it would seamlessly integrate with your existing copies. That was the entire selling point of paying extra for the legacy pledge. You're paying specifically to get components that match your original game. The cards match, the tiles match, everything looks cohesive on your shelf and in your hands when you're playing. But then on December 11th, Madagot casually posts an update saying some Legacy Edition backers in the UK and certain European regions received completely wrong components. We got retail edition cards and tiles, the brand new artwork instead of the legacy artwork we explicitly paid extra for.

And here's where I absolutely lost it. Madagot's official statement tries to downplay it by saying, "It's just the backs that are wrong, but that's being dishonest about the actual scope of the problem. We opened our boxes and the entire cards are wrong. The tile backs don't match our original game at all. The card artwork is completely different from what we expected. This wasn't some small printing variation or minor inconsistency. This was receiving a fundamentally different product than was explicitly promised. What makes it worse is their explanation. They're trying to act like this is some random warehouse mistake. They say, "Oh, the boxes were correctly labeled as legacy at the warehouse, so it wasn't a picking error." Which means the factory packed the wrong components into correctly labeled boxes. That's not a random accident. That's a systematic failure at the production level. Somewhere in the factory, legacy components and retail components got completely confused and nobody had a verification process in place to catch it. And they admit they have no idea how many people were actually affected. They're saying, quote, "The reports right now are only from a few people, but with the US, Canada, and Australia all having items arriving this week to backers, we'll be monitoring to see how many people were affected and where. So basically, they're shipping blind, hoping it's isolated and only finding out about problems when angry backers contact them. That's not quality control. That's negligence. They didn't audit the factory before shipping. They didn't

spot check shipments. They didn't verify that legacy boxes actually contained legacy components. And we can already see it's way more than a few people. We're seeing affected backers in the UK, Germany, Belgium, Finland. The list keeps growing every single day. They're monitoring to see the scope. Come on. They should have known the scope before shipping a single box.

But that would have required actually investing in quality control. And that costs money. Which brings us to the bigger picture here. The legacy mixup is terrible. But it's honestly just the latest disaster in a campaign that's been mismanaged from start to finish because the communication throughout this entire thing has been absolutely non-existent. Madagot and Colossal Games have not responded to a single critical comment in the main Kickstarter thread. I'm talking about over 3,000 comments. And they've ignored essentially all of them.

It's the arrogance of it. You know, players are asking basic questions. Where's my shipment? What's my tracking number? Why isn't my support ticket being responded to? And the creators just pretend those comments don't exist. One backer wrote something that really stuck with me. The delay doesn't bother me. It's the arrogance that you think you don't need to keep in contact with the people who helped keep your company doors open.

They delegated everything to this company called PTS, Publishing Technology Solutions, supposedly to handle customer service and fulfillment. And PTS is absolutely completely useless. We submitted a support ticket asking a basic question back in October and they literally closed it in November without ever responding to us. A month passes, we hear nothing, and then the system just autoc closes the ticket without any human acknowledgement. Thank you for your inquiry. We're not addressing it. Goodbye. We're not alone in this at all. Other backers report the exact same experience. One person opened a ticket on October 16th asking for their order number and it got automatically closed on November 13th without any human response whatsoever. Another backer submitted a ticket on November 29th about a package being delivered to the wrong location 600 km away and over 2 weeks later still no response from anyone.

And the tracking system is hilarious in a deeply sad way. The PTS website tracking tool claims that UK orders are still in in preparation status since October 14th, but Matagot is simultaneously claiming that they shipped everything to the UK almost a month ago. So either Madagot is lying about shipment dates or orders are leaving the warehouse and magically returning to in preparation status. One backer literally said, and I quote, "Magical crates that exist in two places at once. That's the only explanation that makes sense. It's so absurd that it would be funny if it wasn't so infuriating. But beyond the legacy component mixup and the communication collapse, there's this mountain of component quality failures that should never have shipped out. The card sleeves, for example, they arrived with these white circles printed on them that are supposedly supposed to indicate the sleeves are transparent. Except the circles actually obscure the card artwork, making the sleeves basically unusable for many cards.

And here's the thing that really bothers me. Backers flagged this problem on board gamegeeek a full week before Madagot even posted an official statement about it. So they clearly knew there was an issue with their sleeves and they did nothing until the community pointed it out publicly. Then when they finally responded, they blamed the manufacturer instead of just owning the mistake. One backer really dug into it and basically said that she thinks Madagot approved this design, discovered it was a problem, and now they're passing the buck to the manufacturer to avoid reprinting everything at their own cost.

Plus, people got shorted on the actual quantity of sleeves in their orders. We're talking 15 to 20 sleeves missing from complete packs. And people were promised refunds for the defective sleeves weeks ago, supposedly happening over a month ago. But those refunds never actually got processed. PTS keeps saying the refund was issued, which is complete nonsense because people never received money. When backers follow up asking where their money is, PTS just ghosts them. The cardboard inserts that organized components in the big box arrived damaged or installed wrong in multiple shipments. Some arrived crushed. Some showed upside down in the box, which then got crushed by the weight of tiles and cards on top. The insert was shown right side up in official product images. So either the factory installed them incorrectly or they installed them correctly but shipping destroyed them. Either way, that's a quality control failure that should have been caught.

Territory tiles have typos that actually change gameplay mechanics. One backer reported a tile called springs of bowon that says the card comes into play with a harbor when it should say sanctuary. That's not just flavor text. That changes how you use the tile in actual play. It should have been caught before any shipment left the factory. That's a fundamental design error that impacts gameplay.

And they knew about some of these issues before shipping. The base game Druid card has a typo that completely changes what the card actually does. So, Madagot promised to send corrected versions separately, but most backers don't even know they're supposed to be getting a replacement. And the ones who know are still waiting. Metal coins shipped with duplicate designs on both sides. The same image repeated instead of different designs. Coins are missing entirely from orders despite being listed on the receipt. Frustratingly, here's what really gets me, though. None of this was inevitable. This wasn't bad luck or unforeseen complications that came out of nowhere. This was a series of strategic choices by Matagot and Colossal to prioritize cost-saving and efficiency over backer satisfaction.

They chose to use PTS as a fulfillment partner specifically to cut costs. They chose not to implement any verification process for components. They chose not to respond to comments or engage with their community. They chose to hold entire orders hostage for metal minis instead of splitting shipments and sending people their games immediately with minis following later. One backer, Fred West, made this exact point. He said that if the only thing holding up North American shipments is the metal minis, they should split the orders. Send people what you have now. Send the minis when they're ready. Don't hold the entire game hostage because you have logistical problems with one supplier. And what makes it even worse is that Colossal has a track record with this exact behavior. In 2019, their Kickstarters had almost identical problems. poor communication, incomplete components, unresponsive service customers, people waiting months for their pledges. So, this isn't new behavior from them. They had a template for failure and they followed it again.

They learned nothing from past mistakes. The arrogance of it is absolutely stunning. They're sitting on information about defects. They're ignoring thousands of comments from frustrated backers. They're not responding to support tickets for months. and they're acting like they don't need to maintain any communication with the people who funded their campaign. One backer literally said, and I'm quoting directly, "Fuck you lazy and incompetent thieves. I know you're too lazy to actually read or respond." And another backer pointed out that even if they're not going to respond to everyone, the fact that they respond to nothing tells you something fundamental about their priorities and how much they respect their community. Josh Gibson wrote about this, saying, "Don't expect an answer from them here. Their customer service is deplorable and non-existent in the comments, and this is days before the December 11th update." What infuriates me most is that when the product does arrive without defects, it's genuinely impressive and beautiful. The metal coins are excellent. Backers who received them say they're some of the best coins they've ever seen in a board game. The box design is stunning. The overall production quality is clearly there. So, they clearly know how to make a beautiful product,

which makes the carelessness and indifference even more offensive. You can manufacture a gorgeous product, but you can't respond to a single critical comment in 30,000. You can't verify components before shipping. You can't split shipments for metal minis to get games out on time. You can't process sleeve refunds that you promised weeks ago. These aren't manufacturing problems. These are management and priorities problems.

And the tragedy is that Inis itself is a genuine masterpiece of game design. The mechanics are elegant and balanced. It creates incredible moments at the table. The design philosophy is masterful. A game this good deserves a Kickstarter campaign that treats it with respect. Instead, it got a campaign managed with apparent contempt for the backers who funded it. So, if anyone's thinking about backing their next campaign, here's what you should expect. Zero communication from the creators during fulfillment, slow or non-existent responses from their logistics partner, components that aren't verified for correctness, timelines that mean nothing, and a company that won't engage with you no matter how angry or frustrated you become. That's what they've proven they're willing to deliver. If you already love Inis the way we do, you might be tempted to back another Madagot campaign because you know the final product will be beautiful, but you're taking a real risk that your fulfillment experience will be absolutely miserable. And if you're a new player or casual gamer, there are other publishers who actually respect their backers enough to communicate with them and deliver on time. For anyone out there who got the wrong legacy components like we did, I want you to know that your anger is completely and totally justified. This wasn't user error. This wasn't bad luck. This was negligence at the factory level compounded by complete communication failure at every management level above it. Your frustration is earned and you have every right to call this out loudly.

Inis is genuinely one of the best games ever made. It deserves better than this campaign. The community deserves better and you as backers who believed in this project and put your money behind it deserved so much better than what you got. Thanks for listening while we absolutely vented about this maddening campaign. We're board game critique and hopefully the next one is about something we actually enjoyed. Yeah. Let's hope we're not this angry next

Progress saved