Skip to main content
Loading video...

Orloj - Board Game Review - YEEESS The Ticking Crock!!

Transcript 38:00

Yes, the ticking croc. Hi everyone, I'm Luke Hector and this is the Broken Aba, a show where I devote my time to ranting and raving about board games, but beauty more the latter part. Pretty special one here today because you know if you're thinking about which games were hyped at Essen, excluding all the sort of Japanese imports and the really hard to get ones, this one was definitely high on a lot of people's list. This is Oloy by Paralo Games. And yes, I have Googled it. This is how you pronounce the word. It's a Czech word for the Prague astronomical clock. It is pronounced oloy. That is what everything on Google has told me you pronounce it as. So if this is wrong, blame Google.

All right, that is about as good as I can get. But this is a one to four player game, big euro game, all based around that clock. And I've actually seen the clock now in person. I had a um some of you will remember I had a holiday to Prague, a little city break at the end of September. And I made it so that I I made certain that I would go visit the clock, not internally, but you know, externally. Saw the clock. I got there about 5 minutes before it was striking the hour. So, I even videoed the whole Walk of the Apostles thing that it did. Was kind of expecting a little bit more of a spectacle when it struck the hour. But, you know what? It's cute. And can't stress enough how absolutely amazing the clock actually looks. I mean, as a feat of engineering, it is something to behold. But, God knows how the hell you actually read the damn thing. But, it's Yeah, it's a solid piece of engineering and it's cool. And if you do go to Prague, I do highly recommend you go at least have a look at it. Well, you can hardly miss it. It's right in the center of Oldtown. Remember me.

This is not a review copy. I grabbed it with my own cash and suffice to say the Patreons are eager just a bit for me to give a view on this one because it was really high up there on the votes as to what they wanted me to look at. But, you know, I was keen to give this one a look. Mainly just because that trip to Prague is still fresh in my memory and it was a really good city. I mean, yeah, it's one of my favorite holidays I've been on, frankly. And, you know, I want to see if this is any good because I don't know very much about the publisher. I think they're relatively new. It's, you know, definitely getting a lot of hype and buzz. So, the question is, is it all justified or is this just some excuse to stick a bunch of round things in a game?

Here is an ordinary square. Whoa, whoa, slow down, Eggghhead.

Now, there's quite a lot of rules, so I will try to simplify this as best as I can. You are competing to build the different parts of the astronomical clock. So, you've got these month dials and you've got these zodiac dials, you know, basically big and small. And the idea is is that your actions are based on this clock mechanism here. So there are two aspects to it. Well, technically three, I guess. You have the moon part which just turns around as normal and it's basically a track for you to get bonuses on. But the way that you do your actions is that you will turn the clock at least one rotation and you can spend these deviation tokens to make it move a little bit quicker. You can basically force the mechanism, but then after you've spanned that bit, you can then spend those same deviation tokens to spin the inner ring anticlockwise. So, one goes clockwise, one goes anticlockwise. Once you've got it settled, your worker goes on the spot, and it allows you to take two different actions in any order based on the two rings. And this is essentially how the bulk of your actions are done. You have a few additional actions you can do like converting resources and placing down apostles and stuff, but for the bulk of it, it is this dial. This is what is really coordinating everything and every player is using this and turning it. So where it is and what it's doing is all going to come down to the timing aspect.

Once you have got your worker down on the action, you perform them in any order you like. What kind of actions are there? Well, firstly, you've got mastery tracks. So these free mastery tracks here, when you level up these, not only will they be good for endgame scoring, but they get you bonuses like these seals, which are basically like one-off bonuses you can flip over. But ma mainly they allow you to do certain things better in the game like I can spin the clock more. I get more stuff when I pass. I can make the moon track spin more. You know that kind of thing. You can also build workshops which come in the form of these cards. These cards you place it next to each other on your board. You put them in rows and if you can make the two halves of a symbol match up then it gives you bonus actions. But for the most part these get you bonuses, cost you resources to build and allow you to place these assistants down. Where did I put those assistants? Here they are. These assistants are basically endgame scoring opportunities and they score in various different ways. You have various different things in the game that will let you grab them.

The workshops are where you put them down. On top of that, you can also move this calendar mele. Again, this is very much a game of rondell's here. A rondelle around the main calendar clock itself where it lands. You get bonuses either side. You can tell that rondell's are kind of the theme of this game here, right? You also can construct the actual clock itself, which is kind of like the bulk of your points are going to come from there. Essentially, the game will be set up in such a way that several of these month and zodiac tiles will be on the board already and some you will have to build off the spaces. And the way it works is that you have a little disc on this board. You move it around and where it lands dictates what adjacent tile you're allowed to build. They have resource costs which are based on looking at the exposed areas and rows and columns. So, you know, one might cost me free wood, one iron, and a paint to build, for example. And then you take the tile, you put it down to where it needs to go, and one of your workers that's available will go on it, and it scores you points if you can get them all in a group. This is definitely a case where workers are one of the resources in the game on top of things like wood, iron, and paint, and gold.

You also need to micromanage your workers because you'll only start off with so many of them in the game. You need to unlock them by utilizing various bonuses on your player board. You got other bits you can do as well. You've got tracks you can upgrade to produce more resources. You've got places to put your apostles. What are the apostles? Well, everybody starts off with about 12 of these things. And they are basically, you know, they're part of the clock itself, but via this board here. If you ever get an action to collect an apostle, it's got two at the bottom of these cog tracks. Again, notice a theme here where you're allowed to pick one of these and when you've got these as a free action, you can stick them on your board in the right color spots. It costs resources, but it gets you some cool bonus and potential points for filling up rows and columns. I mean, every Euro game ever, it's all about rows and columns here. You know, quite a lot is going on in this game, but the way it works is that there are no rounds. So, everybody will be taking actions via this clock, utilizing resources and workers as they can, building up the various parts of the clock. But during that time, this rooster is moving along this track. You won't be able to see it from here. Here we go. This rooster is moving along this little bonus track here. And the idea is is when the rooster gets to the end, there's kind of like a little minor intermediate scoring bit, but it basically is a round tracker. So after so many rounds, the game's going to end anyway, but typically the game will end when everybody has built all bits of the clock. So everything the clock is fully complete, finish equal turns, total up some endgame points from objectives and mastery track bonuses and other little things that bops here, you know, like

every other Euro game, and of course, the one with the most,

of course. Yeah, there's quite a bit going on here and that's a very simplified overview of the game. It all boils down to this clock mechanism, which to be fair is the best aspect of this game. I like Rondell's up to a point. You know, Rondell's for the sake of Rondell's is a bit like me and some of these certainly do have that problem, but I like this clock mechanism of dictating your actions. I like the fact that, you know, it has to move a certain distance, but you can make it move further, so there is some mitigation, but then you've also got the other one that doesn't move at all. you're the one who has to spin that. And it all comes down to these deviation tokens. You effectively have five of them that you can keep flipping and unflipping over in order to force the mechanism. And this in itself is essentially a resource that you must not underestimate. These things are very useful. But dropped it there. But I'm very glad that the game didn't restrict you too much on the clock. I mean, you can certainly at the start of the game, if you go too mad with your deviation tokens and don't level up your blue mastery track, you will find the clock a little bit restrictive at times. But for the most part, it should be, you know, you should be able to do the majority of what it is you want. And occasionally, you will get a situation where it's like, I really want to do the construction mechanism, but I can't at this point. Well, what else can I do?

But, you know, there are ways to mitigate it. And it's just a fun mechanism in itself, especially when you've only got so many workers and you're bumping off other people's workers. Nobody gets blocked in this game. It's purely a case of do you want to give that person a worker back so they don't have to take a pass turn. Although, let's face it, you don't really pass much in this game anyway. And it's just a really cool fun mechanism to use. Now, they do go a little bit overboard with the rondell's in this. I mean, you've got this like painter dude who basically circles around the clock and gets you bonuses. Why? I don't know. You've then got that construction mechanism I mentioned where you move this little thing in a little rondelle and that dictates which one you're allowed to build. I mean, that thematically doesn't make any sense whatsoever. It's just an excuse to have more rondell's in the game. I mean, hell, even the apostles are more rondell's at the end of the game. I get that your game is about a clock, guys.

Okay, but seriously, it doesn't need to be like a clone of shipyard. All right,

but you know, that being said, it's still good fun. There was a lot of rules to explain, and I didn't even go over every single one of them, but thankfully, the game is actually not that complicated to like play once you get going. The rule book itself is written fairly well. There's a decent amount of pictorial examples, a fair amount of text. The layout is okay. I think maybe the layout of certain when it explains certain things could have been a little better, but for the most part, reading the rule book should be a good way to learn how to play the game. You could always play the solo mode in here if you really want to help or just play two-handed. But it's one of those games where you have a reasonable amount of options, a decent amount of different things that can trigger, but it doesn't feel like it's overly complicated. It's not ridiculously complicated rules. Each of the actions in this game feels relatively straightforward to do with maybe construction being the most fiddly and even then it does have a nice graphical representation of how the construction action works on your board as a good memory jogger. So even though there's a lot of different things that can trigger, the complexity comes more down from your level of choices and potentially how long some of these turn can take with all the bonuses that you trigger. More on that a bit later. But when I say bonuses, it's a good thing here because it's one of those games that feels quite rewarding from turn to turn. Yes, you can have a turn that doesn't feel quite as good as what someone else does. But the game triggers a lot of effects. You know, I get to do this action here, which then lets me level up this, which gets me a seal. The seal allows me to do this action, right?

I'll flip that over. So, I'll do that. Spend those resources. So, I get this bonus, a few points. I get this calendar bonus here. Oh, that allows me to level up the mastery tracks again. Okay, we'll level up that. That gets me to spin this moon track again. It's there's a lot of different, you know, rewards that you get. And it has a similar feel to what Adidas Dream did. Remember I mentioned about interconnected actions. It's not so much that these actions are interconnected. I mean, they are to an extent, but it's more that in Adidas Dream, if you were if you were lacking in something, like I'm lacking in a particular resource or something that I really need, there was always a way to get it from multiple different avenues. Well, this is kind of the same deal. I need to get up on this mastery track. I need these resources. Well, whichever thing you need, there are multiple ways to go about doing it. It's just a case of whether you can make it work from this clock face here. Hence, be mindful to save some of your deviation tokens cuz you're going to need them. But it means that the game doesn't feel too restrictive. Everybody is able to win a prize at the show. It's just a case of whether somebody wins a bigger prize than somebody else.

Isn't that lovely?

The variety in this game is not half bad either. There's multiple different ways that you can score points. Although the bulk of like the main path that you're doing in order to score points is by building this clock. You know, you can not really go through this game and not build bits of the clock. You're going to need to at some point otherwise you're really focusing on something else. And even then, I would struggle to think that people couldn't beat you if you did that. But, you know, so everybody's got to do a little bit of this clock. But there are different things that score you points in this game and they're all worth pursuing. You know, I will get points if I meet these little objectives during a game where the first person to get it gets a prize. Sweet. I'll get some of those. The workshops can get you a decent amount of points. If you can load them up with assistance and make those good. The mastery tracks, they themselves have scoring tiles at the top. You know what they are. Person at the highest up the track gets to get more points from it. Again, that could be your focus during the game. And there's just other little bits and bobs here and there that will translate to points. It's not a point salad by any means, but it's not that the clock is the only thing that gets you points.

It's just ignoring the clock entirely might not go your way. I mean, you can kind of make it work, but it's tough. You know, it's not easy to play this game without doing something on the clock, but you know, the game is called Alloy and it's about the clock. Okay, I can give it a little bit like, you know, a little bit of leniency on that. But even the setup can be variable to some extent. If you have setup cards to give you different resources at the beginning, there's prescribed ones for your first game, but then you can just shuffle them up and dish them out randomly. That's always good. I like games where the different resources you get at the start can be different. It just opens up different paths that you might want to take. It gives you a little bit of early game guidance. Always good. And you can even vary the calendar bonuses around here. So, this has fixed the bonuses normally, but you can actually put random tiles across to change how it is. Honestly, I don't think that's a major deal really. I mean, it's not like I noticed from game to game. Oh, because the calendar tiles are set up that way. You know, it's fundamentally a different game. N that's going one step too far in the whole v variety of setup, but just suffice to say there is a decent amount of variety here. Not loads. I've seen Euro games do it better, but still a good amount.

The problem is choice.

It is very much a thinky game as well. I mean, there's a lot of different, you know, parts that you're going to have to do, and you're going to have to plan ahead a little bit with this clock. The game has a little bit of interaction more than most Euros tend to do. Although the interaction is not so much I get to do stuff with other players. It's more that everybody is mcking around with this clock action here. So if somebody is going before you and the clock face is here, for example, and it's like, well, I really could do with one of these actions over here, how much are they likely to move the clock? Well, you can see how far they could move it. You can see how many deviation tokens they've got. And based on what they do, you kind of have to factor that in. Although this is both a positive and a negative because yes, there is a bit of interaction with this clock and it is, you know, definitely a thinking point to think, well, how much is that clock likely to move by the time it gets back around to me? In high player counts, the clock gets a little bit too much on the chaotic side because once you've taken your turn, if three other people are going to act after you and they've got multiple ways to move the clock, you know, high mastery tracks or whatever, then you might as well be waiting until the person before you takes a turn. And even then, that could be dubious because the clock is going to change. so dramatically by the time it gets round to you. You don't really get much time to think about your next turn. Um, I'll elaborate more on that in the negative section, but you know, it's just to say that yeah, there's a little bit of interaction in this game, which is nice.

You know, most Euros are entirely multiplayer solitaire, but it does come at a price.

Short answer, yes with an F. Long answer, no, with a butt. So, let's go into the negatives. First off, I want to talk about the art and like graphic design used in this game. I wouldn't say the art was terrible. I mean, when this is on the table, it certainly does turn heads. People look at it and they go, "Oh, it's very striking." It's a little bit too striking, though. I mean, the the color palette is highly saturated and the graphic design is, you know, relatively straightforward to follow. In most cases, it's just trying to actually find, you know, the icons that you're trying to do can be a little bit problematic. And the sections are, you know, they blend a lot into the background art. So, as soon as you get this out, the first reaction that most people have IS MY EYES. [groaning] AND rightly so. It reminds me a little bit of what Heaven and Halee used to have, that style of art. And honestly, this is not my favorite style of art, you know, from a stylistic choice, but that's a personal gripe. But even then, it does feel like it's a little bit too much in you, like when you're trying to visualize the game state and like, you know, what's going on at certain bits.

some of the tokens, some of the tiles and things like that can just sort of blend into the background a little bit too much. Like almost like it blurs it. You're kind of playing this game almost like you're on permanent motion blur effect. But it once you get used to it is not too bad. It's just I think maybe they could have toned down the color scheme a little bit. You know, still give you color. I don't want it to be a beige euro. But, you know, maybe you know, well, here's a prime example. You look at a board like this, you know, from the photos. Then remember what the board looks like in KBAN EV. Now, I'm not saying no tool needed to graphic design this game, but you know, in Carban EV, the new one, how easy it is to see where all the different bits are. The se they're sectioned off really good and nothing just blends into something else. Well, this is something that could have benefited from that. Section these bits off a lot better. Make it so that they're very distinctive and not all just blending into whatever background artwork there is. It's just just needed to stand out a little bit more.

You get to make and break the rules here. It's also quite a bit of a table hog. I mean, it does require a lot of space here. I need to have a, you know, I need to have this board somewhere with a bit sticking out of it, which normally it wants you to put above the board, but if your table is rectangular, you're not going to be able to fit it in that way. It needs you to have a player board with, you know, other tiles sticking out from the left. You need to be able to put cards out in a horizontal row, cards around the outside of the board. You need to store the resources and that. It's going to demand the space, especially with four of you. You need to make certain of that. Please excuse the crudity of this model. I didn't have time to build it to scale or to paint it.

Setup can also take a bit of a while as well. I find setting this game up a bit of a chore and there's not a lot that other players can do to really help because they can sort out their player boards. Although there's still quite a lot of workers that need to go to different places on the board. You've got to tell them where to go. But the biggest like setup chore this game has is dealing with all the different objective tiles that you've got where you've got like I think like three or four different things in this game where it's a case of right take a random one of this color and a random one of this color and a random one of this color and put the rest back in the box and you've got to do about four or five times. So it gets a little bit problematic there. But this is the bit that takes the time. You have to basically put all the dials for the month and the zodiacs or whatever. That's a endgame thing. You have to put them all into this bag and then based on player count, you have to take a certain amount out. And then these are the ones that are blocked on here. So you have to put these block tiles on the zodiac and the uh month dial bits. Then you have to draw another one out of the bag. Then you have to put them on the actual calendar like illustrated way up. Then you need to rinse repeat this for the zodiac one. So once you've done it for the months, you've got to do it for the zodiacs.

This bit takes forever to do. And I wish there was a easier cleaner way to do it.

How hard can it be? I don't quite like the way that this clock is built up so much before the game even starts. That's actually um kind of leads into another flaw here. I mentioned the player scaling. We'll get on to four players in a minute. I don't think this game works that well at two either. You know, it's not that bad. I think two player is better than four player, but the problem is is that a lot of this clock is built up before any game starts. Even in a four player, like a quarter of this clock is already finished. I would have liked it more if it wasn't built up to that extent. Yeah. It creates little pockets and groups where when you put things in a group of workers, you get more points. So, I guess that's what it's trying to do. But in a two-player game, three quarters of the clock is pretty much finished. You know, there's barely anything on the construction tiles for you to actually build in a game about building the soding clock, which is kind of a little bit weird, but you know, it just makes the two-player feel a little bit like this is just a little minor thing now, and now we're really doing all these other aspects.

But then, let's get into the four player side. Four player. As I mentioned, this bit feels too chaotic in four players. This clock will move so much by the time it gets back around to your turn that planning ahead in this game is, you know, damn near impossible at times. And this leads on to two problems which are probably the main problems. I've mentioned a few small ones. These are the two main ones. Firstly, the AP. The AP potential in this game is pretty high because not only have you got different things triggering all over the place, but because you cannot really in a fourplayer game especially predict where this clock is going to be pointing or anything at any particular time, trying to plan your actions in advance is pretty tricky. Now, the actions do repeat. I mean, they they appear on opposite sides of the clock. So, hopefully if it passes it once, it will go around to the other side, but there's no guarantee of that. And if you don't have the ability on the mastery track or deviation tokens, you know, willingness to spend them to actually make it spin all the way back around again, it can mean that you're waiting essentially for the person before you to act by the time you can plan ahead. And then based on what they do, you have to kind of reset your plan sometimes and go, "Right, well, now what can I do?" And this gets people into that AP nature which because there's a lot of different things in this game you can do a lot of different actions. It does make people freeze up.

Not helped by the fact that there's no reference aids in this game. What? Seriously, how much have I got to bang this drum? You know, the reference aids in here are printed. You know, that is a waste of space. There's nothing on the back of the book. So, you couldn't even print anything there. They instead print this appendix and the back two pages of the book for like, you know, what each scroll does, what the objectives do and all that lot, which is all well and good, but then it has like the additional actions here and what the the different icons mean on the tracks and the sculptor actions and everything. It's just like this is the sort of thing I want in front of me. I mean, you've got like seven or eight different actions you can do in this game and about five or six different additional bonus actions. I need that on a reference aid in front of me. People who were learning this game that struggle to remember this kind of stuff need reference aids. And we've done this in so many other games. If you can make, you know, punch out boards like this, if you can make wooden screen printed tokens, and if you can put it together all these like crazy cog mechanisms and whatever, you can make a couple of A5 sheets and just give them to me with stuff on them. I mean, Seti, for example, you remember the little booklet thing you got in Seti? It's one of the best reference aids I've seen for a game. give me something like that because some of the iconography isn't clear on certain things. You know, the the additional action to like spend the coin as any resource. You get this tiny little card in front of you with the additional actions on it. That's the only age you get. No words, though, so you don't know what any of those six symbols necessarily mean. Now, some of them are pretty straightforward. Yes, you'll be able to figure out that this

is this, this is this, but the icon, for example, for spending a coin as any resource looks like the icon for just spending a resource. So, it's not clear from that icon that it means this, and there's one or two others that fall victim to this. Now, yes, there are more complicated euros out there where the actions really desperately need a reference aid. You can play this without the aids, but seriously, publishers need to get into this mindset of trying to make their games more accessible to people and stop hiding them in the penultimate pages of a rule book that I've got to keep finding and passing it around and everyone's got to go, "Oh, hang on. Let me just get this massive thing here. Yeah. Let me just see. Where do I need to look at this? It's It's annoying. All right. Does it take that much?

Here's the big one. Downtime. Downtime can be pretty high in this game because you've got a lot of different things that can trigger. Your turn may simply be to go on here. I get to level up an upgrade, get a coin, and produce some wood. That could be how short your turn is. But your turn could also be something like this. I Right. Okay. I'm going to trigger these mastery actions. Okay. These mastery actions are going to get me a seal. Right. That's cool. Get me that seal. It also lets me get an assistant or the moon. Well, I'm going to trigger the moon. So, I'm going to make my uh, you know, moon track go. I've lost the moon counter, but say I'm going to make my moon counter go around here. So, that gets me these resources and lets me flip some deviation tokens. Great. Um, but the mastery also has got me the seal. Well, this seal allows me to do uh a painter action. Okay. And Okay. So, I'm going to move the painter around here.Uun dun dun. Uh this lets me get those mastery track upgrades as well as a resource of my choice. Great. Okay.

Well, that's passed me over another seal. So, I'll grab this one that allows me to construct. Well, I'm going to do a construct. So, let's see. Construct. I need to move this thing around this rondelle here. Pay these resources. Get these points. Uh oh, I can get um apostle as well as a bonus from this. So, okay, fine. that apostle. I'm as a free action. I'm going to put it on MY BOY. HOLY CRAP. GET ON WITH IT.

HOW LONG IS THIS GOING TO TAKE?

A little bit insane at times with the amount of stuff that could trigger on your turn. And it's rewarding to the player when that happens. It's a pain in the ass for everybody else who have to wait for you to finish all that stuff. Turns are vastly different in terms of their length for players. And if you're only doing like fairly smallish actions because either you've, you know, had a bit of a problem with your efficiency or that's just what you needed to do there, it can be a little bit annoying when I'm sort of sat there going, "Well, I can't really plan my next turn because there's loads of people to act before me and your turn has taken about the same length as an entire round of turns. Come on, get on with it." It's, you know, it doesn't happen all the time, but certainly the fact that you can't plan ahead on this and the fact that so many bonuses could trigger for people does mean that turns can extend a little bit beyond what a normal turn should take.

And if it's done by a player that can't handle lots of different things triggering, then you enter into that whole problem of everything stretching out to a different time limit. And you might even make a mistake fig, you know, missing out. Oh, I was meant to be able to do this, which lets me do that. Ah, I forgot. How do I retract this? It's that does come up there. I would have like maybe there was just a little bit more constraint as to how many different things you could do on your turn. Like maybe you have infinite times where you can spend resources as the resources. Great. But then stuff like the apostles, the construct or stuff like that. Maybe it should have said that you can only do one of these certain things at a time. So there could be four different ones that could trigger during a round, but you can only do one at a time or something. you know, just maybe constrain it a little bit cuz it does get a little bit out of control, particularly with four players.

Oh no, I've gone crosseyed.

And there's some minor little balance things here and there, but you know, this is sort of my opinion. I do find that, you know, these little objectives that you can gun for, the ones where it's first come, first serve, I think they're a little bit harsh because there's first, second, and third for endgame points, but there's a bonus tile that you only the person who gets there first gets. So, it's almost a little rich get richer. It's like I got there first. I get a cool bonus which is really handy and I get the most points. It, you know, just feels like maybe the bonus should have been available to everybody, but the seals I think are a little bit of an issue because you get the seals quite easily by going up the mastery tracks and they range in power levels because on the one hand you might just be able to move the moon track. Well, the moon track's pretty damn good because you can get a lot of resources and deviation flips there. I mean, you know, when you're able to move the moon about six, seven spaces, the moon actually becomes slightly overpowered in that respect. But there are other times where you might just get a coin and level up your rooster track, which is just how many times you flip the deviation tokens in the intermediate phase when the rooster gets to the end.

Whoopde-doo. It's not even that important. A track and the point differential that you get in there, like lose a point for each deviation unflipped and gain a point for each extra one. It's really not that much of a deviation. It's kind of a minor part of the game. But those feel like really minor bonuses to get for a seal. Even like an upgrade, upgrades just don't feel that great to be honest. Upgrading your forge, which is a little tile that gives you more action bonuses when you do a construct, is paramount. You should always upgrade that to the max because you will be constructing often in this game. And the extra stuff you get on top of that could be invaluable. But upgrading these, I don't know. The production doesn't feel as needed because you it takes a while to upgrade all of these. And the only reason you're doing all three of them is because it unlocks other workers. That's really the primary reason. I think they put that in there because they realized that not people weren't upgrading these tracks enough because you only upgrade it to two regardless. It's just you get two in another basic or two in a gold if you get it all the way to the max. But I found that when I focused on production tracks, it really doesn't end up translating to much. It's usually a lot better to focus on one production track because then when you have the ability to spend free of anything for a gold, you'll make a lot of that particular resource and so you can just make that your focus. But given how easy it is to get resources from things like you know some of the like the sculptor one getting you coins and gold which are basically like you know great resources, the fact that the moon track is so easy to trigger and by triggering the moon

track you can get like you know multiple resources and stuff pretty easily on that front and even the calendar bonus can help you get more resources. It's it just doesn't feel like the production track really contributes a lot to that fact. most people are swimming in resources all the time that you know the amount of time it takes you to upgrade those feels pale when you could just literally make the moon spin and get most of what you need anyway. But the other thing is that some of these seals allow you to get apostles or do entire painter and construction actions. Being able to move the painter can be pretty solid because you might move the painter and it lets you do an upgrade. So, why would I have a seal that lets me do an upgrade when there's a one that lets me move the calendar mele which can get me to do an upgrade and get me something else? One infinitely feels more powerful than the other. But on top of that, construct. Construct as a seal bonus is insanely powerful because construct is a big way of getting points and it's like one of the key aspects of the game. So, the fact that I can do it from a seal, I'd rather take the construct action and do a tiny little cube upgrade. it. You know, I have found that that, you know, getting additional actions from these sealed tiles is probably a little bit too overpowered compared to the tiny little bonuses that you could get. So, there are some little iffy balance bits here and there. It doesn't destroy the game, but again, I have noticed this and other people have as well. It's just something to bear in mind.

There'll be plenty of time to discuss your objections when and if you return.

Following on from the negatives, we go into the solo mode. And there's not a huge amount to say about the solo mode other than honestly I don't think you should bother with it. You know, I I am a solo games player, okay? A lot of my games I have to play solo, but you know, even I will stress that not every game needs a solo mode. And I think this one was a prime example of that. Basically, what happens is you have a fairly easy to pilot, I'll give it that, or Tom Deck. But the way it does its actions is not only quite cheaty. It doesn't require a lot of resources or gathering or anything like that. It basically tells you in advance what it's trying to build. Like I am trying to build these particular tiles on this clock. How are you going to compete to beat me at that? So it kind of forces you to play an optim optimization puzzle to try and stop the AI based on what it's broadcasting to you. Now, if you like that sort of thing, the solo mode could work for you. But for me and a lot of other people, this is a common complaint. It feels flat and it doesn't feel like the multiplayer experience you because it forces you to do what the AI is telling you to like warning you about. I I am going to build these. You must stop me or you're going to lose basically. So I must do certain things to stop the AI. I don't get to do what I want to do. You know, I want to play a game solo and it's like, okay, cool. I'm going to I'm going to munchkin this ma mastery track here and see what happens if I go mad on this and workshops great.

But if the AI says it's doing something and you're not doing anything to stop it, the AI is just going to steamroll you. And to be honest, the AI is able to do things at a much quicker pacing you just generally that chances are it will just steamroll you anyway. It's bloody tough to beat this AI. But when all s all said and done, as much as it's relatively easy to pilot, it's just not a mode I want to return to. You know, if I want solo modes to replicate the multiplayer experience as best as they can without being overly complicated. Well, this does a good job of not being overly complicated. You know, the AI is relatively straightforward to pilot. There is a section of rules that you are going to have to learn and some extra terminology here and there but for the most part the solo mode is basically about say three four p yeah yeah about four pages and there are difficulty levels that you can tweak but you know for the extra little bit of overhead I just wanted something a bit you know more like come on you know I can't get players to this table I want to play it the the game of alloy and play it similar to a multiplayer experience well the solo mode frankly isn't the same as a multiplayer experience. And for me, it just probably shouldn't have been in the game. It's definitely not worth picking up if you're a solo player and hoping that that's going to be your prime way to play this.

Nobody wants to play with me.

So, a long review and finally we get to the verdict. Is Alloy worth it? There's a lot of good and a lot of bad for this. Uh the most of the bad stuff is relatively small bits and bobs, but one or two major parts with the AP um issue and certainly the downtime between turns. Player scaling could certainly be a lot better as well. I mean, two feels like most of it's already built and four just feels a bit too chaotic and long for what the game needs to be. Free player definitely a sweet spot, but I like a lot of the action stuff in this. I love this clock for, you know, warts and all. I love this clock for spinning it around and trying to dictate your actions via it. You know, that is a cool mechanism and it's good that you've got those deviation tokens to mess around with all the rondell's. So, the rondell's don't feel crazy restrictive. You've always got a way to mitigate it if you're playing, you know, the game right. There's a lot of different avenues for points. I mean, you've got the mastery tiles, you've got the workshops, you've got constructing the clock, which should be like a main focus. But, you know, there's a lot of different ways that you can score points in this game, and you can approach it different ways. Good amount of variety in the setup with the different resources you can get. I mean, if you really want to customize the calendar bonuses, you can, but you know, that's maybe a little bit too far. But, and also, I like the fact that the game is not crazy complicated. You know, this could have been a massive complex game of rules and everything with all these actions, but no. Yes, you've got a lot of choices, but each of the choices doesn't feel too complex in how they operate. Construction probably being the most, and even then, that one's not too complicated. So, as much as you do end up with a bit of a front-loaded rules

explanation compared to something like a Mine Clash Euro or a Lerta Euro, it's definitely a lot easier to get into this sort of game or even like Galactic Cruise for example. Yeah, this one you'll definitely gravitate towards more than those if complexity is an issue for you. Although, you do need to be able to get your eyes right to be able to see where a lot of stuff is because of this art style. But, you know, that could be more just a personal stylistic choice than anything else. It's a solid game all round, but I think it's held back from being a particularly great game. I certainly don't think it's like excellent, you know, one of the best of the year. But I've enjoyed my time with this and it's certainly been worth giving it its plays, even if for the most part I'm going to want to play this as a free player game. And you could maybe twist my arm to play it four, but honestly, I'd rather play this at two and three players. The solo just it changes the game too much. It doesn't feel like it was a worthy inclusion and four player maybe just oversteps the mark in terms of time length which you know you're talking 2 and a half hours for a typical game. Um you know which doesn't feel too long in terms of compared to like a 3hour game or something but because of the downtime between turns that 2 and 1 half hours does feel longer than it normally would.

It's it's still solid though overall. I'm giving it a 7 out of 10. It's a good game. I recommend it for Euro fans, particularly if you're a big fan of Rondell's and you like to have a lot of different uh, you know, little different choices on your turn without too much complexity. It's just, as I say, it's a little bit restricted on player count. It's a little bit, you know, prone to AP and downtime issues. And, you know, there are one or two little balance aspects here and there that do kind of grind me a little bit. But, yeah, overall, I've enjoyed my time with this and I can recommend people give it a try. It's just not maybe going to be like a a top 10 wordy game of the year or so. But yeah, give it a shot and see what you think. If not, then at least go to Prague and go see the clock itself because the clock is definitely worth seeing. And honestly, Prague is definitely worth seeing.

A taste worth protecting no matter what. So, that's it for me on this episode of The Broken Mele. If you like what you see, then thumb it up on YouTube and thumb up on board game when it goes live on the page. Check out the rest of my content. There is plenty of Essence stuff to come, but I've already done Sanctuary and Argato. So, by all means, check out those reviews in particular. And yeah, there's more to come. I mean, I've lost count as to how many Yes. And games I've still got to do. There's plenty more to come. Big games and small games. There will be full reviews and speed reviews of plenty. So, by all means, let me know your thoughts in the comment about this game. What do you think of Alli? What do you think of the clock itself? What do you think of Prague? Have you been to Prague? Do you want to go to Prague? You know, by all means, share your little holiday comments down. It'll be quite cool to see. But yeah, overall a solid effort from a relatively new publisher. Be cool to see what they do next, but maybe just take some of that feedback on board and hone it down for your next one. So, take care and remember, as always, regardless of whether you can understand how to read this wretched clock or not, it's still only a game. So, bye for now.

Progress saved