Intrepid: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for intrepid uh this was once again a another kickstarter uh that uh i usually here's the thing i need to just stop backing games on a whim absolutely because i back games the reason why i back as many games as i do is for content for the channel that's really the majority of it um and this one this game isn't all bad however you know what this reminds me of uh at night when you're done oh my god another game not as severe you boot was like the asymmetrical app-driven submarine simulation pretty much it was everyone had to know their great oh yeah it was really cool but it was like hey do you have three friends and all you want to do is play this game then that's that's who that's for and submarine you know enthusiasts this one obviously is not as intense as that but this is one of those games that's fully cooperative asymmetrical which i think is cool you don't see a lot of asymmetrical cooperative games um but the problem that i have with it is because it's asymmetrical you can't really you can't really be cooperative like this to me this feels like it's very solo co-op like i'm rolling my dice i'm doing exactly what i need to do because i can only place on my tiles and maybe i'll help if someone speaks up if no one says go ahead no no i was just
gonna say i think that since we have played this before also we switched our our boards up since we've played and i think each character may be better at getting something else based upon these tiles like the top like which color they are right if they're well not just which color but like i think that when i played the nutrition board um my character was better at getting food well your your tiles because the the resources food and yeah blue sides food and uh oxygen red is climate and power your tiles stay the same like so this is just a glorified i mean and the asymmetry isn't that much it's just you have a special ability every person has one special power really just how how their dice are manipulated right but the reason why this game it's very odd it demands i think four but it's four people who know what the [ __ ] they're doing with dice and everyone if this game there's so much that i want to like about it but what bogs me down is at the end of the day and i don't like oversimplifying games because you can do that with everything oh golden raven this is play two cards you know so and i hate doing that but this one is very i don't get the theme out of it i get hey do some math equations it's a very mathy game yeah so if you're
not good at math make sure you have your phone out with your keys yeah and because of the asymmetry it's like i don't i don't know how cat is getting extra dice kind of have to know how each person plays or go over that in the beginning like we didn't play with japan which is that's the weird the tilting like you roll you roll your dice and it's like oh okay that's how i do that and i flip it and oh it's like okay well everyone's all done i roll perfect so i'm already done i just have to kind of wait around you know yeah and i mean i know we're not into individual thoughts or anything but that i mean the way we ended the game on just that destructive of a card is like you know i'm sure they play tested it yeah but how much did they play tested to know that that card it's like that was like super debilitating and i understand the game is meant to be incredibly difficult and i i don't mind that at all but when you pair it with math it's just like some people already don't like math so this is already not going to be for them because it can't be like oh there's a little math like people hate power grid for that exact exact reason oh man there's so much math i don't even think it's that bad but for this one i'm just like yeah i understand oh this just needs a two through five i get that sure but whenever you have stuff like america which is a complexity one and it is but it's still like okay i need to do this okay then that's gonna let me i'm gonna place that that's gonna go up to a three okay i don't need a three does anyone else need to throw a lot of calculations that you have to do and you know i'll be honest like
i know that she likes this game you know why because she was right there with you as far as knowledge on how to play the game right and maybe i'm wrong but like yesterday when we were playing and she's just like no you can do this and you can do that right she's never that way about a game and she's the same way tonight but for me like dice i like dice games um so dice usually because that's just how my brain works dice are always good for my brain right no i'm right there with you and and watching and learning this character really stuck with me because like this was one that i could totally get even though it was considered more complex of a character this made sense to me and it worked well for how my brain does things yeah no i i totally i totally get that hey what's what's it's weird because i'm conflicted because i'm right there with you it's like i i love the analytics and even though yeah there's very little theme the theme really is in the the mission the missions or the mission cards and the disaster cards that's really the only like you have to kind of pull it out so then it just kind of comes down to equations which is fine but it's the fact that i can't help people who are weaker at math at this game without quarterbacking well to be fair i'm not great at math i'm not but trying to you know work through what i had and what i knew i could get to and then trying to figure out what he had right but it's also this is a good game
if you want to be stronger at math and that's why i like these types of games because the more i play games like this that make me math the better and stronger i get at these types of games sure cat i hate math and i didn't like this do you think you would like it with a different character because there's a bunch in here and we will talk about that because you don't think so what it came down to was all this like just i didn't like like the way the tiles worked i i just didn't like placing the dice i didn't like um constantly having to monitor okay it's going down one up one i think that is a f and not to interrupt i think that's a fair assessment on my baby episode there's a lot of stuff to keep track of it's like okay now we have to drain now we have to move up there's there's a lot of i mean it's almost like dude like steps one through nine it's like yeah like there's a lot of that and that's a lot when there's a lot going on here and they have they do they have a pretty good balance and this is why i think it demands four because it'd be weird having to have another board because i tried i tried playing a four player game and i was not doing any of the synergy with the with the dice but so it's like okay cat and i or power and climate only do power and climate tiles um unless other this is only with the the four characters that we played in the run-through so unless someone else has weird tiles depending on which one they have but and then um
and then blue nutrition and oxygen does nutrition and oxygen but i have a tier three that has a power that's right yeah see what i was talking about here's the thing with my blues my tier fours are actually kind of funky i have i have a advance is the mission yeah yeah and i have all i think we all probably have but then i also have this one which is i can gain any of the resources if yeah yeah so definitely getting up there but here's here's kind of where it becomes difficult like you want to play with four they have really good balance between between the two but because it's asymmetrical you're only really worried about your own dice and because you control one resource you want to only be worried about your resource but you also have to be in sync with your other player yeah and a lot of table talk is required between players and so there are times where i mean you have to constantly yeah like you said constant communication where whenever something happens it's like okay yeah i can do this and that'll get you the power that we're now losing okay and if this isn't like a knock on cat at all but this is just this type of game if one person doesn't say something that throws the game either like if cat was like hey i'm at negative 21. i'd be like well i'm buying some other [ __ ] like i thought you knew it was a negative 21 because we were that was the whole turn though that we were all really sucking each other's power so i i was like oh just we're all taking i think because we were also trying to focus on amy because we had the mission that we were like oh here's the stuff that we that we can do to get amy sing without thinking of of the power so i wouldn't say this game is
thematic really in any way like especially when tiles get destroyed i absolutely hate that rule where you don't get to reduce the drain it's like it makes sense when you turn it out the meteor hits the ship and destroys the power oh well look at that we're not using that power it gets moved over here yeah that that that i'd be interested to know if that house if that if that house rule would break the game reduce the drink or yeah it's like hey we i mean we lost these two tiles i mean i lost two of my starters so it didn't even matter but like if you lose that one oh cat gets to reduce drain now because we don't have this aqua pad system working anymore well and see you took a hit on both of your your big power tiles in fact all the big power tiles took a hit and so that was another problem because you took mine from my oxygen to make sure i had oxygen well the road really is really shitty at the beginning you know we got crushed over the other side so which i don't mind that so much it was just it it's it's a lot it's a lot for an asymmetrical game where the only type of communication i mean you still have to if if cat says hey i'm a negative 23 we can only do so much without [ __ ] someone else over yeah so the game is actively against you you have math and it's not even the dice i don't think which is actively against which is actually that is going to be a lot of people's gripes if they don't know that this game requires you to always be doing math i mean yeah it's addition and subtraction
but it's a lot of it being able to okay so we're going to get okay that's 11 that's 14. so that's okay that's 20 25. i'm going to get to plus 3. so 28. okay so what are you over there well that's five but then now it's minus two so 23 okay and then on top of that it's minus 18. yeah and then it's like oh now it's a weird number it's not minus 19. it's like ah and then something causes you to oh but add three yeah and all for culmination to be like doesn't [ __ ] matter because you're at you're in the three yeah so we just lost you know we you know we we really we got hit really hard in the first couple rounds and lost our reserves right off the bat and uh it felt like we were always behind we could never we could never catch our breasts maybe we were just too low on oxygen the whole time yeah we could never catch our breath i would i didn't say we were always under water but right right the other thing is is i don't like the fact that we have to reset back to the the lowest negative yeah because if we're only using that much drain we should be able to accumulate the the reserve yeah once again it's it's the game's not thematic it's that's that's a that's a game mechanic no but i mean i think that that is a mechanic that is detrimental okay correct but hold on maybe they tried it that way and and when they did that people were all the way up here at the resources i mean think about it you'd be getting way up there and nobody would ever lose the game but that's why you take these cards and that's why you add in like okay you've now had this uh power surge so
you now have to drop like x and that or or make the tears like increase and drain because all the tiers no matter what up to tier four they cost more capacity but they're always the same drain which is nice but if you want to keep the surplus like what amy is saying then now this requires you tier four means minus four drain minus three minus two minus one and we don't know if they tried that either sure yeah but just you know just things that i think or you think that would make this even better and i think that in all fairness we can't say it would make it better without us trying it yeah but that's not my job right i paid for them to do that and i mean they made the game that they wanted to make and you backed it and i backed it because i mean i mean because here's the thing what's funny is you check facebook tomorrow morning for sale you see including shipping yeah you see this you see this cover this badass cover and then you play the game and you're like where's this well and that's a great amount of boxes where we're out there oh this dead guy yeah that's us right there well she she also doesn't look very concerned yeah she's just like she's waving goodbye she's like i'm in the escape oh god we seem to be a little close to the sun too but it's it's like in terms of gameplay and like the the cohesion of playing the game is is fine i just think that it has a lot of things working against it that this is going to be for a very
select group of people it's a math dice manipulation and placement game we feel that the theme isn't there i mean i can see how some people would be like oh it's thematic you know our power converter took a hit and now we're in trouble sure i can see where but to me it doesn't feel like we're in space on this station right the missions don't even really make any sense to me like blood sweat and tears how is that a [ __ ] mission like like you would think you would think the missions would be something that were actively doing to not die they would have whatever restart the power converter or something like that or maybe these could be you know spend your your leftover resources spend six left over energy in order to recharge a panel or something like that that would possibly work i could see that working better yeah like oh you know we're we're repairing the power core so we're eating more because we're out there busting our butts and to be fair we would not be letting all these meteorites hit us and not have anything well i mean it hit us but then like not have anything to repair anything yeah that was kind of a bummer it's like yeah there was no way in this i understand that this is the way the game gets harder but it's like really we can't do anything about the holes about the holes like just nothing we have no special abilities we have no tiles no nothing to be like oh i'm gonna patch this um i get it everything that is thematic is it's only there just to be like hey this game's hard no you don't get to keep your surplus because we need the game to be hard no you don't get to repair the holes we
need the game to be hard so uh we can't we don't want to balance it that way we want to make a hard game but i do feel that the training mission we played yesterday super when we cleaned the club oh yeah it was yeah the generation is literally just to help you learn your are these tiered in difficulty are they all supposed to be the same with stepping so you talk about the the missions the designs the disasters yeah so there's there's four different levels and i think there's like six cards of each level you shuffle them up and then you okay you take three of those and you take three of the orange and you stack them but the other disasters what are they are they in the same difficulty like they're in the same idea yeah there's toxic leak and then solar flare i think is the other um the other one okay um it sure does go from zero to 100. yeah that's the other thing it's like okay yeah you have the training module the training module like i said literally just teaches you the mechanics of the game the meteor shower one which is the act one of the actual scenarios and there's three that's the game that you're like you're not gonna lose the training mission um you're gonna this is rough like because yeah we never touched our emergency supply we didn't do any of that and then here it's just like oh turn one great using emergency supplies already like that um and that kind of bugs me it's i like i don't mind difficult games like purely co-op synergistic cooperative spirit island is my the best co-op that i in my opinion because everyone communicates and times their stuff appropriately and it's still difficult
but here it you feel that the game's against you from the get-go and then you add that's part of the the point you know i mean you're on the space station there's a disaster and you're [ __ ] sure you better but then just look at the game be like oh okay i got it and then don't play it be like like i unders i very much understand what they were going for that is the theme they wanted to do but it's still a game and you still have to have some semblance of wanting to even continue i'm just trying to figure out how they get these this much resource well maybe they don't roll like you know poorly yeah they don't eat ass they don't get a core get their tier fours out i mean i i have no idea how they could have done that without still needing to get dice i mean if this wasn't disabled to get 25 food in one shot it's it's huge yeah so i also don't like the cr like the career badges i really don't think they're like if you're gonna make a difficult game like these should be almost op not i mean not like overpower it's just like win the game like but but something more than oh i can move a negative tile from somewhere to mine like just remove a negative tile like why why can't it just be give someone three capacity imagine if you were like an engineer and you could um reduce this yeah just one time just once just one you only get to do it one time in the capacity phase so why not just have yours place a
place a place an amplifier place an amplifier um i don't remember what you should give someone to die yeah just just have someone's special ability with these not be like overpowered but something to give you whenever you have cards that are so detrimental like the ones that we got and even if you never got rid of those like these these stack yeah so these tiles would have been double hit oh then you roll again and we would have lost a long time ago if i wouldn't have cleared those two yeah and and so if you're going to have these be so destructive have someone's one-time career badge ability i just want to be pretty
so in terms i mean and to add insult to injury the component quality is pretty pretty garbage really the tiles are good the dice are good everything is good even the cards except there's uh well i'd have to grab the box they have a variant you can play with they have it to where the text is like this and when you flip it it's upside down so you have to flip your card like that to read it that's just annoying but these are so finicky and cheap they bug me so bad it's the cheapness that bothers me the wheel i didn't really care about too much like um i mean how many times you're probably not even at negative 21 you're probably a negative 18. but you bumped your board and it [ __ ] it spun well i did not have problems with that but what i do have problems is like this like really just irritating yeah it bows and uh i i also i i really just hate this i don't want to have to like i i think i think lean on it in the interest of saving costs instead of doing a two-sided like encasement where it would sit a little better they just did the little lift and then the spinny thing oh i see so had they encased the spinny thing it would have been different about how many car games really encase of spinning thing i mean there's not too many games with spinners no way no a lot of health benefits but if we're talking about that yeah but if we're talking about that that would be the only thing i could see that would fix it is to actually have you know what i'd rather have i'd rather have a separate thing hey here's the climate and it's a
condensed tiny thing don't you don't have to have your player thing on it you don't have to have any of that i get what they were trying to go for with that i do too i mean but here's what i noticed though when you flip the board over um and you lay down theoretically yes this is flat and should spin correctly however it's bowed and so it's just what also bothers me is this is like a thin plastic or a thin thin piece of paper so it bubbles oh yeah yeah so you're you're you're supposed to do that yes it's not because these are these aren't curving no it's just because that's paper yep so these were curving now yeah they they went this could have been done right it just needed another piece of paper glued to it it needed to be better material and this is fine this this i mean granted that kind of pops out but you just push it in the board the board is fine i actually the board is nice yeah i like that they have these because they don't move around a whole lot they'll move around but then like if you need to get them out it's not weird you don't you don't have to flip it you can just pop it down and grab it this works this they it's just it's i it's one of the more annoying things that does stand out i don't talk about component quality a lot unless it's either really great or really shitty and in in the interim of the game where this is actually a huge portion of it it's just really bad i don't know i don't know and i wonder if all of them came out like this oh yeah that'd be interesting i don't know mine did leave a comment yeah if you're if you're like this yeah were they u-shaped
and bubbled a gentle ramp i i'm conflicted on this game i'm not this is oh i know but that's the thing is i don't know who would play this again i would i know amy would but i don't know if this would work as a two-player game unless amy and i went full stephen hawking and we're controlling two k and we're just like i see it here's your dice here's my test i would play it again 80 capacity i wouldn't play this disaster again yeah i would play a different well it's a shame there's only three to pick from well but i also there's your expansion content but i also think yeah switching out your your nations i think would really change it up too because like i'm comfortable playing this country but give me another country and then i'm gonna have to relearn it give you weird japan like this where you have that's part of the that's that that's an appeal asymmetry root is just like that it's like oh i want to play but what that means is that that gives me the replayability and then i can see if i would like it more if i did because these are also going to change yeah so and and then it matters if you play the red side of the blue side so there's replayability in this where there's a lot of unknowns and you could find a combination that you like even better yeah or worse well they yes you're right the tiles are different really only in the asymmetry of your dice they're not different in re because
at the end of the day you're you're doing the same thing over and over and over at the end of the day like you say the game is the same game yeah every time you play yeah it's not like if we had root on the table and we're all playing different factions and like okay cat's invading over here i'm gonna go blow up your sawmill over here every game is different right this one it's we're taking the same steps through i mean the captain is that is kind of like that but there's so many more different things that happen and it happens more often that you have to mitigate those it's also not a two-hour game all right captain is dead well i guess it depends on who's playing how many players you have you know because plays up to seven but um yeah but like yes yeah right so it's yes you're you're really just trying to constantly gain the same four resources and whether that's by using dice spending dice to gain dice or using your tiles to gain dice it's it's ultimately gonna be the exact same game um but how you play it changes yes but it's the same game i i won't deny that the i mean because you're always going to start with the same starter tiles you know whether red or blue but that's that's fine this is the thing that might change for you yeah you know it's not like if we're playing suburban yeah we start with the same tiles but the offerings are going to be different we can build that from there so like if i had a red board like my blue board is food right my red board though is i would go around
yeah it's it's always yeah it's just reds are always power and climate the i mean speaking of the nations though one thing that i actually saw today was someone talking about the representation that wasn't interpreted uh which is actually really interesting because since it is the i think it's the international space station they do have a vast uh like cast like there's only one america then they have like they have uh south africa they have japan they have brazil they have a lot of different countries um you mean multi-ethnic representations yeah which they which i mean i'll give them props too because i mean they're very inclusive in the game yeah so and i think that's pretty cool uh it would have been even even neater if okay there's not if the tiles were uh there's one for solo because you can play this but if it was back if it was like here's a male german and a female german um that would even double their their representation so definitely gotta give them props to that i mean the game comes it was it wasn't expensive either it was like i think 90 bucks total for the all-in and you got like 12.
no that was like what 90 with shipping i think so that's amazing it wasn't that expensive of a game but yeah i think you get like 12 total nations um and then three scenarios i would have liked to see more scenarios probably affects your replayability you've got the training this one the toxic leak and then the other one and then the expansion yeah i don't know i don't know i think the game works but this is going to be force this is not a casual co-op game this isn't like oh let's i can teach you pandemic this one's like hey do you do you yeah do you remember those elementary school minute math quizzes oh my gosh that's this remember how fun those were and how much of a good time you had you like anxiety and feeling stupid whenever you forget to put a diet on the tile and that causes your your game to it's like well then this is the game for you yeah it's it's an odd one i think so okay you're the one who hated it the most you got anything to no anything else [ __ ] on it i'll never play it again i have no interest i have none i have no interest i don't ever want to play and rep it again you guys get anything else you want to add throw one on the table all right on a scale of one to ten we'll start with cat because everyone's gonna be super duper low i'm gonna give it that hot ass four oh okay that wasn't that slow yeah well i can't say they did a bad job i mean i just hate it now this is sheamus shawson that's what
is explain your ratings what was shawson's joshua was the quiz yeah well because um again it's playable other people enjoyed it it's math heavy so i just i can't fault it for being it is is just fundamentally i'm not good at math and i don't enjoy math i don't think it's fun and i thought i think you had a better time playing shawson she didn't like the questions you know what three [ __ ] she's like hold on wait because i was gonna go with three and i said maybe two oh it's a one yeah give me the torment die it's a disaster no it's not all right it's a three first it's confirmed sure yeah i'll give it uh amy um i would do a six six yeah i um i would play this again i think that it would be harder if i played a different character because i'd have to relearn that stuff right but i would play it again but you also have to have the right group to play this game yeah yeah you have to but it's hard because like you have to have a type a but also at the same time it's like very hard playing with a type a right and that's the thing it's like i mean a lot of people are gonna use not a type a won't get this done like yeah i'm a type a and it was yeah i know you might be you might be a type b no i'm a time banner no oh wow oh wow [ __ ] alphas no i'm type a i'm not even close to type a so let's not go there type b yeah that's me it's a five for me i'll play it again
once more but it's a five for me yeah all right it's gonna be oh well and i was gonna i was gonna say with cat's thing it's like this game a lot of people argue that quarterbacking isn't like games don't cause quarterbacking and i'm like i mean sure yeah i like definitely it's a player thing as well but i think there are certain games that lean more into it this i think this is the prime example if you're playing with someone who's just like i don't know what to do i don't i'm not i got these it's like [ __ ] place to die i would argue like even in like the structure of just not even just as players but if you were to take it thematically like someone has to be a leader in this situation someone has to help you with the commander we didn't hear a word or more from the payload specialist yeah it's like because i mean you're sitting there like okay we need this much and someone who's quick at math or like stronger at math they'll be like okay so this is okay that's gonna be 28 okay so that's gonna be that so that's good so i need you to do okay you're not doing anything with your diet or if they can't it's like oh okay if they catch something and they can optimize it for you it's gonna be hard not to be like don't play for me like yeah or people can do that and then it's like okay then we'll lose and it's like fine let us lose it's like but then i don't want to waste an hour and a half but then i don't want to play i'll go play another game where we'll win or i'll have a better time in an hour now and that's the other thing it if this is this is a challenging cooperative game i would much rather play other challenging cooperative games that are heavier in theme that i have a better time with that everyone doesn't have to be a strong strong in something deep madness down this is great i mean i'm thinking
yeah deep madness uh i mean eldritch horror um robinson caruso no no robertson crusoe spirit island if you want a complex cooperative spirit island without a doubt uh you give it a five times
uh i think if someone was like hey we need another person would you play i would jump in but i wouldn't bring this to a game day and try to get people to forgot to play it i'm bringing it i can bring it but like kind of with amy said it's like imagine if i was just like i'm gonna try complexity four and then i'm just like a newborn baby trying to figure out okay you have to spin a die on your finger and flick it and you got to see it it's like what's up and you gotta catch it behind you trick shot you have to okay what is it if it's a two we can't place it damn it but there are the there are the people that like are space nuts and space games and that's their thing and like brandon brandon he would he'd be like oh i want to play this game space game and he wouldn't math that's the thing and this game is a six right now but i could see going it wouldn't it would never hit an eight it would hit a seven if i was playing with people who were math nerd like and i'm not a member basically basically not youtube that was steven cat not me not me here's the thing they're like totally not a math nerd it's five not a three this worked for me yeah and it's just this character but if i handed you germany and i was like okay would you like have fun you'd have to be like oh okay i can use the six to get this two and three out okay now i mean okay no i got it anybody who plays board games should know how to play an asymmetric game just like root you know hey pick a faction board you know read it and let's go you would think that but that's why root is not anyone's top ten i mean it's it's not i
think it isn't my top ten but that's why it's not in like the top ten of bgg because casual people can just pick up even the simplest faction of root that's not true i love being the river folk because everyone just buys my love but they're not they're not easy to win with no but i'm trying but that's the thing is like if you're playing a game respect the game and aim to win and even if we had to cheat like one round when you were like ah which one when you changed it you're like fine we're doing this i was like i should have lost yeah but i was showing board up on the space station were like oh no i didn't install that power converter i put the thing over here instead look if you're gonna have core meltdowns in the middle of the disaster deck i'm gonna cheat like that's a that's a level four that is a red alert i mean hey the core just shut down not system impact now they said they say oh the core melted down oh you mean shut down don't wait yeah this one which is a level four explosion i get that one not cool meltdown meteor strike anyway if it's hot enough to melt through the core it's high enough to melt through the spacecraft uh but once again another thing to talk about i do like i do like the way that the missions do work like i like that you can preemptively start planning um and you can activate them at any time uh instead of being like they're instead of always being a constant thing like you can be like okay we're good on oxygen boom now let's try and go for it but you still are racing against the
clock because the deckhand right now so i do like that that the players dictate when they want to try you can try and hit two all at once if you can manage it and potentially shorten the game you can because the game's against you but but anyway yeah i'm gonna give her the six cool so potentially a seven if i was playing with math nerds yeah probably [ __ ] valedictorians who love space you love yeah yeah stephen hawking yeah stephen hawking neil degrasse okay bill nye neil degrassi tyson jeff bezos he does love space and elon musk and i would just be like can i have all your money you guys not even all so yeah i was like hey try this game with your infinite money can i sell you this game for eight billion dollars he's like is that a lot bezos would be like i think i have like 5 000 copies in the warehouse i bought the company don't even know the company name anyway that's our thoughts on the intrepid let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you wonderful hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you