Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 46:25

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for nightfall and this discussion is going to be a two for one because we're going to be talking about the team verse team aspect as well as the cooperative so the run through was the cooperative version uh that was just easier to record and um i just didn't want to do the team first team as a run through uh so which one do you guys want to talk about first what you just said you want to talk about team first team or co-op let's do the cooperative because it's pressure on our minds that's fair okay this is a whatever cooperative game yeah um that was fine yeah i mean i didn't i didn't hate it uh i felt it confirmed to me exactly what i was thinking when i was told this is team first team this is cooperative this is campaign yes you have three different modes and none of them are done exceptionally well right not saying that they're bad right technically the campaign we don't know um i feel like i would be more into the campaign because ryan lockett wrote the stuff right and it would probably it's just one or two players you just kind of can go through it another horrible overall theme like generic stuff for stuff like that it's a fantasy generic yeah just demons coming out for those knights defending them right uh but the cooperative for me i never once felt like we were in any

sense of like oh man if we don't pull this off yeah so i mean if we look at the score because we can talk about awesome team versus team team vs team it was 10 to 9 points at the end here it's what 10 2 7 6 6 yeah six and i never felt threatened by it yeah and it's only six because we actively let them kill right because we knew it was going to benefit us to win the game anyway right um so the thing i probably what might do better and again this is kind of a hard thing i think you draw one card you do the primary ability you draw the second card you do the secondary yeah because the fact we could choose we chose a lot of times where they would do the less optimal players right and see i was thinking of that and i even was nothing yeah that's what i mean by the less optimal play yeah and i even double checked that i was like okay you know what let's just see let me re-read it draw two cards from the cooperative deck each cooperative card has a primary action at the top and the secondary action when you draw the cards place one of these cards right side up in the second card upside down so that in and of itself says you pick right in what order they do which makes it more strategy than luck based in that sense right um but it also doesn't really it doesn't lend itself to being a good ai system right right because i was going to say the ai is pretty stupid in fact most of the time based off going off the rules which for the record in this rule book it you can clearly tell cooperate the cooperative mode wasn't was a second thought because it's a page right like in fact it doesn't even give you any unique setup or something it's

just like hey set up for the standard game but now you use this ai deck it's like i i like the fact that there's two abilities that's pretty cool you don't see that a whole lot usually it's just here's the enemy and here's its massive sheet of [ __ ] it does right so the fact that it's like okay well i have this particular amp therefore it's going to do something different in terms of replicating of team verse team not really i felt like there wasn't any strategy there now to be fair one of the things i do think is you it's a game night you're teaching this game to random people the cooperative mode especially with that ability to basically make it easier so it's not rougher on people yeah it makes the game a little bit more enjoyable for that aspect for like so what i call almost the game night demo right that's how i play and then once you've got those rules down like you understood with nice too boom it's team vs team well i i would agree with you except you can only play co-op one to three yeah so so then if you which you technically you can play team first team with three people or two uh you're you don't play team that's not a team right like one versus one is not a team right two verse one one side's a team uh and the other person is just okay i guess i'm here um but there also wasn't a whole lot of cooperative strategizing not really really we pretty much each took our own turns we knew our strengths we saw our options and there were a couple of times i was like

well what do you i have to think about this and yeah right it's like hey as long as the imps don't come out then we're good i don't care what what it does part of it is i just didn't want to bring up every single time well which of these options should we all choose together that's true the other thing we did not do other than for the magic portal any spot that had a special ability we just fully ignored yeah most of the time this one this one's like the magic portal like that magical oh that was the only one that we did because you don't ever really have to utilize it the ai is so stupid right and i mean half the time yeah based off rules it was like okay well theoretically would do this but it should make sense to go after this elder right because yeah like it's the weakest one and like whenever with the imp lord summoned a imp and it's like okay well technically it doesn't say where it goes but i it would make sense for it to go in this one and kill that elder outright yeah all right yeah but the square special abilities i i don't think that it adds anything useful no i think it just complicates things unnecessarily it in co-op or just interiors um and we ignored them most of the time i forgot about them most of the time yeah i think and then it would really give you your magic if you can spam your ability right um it's the only one they get utilized on a regular basis the only one that people focus on we forgot multiple times the minus one health on both sides monster and yeah person we've got the heel one i don't think that was as many as often

but i know it did i think it's also just because they're on the corners they're all on the edges and so if maybe well actually no never mind they're all going to be on the edges because the seal always has to be in the middle right but they're all on one side so if you're if you're on any of the main half of the board then you're like well they're never coming into play right uh yeah so it's like you can't play the cooperative to get people used to the game i don't think that's why because then you're gonna be like okay we have three well to do team first team we need a fourth player well they don't know how to play right and unless it's the person teaching yeah that's true yeah and i think that's gonna be a bigger undertaking than most people want all at once yeah hey you want to learn this intro game and then play it for real right and i i've never really liked stuff like that um where where the intro game is just a shell or even a in this case a completely different mode right like it's like it's not like a tutorial to a main campaign where it's like okay well we're all learning it's learning it together now let's play out the rest of the campaign together right like sleeping gods uh glute haven jaws of the lion bard sung has a tutorial where it's like okay here's a little bit here's a little bit of stuff so you're familiar with the game yeah and now let's add more so it's not as overwhelming yeah i just wasn't being honest tutorial wasn't even a tutorial it was a here's what you do oh and joshua sleeping gods yeah yeah um exactly what happened pretend you drew this card

but because they illustrate the point and explain right draws the line does something similar where it's just kind of like hey here's your basic attacks your first attack is this and then it kind of opens up for the next five games of the tutorial system uh but here's the weird thing is like i don't i never understand what these games who they're for yeah because it's like okay do you want a you know 1v1 like strategic move around the board to fight each other then you're then you're usually not getting people who like cooperative games if you're willing cooperative games and you're playing a game that's not really designed for that right so you and this is kind of like well you multitasked multitasked on too many things and you failed on both of them yeah uh which to be fair uh i guess i say fail that's more harsh this isn't a you know dog [ __ ] cooperative game it's fine yeah but it does feel like an afterthought it feels like it's a team versus team game that they went hey we can make this more versatile yeah hey oh well we don't want to upset the cooperative gamers right it's the same thing of adding solo to right tons of games that don't inherently need us exactly or uh the reverse of that it's like hey we designed this game for four players well if i want to play with five all right fine [ __ ] here's your fifth player expansion the game's gonna suck now right but here's your you can do it uh so i mean it did a decent job of

having okay we're tied to these imps and on your turn they go first so you can't ever really predict what they're gonna do right which is kind of like if someone was playing the demons you don't know exactly what they're gonna be able to do right but all of that alluded to well it doesn't really matter because we just have so much agency over anything right so i never felt like they were a good ai and there's no way to change any of that because once again an afterthought rulebook is great it's literally that it's it's just this page and this is just some clarifications for specific games for two demons the implore than the frozen lurker so the rest of it is okay i guess they move like hey here's how they move here's their priority target which is on the back so that's it i don't know like on a scale of one to ten i'd give the co-op five feels too high for some reason i i agree but on the scale of what we normally give a five i think it is a five it's not a bad game but it's not a great game it's got some flaws but it's got some smoothness yeah so yeah so put it right in the middle like five it's just never going to challenge me yeah like i was looking for a co-op game it's not my type of exactly yeah but for people who want to play a coil game who want to play a light game that wants to socialize and have a beer and relax and game with friends and kai know it's

going to be hard to lose yeah go for it yeah those kind of games are always so hard to me because it's like if i want to do those kind of stuff i'll just do those right i'll play or i'll play jack box or something right i don't i don't want to do the whole rigmarole of setting up the game to then casually just say hey yeah or i'll play party games but yeah it's just so so odd i've been in game groups that that's that's what the game group felt like always it was snacks and beers and they played like games which you know it's great i i can do that right now and then yeah but then i need my chunky game right i need my i need to actually be challenged and those and those attitudes to me always feel like larger groups would want to participate yeah that's also true and this is weirdly limited yeah it's three is limited well i see it feels to me like it's an evolution of ghost stories and last bastion very very similar oh mechanics very very similar board layout yeah um definitely adds layers of complexity but you know and some value on top of that but it really just feels like an evolution of that yeah sure yeah and especially i mean i guess i would rather play this than that right because at least i have some control over what i'm doing uh add additional powers that come up into play yeah i mean again this goes to both of it the cards are cool there are all of them have three options pretty much for the most part yeah there are some that don't but even the ones that don't have three options i don't have

one in my hand right now um kind of still give you two options because it's still a double of two different options yeah i think there are always three options if you think about it because you have the two and then the minor action on the back right so you always have three options on every single car which to me that's cool i like that yes um the multi-use cards is definitely the highlight of this game yep um i like the seals because the seals are pretty powerful they they are yeah are you guys giving the co-op a five i'm getting the copper five what were you giving it i would go sexy six okay um and see that's not even like offensive like right i can see people just kind of like who could enjoy this this is definitely just not for me right um so then we go to the team verse team which we played prior to the cooperative because i wanted to at least talk about that because that's the main way of playing it right um so i can see the team verse team being stronger than my initial thoughts because this rule book is it's not the worst i've ever read right but lacking in some key ways and in some very specific details that in a team verse team can make or break right you know how dudes well even just you'll notice we don't have four anymore we had four for the team first team uh but yeah so in team first team one side plays the demons one side plays the knights then the knights technically start out with one a point ahead and they get a point

consistently at the end of every round so it's like a yeah longevity how long can we survive before the demons inevitably kill the elders like it's just gonna happen um but the the demons can jump in in victory points uh quite rapidly actually when so with the team first team uh i thought it was actually really balanced i like i i never i felt some some powers like on the demon side might have been more busted uh did you guys ever feel like oh man like those nights like that ability sucks like that's that's oh again against us yeah like it's like because like there were times where we were like okay the imp lord is clearly o.p uh i would say just overall the the fact that the knights can just jump in and defend the elders instantly and it's hard to work around that yeah maybe that's what the balance is that the knights can constantly just ramp up their defense and hop in i think at any given moment and the demon powers are more powerful right yeah to be like okay fine you want to defend we're going to kill you and then at least get a point that way i will say that the whole elder's mechanic is a really nice strategic and and it's a it's a great addition over ghost stories last bastion those types of things having a third element that is a goal that is something that right it's not a requirement to achieve but it really is

it's fundamental probably for the demons like i i can't see the demons we're depending on just killing knights yeah because the knights get point per turn so that means demons have to kill twice both nights each time each round they have to kill both knights right um just to keep pace yeah yeah i think so no i agree i think the elders is a very very nice change of pace it's not just you know our knights versus your demons it's it throws a little wrench in there where it's like man do we let that elder die right because we sacrificed a lot of knights in the team versus team to save elders yeah and well because there's also that one it's yeah we could let him go and keep that night i think it was one of the when the wind knight died it's like you could sacrifice him because that only gives him one point instead of the two and i like that kind of way of thinking right and that kind of decision making that okay my knights good but is it good enough to basically give them an extra point right now yeah like are we going to benefit more by keeping like so like the healing knife i probably actually would sacrifice an elder to yeah try and keep him around or even if it's even if we have the wrath night out it's like yeah okay yeah because like if i have the wrath night before you get to go it's like yeah let that elder die because i can do two damage right to you know to brett and he's already gone right uh so since he can't go anymore unless

like the other demon player is gonna be able to run in and heal him then you can probably kill him and conversely the demon strategy is primarily how do we wear you guys down yeah you know you hit everything how do we separate from you and attack the ice yeah how do you move us into corners to where we can't rush and defend right yeah and and i mean that's it's fun that there are different strategies you know so if we played the same four people reverse the teams yeah i think it would be a very different feeling kind of game yeah and you know what i was actually this is going to sound way worse than i than i mean it to be and so i apologize if this offends but whenever i set this up as team vs team i thought that zach and i would have an edge against you and other zack because we just play games like those like competitive 1v1 kind of game so i was like is this going to be too skewed to have those type those like-minded people on the same team no i it it this is actually a surprisingly competitive game where it feels like it meets it works for every type of thinker right where it's not like okay if we do like if we if like if there was like a team chess game i feel like zach and i would do relatively well against people who have never played chess sure yeah uh but this game it's like oh you've never really played the team first team tactical movement game you know what that's fine i feel like you're gonna do well but i think some of that is the fact that

so these cars are super random yeah but not random enough like you can't kind of have an idea of what you're going to do but there is no real super long term strategy because you're getting a new hand everything right right yeah you can't hold on to cards you can't hold on to cars so so even players who are less strategic still can compete with strategic players because the strategic players just can't long term plan yeah they can better plan in a round theoretically yeah but we've seen this game can change rapidly that a round might not matter that much i think it would appeal what do they have an age recommendation it's not convenient sorry i was looking at the number of players i was like wonderful but i actually like 13. okay yeah i can see that i guess he's clever 12 13 year olds enjoying it yeah the um with their parents or their uncle aunt right with uh with the way that the cards so drastically change and the fact that you can't hoard credit cards yeah i think that is what kind of gives it an edge of balancing everything out because you have no way of predicting what your opponent might be able to what that what they might have well what your next card's gonna be yeah like because i saw there were definitely cars like oh wow if you had those three cards in a row you could like destroy a demon in one move and then move 14 spaces you know do one damage every spot you move yeah yeah it's true the chance that you could ever get those cards because you can't hoard you can't yeah store up you can't

basically you know keep until you get that right hand and even with the the possibility of other enemies slowing you and then you actually just kind of effectively i like the fact that it didn't just doesn't just take a card away right it's like no you can still use it it's just now one of these shittier actions right and um it's better than this card but definitely not as good as any of these any of the actual ones yeah and i think the fact where whenever each time i got a new hand it was like i was like this seems the best way to use these however the board state i got i got them this way this like this isn't cool but range attack range attack range attack all right i killed you one point that wasn't cool but i had all these badass abilities um because like you were talking about the seal and mark cards yeah uh which i still haven't figured out if why he i think seal is just for the knights i think so okay that's kind of what i was thinking mark and the demons mark um you can only ever have one of them yep and all of them are good oh it's good well [ __ ] i mean some are a little bit more situational but yeah they're all good like so i have one imagine the quiver of life that you can use range attacks to heal on the the um who was it not the one night on the seer night yeah you can use melee attacks or range attacks it's like oh yeah okay i'll just be here and just [ __ ] feel better one pulsing flame on the holy night every time you move into a space do one damage to an enemy she also heals

so literally you can just walk around doing damage while never dying yeah yeah and it's really cool that they cause that would be good on anyone right but there are some nights and some demons that certain cards are better for right uh not that they're specific to them but it's like yeah this is really good like we saw it with the imp lord yeah he you have the heel of the heel at the end of your turn then it effectively wiped him from even a consideration of us killing him right we had to do so much damage consistently that was like i don't think with both of us taking our entire turns we could do it enough right right i mean we probably could have if we in one full round if we killed all the imps because then he would just get one but then again it's like okay then his entire turn is bringing him back out he his magic ability if he we'd have to get lucky and hope he doesn't have magic well but you can spend two every two cars so you can get two imps tomorrow what because you can spend four cars to get two amps so he would have three amps uh no the basic doesn't get yes it does yeah never mind yeah so it's so he he could have three amps every single round yeah we have this finish that he was also the first player every single time so he always had an extra amp no matter what yeah um then he could then basically look around the side i could always make more imps if i want to and so basically it was an unblockable fortress pretty much especially because it's like his create and he also gets to take an action with it right and he can place it in closer

or jason so like really in all reality he should have just holed up in the middle yes and then just spawn them in adjacent spots and then have them attack it doesn't matter who is attacking them make them walk away make them go into corners um so the farthest way possible yeah so i just i really do think out of all the demons the imp lord is the most busted right like yeah all of them are good and that's the thing is like all the demons and all the knights are good like i don't feel like well this one's useless you know yeah yeah but i mean the molten scion has health i played four of them in that game and they were all they were all good and it's like we didn't really get to see them utilize super well because we had to focus fire on you because it's like well the implore is [ __ ] useless or not useless like not even an option yeah it wasn't worth the amount for one point it wasn't doing enough damage to basically say we have to do this right yeah so it's one of those it's that risk reward type thing where yours were doing a lot more damage mm-hmm and we're easier and we can kill you so it was points and damage control yeah which is its own interesting balance is that you know it's it's an annoyance yeah but it's not a real problem yeah because i feel like he's not at he it could have just been best case scenario for him because if he was last then yeah he's he's effectively he sucks ass yeah because yeah he's going to get one imp at the beginning but we just kill it right and then we can focus fire he only has five health and then you can destroy them pretty easily yeah so that

is very fascinating that some knights and demons are stronger weaker depending on turn order so which do you think that's a benefit or positive or a negative i don't know because there's a stagnant turnover right demon demon knight demon knight and you would at best build to do in the team battle where basically go demon and demon demon then demon right because demons always have to go first yep so it would just basically say whoever was the second you know first night second night it would just flip-flop equally right um i think in the rare currents like where you had the implored be the first one it's kind of just unlucky yeah uh it definitely gives probably a slight advantage to the demons in that situation yeah but it's also just a draw of a card it's chance yeah technically demons set up and it's like oh we got two okay well i'm going first i'm picking up lord right uh it's true yeah it's like i don't know which would have been better if it goes demon knight demon knight or if it went demons go first but they pick who goes so nice go first and they pick who goes right so how i would probably do is uh because you know the demons are gonna go first give them their demons they pick their demon then flip a coin for which demon goes first because then if i choose the imp lord i have a 50 50 shop actually going first if i don't i pretty much hurt my team realistically versus help my true because yeah because i'm

giving them a point because they're going to focus on me on that immediately yeah that would be interesting to see how that changes yeah it may not it may not be that simple personally yeah because because the other demon player can summon demons some of the time depending on that is also true they're like and they can uh well actually yeah any demon could use command to add two to add a name that's right oh is that the add yeah you you so you can use a closer adjacent or use two to add an imp so if the import was going last then it would be like okay on my turn i'm just gonna use these commands and bring out more for you um so i mean still he doesn't re like he can only use m's i guess if he's commanding as well but his ability doesn't allow him to utilize them except as defense right uh yeah personally i'm not a fan of the static turn order i think and it's it's hard because you want to keep it tactile like onitama or or chess where it's like it's a i like i'm gonna take two turns in chess um in a row well yeah but it's not such a strategic game that the turn order really matters that much i think it is oh i think i think it becomes that i think the first few plays of and there are a few games that are like this where it's like yeah you're kind of playing the game but then as you play more and more then it becomes more about trying to read other people and trying to strategize more against okay so 100 during the end round like my imps were attacking

because i knew it was always last i had to make more decisions of do i even jump in to defend stuff because i'm giving two demons a full turn to come and kill my knight i'm that much weaker yeah um where like seth only had to contend with one demon so zach had literally come in and just wiped him out all by himself before he had her to heal to move off action to do enough damage to basically threaten yeah um because anything exactly yeah anything zach could do to me not not this one the other one to me he had to hope i couldn't counteract it like if he does four games mean i'm just like okay i'm gonna heal then your turn is effectively null and void if you wanted to also kill me right granted that's also if you're trying to kill the knights which isn't your primary focus right yeah it is to whittle elders down because we only have so much healing right um we have to kill you guys to stay ahead so there is there is balance there yeah i just don't like the fact that you it are always going last yeah like zach is always going first there's no and then that i think you actually lose teammate cooperation yes yeah there is there is some there where it's like hey can you like i have these multi-use cards i could probably kill brett but i really want to use this ability can you do any damage no [ __ ] it it really stops it from seth has to rely that i can finish up

any tasks that he could where let's say i had a good way to start like just doing mass damage all around and then the set can go and choose what to clean up after the action there's never going to be that option yeah so if i had something that was just kind of oh do one damage to everything yeah well zach's going to get a turn before that and when we have the instance in between that they're going to do all their actions between them there were times like i can do one damage to all damps so they now just all heal yeah but they would all yeah it's kind of a wasted turn at least you feel it's a wasted turn but it's like in all reality it's not because then they all have to heal right and they're not instead of doing other damage um i don't know i wouldn't have done the turn by turn i would have done it in either like okay it's the demon's turn they pick which one goes um and then the knights pick which one goes then the other demon goes and the other knight goes i feel like that allows a lot more agency a lot more strategy and a lot more cooperation between teams right i definitely i was thinking what if you went demon first than the two knights and then the demon but i think that would just be and it's gonna be hard once you got to three on three true or two on fire right yeah so the alternating i think that's one of the reasons why they have it stagnant is because it doesn't matter than a player count true yeah and also it's probably to inhibit the kinds of synergistic attacks that you guys have right been talking about because if if the same team got

all two of their characters go at the same time i agree i don't think two i think that would be 18 going two characters at the same time works but um not be able to change which night goes first yeah is a little bit more refreshing what is the other frustrating part so let's talk about the negatives um this rule book is extremely frustrating it is so like lazy in its explanation that it comes off very much as the designer was like yeah no i get it it's like well yeah you you [ __ ] know you made the game like you need to write rules as if you are explaining it to the dumbest person and because you didn't do that you should play test it with the dumbest people you can find right right so i'm just gonna make a [ __ ] i'm not gonna bring politics i was like man oh that's a solid joke for that but no uh but yes that's exactly kind of what you do because gaps in your like in your mind oh attacking and dealing damage those are the same thing well yeah to you but when people are specifically are reading the fact that your rule book says something different and your playwright says something different then it it brings into the fact and the implore is the best example of this where it's like when attacked you may trade places with any m so the attack hits the up instead okay cool what's considered an attack because we have cards that say deal

damage is that an attack or is it specifically when someone uses the range and melee icons right because and this was a long discussion it was it actually came down to who wins yeah like i mean i mean it's a fundamental strategy of the entire game yeah is whether or not you can do this based on what i do exactly and that's so frustrating because those types of discussions always come off as if the the people arguing are lying to be able to twist it in their way so they can win a game and it's like no here's how i'm trying to figure it out and it's frustrating that we even have to do this because in the rulebook it states okay here are your actions then melee and range say deal one damage and all these cards say deal three damage it's like okay well let's apply it to other games that do this and i mentioned gloomhaven where it says deal damage that bypasses defense okay so that's just a flat damage therefore the implore's ability cannot go off unless he's specifically attacked well no because then we find out in a [ __ ] example later on that it states dealing this damage is he's attacked by this card that says dl2 damage right and even explains it as um adjacent's range and closes melee yeah because that matters for the wind lord yeah the wind knight yeah because it can block range attacks anywhere on the board right yeah but because you have an action that specifically says range and then these these

cards are saying deal damage adjacently yeah they only need to add one word to each of those phrases right to clarify one melee damage yeah one ranged attack yeah or icons on the card because you have things that say close or adjacent so just put both icons on there yeah exactly because i also remember yeah i mean we've even got the player rate that says here's what's closed and here's what to jason yeah so why not add here's what's melee and here's what's ranged yeah because whenever we were describing the first the very first attack you guys did zach was like oh can i use my ability and i remember saying well in my head closest melee and adjacent is ranged but that's not what stated yeah they don't use those words yeah and they do use those words so how do those fit and that actually is probably the most frustrating thing you have two terms so this is range or adjacent yeah just call them one or the other yeah so this is range or instead of um range attacks it's a json attacks and then all your terminology goes off of that closed decks which there's no melee there's close attack yeah and i mean but this is where he was he was making assumptions because he's like well i gave you this he's like what more do you [ __ ] want you morons is what what t alex davis is saying because when you look at this it says melee attack close one right so it's like yeah you can read between the lines and be like oh clearly this is obviously what that is it says close that's melee therefore you know we can jump in and defend his knights therefore every time the imports

attack he can swap it with an imp yeah but the most insulting thing along on this very subject is that they even added terminology to one of the player aides yeah so they knew that there needed to be some clarity right but they missed that there needed to be more clarity right it's like yeah because it's like terms should have been like oh what's you know what's that and these are good because these need clarity yes they're heavily implied but it's specifically spelled out so you know exactly right like what's an ally what's an enemy yeah allies are everything on your side enemies are anything except you except oh yeah that's true yeah cause some games use ally as also yourself yeah yeah and so spell it out very clearly these are good you missed a few that turned out to be very important exactly and and that that [ __ ] is just so frustrating when you're trying to be like okay well let me let me try and find in the rulebook oh let me scroll through the story stuff in the campaign and the one page co-op and then let's see if i give you an example and then see if i can and but that's the thing is your rules should not be in examples i agree that is like he must have like it should it must have been like an intern he didn't feel like paying to read the rule book um because it's it's so bad and i always hate because apparently there's a there's an updated one and it's like well happy you don't release the game then i think there's there's a fundamental flaw in some play testing which is the author is teaching the game

yeah and here's the book yeah no no here's the game here's the book you tell me later yeah because so many so many designers i'll be here in about two hours you can tell me how you played it yeah here's here's a clipboard a pen and paper write down every like no matter how asimine you think it is write it down because if it's not clear and there's six of you playing well then it's not it's not you guys and tell me what you guys made up as the rule yeah tell me what your guys's assumption what you guys came up as a group is the rule if i don't like that i think that's not how it should be done i need to explicitly say how to fix that part yeah because if everybody makes the same assumption like you play test this ten thousand times and yes your wording is a little bit often you should go fix it but every makes the same assumption like close means close attack it doesn't matter what it is yeah then you're fine you're good right your terminology clearly i clearly everyone got it right if you don't have it where it's at least 90 percent are doing that yeah you didn't write it well yeah because sometimes some people just don't get something right but if everyone we had four people playing the team first team and it's like we were all like on totally different wavelengths right and it's like if it was one person who was like well that doesn't make sense to me but the other three are like well it's so obvious that it's that then yeah it's a different story but we were all like well here's how i took it here's how we did it okay well actually no that's not

how i heard the way we were doing it right and then we discussed it long enough that at least two of us flipped sides right yeah like you convinced me well you convinced me and in a game that wants to be tactile like this you you can't have those options because it's just it's gonna feel more personal right and i i just don't like that um but other than that like i think it's a pretty it's a pretty interesting um you know strategy you know team burst team i don't play a whole lot of those um but you know the weird part i don't see myself playing this a lot like one once again i would need four and if i have four people yeah i'm not doing this three or four maybe one v1 wouldn't be bad maybe for 1v1 it is each player draws no that you can do the campaign campaigns cooperatively two players each player draws three random character cards from their team deck and chooses two okay so you control two demons and so but in that instance it would be that would probably be the way i'd want to do it because then you can decide which demon you want to do like if i controlled you know the two knights you know if i control the guardian knight and the phase knight i'm for the record the design of all the uh knights and demons i think is great yeah i really like their design i think they're super cool and they fit well to

their names and the cards the icons is all very simple and easy to follow the art's great the try and lock it what do you expect right um yeah i mean i honestly like the um typeset that they used i don't know what kind of art style you would call this gothic no because it looks i don't know because it's not clear it's not crystal clear it's like very it's like weirdly faded and like as if someone did a crystal like like this was very highly detailed and then they went and and smeared it yeah it's like a near near impressionist yeah it's just so i don't know i anyone who anyone who's an artist could let me know in the comments but i like that in the 1v1 because if i had the phase nine the guardian knight oh it's it's my turn as a knight okay i'm gonna do i'm gonna use i'm activate this one yeah which i was reading the re-reading the um the way the turn order works and it almost seems like that's what it was going to be once again this is just not clear right game structure starting with the first character a demon always goes first each character takes a turn and alternating turn order demon knight demon knight which leads me to believe that yes you have a very static hugo i go you go he goes but as written it is flexible it does sound like that it was kind of like each turn the team can decide who goes first which character on and because if you're playing it as a two-player game that is how it would be right you pick which one they go you're as a demon player pick one go and you do the other one

which would definitely increase the team dynamics so i honestly at this point probably just house rule if i was going to play this game and just say um the team is going to make the decision every single round you can decide that you know you take two minutes look over each other's cards yeah you make a decision you announce to the table so there's no changes up so that way yeah um you can't change cards or anything like that right yes this is oh man okay here's what i got right because like if the demon does something that just completely messes up our plan like it's the night well you may well okay you go and then i might be able to fix it yeah because then then it relies more on strategy you're not reliant on like if these were my if these were my cards and then you know you do something and it's like oh damn i don't have anything to counteract that okay like it it's like it would allow me to be like oh okay well brett can you do anything to stop that yeah i can okay well then we'll have you go yeah cause then maybe i could do something with these right so again maybe that was his intention to leave it ambiguous maybe but i i hate that i need it's like i just i don't like that because you don't need to you could just stall out saying like hey you can go static turn order or you guys as a team can always make a choice of which one goes which yeah or even because i don't like house ruling this is something i've never been into it's not my job to try and fix your game i just i have too many games to play i'm going to play the ones that straight out of the box i can i know

what to do but it's like if you want it to be you know you know structure turn order then at least throw in a variant variant rule uh you know customizable turn order or whatever but that was a lot of work and he didn't feel like putting that in there uh so yeah i mean that's kind of where i'm at i once again i don't want to play this cooperative campaign i'm intrigued by yeah uh especially the storyline might have you and i jump on that just because it's one to two and zach hates me and he's never free when i need him to be i'm definitely i'm definitely feeling better about the game overall than you are so i don't hate this game no i know but i mean but i think you would like it more uh out of out of the four of us doing the campaign you would probably be the stronger one to do it with um so i'm intrigued by the yeah i'm intrigued by the the campaign and if someone were to be like hey we need a fourth player we need a sixth player for you know to do nightfall would you play i'd be like yeah like i immediately jump in but i don't feel like i would be the one organizing this yeah suggesting it or suggesting it i don't to be fair i don't have a lot of team vs team games and there's a reason for that i don't have captain sonar because i need eight people six if i'm really desperate six isn't six uh so but i would never play that with less yeah no i would never and i would never do turn by turn even to teach that i'd

be like buckle up yeah like turn turn by turning kind of play that game turn by turn it sucks it's so slow and it's not engaging or fun at all but it's like i get it if you're having five people who have never played and you're like okay let's sure but i'm like you're just gonna get it and the thing is if you wanna play that game with less people go get sonar it's built for four people oh and then i forgot i forgot that that wasn't um because i realized that eight people is a lot it's rough it's basically a convention game yeah uh so so yeah i mean overall i think it's i think it's a extremely balanced pretty fun uh team first team game so on a scale of one to ten would you guys give the team burst team because we're out of five or six for the co-op i'm probably still at five honestly really yeah wow interesting okay um i don't know i'm torn between like seven and eight seven feels more like a seven yeah that's kind of where i'm at i uh i'm feeling seven for the team first team uh i could argue a six because that rule book ambiguity is very frustrating okay so there if i'm joined between seven and eight the the rule book flaws are gonna make it a decision right right but i think i think they're not so like we were able to play the game and it's like as long as you have people who aren't going to be like stubborn then everyone could be like okay yeah that makes that makes the most sense and you just go from there so it's not that big of an issue for me to be like oh it's going way down but yeah i mean i had a good time so 7 out of 10.

but that's our thoughts on nightfall everyone let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved