Skip to main content
Loading video...

DO NOT BUY Blood On The Clocktower

Transcript 16:19

Blood on the Clock Tower is my best board game of all time, but I still do not recommend buying it. Even if you already adore social deduction and hidden roles, even if that is your favorite thing on a table, even if you have been hunting for the serious version of this genre for years. Let me explain. I own this game. I have about 50 plays of it. Most of those nights I was the storyteller, not sitting in the circle. I adore this game, but I know so many people who spent a ridiculous amount of money on a box that sits on a shelf because the night they bought it for does not actually exist in their life. I am only about 2 years into this hobby and I am still learning. This is my taste. We do this here on this channel. I would rather tell you the inconvenient version than pretend owning a masterpiece automatically makes sense.

Let me say the good part first because if I skip it, this turns into a rant and it is not a rant. When this game is on, it is on. Everybody gets a role that actually does something. You are not sitting there as generic villager number seven hoping someone looks guilty. If you die, you are not sent to the kitchen. You still talk. You still argue. You still get one last vote hanging over the table like a little ghost with opinions. The scripts change the puzzle. Trouble brewing feels like one game. The nastier scripts feel like you learned a new language. There is real information to work with, not just vibes, not just he blinked weird. People have facts and then some of those facts are wrong and the fight is figuring out which. When you have the right group, time disappears.

I have had nights where we finished one game and immediately wanted another. That is not a small compliment. That is why it sits at number one for me. Playing it and owning it are not the same sentence. I know because I own the box. A great session does not mean you needed that giant thing in your house. The hobby loves collapsing this is brilliant into go buy it tonight. I bought it. That is why I get to say the next part without guessing. You can already play without buying it. There is an official way to play online. One person hosts, everybody else can jump in. There are digital tools for running the night. People have been playing this for years without ever touching the physical grim. If your group is curious, start there. See if you even like the rhythm before you drop what this thing costs. I know that sounds obvious. It is amazing how many people skip the obvious part and go straight to the unboxing video. Then there is the mandatory storyteller in every game. Somebody has to sit out. Not sit out like I will watch and snack. Sit out like a full-time job. That is where most of my 50 plays actually live. You run the nights. You wake people in the right order. You track who is drunk, who is

poisoned, who just died, who is secretly not the role they think they are. The quality of the entire evening is attached to that one person. A good storyteller makes the game feel alive. A tired one or a new one or one who misses a single token can waste 2 hours. I have called an ending wrong. Scarlet woman sitting there. Imp dies. Game over. Except it was not game over. You feel that in your stomach. That is 1 hour the table does not get back. If nobody in your group actually wants that job, do not buy the box. You do not have a blood on the clock tower group. You have a group that likes the idea of one. I bought it because I like that job. That is not a small detail. Player count is the next quiet killer. The box will flash a huge range at you. 5 to 20 something. Looks generous. Looks like a party game. The version people fall in love with lives in a much narrower window. For me, it really starts breathing around 9, 10, 11, 12. Under that, it gets short and swingy. You do not get enough days for the information to stack. It can still be fun. It does

not feel like the thing the hype is describing. Over that, nights get long. The day turns into a shouting match and you cannot hear the one person who actually had the fact that mattered. Most hidden role groups I know are 5 6 7 maybe eight. That is a normal board game night. That is not automatically a clock tower night. If your real group is small, you are buying a game for a table you do not have. This is also not a game you drop into a night. This is the night teach. First night, one full game. That is your evening. Fans of it will play two or three backtoback and call that a good time. I have done that. I liked doing that. If your group identity is we rotate four games before midnight, this box will sit. Not because it is bad, because it eats the calendar. Then the room. You do not play this on a kitchen table the way you play almost everything else. Chairs in a circle. Empty space in the middle. The little town board goes on the floor. People get up and whisper.

The storyteller needs a gap to walk in and out. I have tried to force this into spaces that were just not that. It gets awkward fast. You bump chairs. You kick the board. Private chats are not private. Somebody's cat becomes a player. If you live in a small place or you only play at a crowded table, that is not a small inconvenience. That is the format refusing to fit. Time is the same story. When the table is humming, 60 to 90 minutes can fly. When the table is new or big or messy, it stretches. Two hours happens. The first night especially, everybody closes their eyes. The storyteller walks the circle.

At a high player count, that first night is just quiet for a long time. That is a lot of people's first impression. Not the brilliant argument, the sitting still. If that already feels wrong in your body, listen to that. And then the price. Because of course, the price. This is not a $20 hidden roll game. It is not even a $40 one. You are looking at the kind of number that could have been three other games. The production is beautiful. The box is part of the machine. I get why it costs what it costs when you actually use it. If it hits the table a lot, the math works.

Mine does because I am usually the person running it. If it hits the table twice, you bought a very expensive memory of wanting a better werewolf. First games are fragile. Trouble brewing is the on-ramp. You kind of need that before the Wilder scripts make any sense. throw new people into a loud room with too many chairs and a script they cannot hold in their head. They do not think, "Wow, depth." They think, "I do not know what is happening, and I would like to leave." A cheap hidden roll game survives a bad first night. You shrug. You play again next week. It is fine. This box often does not survive that.

The first impression is expensive. If it goes badly, the thing stays in the closet with this little cloud of embarrassment around it. There is also the part where nothing is reliable. Drunk. Poison. People who register as the wrong thing. [snorts] Information that looks like a fact and is not a fact. I like that puzzle now. After a lot of plays, I like building the version of the world where two pieces of information cannot both be true. The first stretch of plays, it did not feel like a puzzle. It felt like the logic board got thrown on the floor. If you love social deduction because you want to lock a chain of evidence, this game will mess with that love on purpose.

Some people come out the other side and call that the whole point. Some people never stop being annoyed. Both reactions are reasonable. I have felt both in the same week. The day phase is an open floor. There is no neat little mission structure catching you. There is talking then more talking then a nomination. Fast talkers run that room. Loud confidence becomes its own evidence. I have watched quiet players who are actually good at this genre just disappear. They had the read. They never got a clean sentence. That is not a rules mistake. That is the social shape of the game. If your favorite hidden roll nights work because the structure forces everyone to vote on the same thing at the same time, Clock Tower will feel sloppy in a way you may not enjoy.

Dying is better here than in the old games. I mean that you stay, you talk, you get that one ghost vote. It is still less. Getting killed early in a long game is a weird half state. you care. You are also watching other people who still have their knight abilities and the nominations. And at the end, those leftover ghost votes can still push an execution over the line because the number you need is half the living players. And a dead yes still counts. I have been on both sides of that. When it saves the town, it feels legendary. When the living table spent an hour talking and then a ghost hand tips it, it feels cheap. Same rule, completely different stomach. Roll luck is real. Some nights you are the demon and the game is a movie. Some nights you are the butler and you are asking permission to raise your hand. Some towns folk get one button they press once all game. Some evil roles are doing something every single night. There are outsider roles that can just end the game on a bad pick. First day, thank you for coming. After 50 plays, most of them from outside the circle, I can laugh at that. The first time it happens after

you cleared the afternoon and moved the furniture, it does not feel like design. It feels like the evening got stolen. I am going to say this part quickly because I do not want to turn it into a lecture. The default format asks a lot of a body. Walking, whispering, hearing one conversation in a circle of 10 other conversations, paying attention with your eyes closed, being okay with people lying to your face for an hour. If that sounds exhausting instead of exciting, believe yourself. There are patches in the box for late arrivals and nervous players. They exist because the core loop is demanding. A game can be brilliant and still be a lot. So, who should actually buy it? A group that can regularly get 8 9 10 more people who want this exact game. Somebody who enjoys storytelling, not somebody you guilt into it. That somebody is why I own a copy. A room that can become a circle time that can become the whole night. And ideally, you have already played online or at a friend's or at an event. You know the feeling in your chest when the nomination starts. Then the box is worth it. Then I understand the money. Then I would tell you to stop reading comments

and just get it. That is the situation I bought into. It is not the default. Who should not buy it even if they adore this genre? Your Tuesday night is five or six people at a table. Nobody wants to sit out and run the thing. You like mixing games. You like a teach that takes 10 minutes. You like going home before the neighbors hate you. Your space is a table, not a room. Your budget would rather be three other games that will actually leave the shelf. You fell in love with hidden roles because they were sharp and short and everybody stayed in the fight the same way. That person should play Clock Tower. That person should not automatically own Clock Tower. I already made a video about this tension and I am going to put it where it belongs, which is here at the end, not as a disclaimer at the start. I said blood on the clock tower is still the richest social deduction design I know. I also said Avalon, especially the bigger box, is the one I would put in front of most groups. That has not changed. This video is just the buying version of that sentence. Richest is not the same as correct for your Tuesday. Best design is not the same as best purchase. I can hold both of those at the same time. I own the box. I have

50 plays. That keeps proving both. After all of that, my verdict is boring and true. It is still my number one. I own it. I would still rather run this or play this than almost anything else when the conditions are right. I still would not tell most people who love social deduction to buy it. Play it first. Steal a seat in someone else's game. Try it online. See if your group will protect a night for it. If the answer is yes and it keeps being yes, then the box stops being a souvenir and starts being a tool. If the answer is we might, that is a no. We might is how these things become very pretty furniture. That is all I wanted to say.

Progress saved