Forage Review - Explore, Store & Gift Your Way Through The Dice
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Rackle from Board Gameco and today I'm reviewing Forge from FlatOut Games. Forge is a one to six player roll and write game in which players are going to be rolling dice collectively, choosing from those dice, assigning them to three different types of cards across 13 rounds of play, all while attempting to daisy chain as many points as possible, better than the other players or better than the solo goals if you are playing it solo. Before we dive more into this, this channel is sponsored by All Play. We'll talk more about them at the end of the video. With that said, we should dive into forge over here. Although, I should say this is also a prototype rules and components of this exchange. I'll have a link to the crafting campaign down below. In forge, you're going to be rolling these dice. Let's go ahead and start. Let's just show you how a few turns play out because you'll get a much better sense just by watching it happen. We're going to roll the dice over here. Hopefully, those go in there. And then we're going to assign them.
Wow. That, by the way, is possibly the single best role I've had in every single game I've played. But the good news about Forge is Forge is a game in which all players can benefit from getting a really strong role. You see the main die, that black dye over here goes to the center. These are all different over here. These all the same, so they go over here to the equal side. They are a grouping of the same symbol. These two as well are a grouping of the same symbol. And so now on our turn, we can take groupings of dice. When you take dice, you take the center die and then you take one of the groups, which there's not a group on this side. We'll talk more about that next turn when we roll again. But over here, I'm going to take this die as well as these and I'm going to assign them. And given what I have right now, I'm going to assign them to the se to the center card because I think that's where they make the most sense. We're going to take that die. It is a uh pink die. So, we're going to cross off a pink jar or cross off circle, whatever you want. I'm actually going to cross them off over here. Then, we're going to cross off these as well because we got five of those. We take a grouping of symbols and applying them to this card over here. There you go. I got a grouping of symbols and I put them on that card. That is a turn over here.
That is one turn of the game. Although, I should have started, by the way, by revealing one of these and putting them into the pool. These are play ways players can trade in time. I didn't do that, but we'll start with that. There we go. That's a turn. I I wrote I turned over the first of these. I grabbed my dice. I assigned them to this card over here. And then from the next step is I'm going to go ahead and take a card from one of these piles. Given the fact that I burned through a bunch of these, I'm actually going to take a pantry card over here. I'm going to take a pantry card. And then I can choose to keep it or get rid of it. I think in this case, I'm actually going to keep it. I'm going to keep this pantry card. I could have gotten rid of it and simply taken one time. Time being a general resource you can use in a variety of ways. That's a turn. That's one of 13 turns to be specific. Then I'm going to go to the next turn. We're going to do the exact same thing. Again, keeping in mind, by the way, all players get to do that drafting choice. All players take dice and you don't deny dice from other players. Everyone could have chosen the exact same combination as they attempt to sign them to their cards. We'll take a few more turns and we'll talk through things as we go. We're going to roll these dice over here. We got that. This is going to be our center die. We have these as a grouping again. Wow, these rolls are insane. We're going to put these over here. And then we're going to fit these over here, which gives me an opportunity to show you something fun because, well, I like fun things. First thing we're going to do is we're going to take these over here. I would ideally have loved to be able to assign this and this all to this over here, but I don't think I can in this case. The question is, do I do an inefficient action to show you how things work? I don't think I will. I'm going to start by taking the dice on the side. These are all different symbols, so they go on this side of the card. When you're drafting a die, you always take the center, and then you take either a group from either side. This is always going to be one group. And then these will be grouped by
the various types. So I'm going to take all of these symbols and I'm going to assign them to our pathway card. I'm going to mark off the symbols one at a time. I'm going to take this one and let's circle that or cross off again. I'm going to do that. I'm going to cross off that. I'm going to do that one over there. Let's cross off this over here. And then this one will cross off this. So I've crossed off four different symbols on those paths. And you mark off the pathways in between as you do. So the goal of this card is to enclose various areas. So, as I enclose different areas fully, meaning if I had done this, this, and this, this center area would be totally enclosed, and I'd get those two points. If I enclose this area, I get a time, marking off the time on the card and being able to spend that later. That's going to be how this card works. Now, this card, you can only use dice from the different type side, meaning it has to be the different types. It is possible for one of these to match the center die, meaning the center d is always on the center, even if there's a group like so. So, you take these dice, they apply to this card.
groupings of dice apply to your pantry cards. And then on this card, on the uh the gift giving cards, you can use either groups or we groups or the separate types, however you want to combine them. That's all illustrated by the way these symbols show you how you can spend your dice. That is turn two. Not a lot happened over here. Let's go ahead and do one more. Oh, actually I'm not done yet. I want to show you something. I have these two time symbols, and you can use those in a variety of ways. In this case, right now, I'm going to cross off both time symbols to be able to take another grouping of dice. That's something you can do at the bottom. cross off two dice to that one additional grouping. And so now I'm going to be able to take this and this and assign them how I want. And so in this case, I could hypothetically assign these group of four to this over here because this specific box wants four of any dye. This wants three specifically of those raspberries. And this wants four of any green. So it has to be one of the two green symbols. But so it's not any, but it's not specific.
And that's how you spill off these boxes over here. But the problem with doing so is I could do this over here. This would be wasted. So, I think I'm going to assign it to some jars again. So, what I'm going to do is I'm going to take these four and assign them again to jars. Again, I spent two time symbols to be able to take a separate group. This is still turn two. And I'm going to cross off one, two, three, and then four over here. And you can cross them in any order however you want. That now finished this row. So, I'm going to get this one point from that. Then, I'm going to take this over here and let's put it uh let's put it down over here. We'll start a new card even though I could finish that card. And we'll place that there. That is turn two. Let's go to turn three. Once again, I forgot at the beginning of turn two to reveal this, and this is actually a new type. This allows players to immediately spend two time to get one of those two symbols, which are over here. We'll talk more about them soon, or to simply take a time. So, I've taken a time. Again, that's supposed to happen at the beginning of your turn, not at the end of your turn. And then the last thing you do is you get to draw a card. In this case, I'm going to draw an exploration card to show you how these work. We're going to slide these over a little bit. These are going to move them a bit. And then we're going to take this card and put it on either the left or the right. I think in this case I'm going to put them on the the left side over here. That creates a new grouping.
So you can see as you fill in these groupings you get the combination of those two cards. And again I could have simply discarded that and taken one time. Let's do one more turn and then we'll walk you through things. But let's actually remember to flip this over this time putting this in the center. These once players pay for them they can take them and then they get the benefits and those tokens go away. We're going to roll these over here. We're going to put this down in the center and then again we'll create those groupings. We again have a grouping of three. We now have a grouping of two over here as well. And then we have this on this side. That's going to be the grouping. It's a very standard grouping. Uh you've seen me get pretty good rolls, but very often you are getting groupings of only three dice at times. And again, I could decide how I want to assign them. I could put all these over here, which could work. I don't really want to. Honestly, I don't really love this role. It's not the way I want to go out over here. But you know what? I'm going to show you how something works just so you can I'm going to do something a little inefficient just so you can see a mechanic. So I'm going to take this grouping of the dice over here. And again, you're not taking them. All players can take them. And I'm going to assign these two to this card because I wanted three raspberries. But you'll note I only have two raspberries. That's where you can spend time in other ways.
You can always spend time to basically get a wild symbol when filling out any of your cards. You can get a symbol on the tracks over here. You can get a symbol on your pantry or you can cash it in. I'm going to add a uh raspberry. And that allows me to check off this box over here. That's one of three boxes needed to complete this card. That's how you play the sequence of this game. Let's talk through all the things we didn't get to. So, on the exploration cards over here, you're trying to basically connect groupings. As you connect groupings, you're going to be able to get the bonuses in the centers or even on the edges. When a card is complete, you get an extra time over here. You do not have to get the bonuses on the edges to be complete. You just have to mark off all the symbols for a card to be complete. And you'll get time as well as all the bonuses as you go. On these cards over here, you're going to get bonuses for the rows and columns you complete. Something like this is a grouping. So, I'd have to complete all eight of these. And then I get one of these, which means I'd mark off this over here. Those are worth one point each, but a combination of two of them is worth five points. So grouping is five points if you have both of those symbols. And again, if I crossed off paths over here, then I'd be able to go ahead and mark off and get this symbol as well. That would be a grouping of those on this card over here. When you complete them, you'll get the bonus over here, as well as you also get a time.
Speaking of which, over here, you're also going to get a time. Over here, they also give you scoring goals. So, for example, this one says, "I'm now getting an extra point in the game for each of those orange symbols I've acquired." So, these cards, the giftgiving cards, more so than the others, give you a direction of what you're trying to do, versus the other two, give you a lot of the things that you're trying to do. For example, as we cross these off, you get extra movement on this map, or you get extra time symbols, or you get to mark off a gift box somewhere. You're trying to combine these cards in different ways to get all those bonuses. Meanwhile, as you play the game, you're flipping over these, which give you ways to spend your time as well. You want to get an extra over here, spend four time, and get mark off two gift symbols. That can be incredibly important if you think about the math of that. Four time over here. If each time is worth one wild, then four time is potentially giving you as much as eight over here. And honestly, some of these boxes have five. I don't think I've seen a six, but they can go up to five, which means you can potentially trade in four time for 10 time worth of boxes as you mark those off. So, these are very important to be able to get your hands on as you play. Then there's goals.
There's variable goals. These are all double-sided, and there's a whole p batch of these as well in the in the the deck over here. But you're basically going to have three goals each game that give you things you're trying to do and the first players to get them are going to get more points. So the earlier you do these, the more points you get. Complete two of each card type. That's very hard. You're going to get there towards the end of the game. You're not these goals like they might seem like, oh, I'm just going to do the thing. No, you're often completing the goals in the last like third of the game, last quarter of the game. It is hard to work your way up there. Plus, the game has a chaining effect as you play, which means early turns are slower. Late game is where the game really picks up the pace. Those are, I think, the main things. At the end of the game over here, you're going to be scoring for your goals. You're going to be scoring for your journey cards, all the points you acquired over here. You're going to be scoring points for your gift giving cards over here, as well as your pantry, all the points you got, as well as your exploration, which I think oh, the journeys. Journeys are going to be uh these tiles over here. The exploration are going to be these cards over here.
And then lastly, you total all that up, see how many points you got, and that is how you play a game of forage. The solo mode is basically the same thing. You're just trying to beat certain goals, as well as there's a whole list of achievements you can get. If you've played flat flatout games before, those are going to be very familiar to you. That is how you play the game. Which brings us into our view of what I like, don't like, and can see others not liking. Starting off with what I like. And to begin with, the variable goals. I always love variable goals in games. Flatout Games generally does this very well with their games, giving you a different direction as far as what you're trying to do. Because like, of course, you want to play your own puzzle, but this gives you a way of like what what puzzle are you trying to play? Are you trying to complete a even-handed game? Some of these cards might reward you for doing like four exploration cards. What way what direction are you trying to build towards as you play? Over here, we have 20 time on your cards. trying to get a lot of time early on or earning three giftgiving card icon bonuses on cards. So, for example, these over here are going to be helpful that over here. In fact, if I was trying to play towards that, I would have place this on this side with that in mind if I was paying a bit more attention. Again, the the goals give you direction in a game that's going to have a lot of combo chaining as you play. And there's some solid synergies as you play. Like, speaking of the combo chaining, like the first twothirds of the game almost is mostly just trying to draft dice and place things as much as you as many symbols as you can get. Usually, more symbols is better than less symbols.
There's exceptions, sure, but usually if you can get four dice over three dice, that's going to be better on average. Especially as you fine-tune in though, and towards the last third of the game, last quarter of the game, you're going to have things cascading between the past. You're going to be starting to complete your pantry cards and getting bonuses that get you extra symbols here. That's going to complete these, which you can turn into there. You're going to be constantly chaining things together, as well as the fact that as you draft cards at the end of each round, choosing when to keep them versus when to trade them for time is a big decision because, of course, you want all the cards, but you will not finish all the cards. You will not like I don't want to say how many cards you actually can get in the game because I think it's going to be wildly different. But you're you're talking about you start with three cards. That's 13 rounds. That's 13 more cards. That's 16 cards. You are not doing 16 cards. If you do 16 cards, please let me know. I don't think it's possible. I want to say I'm trying to think through my games. I want to say because I've done that. I want to say like seven to nine cards might be doable. Somewhere in that range, but even like I'm just trying to math cuz I know I've gone for the goals. I'm trying to think how many cards I've ever completed. But I do think seven to nine is achievable. Nine might be too optimistic. For sure, seven is doable, but that means choosing which cards to keep and which cards to trade in for time that lets you complete other cards.
That's a big deal. And planning around those things is a big deal. Then I love these scoring combinations. The gift giving cards are the least interesting cards for me personally cuz I like the chaining bonuses these give. But the flip side is I like the score is the scoring variables. Trying to get a few giftgiving cards early on. My personal strategy so far has been leaning into gift giving early on the gift giving deck because since those give you scoring goals, trying to build my game around those scoring goals helps me synergize as I play it out because later in the game you make something that's great, but you make something that's bad too late to pivot. Getting a bunch of these cards early on can certainly help you choose a direction. Oh, and getting points for these. So, let me try to work my way towards cards that give me these because getting more of those is going to be doubled up on. So, that's really the way I want to play it. So trying to find those synergies early on is very very helpful in the game. And that brings us to the late game. The late game gets a little crazy. The first again 13 round game. I say the first like seven to nine rounds you're basically just drafting dice feeling like you're not getting a lot done. And those last three to four rounds is where suddenly things start comboing and you're like now I scratch off this and I do that and I get those. That lets me move on this track. That's me gets a gift over here. I'm going to buy that bonus over here. That gets me an extra two gifts. That finishes this card.
That's two more time. I'm going to trade in two more time. Drafts another pool of dice. you start having those crazy synergies later on in this game as is the kind of thing I'd expect from this kind of game. As far as things I don't like in the game, the main problem I have with it is that I have fun with this game in the last quarter of the game. And the first three quarters or two/3, depends on where you start chaining things off, I don't find quite as much fun because you are drafting pools of dice and not feeling like you're getting a lot done. Now, the math works out at the end of it all. At the end of it all, you get to a game where it does feel comboastic at the end, but that's still twothirds of my game is often spent drafting what some feels like a lot of dice. Like you have those turns, you're like, "Look at that. I got five dice plus that. I just check off a bunch of boxes and you still get barely anything out of it." Even d even turns where you get a lot of dice doesn't feel super cool for the first twothirds of the game. It feels like you're constantly just trying to get as many things as possible to just try to make it all work. And I have found that personally I only start getting those ch again that that chaining off towards the end of the game which means the bulk of the time that I'm playing I feel like I'm not getting enough done and only when I get to the end game does all the fun start happening. That's the biggest problem I have with the game. It's not about the math of the game. It's about the experience I have as a player where twothirds of my time feels like even the cool turns aren't cool enough. They're not powerful enough. So it's not a criticism of how much you get done by the end. It's a criticism I have of the feeling I have as a player where I'm feeling deflated and behind. Like even as these keep popping up, you're like, nine times, I don't have nine time. When am I spending nine time on things?
That's never going to happen. And yes, it does happen at the end, but that means this pool tends to build up as you play, not being utilized until the end. So, and that feels like your cards as well. You're like drawing new cards and you're like, I'm never going to finish these cards. What is happening here? And so it does get better the more you play for sure, but I still find that the math of the game results in a end game that is a lot of fun and very satisfying, but an early game that is very slow, even on turns that should feel that should feel like they're ideal. I'll also say that trading in a time for points, as much as that's mathematically worth it, that's just less fun in a game where I'm again, I'm already sitting here sweating trying to make it all work and I'm like, wait, so I should trade a nine time for 12 points? Like sure, I might win the game, but like that doesn't feel fun when time is one of the main tools you have to be able to try to turn into things. So for me, like I'm a I'm not saying I'm good at this game. I'm not even saying I win this game, but I am saying that for me, I'm always going to choose a a token like this where I can get my bonuses going as opposed to a token like this where I can trade in a lot of time for a great return on points, but it's not where the fun is because I'm already feeling deflated and behind on trying to get my cards done. So trading in time for points is not an experience I love, especially when I'm already struggling to feel like I get enough done in the game. As far as I can see others not liking, much of your card draw is going towards time. Like again, I talked to already. You're not going to be able to do all the cards over here. You be drawing cards, placing them towards time, and and that can go towards that unsatisfying aspect where it feels like, okay, I have this cool potential, but I have to give up this entire card of potential for one time. Again, it's a it's a player feeling critique where it's like, yes, the math works out because you're not going to be able to
do all your cards. So, you have to trade them in at times, but it feels like you're giving away a lot to get very, very little, even though you're really just giving away a lot of things you won't do to get something that will help you towards that engine. And I'll say hunting for the ideal combinations of cards can feel luck driven at times. It's like hoping you get the right pantry. Like if you burn through all of your like your brown over here and getting a card that has tons of extra pink when you already haven't finished on other cards, the combination of cards, both your pantries, your exploration, and your gift giving, those definitely have a degree of luck driven based on how the synergies are going to work out and you might not appreciate that extra element of luck in the game. Like the dice the dice luck kind of balances out because all players are being handed that. Granted, it might be better for one player or another, but it's the card draw where I find that could be more like, oh, you just got those two giftgiving cards that combo really well together, and I just got a bunch of cards that don't help me at all. As far as final thoughts on Forge, I overall enjoy forage, make no mistake.
This is a 3.5 out of five for me. It's a fun game. I've enjoyed it. Uh, I still like it's it's I've played this both solo and multiplayer. I I prefer multiplayer almost for sure. Like there's something fun about solo, but like multiplayer has an aspect where the luck feels like we're all in together and I'm trying to power past you, not pass an arbitrary score. Even though I always appreciate flatout games and how they give you these goals to go for. Side tangent. Point is more that for me I enjoy forge and I think it's fun and I enjoy the endgame a lot. The biggest thing for me in this game is that I wanted to like it a lot more than I did especially because of the type of game. Like I like chaining bonuses in these kinds of games. But I think for me that player experience of drafting five dice or four dice or whatever it is that happens. Again I had that six dice turn over here. That's never happened to me in all my plays and still I do it all and I'm like and nothing happened. I drafted six dice and nothing happened. It doesn't feel like you're getting points. It doesn't feel like you're working towards things. It feel I mean you are working towards things, but from a player experience, I I just find that twothirds of the game is spent working towards the part of the game that is fun for me. And that's the biggest thing that holds it back for me. The the the tail end of the game, amazing.
Everything's chaining, everything's popping off, and it's a lot of fun and very satisfying, but still two-thirds of the game working my way to the part where I have fun. So, a 3.5 out of five. I enjoy it a lot with caveats. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out That's Pretty Clever. Gone Clever has a bunch of games in that system. That's another one where you also have the combos chaining off towards the end. I think because of the way the points work in that game, I feel like I'm always getting stuff every turn and it feels like the the arc of the game works out better for me. And then also check out from Flatout Games as well, Cascadia Rolling Right or Cascadia um Rolling Rivers and Rolling Hills. I've really enjoyed both of those games as far as versions of the Cascadia system but taken to the Rolland domain. And then earlier I mentioned that Allplay is a channel sponsor. If you head to allplay.com, you can check out a variety of games, both from Allplay themselves as well as some of their partners. Check out Cascadero from uh oh my gosh, Cascadero from uh Bitewing Games. Bitewing Games. Cascadero is designed by Raino Canissia. It is a smaller version of Cascadero, giving you a roll and write experience of Cascadero in a smaller accessible form. Also has that kind of chain of things, gathering dice, and trying to get as many points as possible. In any case, and until next time, I'm Alex Radcliff from Board Gameco. Hope you found this video helpful and as always I hope you have a good