Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 18:21

As board game experts, can we pick fake board games out of a lineup? Or are we going to get lost in the shuffle? Paula, would you consider yourself to be a board game expert? Yes. Wow. Okay, that was definitive. Uh, yeah. You have to have confidence. It starts with confidence. You got to fake it till you make it, Chaz. Well, today we are going to put that board game confidence to the test because Matthew has put together a little challenge for the that guy. Yes. Over the course of five rounds, Matthew is going to present us with three games each round. Two of these descriptions are real and one is fake. And our job is to guess which one is fake. Great. And he wrote the one that's fake. Yes. I don't want to give my competitor a hint here, but I have found that if Matthew starts laughing a lot before he delivers Okay. the information. It's probably the one that he wrote cuz he loves to laugh at his own jokes.

We'll listen to his three descriptions. We'll maybe debate a little bit and we'll lock in our votes. Got it. Got it. Got it. Got it. Let us go to the video split screen with number one. Hello. You may call me the question master. No, no one else is calling me that yet, but I feel like it could. It could catch on. Game one, ticktac tongue. Playing as chameleons using a prosthetic tongue, players must try to knock down targets before their opponent does. That feels real. Game two, crocodile pool party. The crocodiles are loose in this luxurious hotel swimming pool. And now there is one less swimmer. And game three, slap the penguin. They can't fly, but they sure do slide. Well, slap a penguin and see how far it goes.

Oh, no. That could be it, too. I think the first one is real. Tic tac tongue. Yeah, that sounds like something that would be real. Right. And it's got one of those sticky like hand grabber things. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Or like a Or am I bluffing you? Oh, you wouldn't dare. I wouldn't dare. I'm not clever enough to have thought of it until I was already midway through offering what I think is really good. I was imagining like a prosthetic that fits around your tongue and has like a stick and like you have to do that. Oh yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I can totally see that being a thing that human being thought was a good idea to make. I think that's real. Okay. But I'm really torn about slap the penguin and crocodile pool party with a hotel swimming pool. I know there's one less swimmer. Yeah.

But slap the penguin. Why would you call your game that? Like the the mechanics of Slap the Penguin feel real to me? Okay. Right. Like it's a dexterity game. You're flicking, but the name of it I just Is that what they would call that? Yeah. Well, I mean, you've seen Board Game Geek. There's games, you know, every every potential name has at least been considered, it would seem. And some games have the same name as each other, and sometimes they come out in the same year, and it is confusing. I have a strategic idea. Okay, so this is just the first round. What if we go in splitting our forces, you take the crocodile pool party, which very much could be fake, and I'll take the slap the penguin, which honestly I think has a better chance of being real. And we will then go in because we both think the tic tac tongue is real. That way at least one of us is getting a point to start with.

Well, how come I have to take the crocodile pool party? Well, you take the other one then. The choice, as they say, is yours. Oh gosh. I don't know. You pick the one you want and then I'll take the other one. Are you sure? Yes. Cuz I can't decide. And this analysis paralysis will break us. Give me a coin. Hold on. Let me get a coin. In a previous episode that I recorded with Grant, we flipped an SD card. And what? So, I got my my lucky flipping SD card. Oh. So, we got crocodile pool party and penguin. So, which is which? If it's heads or on the table on the floor. If it's on the floor. Do you want me to flip it again? No. You get penguin. I get crocodile pool party. Are we locking in? We're locked in. We are locked in. Don't you mess with me, Matthew Jude. The madeup game is of course slap the penguin, but I maintain I think it would be good.

Should have known. He loves penguins. You knew I did. I did. I totally did. How did you Crocodile Pool Party? I haven't played it, but I've seen it advertised on Saturday morning cartoons in the late ' 80s and early 90s. I was so angry at you. Here I am trying to like be like, am I bluffing? And then you did it to me. It is on. Let's go. Next question. Game one, audit the tax game. This game centers around the yearly encounter with the IRS and the preparations necessary to successfully deal with this confrontation as players try to convert taxable money to non-t taxable by landing on positions which contain various tax shelters and credits. Game two, admin mayhem. The papers are piling up, so it's time to knuckle down and be a team player getting everything filed away before midnight. And game three, offshore oil strike. Players taking the roles of either BP, AMO, Chevron, or mobile in their quest for oil. The first player to make $120 million wins. None of these sound real. And I hate Matthew. But to be fair, after that first round, I kind of hate myself, too. Oh, don't feel like that. Don't feel like that. I feel like he chose the third one with the actual names of companies because it's going to feel like he made that up, but I feel like that's a game someone else made up

and then put on BG. Ooh. Right. See, I was thinking the names of the actual companies in that was a tell that that was the fake one. See, that's what I think he wants us to think that actually it's real. Would he be that crafty, that underhanded? Yeah. Okay. Okay. Yes, he would. The very first one, the description was so over complicated. I could totally see that being a real game that someone made because they had this passion for explaining the tax system and they went It's like an educational game. Yes. They went way over. It's like used at corporate events or at least the designer envisioned it being used at corporate events. I was leaning towards the second or third one, but before we got to the last one, I was thinking it was the second one. But before we got the second one, I was thinking it could be the first one. This isn't This isn't helping. I'm going with the second one.

Number two. You're locked in. I'm I Yes. Click. I'm locked in. I'm going to say the first one sounds so boring and like nothing. That That's the one Matthew made up. I'm locking in on number one and I'm locking in. Just doing your taxes. The fake game this time. Who knew? It's admin Mayhem. I think I should get a bonus point. I knew the third game was real and that's the one that he thought was going to trick us. Tell you what I'll do. I'm still feeling guilty about the crocodile pool party. I'll be right

back. I will give you a quarter of a point represented by this white chip. I'll take whatever I can get at this point. All right. Game one. Don't scare the clown. The family circus game where the clowns perform their dangerous tricks. Game two. Let's be safe. A matching game the family can play together while also giving parents the chance to talk about safety in a relaxed manner. That's real. Game three is Swack. The new wacky game that's loaded with action. What happens when you take the cheese off the giant mousetrap? Just wait and see. You might move ahead of the big cheese scoreboard or you might move back if the trap goes swack. Oh, do you see how he started to laugh at the end of that when he said as the trap goes swack and then his mouth twitched cuz he was starting to laugh.

Number two. I think that's real. Got to be real. That's a real game. Absolutely real. The first one was also in that same theme, but the third one wasn't. So why did he do that? Why is there a wild card in this category? I don't know. So, that means he either started with the safety one and he found one other safety one that was real, couldn't find another one that made up something weird. But, I don't think he'd do that. I think that he would start with a safety one, make up a fake safety one, try to find a third safety one, not be able to, then go with swag. Find something wacky sounding to trick us into thinking. I think number one is the fake game. I also think number one is the fake game. But but I can't prevent you the opportunity of closing the gap.

So I'll take number three. Is no but no because if you if that's right if number three is right then you extend the gap even further. That's true. But we have established I may totally be playing you. You might be. Yep. So you know what I'm going to do? I'm going to leave it up to you. I will pick number one or number three. Your choice. Mind games. No, I'm locking in number one. And if you would like to take number three, which might be the fake game because he did start to laugh after he said the trap goes swack. I will take number three just to keep things interesting. Oh my god. Um, remember how confident I was at the start of this video? Can you believe swack is real? It looked real dangerous. That's what it is. But don't scare the clown isn't real. I'm sorry to disappoint you. You have not disappointed me. I'm so happy I got a point. Now you are only three quarters of a point behind. Yeah. With two more left, it's anybody's game.

Game one, Mr. Bacon's Big Adventure. Mr. Bacon's Mr. Bacon's Big Adventure. Join Mr. Bacon on a mouthwatering mossy through Meatland. Navigate your way through the mustard marsh, cross the eerie wiener wasteland, and sail the sausage sea on a mission to find the great frying pan at the end of the trail. I think he wrote that. Game two, monkey mayhem. Game two, monkey mayhem at Mystery Mansion. There's a monkey on the loose and he's stolen the caretaker's keys. Help sedate the ape before he lets all the other animals escape. Game three, Guts of Glory, is an eating contest set in a post-apocalyptic future in which players race to win the approval of the roaring crowd by cheering and swallowing the most spectacular food. But if you can't fit it in your mouth, something will get spewed out. Oh no. Oh, I don't know.

These are I could see him writing all of these. I think I have a choice locked in. Oh, really? Yes, I do. Would you like to share with the class or you going to wait to hear me waffle my logic for a while first? See, I don't I don't want to bias you one way or the other. Mhm. Um but maybe on the count of three, we both say our guess that that way we're not biasing each other. Yeah. One, two, three. The spew game. Oh, the first one, the food game. But it could be the spew game. Let's just narrow it down. The middle one, the monkey mayhem. That totally sounded plausible. That could be real. I could also see Matthew writing that, but it could be real. It's tricky. It's very difficult. All right. Well, my reasoning was this. Game number one, Mr. Bacon's Big Adventure, I not only know is real, I have in my garage. You have Mr.

Bacon's Big Adventure. I have Mr. Bacon's Big Adventure. I changed my answer to The Monkey Game. Oh. Oh, just in case. Touche. Okay. Tell you what, if you're right, I'll give you not only a point, I'll give you one and one quarter points. Oh, boy. Yeah, I'll have two and a half points. You'll have two and a half points. Sedate the ape. Let's Let's see if sedating the ape is the way to go. The fake game this time is, of course, Monkey Mayhem at Mystery Mansion. What? Are you kidding me? Oh, well played, Matthew. Well played. There's something about sedate the ape that I was like, he could have written that. I will get you another quarter point. You You earn Yeah, mister. Your full point. Thank you. And your quarter point. Thank you.

All right. So now, what are the scores right now? The scores are two and a half to two. I will win by half a point or lose by a point and a half. Here we go. Are you ready for our fifth and final question? Look at that smug look on his face. Smug ape sedating guy. And the final round is all about Carcasson expansions. Expansion one, Carcasson the plague. Pestilence descends upon Carcasson, spreading under players control across the landscape tiles and carrying off any followers unfortunate enough to be located there. Expansion two, Carcasson the cult. When a cloister and a cult are adjacent, a challenge begins and the player who encircles theirs tile first gets nine points and the other player gets nothing. And expansion three, Caucason the guillotine. With so many special mele around, sometimes it's better to get back to basics. Here I am thinking like, oh, I know some of the Carcasson expansions. Of course, you wouldn't choose any of the ones that you've heard of like the princess or castles or whatever they are. The first one he mentioned was the plague. My thinking was, oh, Carcasson's not going to make, you know, such a downer of an expansion.

But then each subsequent expansion got it made the plague feel more plausible. Yeah. Yeah. Each one was a bigger and bigger downer. I guillotine's got to be fake unless it's I feel like I was leaning toward Colt because I was like uh that I think that's fake, but then guillotine but maybe he just didn't give us the full description of it. So the way he described it makes it feel fake cuz he like said it as a little joke, right? Sure. Sure. Now I also wonder if these are official officially released expansions or are these like fan-made expansions cuz that changes everything if that's on the table. But how would the guillotine part work in the game? Like you just do a thing and it takes special meeples away. Like you can kill your opponent's special meuples. He didn't go into enough description. Maybe it comes with little headless meeples that you replace your mele on the board with. That's totally something I think that people would take their time to produce. Yeah. Okay. I have a guess. I think I have my guess, too. On three. Yes. One, two, three. C.

So, I'm worried that it's that he wouldn't do the second one two times in a row, but Well, there's only one way to find out. Oh, boy. We mail Matthew a certified letter and we wait 6 8 weeks for it to come back. So, it's going to be an extra long episode today. Yeah. I'm back from the post office and Matthew has mailed in his reply. Let me just load it up. He sent us a floppy disc which uh has a little video on it. And here we go. There's a lot of expansions for Carcasson that do not seem like they are real. But Carason, the guillotine is also, while highly plausible, very highly not real. Good, good job. I thought the guillotine one sounds so fake. I bet it's real. I was just thinking from a marketing perspective. It's like, who at Carcass Own Central is going to say, "Yes, let's associate our brand with that." But the plague and occult, it was very difficult to narrow it down. Take your full third red chip. All right. So that means I ended up with a score of three. And I ended up even if you don't count if you don't count my half point, that's still you only won by one point. So actually it was not a landslide. It was not a landslide at all. I squeaked by by the squeakiest of squeaks. So well done Paula. We will be right back with a game night pick for you.

Chaz has gone to get today's game night pick. Here it is. I got it. They said it couldn't be done. But you did it. Somehow you went to your garage and I found Mr. Bacon's Big Adventure. I'm still really angry that this was a potentially fake game and you just knew it was real. You're like, "This is in my house right now." I'm proud. That's the feeling I'm feeling right now. But full disclosure, I have never actually played it, so I can't in good conscience actually recommend it. You can pick it. You just can't recommend it. I can pick it definitely. I mean, if nothing else, it's a great conversation piece. I look at Mr. Bacon and the big adventure he's going on. Oh, there's cacti made out of sausages. Yeah, look at this. We got we got trees made of olive loaf. I hate it.

We got a pathway made of different like pastrami and other sweet meats. Cabin made out of hot dogs and pepperoni. Oh, it's the best kind of cabin. And then uh these are slightly discolored from the sun, but don't let that fool you. They are just corn dogs just here. Maybe a corn dog forest. If you actually have this or have played a copy of it, let us know down in the description. I would love to know your impressions of this game. Yes. Meanwhile, I am going to go put this guy back in its weather controlled, climate resistant plexiglass case that I keep it in. So, thanks for watching and uh we'll see you again soon. Bye, everyone.

Progress saved