Skip to main content
Loading video...

Table Talk - Should Your Board Game Tell A Story?

Transcript 15:40

hi and welcome to watch it play it's table talk my name is Rodney Smith and in this series I share my initial thoughts on a board gaming related topic and then invite you to respond in the comments below which I'll compile into a follow-up table TalkBack episode and that way we can all participate in the conversation the other members of the watch and play team will also be dropping in with their thoughts throughout this video too now to set the stage for our conversation let's go on a quick nostalgic Journey back to 2011. good evening and welcome to the Mansions of Madness so that was me kicking off the very first video for watch it played even before I knew that what I was going to be doing here would become watch it played I've got a hoodie on I'm doing that creepy voice all because I was about to start teaching and playing Mansions of Madness first edition and one of the things I loved about that game is that it invited you to take part in a story set in the Arkham Horror universe and I wanted you to get a sense of that narrative element as I began the video now did I succeed probably not but I was trying as you could tell very very hard I don't have the first edition anymore but here's the second edition of mansions of Madness and just like the first if you take it purely at face value this game also is nothing more than lifeless bits of cardboard and plastic but I think it's a game that invites you to see it as something more the art the characters the monsters these all propose that in this game we're not just going to be moving pieces around in order to collect points here

we're being invited to take on the role of investigators going into a haunted mansion in order to face unimaginable evils the idea of being dropped into a vibrant world and taking an active part in that story I've liked board games for a long time but it's that story aspect to it that's a bug that bit me and is never really letting go and I'm not the only one just asked Paula so I love narrative and games my very first ever game night we played Settlers of Catan and betrayal house on the hill and I'll be honest with you I have no memory of that game of Catan but I remember all the details of that game of betrayal house on the hill and I fell in love with The Narrative of that game in the way that made me feel and that might be because I'm an actor so I love feeling immersed in a story and while narrative is no longer a necessary component for me to enjoy a game I mean castles of burgundy is my most played game of 2022 and that has no narrative if a game has a narrative it is immediately on my radar Paula brings up a great point that I also want to emphasize when she talked about her castles of burgundy playthroughs she mentions that although she enjoys stories and games it's not essential that exists for her enjoyment and for the sake of this discussion let's all assume that we all want games that work or are good however you define that on some mechanical level after that though how much story are we looking for because we're all going to have different tastes when it comes to the

amount of narrative we want the game to provide and that's why I want to dig into next but first I couldn't ask for a better sponsor to pair with this topic than audible which is itself the home of Storytelling with hundreds of thousands of audiobook titles to choose from across every genre you can imagine from Best Sellers and new releases to Mysteries and thrillers Wellness motivation business and more but here's the discovery I've been most excited about there are audio books that take place in board game settings I've been listening to secrets in Scarlet a fiction novel set in the Arkham Horror universe and like the game it takes you around the globe detailing several pulp horror Adventures it's actually Nine Stories in one and each has been wonderfully written and engagingly narrated which has been great because I don't get as much time to read boxes I'd like unless it's a rule book but with the audible app I've got my audiobooks with me all the time and I can pick up where I left off while I'm driving or doing tours around the house it just suits me perfectly and now when I play the game this novel is set in I'm gonna have a fuller brighter and more terrifying appreciation of it and there are several other audiobooks in our board game universes like Warhammer battle Tech Dungeons and Dragons Magic the Gathering and the best part is you don't have to take my word for it as a new member you can try Audible for free for 30 days and during that time you can pick any one title to download and keep forever even if you decide to cancel the membership later if you're a Prime member you can pick up two titles for free either way you're not locked in there is no commitment pick a title for free by visiting audible.com watch it or text watch it to 500 500 to try audible free for 30 days you'll also find those

links in further details in the description of this video to help you decide if Audible is a good fit for you and speaking of a good fit let's talk about the ways a game will try to fit a story into its experience and oftentimes it starts right on the cover of the Box itself I see a scene of action like this and my mind is already spinning with possibilities well I end up playing as one of these characters why be made to feel the same sense of urgency and heroism and what the heck is this technical thing here and why is this old man clutching a book at a time like this I want to know what's in that book even though I knew I was going to be showing you this cover right now I'm still getting excited talking about it and I guess that's because this does represent to me the potential that I'll get to play as one of these characters be a part of this story and that really draws me in now here's another cover perfectly lovely great game inside of here but I don't feel it's inviting me to be part of a story but that's also what's interesting because this cover might draw you way more in than this one does and if so I'm curious is that because as a piece of art you just like this one better or maybe you aren't looking for a cover to suggest that the game is inviting you to be part of a story or maybe this cover does call out to you with a story who is this bird where is it flying off to what's going on it's cute little bird brain I mean I suppose this cover could invoke some kind of a story but I don't think that's what it's trying to do on the other hand whether a game is trying to tell a story or not sometimes you just might want that story so badly you go the extra mile just like jazz did I love storytelling and board games it's one of the fundamental elements of the hobby that I enjoy

perhaps most in fact I have been known to take a game that already weaves together narrative elements like one of my current favorites Nemesis here which is essentially a board game based on the movie Alien but last time I played Nemesis I actually added additional custom homemade storytelling elements into it I included additional characters for the players to meet and interact with there were puzzles and Mysteries and RPG elements for the players to solve that I incorporated into it and I even kind of wrote a short narrative that had a beginning a middle and an end for the players to resolve and as a result that enhanced storytelling experience just left me wanting to do it again I have to say I do want to try Nemesis Chaz Edition someday but while he's going the extra mile to add even more story to games let's go back to one of the earliest ways that I can remember encountering story elements in Hobby Games and that's through flavor text that's the little bits of text usually in italics that's meant to give a bit more personality to a card or component for example this isn't just any old magnifying glass we're told this is a lens into a world unseen which may reveal things we wish it hadn't I imagine many players just ignore the flavor text entirely after all it's not essential that you read it to win the game it shouldn't probably influence your strategy but that doesn't mean some players won't stop and read it even possibly out loud at the table and I say this because I know I've been known to do that sometimes and I apologize to anyone I've ever annoyed because of it I don't do it as much now but I think I

used to do it in the hopes that it might bring the bits of cardboard and plastic to life more and help evoke the feelings that I got from looking at the cover did it do that uh well I'm not convinced that it did as much as I had hoped it was doing it but I'm curious to know your experience of flavor text and whether it's something you take the time to even read or not even if it's just quietly to yourself this next point we sort of covered when talking about the cover of a game because the art of a game even beyond the cover on the cards on the tokens in the rule book really everywhere all of that can encourage the players to feel the story of the game coming to life just think of the components themselves many of us board gamers have grown fond of these little people we often refer to in board games as meeples but how much more evocative is a piece like this I'm no longer represented by a squat little human like a lump of wood look at this I'm now a colorful Ranger on a trusty Steed when I get a character card to go with my player piece that looks like this I can't help but think about who this character is and what motivates them you might even get a character card that comes with a full biography telling you about the character's motivations their hopes and their dreams their strengths and their weaknesses but as Monique and Naveen will explain not everybody needs to be even wants that amount of background information to support their enjoyment while playing a game for us we are both what people call eurogamers and So Stories don't play a huge role in our gaming experiences for me I do enjoy a little bit of flavor text especially in the rule book as I'm kind of going through just to help make the theme come alive and I noticed that it also helps me remember how to do

certain things in the game if I know thematically why I'm doing them right yeah for me stories in gaming especially when there's long text yeah it doesn't really do too much for me I like the cubes the mechanisms and a nice draft board yeah but the history of a time period or something like that could bring out some of that theme as to why exactly I'm being a merchant yeah this and that so technically stories do have an effect on me just not in the way that you would I guess traditionally think about it as long as there's no long text that's right so while some people might enjoy the story elements for others they just kind of get in the way or they're an unnecessary distraction unless they're serving as specific purpose and if we're being honest oftentimes the story has little impact on the gameplay itself what I mean is a card might tell me that this character never Strays from a fight but that doesn't mean when I'm playing I have to go charging into every fight except now that I've been told that's how this character thinks because of how I think about stories and games yeah it might actually motivate me to play riskier moves than I normally would as a player because on some level I'd feel that was more in service to the story of the game but that's dangerous to do as a player because if the other people at the table aren't embracing that story aspect of the game they might feel that I'm just making bad moves valuing the story over doing the thing that's going to help us win so I think as much as I'm drawn to embodying those character moments I've learned to rein it in if the other players aren't really on the same page because that's not going to be fun for

them having this unpredictable player at the table taking risks out of a sense of Duty to some story that's coming to life in just my head I've been talking quite a bit about how different aspects of a game can introduce story elements into it but sometimes there's full paragraphs of story to read in a game or in an app that comes with the game other times like in this Robin Hood game There's an actual book and you advance through this with several story moments your active be a part of while playing this is another area where players may be divided because some will find these moments of written narrative as something that brings more substance and story to the game giving it more depth and detail While others will just see it as an interruption to the flow of play and with that in mind here's Matthew to share some of his thoughts on this exact thing I can't say I love narrative in board games perhaps unfairly I've always said that anything that's more than a paragraph to read That's not rules is too much and just shouldn't be in a game not to say that there aren't games with narrative that I haven't enjoyed the adventures of Robin Hood I really really like that game but looking around my room I'm struggling to find any other examples but I love games that tell a story that we can create a story war games where you can relive a story and knowing what happened knowing the narrative is important there but I am much more of a fan of the stories we create ourselves while we play when it comes to board games I'm certainly willing to be proved wrong I've just never cared for long bouts of narrative

and Matthew will tell you he enjoys storytelling in role-playing games he's just not drawn to it in board games and as much as I like stories and games I have to admit sometimes reading several paragraphs of text in the middle of a game just feels like work or at the very least it interrupts the flow of the game and maybe you feel the same way as we start to wrap up again I'll just confirm if it isn't already obvious I enjoy when a game gives me the opportunity to go beyond its mechanics beyond what we're physically doing moving pieces around and into a realm of imagination where a story is unfolding in front of us one that is players we're experiencing together in a shared way but how a game does that that's something I've been thinking about lately particularly in light of something that Matthew said and it's probably what prompted me to make this video as much as I love all that flavor text and the story elements a game might want me to read where it's telling me what's happening some of my best memories of stories and games came from when the game only offered a hint of a story small pieces that we as players then picked up and ran with recently I was visiting with my friends Jamie and Matt and we were playing old tree which has all of the story tricks we've covered so far evocative art flavor text story moments to be read out loud and so on but it was revealing a card like this that became one of the story highlights for us a few words and this picture sent us down a wild path of imagination it told us that a robber was harassing The Village okay sure but look at the picture the victims are all naked so there's a robber and he's not just

stealing people's money he's taking everyone's clothes why would a robber steal all the clothes off of this entire family what's motivating this person suddenly we didn't just have abandoned harassing villagers we had a kleptomaniac With No Boundaries a true Miss Grant and from that and several other things laughter and truly memorable story moments came out of that gaming session and so many of those story moments were just things we were making up ourselves I think what I'm coming to appreciate is that there's the story the game is trying to tell you when it has you stopping to read passages of text or biographies of a character but then there's also the story The Game allows you to tell which is written nowhere but left in the open spaces between moments that as players we imagine and then create out loud for ourselves even Beyond this picture that prompted us to imagine an out-of-control clothing Bandit sometimes there may be no intentional prompt that still creates a story moment it can simply come from the player's own making in our patreon Discord one of our members Nissa recounted how in her very first game of Scythe she took to naming her workers and giving them a backstory nothing inside suggests that it intense players do this but I'm realizing sometimes as players the stories we choose to make up are just as strong if not stronger than the stories a game is attempting to intentionally tell us now I should probably wrap up here and turn this back over to you first off are there ways that games can intentionally attempt to evoke a sense of story that I've missed if you can think of any please share them also do you care about whether or not a story comes to life in a game when you're playing it or is that entirely secondary or perhaps not even relevant to you at all if you do like a story

what games have been the most evocative to you and was it because of the way the game told the story or the way that you created a story from the things that happened in the game or maybe it was a bit of both please share in the comments below and in the upcoming table TalkBack episode I'll compile your answer and dive into this deeper with you so we can see this topic from a variety of perspectives but until then thanks for watching

Progress saved