First Impressions of Descent: Legends of the Dark - TCbH Review
Transcript
hey everyone this is jack from the cardboard herald and today we are going over my thoughts my impressions my first gut instincts after playing the new descent legends of the dark the brand new iteration of the descent system from fantasy flight games so with that said what is this game this is the third attempt at descent we had to send first edition then second edition then we actually had a parallel star wars imperial assault implementation of the descent system and then this is something that fantasy flight is saying is not actually descent third edition this is going to be a parallel path for the descent universe but i really think they were just kind of hedging their bets and hoping that if this takes off then they would continue to support this as the de facto descent third edition now unlike the earlier attempts at the descent system this is from the get-go an app-assisted game that is fully cooperative and the app takes over all of the dungeon master type of duties this contrasts heavily with the 1v all of the original descent in imperial assault however since the release of imperial assault second edition of descent as well as imperial assault have gotten their own apps that essentially are doing this same type of thing
re-implementing the components of the game to make it a fully cooperative versus 1v all game the big difference here is this was designed with that in mind and cannot be played without the app so what is the campaign it's a fantasy adventure to uncover some mystery save the day protect the forces of good versus the forces of evil each of the characters have their own storyline that they're going to be pursuing and making choices that will have rippling effects throughout the campaign however the main course of it is going to be this joint unified story it can have branching paths but for the most part you're going to see the same things as other players the typical shtick is that you'll have a mission and then after the mission you'll follow that up with some sort of story beat and then also some township phase of managing your characters and then choosing how you proceed from there which is a perfect time for me to get into what i really liked about the game one of the biggest shifts about this from previous iterations in the descent system is what for intents and purposes i will call the flippy system you have your character card that's in front of you as well as the equipment that's in front of you and these cards are dual sided you can flip them over so i played as the dragon kin during my initial game and i had a staff that had two different heads on it and that represented the different sides of the cards now i can continue
utilizing the sides that i have out in play but i add exhaustion tokens to them in order to represent exerting extra energy in order to trigger certain effects as well as certain conditions from the enemies can be added to my character card or my equipment and until i take an action to either flip over my character card or my equipment all of the exhaustion all of the status ailments that are on them are going to continue to be in play so i'm going to have to at some point make that change which is going to have slightly different stats or it might have a different ability represented on it or it might give me a different approach this created a sort of rhythm to the game a momentum that you had to take into consideration with whatever you were doing and it also gave you a little bit of variety you know going in that you can't lean into one thing and one thing only if you're going to have to flip it over at some point probably what i liked most about this is how all the combat systems worked cohesively in this to make it all feel overall organic from the corruption tokens like give you damage at the beginning of every round for each one of your cards that has one of those tokens on top of it to the ready token which can be put on a character or equipment cards in order to have free actions to flip them over the status ailment that gives you damage when you do choose to flip those over it makes it feel ingrained and focused in a way that
descent never really did in the past and gives it a real distinct feeling that i thought was overall fun and intuitive visually the game is stunning i was expecting it to look a little toyish on the table garish if you will like i i knew the 3d terrain was going to be a big part of this i knew that the the presentation was a selling point but also there was a part of me that was like yeah this is going to just be a little too much which in some ways is the case and i'll get into that but from a visual perspective the miniatures look outstanding the the terrain as it's set up looks dynamic and really interesting gives it a lot of great character and looks completely different than anything else uh that i've played in this genre so it's spectacular to look at and just inviting you want to play with it and it gives it a suitable epic feel that you want in an epic fantasy game and as far as the app the app is a pretty good iteration on what they've done with the apps in the past it's nice that it allows for some inventive stuff being part of the game from the initial design it allows for like crafting recipes and random drops from enemies they can do some really interesting stuff with enemies and of course i really prefer fully cooperative games rather than one via all classic dungeon crawls i thought that was great for the original descent i thought that was great for you know hero quest one of
the foundational games that made a huge impact on my life but at this point i truly believe that the future of this genre is in fully cooperative games and being able to integrate the app and relying on that while still making it a fully fledged board game experience gives it a different feel a contrast from say gloomhaven which of course there is an app that you can get for gloomhaven that takes a lot of the accounting responsibilities off of the players but by not requiring an app it gives it a completely different vibe and there are distinct limitations that gloomhaven would have as compared to this not to say that this is better than gloomhaven so let's get into what doesn't work because we're talking about the app and yes i i do like the the notion of an app to assist with things but this is kind of bananas it's kinda out of control first off by having such big terrain pieces and components that are going to emerge as you play rather than being set up according to a diagram and a scenario book or something it means you're going to constantly have to reach certain points and interrupt your turn because you've taken an action that allows you to explore the next tile and put out these enormous tiles which is going to cause players to kind of shift
things around because you didn't know exactly where it was going to build out to and the game is bonkers huge like it is massive on the table the first mission alone ended up taking almost three feet in width in order to accommodate it and if you aren't sure exactly how that is going to develop as the game goes you're going to have to make some interesting decisions about how you rotate player positioning around the table in order to accommodate this massive set of furnishings while i do think it is more emergent and in some ways more immersive to populate the board keeping a sense of mystery and discovery in the game it essentially cancels out all that immersion when players are going to have to stop and then build up the board assemble some pieces move things around and go like okay how are we going to move my player tokens over here so that way we can we can make sure to fit this all on the table so that is a drag that that interrupts the game with such frequency whereas i would just rather have it all set up at the beginning and maybe just trigger events with certain miniatures adding to the board or story beats or that kind of stuff also the app itself i don't know what they were thinking over at fantasy flight as far as how much story they wanted to integrate into the game they went so overboard like the story beats before
and after each scenario are incredibly long they they just said you know what other games will give you maybe like two paragraphs of story at a time instead we're going to have like a page and a half of dialogue that isn't going to be voice acted and so players are going to have to read it and that could be an awkward situation if you'd have players who don't really want to charismatically read aloud dialogue for multiple characters because the game represents the whole party not just the player characters themselves so it's the whole adventuring party with all the characters talking to one another the writing isn't particularly amazing it just kind of feels like generic fantasy writing and there is so much of it the alternative to reading aloud is that players are sitting around a tablet together hunched over reading that dialogue i am the type of person who likes reading flavor text i like reading aloud but even this felt incredibly exhausting to just get to the meat of the scenario i just want to play the game they went way overboard with baking in so much narrative and so much dialogue that it feels cumbersome and clunky and the last thing that i noticed with just one scenario here so bear that in mind but it really didn't work for me is that the two characters that me and my buddy were playing they made virtually no distinct choices
from one another it was always going to be that we approached the enemy as close as we could and deal as much damage as we possibly could with the cards that we had yeah we might get into some of the flipping situation with our equipment which would modify what our attacks were capable of doing but nonetheless there were no real tactical decisions that we were making about my character who's this type of character versus his character which was this type of character and you may say jack this is just the first scenario there's all kinds of abilities that you will level up into for these characters and yeah that's true but i looked at those abilities they don't really seem to differentiate the characters that much especially in contrast to their last attempt at the descent system with imperial assault where i feel like in that each character is going to make a different choice about where they would want to end their turn and how they would want to approach enemies so it took away a lot of the strategic and tactical feeling that these games are best at and kind of homogenized it part of that may be that we both picked a melee class nonetheless it should feel like there are differences between us no matter what characters we play and that just wasn't there so overall my experience was i did have fun but also i had a really mixed feelings on the game itself
really loved the character management system i think that was interesting that provided a little bit of nuance and strategy and also made the game mechanics the the interactive elements of combat and just how you perform your turn feel really cohesive and fresh in a way that this system needed and also i i really like interacting with the board discovering things and just seeing this massive showpiece on the table and so i am excited to play another game of this but in contrast to so many other games in this genre including fantasy flight's previous iterations in this series the imperial assault and descent second edition with their own app based games it's a hard sell to say that this is in any way better than those games especially better value when you consider the 175 dollar price tag of this so those are my thoughts but i would love to hear your own thoughts if you play the game if you have your own contrasting opinion if you disagree with anything or if you want to add your own experience to the things that you agree with let us know in the comments below as always thank you so much for watching i've been jack for the cardboard herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcast and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com
our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald