Raising Robots Review - Board Game Review - If Robots Had Wings
Transcript
hi everyone I'm Luke heor and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kendra. Kender stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on orders over £30 further discounts on bulk purchases and even 5% of your spending refunded back to you as points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection A F of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so today I'm taking a look at raising robots this is a new game from novel games thank you for the review copy and it's recently filling off Kickstarter and it's been getting a decent amount of Buzz know some people have been really loving it but generally it's had positive reviews and positive looks across the way I didn't know much about it going in cuz I've been toning down my Kickstarter purchases but it definitely look striking from the cover and uh you know it's got the sort of cartoony cutesy artwork so I figured it was going to be quite a light theme but when I opened the got into well we'll get on to components that there later but into the actual game play I noticed it Beed a lot of similarities to another game called wingspan one of ston my's more popular releases back in the old days when I felt like they were putting out the really good games but this one
is different enough from Wings band there are some similarities but there's definitely some key differences here and of course does that mean it's one that can be you know sit Al on side in the collection or could one replace the other we'll have to see so in raising robots you essentially have a board with three rows on it and these rows are very much like the wingspan boards with the three different habitats Etc and I'm dealing with animals here we're dealing with robots essentially players are constructing robots which will provide different abilities but the three different rows correspond to three different actions that you can perform in addition to a couple of other side actions which are unrelated and the idea is is that with these various robots that you create and the actions you're effectively trying to build an engine up over eight rounds which is played pretty predominantly simultaneously with the other players and you're utilizing action cards to dictate what you're going to do for the round except this is hidden in secret to begin with and so with these cars you're basically just trying to generate resources and victory points not like any other engine builder and do it the most efficiently and create like cool combos along the way in the rounds though you have these five action cards but what happens first is everybody has a deck of energy cards and I'm going to try and make sure the light doesn't reflect off these too much but these energy cards essentially dictate kind of like the like the power level of the abilities you're trying to trigger the abilities have all got different power levels on there like you know if I an unupgraded version has a level two requirement the next one has a level four so you need more power to do more
like really cool actions or you know maybe you don't need as much power if you've upgraded the ability to be more efficient but the idea is is that you'll reveal two of these energy cards as you know at the start of a round and then in secret players will select from the five different actions via these cards and place them underneath the energy card so if I've revealed these two for example then I will decide what I want to do I'll do design here I might do upgrade here and then players will reveal these actions and depending on the energy card that was used there might be some bonus energy cubes thrown into the mix into a kind of shared pool and then you'll go through the actions in a particular sequence triggering them simultaneously so you can kind of do your own thing on your own board but you can only do AC that you revealed cards for or have energy cubes in the shared pool so you may not necessarily do every action every round and of course depending how much power you have available will dictate how good the action is going to be this will essentially rids and repeat for eight rounds and then at the end of course the one with the most points of course so the obvious good bit is components even if you buy the retail version of this you're still getting pretty good components retail has mostly car cardboard pieces so you'll punch them out a cardboard and these will reflect the tokens and various other bits they're still good quality cardboard it's not like it's cheaper flimsy it will do the job nicely but if you do for out for the deluxe version w we this is well produced I mean the artwork is the same throughout and the
artwork is beautiful it is really good really nice colorful artwork and some really cool like pictures of these robots which come in all sorts of weird Gees I mean I've got one in front of me here that looks kind of like a roulette tap table with a slot machine on top and it's essentially a robot like that kind of odd but there's a lot of weird quirky designs here and I can just tell that whoever did the artwork for this probably had a field day coming up with half of these ideas your mother even the boards themselves they're very colorful very striking and of course if you have the deluxe version it means that you're getting upgraded wooden components and um there's quite a lot I mean this is just a handful that I have in my hand you've also got chunky yellow cubes for these energy things but but it this way this is a bag that I typically do when I play games I bag things up by players so players can simply take the bag and they've got all their stuff in here this is jam-packed full with wooden bits and the few cards that they need I mean you have got you know the different inventory uh resource tokens that you have on the top of your board but then you've also got a mly collection of all these like thick wooden upgrade tokens of different types you've got a Meo that you put around your board you've got the energy cubes themselves there's quite a lot of good production value in here now it's not necessarily the cheapest game in the world as a result but if this is one that you're thinking of keeping I do partially recommend grabbing the deluxe version if you can cuz it's just going to be a very nice striking package the man suddenly skyrocketed you all saw it the game pulls a fast one on you in
terms of its graphic design and Rule set as well when I open the game up and got the stuff out it does look kind of you know busy in terms of a lot of the iconography and the different abilities that go off and the cards and everything there's like a bit of an overwhelming amount of information that sort of flies at you as you open the game up and I thought oh my God this is going to be really complex really fiddly how am I going to deal with all this surprisingly though give it a chance the rule book is very easy to use and very clear I mean I didn't really have a TR you know much trouble following this and yes it looks like a big rule book but this is like giant size font you know easy to read font and a lot of pictorial examples it's a really solid rule book All Around frankly and once you're done with this you probably won't have to reference many rules in it you've got a very good summary on the back with all the key iconography that you kind of need there's a separate sheet to to go into the the different like player powers that you can have so once you know what your player power does you can kind of toss the sheet away for the most part but it was surprisingly smooth to play I was taught this first I didn't actually learn it myself at first I sort of thought right I've read the rule book this is pretty cool then I went to a game night someone taught it to me and I was surprised that yeah it does actually kind of gel nicely it's smooth the rules aren't complicated and the graphic design does a good job of highlighting what things are the actions have arrows to say what order they're done in all the robots have the same layout and it's
pretty easy to tell right that's the cost that's the victory points that's where it goes and here are the two abilities that could trigger off it there's no like weird like exceptions to the rule in this game everything kind of works as you would expect it even the you know the energy cards and how that works pretty smooth experience you flip the cards over put the cubes out in a shared pole and then you can see clearly which actions you're allowed to do at what power levels you know via this little Central board uh really the only minor sort of fiddly thing is just having all these upgrade tokens everywhere on various slots so you don't actually know what the upgrade does until you take the token off it so maybe there's a little bit of fiddling around with that but that's a pretty minor niggle overall it's a lot smoother than it gives it you know than it tries to portray and I know this is probably going to scare off a few people when they look at it and go oh my word what is this but stick with it trust me it's simpler than it looks I don't get it the replay value in this game is pretty solid actually I mean there is a lot of these robots this is the robots uh apart from about 10 that I've got on my board here from a solo game I was doing but this is the size of the deck of robots there's a lot and yes you get these sleeves in the deluxe box it comes with the sleev so you don't even have to buy your own there's another reason to get the deluxe version but yeah there's a lot of robots in here a lot of different types A lot of different kinds the only downside is that yes there's a lot of different robots but the abilities on these do tend to be a little bit syy like there's not that many different
variations of the abilities that they have Bight my tiny metal ass like I say you're going to play this game and you're not going to play that Many Robots so much like wingspan you're not going to see much of this deck in each play so there's certainly a lot of different you know bits of artwork and different types of abilities that will come up but even ignoring the robots two other aspects really add to the replay value firstly I really like the upgrade system the upgrade system gives you a ton of these little tokens all over your board so they effectively fill up little slots and you know you can upgrade them in any order you see fit if you ever get to do an upgrade which is a separate action or maybe some robots will do it you can choose any of the tokens you like you take take the token off it reveals a boost to whatever ability or you know upgrade action it may be but then you also take the token and put it on say your starting player power or the different robots to upgrade their abilities so it's not just simply oh I'll take a I'll take this token off the design action so that I get an extra power every time I use the action great I also get to say right well I'm going to put it on this robot here so now when I use this robot I get to use the bottom action which is more powerful I can decide what I want to take off and where I want to put it with the slight restriction that the different colors must go on matching colors except for one player power that gets around it so I really like that system because you can play a lot of different styles depending on what robot cards you get or what inventor you're using just simply by upgrades alone but then the inventors
themselves are really cool I mean you have got quite a decent amount of these player powers in the game and I mean this is just yo-yo for example that I was using in my last solo game each of these have different setup tweaks they have different abilities going forward round end abilities and each of these can be upgraded as well to make their abilities better and there's a decent amount of them I mean 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 14 in the box and that's not like oh the deluxe gave me a ton more no that's 14 that were in the box if You' got people who know what they're doing in this game this game is pretty fast I mean we played a free player of this the other day and we got it done in something like a an hour and a bit it really was pretty fast and I'm kid you not teaching the game getting it set up playing it and taking it down we did it faster than another group nearby was doing a five player game of last Light yeah you know the game that's getting all this praise about being a super fast 3x game yeah we finished this in less time than they did and they started half an hour before us hm okay you know this game is somewhat quick especially with the simultaneous turns now that being said you probably do want to teach the first turn in turn order so people know what they're doing that at least needs to be a little bit slower and obviously you are still down to the lowest common denominator because if somebody slows the you know the actions down in a turn they are going to drag the game out so playing this with five or six players I'm a little bit like I don't particularly want to it's pretty chaotic and you know six players you're always
going to get at least one or two people dragging it down not to mention a table space would be insane but yeah anywhere up to four players you can play this in a decent very quick length of time now both this and wings man have elements of luck of the draw and certainly people have used that as a criticism of both games myself included I love wingspan to death but it's got its flaws it's not a Flawless game this one however I think takes that luck of the draw aspect and probably takes it a little bit further than what Wings spand it and mostly it comes down to these energy cards that you have and this is where I'm another biggest fan of this mechanic in the game what this is where you draw two at random from your deck everybody has the same deck unless the inventor says otherwise and they have varying different levels of power they may generate cubes or they may say the cubes are worth double their normal output now the problem is is that these are random entirely randomly drawn from your deck and you have no way to mitigate this whatsoever so you may have a term when you think right well I need a couple of decent high power actions because I want to do this and this this round okay and then you draw two cards and you find you get a couple of twos or three or maybe even just a one even I mean you've got two yeah in a typical free player game for example uh is it or is this a solo game but now free player game you should have let's see uh two twos three threes two fours and a one with varying different levels of cubes in that so you think well you know what I could really do with a three and a
four this round because that would mean I could do these actions and then you draw a two and a one no that sucks I mean yeah the cubes are worth double the output but the problem with that is is that this whole idea of oh the shared resource you're thinking oh what will other players want to do you know they might want to put down the same action as me in that case they'll might they might put cubes in the middle that's entirely a lottery crapshoot because you have no idea of knowing what actions the other players are going to do I mean if they focus entirely on one row and nothing else then yeah okay you could guess that they might go for that one but there's two actions here that don't care what you have in your row if you've got the resources you can always build a robot and if you've got the resources you can always do an upgrade so that's always on the cards but even then you kind of need to do all five actions in some respect so when you're looking at a lot of players particularly when there's a lot of you at the table how on Earth are you supposed to know what they're going to put down and even then you don't know whether they're going to be contributing cubes to your particular action it's like all right you might do recycle but then you've only got one card that gives cubes you might put it on the one that doesn't give cubes so you can't really predict it so it just ends up being very random how this board turns out and as such my turns can be sometimes scuppered purely by an unlucky draw of energy cards or an unfortunate setup of how the other players decided to do their actions there's none enough ways to predict what they're going to do what am I psychic another aspect of that luck that really comes into play is the class cards there's a lot of them and
you know fair enough for variety these are basically objectives you can go for like build a bunch of robots get a bunch of this upgrade get a bunch of this resource that kind of thing they give you bonus points it's the bonus cards from wingspan now the ones from wingspan were fairly lucky and certainly it was much better to house rule that with The Arc Nova mechanic to say you know draw a couple at the start of the game and then discard one halfway through the problem with this is yes you can end up with two of these at least by the end of the game possibly even more than that but they are entirely random as to how you get them and yes it does say draw three and pick one but I don't think that's even enough I'm might even house rule that to be higher because a lot of these are very specific and in order to get a decent amount of points from them to have any kind of meaning you need to do really well at these you can't just simply go I'll get class D on every single one it's only two points it's meaningless two points you really want to be getting something like N9 or 13 out of these but I might have a situation where start at a game I decide um I'll pick this one it wants me to do the pink upgrades okay Cay I can I can go for that from the start of the game but then in the middle of the game everybody gets to draw more and you can upgrade in order to draw more as well so I might go right I draw free um I haven't been doing that haven't been doing that and I don't have much of that well I've just drawn three class cards that are useless for me so I get no extra points somebody else draws free and goes oh I've been doing quite a few upgrades this game you know what I can get a fair few points and that's great I'll take that one so by sheer fluke that players ahead of me and it's
nothing to do with skill or anything it's just bad luck of these and so so I don't know I wish maybe these were a little bit easier to score points with or maybe that they shouldn't be a face down deck what if they were like a face up display like say you had you know like 8 to 10 of them out on a face up display at the start of the game so you knew exactly which ones were available and then you could gear yourself up to a couple of them and then when it gives you more as the game goes on you can go right I've been doing this one I've been getting a lot of gear resources that card is there I now take this card you can see whether anybody else is going you in competition but you would be then racing to get that card dear God what is it like in your fully little brains it must be so boring now the game is pretty tight with its resources and you might think well that's not a negative I like tight games in which case fair play but it's tight enough in this game that you can have some rounds that even coupled with the whole luck of the draw aspect I mentioned before you could still just not be able to do a lot because you're one short on this resource or don't have any cards to play and the cards aspect is a big deal because the cards do not come in sufficient quantities in this there are only two ways on the board you know two or three ways to get cards the design action has a way that you discard your entire hand and draw all but plus one not the most efficient way of doing it and you got to get rid of cards in order to make it worthwhile but the other way is that there are a couple of little ways to get a wild resource of which a wild resource could draw a card but honestly I'd rather get resources than the cards if I'm doing that but the
problem is is that outside of that you don't generate a lot of cards unless you find the robots that can give you more cards and I've had games where players just because they haven't upgraded those particular actions or just happen to have not drawn robots that give cards end up with a situation where they just can't physically get enough cards to do anything with I had one game where the only reason I even came second place was because I was doing a a Spam action all the time that gave me a lot of victory points each round but I practically had half the game where I couldn't do a single assemble action cuz I had no cards there was no way for me to draw them I had no robots to do it the wild resources were needed for other things and so you know while other people have got like big hands of cars and they go oh I fancy playing that and I fancy playing that and these are worth a lot of points they're worth playing I'm sort of sat there not able to have many options and I didn't feel particularly good while playing it's not that fun to just Spam a single action for victory points all the time as much as it did allow me to come second and it was only by three points but I would have liked maybe that it was just a bit easier to draw cards I mean wingspan hasn't an action devoted to draw drawing cards so if you need more cards in wingspan it's pretty easy to do so here it's a lot harder to get them and I don't know why it needed to be quite so hard to get them why not give players a plentiful supply of cards you know and have the action do something different it just seems a little bit odd but you know some people will really like that tight factor and if so then great you're in luck your kids are soft the game also does feel very multiplayer solitary yes you have the fact that people will contribute to the shared pool of energy
Cubes but that's literally it there is no other multiplayer interaction in this game you play simultaneous turns you do your own thing and once you've like got over that flip the two cars to see what other people played that's it I can blot them out of existence and the rest of the round is entirely my own thing and my own abilities so yeah you can play this with six players but honestly what's the point it just adds more chaos to the middle thing I mean in six players pretty much every single phase is going to get used you have no idea where the cubes are going to come from and you can't really plan your turn effectively whereas with less players you can at least have some idea that some actions are probably going to be worse than others or you have to accept that some actions won't appearing around and that can make a big deal wait my cheating unit malfunctioned I would have liked maybe just a little bit more interaction or a little bit more care as to what other players were doing because you're not racing for any Milestones you're not racing for particular goals or anything not even that is in the game so literally flip the two cards and that's it you're out of existence pretty Solitaire and I think they could have put something in here you know especially to set it aside from something like wings ban and just make it a little bit more meaningful to shove High player counts on the cover yeah but your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could they didn't stop to think if they should the game has a solo and two-player variant although it's a very easy variant to mitigate basically all you do is that you simply take a spare set of phase cards from a player that's not in the game you lay them out face down and put a certain amount of Cubes based on the rule book and then depending on whether you're playing Solo or two player you
reveal so many at a time you put the cubes out and these are the actions where they go that's entirely it there's no actual AI opponent all it is is just basically a beat your own score thing and that's a bit of a shame because I would have liked a cool robot AI that you actually played against to have like a Target to you know Target number or Target like thing that messed you over but really it doesn't it's just a luck of the draw which actions get done although it does make it a little bit more predictable than say the free player plus because with multiple players around the table it's just a lottery crapshoot to see who which who puts which action cards out but because these refresh every two rounds you essentially go right first time they did upgrade and assemble well I know they can't do that this round so they've only got choose two out of these three so they're likely to pick these ones maybe I should plan for that that actually elevates the solo mode in some respects over the multiplayer play but then at the end of the day yes you're playing a quick game and you get to do all the cool combo building but it's just beat your own score and the score value on this are tough I mean you do reasonably well at this game you'll still be ranked as an amateur or average at this in order to get heroic epic and legendary you've got to score a sick amount of points in this and the only way you are going to score a sick amount of points is if the stars align for you in respect of you know the energy cards that you draw at the time you want drawing the right class cards that you can easily Munch in just Smite getting them late in the game there's a lot of things that have to work out for you in order for your score to get that high and that
just feels a bit demeaning and punishing when you feel like you had a good game you had fun and then the scoreboard basically tells you stop it you're so stupid well sry I mean I drew two class cards during a game and they were for stuff I couldn't do what can I do there's nothing I can do to mitigate that it you know stuff like that kind of rubs me the wrong way and I just would have liked the solo mot to just been a bit more interesting than just beat your own score and the like but at least I give it props for saying that it was you know very easy to do I mean you can play the two-player variant easily you can play the solo variant easily get the game done in a quick amount of time and you know that that's praise but yeah I don't know how often I would want to bring it out just for that so raising robots overall does a pretty good job in some aspects but lets down on a few others I do really like the variety in this game the upgrades and the inventors do lead to some cool paths that you can take of course some of that is dictated by the robots that you draw it looks beautiful on the table and I was surprised at how easy it was to play and how smooth it was despite the ton of iconography that it throws at you normally I would have expected this to be really fiddly and really clunky but it doesn't feel that way it's essentially like a robot that's being nicely oiled it's uh it's doing its job there's no like bits falling off it what the combo building with the cards is still here even if the abilities aren't the most exciting in the world you know I think the wingspan birds do a better job of that but there's a lot of decent
stuff to talk about this but you kind Overlook some of those flaws as well you know the fact that you can play this with six players is not necessarily the right way to go about it because it does make things very chaotic and of course you're going to need a massive table to do it the it would also upgrade the length of time it takes to play Waiting for six people to finish the main problems I do have though are you know the fact that it is very solitary in nature despite having all these players at the table and the luck of the draw aspect I think does does hurt it quite a bit because I have to think right I need luck of the draw of the robots I need luck of the draw of my energy deck I need pretty much a lot crapshoot as to what other players pick for their actions and I have a big luck of the draw aspect for the class objective card so a lot of that is present and some of you might argue hang on isn't that in the other game as well and it is but not to this much extent you know the bonus objective cards are the main thing with wingspan you get some face up cards to choose from and there's plenty enough Birds to go for so yes there's an element of luck there but there's more here there's like twice as much here and maybe we didn't want twice as much here you know I wanted just a little bit less a little bit more control but those niggles are you know sorry they're not niggles but those flaws do not take it out of the Realms of being something that I would recommend so I'm overall giving this one a pretty decent 7 out of 10 it's solid it's good I give it a seal of endorsement and I think you probably want to check this out to you know if you like these combo building games of the look strikes you fancy if you like
the idea of some of that replay value but don't go into this thinking this is going to be like a Wings ban killer or anything of the like it's an alternate wingspan is its own thing it does its own thing it's got its own theme its own mechanics it uses the row thing and that's mainly it apart from just triggering abilities on cards here the upgrade system is certainly unique to this the look of it is certainly pretty much on par as well and you know the player powers and all the other little bits are cool and cool things to have it's just those flaws do get in the way of it I think you know I would have liked to have seen a few changes there but overall a solid package I recommend giving a shot 7 out of 10 check it out and see for yourself so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you SE them please thumb up on YouTube and thumb it up on board gamee when it goes live on the site don't forget to check out the other content that I've done so far which at the moment for 24 is literally a Q&A in an arc NOA Marine Worlds review don't worry there's more to come yet the top 100 is almost ready to start putting out videos until next time remember regardless of how well oiled your robot happens to be it's still only a game so bye for now and take
care